Topical 5-fluorouracil in the treatment of Darier's disease

Therapeutic Options for the Treatment of Darier's Disease: A Comprehensive Review of the Literature

Darier's disease (also known as keratosis follicularis or dyskeratosis follicularis) is an autosomal dominant inherited disorder which manifests as hyperkeratotic greasy papules in the first or second decade of life. Aside from symptom management and behavioral modifications to avoid triggers, there are currently no validated treatments for Darier's disease (DD). However, a variety of treatments have been proposed in the literature including retinoids, steroids, vitamin D analogs, photodynamic therapy, and surgical excision. The purpose of this review article is to identify therapeutic options for treating DD and to outline the evidence underlying these interventions. A search was conducted in Medline for English language articles from inception to July 4, 2020. Our search identified a total of 474 nonduplicate studies, which were screened by title and abstract. Of these, 155 full text articles were screened against inclusion/exclusion criteria, and 113 studies were included in our review. We identified Grade B evidence for the following treatments of DD: oral acitretin, oral isotretinoin, systemic Vitamin A, topical tretinoin, topical isotretinoin, topical adapalene gel, topical 5-flououracil, topical calciptriol and tacalcitol (with sunscreen), grenz ray radiation, and x-ray radiation. All other evidence for treatments of DD consisted of case reports or case series, which is considered grade C evidence. Considering the quality and quantity of evidence, clinicians may consider initiating a trial of select topical or oral retinoids first in patients with localized or generalized DD, respectively.

Darier and Hailey-Hailey disease: update 2021

The autosomal-dominant genodermatoses Darier disease and Hailey-Hailey disease present special challenges to dermatologists. Despite their similar pathogenesis featuring impaired adhesion of suprabasal keratinocytes as a result of defective ATPases in epidermal calcium channels, the two diseases differ considerably in clinical presentation and therapeutic options. Darier disease is characterized by reddish brown, keratotic papules in seborrheic and intertriginous areas, which may coalesce into extensive lesions. Individuals affected with Hailey-Hailey disease primarily develop intertriginous papulovesicles and small blisters, which often evolve into erythematous plaques with erosions and painful fissures. Quality of life is significantly reduced because of complaints (itch, burning sensation, pain), body malodor and chronicity. Therapeutic options remain limited. Antiseptics and intermittent topical corticosteroids are a cornerstone of therapy, and systemic anti-infective treatment is often required in cases of superinfection. Ablative surgical interventions such as dermabrasion and CO₂ laser surgery can lead to long-term remissions in intertriginous Hailey-Hailey disease, while temporary relief may also be achieved by intralesional injections of botulinum toxin. Of the systemic medications available for Darier disease, acitretin, which is approved for this purpose, has the best supporting evidence. The efficacy of immunosuppressants and immune modulators is inconsistent. Low-dose naltrexone produces more satisfactory results in Hailey-Hailey than Darier disease. The present CME article summarizes current knowledge of the two dermatoses, taking recent developments into account.

Management of Darier disease: A review of the literature and update

Darier disease (DD) is a rare type of inherited keratinizing disorder with no definitive therapeutic approach. The objective of this study is to provide a detailed literature review of all the available treatment modalities of Darier disease, including those that are both surgical and non surgical, to compare their efficacies and to propose a novel therapeutic approach. A complete search of the literature for all articles describing the different treatments of Darier disease, with no restrictions on patients' ages, gender or nationalities, was performed with the use of PubMed. A total of 68 articles were included in the study: 3 prospective studies, 44 case reports/case series and 21 letters/correspondences/clinical images. The treatments described were topical, oral or physical. Retinoids (isotretinoin, tazarotene and adapalene) and fluorouracil were the two most effective topical treatments. Oral retinoids were the most effective oral therapy and were prescribed in the cases of generalized Darier disease. For localized and resistant skin lesions, physical therapies including surgical excision, dermabrasion and CO2 laser ablation were the first line choices. Limitations of this article include the inability to verify the accuracy of the published data, the relatively small sample size, the absence of randomized controlled clinical trials and possible unidentified confounding factors in various studies. In every therapeutic approach to Darier disease, consideration of patient comorbidities, disease distribution, severity and treatment accessibility is essential. Large and randomized clinical trials are necessary for the comparison of the efficacy and the safety of all the treatments of Darier disease and settling a consensus for management.

Topical 5-fluorouracil in dermatologic disease

BACKGROUND

5-fluorouracil (5-FU) has proven to be an effective therapy in the treatment of a variety of dermatologic conditions. Approved by the United States Food and Drug Administration for the treatment of actinic keratoses and superficial basal cell carcinoma, topical 5-FU has also demonstrated efficacy in the treatment of a variety of other dermatologic diseases.

METHODS

A search of the MEDLINE standard computer database, MEDLINE advanced database, and EMBASE database was conducted.

RESULTS

Thirty-four articles met criteria for inclusion in this review. These articles represented 16 randomized controlled trials and 18 case series. Each article was reviewed and summarized.

CONCLUSIONS

Topical 5-FU is used in a variety of dermatologic disease processes with a wide range of efficacy and levels of evidence. Based on extent and level of evidence, our disease-specific systematic review found that the evidence is strongest for topical 5-FU use in the treatment of actinic keratosis, squamous cell carcinoma, and basal cell carcinoma. This review serves as a comprehensive summary of topical 5-FU use in dermatology.

