Influence of Apolipoprotein E polymorphism on susceptibility of Wilson disease

An Effort to Identify Genetic Determinants in Siblings With Wilson Disease Manifesting Striking Clinical Heterogeneity: An Exome Profiling Study of Two Indian Families

BACKGROUND

Wilson disease (WD) is a rare autosomal recessive disorder of copper metabolism caused due to mutations in the copper transporter ATP7B. There is often a striking variability of clinical manifestations among patients with ATP7B mutations, including in siblings. This phenomenon may be caused by individual differences in copper accumulation in hepatocytes and intolerance to copper toxicity as governed by genetic variations in copper metabolism genes acting as modifier loci to the disease.

OBJECTIVE

To elucidate the genetic basis of striking clinical heterogeneity among two siblings of two families with WD.

METHODS

The disease diagnosis and subsequent clinical examinations were performed by expert clinicians. The younger siblings in both families presented with early neurological manifestations at a younger age than their older siblings. Interestingly, only the younger siblings were reported to have had hepatic manifestations. Exome sequencing of all the four individuals was performed to understand their heterogeneous phenotypic outcomes.

RESULTS

Genetic screening revealed no difference in the ATP7B variant spectrum between the siblings of each family. However, the siblings of both the families were found to harbor mutually exclusive pathogenic variants in suspected modifier genes implicated in copper metabolism and/or other neurological and hepatic disorders having overlapping symptoms with WD, viz., CFTR, PPARG, ABCB11, ATP7A, CYP2D6, mTOR, TOR1A, and CP, which can potentially explain their differential clinical phenotypes.

CONCLUSION

Clinical heterogeneity between siblings with WD with the same ATP7B mutation profile may be attributed to the presence of different pathogenic variants in potential modifier genes.

Cholesterol metabolism: Towards a therapeutic approach for multiple sclerosis

Growing evidence points to the importance of cholesterol in preserving brain homeostasis. Cholesterol makes up the main component of myelin in the brain, and myelin integrity is vital in demyelinating diseases such as multiple sclerosis. Because of the connection between myelin and cholesterol, the interest in cholesterol in the central nervous system increased during the last decade. In this review, we provide a detailed overview on brain cholesterol metabolism in multiple sclerosis and its role in promoting oligodendrocyte precursor cell differentiation and remyelination.

Missing heritability of Wilson disease: a search for the uncharacterized mutations

Wilson disease (WD), a copper metabolism disorder caused by mutations in ATP7B, manifests heterogeneous clinical features. Interestingly, in a fraction of clinically diagnosed WD patients, mutations in ATP7B appears to be missing. In this review we discuss the plausible explanations of this missing heritability and propose a workflow that can identify the hidden mutations. Mutation analyses of WD generally includes targeted sequencing of ATP7B exons, exon-intron boundaries, and rarely, the proximal promoter region. We propose that variants in the distal cis-regulatory elements and/or deep intronic variants that impact splicing might well represent the hidden mutations. Heterozygous del/ins that remain refractory to conventional PCR-sequencing method may also represent such mutations. In this review, we also hypothesize that mutations in the key copper metabolism genes, like, ATOX1, COMMD1, and SLC31A1, could possibly lead to a WD-like phenotype. In fact, WD does present overlapping symptoms with other rare genetic disorders; hence, the possibility of a misdiagnosis and thus adding to missing heritability cannot be excluded. In this regard, it seems that whole-genome analysis will provide a comprehensive and rapid molecular diagnosis of WD. However, considering the associated cost for such a strategy, we propose an alternative customized screening schema of WD which include targeted sequencing of ATP7B locus as well as other key copper metabolism genes. Success of such a schema has been tested in a pilot study.

