Inhibitory activity of HIV envelope gp120 dominates over its antigenicity for human T cells

Natural analogue peptides of an HIV-1 GP120 T-helper epitope antagonize response of GP120-specific human CD4 T-cell clones

Neutralizing antibodies and specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) may contribute to controlling viral spread, and ideally, to virus clearance in HIV infection. Both effector mechanisms depend on specific CD4 T-helper (Th) cells. Nevertheless, HIV hypervariability facilitates appearance of escape mutants for antibodies and for CTL responses. Here we also show that natural mutations (i.e., from sequences of different HIV strains) in an immunodominant Th epitope recognized by human CD4 clones specific for the envelope glycoprotein gp120 escape CD4 T-cell recognition. Furthermore, several natural analogue peptides exert an antagonistic function by inhibiting proliferative response of T cells specific to gp120 with a wild-type sequence. If similar events occur in vivo, they may represent an additional escape mechanism for HIV. In fact, antagonism for CD4 Th response may occur during superinfection with a different strain, or with the appearance of a variant carrying a mutated antagonistic sequence. In both cases, impaired Th cell function could lead to reduced immune control of HIV infection by interfering with CTL and antibody response.

Priming of human CD4+ antigen-specific T cells to undergo apoptosis by HIV-infected monocytes. A two-step mechanism involving the gp120 molecule

The study of the pathology of HIV-1 infection in chimpanzees supports the idea of the crucial role of HIV-infected monocytes in the pathogenesis of AIDS, although viral mechanisms that lead to T cell dysfunction and deletion during HIV infection are still unclear. We show here that HIV-1-infected antigen-presenting monocytes (APCs) are able to prime in vitro non-HIV-infected antigen-specific CD4+ T cell lines or peripheral blood CD4+ T cells to undergo apoptosis after antigen-specific restimulation. The priming of T cells for apoptosis occurs in the absence of HIV replication in the T cells. Priming for apoptosis required two concomitant signals present on the same APC, an antigenic stimulus and a second signal provided by the HIV gp120 protein as demonstrated by the use as APCs of EBV-LCLs infected with different recombinant deleted proviruses or transfected with different HIV proteins. These results provide a mechanism for the priming for apoptosis of T cells in HIV-infected patients, implicating a role for HIV-infected APCs in the induction of T cell dysfunction and depletion in AIDS.

Handling of retroviral antigens by human antigen-presenting cells

Antigen-specific T helper cells play an important role in retroviral infections. Indeed, they provide help for B-cell activation and antibody production and for clonal expansion of cytolytic lymphocytes. Therefore, we used retrovirus-specific human T helper clones in order to define modes of antigen presentation, antigen-presenting cells and the molecular context of Th epitopes that could be exploited in the design of immunogens aimed at optimizing the Th cell response. In particular, we describe several mechanisms of receptor-mediated antigen uptake that enhance the stimulation of human T-cell clones specific for HIV and HTLV-1 antigens; we report on the differential recognition of Th epitopes depending on the molecular-viral context; we show that dendritic cells are the most efficient presenting cells and are essential for the induction of in vitro primary Th cell responses; and finally, we propose that Th cells specific for internal, conserved antigens of HIV such as reverse transcriptase, may be candidates for intrastructural help resulting in induction of envelope specific antibodies.

Cultured human Langerhans' cells are superior to fresh cells at presenting native HIV-1 protein antigens to specific CD4+ T-cell lines

Cultured Langerhans' cells (CLC) exhibit enhanced antigen-presenting function compared to freshly isolated LC (FLC), but they are commonly believed to be inefficient at processing intact proteins. In this study, FLC and CLC from normal, human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) seronegative volunteers were compared for their ability to present the HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein gp120 or reverse transcriptase (p66) antigens to autologous, specific CD4+ T cell lines. Epidermal cell suspensions enriched for LC were prepared from suction blister roofs. FLC stimulated T cells at lower antigen concentrations compared to unfractionated peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC). CLC were more potent on a per cell basis than FLC, PBMC or adherent monocytes at presenting native gp120, native p66 or immunogenic peptides. CLC were also more efficient than FLC or PBMC in terms of the amount of antigen required for T-cell activation. Chloroquine and leupeptin inhibited presentation of intact p66, but not of an immunodominant peptide, by FLC or CLC, thus indicating that both cells utilize antigen-processing mechanisms that are based on intracellular acidification and protease activity. Incubation of CLC with monoclonal antibodies against HLA-DR, CD11b, CD18, CD50, CD54, CD58 or CD80, but not anti-major histocompatibility complex class I (MHC-I), inhibited antigen-specific T-cell proliferation to varying degrees. We conclude that human CLC retain the ability to process and present protein antigens potently to CD4+ T cells. Thus, CLC have the capacity to participate actively in the generation and maintenance of T-helper cell immunity to viral antigens during HIV-1 infection.

