An Analysis of Sonothrombolysis and Cavitation for Retracted and Unretracted Clots Using Microbubbles Versus Low-Boiling-Point Nanodroplets

Overview of Therapeutic Ultrasound Applications and Safety Considerations: 2024 Update

A 2012 review of therapeutic ultrasound was published to educate researchers and physicians on potential applications and concerns for unintended bioeffects (doi: 10.7863/jum.2012.31.4.623). This review serves as an update to the parent article, highlighting advances in therapeutic ultrasound over the past 12 years. In addition to general mechanisms for bioeffects produced by therapeutic ultrasound, current applications, and the pre-clinical and clinical stages are outlined. An overview is provided for image guidance methods to monitor and assess treatment progress. Finally, other topics relevant for the translation of therapeutic ultrasound are discussed, including computational modeling, tissue-mimicking phantoms, and quality assurance protocols.

Exploring the Postactivation Behavioral Patterns of Intratumorally Injected Theranostic Nanodroplets: An Ultrasound-Only Extravascular Monitoring Technique

Phase-change nanodroplets (PCNDs) are customizable and controllable theranostic agents of particular interest in extravascular therapies such as drug delivery and histotripsy. High-bulk-boiling-point (HBP) PCNDs are preferred for their enhanced thermal stability under physiological temperature to achieve on-demand therapeutic effects on target sites-mainly in tumor tissue. However, the behavioral patterns of high-concentration, heterogeneously distributed HBP PCNDs in vivo have rarely been explored-the foci of PCND-related therapies mostly fall on the final therapeutic effect rather than the detailed behaviors of PCNDs, which may hamper the development and improvement of in vivo treatments with PCNDs. To fill the gap, we demonstrate an ultrasound-only extravascular monitoring technique to analyze the underlying behavioral patterns of intratumorally injected HBP PCNDs. In our hypothesis, recondensation and coalescence are the two predominant patterns influencing the trend of the postactivation signal of PCNDs. A "blink map" method was, thus, proposed to separate the two parts of the signal by recognizing the unique signal pattern of stochastic recondensation, and four derivative metrics were calculated for further analysis. The results revealed the postactivation patterns of PCNDs at different activation-pulse durations and activation stages throughout the activation-imaging period, and several general trends were observed and explained by existing theories, suggesting the feasibility of our extravascular monitoring technique. Overall, this work enriches the knowledge of the characteristics of HBP PCNDs as extravascular theranostic agents, and the monitoring results have the potential to provide timely feedback on PCND-related treatments underway, which may help adjust the treatment strategy and improve the therapeutic efficacy.

Effect of Ultrasound on Thrombus debris during Sonothrombolysis in a Microfluidic device

Microbubble-mediated sonothrombolysis has been proven to be a non-invasive and efficient method for thrombolysis. Nevertheless, there is a potential risk that the thrombus debris generated during the dissolution of the original thrombus are too large and can lead to hazardous emboli. Using a sonothrombolysis microfluidic platform, we investigated the effects of ultrasound power, thrombolytic agent and microbubble concentration on the size of thrombus debris with the example of microbubble-mediated sonothrombolysis of arterial thrombus. Additionally, we studied the effects of ultrasound power on the size and shape of thrombus debris produced by acute and chronic arterial sonothrombolysis. In acute arterial sonothrombolysis, ultrasound power has significant effect on the size of thrombus debris and steadily increases with the increase of ultrasound power. Conversely, in chronic arterial sonothrombolysis, the size of thrombus debris is minimally affected by ultrasound power. Using the sonothrombolysis microfluidic platform, the relationship between ultrasound power and the safety of sonothrombolysis has been illustrated, and the sonothrombolysis microfluidic platform is demonstrated to be a promising tool for further studies on the process of sonothrombolysis.

