The pathology of lumbosacral lipomas: macroscopic and microscopic disparity have implications for embryogenesis and mode of clinical deterioration

Lumbosacral lipoma in childhood, how strong is the evidence base? A systematic review

OBJECTIVE

Conus region lumbosacral lipomas (LSLs) are highly heterogeneous in their morphology, clinical presentation, and outcome, with an incompletely understood natural history and often treacherous surgical anatomy. This systematic review aims to critically evaluate and assess the strength of the current LSL evidence base to guide management strategies.

METHODS

According to a systematic review following PRISMA guidelines, a search was conducted using the key term "lumbosacral lipoma" across MEDLINE (OVID), Embase, Cochrane Library, and PubMed databases from January 1951 to April 2021. All studies containing ten or more paediatric conus lipomas were included. Data heterogeneity and bias were assessed.

RESULTS

A total of 13 studies were included, containing 913 LSLs (predominantly transitional type-58.5%). Two-thirds (67.5%) of all patients (treated and non-treated) remained clinically stable and 17.6% deteriorated. Neuropathic bladder was present in 8.6% at final follow-up. Of patients managed surgically, near-total resection vs. subtotal resection deterioration-free survival rates were 77.2-98.4% and 10-67% respectively. 4.5% (0.0-27.3%) required re-do untethering surgery. Outcomes varied according to lipoma type. Most publications contained heterogeneous populations and used variable terminology. There was a lack of consistency in reported outcomes.

CONCLUSION

Amongst published series, there is wide variability in patient factors such as lipoma type, patient age, and methods of (particularly urological) assessment. Currently, there is insufficient evidence base upon which to make clear recommendations for the management of children with LSL. There is an imperative for neurosurgeons, neuroradiologists, and urologists to collaborate to better standardise the terminology, assessment tools, and surgical interventions for this challenging group of conditions.

Complex lumbosacral spinal cord lipomas: A longitudinal study on outcomes from a Singapore children's hospital

BACKGROUND

Total/near-total resection (TR/NTR) of complex lumbosacral lipomas (CSL) is reported to be associated with better long-term functional outcomes and lower symptomatic re-tethering rates. We report our institutional experience for CSL resection in affected children.

METHODS

This is a single-institution, retrospective study. Inclusion criteria consist of patients with CSL with dorsal, transitional and chaotic lipomas based on Pang et al's classification. The study population is divided into 2 groups: asymptomatic patients with a normal preoperative workup referred to as 'prophylactic intent' and 'therapeutic intent' for those with pre-existing neuro-urological symptoms. Primary aims are to review factors that affect post-operative clean intermittent catheterization (CIC), functional outcomes based on Necker functional score (NFS), and re-tethering rates.

RESULTS

122 patients were included from 2000 to 2021. There were 32 dorsal lipomas (26.2 %), 74 transitional lipomas (60.7 %), and 16 chaotic lipomas (13.1 %). 82 % patients achieved TR/NTR. Favourable NFS at 1-year was 48.2 %. The re-tethering rate was 6.6 %. After multivariable analysis, post-operative CIC was associated with median age at surgery (p = 0.026), lipoma type (p = 0.029), conus height (p = 0.048) and prophylactic intent (p < 0.001). Next, extent of lipoma resection (p = 0.012) and the post-operative CSF leak (p = 0.004) were associated with re-tethering. Favourable NFS was associated with lipoma type (p = 0.047) and prophylactic intent surgery (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Our experience shows that TR/NTR for CSL is a feasible option to prevent functional deterioration and re-tethering. Efforts are needed to work on factors associated with post-operative CIC.

The Surgical Histopathology of the Filum Terminale: Findings from a Large Series of Patients with Tethered Cord Syndrome

This study investigated the prevalence of embryonic and connective tissue elements in the filum terminale (FT) of patients with tethered cord syndrome (TCS), examining both typical and pathological histology. The FT specimens from 288 patients who underwent spinal cord detethering from 2013 to 2021 were analyzed. The histopathological examination involved routine hematoxylin and eosin staining and specific immunohistochemistry when needed. The patient details were extracted from electronic medical records. The study found that 97.6% of the FT specimens had peripheral nerves, and 70.8% had regular ependymal cell linings. Other findings included ependymal cysts and canals, ganglion cells, neuropil, and prominent vascular features. Notably, 41% showed fatty infiltration, and 7.6% had dystrophic calcification. Inflammatory infiltrates, an underreported finding, were observed in 3.8% of the specimens. The research highlights peripheral nerves and ganglion cells as natural components of the FT, with ependymal cell overgrowth and other tissues potentially linked to TCS. Enlarged vessels may suggest venous congestion due to altered FT mechanics. The presence of lymphocytic infiltrations and calcifications provides new insights into structural changes and mechanical stress in the FT, contributing to our understanding of TCS pathology.

