A gp120 HIV peptide with high similarity to HLA class II beta chains enhances PPD-specific and autoreactive T cell activation

Alloimmunity to Class 2 Human Leucocyte Antigens May Reduce HIV-1 Acquisition - A Nested Case-Control Study in HIV-1 Serodiscordant Couples

Enveloped viruses, including the Human Immunodeficiency Virus-1 (HIV), incorporate host proteins such as human leucocyte antigens (HLA) into their envelope. Pre-existing antibodies against HLA, termed HLA antibodies, may bind to these surface proteins and reduce viral infectivity. Related evidence includes macaque studies which suggest that xenoimmunization with HLA antigens may protect against simian immunodeficiency virus infection. Since HIV gp120 shows homology with class 2 HLA, including shared affinity for binding to CD4, class 2 HLA antibodies may influence HIV acquisition via binding to gp120 on the viral envelope. We conducted a nested case-control study on HIV serodiscordant couples, comparing the frequency of HLA antibodies among highly exposed persistently seronegative controls with those who went on to acquire HIV (HIV-seroconverters). We first performed low resolution HLA typing on 143 individuals who were HIV-infected at enrollment (index partners) and their corresponding sexual partners (115 highly exposed persistently seronegative individuals and 28 HIV-seroconverters). We then measured HLA class 1 and 2 antibodies in the highly exposed persistently seronegative individuals and HIV-seroconverters at early and late timepoints. We analyzed whether such antibodies were directed at HLA specificities of their HIV-infected index partners, and whether autoantibodies or complement-fixing class 2 HLA antibodies were present. Seventy-nine percent of highly exposed persistently seronegative individuals had HLA antibodies; 56% against class 1 and 50% against class 2 alleles. Half of the group of highly exposed persistently seronegative individuals, prior to seroconversion, expressed class 2 HLA antibodies, compared with only 29% of controls (p=0.05). HIV infection was a sensitizing event leading to de novo development of antibodies against HLA-A and HLA-B loci, but not against class 2 loci. HLA autoantibodies were present in 27% of highly exposed persistently seronegative individuals. Complement-fixing class 2 HLA antibodies did not differ significantly between highly exposed persistently seronegative individuals and seroconverters. In multivariable regression, presence of class 2 HLA antibodies at early timepoints was associated with reduced odds of HIV acquisition (odds ratio 0.330, confidence interval 0.112-0.976, p=0.045). These epidemiological data suggest that pre-existing class 2 HLA antibodies were associated with reduced odds of HIV acquisition.

HIV immunopathogenesis and strategies for intervention

Therapeutic options aimed at tackling the HIV pandemic face many obstacles. The lack of readily accessible and affordable therapies means that most of those affected go untreated. The array of escape mechanisms used by HIV has undermined the efficiency of many antiviral products and continually represents a barrier to the development of an effective vaccine. Recent developments have seen a shift away from a cytopathic viral model of HIV pathogenesis towards the crucial role of immunopathogenic features--notably generalised immune activation--in the development of AIDS. As conventional vaccine strategies have sought to promote viral neutralisation and suppressive cellular responses, novel strategies that aim to address HIV immunopathogenesis should be sought. We review current opinion on HIV-induced pathogenic immune activation and strategies aimed at eliminating HIV, including a potential role for non-neutralising antibodies as part of a therapeutic vaccine option.

HLA homology within the C5 domain promotes peptide binding by HIV type 1 gp120

The mechanisms by which HIV-1 induces chronic pathogenic immune activation associated with disease progression remain unclear despite many years of AIDS research. One proposal suggests that sequence and structural mimicry between gp120 and HLA may endow HIV with the capacity to arouse alloreactive and autoimmune responses within the susceptible host, fueling disease progression in a manner similar to graft-versus-host disease (GVHD). Both gp120 and HLA share a common functional interaction with CD4 but also demonstrate peptide binding properties. Here we report the conserved nature of this feature across HIV-1 envelopes, the crucial role of the HLA homologous C5 region for peptide interactions, and the elimination of this property through specific antibody targeting. Given that the C5 domain mimics a HLA activation domain and the reported clinical benefits associated with nonneutralizing antibodies against this region, targeting the C5 domain may have use as a therapeutic vaccine to protect against disease progression.