Enhanced cavitation dose and reactive oxygen species production in microbubble-mediated sonodynamic therapy for inhibition of Escherichia coli and biofilm

Sonodynamic therapy (SDT) is an emerging antibacterial therapy. This work selected hematoporphyrin monomethyl ether (HMME) as the sonosensitizer, and studied the enhanced inhibition effect of Escherichia coli and biofilm by microbubble-mediated cavitation in SDT. Firstly, the influence of microbubble-mediated cavitation effect on different concentrations of HMME (10 µg/ml, 30 µg/ml, 50 µg/ml) was studied. Using 1,3-diphenylisobenzofuran (DPBF) as an indicator, the effect of microbubble-mediated cavitation on the production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) was studied by absorption spectroscopy. Secondly, using agar medium, laser confocal microscopy and scanning electron microscopy, the effect of microbubble-mediated cavitation on the activity and morphology of bacteria was studied. Finally, the inhibitory effect of cavitation combined with SDT on biofilm was evaluated by laser confocal microscopy. The research results indicate that: (1) Microbubble-mediated ultrasound cavitation can significantly increase cavitation intensity and production of ROS. (2) Microbubble-mediated acoustic cavitation can alter the morphological structure of bacteria. (3) It can significantly enhance the inhibition of SDT on the activity of Escherichia coli and its biofilm. Compared with the control group, the addition of microbubbles resulted in an increase in the number of dead bacteria by 61.7 %, 71.6 %, and 76.2 %, respectively. The fluorescence intensity of the biofilm decreased by 27.1 %, 80.3 %, and 98.2 %, respectively. On the basis of adding microbubbles to ensure antibacterial and biofilm inhibition effects, this work studied the influence of cavitation effect in SDT on bacterial structure, providing a foundation for further revealing the intrinsic mechanism of SDT.

Sono-activated materials for enhancing focused ultrasound ablation: Design and application in biomedicine

The ablation effect of focused ultrasound (FUS) has played an increasingly important role in the biomedical field over the past decades, and its non-invasive features have great advantages, especially for clinical diseases where surgical treatment is not available or appropriate. Recently, rapid advances in the adjustable morphology, enzyme-mimetic activity, and biostability of sono-activated materials have significantly promoted the medical application of FUS ablation. However, a systematic review of sono-activated materials based on FUS ablation is not yet available. This progress review focuses on the recent design, fundamental principles, and applications of sono-activated materials in the FUS ablation biomedical field. First, the different ablation mechanisms and the key factors affecting ablation are carefully determined. Then, the design of sono-activated materials with high FUS ablation efficiencies is comprehensively discussed. Subsequently, the representative biological applications are summarized in detail. Finally, the primary challenges and future perspectives are also outlined. We believe this timely review will provide key information and insights for further exploration of focused ultrasound ablation and new inspiration for designing future sono-activated materials. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: The ablation effect of focused ultrasound (FUS) has played an increasingly important role in the biomedical field over the past decades. However, there are also some challenges of FUS ablation, such as skin burns, tumour recurrence after thermal ablation, and difficulty in controlling cavitation ablation. The rapid advance in adjustable morphology, enzyme-mimetic activity, and biostability of sono-activated materials has significantly promoted the medical application of FUS ablation. However, the systematic review of sono-activated materials based on FUS ablation is not yet available. This progress review focuses on the recent design, fundamental principles, and applications in the FUS ablation biomedical field of sono-activated materials. We believe this timely review will provide key information and insights for further exploration of FUS ablation.

Vortex-ultrasound for microbubble-mediated thrombolysis of retracted clots

Endovascular sonothrombolysis has gained significant attention due to its benefits, including direct targeting of the thrombus with sonication and reduced side effects. However, the small aperture of endovascular transducers restricts the improvement of their potential clinical efficiency due to inefficient acoustic radiation. Hence, in an earlier study, we used vortex ultrasound with an endovascular ultrasound transducer to induce shear stress and enhance the clot lysis. In this study, the vortex acoustic transduction mechanism was investigated using numerical simulations and hydrophone tests. Following this characterization, we demonstrated the performance of the vortex ultrasound transducer in thrombolysis of retracted clots in in vitro tests. The test results indicated that the maximum lysis rates were 79.0% and 32.2% with the vortex ultrasound for unretracted and retracted clots, respectively. The vortex ultrasound enhanced the efficiency of the thrombolysis by approximately 49%, both for retracted and unretracted clots, compared with the typical non-vortex ultrasound technique. Therefore, the use of endovascular vortex ultrasound holds promise as a potential clinical option for the thrombolysis of retracted clots.