Clinical analysis of tethered cord syndrome and gene expression profiling of wound healing surgery

Introduction

The method to prevent progression of symptoms in tethered cord syndrome (TCS) is neurosurgery. However, postoperative wound healing is a lengthy process and is hindered by the release of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) through the wound. To the best of the authors' knowledge, there is no study evaluating the changes in the expression of factors involved in the wound healing process after neurosurgery for TCS.

Aim

To clinically analyse 2 cases of TCS and evaluate the change in expression of selected genes during the postoperative wound healing process.

Material and methods

Determination of TCS in two adult patients (woman, aged 26 years; man, aged 53 years) was based on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). After confirming the initial diagnosis, a neurosurgical procedure was performed to remove the intrathecal spreading adipoma and transect the medullary terminal thread in patients. In the postoperative period, impaired wound healing was noted as a result of CSF secretion through the surgical wound.

Results

Molecularly, there was an increase in expression of all genes assessed in skin biopsy specimens compared to skin samples. Impaired postoperative wound healing after neurosurgery for TCS is expected due to CSF leakage through the surgical wound. The greatest changes were noted for metalloproteinases (MMPs) and four isoforms (A-D) of vascular endothelial growth factor A-D (VEGF-A-D; p < 0.05).

Conclusions

Changes in the expression of our selected genes can be used to monitor and predict the process of wound healing and scar formation, which occurred in our cases at 19 and 20 days after surgery.

Physiological rapid growth of spinal lipoma in the early postnatal period

OBJECTIVE

Spinal lipomas are congenital malformations. They do not express tumorous growth but are found to increase in volume like other normal subcutaneous fat tissue during the early postnatal period. To understand the natural course of volume changes in spinal lipomas, the authors measured the changes in size of spinal lipomas together with the normal subcutaneous fat in relation to BMI.

METHODS

A total of 27 patients with conus spinal lipoma excluding lipomyelomeningocele who underwent MRI twice before surgery (on initial diagnosis and immediately preoperatively) were included. Patients' ages at the time of the first MRI ranged from 0 to 32 months (mean 2.9 months, median 1 month). Candidates were categorized by age into three groups: < 1 month, 1-2 months, and ≥ 3 months. The growth rate of the spinal lipomas (in three directions), change in thickness of the normal subcutaneous fat, growth rate of the normal spinal canal (dorsoventral direction), and change in BMI were retrospectively analyzed between the three groups.

RESULTS

The mean interval between MRI studies was 83.1 days. During this time, the mean lipoma growth rates were 199%, 149%, and 133% in the dorsoventral, lateral, and craniocaudal directions, respectively (with 100% representing the first measurement). The mean change in the thickness of the normal subcutaneous fat was 183%. The mean growth of the normal spinal canal was 111%. The mean increase in BMI was 124%. These rates were all significantly higher in the younger groups. There was no significant difference in the growth rates between the lipoma and the subcutaneous fat in every age group. In contrast, the growth rate of the lipoma significantly exceeded that of the spinal canal in patients younger than 3 months. The subarachnoid space around the lipoma became obstructed in 35.3%, and spinal cord distortion occurred in 48.1% of the patients younger than 3 months.

CONCLUSIONS

Spinal lipomas rapidly increase in volume before the age of 3 months and especially in infants younger than 1 month. Their features closely correlate with the physiological growth of the normal subcutaneous fat and the increase in BMI. The rapid growth of lipomas suggests the importance of close observation in this period, keeping in mind the typical anatomical changes of lipomas and their surrounding structures.

[Expert consensus on diagnosis and treatment of spina bifida]

Spina bifida and tethered spinal cord are congenital diseases that can lead to severe disability. At present, most doctors in relevant specialties in China still have insufficient understanding of spina bifida, resulting in high incidence and aggravation of its complications. To provide guidance for the diagnosis and treatment of spina bifida and tethered spinal cord in China, experts from neurosurgery, urology, orthopedics, spine surgery, and rehabilitation departments who have experiences in the diagnosis and treatment of spina bifida discussed and summarized their experiences, and referred to the relevant literature on the diagnosis and treatment of spina bifida at home and abroad. Expert consensus was formed in the following aspects: concept, classification, and pathological changes of spina bifida; diagnosis; treatment process and operation timing; principles and methods of treatment; rehabilitation; and follow up. This expert consensus can provide reference for relevant care providers of spina bifida in China.

Does conus morphology have implications for outcome in lumbosacral lipoma?

