The SCID mouse as a model for multiple myeloma

The use of animal models in multiple myeloma

In myeloma, the understanding of the tissular, cellular and molecular mechanisms of the interactions between tumor plasma cells and bone cells have progressed from in vitro and in vivo studies. However none of the known animal models of myeloma reproduce exactly the human form of the disease. There are currently three types of animal models: (1) injection of pristane oil in BALB/c mice leads to intraperitoneal plasmacytomas but without bone marrow colonization and osteolysis; (2) injection of malignant plasma cell lines in immunodeficient mice SCID or NOD/SCID; the use of the SCID-hu or SCID-rab model allows the use of fresh plasma cells obtained from MM patients; (3) injection of allogeneic malignant plasma cells (5T2MM, 5T33) in the C57BL/KalwRij mouse induces bone marrow proliferation and osteolytic lesions. These cells did not grow in vitro and can be propagated by injection of plasma cells isolated from bone marrow of a mouse at end stage of the disease into young recipient mice. The 5TGM1 is a subclone of 5T33MM cells and can grow in vitro. Among the different models, the 5TMM models and SCID-hu/SCID-rab models were extensively used to test pathophysiological hypotheses and to assess anti-osteoclastic, anti-osteoblastic or anti-tumor therapies in myeloma. In the present review, we report the different types of animal models of MM and describe their interests and limitations.

Animal models of multiple myeloma and their utility in drug discovery

To evaluate potential new therapies and targets for treating multiple myeloma (MM), reproducible, biologically relevant in vivo models are required. Preclinical in vivo models of human MM allow investigators to evaluate novel therapies alone and in combination and quickly translate these results to the clinic where patients directly benefit, whether in the form of a new clinical trial, new doses and schedules, or new drug combinations. Presented in this unit are protocols for generating and maintaining a human extramedullary MM tumor in mice. Additionally, the extramedullary tumor can be excised and digested into a single-cell suspension and the human MM cells injected into mice subcutaneously, intravenously, or intratibially. Once these tumors are generated, they can be used to evaluate novel anti-MM agents and other therapies.

Nonirradiated NOD/SCID-human chimeric animal model for primary human multiple myeloma: a potential in vivo culture system

The NOD/SCID human chimeric animal model was generated by implanting of human fetal bones (FBs) into subcutaneous sites of NOD/SCID mice (NOD/SCID-hu(+)), followed by inoculation of primary bone marrow mononuclear cells (BMNCs) obtained from patients with multiple myeloma (MM) into the FBs. The BMNCs from 30 patients with MM were inoculated, and 28 (93%) of them revealed evidence of tumor growth of myeloma cells (MCs) in the NOD/SCID-hu(+) mice. Intriguingly, 17 (61%) of the 28 patients' BMNCs inoculated developed not only myeloma in the bone marrow of the FBs, but also extramedullary macrotumors (EMTs) along the periosteum of the FBs. The tumor cells in these EMTs had plasmacytoid morphology and preserved antigens and cytogenetics similar, if not identical, to those in the parent MCs. Moreover, small tumor blocks from nine EMTs were transplanted into subcutaneous sites of subsequent recipient NOD/SCID mice without human FBs (NOD/SCID-hu(-)), and all but one grew successfully. Two of the EMTs have been maintained in the animal model for more than 12 months. The NOD/SCID-hu(+) chimeric animal model is highly efficient for growth of primary MCs and presents clinical features of human MM. The engrafted MCs can be maintained subsequently in NOD/SCID-hu(-) mice as in vivo culture.

Peyronie's disease fibroblasts demonstrate tumorigenicity in the severe combined immunodeficient (SCID) mouse model

