The cytochrome P450 aromatase lacking exon 5 is associated with a phenotype of nonclassic aromatase deficiency and is also present in normal human steroidogenic tissues

46,XX aromatase deficiency: A single-center experience with the varied spectrum and recurrent variants, and a systematic review of hormonal parameters

BACKGROUND

Aromatase deficiency is a rare disorder, with only a few cases reported in India. We describe a single-center experience in western India, with a systematic review of genetically proven 46,XX aromatase deficiency patients to evaluate hormonal parameters.

METHODS

Retrospective review of case records, collating phenotypic and genotypic data and molecular modeling. Systematic review of 46,XX aromatase deficiency, analyzing data on gonadotropins, estrogen and androgens.

RESULTS

In the seven patients from our center, presentation was frequent in childhood or adolescence (4/7: delayed puberty or hyperandrogenism), with maternal virilization (4/7), predominance of Prader III/IV (5/7), and initial rearing as females (6/7). Three patients had hypoplastic ovaries. One patient had spontaneous regular menses. We report three novel (p.Arg115Pro, p.Arg192Pro, and c.145+1_145+4delins) and two recurrent variants (p.Val370Met, and c.145+1_145+4delins) in western and northern India, respectively. On systematic review (n=43), gonadotropins were elevated (FSH>LH) across ages (except preterm infants), androgens were elevated in about one-third of cases during childhood and puberty, and estradiol was lower than in controls in mini-puberty and puberty. Spontaneous thelarche and streak ovaries were significantly more frequent in patients with non-truncating and truncating variants, respectively.

CONCLUSION

We report uncommon presentations with possible founder variants, and highlight hormonal parameters across ages. Serum FSH levels were elevated except in preterms, and can be used as a diagnostic marker.

Differences in SCN1A intronic variants result in diverse aberrant splicing patterns and are related to the phenotypes of epilepsy with febrile seizures

OBJECTIVE

Intronic variants of the SCN1A gene are detected in patients with epilepsy with febrile seizures (EFS), which includes a series of phenotypes with different severities. However, the pathogenicity of intronic variants and their genotype-phenotype correlation remain under characterized. The purpose of this study was to determine the changes in mRNA splicing caused by SCN1A intronic variants associated with EFS and their association with phenotypes.

METHODS

Five SCN1A intronic variants detected in patients with focal epilepsy with antecedent febrile seizures plus (FEFS+) and Dravet syndrome (DS) were molecularly cloned. Through an in vitro minigene splicing assay, their influence on mRNA splicing was qualitatively and quantitatively compared and analyzed using reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) and fluorescence quantitative PCR (Q-PCR).

RESULTS

The severe phenotype of DS-associated variants c.602 + 1G > A and c.4853-1G > C, which occurred in canonical splice sites of introns, caused exon skipping and little retention of full-length mRNA, while the milder phenotype of FEFS+-associated variants c.473 + 5G > A, c.473 + 5G > C and c.4853-25T > A, which occurred in potential splice sites or in deep intronic regions, presented partial exon skipping or intronic insertion and significantly higher retention of full-length mRNA at different levels. Full-length mRNA retention was negatively correlated with the location of intronic variants and phenotype severity.

CONCLUSION

The different aberrant splicing patterns resulting from SCN1A intronic variants with different positions represent a potential molecular mechanism for phenotypic differences in EFS. This research provides valuable clues for functional studies on the pathogenicity of intronic variants and for the evaluation of genotype-phenotype correlations.

Novel CYP19A1 Mutations Extend the Genotype-Phenotype Correlation and Reveal the Impact on Ovarian Function

Context

The steroidogenic enzyme aromatase (CYP19A1) is required for estrogen biosynthesis from androgen precursors in the ovary and extragonadal tissues. The role of aromatase, and thus estrogens, is best illustrated by genetic variations of the CYP19A1 gene leading to aromatase deficiency or excess.

Objective

The objective of this work is to characterize novel CYP19A1 variants.

Design setting and patients

Variants causing aromatase deficiency were suspected in four 46,XX children of African and Indian origin by careful clinical phenotyping. Sequencing of the CYP19A1 gene identified novel variants. Minigene experiments, aromatase activity assay, and computational, and histological analysis were used to characterize the variants.

