Wasp venom immunotherapy changes IgG antibody specificity

Suppression function against environmental dust exposure after Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus immunotherapy is associated with production of specific and cross-reactive immunoglobulin G4

BACKGROUND

Whether Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus (Der-p) allergen immunotherapy (AIT) can induce Dermatophagoides farina (Der-f) specific immunoglobulin (sIg) G4 production and tolerance to environmental allergens has not been fully investigated.

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to determine serum Der-p-sIgG4 and Der-f-sIgG4 levels in asthma and/or rhinitis patients undergoing Der-p AIT and their ability to reduce immune responses triggered by indoor-dust extracts.

METHODS

We performed a real-world prospective trial and enrolled patients with allergic rhinitis and/or asthma in Guangzhou, China. These patients received either Der-p AIT (SCIT group) or routine medications (non-SCIT group) for 156 weeks. Clinical outcomes were assessed by the combined symptom medication score (SMS) and FEV₁ % changes. House dust samples were collected to analyze allergen levels. Serum levels of Der-p-sIgG4 and Der-f-sIgG4, serum inhibitory capacity against Der-p, Der-f, and indoor dust extract by sIgE-facilitated allergen binding to B cells (IgE-FAB), and serum blocking indoor dust extract-induced basophil activation inhibition assays (BATI) in peripheral blood monocytes were carried out at weeks 0, 4, 12, 16, 52, 104, and 156 after the initiations of the treatments.

RESULTS

Our study enrolled a total of 60 participants, with 30 patients in each group. Patients in the SCIT group had significantly improved SMS when compared with the baseline and the patients in the non-SCIT group. Median levels of Der-p 1 and Der-f 1 in indoor dust extract were 1.86 μg/g and 4.74 μg/g, respectively. Serum Der-p-sIgG4 and Der-f-IgG4 levels in SCIT patients showed a significant increase from week 12 to week 156. Serum in these SCIT patients could significantly block Der-p, Der-f, and indoor dust extract formation of allergen-sIgE complex and reduced the threshold of IgE-FAB from 16 weeks after the initiation of the treatment. The capacity to inhibit Der-p, Der-f, and indoor dust extract BATI was observed in SCIT serum after 12 weeks. Der-p-sIgG4 and Der-f-sIgG4 had a significant correlation with IgE-FAB and BATI in SCIT patients at all time points.

CONCLUSION

Single Der-p immunotherapy induced both Der-p-sIgG4 and Der-f-sIgG4 production, which might cross-reactively induce tolerance against environmental allergen exposure in patients with asthma and/or rhinitis.

Allergen Immunotherapy-Induced Immunoglobulin G4 Reduces Basophil Activation in House Dust Mite-Allergic Asthma Patients

It is unclear if allergen immunotherapy (AIT) can reduce allergy effector cell activation. We evaluated the basophil response during Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus (Der p) subcutaneous immunotherapy (SCIT) and its relationship to allergen-specific immunoglobulin G4 (sIgG4) in allergic rhinitis and/or asthma patients. The study included 55 subjects, of which 35 cases received Der p SCIT and 20 controls received standard medications. Symptom and medication scores (SMSs), sIgG4 levels, specific immunoglobulin E (sIgE) levels, allergen-induced basophil activation tests (BATs) in whole blood, and BAT inhibition assays in serum were determined at weeks 0, 4, 12, 16, 52, and 104 of SCIT. Levels of Der p sIgG4 in SCIT patients significantly increased after 12 weeks of treatment compared to week 0. Serum obtained from SCIT patients significantly inhibited basophil activation after 12 weeks of treatment. Removal of immunoglobulin G4 (IgG4) antibodies at week 104 reduced the ability of serum to block basophil activation. An increase of Der p sIgG4 rather than reduction of Der p sIgE correlated with the reduction of basophil activation during SCIT. The sIgG4 antibodies may compete with sIgE binding to allergens to form an immunoglobulin E (IgE)-allergen complex. SCIT reduced the sensitivity of allergen-triggered basophil activation in Der p allergic rhinitis and/or asthma patients through induction of sIgG4.

