Real-world experience with the Sydney System on 1458 cases of lymph node fine needle aspiration cytology

Endobronchial ultrasound-guided transbronchial fine needle aspiration of mediastinal lymphadenopathy: Diagnostic performance and clinical implications of the World Health Organization reporting system

INTRODUCTION

Lymph node fine-needle aspiration cytology (LN-FNAC) is a common, rapid, minimally invasive and cost-effective diagnostic method. For mediastinal lymph nodes, endobronchial ultrasound (EBUS) guided LN-FNAC is a first-line investigation and has an indispensable role in the diagnosis and staging of patients with suspected lung cancer. Recently, a new WHO system has been proposed for classification of LN-FNAC heralding five different diagnostic categories; insufficient, benign, atypical, suspicious for malignancy and malignant. The aim of this study was to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy and risk of malignancy (ROM) of these categories in EBUS-guided LN-FNAC from mediastinal lymph nodes.

METHOD

We evaluated 2110 consecutive mediastinal lymph nodes during this one-year retrospective study. Corresponding radiological images and histologic material were used as ground truth to calculate accuracy, sensitivity, specificity and ROM.

RESULTS

The WHO system showed an overall accuracy of 93.7% with a sensitivity of 83.0% and a specificity of 97.5%. The positive predictive value was 92.3% and the negative predictive value 94.2%. The overall ROM for each category in the WHO classification system was 12.8% for the inadequate, 2.4% for the benign, 47.4% for the atypical, 81.0% for the suspicious for malignancy and 93.6% for the malignant category.

CONCLUSION

The results of the present study indicate that the new WHO system entails a high diagnostic accuracy regarding EBUS-guided LN-FNAC assessment of mediastinal lymph nodes and supports its integration into clinical practice. Application of the WHO system standardizes risk assessment thus facilitating communication between cytopathologists and clinicians and minimizes the need for histopathological analysis.

The Current and Future Impact of Lymph Node Fine-Needle Aspiration Cytology on Patient Care

Lymph node (LN) fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) is a common diagnostic procedure for lymphadenopathies. Despite the qualities and potentialities of LN-FNAC, the number of possible pathologies and the variety of clinical contexts represent a challenge and require a continuous upgrading of the procedure according to the emerging clinical requests and new technologies. This study presents an overview of the current and future impact of LN-FNAC on the care of patients with lymphadenopathy.

The Sydney system for lymph node FNA biopsy cytopathology: A detailed analysis of recent publications and meta-analysis and a proposal for the components of an ideal prospective study of a cytopathology reporting system

BACKGROUND

The Sydney system for fine-needle aspiration biopsy of lymph nodes has five categories, stressing the role of correlation of cytopathology with clinical, ultrasound, and ancillary findings to achieve diagnosis. The five categories constitute a hierarchical system with increasing risk of malignancy from benign to atypical, suspicious, and malignant categories, which informs recommendations for further workup to achieve a final diagnosis as possible. This article analyzes 10 publications using the Sydney system and a meta-analysis of nine of these studies. The primary goal of the analysis is to ascertain the causes of the large ranges in risk of malignancy for the "atypical" and "inadequate" compared to "benign," "suspicious," and "malignant" categories, which were comparable to well-established reporting systems. Research protocols are proposed to improve future studies.

METHODS

PubMed literature search from January 2021 to December 2023 identified studies evaluating performance of the Sydney system.

RESULTS

Ten studies showed heterogeneity with clinical setting, study design, ultrasound use and rapid on-site evaluation, operator, cutoff points for "positive" cases, with inherent partial verification biases, resulting in a wide range of risk of malignancy, specificity, and sensitivity values.

CONCLUSION

Analysis shows the large range is due to heterogeneity of the studies, which suffer from biases and variable statistical analysis that are ultimately included in any meta-analysis, detracting from the usefulness of the risk of malignancy derived by the meta-analysis. Components for ideal analyses of reporting systems are presented.

Uses and limitations of small-volume biopsies for the diagnosis of lymphoma

Although surgical biopsy remains the gold standard for the diagnosis of lymphoma, small-volume biopsies including fine-needle aspiration and core needle biopsy are increasingly being used as a first line diagnostic tool. Small-volume biopsies are safe, rapid and cost effective; however, diagnostic utility varies by lymphoma subtype. It is important for pathologists and clinicians to recognize both the strengths and limitations of such biopsies.

