Regulation of resistance against adjuvant arthritis in the Fisher rat

Sympathetic neurotransmission in spleens from aging Brown-Norway rats subjected to reduced sympathetic tone

Senescence of innate and adaptive responses and low-grade inflammation (inflammaging) hallmarks normal aging, which increases vulnerability to infectious diseases, autoimmunity and cancer. In normal aging, sympathetic dysregulation contributes to the dysregulation of innate and adaptive immunity and inflammaging. Sympathetic innervation of immune cells in secondary immune organs regulates immune responses. Previously in Fischer 344 (F344) rats, we reported an age-related increase in sympathetic tone and sympathetic dysfunction in beta-adrenergic receptor (AR) signaling of splenic lymphocytes that contributes to immune senescence, although the responsible mechanisms remains unexplored. In this study, we extend our previous findings using the much longer-lived Brown-Norway (BN) rats, whose behavior and immune response profile differ strikingly from F344 rats. Here, we investigated whether increased sympathetic nerve activity (SNA) in the aging spleen contributes to age-related sympathetic neuropathy and altered neurotransmission in splenic lymphocytes in BN rats. Fifteen-month male BN rats received 0, 0.5 or 1.5 μg/kg/day rilmenidine intraperitoneally for 90 days to lower sympathetic tone. Untreated young and age-matched rats controlled for effects of age. We found that elevated SNA in the aging BN rat spleen does not contribute significantly to sympathetic neuropathy or the aging-induced impairment of canonical β-AR signal transduction. Despite the rilmenidine-induced increase in β-AR expression, splenocyte c-AMP production was comparable with age-matched controls, thus dampening nerve activity had no effect on receptor coupling to adenylate cyclase. Understanding how aging affects neuroimmune regulation in healthy aging rodent models may eventually lead to strategies that improve health in aging populations vulnerable to immunosenescence and low-grade systemic inflammation.

The determinants of susceptibility/resistance to adjuvant arthritis in rats

Adjuvant arthritis (AA) serves as an excellent model for human rheumatoid arthritis. AA is readily inducible in certain rat strains, but not in others. Susceptibility/resistance to AA is determined by multiple factors. Among the genetic factors, both MHC and non-MHC genes contribute to arthritis susceptibility, and specific quantitative trait loci show association with the severity of the disease. Differential T-cell proliferative and cytokine responses, as well as antibody responses, to heat-shock proteins are evident when comparing AA-susceptible and AA-resistant rats. In addition, neuroendocrine factors and the housing environment can further modulate arthritis susceptibility/severity in particular rat strains.

Stress in Autoimmune Disease Models

The release of endogenous glucocorticoids is critical in regulating the severity of disease activity in patients with inflammatory conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis (RA). Blocking cortisol production results in a flare-up in disease activity in RA patients, and surgical removal of the adrenals in patients with Cushing's disease has been reported to exacerbate autoimmune disease. In adjuvant-induced arthritis (AA; a rat model of RA), there is an activation of the hypothalamo-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis associated with the development of inflammation. In addition, there are profound changes in peptides within the paraventricular nucleus, which are responsible for regulating the HPA axis. These changes have profound implications on the ability of AA rats to respond to acute stress. Understanding the regulation of the HPA axis in health and disease holds out the promise of targeted therapy to alleviate inflammatory conditions. This article will consider the impact of stress on an individual and his or her susceptibility to inflammation. We wish to question the idea that stress is "all bad." As we shall see, exposure to a single acute stressor can alter the phenotype of the rat to change it from being susceptible to resistant in autoimmune disease models. This alteration in susceptibility takes days to manifest itself, but can last for weeks, suggesting beneficial effects of exposure to an acute stressor.

Microbial considerations in genetically engineered mouse research

Microbial infections have long been of concern to scientists using laboratory rodents because of their potential to confound and invalidate research. With the explosion of genetically engineered mice (GEM), new concerns over the impact of microbial agents have emerged because these rodents in many cases are more susceptible to disease than their inbred or outbred counterparts. Moreover, interaction between microbe and host and the resulting manifestation of disease conceivably differ between GEM and their inbred and outbred counterparts. As a result, infections may alter the GEM phenotype and confound interpretation of results and conclusions about mutated gene function. In addition, because GEM are expensive to produce and maintain, contamination by pathogens or opportunists has severe economic consequences. This review addresses how microbial infections may influence phenotype, how immunomodulation of the host as the result of induced mutations may modify host susceptibility to microbial infections, how novel host:microbe interactions have led to the development of new animal models for disease, how phenotype changes have led to the discovery of new pathogens, and new challenges associated with prevention and control of microbial infections in GEM. Although the focus is on naturally occurring infections, extensive literature on the use of GEM in studies of microbial pathogenesis also exists, and the reader is referred to this literature if microbial infection is a suspected culprit in phenotype alteration.