Allergen immunotherapy in allergic respiratory diseases: from mechanisms to meta-analyses

Allergen-specific immunotherapy (SIT) involves the repeated administration of allergenic extracts to atopic individuals over a period of 3 to 5 years either subcutaneously (SCIT) or sublingually (SLIT) for the treatment of allergic respiratory diseases, including asthma and allergic rhinitis (AR). In studies, SCIT and SLIT have been shown to improve existing symptoms of asthma and AR and to also have the capability to cause disease-modifying changes of the underlying atopic condition so as to prevent new allergic sensitization as well as arrest progression of AR to asthma. Recent evidence suggests that immunotherapy brings about these effects through actions that use T-regulatory cells and blocking antibodies such as IgG(4) and IgA(2,) which can then result in an "immune deviation" from a T-helper (Th) 2 cell pattern to a Th1 cell pattern. Numerous meta-analyses and studies have been performed to evaluate the existing data among these studies, with the consensus recommendation favoring the use of immunotherapy because of its potential to modify existing diseases. Significant adverse reactions can occur with immunotherapy, including anaphylaxis and, very rarely, death. A primary factor in considering SIT is its potential to provide long-lasting effects that are able to be sustained well after its discontinuation. Given the significant burden these allergic diseases impose on the health-care system, SIT appears to be a cost-effective adjunctive treatment in modifying the existing disease state.

Immunology in the Clinic Review Series; focus on allergies: basophils as biomarkers for assessing immune modulation

Allergen-specific immunotherapy is an effective clinical treatment for hypersensitivity to many allergens. Studies of basophils during immunotherapy have provided insight into underlying immune mechanisms and support the potential use of basophil activation as a biomarker of clinical outcomes. This review examines the evidence for different pathways of basophil modulation associated with various forms of immunotherapy. Better understanding the molecular mechanisms of basophil activation and desensitization and the relationship between suppression of these effector cells to clinical outcomes holds promise for further development and improvement in potential therapies for allergic diseases.

Dose dependence of immunological response to sublingual immunotherapy

BACKGROUND

Sublingual-swallow immunotherapy (SLIT) is an accepted treatment for allergic rhinitis but its optimal dosage is scantly investigated. We studied the dose dependence of clinical efficacy and immunological response to SLIT by administering two different dosages of the same allergen in rhinitic children monosensitized to grass pollen.

METHODS

Seventy-one patients with comparable age and symptoms were randomized to receive SLIT by the same grass pollen extract from Stallergenes (Antony, France), 40 of them with the 100 IR and 31 with the 300 IR extract. All patients recorded diary cards for symptoms, medications and side-effects of the treatment, and had measurements of specific IgE and IgG4 in serum by the CAP System FEIA (Pharmacia, Uppsala, Sweden) and in nasal secretion by an in situ incubation method with the same reagents of CAP System FEIA.

RESULTS

Symptom/medication scores during the pollen season were significantly higher in patients treated with the lower dosage compared with those treated with the 300 IR dosage. Side-effects occurred with a comparable rate (25.8%vs 27.5%) in the two groups. Serum-specific IgE and IgG4 had no significant changes after 3 months of SLIT in both groups, while a significant seasonal increase of nasal IgE (P = 0.015) and IgG4 (P = 0.019) was found only in patients treated with the lower dosage.

CONCLUSIONS

A rise of specific IgG4 and a blunting of seasonal increase of specific IgE in serum was repeatedly reported during subcutaneous immunotherapy (SCIT) with pollen extracts. Our findings show such blunting of specific nasal IgE along with a low symptom/medication score in patients treated with SLIT with the higher dosage, but not a concomitant rise of specific nasal IgG4. This suggests a local immunological effect of SLIT, different from systemic mechanisms of SCIT.

Is immunotherapy-induced birch-pollen-specific IgG4 a marker for decreased allergen-specific sensitivity?