Combined fine needle aspiration cytology and core needle biopsy in the same setting: A two-years' experience

INTRODUCTION

Fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) combined with rapid on-site evaluation (ROSE) and ancillary techniques is an accurate diagnostic tool for many pathologies. However, in some cases, it may not be sufficient for actionable diagnoses or molecular testing, especially for cases that require large immunohistochemical panels or cases in which histological features are mandatory for the diagnosis. Core needle biopsy (CNB), on the contrary, provides samples that are suitable for histological features and sufficient for all ancillary studies. However, CNB is often performed by radiologists or clinicians without the direct participation of cytopathologists, which can lead to missed or delayed diagnoses. This study reports on the experience of combining FNAC and CNB performed in one setting by cytopathologists. The aim was to evaluate the impact of CNB on FNAC and the diagnostic efficiency of the combined procedures.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

One hundred forty-two FNAC and CNB procedures performed in the same setting over a period of 2 years were analysed. The FNAC diagnoses were compared and integrated with the subsequent CNB diagnoses. The impact of CNB was categorized as follows: non-contributory, in cases of inadequate samples; confirmed, when the CNB and FNAC diagnoses were the same; improved, when the CNB diagnosis was consistent with the FNAC diagnosis and further specified the corresponding entity; allowed, when CNB produced a diagnosis that could not be reached by FNAC; changed, when the CNB changed the previous FNAC diagnosis.

RESULTS

CNB confirmed the FNAC diagnosis in 40.1% of cases (n = 57/142). CNB improved the FNAC diagnosis in 47.2% of cases (n = 67/142). CNB allowed a diagnosis that could not be performed on FNAC in 2.1% of cases (n = 3/142). CNB changed a previous FNAC diagnosis in 2.1% of cases (n = 3/142). CNB was non-contributory in 8.4% of cases (n = 12/142). CNB produced a positive impact on the whole diagnostic procedure in 51.4% of total cases (n = 73/142). The combined FNAC and CNB resulted in actionable diagnoses in 91.5% of all cases (n = 130/142). A complete molecular assessment was successfully performed in 14.7% of cases (n = 21/142) utilizing either FNAC or CNB material.

CONCLUSIONS

The combined use of FNAC and CNB in one setting improves the diagnostic accuracy of both procedures. This approach exploits the advantages of each procedure, enhancing the accuracy of the final diagnosis.

Pitfalls in Lymph Node Fine Needle Aspiration Cytology

BACKGROUND

Fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) is an accurate, minimally invasive, and cost-effective biopsy method for enlarged lymph nodes. While the role of lymph node FNAC in the diagnosis of infectious or reactive conditions and metastatic malignancy is unquestioned, differing views still exist on its role in the diagnosis of lymphoma. Nevertheless, regardless of the practice setting, pitfalls and potential for error exist, and it is incumbent upon the pathologist to be aware of these pitfalls, as this is the first line of defence against errors.

SUMMARY

This discussion will focus on potential interpretational errors, specifically highlighting scenarios leading to false-negative and false-positive diagnosis and errors in tumour classification, with an emphasis on cytomorphology. Potential entities that may fly below the radar of the pathologist - so-called off-radar entities - are also discussed, as a reminder to consider broad differentials in cases with unusual morphologic features. Some reasons for false-negative diagnoses include low-grade lymphomas that mimic a mixed, polymorphous reactive lymphoid population or aspirates with a paucity of lesional cells, through either sampling error or the intrinsic nature of the entity, e.g., nodular lymphocyte predominant Hodgkin lymphoma. Some of the potential causes of false-positive diagnoses that are discussed include viral-associated lymphadenopathy, Kikuchi-Fujimoto lymphadenitis, or benign adnexal lesions mimicking metastatic malignancy. Errors in tumour classification covered include metastatic carcinoma, sarcoma, melanoma, and lymphoma mimicking each other, and Hodgkin lymphoma and its mimics. Finally, less common entities such as follicular dendritic cell sarcoma and others are briefly mentioned, to remind us of conditions that may slip under our diagnostic radar.

KEY MESSAGES

A systematic review of diagnostic pitfalls and traps is elucidated here, with some tips to avoid these traps. The triple approach to the diagnostic workup is emphasised, which includes rigorous clinicopathologic correlation, attention to cytomorphology, and judicious application of ancillary tests.

