Stability and Dissociation of the Large Subunit RuBisCO Binding Protein Complex in Vitro and in Organello

Role of ClpP in the Biogenesis and Degradation of RuBisCO and ATP Synthase in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

Ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (RuBisCO) associates a chloroplast- and a nucleus-encoded subunit (LSU and SSU). It constitutes the major entry point of inorganic carbon into the biosphere as it catalyzes photosynthetic CO2 fixation. Its abundance and richness in sulfur-containing amino acids make it a prime source of N and S during nutrient starvation, when photosynthesis is downregulated and a high RuBisCO level is no longer needed. Here we show that translational attenuation of ClpP1 in the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii results in retarded degradation of RuBisCO during S- and N-starvation, suggesting that the Clp protease is a major effector of RubisCO degradation in these conditions. Furthermore, we show that ClpP cannot be attenuated in the context of rbcL point mutations that prevent LSU folding. The mutant LSU remains in interaction with the chloroplast chaperonin complex. We propose that degradation of the mutant LSU by the Clp protease is necessary to prevent poisoning of the chaperonin. In the total absence of LSU, attenuation of ClpP leads to a dramatic stabilization of unassembled SSU, indicating that Clp is responsible for its degradation. In contrast, attenuation of ClpP in the absence of SSU does not lead to overaccumulation of LSU, whose translation is controlled by assembly. Altogether, these results point to RuBisCO degradation as one of the major house-keeping functions of the essential Clp protease. In addition, we show that non-assembled subunits of the ATP synthase are also stabilized when ClpP is attenuated. In the case of the atpA-FUD16 mutation, this can even allow the assembly of a small amount of CF1, which partially restores phototrophy.

Reconstitution of Pure Chaperonin Hetero-Oligomer Preparations in Vitro by Temperature Modulation

Chaperonins are large, essential, oligomers that facilitate protein folding in chloroplasts, mitochondria, and eubacteria. Plant chloroplast chaperonins are comprised of multiple homologous subunits that exhibit unique properties. We previously characterized homogeneous, reconstituted, chloroplast-chaperonin oligomers in vitro, each composed of one of three highly homologous beta subunits from A. thaliana. In the current work, we describe alpha-type subunits from the same species and investigate their interaction with β subtypes. Neither alpha subunit was capable of forming higher-order oligomers on its own. When combined with β subunits in the presence of Mg-ATP, only the α2 subunit was able to form stable functional hetero-oligomers, which were capable of refolding denatured protein with native chloroplast co-chaperonins. Since β oligomers were able to oligomerize in the absence of α, we sought conditions under which αβ hetero-oligomers could be produced without contamination of β homo-oligomers. We found that β2 subunits are unable to oligomerize at low temperatures and used this property to obtain homogenous preparations of functional α2β2 hetero-oligomers. The results of this study highlight the importance of reaction conditions such as temperature and concentration for the reconstitution of chloroplast chaperonin oligomers in vitro.

Chaperone-assisted Post-translational Transport of Plastidic Type I Signal Peptidase 1

Type I signal peptidase (SPase I) is an integral membrane Ser/Lys protease with one or two transmembrane domains (TMDs), cleaving transport signals off translocated precursor proteins. The catalytic domain of SPase I folds to form a hydrophobic surface and inserts into the lipid bilayers at the trans-side of the membrane. In bacteria, SPase I is targeted co-translationally, and the catalytic domain remains unfolded until it reaches the periplasm. By contrast, SPases I in eukaryotes are targeted post-translationally, requiring an alternative strategy to prevent premature folding. Here we demonstrate that two distinct stromal components are involved in post-translational transport of plastidic SPase I 1 (Plsp1) from Arabidopsis thaliana, which contains a single TMD. During import into isolated chloroplasts, Plsp1 was targeted to the membrane via a soluble intermediate in an ATP hydrolysis-dependent manner. Insertion of Plsp1 into isolated chloroplast membranes, by contrast, was found to occur by two distinct mechanisms. The first mechanism requires ATP hydrolysis and the protein conducting channel cpSecY1 and was strongly enhanced by exogenously added cpSecA1. The second mechanism was independent of nucleoside triphosphates and proteinaceous components but with a high frequency of mis-orientation. This unassisted insertion was inhibited by urea and stroma extract. During import-chase assays using intact chloroplasts, Plsp1 was incorporated into a soluble 700-kDa complex that co-migrated with the Cpn60 complex before inserting into the membrane. The TMD within Plsp1 was required for the cpSecA1-dependent insertion but was dispensable for association with the 700-kDa complex and also for unassisted membrane insertion. These results indicate cooperation of Cpn60 and cpSecA1 for proper membrane insertion of Plsp1 by cpSecY1.