BACKGROUND

The role of IgG4 during allergen-specific immunotherapy (SIT) is still controversial. The available studies present paramount differences in in vitro techniques, allergens, and clinical outcome parameters. By implementing a sensitive method, and pivotal clinical outcome parameters, we wanted to ascertain the utility of IgG4 as a clinical marker of decreased allergen-specific sensitivity to a common aeroallergen.

METHODS

Sera were drawn from 23 birch-pollen-allergic patients during a placebo-controlled clinical trial on birch pollen SIT. Seventeen patients received active treatment. Blood samples were drawn at 0, 2, 4, 7, and 30 treatment weeks, and 36 months. The binding activity of autologous IgG, IgG4, IgE, and IgE- and/or IgG-depleted serum to (125)I-labelled recombinant Bet v 1 was assessed in a fluid-phase radioimmunoassay. Disease severity was assessed subjectively on a visual analogue scale (VAS), and objectively by intradermal late-phase reaction diameters.

RESULTS

Before SIT IgG4 fraction of IgG-allergen binding varied from 4 to 74%, with a median of 36%, increasing to 71% after 36 months. Changes in IgG4 or IgG4/IgG fraction were not correlated to clinical outcome parameters. Changes in IgG allergen binding and VAS were significantly correlated (sigma = 0.72; p < 0.05). SIT increased the serum-blocking activity of IgE allergen binding from 25% before SIT to 80% after SIT. No changes were observed in the placebo group.

CONCLUSION

The data suggest that IgG4 per se is a poor marker of decreased allergen-specific sensitivity to birch pollen, both as a single measurement and as delta values.

Mechanisms of immunotherapy: IgG revisited

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

This paper will review historical and recent evidence for the induction of 'blocking' IgG antibodies during successful specific immunotherapy.

RECENT FINDINGS

Specific immunotherapy is frequently associated with a rise in allergen-specific IgG4 antibodies and a modest reduction in specific IgE titres, although this does not always correlate with clinical efficacy. There is accumulating evidence that specific immunotherapy also influences the blocking activity on IgE-mediated responses by IgG4, and cellular assays are commonly used to investigate these changes. Recently, a novel assay, which detects allergen-IgE binding using flow cytometry, has been used to detect 'functional' specific immunotherapy-induced changes in IgG antibody activity. Results suggest that successful specific immunotherapy is associated with an increase in IgG blocking activity that is not solely dependent on the quantity of IgG antibodies.

SUMMARY

Successful immunotherapy is associated with quantitative and qualitative changes in the allergen-specific IgG antibody response. The induction of IgG antibodies with blocking activity may have a protective role not only through the inhibition of allergen-induced, IgE-mediated release of inflammatory mediators from mast cells and basophils, but also through the inhibition of IgE-facilitated antigen presentation to T cells. Qualitative changes in the allergen-specific IgG antibody response may possibly be an important mechanism underlying the clinical efficacy of specific immunotherapy. Monitoring changes in blocking activity using cellular assays may give an early indication of the potential success of treatment.

Inhibition of allergen-IgE binding to B cells by IgG antibodies after grass pollen immunotherapy

BACKGROUND

Among atopic individuals, levels of allergen-specific IgG antibodies have been inversely associated with the degree of allergen sensitization. Additionally, allergen-specific IgG antibodies are markedly increased by allergen injection immunotherapy. These observations have led to proposals that allergen-specific IgG antibodies might have protective properties in atopic individuals.

OBJECTIVE

We hypothesized that after grass pollen immunotherapy, these antibodies disrupt IgE-dependent allergen processing by antigen-presenting cells.

METHODS

We have developed a novel flow cytometric assay based on detection of allergen-IgE binding to the low-affinity IgE receptor on B cells to examine the blocking effects of sera collected from 18 patients who participated in a double-blind, controlled trial of grass pollen immunotherapy for 1 year.

