Variation in factor VIII inhibitor reactivity with different commercial factor VIII preparations

Plasma-derived FVIII/VWF complex shows higher protection against inhibitors than isolated FVIII after infusion in haemophilic patients: A translational study

Introduction

Presence of von Willebrand factor (VWF) in FVIII concentrates offers protection against neutralizing inhibitors in haemophilia A (HA). Whether this protection is more evident in plasma‐derived (pd) FVIII/VWF or recombinant (r) FVIII concentrates remains controversial.

Aim

We investigated the protection exerted by VWF against FVIII inhibitors in an in vivo mouse model of HA exposed to pdFVIII/VWF or to various rFVIII concentrates.

Methods

Haemophilia A mice received the different FVIII concentrates after administration of vehicle or an inhibitory IgG purified from a commercial pool of HA plasma with inhibitors and FVIII:C recoveries were measured. Furthermore, using a novel clinically oriented ex vivo approach, Bethesda inhibitory activities (BU) of a commercial pool of HA plasma with inhibitors were assessed using normal plasma, or plasma from severe HA patients, without inhibitors, after treatment with the same concentrates.

Results

in vivo studies showed that pdFVIII/VWF offers markedly higher protection against inhibitors when compared with any of the FVIII products without VWF. More importantly, in the ex vivo studies, plasma from patients treated with pdFVIII/VWF showed higher protection against inhibitors (P values ranging .05‐.001) in comparison with that observed in plasma from patients who received FVIII products without VWF, regardless of the type of product evaluated.

Conclusion

Data indicate that FVIII+VWF complexes assembled in the circulation after rFVIII infusion are not equivalent to the naturally formed complex in pdFVIII/VWF. Therefore, rFVIII infused into HA patients with inhibitors would be less protected by VWF than the FVIII in pdFVIII/VWF concentrates.

FVIII/VWF complex displays a greater pro-haemostatic activity than FVIII preparations devoid of VWF: Study in plasma and cell-based models

INTRODUCTION

Plasma-derived FVIII/VWF complex was reported to be less sensitive to inhibitors than FVIII preparations devoid of VWF.

AIM

To compare the efficacy of FVIII/VWF complex (Fanhdi) and five different VWF-free FVIII preparations in restoring thrombin generation and activation of thrombin-activatable fibrinolysis inhibitor (TAFI) in haemophilic plasma, with and without inhibitor, and in cell-based models.

METHODS

Experiments were performed in haemophilic plasma supplemented with inhibitory IgG or in plasma samples obtained from haemophilia A patients without (n = 11) and with inhibitor (n = 12). Thrombin generation was evaluated by calibrated automated thrombography (CAT) under standard conditions, in the presence of activated protein C (APC) or thrombomodulin (TM), and in cell-based models including endothelial cells, either alone or in combination with platelets or tissue factor-expressing blood mononuclear cells. The kinetics of TAFI activation was determined by a two-stage functional assay in the absence and in the presence of APC.

RESULTS

In haemophilic plasma without inhibitor, Fanhdi enhanced thrombin generation and TAFI activation as well as recombinant (2nd-4th generation) and plasma-derived FVIII preparations devoid of VWF. On the contrary, in plasma with inhibitor, Fanhdi displayed a greater ability to restore thrombin generation and TAFI activation under all tested conditions. Notably, in cell-based models including endothelial cells, Fanhdi proved more efficient than all other preparations in improving thrombin generation even in the absence of inhibitor.

CONCLUSION

The greater pro-haemostatic activity of FVIII/VWF complex, either in haemophilic plasma with inhibitor or in the presence of endothelial cells, may offer therapeutic advantages.

Current and emerging factor VIII replacement products for hemophilia A

Hemophilia A is a congenital X-linked bleeding disorder caused by coagulation factor VIII (FVIII) deficiency. Routine infusion of factor replacement products is the current standard of care; however, the development of alloantibodies against FVIII remains a challenge. The treatment of hemophilia has undergone major advances over the past century to improve safety, effectiveness, manufacturing, and convenience of factor products. Major recent advances in the treatment of hemophilia A include the emergence of extended half-life products, factor VIII orthologs, and gene therapy products. Extended half-life products were designed to decrease the frequency of infusions, but only modest half-life extension is achieved. Factor VIII orthologs featuring lower cross-reactivity with anti-FVIII antibodies may be less susceptible to inactivation by inhibitors. Meanwhile, gene therapy may potentially provide a cure for hemophilia A, thus abrogating the need for protein-based factor replacement. This review aims to discuss current and emerging FVIII replacement products for hemophilia A.