OBJECTIVE

Lumbosacral lipomas (LSL) of the 'dorsal' type have been associated with more favourable outcomes compared with other conus region lipomas. We hypothesised that integrity of the conus on MRI underpins the improved prognosis in this subgroup of LSL patients.

METHODS

The definition of 'dorsal lipomas' included lipomas with attachment to the conus, but where the conus could be delineated on MRI (Morota type 1) as reported by Morota et al. (J Neurosurg Pediatr 19:428-439, 2017). Additional inclusion criteria included asymptomatic status at presentation, age >3 years at follow-up, and neurological and urological evaluation at presentation and at last follow-up. Lipoma extent and conus level were recorded. Outcome measures were the need for untethering surgery and neuro-urological status at last follow-up. Urological outcomes were defined by continence and efficacy of bladder emptying.

RESULTS

Twenty-six children were included (median age 8.7 years). Conus level was low (at or below L2) in 92%. Nine required untethering surgery: 5 prophylactic, 4 because of clinical deterioration. Twenty-five children were continent at last follow-up, one had stress incontinence, and none required catheterisation. One had persisting ankle weakness after surgery requiring orthotic support.

CONCLUSIONS

In LSL of the conus, visualisation of the conus on MRI is associated with good urological and motor outcomes. The integrity of the conus appears to be a more important prognostic factor than anatomical level. An observational approach to this group of LSL patients does not appear to compromise outcomes. These findings support a selective approach to untethering surgery.

Expression Patterns of Hypoxia-Inducible Factors, Proinflammatory, and Neuroprotective Cytokines in Neuroepithelial Tissues of Lumbar Spinal Lipomas-A Pilot Study

OBJECTIVE

Lumbosacral lipomas (LSLs), one form of closed spinal dysraphism, are congenital disorders of the terminal spinal cord (SC). Delayed neurologic deterioration often occurs in the subsequent developmental course of the patient. Identifying the cellular and molecular factors underlying the progressive damage to neural structures is a prerequisite for developing treatment strategies for LSLs.

METHODS

Nine LSL specimens obtained from the SC/lipoma interface during surgical resection were examined. Normal SC tissue served as a control. Clinical characteristics were obtained, and spinal magnetic resonance imaging was re-evaluated. Cellular marker profiles were established. Immunoreactivity (IR) of hypoxia-inducible factor 1α (HIF-1α/-2α), erythropoietin (Epo)/erythropoietin receptor (EpoR), interleukin-1β (IL-1β)/IL-1R1, and tumor necrosis factor α/tumor necrosis factor receptor type 1 were analyzed qualitatively and semiquantitatively by densitometry. Colabeling with cellular markers was determined by multifluorescence labeling. Cytokines were further analyzed by real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction.

RESULTS

LSL specimens showed significant gliosis. HIF-1α/HIF-2α-IR and Epo/Epo-IR were found at significantly higher levels in the LSL specimens, as were IL-1β-/IL-1β receptor type 1 (IL1-R1) and tumor necrosis factor α/tumor necrosis factor receptor type 1 (P < 0.001), than were the controls. At the messenger RNA level, cytokines appeared partially induced. Double immunofluorescence labeling confirmed the costaining of these factors with inflammatory and glial markers.

CONCLUSIONS

The expression of hypoxia-related and inflammatory mediators was shown for the first time in LSL specimens. These factors might play a role in multifactorial secondary lesion cascades underlying further damage to the neural placode in closed dysraphism.

Congenital Spinal Lipomatous Malformations. Part 1. Spinal Lipomas, Lipomyeloceles, and Lipomyelomeningoceles

Background: Lumbosacral spinal lipomas and lipomyeloceles are usually identified in early childhood. Terminology, histopathology, and diagnosis for these malformations can be confusing. Materials and Methods: This is a PubMed review with comparison of embryology, gross, and histopathology, and reporting requisites for these and related closed spinal malformations. Results: The spinal lipoma group (congenital spinal lipomatous malformations) includes subcutaneous, transdural, intradural, and noncontiguous malformations stretching through the entire lower spinal region. This lipomyelocele trajectory overlaps the embryonic tail's caudal eminence. Histopathologically, the lipomyelocele spectrum is a heterogeneous, stereotypical set of findings encountered from dermis to spinal cord. Diagnosis requires detailed correlation of images, intraoperative inspection, and histopathology. Conclusions: Appropriate terminology and clinicopathologic correlation to arrive at a diagnosis is a critical activity shared by pathologist and clinician. Prognostic and management differences depend on specific diagnoses. Familial and genetic influences play little if any role in patient management in closed spinal malformations.