HIV type 1 envelope glycoprotein 120 carboxy-terminal peptide-induced human T cell lines selectively suppress heterogeneous proliferative T cell responses to soluble antigens

It has been proposed that the highly conserved human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) envelope gp120 carboxy-terminal sequence, TKAKRRVVEREKR (CT120), may represent a functional mimic of the human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class II DR beta-chain third hypervariable region (HVR3) sequence motif located at position 69-81. Presentation of this potentially pathogenic fragment by HLA class I and/or II molecules, in a manner analogous to the indirect pathway of allorecognition, may induce both widespread cellular activation and also break self-tolerance, resulting in the selective and progressive anti-self HLA class II-directed immune suppression, which is a central feature of HIV-1 infection and the associated acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS). To investigate the functional role of the HIV-1 gp120 C-terminal fragment T cell lines (TCLs) were raised from three healthy HIV-1-seronegative subjects at low risk of HIV-1 exposure, by repeated stimulation with a short synthetic 13-mer CT120 peptide in vitro. Graded concentrations (10[3] to 5 x 10[4]) of CT120 TCLs suppressed the primary 6-day proliferation of autologous PBMCs in response to the soluble antigens tetanus toxoid (TT) and purified protein derivative (PPD). In contrast, CT120 TCLs demonstrated no suppressive effect on 3-day phytohemagglutinin (PHA), concanavalin A (ConA), and pokeweed mitogen (PWM) mitogenic responses. Fractionation of CT120 TCLs into highly purified CD4+ and CD8+ T cell subsets demonstrated that the CD8+ T cell fraction mediated the suppressor effector function. HLA restriction analysis revealed a complex pattern as both anti-HLA class II DR and anti-HLA class I (A, B, C) MAbs inhibited proliferation of oligoclonal CD8+ CT120 TCLs. Strategies aimed at specifically inhibiting such putative immunopathogenic HIV-1-encoded T cell epitopes may be an important consideration for development of future HIV-1 immunotherapy.

Safety profile of phase I and II preventive HIV type 1 envelope vaccination: experience of the NIAID AIDS Vaccine Evaluation Group

The NIAID-sponsored AIDS Vaccine Evaluation Group was established in 1988 to perform phase I/II clinical trials with candidate preventive HIV-1 vaccines. This report includes safety data from 1398 HIV-negative, healthy volunteers who were enrolled into 25 phase I and 1 phase H multicentered, randomized, double-blind studies evaluating seven recombinant HIV-1 envelope vaccines, two V3 loop synthetic peptide vaccines, and two live poxvirus-vectored recombinant envelope vaccines. All studies but three were placebo controlled; the placebo was either the adjuvant alone or, in studies of recombinant poxvirus vaccines, it was the vector with no gene insert or a non-HIV gene insert. All candidate vaccines were generally well tolerated. The only adverse effects that were clearly related to vaccination were occasional acute local and systemic reactions that were associated with the adjuvants. Three adjuvants in particular were associated with moderate to severe local reactions: alum plus deoxycholate (ImmunoAg), MTP-PE (Biocine Corp.), and QS21 (Genentech, Inc.). MTP-PE was also associated with self-limited severe systemic reactions. There were no serious adverse laboratory toxicities and no evidence of significant immunosuppressive events after receipt of the candidate vaccines. A few volunteers experienced symptoms that might relate to an underlying immunopathologic mechanism (rash, hemolytic anemia, arthralgia), but their presentations were mild and their incidence was low. Eleven volunteers were diagnosed with malignancies during or after their participation, which was within the 95% confidence interval of the number of cases predicted by the National Cancer Institute SEER (Program for cancer surveillance, epidemiology, and end result reporting) database. In conclusion, the envelope-based recombinant or synthetic candidate HIV-1 vaccines appear to be safe and this work has prepared the way for the testing of increasingly complex candidate HIV-1 vaccines.

