Urinary saturation: casual or causal risk factor in urolithiasis?

Correlation research demonstrates that an inflammatory diet is a risk factor for calcium oxalate renal stone formation

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Previous studies have demonstrated associations between the Dietary Inflammatory Index (DII®), an analytical tool which evaluates the inflammatory potential of the diet according to the pro- and anti-inflammatory properties of its components, and renal stone formation. However, these have not comprehensively addressed important parameters such as stone type, gender, DII scores in stone formers (SFs) and healthy controls (Cs) and associations of DII with urine and blood chemistries. These were adopted as the survey parameters for the present study, the purpose of which was to test whether the contributory role of an inflammatory diet on stone formation could be further confirmed.

METHODS

97 calcium oxalate (CaOx) SFs and 63 Cs, matched for age and gender each completed a semi-quantitative food frequency questionnaire from which nutrient composition was computed. These data were used to calculate the DII® score. To control the effect of energy intake, energy-adjusted DII scores were calculated per 1000 kcal consumed (E-DII™). A single blood sample and two consecutive overnight (8h) urine samples were collected from a subset (n = 59 SFs and n = 54 Cs) of the overall number of particpants (n = 160). These were analysed for renal stone risk factors. Data were analysed using regression models fit in R software.

RESULTS

E-DII scores were found to fit the data better than DII, so they were used throughout. E-DII scores were significantly more positive (more pro-inflammatory) in SFs than in controls in the combined gender group (-0.34 vs. -1.73, p < 0.0001) and separately in males (-0.43 vs. -1.78, p = 0.01) and females (-0.26 vs. - 1.61, p = 0.05). In blood, a significant negative correlation was seen between E-DII and HDL cholesterol. In urine significant positive correlations were seen between E-DII and each of calcium (ρ = 0.25, p = 0.02), phosphate (ρ = 0.48, p < 0.001), magnesium (ρ = 0.33, p < 0.0001) and uric acid (ρ = 0.27, p = 0.004) concentrations. A significant negative correlation was seen between E-DII and urinary volume ρ = -0.27, p = 0.003). There was no correlation between E-DII scores and the relative supersaturations of urinary CaOx, calcium phosphate (brushite) and uric acid.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings provide hitherto unreported quantitative evidence in support of the notion that the diet of calcium oxalate renal stone patients is significantly more pro-inflammatory than that of healthy controls.

Proposal for pathogenesis-based treatment options to reduce calcium oxalate stone recurrence

Objective

Prevalence of kidney stone disease continues to increase globally with recurrence rates between 30% and 50% despite technological and scientific advances. Reduction in recurrence would improve patient outcomes and reduce cost and stone morbidities. Our objective was to review results of experimental studies performed to determine the efficacy of readily available compounds that can be used to prevent recurrence.

Methods

All relevant literature up to October 2020, listed in PubMed is reviewed.

Results

Clinical guidelines endorse the use of evidence-based medications, such as alkaline agents and thiazides, to reduce urinary mineral supersaturation and recurrence. However, there may be additional steps during stone pathogenesis where medications could moderate stone risk. Idiopathic calcium oxalate stones grow attached to Randall's plaques or plugs. Results of clinical and experimental studies suggest involvement of reactive oxygen species and oxidative stress in the formation of both the plaques and plugs. The renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system (RAAS), nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate (NADPH) oxidase, mitochondria, and NOD-like receptor pyrin domain containing-3 (NLRP3) inflammasome have all been implicated at specific steps during stone pathogenesis in animal models.

Conclusion

In addition to supersaturation-reducing therapies, the use of anti-oxidants, free radical scavengers, and inhibitors of NADPH oxidase, NLRP3 inflammasome, and RAAS may prove beneficial for stone prevention. Compounds such as statins and angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitors are already in use as therapeutics for hypertension and cardio-vascular disease and have previously shown to reduce calcium oxalate nephrolithiasis in rats. Although clinical evidence for their use in stone prevention in humans is limited, experimental data support they be considered along with standard evidence-based medications and clinical expertise when patients are being counselled for stone prevention.