Peyronie's disease is a localized connective tissue disorder, caused by trauma to the erect penis, which results in cellular proliferation and excess extracellular matrix production within the tunica albuginea of the penis. We have previously demonstrated that cells derived from Peyronie's disease plaque tissue demonstrate increased cell growth, increased S-phase on flow cytometry, stabilization and inactivation of p53, and consistent morphologic transformation, all suggesting that these cells are biologically transformed. Severe combined immunodeficient (SCID) mice have been used extensively to study the pathobiology of malignant and benign tissue and cells. This study was undertaken to determine if Peyronie's derived fibroblasts had the potential to demonstrate tumorigenicity in the SCID mouse model, thus confirming their biologically transformed nature. Cultured fibroblasts were derived from three sources, namely, plaque tissue excised from men with Peyronie's disease, tunical tissue excised from young men with congenital penile curvature and neonatal foreskins. BALB/C SCID mice were divided into three groups and each group was inoculated with cultured fibroblasts from each of the three different sources. All animals were evaluated regularly and maintained in isolation for a period of 3 months following inoculation. All SCID mice inoculated with cells derived from Peyronie's disease plaque tissue (n=10) developed subcutaneous nodules at a mean time period of 2.5+/-0.5 months following injection. The mean maximum dimension and weight of the nodules at the time of killing the animal was 1.1+/-0.2 cms and 0.6+/-0.2 g, respectively. Histologically, the nodules were composed of large pleomorphic epithelioid cells with a high mitotic activity, which were negative for cytokeratin but positive for vimentin. None of the SCID mice inoculated with cells cultured from either normal tunica (n=5) or foreskin (n=5) developed subcutaneous nodules. In conclusion, the tumorigenic nature of Peyronie's disease plaque-derived fibroblasts sheds further light on the pathobiologic characteristics of these cells. Specifically, these data confirm that cells cultured from Peyronie's disease plaque are biologically transformed. Future refinement and study of this animal model may permit a more complete understanding of the pathophysiology of Peyronie's disease and fibromatoses in general. Furthermore, such an animal model may, in the future, allow a more ready evaluation of the therapeutic interventions for Peyronie's disease.

Insights into extramedullary tumour cell growth revealed by expression profiling of human plasmacytomas and multiple myeloma

Malignant plasma cells generally grow within the bone marrow microenvironment; however, they can also grow at extramedullary sites. To identify the tumour-specific alterations required for extramedullary growth, we analysed the expression profiles of a series of plasma cell neoplasms including primary multiple myeloma (MM), plasma cell leukaemia (PCL) and extramedullary plasmacytoma (EPC). Hierarchical clustering analysis segregated the EPCs from the remaining samples, and revealed an expression pattern associated with angiogenesis in the EPCs, involving higher expression of the genes TIE2, NOTCH3, CD31 and endoglin. Direct comparison of EPC samples with the MM samples identified 156 genes significantly upregulated and 85 genes significantly downregulated (P < 0.005, t-test) in the EPCs, including several genes involved in angiogenesis and adhesion that were upregulated (including angiopoietin 1, SPARC, Notch3 and fibronectin 1). Immunohistochemical staining demonstrated CD31 and endoglin protein expression in the EPC tumour cells, which are both angiogenesis related and could confer malignant plasma cells with the ability to grow outside the normal bone marrow environment. Defining how malignant plasma cell growth is regulated in the bone marrow versus at extramedullary sites will help to delineate the mechanisms underlying the dependence of tumour cell growth on angiogenesis and cell adhesion.

A model of chronic lymphocytic leukemia with Ritcher's transformation in severe combined immunodeficiency mice

OBJECTIVE

The major aim of the study was to establish a murine model of chronic lymphocytic leukemia with B-1 cells derived from a New Zealand white mouse.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Malignant B-1 cells (named CLL-RT cells) derived from a New Zealand white mouse were injected into the peritoneal cavity of severe combined immunodeficiency mice. Upon follow-up of recipient mice, the lymphomas showed characteristics similar to chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) with Ritcher's transformation.

RESULTS

Blood samples from the recipient mice showed that CLL-RT cells increased rapidly in peripheral blood after 5 weeks. Serum interleukin-10 also increased significantly in recipient mice, as in human chronic lymphocytic leukemia patients. These CLL-RT cells showed a high nucleus-to-cytoplasm ratio. These cells could metastasize via circulation in the recipients and form diffuse lymphomas in various tissues. These aggressive and diffuse lymphomas were similar to Ritcher's transformation of human CLL. The cell surface antigens of the spleen and peritoneal resident cells were analyzed by flow cytometry. The CLL-RT cells constantly expressed surface immunoglobulins M and G, and CD5, CD19, B220, and CD40 molecules. They did not express any CD11b, CD3, MAC-3, CD23, NK1.1, or H-2K(d) molecules.

CONCLUSIONS

The characteristics of our animal model are very similar to human CLL. This animal system could be an ideal model for the human disease. We believe the animal model would be valuable in therapeutic studies and aid in the identification of the specific genetic alleles associated with the disease.

Growth and immortalization of human myeloma cells in immunodeficient severe combined immunodeficiency mice: a preclinical model

Human multiple myeloma (MM) purified tumour cells readily undergo apoptosis in vitro. Interleukin 6 (IL-6), a main growth factor of tumour cells, has enabled the development of IL-6-dependent MM cell lines. Recently, we developed anti-gp130 monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), two of which (B1 + I2) were able to dimerize gp130 and replace IL-6 in vitro. We show here that the injection of B1 + I2 IL-6 agonistic mAbs via the inguinal subcutaneous (SC) route efficiently produced tumours in severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) mice grafted with IL-6-dependent myeloma cell lines compared with either the intraperitoneal (IP) or abdominal surgical bursa (SB) routes. The SC tumour graft, together with Matrigel and vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), leads to a strong vascularization and early detection of serum human immunoglobulins (huIgs). SCID mice treated with B1 + I2 mAbs were injected with fresh MM cells from five patients, four of whom had consistent levels of huIgs, and tumour growth was present in two. For one patient, tumour plasma cells that were passed several times subcutaneously in new SCID mice, still expressed their initial markers after several months. They remained unable to grow in vitro in the presence of B1 + I2 or IL-6. The nature of the SCID factors involved and the triggered genes are under investigation.