Wilson's disease: update on pathogenesis, biomarkers and treatments

Wilson's disease is an autosomal-recessive disorder of copper metabolism caused by mutations in ATP7B and associated with neurological, psychiatric, ophthalmological and hepatic manifestations. Decoppering treatments are used to prevent disease progression and reduce symptoms, but neurological outcomes remain mixed. In this article, we review the current understanding of pathogenesis, biomarkers and treatments for Wilson's disease from the neurological perspective, with a focus on recent advances. The genetic and molecular mechanisms associated with ATP7B dysfunction have been well characterised, but despite extensive efforts to identify genotype-phenotype correlations, the reason why only some patients develop neurological or psychiatric features remains unclear. We discuss pathological processes through which copper accumulation leads to neurodegeneration, such as mitochondrial dysfunction, the role of brain iron metabolism and the broader concept of selective neuronal vulnerability in Wilson's disease. Delayed diagnoses continue to be a major problem for patients with neurological presentations. We highlight limitations in our current approach to making a diagnosis and novel diagnostic biomarkers, including the potential for newborn screening programmes. We describe recent progress in developing imaging and wet (fluid) biomarkers for neurological involvement, including findings from quantitative MRI and other neuroimaging studies, and the development of a semiquantitative scoring system for assessing radiological severity. Finally, we cover the use of established and novel chelating agents, paradoxical neurological worsening, and progress developing targeted molecular and gene therapy for Wilson's disease, before discussing future directions for translational research.

Copper and lipid metabolism: A reciprocal relationship

BACKGROUND

Copper and lipid metabolism are intimately linked, sharing a complex, inverse relationship in the periphery (outside of the central nervous system), which remains to be fully elucidated.

SCOPE

Copper and lipids have independently been implicated in the pathogenesis of diseases involving dyslipidaemia, including obesity, cardiovascular disease and non-alcoholic fatty liver disease and also in Wilson disease, an inherited disorder of copper overload. Here we review the relationship between copper and lipid regulatory pathways, which are potential druggable targets for therapeutic intervention.

MAJOR CONCLUSIONS

While the inverse relationship between copper and lipids is apparent, tissue-specific roles for the copper regulatory protein, ATP7B provide further insight into the association between copper and lipid metabolism.

GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE

Understanding the relationship between copper and lipid metabolism is important for identifying druggable targets for diseases with disrupted copper and/or lipid metabolism; and may reveal similar connections within the brain and in neurological diseases with impaired copper and lipid transport.

Difference in iron metabolism may partly explain sex-related variability in the manifestation of Wilson's disease

BACKGROUND/AIM

Wilson's disease (WD) is a hereditary disorder characterized by abnormal metabolism of copper. For unknown reasons, the clinical picture of this disease appears to be sex-dependent. Because the metabolism of copper and iron is interrelated, we aimed to evaluate whether the variability in the clinical picture of WD could be explained by the sex difference in iron metabolism.

METHODS

A total of 138 WD patients were examined in this study: 39 newly diagnosed, treatment naive patients and 99 individuals already treated with decoppering drugs. The serum concentration of ceruloplasmin (Cp) and copper were measured using an enzymatic colorimetric assay and by atomic absorption spectroscopy, respectively. The parameters of iron metabolism were determined by using standard laboratory methods and enzyme immunoassays.

RESULTS

In the treatment naive group men had a higher median serum concentration of ferritin (290.5 vs. 81.0 ng/mL, p < 10^-4), and hepcidin (Hepc) (55.4 vs. 22.8 ng/mL, p < 10^-3) compared to women, and tended to have higher concentration of iron, hemoglobin (HGB) and number of red blood cells (RBC). In the treated group men had higher median ferritin (122.0 vs. 46.0 ng/mL, p < 10^-4), Hepc (23.5 vs. 10.8 ng/mL, p < 10^-4), iron (102.5 vs. 68.0 μg/dL, p < 10^-4), HGB (15.0 vs. 13.2 g/dL, p < 10^-4), and RBC (5.0 vs. 4.5 M/L, p < 10^-4) than women.

CONCLUSION

Iron metabolism differs between men and women with WD, which may partly explain the sex difference noted in the disease manifestation.