Whole spine MRI is not required in investigating uncomplicated paediatric lumbosacral lipoma. A retrospective single-institution review

PURPOSE

Lumbosacral lipoma (LSL) is a severe occult spinal dysraphism, frequently associated with neurological, urological and orthopaedic complications. Whole spine imaging is typically performed to identify concomitant, but spatially separate, congenital anomalies. Our hypothesis: the incidence of additional, clinically significant abnormalities of the neuraxis is low; thus, imaging should be optimised at the lumbosacral region. We aim to assess the prevalence and relevance of LSL-associated lesions.

METHOD

A single-centre, retrospective, radiological review using a prospectively maintained operative database.

INCLUSION CRITERIA

children (< 16 years) with confirmed diagnosis of LSL and received whole spine MRI. Fatty filum, syndromic cases and cutaneous stigmata above lesion level were excluded. Data was extracted from radiological imaging, reports and clinical correspondence.

RESULTS

One hundred twelve patients (40:72, M:F) aged 0.5 years (0.2-2.7) (median ± IQR) with LSL had whole spine MRI between 2001 and 2017. Classification of LSL: transitional 48 (43%); dorsal 30 (27%); caudal 28 (25%) and chaotic 6 (5%). Additional anomalies included syringohydromyelia 44 (39%), subcutaneous tract 19 (17%), abnormal vertebral segmentation 18 (16%), dermoid cyst 1 and 1 Chiari I deformity. There were no Chiari II malformations. No child required surgery for an associated lesion. Binary logistic regression revealed no factors associated with predicting secondary lesions.

CONCLUSIONS

In congenital LSL, additional anomalies of the neuraxis are typically loco-regional rather than pan-CNS and additional lesions are rarely clinically significant. The loco-regional distribution of anomalies suggests that only lumbosacral spinal imaging is required in the initial evaluation of LSL. Such a policy would lessen the anaesthetic/sedation time for children and reduce imaging cost per patient. MRI protocols could be refined to optimise imaging quality at the region of interest.

The pathology of lumbosacral lipomas: macroscopic and microscopic disparity have implications for embryogenesis and mode of clinical deterioration

AIMS

Lumbosacral lipomas (LSL) are congenital disorders of the terminal spinal cord region that have the potential to cause significant spinal cord dysfunction in children. They are of unknown embryogenesis with variable clinical presentation and natural history. It is unclear whether the spinal cord dysfunction reflects a primary developmental dysplasia or whether it occurs secondarily to mechanical traction (spinal cord tethering) with growth. While different anatomical subtypes are recognised and classified according to radiological criteria, these subtypes correlate poorly with clinical prognosis. We have undertaken an analysis of surgical specimens in order to describe the spectrum of histological changes that occur and have correlated the histology with the anatomical type of LSL to determine if there are distinct histological subtypes.

METHODS AND RESULTS

The histopathology was reviewed of 64 patients who had undergone surgical resection of LSL. The presence of additional tissues and cell types were recorded. LSLs were classified from pre-operative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans according to Chapman classification. Ninety-five per cent of the specimens consisted predominantly of mature adipocytes with all containing thickened bands of connective tissue and peripheral nerve fibres, 91% of samples contained ectatic blood vessels with thickened walls, while 22% contained central nervous system (CNS) glial tissue. Additional tissue was identified of both mesodermal and neuroectodermal origin.

CONCLUSIONS

Our analysis highlights the heterogeneity of tissue types within all samples, not reflected in the nomenclature. The diversity of tissue types, consistent across all subtypes, challenges currently held notions regarding the embryogenesis of LSLs and the assumption that clinical deterioration is due simply to tethering.

Ependyma-Lined Canal with Surrounding Neuroglial Tissues in Lumbosacral Lipomatous Malformations: Relationship with Retained Medullary Cord

BACKGROUND

An ependyma-lined canal with surrounding neuroglial tissues can be present in lumbosacral lipomatous malformations; however, the precise embryological significance is still unclear.

METHOD

Six out of 50 patients with lipomatous malformations had ependymal structures. We retrospectively analyzed the clinical, neuroradiological, and histological findings of these patients to demonstrate the relationship with the embryological background of the retained medullary cord (RMC), which normally regresses, but was retained here because of late arrest of secondary neurulation.

RESULTS

Five (13.9%) of 36 patients with filar and caudal types and 1 of 3 lipomyelomeningoceles had ependymal structures, while none with dorsal and transitional types had these tissues. Histologically, the ependymal structures surrounded by neuroglial tissue and containing various amounts of adipose tissue bear a striking resemblance to the ependymal structures in RMC.

CONCLUSION

The 13.9% incidence of association between the ependymal structures and filar and caudal types is thought to be because of second ary neurulation failure with the same embryological background as that of RMC. Dorsal and transitional types, resulting from primary neurulation failure, therefore, did not have ependymal structures.