Plasma-derived versus recombinant factor concentrates in PUPs: a never ending debate?

Inhibitor development in haemophilia is a serious complication to treatment with factor concentrates. Since the advent of more pure products, especially developed using recombinant DNA technology, some studies have shown an increased incidence of inhibitors in previously untreated patients (PUPs) receiving recombinant products whereas plasma-derived concentrates sometimes have been claimed to have a protective role, probably due to the content of von Willebrand factor (VWF). In fact, experiments indicate that the VWF may block uptake of factor VIII into macrophages for further processing to the immune system. Also, a competition between VWF and inhibitor binding to the C2 domain of factor VIII has been suggested. Recently, large cohort and surveillance studies have created a vigorous debate about the role of product class for inhibitor development as results have been conflicting. The only randomised prospective study, the SIPPET study, was published in 2016, and substantiated previous reports claiming that plasma derived concentrates give less inhibitors in patients with severe haemophilia A, previously not exposed to factor VIII. The debate will continue.

First prospective report on immune tolerance in poor risk haemophilia A inhibitor patients with a single factor VIII/von Willebrand factor concentrate in an observational immune tolerance induction study

INTRODUCTION/BACKGROUND

Development of neutralizing inhibitors against factor VIII (FVIII) is a major complication of haemophilia A treatment.

AIM

The ongoing, international, open-label, uncontrolled, observational immune tolerance induction (ObsITI) study evaluates ITI, the standard of care in patients with inhibitors.

PATIENTS/METHODS

Forty-eight prospective patients in this interim analysis received a single plasma-derived, von Willebrand factor-stabilized, FVIII concentrate (pdFVIII/VWF) for ITI. According to recommended Bonn protocol, 'low responders' at ITI start (<5 BU) received 50-100 IU FVIII kg(-1) daily, or every other day; 'high responders' (≥5 BU) received 100 IU FVIII kg(-1) every 12 h.

RESULTS

Forty of 48 patients (83.3%), had at least one risk factor for poor ITI-prognosis at ITI start (i.e. age ≥7 years, >2 years since inhibitor diagnosis, inhibitor titre ≥10 BU at the start of ITI, or prior ITI failure). Nonetheless, 34 patients (70.8%) achieved complete success, 3 (6.3%) partial success, 1 (2.1%) partial response; ITI failed in 10 patients (20.8%), all with poor prognosis factors. All six low responders achieved complete success. ITI outcome was significantly associated with inhibitor titre level at ITI start (P = 0.0068), number of poor prognosis factors for ITI success (P = 0.0187), monthly bleeding rate during ITI (P = 0.0005) and peak inhibitor titre during ITI (P = 0.0007). Twenty-two of 35 high responder patients (62.9%) with ≥1 poor prognosis factor achieved complete success.

CONCLUSION

Treatment with a single pdFVIII/VWF concentrate, mainly according to the Bonn protocol, resulted in a high ITI success rate in haemophilia A patients with inhibitors and poor prognosis for ITI success.

Novel investigations on the protective role of the FVIII/VWF complex in inhibitor development

Development of inhibitory antibodies to infused factor VIII (FVIII) concentrates is the most serious unresolved complication of haemophilia A treatment. Systematic reviews suggest a twofold higher incidence of inhibitors with recombinant (rFVIII) vs. plasma-derived (pdFVIII) FVIII products, but study methodologies vary widely. The lower immunogenicity of pdFVIII concentrates is believed to derive from the presence of von Willebrand factor (VWF) which acts as protector and chaperone for FVIII. Several novel investigations reinforce the protective role of the VWF/FVIII complex in inhibitor development. At the basic science level, numerous in vitro and in vivo experiments have demonstrated that VWF-containing pdFVIII concentrates (pdFVIII/VWF) provide better protection against inhibitor neutralization than rFVIII products. Conformational aspects of the binding between VWF and FVIII are thought to prevent the 'attack' on FVIII by inhibitory antibodies. VWF/FVIII binding is 100% in pdFVIII products but only 80% in recombinant products and this 'free' FVIII may be a target for inhibitory antibodies. At the clinical level, newer strategies to prevent inhibitor development in previously untreated patients with severe haemophilia are under investigation. The concept of early prophylaxis (before the onset of a bleed) is convincing from a theoretical point of view but requires further evaluation. The Study on Inhibitors in Plasma-Product Exposed Toddlers is specifically addressing the issue of relative immunogenicity between classes of FVIII product (recombinant vs. plasma-derived). Currently nearing its target enrolment of 300 patients, this international randomized controlled trial is expected to provide some definitive answers about this ever-present clinical dilemma.