Efficacy of Theobromine and Its Metabolites in Reducing the Risk of Uric Acid Lithiasis

Uric acid lithiasis accounts for about 10% of all types of renal lithiasis. The most common causes of uric acid lithiasis are low urinary pH, followed by high concentration of urinary uric acid, and low diuresis. Treatment of patients consists of alkalinization of urine, reducing the consumption of purine-rich foods, and administration of xanthine oxidase inhibitors, because there are no established therapeutic inhibitors of uric acid crystallization. We recently found that theobromine inhibited uric acid crystallization in vitro, and that the increased urinary level of theobromine following its oral consumption was associated with the prevention of uric acid crystallization. In this study, we evaluated the inhibitory effects of theobromine metabolites and other methylxanthine-related compounds on uric acid crystallization. We also measured the urinary concentrations of theobromine and its metabolites in samples from healthy individuals and patients with uric acid stones and compared the extent of uric acid supersaturation and uric acid crystal formation in these different samples. Theobromine and other methylxanthines that lacked a substituent at position 1 inhibited uric acid crystallization, but other methylxanthines did not have this effect. Individuals with clinical parameters that favored uric acid crystallization did not develop uric acid crystals when theobromine and its metabolites were in the urine at high levels. Thus, theobromine and its metabolites reduced the risk of uric acid lithiasis.

Validation of a novel diagnostic test for assessing the risk of urinary uric acid crystallization

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Uric acid (UA) kidney stones account for 10 to 11% of all kidney stones, and this percentage has increased over time. An accurate, rapid, simple, and low-cost test is needed to distinguish urine that is susceptible and resistant to the formation of UA crystals. The aim of this paper is to develop a test to assess the risk for UA crystallization (RUAC) and to validate its utility in routine clinical practice by analysis of urine samples of UA stone formers and healthy volunteers.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Urine samples of 20 healthy adult volunteers and 54 active formers of UA stones were collected. Three samples were collected from each participant, with at least 7 days between each collection. The main lithogenic parameters for UA stones were determined, and an RUAC test was performed in all urine samples.

RESULTS

Our RUAC test reliably discriminated urine that was resistant and susceptible to the formation of UA crystals. This test had high specificity (94%) and a low percentage of false negatives.

CONCLUSION

The RUAC test described here had high diagnostic accuracy, low-cost, and a rapid assay time, that make this test an attractive screening tool for UA stone fomers follow-up.

LITHORISK.COM: the novel version of a software for calculating and visualizing the risk of renal stone

Estimation of state of saturation with stone-forming salt represents a reliable tool to assess the overall risk. The available methods are based on computer-assisted ab initio calculations. Our earlier method URSUS was subsequently substituted by Lithorisk®, a software including visualization of risk profiles. Unfortunately, Lithorisk does not adapt to new versions of Windows® and Macintosh® Apple, neither runs on smartphones or tablets. We propose a novel version of the software which can be directly used online on any device equipped by different operating systems. Upon online connection and after registration, the software is ready for unlimited accesses, in either Italian, English or French. After digiting input variables (urea and creatinine also included) in a fixed dashboard, state of saturation is promptly given. In addition to state of saturation (ß) with calcium oxalate, brushite and uric acid, ß struvite and cystine are available. Both input variables and ß results are graphically depicted as green or red horizontal bars to indicate recommended values. The software was implemented with equations allowing to omit sulphate and ammonium excretion for users with difficult access to these measurements. This simplified version, tested for ßCaOx and ßBsh on 100 urine samples showed close correlation with the full version. The software gives a list of total and free concentrations and soluble complex species distribution. Results can be printed or saved as PDF. So, we propose an easily accessible software to estimate state of saturation usable on any operating system and personal device.

