Studies on the neutralization of herpes simplex virus. VII. Reevaluation of the equilibrium theory concerning the unneutralizable persistent fraction

A micro-neutralization system for detection of s-CRN antibody to herpes simplex virus

It was learned that the ordinary micro-neutralization system with herpes simplex virus (HSV) gave a composite result of the initial neutralization and the effect of antibody on subsequent growth of unneutralized virus. In the case of slow-reacting complement-requiring neutralizing (s-CRN) antibody, which was detected by incubating virus-serum mixtures at 4 C for 3 days before addition of complement, the titer obtained was lower than expected from the result of the plaque reduction test. This was thought ascribable to its low ability to prevent viral breakthrough caused by growth of unneutralized virus. This was overcome by adding an appropriate amount of hyperimmune antibody at 3 hr after addition of cells. The endpoint of s-CRN antibody so determined was but slightly lower than that obtained by the plaque reduction test. Early (1-week) rabbit sera, which were negative in the ordinary micro-neutralization test, titered 1:2,560 to 1:5,120 when tested by this method. When the 3-day sensitization in the cold was substituted by 5-hr incubation at 37 C, the titer obtained was 2 to 4-fold lower; in this case, however, the whole process could be finished within 3 days. Also, s-CRN antibody reactive with type 2 HSV in homologous and heterologous sera could be detected by the same method using type 1 hyperimmune serum as the additional antibody.

Studies on the neutralization of herpes simplex virus. XI. Differences between slow-reacting complement-requiring neutralizing (s-CRN) antibodies in IgG and IgM

Late IgG and IgM from a rabbit immunized with herpes virus were tested for ordinary neutralizing (N) antibody, complement-requiring neutralizing (CRN) antibody and in addition CRN antibody detectable by overnight sensitization at 0 C (s-CRN antibody). Heat stability tests showed that IgG s-CRN antibody was slightly less resistant to heating at 70 C than were N and CRN antibodies, whereas all three activities of IgM were quickly degraded at this temperature. Dose-response curves with varying amounts of complement (C) or anti-antibody revealed a marked difference between IgG s-CRN and IgM s-CRN antibodies. While 1-hr sensitization at 37 C was insufficient to detect IgG s-CRN antibody, it had the same effect as overnight sensitization at 0 C for IgM s-CRN antibody. When sensitization at 0 C was prolonged to 3 days, unexpectedly high endpoints exceeding 1:10,000 were obtained even with IgM. consequently, enhancement by C was several hundred-fold with IgM in contrast to 5- to 10-fold enhancement of IgG s-CRN antibody, which was similar to that after overnight sensitization. Also IgM obviously required more C than did IgG. These results suggest that IgM of late serum is slower reacting and more C-dependent than IgG s-CRN antibody. Tests with early rabbit sera indicated that the s-CRN antibody detectable by 3-day sensitization reaches a high level before the appearance of N antibody.

Neutralization of animal viruses

Various aspects of the interaction of bacterial viruses and antibody were studied by Andrewes and Elford in England. Similar studies, as well as studies on animal viruses, were carried out in Australia by Burnet and his colleagues. One result of their extensive studies, which were summarized in great detail, was the conclusion that, with respect to their interaction with antibody, bacterial and animal viruses were basically different. Specifically, the difference resided in the stability of the union of virus and antibody, whereas bacterial viruses formed stable complexes, animal viruses formed complexes that tended to dissociate readily. The introduction of animal cell cultures as host systems greatly aided in the study of animal viruses, with respect to fewer and more readily controlled variables, and by the use of the plaque assay in enhanced quantitative reliability. In 1956, Dulbecco et al. described the interaction of two animal viruses with their respective antibodies. The results of these studies led these investigators to conclude, among other things, that animal viruses, at least the two they studied, reacted with antibodies to form complexes that did not dissociate spontaneously. This interpretation was challenged by Fazekas de St. Groth and Reid. As more animal virus-antibody systems were studied by many investigators, there seemed to be a greater accord for irreversible, rather than reversible, interaction. For this reason, in this chapter it is assumed that there are no differences between bacterial viruses, as one category, and animal viruses, as a separate category, concerning their interaction with antibodies. Rather, differences, when they exist, are considered to be related to the viruses per se. Although this chapter is intended to survey the neutralization of animal viruses, occasional reference is made to the studies on bacterial viruses when these studies are pertinent and illuminating to the topic at hand.

Studies on the neutralization of herpes simplex virus. VIII. Significance of viral sensitization for inactivation by complement

Early and late IgG of rabbits immunized with herpes virus showed, respectively, 8-fold and 2-fold enhancement of neutralization endpoint in the presence of complement (C). Kinetic curve experiments employing an appropriate amount of virus revealed that both neutralization and sensitization followed first-order reaction, and each IgG possessed a certain range of concentration where neutralization was negligible while sensitization was marked. Dose responses of neutralization and sensitization velocities demonstrated that the C enhancement of late IgG was about 7-fold and that of early IgG more than 20-fold. These facts suggested that the IgGs contained two different entities of complement-requiring (CRN) and non-requiring neutralizing (N) antibodies at different proportions, only the former being responsible for sensitization. The different CRN: N ratios obtained by the endpoint and kinetic methods may mean either that the two antibodies differ in avidity for the virus or that the number of critical sites per virion for CRN antibody is greater than that for N antibody. In this interpretation, sensitization by CRN antibody as well as neutralization by N antibody is thought to result from attachment of a single antibody molecule to the viral critical site. Alternative explanations, ascribing the mechanism of neutralization to steric hindrance of critical sites or to multiple hit of those sites by antibody, were denied by analyses of the present data.

Neutralizing activities of early and late IgG fragments from rabbits immunized with herpes simplex virus

Rabbits immunized with herpes virus were bled periodically and bivalent and univalent fragments of IgG from each serum sample were prepared by enzymatic digestion. The 2-week F(ab')2 showed a low neutralizing activity only after addition of anti-IgG. F(ab')2 of the 4-week serum retained almost all of the neutralizing activity of IgG, while its univalent fragments demonstrated none even when tested with anti-IgG. In contrast to these early IgG fragments, univalent fragments of the 9-week and 20-week IgG neutralized the virus to considerable extents in the absence of anti-IgG; after addition of anti-IgG the activity equaled that of intact IgG in the cases of Fab' and Fab-II, though the activity of Fab-I was relatively low. Three three univalent fragments were all sensitive to heating at 70 C and to ultraviolet irradiation, whereas intact IgG resisted these treatments. F(ab')2 was resistant to the heating and less sensitive to ultraviolet irradiation than univalent fragments. Neutralization kinetic curve experiments to test blocking effects of IgG fragments against the neutralization by intact IgG suggested that the early Fab' did combine with the virus and that the late Fab' exerted a higher blocking effect than the early Fab'.