The chaperonins of Synechocystis PCC 6803 differ in heat inducibility and chaperone activity

The chaperonins GroEL and Cpn60 were isolated from the cyanobacterium Synechocystis PCC 6803 and characterized. In cells grown under optimal conditions their ratio was about one to one. However, the amount of GroEL increased considerably more than that of Cpn60 in response to heat stress. The labile chaperonin oligomer required stabilization by MgATP or glycerol during isolation. Use of the E. coli mutant strain, groEL44 revealed that the functional properties of the two cyanobacterial chaperonins are strikingly different. Overexpression of cyanobacterial GroEL in the E. coli mutant strain allowed growth at elevated temperature, the formation of mature bacteriophage T4, and active Rubisco enzyme assembly. In contrast, Cpn60 partially complemented the temperature-sensitive phenotype, the Rubisco assembly defect and did not promote the growth of the bacteriophage T4. The difference in chaperone activity of the two cyanobacterial chaperonins very probably reflects the unique chaperonin properties required during the life of Synechocystis PCC 6803.

Disassembly of the cytosolic chaperonin in mammalian cell extracts at intracellular levels of K+ and ATP

The eukaryotic, cytoplasmic chaperonin, CCT, is essential for the biogenesis of actin- and tubulin-based cytoskeletal structures. CCT purifies as a doubly toroidal particle containing two eight-membered rings of approximately 60-kDa ATPase subunits, each encoded by an essential and highly conserved gene. However, immunofluorescence detection with subunit-specific antibodies has indicated that in cells CCT subunits do not always co-localize. We report here that CCT ATPase activity is highly dependent on K+ ion concentration and that in cell extracts, at physiological levels of K+ and ATP, there is considerable dissociation of CCT to a smaller oligomeric structure and free subunits. This dissociation is consequent to ATP hydrolysis and is readily reversed on removal of ATP. The ranking order for ease with which subunits can exit the chaperonin particle correlates well with the length of a loop structure, identified by homology modeling, in the intermediate domain of CCT subunits. K+-ATP-induced disassembly is not an intrinsic property of purified CCT over a 40-fold concentration range and requires the presence of additional factor(s) present in cell extracts.

Molecular chaperones and protein folding in plants

Protein folding in vivo is mediated by an array of proteins that act either as 'foldases' or 'molecular chaperones'. Foldases include protein disulfide isomerase and peptidyl prolyl isomerase, which catalyze the rearrangement of disulfide bonds or isomerization of peptide bonds around Pro residues, respectively. Molecular chaperones are a diverse group of proteins, but they share the property that they bind substrate proteins that are in unstable, non-native structural states. The best understood chaperone systems are HSP70/DnaK and HSP60/GroE, but considerable data support a chaperone role for other proteins, including HSP100, HSP90, small HSPs and calnexin. Recent research indicates that many, if not all, cellular proteins interact with chaperones and/or foldases during their lifetime in the cell. Different chaperone and foldase systems are required for synthesis, targeting, maturation and degradation of proteins in all cellular compartments. Thus, these diverse proteins affect an exceptionally broad array of cellular processes required for both normal cell function and survival of stress conditions. This review summarizes our current understanding of how these proteins function in plants, with a major focus on those systems where the most detailed mechanistic data are available, or where features of the chaperone/foldase system or substrate proteins are unique to plants.