Effects of stress on inflammatory autoimmune disease: destructive or protective?

We have summarised evidence in the literature for modulatory effects of stress on inflammatory autoimmune disease. We find that overall there is strong evidence for such an interrelationship. Apparent discrepancies between groups and studies are probably due to differences in experimental design, whether longitudinal or retrospective. Other important variables are the specific effects of different types of stress and the intensity and timing of the stressor relative to onset of inflammation. We conclude that there is much of benefit to be learned from scientific study of stress, such as harnessing and rationalising of stressful experiences through self-expression in patients, or the identification of novel anti-inflammatory compounds activated by stress.

Protective effect of prior acute immune challenge, but not footshock, on inflammation in the rat

Previous studies have revealed that a single exposure to an acute stress or acute immune stimulus can produce long-lasting changes in the activity and responsiveness of the hypothalamo-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis. The HPA axis is believed to be an important component in determining the susceptibility and severity of inflammation in autoimmune disease models such as adjuvant-induced arthritis (AA). In the present study we have tested the hypothesis that a single exposure to either footshock or lipopolysaccharide (LPS) 3 weeks prior to adjuvant injection can alter susceptibility to AA. Changes in HPA axis parameters were also determined. The results demonstrated that prior exposure to LPS conferred resistance to inflammation in AA, which was not related to a delay in onset of inflammation but rather an alteration in susceptibility. In contrast, prior exposure to the acute stress of footshock did not alter susceptibility. HPA axis parameters were increased in adjuvant-injected rats whether inflammation was present or not. These data suggest that prior exposure to acute immune stimuli, but not to acute footshock stress, may alter susceptibility to inflammation in the rat AA model. These changes in susceptibility do not appear to be solely mediated by increases in HPA axis activity, which were apparent in all AA groups irrespective of the presence of inflammation.

CRH in chronic inflammatory stress

Corticotropin-releasing hormone (CRH) is an important regulator of inflammation at the central level through hypothalamo-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis control of glucocorticoid secretion. Integrity of the HPA axis during autoimmune disease is critical in controlling the severity of inflammation, but the evidence for an HPA axis defect in the etiology of autoimmune diseases is not compelling. CRH secreted from leukocytes and neuronal terminals in peripheral tissues also plays a role in mediating inflammation. Elucidating the pathways underlying the expression of CRH, both central and peripheral, and interactions of CRH with other inflammatory mediators such as substance P, confers great potential for the development of a new generation of anti-inflammatory agents.

Susceptibility to autoimmune disease and drug addiction in inbred rats. Are there mechanistic factors in common related to abnormalities in hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis and stress response function?

DA and LEW inbred rats are extraordinarily susceptible to a wide range of experimental autoimmune diseases. These diseases include rheumatoid arthritis models such as collagen-induced arthritis (CIA) and adjuvant-induced arthritis (AIA), multiple sclerosis models such as myelin-basic-protein (MBP)-induced experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (MBP-EAE), and autoimmune uveitis models such as retinal S antigen (SAG) and interphotoreceptor-retinoid-binding-protein (IRBP)-induced experimental autoimmune uveitis (SAG-EAU and IRBP-EAU, respectively). DA and LEW rats are also addiction-prone to various drugs of abuse, such as cocaine. Moreover, they exhibit a variety of behavioral and biochemical characteristics that appear to be related to their susceptibility to addiction. By contrast, F344 and BN rats show quite different phenotypes. They are relatively resistant to CIA, AIA, MBP-EAE, SAG-EAU, and IRBP-EAU, and they are relatively resistant to addiction. Interestingly, both DA and LEW rats, in contrast to F344 and BN rats, have abnormalities in hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis function. For example, circadian production of corticosteroids is very abnormal in DA and LEW rats; that is, they exhibit minimal circadian variation in corticosterone levels. Since corticosteroids potentially have significant influences on immune function and autoimmune disease susceptibility and may also influence sensitivity to drugs of abuse, we have begun to dissect genetic control of these various phenotypic differences, focusing initially on the regulation of autoimmune disease expression. Using genomewide scanning techniques involving F2 crosses of DA x F344 (CIA and AIA), DA x BN (CIA), and LEW x F344 [IRBP-EAU and streptococcal-cell-wall arthritis (SCWA)], we have identified, to date, 14 genomic regions [quantitative trait loci (QTL)] that regulate disease expression in these crosses. Development and analysis of QTL-congenic rats involving these loci are in progress and should permit us to address the relationships among autoimmune disease susceptibility, drug addiction, and HPA axis and stress response function. These initial data, however, indicate that the genetic control of the autoimmune disease traits is highly complex.