The HIV/AIDS epidemic: its evolutionary implications for human ecology with special reference to the immune system

The epidemiology of AIDS in Africa is discussed. Serological and clinical data on virology and population genetics are related to current theories of heterosexual transmission and to cultural practices involving the exchange or transmission of body fluids between individuals, such as female and male genital mutilation and indigenous or 'folk' medicine, as well as non-Western medical uses of medical syringes. A review of the relationship of autoimmune conditions, graft-vs-host disease and the retrovirus/oncogene involvement is presented. These data place in a new perspective concepts of widespread heterosexual infection and transmission of HIVs as well as their relation to AIDS in the context of the evolution of the human immune system.

Neutralization of HIV type 1 infectivity by serum antibodies from a subset of autoimmune patients with mixed connective tissue disease

Mixed connective tissue disease (MCTD) is a rheumatic disorder with clinical similarities to HIV-1 infection, and with characteristic autoimmune anti-RNP antibodies specific for the U1 snRNP splicing complex. Anti-RNP antibodies cross-react with the HIV-1 surface, owing to multiple homologies between the gp120/41 envelope complex and the 70K protein of U1 snRNP. A key epitope of 70K, its RNA-binding site, is homologous to a dominant B and T cell epitope in the third variable loop (V3) of gp120. In this study, we tested the ability of anti-RNP sera to inhibit HIV-1 infectivity in vitro. Of nine sera tested, five were 70-99% effective in neutralizing one or more HIV-1 strains. One serum was > 99% effective in neutralizing HIV-1MN, and 86 and 77% effective against the primary isolates HIV-1(CO) and HIV-1(JR-FL), respectively, an efficacy equal to that of a pool of broadly neutralizing antibodies from HIV-1-infected subjects (HIVIG). The mean neutralizing titer of anti-RNP sera against HIV-1(JR-FL) was 3.9-fold higher than that of HIVIG. Neutralizing potency was associated with high reactivity to gp120 by ELISA, and with the presence of serum rheumatoid factor, known to enhance antibody neutralization of other viruses. The current findings provide further evidence that individuals unexposed to HIV-1 may develop immunologic resistance by alternative mechanisms, possibly including molecular mimicry, or exposure to as yet unidentified retroviruses. Thus MCTD, which involves both B and T cell reactivity to self-epitopes homologous to HIV-1, may elucidate new strategies for generating protective immunity to this virus.

HLA class II on HIV particles is functional in superantigen presentation to human T cells: implications for HIV pathogenesis

The mechanisms of immune suppression by the human immunodeficiency virus, HIV-1, are more complex than simple helper T cell deletion via infection and viral-induced lysis. Since the recent description of cellular proteins associated with HIV suggests that these proteins may be active in viral pathogenesis, the nature of HLA class II gene product carried on HIV, one of the most abundant of the human components carried with the virus, was examined. HIV bearing HLA-DR was shown to act with bacterial superantigen, staphylococcal enterotoxin A (SEA), to stimulate highly purified human T lymphocytes. T cell stimulation by wild-type HIV was shown by both induction of proliferation and by production of the cytokine interleukin 2 (IL-2). In contrast, HIV produced from mutant cells lacking class II genes were unable to cooperate with SEA to activate T cells. Neither whole HIV nor several proteins purified from HIV (gp120, gp41, p24, p7, and p6) exhibited superantigen-like activity in this system. HLA-DR-bearing HIV could, in the continued presence of SEA, induce T cell apoptosis, as detected by nuclear fragmentation and morphological criteria. These data indicate that human cellular proteins associated with HIV may be biologically active, and these proteins should be considered in mechanisms of viral pathogenicity and immunogenicity.