Main outcome measure and results

CYP19A1 variants were found in all patients: a deletion in intron 9 leading to p.P423_H503del, a delins variant at p.P154, and point variants p.V161D, p.R264C, p.R375C. Except for R264C, all variants showed a loss of function. Protein structure and dynamics studies were in line with functional assays. The 2 female patients with delins variants manifested with ambiguous genitalia at birth. Histologic investigation revealed normal ovarian tissue on one side and a streak gonad on the other. Two female patients presented with abnormal pubertal development and polycystic ovaries.

Conclusion

In girls, aromatase deficiency usually manifests at birth, but diagnosis may also be made because of abnormal pubertal development or ovarian torsion due to (poly)cystic ovaries. The ovary harboring CYP19A1 variants may present as streak gonad or appears normal at birth, but is then at very high risk to produce cysts with aging and is therefore prone to ovarian torsion.

Differential effects of variations in human P450 oxidoreductase on the aromatase activity of CYP19A1 polymorphisms R264C and R264H

Aromatase (CYP19A1) converts androgens into estrogens and is required for female sexual development and growth and development in both sexes. CYP19A1 is a member of cytochrome P450 family of heme-thiolate monooxygenases located in the endoplasmic reticulum and depends on reducing equivalents from the reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate via the cytochrome P450 oxidoreductase coded by POR. Both the CYP19A1 and POR genes are highly polymorphic, and mutations in both these genes are linked to disorders of steroid biosynthesis. We have previously shown that R264C and R264H mutations in CYP19A1, as well as mutations in POR, reduce CYP19A1 activity. The R264C is a common polymorphic variant of CYP19A1, with high frequency in Asian and African populations. Polymorphic alleles of POR are found in all populations studied so far and, therefore, may influence activities of CYP19A1 allelic variants. So far, the effects of variations in POR on enzymatic activities of allelic variants of CYP19A1 or any other steroid metabolizing cytochrome P450 proteins have not been studied. Here we are reporting the effects of three POR variants on the aromatase activities of two CYP19A1 variants, R264C, and R264H. We used bacterially expressed and purified preparations of WT and variant forms of CYP19A1 and POR and constructed liposomes with embedded CYP19A1 and POR proteins and assayed the CYP19A1 activities using radiolabeled androstenedione as a substrate. With the WT-POR as a redox partner, the R264C-CYP19A1 showed only 15% of aromatase activity, but the R264H had 87% of aromatase activity compared to WT-CYP19A1. With P284L-POR as a redox partner, R264C-CYP19A1 lost all activity but retained 6.7% of activity when P284T-POR was used as a redox partner. The R264H-CYP19A1 showed low activities with both the POR-P284 L as well as the POR-P284 T. When the POR-Y607C was used as a redox partner, the R264C-CYP19A1 retained approximately 5% of CYP19A1 activity. Remarkably, The R264H-CYP19A1 had more than three-fold higher activity compared to WT-CYP19A1 when the POR-Y607C was used as the redox partner, pointing toward a beneficial effect. The slight increase in activity of R264C-CYP19A1 with the P284T-POR and the three-fold increase in activity of the R264H-CYP19A1 with the Y607C-POR point toward a conformational effect and role of protein-protein interaction governed by the R264C and R264H substitutions in the CYP19A1 as well as P284 L, P284 T and Y607C variants of POR. These studies demonstrate that the allelic variants of P450 when present with a variant form of POR may show different activities, and combined effects of variations in the P450 enzymes as well as in the POR should be considered when genetic data are available. Recent trends in the whole-exome and whole-genome sequencing as diagnostic tools will permit combined evaluation of variations in multiple genes that are interdependent and may guide treatment options by adjusting therapeutic interventions based on laboratory analysis.

Estrogens in Human Male Gonadotropin Secretion and Testicular Physiology From Infancy to Late Puberty