Comparison of Supersaturation Outputs from Different Programs and Their Application in Testing Correspondence with Kidney Stone Composition

Introduction: Relative supersaturation (SS) for calcium oxalate (CaOx), calcium phosphate (CaP), and uric acid (UA) has been used for assessing urinary crystallization and estimated by programs, including EQUIL, Joint Expert Speciation System (JESS), and Lithorisk. We compared outputs from these programs and their correspondence with stone composition. Materials and Methods: SS of CaOx, CaP, and UA, using EQUIL, JESS, and Lithorisk were calculated from stone-forming patients. Pearson correlation coefficients were used to ascertain the correspondence between the outputs. Fractional regression models evaluated the relationship between SS and the percentage of each compound in the stones. Results: Two hundred eleven patients were included. Pearson correlation coefficients for CaOx (r ≥ 0.96), CaP (r ≥ 0.99), and UA SS (r ≥ 0.99) showed a high correspondence between all programs. We observed a significant correspondence between CaOx SS and the percentage of CaOx dihydrate in the stone (p < 0.001), as well as between the percentage of brushite and apatite and CaP SS. UA SS showed the strongest correspondence with the percentage of UA in the stones (p < 0.001). Conclusions: Good correlation between EQUIL, JESS, and Lithorisk was observed and good correspondence with stone composition. The magnitude of the association demonstrated by fractional regression models supports evidence for applying SS in clinical practice.

Low Sodium Diet Decreases Stone Formation in Genetic Hypercalciuric Stone-Forming Rats

BACKGROUND

Urine (u) calcium (Ca) excretion is directly dependent on dietary sodium (Na) intake leading to the recommendation for Na restriction in hypercalciuric kidney stone formers. However, there is no direct evidence that limiting Na intake will reduce recurrent stone formation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We used genetic hypercalciuric stone-forming (GHS) rats, which universally form Ca phosphate (P) kidney stones, fed either a low Na (LNa, 0.05%) or normal Na (NNa, 0.4%) Na diet (D) for 18 weeks. Urine was collected at 6-week intervals. Radiographic analysis for stone formation and bone analyses were done at the conclusion of the study.

RESULTS

Mean uCa was lower with LNaD than NNaD as was uP and LNaD decreased mean uNa and uChloride. There were no differences in urine supersaturation (SS) with respect to calcium phosphate (CaP) or Ca oxalate (CaOx). However, stone formation was markedly decreased with LNaD by radiographic analysis. The LNaD group had significantly lower femoral anterior-posterior diameter and volumetric bone mineral density (vBMD), but no change in vertebral trabecular vBMD. There were no differences in the bone formation rate or osteoclastic bone resorption between groups. The LNaD group had significantly lower femoral stiffness; however, the ultimate load and energy to fail was not different.

CONCLUSION

Thus, a low Na diet reduced uCa and stone formation in GHS rats, even though SS with respect to CaP and CaOx was unchanged and effects on bone were modest. These data, if confirmed in humans, support dietary Na restriction to prevent recurrent Ca nephrolithiasis.

Uric acid stones, clinical manifestations and therapeutic considerations

Uric acid stones account for 10%-15% of all urinary stones. Changes in dietary habits, environment or both can result in the increase of uric acid stones. The formation of uric acid stones is related to hyperuricosuria, low urinary volume and persistently low urinary pH. Diabetes and obesity also significantly increase the risk of stone formation. Dual-energy CT provides a convenient and reliable method for diagnosis. Stone composition analysis and 24-hour urine metabolic evaluations should be considered for further evaluation. Most small uric acid stones (diameter <2 cm) can be treated by pharmacotherapy or extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy. However, ureteroscopy and other minimally invasive procedures should be reserved for larger stones (diameter ≥2 cm), or patients with concomitant urinary tract obstruction and/or infections. Additionally, adjustment of potential pathophysiologic defects by pharmacotherapy and dietary modification is strongly recommended for the prevention of uric stone recurrence.

Impact of food quantity and quality on the biochemical risk of renal stone formation

OBJECTIVE

This study evaluated the role of body mass index (BMI) and dietary potential renal acid load (PRAL) with urinary saturation for calcium oxalate (US-CaOx), calcium phosphate (US-CaP) and uric acid (US-UA) in renal stone formers.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective analysis was conducted of laboratory data collected on 442 renal stone-forming patients. Demographic information, BMI and 24 h urinary samples were collected from patients on their regular diets. PRAL was calculated as the Load of Acid to Kidney Evaluation (LAKE) score through a short questionnaire.