RESULTS

In all 10 patients who received active therapy, there was induction of activity that inhibited allergen-IgE binding to B cells (P =.02, vs placebo subjects), as well as subsequent allergen presentation to T cells. This activity copurified with IgG and was allergen specific, because sera taken from patients treated with grass pollen immunotherapy but who were also birch pollen sensitive did not inhibit IgE-birch pollen allergen binding to B cells.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that allergen-specific IgG antibodies induced by immunotherapy can disrupt formation of allergen-IgE complexes that bind to antigen-presenting cells and facilitate allergen presentation.

Evaluation of the safety of an abbreviated course of injections of allergen extracts (rush immunotherapy) for the treatment of dogs with atopic dermatitis

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the safety of an abbreviated course of injections of allergen extracts (rush immunotherapy) for the treatment of dogs with atopic dermatitis.

ANIMALS

30 dogs with atopic dermatitis examined at a veterinary dermatology referral practice for treatment with allergen-specific immunotherapy.

PROCEDURE

A catheter was placed in a vein in each dog. Dogs were constantly observed throughout the procedure. Allergen extracts were administered in increasing concentrations every 30 minutes for 6 hours to a maintenance concentration of 20,000 protein nitrogen units/ml. Epinephrine, oxygen, and emergency treatment were available as needed.

RESULTS

In 22 (73%) dogs, rush immunotherapy safely replaced the prolonged induction period (15 weeks) of weekly injections that consists of increasing concentrations of allergen extract. In 7 (23%) dogs, the induction period was abbreviated to 4 weeks. Of the 8 dogs that developed problems during rush immunotherapy, increased pruritus necessitated premature cessation of rush immunotherapy in 7, and 1 developed generalized wheals. Oral administration of prednisolone (1 mg/kg of body weight) resulted in resolution of adverse effects in all 8 dogs.

CONCLUSION AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Rush immunotherapy performed by personnel at a veterinary hospital is a safe method for treatment of dogs with atopic dermatitis.

Early effect of ultrarush venom immunotherapy on the IgG antibody response

BACKGROUND

We have previously shown in several allergy models that allergic and tolerance status with respect to allergens is associated with a somewhat different dominant specificity of IgG antibodies. The objective was to test this hypothesis in the compelling model of ultrarush venom immunotherapy (VIT), which induces clinical tolerance after only a few hours of treatment.

METHODS

Antibody titers and specificity were evaluated through solid-phase ELISA using streptavidin-biotin technology in 12 patients allergic to wasp venom before and during the ultrarush procedure (at 12 h, 24 h, and 15 days). The results were compared with those from another group of 20 patients treated with venom injections for at least 2 years.

RESULTS

No significant change was observed in IgG titers during the early phase of VIT. The capacity of individual sera to prevent the antigen binding of pooled IgG from allergic patients changed rapidly, with mean percentage inhibitions falling from 80+/-15%, before starting VIT, to 26+/-14%, 35+/-15%, and 34+/-5% after 12 h, 24 h, and 15 days of treatment, respectively (P<0.001 by one-way ANOVA). The capacity of individual sera to prevent the antigen binding of pooled IgG from patients receiving prolonged VIT changed, with mean percent inhibitions increasing from 47+/-8%, before starting VIT, to 76+/-7%, 83+/-6%, and 87+/-6% after 12 h, 24 h, and 15 days of treatment, respectively (P<0.001 by one-way ANOVA).

CONCLUSIONS

During the initial phase of ultrarush VIT, a change in IgG specificity, i.e., a change in the set of epitopes dominantly recognized by IgG on wasp-venom antigens, occurred concomitantly with early clinical tolerance and was already detectable a few hours after the onset of treatment. Although it may be an epiphenomenon, this change represents the earliest humoral modification described so far during this procedure. The mechanism is unknown, but it appears to be a selective depletion of the highest avidity antibody fraction by the venom injected in large doses at this stage of therapy. Finally, our data now show the previously documented association between a particular IgG specificity and the clinical status (allergy vs tolerance) to be true also with ultrarush VIT, a model in which the clinical ability to display allergic symptoms is rapidly reversed.