Myeloma progenitors in the blood of patients with aggressive or minimal disease: engraftment and self-renewal of primary human myeloma in the bone marrow of NOD SCID mice

The myelomagenic capacity of clonotypic myeloma cells in G-CSF mobilized blood was tested by xenotransplant. Intracardiac (IC) injection of NOD SCID mice with peripheral cells from 5 patients who had aggressive myeloma led to lytic bone lesions, human Ig in the serum, human plasma cells, and a high frequency of clonotypic cells in the murine bone marrow (BM). Human B and plasma cells were detected in BM, spleen, and blood. Injection of ex vivo multiple myeloma cells directly into the murine sternal BM (intraosseus injection [IO]) leads to lytic bone lesions, BM plasma cells, and a high frequency of clonotypic cells in the femoral BM. This shows that myeloma has spread from the primary injection site to distant BM locations. By using a cellular limiting dilution PCR assay to quantify clonotypic B lineage cells, we confirmed that peripheral myeloma cells homed to the murine BM after IC and IO injection. The myeloma progenitor undergoes self-renewal in murine BM, as demonstrated by the transfer of human myeloma to a secondary recipient mouse. For 6 of 7 patients, G-CSF mobilized cells from patients who have minimal disease, taken at the time of mobilization or after cryopreservation, included myeloma progenitors as identified by engraftment of clonotypic cells and/or lytic bone disease in mice. This indicates that myeloma progenitors are mobilized into the blood by cyclophosphamide/G-CSF. Their ability to generate myeloma in a xenotransplant model implies that such progenitors are also myelomagenic when reinfused into patients, and suggests the need for an effective strategy to purge them before transplant.

A gp130 Interleukin-6 Transducer-Dependent SCID Model of Human Multiple Myeloma

Agonist antihuman gp130 transducer monoclonal antibodies (MoAbs) were used in SCID mice to grow myeloma cells whose survival and proliferation is dependent on gp130 transducer activation. The agonist anti-gp130 MoAbs neither bound to murine gp130 nor activated murine cells and, as a consequence, did not induce interleukin-6 (IL-6)–related toxicities in mice. They have a 2-week half-life in vivo when injected in the peritoneum. The agonist antibodies made possible the in vivo growth of exogenous IL-6–dependent human myeloma cells as well as that of freshly explanted myeloma cells from 1 patient with secondary plasma cell leukemia. Tumors occurred 4 to 10 weeks after myeloma cell graft and weighed 3 to 5 g. They grew as solid tumors in the peritoneal cavity and metastasized to the different peritoneal organs: liver, pancreas, spleen, and intestine. Tumoral cells were detected in blood and bone marrow of mice grafted with the XG-2 myeloma cells. Tumoral cells grown in SCID mice had kept the phenotypic characteristics of the original tumoral cells and their in vitro growth required the presence of IL-6 or agonist anti-gp130 MoAbs. Myeloma cells from 4 patients with medullary involvement persisted for more than 1 year as judged by detectable circulating human Ig. However, no tumors were detected, suggesting a long-term survival of human myeloma cells without major proliferation. These observations paralleled those made in in vitro cultures as well as the tumor growth pattern in these patients. This gp130 transducer-dependent SCID model of multiple myeloma should be useful to study various therapeutical approaches in multiple myeloma in vivo.