New predictive approaches for ITI treatment

Immune tolerance induction (ITI) therapy in patients with haemophilia A and inhibitors constitutes a huge burden for affected patients and families and poses a large economic burden for a chronic disease. Concerted research efforts are attempting to optimize the therapeutic approach to the prevention and eradication of inhibitors. The Italian ITI Registry has provided data on 110 patients who completed ITI therapy as at July 2013. Analysis of independent predictors of success showed that, together with previously recognized factors - namely inhibitor titre prior to ITI, historical peak titre and peak titre on ITI - the type of causative FVIII gene mutation also contributes to the identification of patients with good prognosis and may be useful to optimize candidate selection and treatment regimens. Numerous studies have demonstrated that inhibitor reactivity against different FVIII products varies and is lower against concentrates containing von Willebrand factor (VWF). An Italian study compared inhibitor titres against a panel of FVIII concentrates in vitro and correlated titres with the capacity to inhibit maximum thrombin generation as measured by the thrombin generation assay (TGA). Observations led to the design of the PredictTGA study which aims to correlate TGA results with epitope specificity, inhibitor reactivity against different FVIII concentrates and clinical data in inhibitor patients receiving FVIII in the context of ITI or as prophylactic/on demand treatment. At the immunological level, it is known that T cells drive inhibitor development and that B cells secrete FVIII-specific antibodies. As understanding increases about the immunological response in ITI, it is becoming apparent that modulation of T-cell- and B-cell-mediated responses offers a range of potential new and specific approaches to prevent and eliminate inhibitors as well as individualize ITI therapy.

Native plasma-derived FVIII/VWF complex has lower sensitivity to FVIII inhibitors than the combination of isolated FVIII and VWF proteins. Impact on Bethesda assay titration of FVIII inhibitors

Sensitivity to FVIII inhibitors of the native plasma-derived (pd) FVIII/VWF complex vs. the complexes formed after exogenous FVIII infusion in the haemophilic patient has not been thoroughly studied. The role of VWF in the interaction of FVIII with inhibitors was studied in vitro using different combinations of VWF and FVIII concentrates. Normal plasma, pdFVIII/VWF and isolated FVIII (recombinant FVIII, B-domain deleted and pdFVIII) were used. Titre (BU) was kinetically determined (up to 2 h) in serial dilutions of inhibitor IgG (purified from a pool of plasmas with inhibitors) mixed with VWF and then incubated with the different FVIII. Inhibitor was also added to previously mixed VWF+FVIII. Residual FVIII:C was determined. TGA assays were performed with FVIII-deficient plasma spiked with the FVIII-VWF mixtures with/without an ESH-8 antibody. Inhibitor titres for plasma and pdFVIII/VWF were comparable at all time points. Titres for all concentrates of isolated FVIII were significantly higher than those for plasma or pdFVIII/VWF (1.4–1.9 fold) even after preincubation with VWF. At t = 0 h, titres for plasma or pdFVIII/VWF were unquantifiable, but were detectable for isolated FVIII (0.6–1.6 BU). In contrast to pdFVIII/VWF, the decrease in thrombin generation parameters by isolated FVIII in the presence of ESH-8 was significant (P < 0.01) even when previously combined with VWF. In conclusion, VWF protection against FVIII inhibitor activity might be higher with native pdFVIII/VWF complex than with the corresponding compound formed from the isolated proteins. Bethesda assay titration using different FVIII concentrates would be advisable to guide the treatment of inhibitor patients.