Human T helper cells specific for HIV reverse transcriptase: possible role in intrastructural help for HIV envelope-specific antibodies

Cooperation between B cells specific for an antigen exposed on a viral structure and T helper (Th) cells specific for an internal antigen, as demonstrated with influenza, hepatitis B and rabies viruses, has been termed intrastructural help. Th cells specific for internal proteins of HIV, which are much less mutated than its exposed antigens, may be valuable in vaccine design against this virus. We investigated the human Th repertoire specific for the core HIV antigen reverse transcriptase (p66), and determined whether these cells could be candidate intrastructural T helpers. CD4+ T lines and clones were generated from non-immune individuals by stimulation with p66-pulsed antigen-presenting cells (APC). Specific lines were obtained with p66 from 19 out of 21 (90%) of these individuals, vs. 7 out of 29 (24%) with gp120. Diverse epitopes were recognized by different individuals, and various V beta genes were used by these clones. Clones using the same V beta genes were of diverse origin, according to VDJ region sequence. Of these lines 45% responded to p66 in the context of HIV virions. Moreover, p66-specific clones could respond to APC that had internalized HIV complexed with envelope-specific monoclonal antibodies, suggesting that p66-specific Th cells may participate in intrastructural help. These studies indicate that p66-specific Th cells are detectable in vitro in most naive individuals and exhibit clonal heterogeneity, and that the majority recognize an HIV conserved antigen. They respond to p66 following processing of whole virions and are clearly candidates for intrastructural help. If confirmed in vivo, p66 should be included among vaccine candidates investigated to optimize the anti-HIV Th response.

Human T-helper cell recognition of an immunodominant epitope of HIV-1 gp120 expressed on the surface of Streptococcus gordonii

Our genetic system for expression of heterologous proteins on the surface of the Gram-positive bacterium Streptococcus gordonii was used to express a human T-helper epitope of HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein gp120. In previous work on the naive repertoire of human T-helper cells, it was shown that a 15-amino acid synthetic peptide of the HIV-1 gp120 sequence contained an immunodominant T-helper epitope. Synthetic DNA coding for this peptide was cloned in frame within the gene for the streptococcal surface protein M6, and the gene fusion was integrated by transformation into the chromosome of S. gordonii. The expected M6-gp120 fusion protein was found to be expressed on the surface of the recombinant streptococci. To test whether the T epitope could be recognized by T cells when expressed on the bacterial surface within the context of M6, recombinant bacteria were used as antigen in proliferation assays to stimulate the 15-amino acid-specific human T-helper clone, in the presence of autologous antigen-presenting cells. Bacteria expressing the T epitope were efficiently recognized by the T cells in culture. In proliferation assays, 10(6)-10(7) bacteria induced responses comparable to those obtained by standard amounts of synthetic peptide (0.02-0.2 micrograms). Recombinant S. gordonii, a candidate for a live vaccine vector, appeared suitable for delivering T epitopes to the immune system.