[Efficacy and risks of topical 5-fluorouracil in Darier's disease]

BACKGROUND

Darier's disease, an autosomal dominant disorder, is often resistant to therapy. There have been few encouraging reports in recent years of treatment using topical 5-fluorouracil (5FU) in this indication. We describe three cases of Darier's disease treated with Efudix: though it initially proved very effective, after several months this treatment became inefficacious.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Case 1: a 16-year-old girl with Darier's disease refractory to conventional treatments. Treatment with topical 5FU was initiated. After 3 weeks, her cutaneous lesions had practically disappeared, leaving only pigmented scars. At 6 months, worsening of the disease was controlled by increasing 5FU. At 11 months, the disease worsened and 5FU, which proved inefficient, was stopped. Case 2: a 59-year-old woman presenting treatment-resistant Darier's disease was given 5FU. After 1 week, improvement began and was evident at 4 months. However, after 13 months of treatment, the disease progressed, and increased 5FU proved completely ineffective. Case 3: a 29-year-old woman was hospitalized for inflammatory Darier's disease. Topical 5FU was applied to the left half of the body and a short course of oral corticosteroids was prescribed. After 10 days of treatment, there was a clear improvement. After 6 weeks, the patient showed episodes of healthy skin. However after 3 months, the patient stopped taking her treatment due to inefficacy.

DISCUSSION

While topical 5FU seems to be effective initially in treating Darier's disease, this efficacy subsides over time. Although no adverse effects were noted in our patients, use of 5FU can result in serious adverse reactions. Because of the loss of efficacy of this treatment following initial success, coupled with its poorly evaluated safety, caution must be exercised when prescribing it, particularly in patients with dihydropyriminidine dehydrogenase (DPD) deficiency or for use on damaged skin.

[Segmental Darier disease : treatment with pulsed dye laser]

Darier disease is often associated with pruritus and an unpleasant odor, causing medical and emotional problems. Ablative laser therapy has proven effective in ameliorating these symptoms. Side effects of this approach include permanent hypopigmentation and a risk of scarring. We present two cases where non-ablative therapy with pulsed dye lasers proved a safe and effective way to manage the intertriginous lesions. Although the mechanism of action is unclear, our success indicates that pulsed dye laser therapy is an option in Darier disease. Larger numbers of patients, ideally in multicenter studies, must be treated in this way to confirm our results.

Amélioration d’une maladie de Darier traitée par 5 fluorouracil topique

BACKGROUND

Darier's disease is an inherited genodermatosis with autosomal dominant transmission characterized by hyperkeratotic papules of seborrheic regions in the axillae, groin or submammary skin in women. Current therapeutic alternatives are poor, encouraging recourse to alternatives treatments such as topical 5-fluorouracil (Efudix) used until now for pre-epitheliomatous keratosis.

CASE REPORT

A 55-year-old man presenting severe Darier's disease refractory to therapy for more than twenty years was treated with topical 5-fluorouracil. The cream was applied at a concentration of 1% every second day for five months, alternating with clobetasol ointment in order to improve tolerability. After one month of treatment, clinical signs of hyperkeratosis had virtually disappeared from the patient's face and neck. This dramatic improvement persisted for 2 months after the end of the treatment with 5-fluorouracil. No local or systemic side-effects have been observed to date.

DISCUSSION

Darier's disease is caused by mutations of the ATP2A2 gene, which codes for the SERCA2 endoplasmic reticulum calcium pump. This pump is rendered non-functional through decreased ATP and calcium affinity and blockade of phosphorylation-dephosphorylation. We propose a new hypothesis according to which the action of 5-fluorouracil results from restoration of normal intracytoplasmic calcium concentrations, leading to renewed keratinization. Thanks to its mode of activation, this prodrug can compensate for failure of the ATP phosphorylation-dephosphorylation mechanisms necessary for calcium pump activity by releasing phosphoric acids. Thus, topical 5-fluorouracil appears to constitute an effective alternative therapy. Long-term studies in a larger population are needed to clarify the optimal dosage and identify potential side effects.

Darier's disease: epidemiology, pathophysiology, and management

Darier's disease is a rare cutaneous disease with an autosomal dominant mode of inheritance. Greasy papules and plaques arise on the seborrheic areas and in the flexures and almost all patients have nail abnormalities. Acantholysis and dyskeratosis are the typical histological findings. The underlying defect is a result of mutations in the ATP2A2 gene on chromosome 12q23-24 that encodes for a sarco/endoplasmic reticulum calcium ATPase (SERCA 2). Acantholysis is thought to result from desmosome breakdown. Darier's disease is an example of a dominantly inherited disease caused by haplo-insufficiency. Oral retinoids are the most effective treatment but their adverse effects are troublesome. Topical retinoids, topical corticosteroids, surgery, and laser surgery have their advocates but evidence for efficacy is sparse.

Management of Darier's disease

Darier's disease is an uncommon inherited cutaneous disease which is difficult to manage, especially in adolescence. The warty keratotic papules irritate, smell and look unsightly. Histologically, the condition is characterized by the presence of focal acantholytic dyskeratosis. Treatment is unsatisfactory, particularly in patients with erosive flexural disease, but retinoids reduce the hyperkeratosis. Now the mutation causing Darier's disease has been identified, there is a real possibility of more effective treatment in the future.