Management of bleeding disorders: basic science

Development of factor VIII (FVIII) inhibitors is the most severe and challenging complication of haemophilia A treatment and represents the highest economic burden for a chronic disease. Therefore, major research efforts are ongoing to optimize the therapeutic approaches able to minimize this complication. FVIII inhibitors have variable immuno-reactivity against different FVIII concentrates and generally have a lower reactivity against von Willebrand factor (VWF)-containing FVIII concentrates than plasma-derived FVIII (pdFVIII) or recombinant FVIII (rFVIII) that are devoid of VWF, in particular when the inhibitors are directed against the light chain of FVIII. This paper provides an overview of several in vitro and in vivo studies that compared three clinically available clinical FVIII products (Kogenate®, Bayer AG, Leverkusen, Germany; Advate®, Baxter Healthcare, Zurich, Switzerland; and Fanhdi®, Grifols S.A., Barcelona, Spain) in order to evaluate the functional actvity of the FVIII fractions in rFVIII that cannot bind VWF; explore the use of the thrombin generation assay (TGA) as a potential tool for optimizing the choice of FVIII concentrate for use in haemophilia A patients with inhibitors; compare the kinetics of the interactions between anti-FVIII antibodies and FVIII both in the presence/absence of VWF, using surface plasmon resonance.

Thrombin generation assay: a useful routine check-up tool in the management of patients with haemophilia?

Severity assessment of patients with haemophilia A (HA) is traditionally based on FVIII activity (FVIII:C). Clinical phenotype of HA patients often differs between individuals with the same FVIII:C determined with clotting and chromogenic assays. The aim of this study was to assess the influence of the FVIII:C on thrombin generation (TG) assay parameters both in vitro and ex-vivo postinfusion plasma. For in-vitro approach, influence of FVIII:C was evaluated on TG parameters in several dilutions of a normal plasma pool with commercial FVIII-depleted-plasma (FVIIIDP) and in others experiments, adding increasing amounts of different commercial FVIII concentrates (Fanhdi, Haemate-P, Hemofil-M and Kogenate Bayer) to FVIIIDP. In a series of 50 postinfusion samples, from HA patients of different severity, we assayed TG and FVIII:C (chromogenic and clotting). In vitro experiments, the 50% of maximum TG peak (TGMP) was achieved using only 5% FVIII:C and the TGMP was obtained with 40% of normal VIII:C. Impaired response compared with normal plasma was found in FVIIIDP using addition of increasing amounts of different commercial FVIII concentrates. An overall good correlation between the two FVIII assays was observed (y = 0.9115x - 0.273, r = 0.975, P < 0.001); TGMP and the Lag-Phase-Time (LPT) provided some discrepant results when compared with the total range of FVIII:C measurements. In contrast, correlations for TGMP, LPT and endogenous thrombin potential were improved in samples restricted to FVIII:C <5%. We conclude that TG parameters tentatively could be a tool to tailor the global haemostatic capacity in haemophilic patients.

Haemate P von Willebrand factor/factor VIII concentrate: 25 years of clinical experience

Although von Willebrand disease (VWD) has a very long history, our understanding and treatment of the bleeding disorder has only evolved during the past 50 years or so. It was not until the 1920s that VWD was first recognized as a disease separate from that of classical haemophilia. It then took another 30 years before the first effective treatment was developed. Since then, the medical management of VWD has evolved considerably, but not without its ups and downs. One of the key milestones in the evolution of the treatment of VWD was the development of Haemate P/Humate-P (CSL Behring) - the first virus-inactivated factor VIII plasma product. For 25 years, this concentrate has demonstrated excellent clinical efficacy and safety for patients with VWD and for those with haemophilia. This article provides an historical overview of the early landmark efforts to ensure a safe plasma-derived replacement product and outlines the clinical evolution in the use of Haemate P.