Priming with interleukin-1beta suppresses experimental allergic encephalomyelitis in the Lewis rat

Lewis rats exhibit multiple defects in their hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) system that are considered to play a causal role in the susceptibility of this strain to autoimmune diseases, i.e. experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE). In the present study, we aimed to modulate the HPA response of the Lewis rat and establish its consequences for the susceptibility to EAE. Because in Wistar rats, single administration of interleukin (IL)-beta (priming) is known to induce long-lasting (weeks) sensitization of HPA responses to stressors and immune stimuli, Lewis rats were given a single dose of hIL-1beta or vehicle 1 week prior to induction of EAE by immunization with myelin basic protein (MBP). Subsequently, neurological deficits were monitored once daily. The results show that IL-1 priming markedly suppresses the neurological symptoms of EAE, without affecting the onset or duration of the disease. Measurement of vasopressin and corticotropin releasing hormone (CRH) in the external zone of the median eminence revealed that, as compared to Wistar rats, Lewis rats exhibit low vasopressin but identical CRH, and that IL-1 priming increases (0.001) vasopressin without affecting CRH stores, which is consistent with a shift to vasopressin-dominated control of adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH) secretion as described in Wistar rats under conditions of HPA hyper(re)activity. However, IL-1 priming did not affect a.m. corticosterone levels following immunization with MBP or during the clinical phase of EAE. IL-1 priming of Lewis rats attenuated the ACTH responses to an IL-1 challenge 11 days later, which may relate to an increase in resting corticosterone levels. Thus, the mechanisms underlying IL-1 induced suppression of EAE are not related to enhanced HPA responses. In addition, we did not find IL-1 priming-induced alterations in MBP-specific immunoglobulin (Ig)M, IgG1, IgGa and IgGb plasma titres, or gross alterations in T cell activation as reflected in spontaneous or concanavalin-induced T cell proliferation. We therefore speculate that IL-1-induced elevation of resting corticosterone levels may influence the development of EAE.

Onset and severity of inflammation in rats exposed to the learned helplessness paradigm

OBJECTIVE

To test the hypothesis that there is an association between susceptibility to inflammation and a hyporesponsive hypothalamo-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis.

METHODS

Animals were separated on the basis of behaviour in the learned helplessness (LH) paradigm into groups of LH(+) (i.e. animals which did not escape footshock) and LH(-) animals. Adjuvant-induced arthritis (AA) was subsequently induced in the LH(+) and LH(-) animals.

RESULTS

Plasma corticosterone was significantly increased in response to the LH test in the LH(-) compared with the LH(+) rats. We observed an earlier onset and increased inflammation in the LH(-) rats in spite of the greater corticosterone response to the acute stress. We noted lower levels of plasma testosterone in the LH(-) animals suggesting a possible influence for this protective factor in AA.

CONCLUSION

These data suggest that increased onset and severity of inflammation in AA is not a simple consequence of an attenuated HPA axis response to stress as proposed in the Lewis rat. Indeed we have observed the converse. Together these data suggest that the balance of pro- and anti-inflammatory factors released in response to stress may influence the progress of AA.

Activation of T Cells Recognizing an Epitope of Heat-Shock Protein 70 Can Protect Against Rat Adjuvant Arthritis

We have previously reported that CD4+ T cells recognizing a peptide comprising residues 234–252 of the heat shock protein (HSP)70 of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (M.tb) in the context of RT1.B MHC class II molecule emerged in the peritoneal cavity during the course of Listeria monocytogenes infection in rats and suppressed the inflammatory responses against listerial infection via IL-10 production. We report in this work that pretreatment with peptide 234–252 of HSP70 derived from M.tb suppressed the development of adjuvant arthritis (AA) in Lewis rats induced using heat-killed M.tb. T cells from rats pretreated with peptide 234–252 produced a significant amount of IL-10 in response to the epitope. T cells from rats pretreated with the peptide and immunized with M.tb produced the larger amount of IL-10 in response to the peptide, but only a marginal level of IFN-γ in response to purified protein derivative of M.tb. Administration of anti-IL-10 Ab partly inhibited the suppressive effect of pretreatment with peptide 234–252 on the development of AA. Furthermore, transfer of a T cell line specific for the epitope at the time of AA induction markedly suppressed AA. These findings suggested that T cells recognizing peptide 234–252 may play a regulatory role in inflammation during AA via the production of suppressive cytokines including IL-10.