Cytopathological differential diagnosis of malignant tumor cells in the cerebrospinal fluid: A retrospective analysis

Leptomeningeal metastasis is the spread of cancer to the leptomeninges and subarachnoid space and represents a dreadful complication of cancer. The most commonly responsible neoplasms are high-grade lymphomas, leukemias, and some solid tumors, chiefly breast and lung cancer as well as melanoma. Herein we report our ten-year retrospective experience on 715 cases of cerebrospinal fluid cytology, 21 (2.9%) of which were positive for leptomeningeal metastasis. Sample collection and processing, clinical history, interdisciplinary dialog, and ancillary techniques such as immunocytochemistry and flow cytometry are all fundamental in reaching the correct diagnosis and thus optimally caring for patients with leptomeningeal metastasis.

Cystic lesions in the salivary gland. Pitfalls to be avoided on cytology

Cystic lesions of the salivary glands are very uncommon entities. However, on occasion, some neoplasms of the salivary glands show a cystic component, which may be predominant or only partially cystic. Basal cell adenoma, canalicular adenoma, oncocytoma, sebaceous adenoma, intraductal papilloma, epithelial-myoepithelial carcinoma, intraductal carcinoma, and secretory carcinoma are such cystic entities. Cystic degeneration and necrosis, which can develop within solid tumours, represent another possibility. The ability to recognise this type of lesion is a challenge in diagnostic cytology because hypocellular fluid is frequently recovered. Furthermore, evaluating all of the differential diagnoses for cystic lesions of the salivary glands is helpful in obtaining the correct diagnosis. Herein, we evaluate the various types of cystic lesions within the salivary glands.

Digital Examination of LYmph node CYtopathology Using the Sydney system (DELYCYUS): An international, multi-institutional study

BACKGROUND

After a series of standardized reporting systems in cytopathology, the Sydney system was recently introduced to address the need for reproducibility and standardization in lymph node cytopathology. Since then, the risk of malignancy for the categories of the Sydney system has been explored by several studies, but no studies have yet examined the interobserver reproducibility of the Sydney system.

METHODS

The authors assessed interobserver reproducibility of the Sydney system on 85 lymph node fine-needle aspiration cytology cases reviewed by 15 cytopathologists from 12 institutions in eight different countries, resulting in 1275 diagnoses. In total, 186 slides stained with Diff-Quik, Papanicolaou, and immunocytochemistry were scanned. A subset of the cases included clinical data and results from ultrasound examinations, flow cytometry immunophenotyping, and fluorescence in situ hybridization analysis. The study participants assessed the cases digitally using whole-slide images.

RESULTS

Overall, the authors observed an almost perfect agreement of cytopathologists with the ground truth (median weighted Cohen κ = 0.887; interquartile range, κ = 0.210) and moderate overall interobserver concordance (Fleiss κ = 0.476). There was substantial agreement for the inadequate and malignant categories (κ = 0.794 and κ = 0.729, respectively), moderate agreement for the benign category (κ = 0.490), and very slight agreement for the suspicious (κ = 0.104) and atypical (κ = 0.075) categories.

CONCLUSIONS

The Sydney system for reporting lymph node cytopathology shows adequate interobserver concordance. Digital microscopy is an adequate means to assess lymph node cytopathology specimens.

COVID-19 post-vaccination lymphadenopathy: A review of the use of fine needle aspiration cytology

COVID-19 vaccine-associated clinical lymphadenopathy (C19-LAP) and subclinical lymphadenopathy (SLDI), which are mainly detected by 18F-FDG PET-CT, have been observed after the introduction of RNA-based vaccines during the pandemic. Lymph node (LN) fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) has been used to diagnose single cases or small series of SLDI and C19-LAP. In this review, clinical and LN-FNAC features of SLDI and C19-LAP are reported and compared to non-Covid (NC)-LAP. A search for studies on C19-LAP and SLDI histopathology and cytopathology was performed on PubMed and Google Scholar, on 11 January 2023. Reports on LN-FNAC of C19-LAP were retrieved. A total of 14 reports, plus one unpublished case of C19-LAP observed in our institution, diagnosed by LN-FNAC were included in a pooled analysis and compared to the corresponding histopathological reports. In total, 26 cases were included in this review, with a mean age of 50.5 years. Twenty-one lymphadenopathies assessed by LN-FNAC were diagnosed as benign, and three cases as atypical lymphoid hyperplasia; the latter were subsequently confirmed as benign (one by repetition of LN-FNAC, two by histological control). One case of mediastinal lymphadenopathy in a patient suffering from melanoma was reported as reactive granulomatous inflammation, while one unsuspected case was diagnosed as metastasis from melanoma. In all cases, the cytological diagnoses were confirmed by follow-up or excisional biopsy. The high diagnostic value of LN-FNAC in excluding malignant processes was extremely useful in this context and may be particularly valuable when CNB or histological excisions are difficult to perform, as was the case during Covid lockdowns.