In vitro stimulation of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) from HIV- and HIV+ chancroid patients by Haemophilus ducreyi antigens

The cellular immune responses to fractionated Haemophilus ducreyi antigens, coated on latex beads, were assessed in patients with chancroid and in controls, using an in vitro lymphocyte proliferation assay. Several fractions of H. ducreyi antigen revealed stimulating activity. However, only the molecular size ranges 91-78 kD, 59-29 kD, and 25-21 kD induced proliferation that may be specifically related to H. ducreyi infection. Lymphocytes from four HIV- patients, successfully treated for chancroid, were not stimulated by H. ducreyi antigen. In general, lymphocytes from HIV+ chancroid patients were less responsive to H. ducreyi antigen compared with those from HIV- chancroid patients. However, two HIV-infected patients showed exceptionally strong responses to high molecular weight fractions. To our knowledge this is the first report demonstrating that H. ducreyi contains specific T cell-stimulating antigens. Based on this work, further identification and purification of the T cell antigens is feasible.

Molecular mimicry in the pathogenesis of AIDS: the HIV/MHC/mycoplasma triangle

The immune defects characterizing infection with the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and culminating in the acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS) are the result of a multifactorial disease process, components of which are the occurrence of autoimmune phenomena and opportunistic infection. In this discussion, the observation that both the HIV-1 gp 120 envelope and Mycoplasma genitalium adhesin proteins share an area of significant similarity with the CD4-binding site of the class II major histocompatibility complex (MHC) proteins is placed in this perspective and mechanisms by which interaction within this triad could contribute to the T-cell dysfunction, T-cell depletion, Th1-cell-->Th2-cell shift, B-cell proliferation, hyperglobulinemia and antigen-presenting cell dysfunction observed during the development of AIDS are proposed.

Immunogenic combinations of HIV-1 B- and heterologous T-cell epitopes

Peptides were synthesized which combined HIV-1 B-epitopes from gp41, p34pol and heterologous T-cell epitopes from hepatitis B virus (HBV) core or tetanus toxoid. Mixtures of these composite peptides and peptides representing single HIV-1 B-epitopes were used to immunize rabbits in an adjuvant-free immunization regimen. Fusion to T-cell epitopes made the HIV-1 B-epitopes immunogenic and high titers of anti-HIV-1 antibodies were reached. Efficient antibody response against an immunorecessive HIV-1 B-epitope from p34 pol introduced as a B+T-composite also developed in rabbits pre-immunized by composites of the same T-cell epitopes but with a B-epitope from gp41. Fusion changed the fine antigenicity of the epitopes, but at least part of the antibodies against gp41-containing B+T composites recognized whole viral gp160. Composite peptides stimulated T-cells in the majority of the immunized animals.

Promiscuous and specific binding of HIV peptides to HLA-DR1 and DR103. Impact on T-cell repertoire of nonimmunized individuals

The binding of immunogenic peptides to DR molecules is influenced by residues that point into the peptide-binding groove. The T-cell response toward a peptide complexed to an MHC molecule depends on the presence of a sufficient number of T cells reactive with peptide-MHC complex on the surface of APCs. From 96 overlapping HIV peptides, we have selected 11 that show a significant binding to either DR1, DR103, or both. These two DR molecules are identical except for three amino acids at positions 67, 70, and 71 on the beta chain. Peptide-specific T-cell lines and clones were generated with cells from nonimmunized donors homozygous for DR1 or DR103 by using either individual peptides or peptide pools for the in vitro priming. Three of the peptides induced T-cell-specific proliferative response in both individuals, and these peptides were not among those with highest affinity. Most of the peptides induced strong responses against autologous APCs. This might reflect cross-reactivity between HIV and self-peptides. Definition of peptides that both show promiscuous binding to DR and elicit a strong T-cell response is important for design of efficient synthetic vaccines.