Several reports in humans as well as transgenic mouse models have shown that estrogens play an important role in male reproduction and fertility. Estrogen receptor alpha (ERα) and beta (ERβ) are expressed in different male tissues including the brain. The estradiol-binding protein GPER1 also mediates estrogen action in target tissues. In human testes a minimal ERα expression during prepuberty along with a marked pubertal up-regulation in germ cells has been reported. ERβ expression was detected mostly in spermatogonia, primary spermatocytes, and immature spermatids. In Sertoli cells ERβ expression increases with age. The aromatase enzyme (cP450arom), which converts androgens to estrogens, is widely expressed in human tissues (including gonads and hypothalamus), even during fetal life, suggesting that estrogens are also involved in human fetal physiology. Moreover, cP450arom is expressed in the early postnatal testicular Leydig cells and spermatogonia. Even though the aromatase complex is required for estrogen synthesis, its biological relevance is also related to the regulation of the balance between androgens and estrogens in different tissues. Knockout mouse models of aromatase (ArKO) and estrogen receptors (ERKOα, ERKOβ, and ERKOαβ) provide an important tool to study the effects of estrogens on the male reproductive physiology including the gonadal axis. High basal serum FSH levels were reported in adult aromatase-deficient men, suggesting that estrogens are involved in the negative regulatory gonadotropin feedback. However, normal serum gonadotropin levels were observed in an aromatase-deficient boy, suggesting a maturational pattern role of estrogen in the regulation of gonadotropin secretion. Nevertheless, the role of estrogens in primate testis development and function is controversial and poorly understood. This review addresses the role of estrogens in gonadotropin secretion and testicular physiology in male humans especially during childhood and puberty.

46,XX DSD due to Androgen Excess in Monogenic Disorders of Steroidogenesis: Genetic, Biochemical, and Clinical Features

The term 'differences of sex development' (DSD) refers to a group of congenital conditions that are associated with atypical development of chromosomal, gonadal, or anatomical sex. Disorders of steroidogenesis comprise autosomal recessive conditions that affect adrenal and gonadal enzymes and are responsible for some conditions of 46,XX DSD where hyperandrogenism interferes with chromosomal and gonadal sex development. Congenital adrenal hyperplasias (CAHs) are disorders of steroidogenesis that mainly involve the adrenals (21-hydroxylase and 11-hydroxylase deficiencies) and sometimes the gonads (3-beta-hydroxysteroidodehydrogenase and P450-oxidoreductase); in contrast, aromatase deficiency mainly involves the steroidogenetic activity of the gonads. This review describes the main genetic, biochemical, and clinical features that apply to the abovementioned conditions. The activities of the steroidogenetic enzymes are modulated by post-translational modifications and cofactors, particularly electron-donating redox partners. The incidences of the rare forms of CAH vary with ethnicity and geography. The elucidation of the precise roles of these enzymes and cofactors has been significantly facilitated by the identification of the genetic bases of rare disorders of steroidogenesis. Understanding steroidogenesis is important to our comprehension of differences in sexual development and other processes that are related to human reproduction and fertility, particularly those that involve androgen excess as consequence of their impairment.

Aromatase deficiency in a male patient - Case report and review of the literature

OBJECTIVE

Aromatase, or CYP19A1, is a type II cytochrome CYP450 enzyme that catalyzes the conversion of C19 androgens to C18 estrogens. Its crucial role in both female and male physiology has been deduced from human and animal studies using aromatase inhibitors, genetically altered mice, and patients with aromatase deficiency. The latter is an extremely rare disorder. Its diagnosis is particularly difficult in males, who go through puberty normally and therefore usually present as adults with elevated testosterone, bone abnormalities (e.g., delayed bone age and low bone mass), and metabolic syndrome. In this report, we describe a new case of a male patient with aromatase deficiency harboring a known mutation who presented with less severe clinical and biochemical features.

CASE REPORT

The patient presented with low bone mass and delayed bone age after a finger fracture at age 25years. FSH, LH and testosterone levels were normal, but estradiol and estrone levels were absent or barely detectable, raising suspicion for aromatase deficiency. A homozygous c.628G>A mutation in exon 5 was confirmed by direct sequencing. Unlike previously reported cases of aromatase deficiency, he did not display biochemical features of insulin resistance, dyslipidemia, or overweight/obese status. Therapy with estradiol led to the closure of growth plates and a dramatic increase in bone mass.

CONCLUSIONS

Here we explore genotype/phenotype associations of this new case compared to cases reported previously. We conclude that the specific nature of mutation c.628G>A, which can potentially result in several different forms of the aromatase enzyme, may lend an explanation to the variable phenotypes associated with this particular genotype.