Effect of homeostatic iron regulator protein gene mutation on Wilson's disease clinical manifestation: original data and literature review

OBJECTIVE

Wilson's disease (WD) is a hereditary disorder of copper metabolism. The metabolic pathways of copper and iron are interrelated. Our goal was to determine the frequency of the two most common mutations in the coding region of the human iron homeostatic protein gene (HFE) in Europe: C282Y (rs1800562) and H63D (rs1799945) in WD patients, as well as to analyze their relation with WD phenotypic traits.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

HFE mutations were studied by PCR RFLP method in 445 WD patients and 102 controls. All patients met the diagnostic criteria of WD 8^th International Conference on Wilson Disease and Menkes Disease.

RESULTS

HFE C282Y heterozygotes, both women and men, showed WD symptoms earlier than patients with wild-type HFE genotype. HFE 63HD heterozygous men presented symptoms later than HFE 63HH homozygotes, but HFE 63HD women manifested symptoms later than those with HFE 63HH genotype.

CONCLUSIONS

HFE genotype seems to be one of the factors modifying Wilson's disease phenotype.

Dopamine β hydroxylase (DBH) polymorphisms do not contribute towards the clinical course of Wilson's disease in Indian patients

BACKGROUND

Wilson's disease (WD) is a rare copper metabolism disorder with hepatic and neurological symptoms. Dopamine β hydroxylase (DBH) encodes a copper-dependent mono-oxygenase that converts dopamine to norepinephrine, thereby regulating the endogenous dopamine content in the neurons. Polymorphisms of DBH have been reported to be associated with several neurological diseases, such as Parkinson's disease, Alzheimer's disease, schizophrenia and attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder, which have overlapping neurological symptoms with WD. The present study aimed to assess the role of DBH polymorphisms on the clinical course of WD.

METHODS

In total, 141 WD patients from India were included in the present study. Three polymorphisms of DBH (rs1611115 in the promoter, rs1108580 in exon 2 and rs129882 in 3'-UTR) were screened for their association with the clinical attributes (hepatic and neurological features) and age of onset of WD using a polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymorphsm method and sequencing approach. The distribution of genotype or allele frequencies was tested using 2 × 2 contingency chi-squared and logistic regression analysis (additive, dominant and recessive model).

RESULTS

The genotypic and allelic frequencies of these single nucleotide polymophisms did not vary significantly along with the clinical symptoms (hepatic and neurological) or the age of onset of WD. No significant association was observed when we analyzed our samples with respect to harboring different kinds of ATP7B mutations (nonsense/in-del and missense).

CONCLUSIONS

The data obtained in the present study suggest that the selected DBH variants are unlikely to have any significant contribution towards modifying the clinical symptoms of Indian WD patients.

In-silico analysis of novel p.(Gly14Ser) variant of ATOX1 gene: plausible role in modulating ATOX1-ATP7B interaction

Clinical heterogeneity is commonly observed in Wilson disease (WD), including cases with identical ATP7B mutations. It is thought to be an outcome of impairment in other genes involved in cellular copper homeostasis in addition to the mutations in the ATP7B gene. ATOX1, a copper chaperone that delivers copper to ATP7B, is a potential genetic modifier of WD. In the present study, we analyzed the genetic variations in the ATOX1 gene in 50 WD patients and 60 controls. We identified four novel variants, of which, the coding region variant c.40G > A, p.(Gly14Ser) was observed in 2% alleles. Interestingly, p.(Gly14Ser) was seen with an early onset age, reduced serum ceruloplasmin level and manifestations of liver and brain in a WD patient unlike the other having identical ATP7B mutation but normal ATOX1 alleles. Further, computational analysis predicted that p.(Gly14Ser) substitution, in the critical copper binding motif (MXCXG₁₄C) of the protein, affects the protein-protein interaction involved in copper sharing and transfer between ATOX1 and ATP7B-MBD4. Our findings suggest that p.(Gly14Ser) variant of ATOX1 might play a role as a genetic modifier leading to phenotypic variation in WD.