Validation of full-remote reporting for cervicovaginal cytology: the Caltagirone-Acireale distributed lab

INTRODUCTION

Cervical cancer is the fourth most common cancer in women, and its prevention is based on vaccination and screening. Screening consists of molecular human papillomavirus (HPV) testing and cytologic analysis of cervical smears, which require expensive equipment and the interaction of numerous professionals such as biologists, cytologists, laboratory technicians, and pathologists.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We centralize the cervical samples from more than 51 clinics in 1 main laboratory, where automated HPV testing is performed. HPV-positive cases are collected and used to prepare a liquid-based cytology slide, which is stained and immediately scanned. The resulting whole-slide images (WSIs) are immediately available in a remote laboratory where they are examined by experienced cytologists using virtual microscopy. This setup was validated by making each of the 3 readers independently diagnose 506 specimens in random order, using both conventional light microscopy (CLM) and WSIs, with a minimum wash-out period of 3 weeks and with a final discussion for all cases.

RESULTS

Intraobserver agreement among CLM and WSI ranged from 0.71 to 0.79, and interobserver agreement for the 3 readers compared with the consensus diagnosis was similar for the 2 modes of assessment. Readers subjectively felt confident in their WSI diagnosis for inadequate and negative cases, but less so in other cases. The perceived difficulty was slightly higher in WSI readings.

CONCLUSIONS

Interobserver agreement in cervicovaginal cytology is moderate and does not vary if the slides are examined conventionally or digitally. Despite higher reported subjective difficulty and lower confidence in the WSI diagnosis, we did not observe a deterioration in diagnostic performance using WSI compared with CLM.

An economic evaluation of fine-needle cytology as the primary diagnostic tool in the diagnosis of lymphadenopathy

Fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) is commonly used to obtain a pre-surgical pathological diagnosis in many organs, but its cost-effectiveness in lymphadenopathy has not been studied yet. We calculated the cost and diagnostic accuracy of a diagnostic algorithm that uses FNAC as a first-line procedure and compared it to a purely surgical approach in 545 consecutive lymphadenopathies. In 74% of the cases, FNAC alone can obtain a sufficiently detailed diagnosis, avoiding the surgical biopsy. In doing so, the average cost of diagnosis is cut to less than one-third, the patient avoids an invasive procedure and the diagnosis is reached earlier. In conclusion, the systematic use of lymph node-FNAC in the initial assessment of lymphadenopathy is clinically and economically advantageous as it avoids surgical biopsies in cases where cytology can suffice.

Utility of the Proposed Sydney System for Classification of Fine-Needle Aspiration Cytopathology of Lymph Node: A Retrospective Study at a Tertiary Care Center

INTRODUCTION

Fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) is an established first-line technique for the evaluation of lymphadenopathy and, with the help of ancillary testing, can in many instances obviate the need for an open biopsy. The Sydney system was recently proposed to provide consensus guidelines for the performance, classification, and reporting of lymph node FNAC. The present study was undertaken to evaluate its utility and study the impact of rapid on-site evaluation (ROSE).

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A retrospective analysis in which 1,500 lymph node FNACs was reviewed and assigned a diagnostic category from the Sydney system. Cyto-histopathological correlation and adequacy parameters were evaluated.

OBSERVATION AND RESULTS

The cervical group of lymph nodes was the commonest group aspirated (89.7%). A total of 1,205/1,500 (80.3%) cases were category II (benign), and necrotizing granulomatous lymphadenitis was the most common pathology. The 750 cases with ROSE were subclassified as follows: 15 category I (inadequate), 629 category II (benign), 2 category III (atypia of undetermined significance), 9 category IV (suspicious for malignancy), and 95 category V (malignant). Among 750 cases without ROSE, 75 cases were in category I, 576 in category II, 3 in category III, 6 in category IV, and 90 in category V. Category I was thus significantly lower in the ROSE group compared to the non-ROSE group. Overall, the risk of malignancy was L1-0%, L2-0.20%, L3-100%, L4-92.3%, and L5-100%. Accuracy parameters revealed a sensitivity of 97.7%, specificity of 100%, PPV of 100%, NPV of 99.10%, and diagnostic accuracy of 99.54%.