An Intron 9 CYP19 Gene Variant (IVS9+5G>A), Present in an Aromatase-Deficient Girl, Affects Normal Splicing and Is Also Present in Normal Human Steroidogenic Tissues

BACKGROUND/AIMS

Splicing CYP19 gene variants causing aromatase deficiency in 46,XX disorder of sexual development (DSD) patients have been reported in a few cases. A misbalance between normal and aberrant splicing variants was proposed to explain spontaneous pubertal breast development but an incomplete sex maturation progress. The aim of this study was to functionally characterize a novel CYP19A1 intronic homozygote mutation (IVS9+5G>A) in a 46,XX DSD girl presenting spontaneous breast development and primary amenorrhea, and to evaluate similar splicing variant expression in normal steroidogenic tissues.

METHODS

Genomic DNA analysis, splicing prediction programs, splicing assays, and in vitro protein expression and enzyme activity analyses were carried out. CYP19A1 mRNA expression in human steroidogenic tissues was also studied.

RESULTS

A novel IVS9+5G>A homozygote mutation was found. In silico analysis predicts the disappearance of the splicing donor site in intron 9, confirmed by patient peripheral leukocyte cP450arom and in vitro studies. Protein analysis showed a shorter and inactive protein. The intron 9 transcript variant was also found in human steroidogenic tissues.

CONCLUSIONS

The mutation IVS9+5G>A generates a splicing variant that includes intron 9 which is also present in normal human steroidogenic tissues, suggesting that a misbalance between normal and aberrant splicing variants might occur in target tissues, explaining the clinical phenotype in the affected patient.

A Novel Null Mutation in P450 Aromatase Gene (CYP19A1) Associated with Development of Hypoplastic Ovaries in Humans

OBJECTIVE

The CYP19A1 gene product aromatase is responsible for estrogen synthesis and androgen/estrogen equilibrium in many tissues, particularly in the placenta and gonads. Aromatase deficiency can cause various clinical phenotypes resulting from excessive androgen accumulation and insufficient estrogen synthesis during the pre- and postnatal periods. In this study, our aim was to determine the clinical characteristics and CYP19A1 mutations in three patients from a large Turkish pedigree.

METHODS

The cases were the newborns referred to our clinic for clitoromegaly and labial fusion. Virilizing signs such as severe acne formation, voice deepening, and clitoromegaly were noted in the mothers during pregnancy. Preliminary diagnosis was aromatase deficiency. Therefore, direct DNA sequencing of CYP19A1 was performed in samples from parents (n=5) and patients (n=3).

RESULTS

In all patients, a novel homozygous insertion mutation in the fifth exon (568insC) was found to cause a frameshift in the open reading frame and to truncate the protein prior to the heme-binding region which is crucial for enzymatic activity. The parents were found to be heterozygous for this mutation. Additionally, all patients had hypoplastic ovaries instead of cystic and enlarged ovaries.

CONCLUSION

A novel 568C insertion mutation in CYP19A1 can lead to severe aromatase deficiency. Homozygosity for this mutation is associated with the development of hypoplastic ovaries. This finding provides an important genetic marker for understanding the physiological function of aromatase in fetal ovarian development.

Progesterone and estradiol in cat placenta--biosynthesis and tissue concentration

Ovarian and placental steroids are essential for the maintenance of pregnancy. In some mammals it is evident that the placenta is responsible for the production of steroids. However, in the domestic cat, steroid secretion from the placenta has not yet been elucidated. Our study aimed to find out whether feline placentae are able to produce steroids. Placentae from different pregnancy stages were analyzed for mRNA expression of five steroidogenic enzymes (HSD3B1, CYP11A1, CYP17A1, HSD17B1 and CYP19A1) and for tissue concentrations of progesterone and estradiol. Steroidogenic enzymes responsible for the final steps of estradiol (CYP19A1) and progesterone synthesis (HSD3B) were expressed at very high levels and followed almost the same pattern over pregnancy as the intraplacental hormones themselves. By contrast, the other enzymes were found in very low quantities suggesting that biosynthesis occurs via extra-placental steroid precursors. The plasma steroid profiles measured by other groups differ from the placental hormone courses determined by us; therefore we conclude that the feline placenta can produce progesterone and estradiol.