Effects of stress on susceptibility and severity of inflammation in adjuvant-induced arthritis

We have utilized the open field and learned helplessness (LH) models of psychological stress to determine whether a differential response to stress can affect the severity of adjuvant-induced arthritis (AA) within a single rat strain. In response to open field stress, the corticosterone response of the low emotivity rats was significantly lower than that of the high emotivity rats. In spite of the differential corticosterone response to stress, no significant difference was found in paw volumes between the AA high and low emotivity groups. In another study, rats were subjected to a learned LH paradigm and separated into two groups based on failed (LH+) or successful (LH-) avoidance. Plasma corticosterone levels in response to avoidable foot shock in the LH- rats were significantly greater than in the LH+ group. Following injection with adjuvant, paw inflammation occurred earlier and was more severe in the LH- rats compared to the LH+ group. These data show that rats with a greater tendency to avoid foot shock have more severe inflammation, despite having a greater corticosterone response to stress. We conclude that an increased corticosterone response to stress does not affect susceptibility to or severity of inflammation in AA. Indeed, in the LH model a more robust response to stress is associated with increased inflammation and earlier onset of the disease.

A role for mast cells in the development of adjuvant-induced vasculitis and arthritis

The objective of this study was to characterize the role of mast cells in the development of vasculitis and joint swelling in adjuvant-immunized rats. Leukocyte trafficking within mesenteric venules (rolling and adhesion) and mast cell activation (ruthenium red uptake) were examined in vivo. Elevated leukocyte trafficking was observed by 4 days after immunization, whereas joint swelling developed between days 10 and 12. Perivascular mast cells took up ruthenium red and appeared activated by electron microscopy at 4 but not 12 days after immunization. Treatment with the mast cell stabilizer cromolyn on days 1 to 4 after immunization blocked ruthenium red uptake at day 4 and reduced leukocyte rolling and adhesion by approximately 50%. This treatment also reduced rolling, adhesion, and joint swelling at day 12 by approximately 50%. Cromolyn treatment over days 9 to 12 reduced joint swelling but increased leukocyte emigration into the mesentery. Peritoneal mast cells isolated 4 days after immunization elicited significant neutrophil chemotaxis in vitro, whereas day 12 mast cells did not. Mast cell activation and vasculitis were absent in adjuvant-resistant Fisher/344 rats. These data suggest that mast cells play an early role in the initiation of vasculitis and may function by day 12 to limit infiltration of leukocytes from the vasculature. In the joint, however, mast cells appear to contribute to inflammation at early as well as later time points.

Neuroendocrine-immune interactions in homeostasis and autoimmunity

Recent experimental evidence confirms the interrelationships between the central nervous, neuroendocrine and immune systems. Indeed, extensive duality exists in the use of neurotransmitters, hormones and receptors each system displays. In the present annotation, the effect of cytokines, soluble mediators of immune function, on the CNS and neuroendocrine systems is addressed and conversely, we discuss the modification of the immune compartment by the sympathetic nervous and neuroendocrine systems, with particular reference to the role of noradrenaline and corticosterone. Dysfunction between the systems is considered in the context of autoimmune conditions, with emphasis on experimental allergic encephalomyelitis and the contribution of corticosterone-driven T-cell apoptosis to recovery from the disease. Finally, we speculate on the relevance of neuroimmune interactions in the pathogenesis of multiple sclerosis.

Susceptibility to adjuvant arthritis: relative importance of adrenal activity and bacterial flora

Previous studies on the regulation of bacterial-induced arthritis in rats have focused on endocrine aspects as well as differences in T cell immunity against bacterial epitopes. We analysed the role of both adrenal activity and bacterial flora in determining susceptibility to bacterial-induced arthritis. Outbred Wistar rats show a low incidence of adjuvant arthritis. Moderate sensitivity to adjuvant arthritis was found in a selected, stress-resistant line of the Wistar rat, whereas no arthritis was found in a stress-susceptible Wistar line. Plasma corticosterone responses after IL-1 alpha exposure were, however, identical in these two lines, excluding a direct correlation between susceptibility and corticosterone levels. In line with previous findings in germ-free (GF) F344 rats, GF Wistars also appeared highly susceptible to arthritis. We further analysed the corticosterone responses in GF and conventional (CV) rats. Administration of IL-1 alpha induced identical corticosterone responses in both CV and GF F344 rats. In addition, plasma corticosterone levels were measured around the time of onset of arthritis. Whereas no rise was seen in the arthritis-resistant CV rats, a significant increase was observed from day 14 in GF rats, at the moment of onset of arthritis. Although this corticosterone response was insufficient to prevent arthritis, it may have ameliorated disease expression in the GF F344 rats. Our data indicate that the bacterial flora, and therefore T cell tolerance, is of prime importance in determining susceptibility, whereas the activity of the hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis may modulate disease severity.