Inhibition by FK506 of established lesions of collagen-induced arthritis in rats

Immunotherapy in Collagen-Induced Arthritis: Past, Present, and Future

Type II collagen-induced arthritis has played a critical role in the development of novel approaches to the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis. The model has provided insights into autoimmune mechanisms relevant to the pathogenesis of joint disease and permitted the identification of potential targets for arthritis therapy. Notably, the model excelled in the development of cytokine inhibition for rheumatoid arthritis, with investigations demonstrating that a complex network of cytokine interactions regulate the autoimmune response to collagen. Recent studies of collagen-induced arthritis provide indications of novel approaches to disease intervention. New directions include modulation of the recognition and presentation of autoantigens, inhibition of specific T cell subsets responding to autoantigens, blocking of stimulatory cosignals at the cell surface, decoys for cytoplasmic and nuclear activation signals, interference with lymphocyte migration to the synovial joint, and reduction of the mediators of joint destruction. These approaches can be implemented through gene therapy, biological response mediators, or classic pharmacological intervention.

Cyclosporine, FK-506, rapamycin, and other immunomodulators

Immunomodulatory agents represent a unique group of therapies that are not biologics and have relatively specific, noncytotoxic effects on the immune system. Cyclosporine has been the most widely tested of the immunomodulatory agents and shown efficacy in a variety of autoimmune diseases as well as monotherapy in established rheumatoid arthritis. FK-506 and rapamycin, agents similar to cyclosporine, are being tested in human transplantation, with only arthritis studies having been done in animals. Tilomisole, imuthiol, and mycophenolate mofetil have been studied in limited rheumatoid arthritis trials with positive effects. Although more specific and with manageable short-term side effects, this group of therapies requires more studies to establish their efficacy and long-term safety.

Effect of FK-506 on xenografted human Graves' thyroid tissue is severe combined immunodeficient mice

OBJECTIVE

We studied the macrolide antibiotic FK-506, an immunosuppressive agent, in an attempt to ameliorate the lesion of autoimmune thyroid disease in human thyroid tissue xenografted into severe combined immunodeficient (SCID) mice. It was not felt appropriate to employ this agent directly in patients with autoimmune thyroid disease because adequate therapeutic modalities are available and the introduction of new, experimental agents could not be justified. Moreover, the study of the tissue before and after treatment could not have been undertaken directly in patients.

DESIGN

Human thyroid xenografts from four patients with Graves' disease and two normal persons were xenografted into SCID mice. Two weeks after xenografting, human immunoglobulin G (IgG) was detectable in all SCID mice xenografted with Graves' thyroid tissue. Mice were divided into two groups with human IgG levels similar to each other. Mice in the first group were treated with FK-506 daily for 6 weeks; mice in the second (similar) group were given phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) only (control group).

MEASUREMENTS

Blood samples were taken every 2 weeks from the tail veins for human IgG, thyroid stimulating antibody, thyroperoxidase antibodies, thyroglobulin antibodies, and interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma). After 8 weeks treatment, animals were sacrificed; thyroid tissue was examined histologically and for thyrocyte HLA-DR expression. FK-506 was also added to thyrocytes in in-vitro tissue culture conditions.

RESULTS

After 4-6 weeks of FK-506 therapy, human IgG, all thyroid antibodies and IFN-gamma were suppressed, while the levels remained elevated in the control group. Lymphocytic infiltration virtually disappeared in the human thyroid tissue of the FK-506-treated mice and thyrocyte HLA-DR expression markedly declined; in the control mice, lymphocytic infiltration remained heavy and HLA-DR expression remained high. On the other hand, FK-506 added directly to thyrocytes in vitro (without lymphocytes) did not reduce thyrocyte HLA-DR expression.

CONCLUSIONS

FK-506 appears to suppress the activation of intrathyroidal lymphocytes, but not thyrocytes. From these observations, it is concluded that this agent, by its action on intrathyroidal lymphocytes, is able to ameliorate the immunologically mediated histological and serological disturbance in human autoimmune thyroid disease, at least under these circumstances.

The use of immunomodulators in early rheumatoid arthritis

Immunomodulators represent a unique class of drugs that are not biologics, usually are isolated from nature, and have relatively specific noncytotoxic effects on the immune system. Although most slow-acting antirheumatic drugs (SAARDs) have effects on the immune system, these effects usually are not specific, often are cytotoxic, are not associated with specific cellular binding proteins, and their effect on immunity is difficult to correlate with their clinical effects. Most immunomodulators primarily affect T cells; because of their apparent role in rheumatoid arthritis (RA), studies of these agents are appropriate. Cyclosporine, the most widely tested of the immunomodulators, has shown significant efficacy in established RA in studies worldwide. However, only one study using cyclosporine has been performed in relatively early RA, in which the most positive effects might be expected. FK506 and rapamycin, agents similar to cyclosporine, are being tested in human transplantation; the only arthritis studies have been performed in animals. Tilomisole, imuthiol, and mycophenolate mofetil have been studied in limited RA trials, with positive effects. However, no trials have been conducted in early RA. Although promising, this class of drugs will require more studies to establish their efficacy and safety, especially in early RA.