Aromatase deficiency in men: a clinical perspective

Human aromatase deficiency is a very rare syndrome characterized by congenital estrogen deprivation that is caused by loss-of-function mutations in CYP19A1, which encodes aromatase. Here, we review the presentation, diagnosis and treatment of aromatase deficiency in men to provide useful advice for clinical management of the condition. At presentation, all men with aromatase deficiency have tall stature, delayed bone maturation, osteopenia or osteoporosis and eunuchoid skeletal proportions. Diagnosis of the condition is supported by the presence of unfused epiphyses and undetectable serum estradiol levels; the condition can be further substantiated by genetic sequencing of CYP19A1. Transdermal estradiol treatment at a daily dose of about 25 microg might be adequate for lifelong replacement therapy. BMD and levels of serum estradiol, luteinizing hormone and testosterone should be monitored carefully and considered powerful biochemical markers of adequate estrogen substitution in clinical practice. Early diagnosis is important to initiate estrogen therapy as soon after puberty as possible to avoid the skeletal complications that are associated with this condition.

Aromatase expression in the normal human adult adrenal and in adrenocortical tumors: biochemical, immunohistochemical, and molecular studies

OBJECTIVE

The aromatase enzyme catalyzes the final stage of estrogen biosynthesis pathway from androgens. Its expression in the adrenal is poorly studied except for the rare estrogen-producing adrenocortical tumors. In order to further characterize aromatase expression in the adrenal, we evaluated the aromatase enzyme activity, Cyp19a1 gene expression level, and promoter utilization in normal adrenal tissues and in adrenocortical secreting tumors.

DESIGN AND METHODS

Six normal adult adrenals (NA), 2 feminizing adrenal tumors (FT), 10 cortisol-producing adenomas with overt (CS, n=4) or sub-clinical Cushing syndrome (SCS, n=6) and 3 aldosterone-producing adenomas (APA) were studied. Tissue aromatase activity was determined by the tritiated ((3)H)-water method. Total aromatase mRNA were measured by a competitive RT-PCR. Promoter regions PII and PI.4-derived transcripts were also studied in NA, FT, and other steroid-producing tumors by a semi-quantitative comparative RT-PCR. Immunofluorescence analysis was performed in normal human adrenal tissues.

RESULTS

Aromatase activity was detected in NA tissues and in all tumor subtypes, at high levels in both FT. In NA, aromatase immunofluorescence was detected in the cytoplasm of steroidogenic cells, mainly from zona reticularis. Compared with NA, aromatase transcript levels were similar in CS and APA, lower in SCS and similar or higher in FT. Promoter analysis suggested predominant PII utilization in NA, APA, and SCS, but similar PII and PI.4 utilization in CS tumors.

CONCLUSION

Aromatase is expressed at similar levels in normal adrenal and in adrenocortical tumors, but at variably high levels in FT. Different promoter utilization patterns are found among tumor subtypes.

A novel mutation in the human aromatase gene: insights on the relationship among serum estradiol, longitudinal growth and bone mineral density in an adult man under estrogen replacement treatment

OBJECTIVE

Here we report on a new case of human aromatase deficiency in a man of 26 years of age and present the results of five year follow-up during trandermal estradiol (tE2) substitution, focusing on bone growth and mineralization. The lack of patient's compliance to tE2 treatment, resulting in low but detectable serum estradiol levels, provides helpful information about the physiological estradiol needed in serum to guarantee a complete bone maturation and mineralization.

DESIGN

Clinical case report study.

METHODS

Genetic, biochemical and hormonal evaluations and the study of bone health were performed before and during estrogen treatment.

RESULTS

Eunuchoid body proportions, unfused epiphyses, tall stature, osteopenia, increase fasting insulin, mild astenozoospermia and a history of right cryptorchidism were present. Baseline serum FSH was slightly above the normal range and estradiol was undetectable. Genetic analysis revealed a pattern of compound heterozygosity due to 23 bp deletion in exon IV and a point mutation in the first nucleotide of intron IX of the CYP19A1 gene, respectively. The closure of epiphyseal cartilage, the normalization of bone BMD and bone turnover markers, and the improvement of insulin levels were reached during tE2 only when serum estradiol raised above 73 pmol/L. Sperm parameters and overweight did not improve with substitutive therapy.

CONCLUSIONS

This new case of aromatase deficiency underlines the role of estrogen on skeletal maturation, BMD, metabolic abnormalities and gonadal axis. It provides evidence on the need not only of a continuous estrogen replacement, but also of ensuring adequate estradiol levels in serum in order to ensure a complete bone maturation and mineralization and to prevent the worsening of body skeletal proportions. The comprehension of this physiological aspect has relevant clinical significance especially for the development of new therapeutic strategies useful to treat growth disorders by targeting serum estradiol in men.