Enhanced activation of human T cell clones specific for virus-like particles expressing the HIV V3 loop in the presence of HIV V3 loop-specific polyclonal antibodies

Recombinant virus-like particles (VLP), formed by the yeast Ty p1 protein, carrying the HIV gp120 V3 loop on their surface (V3-VLP) have been tested in vitro for immunogenicity and antigenicity by using VLP p1-specific human CD4+ T cell lines and clones. VLP-specific human T cell lines and clones were generated from normal individuals, indicating that VLP-specific precursor cells present in the peripheral lymphocyte pool can be induced to expand clonally upon antigen challenge in vitro, in the absence of previous immunization. It was also shown that V3-specific polyclonal antibodies enhance V3-VLP-induced activation of VLP-specific T cell clones. Antibody-dependent potentiation has been shown previously in other antigen systems, and it depends on enhanced uptake of complexed antigen by Fc receptor-positive antigen-presenting cells. Since in this case antigen is internalized by presenting cells as a complex, it can be inferred that a similar event of antibody-mediated antigen uptake can take place with V3-specific B cells, resulting in presentation by the B cells of T helper epitopes derived from processing of the VLP p1 moiety. This suggests that T helper cells specific for the carrier VLP p1 protein can be activated to provide help to V3-specific B cells in the presence of the appropriate antigen construct.

Kinetics and specificities of the T helper-cell response to gp120 in the asymptomatic stage of HIV-1 infection

Peripheral blood mononuclear cells from 36 asymptomatic HIV-1 seropositive individuals were tested longitudinally for in vitro T-cell proliferation and IL-2 production in response to synthetic peptides spanning the entire gp120 of HIV-1. At baseline, significant T-cell proliferative to pooled and individual peptides was observed in 15 of the 36 donors. After 12 months, proliferative responses to peptide pools were lost or decreased significantly in most donors. Responses appeared to fluctuate over time: at 12 months new recognition sites were detected in four of 10 donors showing T-cell proliferation at baseline, as well as in five of 15 donors with no previous proliferative responses. IL-2 production appeared to be a more sensitive and longer preserved parameter of T-helper cell function: at baseline the majority of donors with no T-cell proliferation produced IL-2 in response to pooled peptides. This response was not decreased significantly after 12 months. The overall patterns of response to both pooled and individual peptides were heterogeneous among donors. Multiple recognition sites were detected in both variable and conserved regions of gp120, but no pool or individual peptide was recognized by all responders. Functional T-cell responses were not statistically correlated to CD4+ cell percentile and absolute numbers.

Primary in vitro sensitization of human T-helper lymphocytes by peptides derived from the V3 loop of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) envelope glycoprotein

To generate CD4+ T-helper cell lines, lymphocytes from HIV-seronegative subjects were primed in vitro with peptides derived from the V3 loop of HIV-1 gp120. Antigen-specific reactivity was inhibited by an anti-DR monoclonal antibody, indicating HLA-class II dependency, but peptides could be recognized in different HLA-class II contexts. Three sites on V3LAI and two on V3MN were identified as targets of the respective V3LAI- and V3MN-specific lines. Recognition of V3 peptides was isolate-specific. The lines did not react against whole gp160, which suggests that V3 may be differently presented when used as such rather than as part of the entire glycoprotein. Similar results were obtained in chimpanzees immunized in vivo against V3LAI.

Role of flanking variable sequences in antigenicity of consensus regions of HIV gp120 for recognition by specific human T helper clones

Human T helper cells can discriminate among strain variants of HIV gp120 because of T cell clones recognizing non-conserved regions, as demonstrated with T cells from HIV-infected individuals and vaccinated volunteers and with primary T cell lines and clones obtained by in vitro immunization. To obtain a better definition of cross-reactions among T cell determinants within HIV gp120 variants, we used a panel of analog peptides within residues 236-251 from the BRU, MN, SF2 and RF strain sequences to induce primary human T cell lines and clones. Different patterns of response were obtained using each of the analog peptides, although they all share the consensus sequence 246-251. Clones recognizing this sequence were generated by priming with the BRU and RF analog peptides, but not with the SF2 analog peptide. SF2 did not induce any 242-245-specific clones, but only T cells recognizing the 236-240 sequence. A preferential response to residues 236-240 was obtained by priming with the BRU and SF2 peptides, but not with the MN and RF peptides. These results suggest that although the analog peptides exhibit a high degree of homology and share a consensus of the C-terminal sequence (246-251), the T cell response to the conserved sequence 246-251 is controlled by flanking sequences. Therefore the presence of a shared sequence per se does not imply in vitro expansion of clones with that fine specificity, even though such clones are available within the naive repertoire and can be triggered by an analog peptide.