Relationship between allergic status and specificity of IgG antibody to inhaled allergens: the grass pollen model

BACKGROUND

We have previously reported that IgG antibodies from healthy individuals and patients suffering from non-seasonal mite allergy bind to different sets of epitopes on Der p 1, allowing almost complete discrimination of the populations.

OBJECTIVES

To confirm this observation in a seasonal allergy model where a clear relationship between allergic symptoms and exposure to the offending agent is established. To investigate whether the pattern of modified specificity is related to the differences in IgG subclass hierarchy usually exhibited by nonallergic and allergic populations.

METHODS

The capacity of individual sera from patients allergic to grass pollen and healthy individuals, including grass pollen-sensitized subjects, to prevent the binding of pooled IgG, IgG1, and IgG4 fractions from grass pollen-allergic patients and healthy individuals to solid-phase bound grass pollen antigen was evaluated in enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) using streptavidin-biotin technology. Specificity controls were performed using sera from patients allergic to cat dander and house dust mite.

RESULTS

The capacity of sera to prevent the antigen binding of allergic IgG averaged 84 +/- 5% for allergic sera and 53 +/- 6% for healthy sera (P < 0.001 by one-way anova). Conversely, using the antigen-binding capacity of healthy control IgG as reference, percentage inhibitions averaged 46 +/- 9% in grass pollen-allergic subjects compared with 80 +/- 4%, 82 +/- 2% in healthy individuals, and mite- and cat-allergic patients, respectively, resulting in two well-separated populations (P < 0.0001 by one-way anova). Similar results were found regardless of whether pooled IgG1 or IgG4 were used.

CONCLUSION

Together with previous data, our results define a new type of humoral signature in the immune response to inhaled allergens. Allergic and healthy status differ not only in the presence or absence of specific IgE antibody but also in the preferential expression of distinct IgG specificities that are better correlated with clinical manifestations and are unrelated to subclass distribution.

Modified antigenic reactivity of anti-phospholipase A2 IgG antibodies in patients allergic to bee venom: conversion with immunotherapy and relation to subclass expression

BACKGROUND

We have previously reported that, in addition to modifying IgG levels and subclass distributions, wasp venom immunotherapy (VIT) rapidly changes IgG antibody specificity.

OBJECTIVES

We investigated whether such a change can be documented in the IgG response to the major bee venom allergen, phospholipase A2 (PLA2), from patients allergic to bees treated with VIT; whether it is coupled to the shift in IgG subclass distribution (IgG4 predominance) usually observed during VIT; and whether it restores the specificity displayed by IgG antibodies from nonallergic individuals.

METHODS

Antibody specificity was evaluated in 17 patients allergic to bee venom in competitive ELISAs by using streptavidin biotin technology. Patients were tested before and during specific immunotherapy (at 15 days and 6 months) and compared with another group of 17 patients treated with venom injections for at least 2 years (VIT patients) and 30 healthy individuals.

RESULTS

The capacity of individual sera to prevent PLA2 binding of pooled IgG from allergic patients changed rapidly with mean percentage inhibitions falling from 84% +/- 14% before starting VIT to 27% +/- 13% and 28% +/- 7% after 15 days and 6 months of treatment, respectively (p < 0.001 by one-way analysis of variance [ANOVA]). IgG titers were only slightly increased. The capacity of individual sera to prevent the binding of pooled IgG from patients receiving VIT changed rapidly with mean percentage inhibition increasing from 60% +/- 12% before starting VIT to 85% +/- 6% and 82% +/- 6% after 15 days and 6 months of treatment, respectively (p < 0.001 by one-way ANOVA). Similar results were found regardless of whether pooled IgG1 or pooled IgG4 were used.

CONCLUSION

VIT results in a rapid change in the antigenic reactivity of anti-PLA2 IgG antibody of human allergic sera, restoring, although not completely, the specificity peculiar to lgG from healthy individuals. This suggests that allergic status and immunoprotection correlate with the preferential expression of distinct IgG specificities, which appear equally distributed over the IgG1 and IgG4 antibody subclasses. It is, however, not known whether the shift in IgG specificity is one of the operative mechanisms of VIT.