Apolipoprotein E in lipoprotein metabolism, health and cardiovascular disease

Apolipoprotein E (apoE), a 34 kDa circulating glycoprotein of 299 amino acids, predominantly synthesised in the liver, associates with triglyceride-rich lipoproteins to mediate the clearance of their remnants after enzymatic lipolysis in the circulation. Its synthesis in macrophages initiates the formation of high density-like lipoproteins to effect reverse cholesterol transport to the liver. In the nervous system apoE forms similar lipoproteins which perform the function of distributing lipids amongst cells. ApoE accounts for much of the variation in plasma lipoproteins by three common variants (isoforms) that influence low-density lipoprotein concentration and the risk of atherosclerosis. ApoE2 generally is most favourable and apoE4 least favourable for cardiovascular and neurological health. The apoE variants relate to different amino acids at positions 112 and 158: cysteine in both for apoE2, arginine at both sites for apoE4, and respectively cysteine and arginine for apoE3 that is viewed as the wild type. Paradoxically, under metabolic stress, homozygosity for apoE2 may result in dysbetalipoproteinaemia in adults owing to impaired binding of remnant lipoproteins to the LDL receptor and related proteins as well as heparan sulphate proteoglycans. This highly atherogenic condition is also seen with other mutations in apoE, but with autosomal dominant inheritance. Mutations in apoE may also cause lipoprotein glomerulopathy. In the central nervous system apoE binds amyloid β-protein and tau protein and fragments may incur cellular damage. ApoE4 is a strong risk factor for the development of Alzheimer's disease. ApoE has several other physiological effects that may influence health and disease, including supply of docosahexaenoic acid for the brain and modulating immune and inflammatory responses. Genotyping of apoE may have application in disorders of lipoprotein metabolism as well as glomerulopathy and may be relevant to personalised medicine in understanding cardiovascular risk, and the outcome of nutritional and therapeutic interventions. Quantitation of apoE will probably not be clinically useful. ApoE is also of interest as it may generate peptides with biological function and could be employed in nanoparticles that may allow crossing of the blood-brain barrier. Therapeutic options may emerge from these newer insights.

Potential Role of Brain-Derived Neurotrophic Factor and Dopamine Receptor D2 Gene Variants as Modifiers for the Susceptibility and Clinical Course of Wilson's Disease

Wilson's disease (WD), an inborn error of copper metabolism caused by mutations in the ATPase copper transporting beta (ATP7B) gene, manifests variable age of onset and different degrees of hepatic and neurological disturbances. This complex phenotypical outcome of a classical monogenic disease can possibly be explained by modifier loci regulating the clinical course of the disease. The brain-derived neurotropic factor (BDNF), critical for the survival, morphogenesis, and plasticity of the neurons, and the dopamine receptor D2 (DRD2), one of the most abundant dopamine receptors in the brain, have been highlighted in the pathophysiology of various neuropsychiatric diseases. This study aims to identify the potential association between BDNF and DRD2 gene polymorphisms and WD and its clinical characteristics. A total of 164 WD patients and 270 controls from India were included in this study. Two BDNF polymorphisms [p.Val66Met (c.G196A) and c.C270T] and the DRD2 Taq1A (A2/A1 or C/T) polymorphism were examined for their association with WD and some of its clinical attributes, using polymerase chain reaction, restriction fragment length digestion, and bidirectional sequencing. The C allele and CC genotype of BDNF C270T were significantly overrepresented among controls compared to WD patients. In addition, a significantly higher proportion of the allele coding for Val and the corresponding homozygous genotype of BDNF Val66Met polymorphism was found among WD patients with age of onset later than 10 years. Furthermore, the A1A1 genotype of DRD2 Taq1A polymorphism was significantly more common among WD patients with rigidity. Our data suggest that both BDNF and DRD2 may act as potential modifiers of WD phenotype in the Indian context.