Molecular chaperones and protein folding in plants

Protein folding in vivo is mediated by an array of proteins that act either as 'foldases' or 'molecular chaperones'. Foldases include protein disulfide isomerase and peptidyl prolyl isomerase, which catalyze the rearrangement of disulfide bonds or isomerization of peptide bonds around Pro residues, respectively. Molecular chaperones are a diverse group of proteins, but they share the property that they bind substrate proteins that are in unstable, non-native structural states. The best understood chaperone systems are HSP70/DnaK and HSP60/GroE, but considerable data support a chaperone role for other proteins, including HSP100, HSP90, small HSPs and calnexin. Recent research indicates that many, if not all, cellular proteins interact with chaperones and/or foldases during their lifetime in the cell. Different chaperone and foldase systems are required for synthesis, targeting, maturation and degradation of proteins in all cellular compartments. Thus, these diverse proteins affect an exceptionally broad array of cellular processes required for both normal cell function and survival of stress conditions. This review summarizes our current understanding of how these proteins function in plants, with a major focus on those systems where the most detailed mechanistic data are available, or where features of the chaperone/foldase system or substrate proteins are unique to plants.

In vitro dissociation of self-assembly of three chaperonin 60s: the role of ATP

A comparative study has investigated the in vitro dissociation and self-assembly of chaperonin 60 14-mers isolated from E. coli (GroEL), yeast mitochondria and pea chloroplasts. In all cases Mg2+ inhibits, and low temperature stimulates, the urea-induced dissociation. ATP or ADP in the presence of Mg2+ enhance the dissociation of the chaperonins. Re-assembly of the 14-mers from their monomers shows different efficiencies between the three proteins. In all cases, however, self-assembly is stimulated by Mg-adenine nucleotides. Surprisingly, effective self-assembly of GroEL is promoted by 20% glycerol in the absence of ATP. The role of Mg-adenine nucleotides in the dissociation and assembly of the chaperonins is discussed.

A modified Escherichia coli chaperonin (groEL) polypeptide synthesized in tobacco and targeted to the chloroplasts

The coding region for the Escherichia coli groEL (chaperonin-60) polypeptide was fused downstream of a pea rubisco small subunit transit peptide coding sequence under the control of a tandem 35S CaMV promoter. Transgenic tobacco plants (Nicotiana tabacum cv. Xanthi) containing this modified groEL gene were produced. The modified groEL polypeptide was correctly imported into chloroplasts and accumulated to high or low levels in different plants. The majority of the modified groEL polypeptide was processed correctly to the mature form within the chloroplasts. Approximately 20% of the imported polypeptides retained a portion of the N-terminal transit peptide (TPgroEL). Both groEL and TPgroEL polypeptides assembled into tetradecameric species in the chloroplasts. In plants accumulating high levels of these products, the majority of the plant chaperonin-60 polypeptides in the chloroplast were present in novel hybrid tetradecameric species containing both bacterial and plant chaperonin-60 polypeptides. In plants accumulating low levels of groEL, the predominant species present appeared to be authentic plant cpn60(14) and authentic bacterial groEL14. The growth and development of transgenic and control tobacco plants were indistinguishable.

Several proteins imported into chloroplasts form stable complexes with the GroEL-related chloroplast molecular chaperone

Nine different proteins were imported into isolated pea chloroplasts in vitro. For seven of these [the large and small subunits of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco), beta-subunit of ATP synthase, glutamine synthetase, the light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b binding protein, chloramphenicol acetyltransferase, and pre-beta-lactamase], a fraction was found to migrate as a stable high-molecular-weight complex during nondenaturing gel electrophoresis. This complex contained the mature forms of the imported proteins and the groEL-related chloroplast chaperonin 60 (previously known as Rubisco subunit binding protein). Thus, the stable association of imported proteins with this molecular chaperone is widespread and not necessarily restricted to Rubisco subunits or to chloroplast proteins. With two of the imported proteins (ferredoxin and superoxide dismutase), such complexes were not observed. It seems likely that, in addition to its proposed role in assembly of Rubisco, the chloroplast chaperonin 60 is involved in the assembly or folding of a wide range of proteins in chloroplasts.