High-density proteoglycan induces specific suppression of adjuvant-induced arthritis in rats

In vitro data support the view that T cells in adjuvant-induced arthritis (AIA) respond to the proteoglycan (PG) component of articular cartilage; however, an in vivo role for PG in AIA has yet to be shown. To do so, we examined the effects of pretreatment with bovine cartilage high density PG (HDPG) on AIA induced by heat-killed Mycobacterium butyricum in Lewis rats. Purified bovine cartilage HDPG emulsified in Freund's incomplete adjuvant (FIA) was injected intradermally into rats 7 days before challenge with Myco. butyricum. The severity of arthritis was significantly suppressed in rats pretreated with as little as 0.75 mg of HDPG, and the arthritis was completely suppressed in rats pretreated with 3.0 mg of HDPG. This suppression was specific, as the same treatment did not protect against type II collagen-induced arthritis. Suppression of AIA is primarily a property of the HDPG, as suppression of the arthritis was significantly less with pretreatment with 3.0 mg of middle density fractions of PG, and no suppression was observed with pretreatment with the lowest density fraction of PG. Thus we report that pretreatment with cartilage HDPG, but not lower density PG, can induce specific suppression of AIA. These in vivo results support the view that immunity to cartilage HDPG plays a major role in the pathogenesis of AIA, and can induce specific tolerance to this type of arthritis.

Suppression of autoimmune thyroid disease by FK 506: influence on thyroid-infiltrating cells, adhesion molecule expression and anti-thyroglobulin antibody production

Autoimmune thyroid disease was induced in female PVG/c rats by neonatal thymectomy, followed by sublethal, whole body x-irradiation. Disease development, assessed by histological evidence of lymphocytic thyroiditis and circulating levels of anti-thyroglobulin antibodies, was reduced significantly by a 3-week course of FK 506 (0.5 or 1.5 mg/kg per day) commencing after the detection of autoantibody production. Thyroid-infiltrating mononuclear cells (MNC) in untreated rats stained predominantly for CD4+ and MHC class II antigen which was expressed widely on dendritic cells. Fewer infiltrating cells expressed TCR alpha/beta, CD5, CD8 or LFA-1 beta. Intercellular adhesion molecule-1 (ICAM-1) was observed on MNC, vascular endothelial cells and a minority of residual thyroid epithelial cells. FK 506 administration reduced markedly the incidence of infiltrating TCR alpha/beta +, CD5+, CD4+, CD8+, and LFA-1 beta + cells and the expression both of MHC class II antigens and ICAM-1 on MNC, endothelial cells and thyrocytes. Compared with normal PVG/c rats, there were reduced incidences of CD4+ CD8- and CD4- CD8+ lymphocytes and an elevation in the CD4+/CD8+ cell ratio in the spleens of animals with autoimmune thyroiditis. These changes were partially reversed by FK 506. Systemic drug levels estimated by enzyme immunosorbent assay were in excess of those known to blockade cytokine production by CD4+ T lymphocytes in vitro and some evidence of minor renal dysfunction was observed. The results are consistent with a therapeutic effect of FK 506 mediated via interference with CD4+ T lymphocyte function and adhesion molecule-dependent cytotoxic effector mechanisms.

Characterisation of passively transferred antigen arthritis induced by methylated bovine serum albumin in the rat: effect of FK 506 on arthritis development

The conditions necessary for the passive transfer of antigen arthritis induced by methylated bovine serum albumin (mBSA) in the rat have been studied. Spleen cells from immunised rats were not capable of transferring disease unless they were first activated in culture with mBSA or concanavalin A. Cells from sham-immunised animals could not be activated to transfer the arthritis. The immunosuppressant drug FK 506 could inhibit the development of the arthritis when present during the activation period in culture or when dosed to the recipients of activated cells.

The effect of FK506 and cyclosporin A on antigen-induced arthritis

FK506 and cyclosporin A inhibited the development of antigen-induced arthritis in the rat and rabbit. FK506 was five times more potent than cyclosporin A in the rat and approximately 20 times more potent in the rabbit. FK506 was effective in both species if administered either from the day of intra-articular administration of antigen or when the arthritis was established. In the rabbit, arthritis returned when administration of FK506 was stopped. FK506 (10 mg/kg/day) caused renal damage which was not observed at a dose of 2.5 mg/kg/day. Both of these doses were equally effective at inhibiting the arthritis. The conclusion from these studies is that FK506 is a more effective anti-arthritic agent than cyclosporin A and that a pronounced therapeutic effect can be achieved at non-toxic doses of the drug.

Comparative studies of the effects of FK506 and cyclosporin A on passively transferred collagen-induced arthritis in rats

We investigated the effect of a novel immunosuppressive agent, FK506, in comparison with cyclosporin A (CsA) on the development of passive arthritis induced by anti-type II collagen (CII) antisera in rats. FK506 pretreatment shortly before serum transfer markedly suppressed the incidence and the severity of passive arthritis, while CsA pretreatment had no observable effects on this disease when used in doses sufficient to suppress the development of active arthritis induced by CII immunization. In an additional study, we examined whether these agents affect antibody-mediated tolerance induction. CII-specific immunological tolerance was induced by serum transfer, but was unaffected by either FK506 or CsA pretreatment in our regimen. While its precise mechanism of the immunosuppressive activity remains to be elucidated, FK506 can act on the antibody-mediated effector phase of arthritis and may offer new insights into the possible role of potential therapeutic utility in human autoimmune diseases.