RESULTS

Urinary risk factors, but also inhibitors of calcium stone formation such as magnesium, tended to increase in relation to BMI (p = .000). Urinary pH (p = .002) and ammonium/sulfate ratio (p = .000) were negatively related to BMI. This resulted in a positive correlation between BMI and US-UA (p = .000), whereas US-CaOx and US-CaP were not influenced by BMI. LAKE score was positively correlated with US-CaOx (p = .022) and US-CaP (p = .000) as a consequence of the inverse relationship between LAKE score and citrate (p = .000). Multiple linear regression analysis identified BMI (p = .009) and male gender (p = .002) as independent predictors of US-UA, and LAKE score (p = .004) and age (p = .001) as independent predictors of US-CaP.

CONCLUSIONS

BMI, which depends on excessive intake of energy from food, is not related to an increased biochemical risk of calcium stone formation, which is more dependent on the renal acid load of the diet. In contrast, obesity is associated with an increased risk of uric acid stone formation due to insulin resistance, impaired ammoniagenesis and low urinary pH.

Urinary supersaturation as a diagnostic measure in urolithiasis

AIM

To demonstrate that urinary supersaturation per se is not a reliable diagnostic measure of the risk for stone formation.

METHODS

Available physical and chemical data for calcium oxalate monohydrate (COM) and calcium hydrogen phosphate dihydrate (brushite, BRU), and urinary supersaturations with respect to COM and BRU in healthy individuals and stone formers, were obtained from the literature. Classical theory of nucleation was used for calculations.

RESULTS

It was found that the rate of homogeneous nucleation (unaided by substrates) of COM and BRU is nil at all conceivable supersaturations of urine. Consequently spontaneous formation of crystals in urine requires the presence of nucleation substrates for (heteronuclei).

CONCLUSION

Urinary supersaturation with respect to lithiatic compounds is a necessary, but not a sufficient condition for nephrolithiasis. The absence of crystallization inhibitors and the presence of efficient nucleation promoters (heteronuclei) in urine are further necessary conditions of urolithiasis occurrence. Urinary supersaturation per se is not a reliable diagnostic measure of the risk of kidney stone formation.

Timelines of the "free-particle" and "fixed-particle" models of stone-formation: theoretical and experimental investigations

Two major theories on renal stone formation will be reviewed, the “free-particle” and “fixed-particle” mechanisms. These theories combine data on intrinsic factors (inborn metabolic errors), extrinsic factors (diet), renal cell responses and the physico-chemistry and biochemistry of urine into mechanisms of stone formation. This paper describes the specific role of time in both mechanisms. The timeline of crystal- and stone formation was deducted from literature data and was measured for two stones using radioisotope decay analysis. The stones of similar size and composition showed, respectively, a timeline of a few years and a development that took decades. In combination with data on stone architecture and patient characteristics these timelines are explained using the free-particle and fixed-particle mechanisms. Consideration of the timeline of stone formation has clinical implications. We conclude that the fixed-particle mechanism can be a slow process where decades pass between the first formation of a precipitate in the renal interstitium and the clinical presentation of the stone. Added to the fact that the mechanism of this initial precipitation is still ill defined, the conditions that started fixed-particle stone formation in an individual patient can be obscure. Blood and urine analysis in such patients does not necessarily reveal the individual’s risk for recurrence as lifestyle may have changed over time. This is in fact what defines the so-called idiopathic stoneformers. For these patients, prevention of outgrowth of previously formed precipitates, papillary plaques, may be more relevant than prevention of new plaque formation. In contrast, a patient who has formed a stone in a relatively short time through the free-particle mechanism is more likely to show abnormal values in blood and urine that explain the starting event of stone formation. In these patients, measurement of such values provides useful information to guide preventive measures.