A point mutation in the gene for the large subunit of ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase affects holoenzyme assembly in Nicotiana tabacum

In photosynthetic eukaryotes, the enzyme ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) is composed of eight large and eight small subunits. Chloroplast-coded large subunits are found in association with chaperonins (binding proteins) of 60-61 kd to form a high mol. wt pre-assembly complex (B-complex). We have isolated a heterotrophic, maternally-inherited mutant from Nicotiana tabacum var. Xanthi which accumulates the B-complex but contains no Rubisco holoenzyme. The B-complex of the mutant dissociates in the presence of ATP, as does that of the wild-type. Processing of the nuclear-coded small subunit takes place in the mutant and neither large nor small subunits accumulate. The large subunit gene from mutant and wild-type plants was cloned and sequenced. A single nucleotide difference was found between them predicting an amino acid change of serine to phenylalanine at position 112 in the mutant. Based on the resolved structure of N.tabacum Rubisco, it is argued that the alteration at position 112 prevents holoenzyme assembly by interfering with large subunit assembly.

Delayed Osmotic Effect on in Vitro Assembly of RuBisCO : Relationship to Large Subunit-Binding Protein Complex Dissociation

Higher plant ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (RuBisCO) cannot reassociate after dissociation, and its subunits do not assemble into active RuBisCO when synthesized in Escherichia coli. Newly synthesized subunits of RuBisCO are associated with a high molecular weight binding protein complex in pea chloroplasts. The immediate donor for large subunits which assemble into RuBisCO is a low molecular weight complex which may be derived from the high molecular weight binding protein complex. When the high molecular weight binding protein complex is diluted, it tends to dissociate, forming low molecular weight complexes. When the large subunit-binding protein complexes were examined after in organello protein synthesis, it was found that the low molecular weight complexes were more abundant when protein synthesis was carried out under hypotonic conditions. This increase in the assembly competent population of low molecular weight large subunit complexes can account for the increased amount of in vitro RuBisCO assembly which occurs under these conditions. The data indicate that the assembly of large subunits into RuBisCO is a function of the aggregation state of the large subunit binding protein complex during protein synthesis. This implies that the binding protein exerts its effects during or shortly after large subunit synthesis.

Assembly of Rubisco from native subunits

Large subunits of ribulosebisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) (3-phospho-D-glycerate carboxy-lyase (dimerizing), EC 4.1.1.39) from prokaryotic sources can assemble into intact enzyme either in vitro or in Escherichia coli cells. Large subunits of higher plant Rubisco do not assemble into Rubisco in E. coli cells, nor is it possible to reconstitute higher plant Rubisco from its dissociated subunits in vitro. This behavior represents an obstacle to any practical attempts at engineering the higher plant enzyme, and it suggests that the in vivo assembly mechanism of higher plant Rubisco must be more complex than is commonly expected for oligomeric proteins of organelles. In pea chloroplasts, a binding protein interacts with newly synthesized large subunits, in quantities expected for an intermediate in the assembly process, as judged by Western blotting. Radiotracer-labeled large subunits which interact with this binding protein can be shown to assemble into Rubisco in reactions which lead to changes in the aggregation state of the binding protein. Antibody to this binding protein specifically inhibits the assembly of these subunits into Rubisco. Rubisco synthesis appears to be subject to many types of control: gene dosage, transcription rate, selective translation of message, post-translational degradation and threshold concentration effects have been observed in various organisms' synthesis of Rubisco. The biochemical mechanisms underlying most of these effects have not been elucidated. The post-translational assembly mechanism in particular appears to require further study.