A gp130 Interleukin-6 Transducer-Dependent SCID Model of Human Multiple Myeloma

Agonist antihuman gp130 transducer monoclonal antibodies (MoAbs) were used in SCID mice to grow myeloma cells whose survival and proliferation is dependent on gp130 transducer activation. The agonist anti-gp130 MoAbs neither bound to murine gp130 nor activated murine cells and, as a consequence, did not induce interleukin-6 (IL-6)–related toxicities in mice. They have a 2-week half-life in vivo when injected in the peritoneum. The agonist antibodies made possible the in vivo growth of exogenous IL-6–dependent human myeloma cells as well as that of freshly explanted myeloma cells from 1 patient with secondary plasma cell leukemia. Tumors occurred 4 to 10 weeks after myeloma cell graft and weighed 3 to 5 g. They grew as solid tumors in the peritoneal cavity and metastasized to the different peritoneal organs: liver, pancreas, spleen, and intestine. Tumoral cells were detected in blood and bone marrow of mice grafted with the XG-2 myeloma cells. Tumoral cells grown in SCID mice had kept the phenotypic characteristics of the original tumoral cells and their in vitro growth required the presence of IL-6 or agonist anti-gp130 MoAbs. Myeloma cells from 4 patients with medullary involvement persisted for more than 1 year as judged by detectable circulating human Ig. However, no tumors were detected, suggesting a long-term survival of human myeloma cells without major proliferation. These observations paralleled those made in in vitro cultures as well as the tumor growth pattern in these patients. This gp130 transducer-dependent SCID model of multiple myeloma should be useful to study various therapeutical approaches in multiple myeloma in vivo.

The Development of a Model for the Homing of Multiple Myeloma Cells to Human Bone Marrow

Prior in vitro studies have suggested a role of adhesion molecules, bone marrow stromal cells (BMSCs), and cytokines in the regulation of human multiple myeloma (MM) cell growth and survival. Although in vivo models have been developed in severe combined immunodeficient (SCID) mice that support the growth of human MM within the murine BM microenvironment, these xenograft models do not permit a study of the role of adhesion proteins in human MM cell-human BMSC interactions. We therefore established an in vivo model of human MM using SCID mice implanted with bilateral human fetal bone grafts (SCID-hu mice). For the initial tumor innoculum, human MM derived cell lines (1 × 104 or 5 × 104 ARH-77, OCI-My5, U-266, or RPMI-8226 cells) were injected directly into the BM cavity of the left bone implants in irradiated SCID-hu mice. MM cells engrafted and proliferated in the left human fetal bone implants within SCID-hu mice as early as 4 weeks after injection of as few as 1 × 104 MM cells. To determine whether homing of tumor cells occurred, animals were observed for up to 12 weeks after injection and killed to examine for tumor in the right bone implants. Of great interest, metastases to the right bone implants were observed at 12 weeks after the injection of 5 × 104 MM cells, without spread of human MM cells to murine BM. Human MM cells were identified on the basis of characteristic histology and monoclonal human Ig. Importantly, monoclonal human Ig and human interleukin-6 (IL-6), but not human IL-1β or tumor necrosis factor-α, were detectable in sera of SCID-hu mice injected with MM cells. In addition, specific monoclonal Ig light chain deposition was evident within renal tubules. This in vivo model of human MM provides for the first time a means for identifying adhesion molecules that are responsible for specific homing of human MM cells to the human, as opposed to murine, BM microenvironment. Moreover, induction of human IL-6 suggests the possibility that regulation of MM cell growth by this cytokine might also be investigated using this in vivo model.

The Development of a Model for the Homing of Multiple Myeloma Cells to Human Bone Marrow

Prior in vitro studies have suggested a role of adhesion molecules, bone marrow stromal cells (BMSCs), and cytokines in the regulation of human multiple myeloma (MM) cell growth and survival. Although in vivo models have been developed in severe combined immunodeficient (SCID) mice that support the growth of human MM within the murine BM microenvironment, these xenograft models do not permit a study of the role of adhesion proteins in human MM cell-human BMSC interactions. We therefore established an in vivo model of human MM using SCID mice implanted with bilateral human fetal bone grafts (SCID-hu mice). For the initial tumor innoculum, human MM derived cell lines (1 × 104 or 5 × 104 ARH-77, OCI-My5, U-266, or RPMI-8226 cells) were injected directly into the BM cavity of the left bone implants in irradiated SCID-hu mice. MM cells engrafted and proliferated in the left human fetal bone implants within SCID-hu mice as early as 4 weeks after injection of as few as 1 × 104 MM cells. To determine whether homing of tumor cells occurred, animals were observed for up to 12 weeks after injection and killed to examine for tumor in the right bone implants. Of great interest, metastases to the right bone implants were observed at 12 weeks after the injection of 5 × 104 MM cells, without spread of human MM cells to murine BM. Human MM cells were identified on the basis of characteristic histology and monoclonal human Ig. Importantly, monoclonal human Ig and human interleukin-6 (IL-6), but not human IL-1β or tumor necrosis factor-α, were detectable in sera of SCID-hu mice injected with MM cells. In addition, specific monoclonal Ig light chain deposition was evident within renal tubules. This in vivo model of human MM provides for the first time a means for identifying adhesion molecules that are responsible for specific homing of human MM cells to the human, as opposed to murine, BM microenvironment. Moreover, induction of human IL-6 suggests the possibility that regulation of MM cell growth by this cytokine might also be investigated using this in vivo model.