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION

FNAC can be used as the 1st line of treatment for lymph node pathology. ROSE can be used as an add-on to FNAC for reducing unsatisfactory rates and help triage material for ancillary testing whenever possible. The Sydney system should be implemented for achieving uniformity and reproducibility.

Diagnosis of Langerhans cell histiocytosis on cytological examination of cerebrospinal fluid: Report of the first case

Langerhans cell histiocytosis (LCH) is a disease of unknown etiology characterized by a proliferation of histiocytic cells resembling dendritic Langerhans cells. LCH can be unifocal or multifocal, with one- or many-organ involvement. The serous fluids are rarely involved. Cytological diagnosis of LCH is possible and relies on recognition of the typical cytomorphological features and subsequent immunocytochemical confirmation. Given the possibility of multisystem involvement, after diagnosing LCH it is necessary to carry out staging exams such as a bone survey, abdominal ultrasound, complete blood count, screening for diabetes insipidus and pulmonary function tests. We present the first case of LCH where the diagnosis was reached on cytological material from the cerebrospinal fluid. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first such case reported in the international literature to date. The morphological and immunocytochemical characteristics of our case are described, and the relevant literature is reviewed.

A roadmap for a comprehensive diagnostic approach to fine needle cytology of lymph node metastases

OBJECTIVE

Fine needle cytology (FNC) is widely used as a first-line procedure in the diagnostic algorithm of lymphadenopathies. In a metastatic setting, a first-line diagnostic approach identifies non-haematopoietic malignancy; however, cytopathologists could also provide a second diagnostic level, identifying the origin of the primary tumour. This paper outlines a comprehensive and practical approach to the cytological diagnosis of lymph node metastases.

METHODS

Cytological diagnoses of lymph node metastases performed over a 10-year period were selected and divided into two groups. The first group, labelled "oncological," comprised patients with a previous history of malignancy; the second group, labelled "naïve," included patients with no relevant history. Pathology records were retrieved to record microscopic findings, namely, background appearance, group architecture, and specific cell features; data from cell block (CB) preparations were also collected.

RESULTS

Overall, 982 cases were selected: 497 cases (50.61%) in the naïve group, and 485 (49.39%) in the oncological group. Overall, a second diagnostic level was achieved in 834/982 cases (84.92%); cases diagnosed as carcinoma not otherwise specified were more frequent in the naïve group than in the oncological group (17.51% vs. 8.04%, P < 0.01). Notably, although CB material was available in only 44.87% of the naïve cases, we were able to achieve a second diagnostic level thanks to the integration of clinical and cytomorphological findings, plus lymph node topography, in 82.49% of the cases.

CONCLUSION

Our results confirmed that in a metastatic setting, FNC can reliably lead to the identification of the origin of the primary tumour.

Actinomycosis mimicking malignancy: a report of three cases diagnosed with fine-needle aspiration cytology

We describe three cases of actinomycosis of the head and neck area, clinically suspected to be malignancies, diagnosed by fine-needle aspiration (FNAC). The patients presented with painless, slowly growing masses in the cervicofacial area. Ultrasonography identified the masses as enlarged lymph nodes which were subsequently biopsied by FNAC. Cytological features were similar in all cases, with a background of granulocytes and scattered lymphocytes and histiocytes. At high magnification colonies of branching, filamentous and beaded bacteria were detected. In the Diff-Quik-stained smears, these filamentous colonies showed an evident yellowish color with the typical feature of the "sulfur granules" consistent with the Splendore-Hoeppli phenomenon. A diagnosis of actinomycosis was made and confirmed in all cases by the subsequent microbiological tests. The patients were treated with high-dose penicillin, which caused the masses to progressively shrink. The lymph nodal localization of cervico-facial actinomycosis may be a diagnostic challenge, because in that area, lymphadenopathies may occur both in benign and malignant conditions. FNAC is a safe, fast, and reliable method to perform an accurate diagnosis of actinomycosis avoiding the surgical excision for histological evaluation.

Observations on hematogones with light chain restriction

Light-chain restricted hematogones (LCR HGs) detected by flow cytometry (FC) may, occur in bone marrow mimicking involvement by a B-cell lymphoma. This phenomenon can present a diagnostic pitfall and negatively impact patient management, and may occur in other organs, including lymph nodes, For this reason, it is recommended to utilize, in case of LCR in lymph node, one additional morphological, phenotypical or molecular criteria for the diagnosis of lymphoma on cytological samples.