Miniaturized Stacked Transducer for Intravascular Sonothrombolysis With Internal-Illumination Photoacoustic Imaging Guidance and Clot Characterization

Thromboembolism in blood vessels can lead to stroke or heart attack and even sudden death unless brought under control. Sonothrombolysis enhanced by ultrasound contrast agents has shown promising outcome on effective treatment of thromboembolism. Intravascular sonothrombolysis was also reported recently with a potential for effective and safe treatment of deep thrombosis. Despite the promising treatment results, the treatment efficiency for clinical application may not be optimized due to the lack of imaging guidance and clot characterization during the thrombolysis procedure. In this paper, a miniaturized transducer was designed to have an 8-layer PZT-5A stacked with an aperture size of 1.4 × 1.4 mm2 and assembled in a customized two-lumen 10-Fr catheter for intravascular sonothrombolysis. The treatment process was monitored with internal-illumination photoacoustic tomography (II-PAT), a hybrid imaging modality that combines the rich contrast of optical absorption and the deep penetration of ultrasound detection. With intravascular light delivery using a thin optical fiber integrated with the intravascular catheter, II-PAT overcomes the penetration depth limited by strong optical attenuation of tissue. In-vitro PAT-guided sonothrombolysis experiments were carried out with synthetic blood clots embedded in tissue phantom. Clot position, shape, stiffness, and oxygenation level can be estimated by II-PAT at clinically relevant depth of ten centimeters. Our findings have demonstrated the feasibility of the proposed PAT-guided intravascular sonothrombolysis with real-time feedback during the treatment process.

Current Status of Sub-micron Cavitation-Enhancing Agents for Sonothrombolysis

Thrombosis in cardiovascular disease is an urgent global issue, but treatment progress is limited by the risks of current antithrombotic approaches. The cavitation effect in ultrasound-mediated thrombolysis offers a promising mechanical alternative for clot lysis. Further addition of microbubble contrast agents introduces artificial cavitation nuclei that can enhance the mechanical disruption induced by ultrasound. Recent studies have proposed sub-micron particles as novel sonothrombolysis agents with increased spatial specificity, safety and stability for thrombus disruption. In this article, the applications of different sub-micron particles for sonothrombolysis are discussed. Also reviewed are in vitro and in vivo studies that apply these particles as cavitation agents and as adjuvants to thrombolytic drugs. Finally, perspectives on future developments in sub-micron agents for cavitation-enhanced sonothrombolysis are shared.

Estimating Thrombus Elasticity by Shear Wave Elastography to Evaluate Ultrasound Thrombolysis for Thrombus With Different Stiffness

OBJECTIVE

There is uncertainty about deep vein thrombosis standard treatment as thrombus stiffness alters each case. Here, we investigated thrombus' stiffness of different compositions and ages using shear wave elastography (SWE). We then studied the effectiveness of ultrasound-thrombolysis on different thrombus compositions.

METHODS

Shear waves generated through mechanical shaker and traveled along thrombus of different hematocrit (HCT) levels, whereas 18-MHz ultrasound array used to detect wave propagation. Thrombus' stiffness was identified by the shear wave speed (SWS). In thrombolysis, a 3.2 MHz focused transducer was applied to different thrombus compositions using different powers. The thrombolysis rate was defined as the percentage of weight loss.

RESULTS

The estimated average SWS of 20%, 40%, and 60% HCT thrombus were 0.75 m/s, 0.44 m/s, and 0.32 m/s, respectively. For Thrombolysis, the percentage weight loss at 8 MPa Negative pressure for the same HCT groups were 23.1%, 35.29%, and 39.66% respectively.

CONCLUSION

SWS is inversely related to HCT level and positively related to thrombus age. High HCT thrombus had higher weight loss compared to low HCT. However, the difference between 20% and 40% HCT was more significant than between 40% and 60% HCT in both studies. Our results suggest that thrombus with higher SWS require more power to achieve the same thrombolysis rate as thrombus with lower SWS.

SIGNIFICANCE

Characterizing thrombus elastic property undergoing thrombolysis enables evaluation of ultrasound efficacy for fractionating thrombus and reveals the appropriate ultrasound parameters selection to achieve a certain thrombolysis rate in the case of a specific thrombus stiffness.