Panel of anti-gp120 monoclonal antibodies reacts with same nuclear proteins in uninfected cells as those recognized by autoantibodies from patients with systemic lupus erythematosus

Mouse monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) directed against the HIV-1 gp120 envelope protein were screened for their reactivity with intracellular antigens expressed in normal uninfected monocytes by indirect immunofluorescence and immunoblotting. Some of these MAbs reacted with the nuclei of normal uninfected cells, producing three main staining patterns by indirect immunofluorescence. Western blot analysis showed that these monoclonal antibodies recognize peptides of various molecular weights present in nuclei preparations of normal monocytes. Reactivity with peptides of similar molecular weight was also detected in sera from both HIV-infected individuals and patients with systemic lupus erythematosus. This evidence for antigenic similarities between HIV-1 gp120 and nuclear antigens represents a novel example of molecular mimicry of self-antigens by HIV envelope proteins, which supports the involvement of mechanisms of autoimmunity in HIV disease pathogenesis through recruitment of autoimmune responses to self-structures by HIV antigens.

Autoreactivity in HIV-infected individuals does not increase during vaccination with envelope rgp160

The HIV-1 envelope protein contains several regions with amino acid homology to HLA class I and class II molecules. We evaluated possible changes in antibody responses to those regions during vaccination with rgp 160 produced in a baculovirus system. Forty asymptomatic HIV-infected patients with CD4 cell counts above 400 were vaccinated with rgp 160. Twenty-one patients were tissue-typed as HLA A2. Sixty-two percent of these patients exhibited cytotoxic lymphocyte antibodies directed to CD8+, HLA A2 cells. This cytotoxicity decreased during HIV gp160 vaccination. In order to further characterize the specificity of these responses, analogues of HLA class I and HLA-DR peptides were chemically synthesized together with their correct HIV-1 gp160 sequences. Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA) with sera from before, during and after immunization were performed with HIV proteins, peptides and their homologues. All patients showed an increase in their previously poor specific T-cell activation to gp160. Fourteen patients developed increased avidities or titres to HIV proteins and/or peptides. Contrarily, serum IgG titers to the HLA homologous peptides were initially low and decreased further during the course of vaccination. This decrease occurred in the majority of patients, 35-40 of the 40 individuals, depending on the antigen. Independent measures of autoantibodies to Ro/SS-A and La/SS-B remained undetectable.

Serum reactivity against an immunoregulatory sequence of HIV p24 in HIV-1-infected subjects

The aim of this study was to assess the antibody reactivity in HIV-infected subjects against an HIV-1 p24 sequence, p226 (aa226-237), including a seven amino acid epitope showing immunosuppressive activity in vitro and to evaluate the relationship between anti-peptide antibody levels and disease progression. Sera of HIV-infected subjects, at different stages of disease, were compared to control sera in a retrospective evaluation. Recombinant HIV-1 p24 and p24- and control-peptides were used in an enzyme immunoassay as targets for antibodies present in the sera. Antibodies directed against the whole p24 protein and its peptides were found in all the sera studied but at different levels. The anti-p226 reactivity was not significantly different at different clinical stages. Nevertheless, it was inversely correlated to the reactivity directed against the whole protein, that was lower in subjects characterized by low CD4 cell numbers.

Immunobiological aspects of HIV treatment

Recent information on the efficacy of anti-retroviral therapy and vaccination strategies has been disappointing as well as confusing. The recently announced Concorde study suggested that there is no advantage to early treatment of asymptomatic HIV infection with azidothymidine alone, even though the levels of CD4+ cells in the treated group were consistently higher than in the untreated group. This will lead to increasing attention being paid to the mechanisms whereby HIV causes AIDS, which have sadly been sidelined in the rush to produce classically based therapies and vaccines. Over the last year many different theories on how HIV kills CD4+ cells and leads to AIDS have been discussed and tentatively explored.