A systematic overview of the first pasteurised VWF/FVIII medicinal product, Haemate P/ Humate -P: history and clinical performance

Patients with von Willebrand disease (VWD) and haemophilia A (HA) lack, to varying degrees, the von Willebrand factor (VWF) and coagulation factor VIII (FVIII) that are critical for normal haemostasis. These conditions in turn make patients prone to uncontrolled bleeding. Historically, patients with severe forms of VWD or HA were crippled before adulthood and their life expectancy was significantly reduced. Over the past decades, specific coagulation factor replacement therapies including Haemate P, have been developed to help patients achieve and maintain normal haemostasis. Haemate P is a human, plasma-derived VWF/FVIII medicinal product, which was first licensed in Germany in 1981 for the treatment of HA-associated bleeding. It has since then come to be accepted as the gold standard for both the treatment and prophylaxis of bleeding in VWD, especially in cases where desmopressin [1-deamino-8-D-arginine vasopressin (DDAVP)] has been ineffective. Haemate P was the first effectively virus-inactivated (pasteurisation: 60 degrees C for 10 h in aqueous solution) FVIII product, whereby the risk of potentially threatening infective complications of plasma-derived products was reduced. Haemate P was also shown to have a VWF multimer profile remarkably close to that of normal plasma. This bibliographic review presents previously unpublished clinical data of Haemate P, based upon internal clinical study reports of the proprietor, CSL Behring, in addition to data already presented in other publications. The data demonstrate a predictable and well-characterised pharmacokinetic profile, and a proven record of short- and long-term safety, while effectively correcting the haemostatic defects in VWD and HA. Recently available data have also shown Haemate P to be of haemostatic value in exceptional clinical circumstances including surgical interventions. By virtue of its plasma-derived combination of VWF and FVIII, in addition to its high VWF:FVIII content ratio (2.4:1), Haemate P is also associated with successful immune tolerance induction in those patients developing inhibitor antibodies. Although the theoretical risk of thromboembolic complications does exist while receiving Haemate P, as it does with any FVIII replacement therapy, the incidence of such complications has remained notably low. Given the robust data that have accumulated for the use of Haemate P, dosing recommendations are also described in this review; the recommendations are tailored to patient-specific contexts including baseline VWF and FVIII levels in plasma and the type of surgical intervention being undertaken. A wide variety of studies have also provided data on paediatric and geriatric populations, all of which have suggested that Haemate P can be safely and effectively used in a wide variety of clinical circumstances.

VWF/FVIII concentrates in high-risk immunotolerance: the RESIST study

Immune tolerance induction (ITI), through the regular infusion of coagulation factor concentrates over a time period ranging from 1 to more than 24 months, is successful in about 75% of high responders. Among the issues of ITI treatment that are still open, the choice of the product to use is one of the most difficult. In fact, common practice is to start with the same product that induced the inhibitory response, but recent findings indicated that plasma-derived products containing large amounts of von Willebrand factor (VWF) can play a positive role. Two retrospective cohorts in Germany and in France and one prospective cohort have shown a high rate of success when VWF/factor VIII (FVIII) products are used to induce ITI. For these reasons, two prospective studies have been planned to complement the international ITI study already started: an observational study in patients who had already experienced a failure with a VWF-free FVIII concentrate, called RESIST(exp) (experienced); a randomized, controlled study in patients who have never tried an ITI treatment before and at high risk to fail, called RESIST(naïve) (naïve).

Impact of different inhibitor reactivities with commercial factor VIII concentrates on thrombin generation

In order to describe the haemostatic role of a variation in inhibitor reactivity with different factor VIII (FVIII) concentrates, we have compared inhibitor titres against a panel of FVIII concentrates and correlated titre with the capacity to inhibit thrombin generation. Three plasma-derived concentrates were tested in vitro in mixing experiments with inhibitor plasmas from 11 patients with severe haemophilia A: Fanhdi, which contains von Willebrand factor (VWF) with a final ratio of approximately 1:1 (VWF IU per IU FVIII:C); Haemate-P with a ratio of 2.5:1 and Hemofil-M containing only trace amounts of VWF. In addition, the recombinant FVIII concentrate Kogenate Bayer containing no VWF was included. Inhibitor titres and the capacity to generate thrombin were measured. A statistically significant difference in measured titres was found with the highest titres recorded against Hemofil-M. The inhibitor titres needed to inhibit 50% maximum thrombin generation were the lowest for Kogenate Bayer and the highest and similar for Fanhdi and Haemate-P with intermediate titres needed for inhibition of Hemofil-M. In this study, the thrombin generation assay provides additional indications for the role of VWF in the treatment of patients with inhibitors. The VWF-containing concentrates Fanhdi and Haemate-P, added to FVIII-deficient plasma with the presence of inhibitor, generate more thrombin than do the purified concentrates Hemofil-M and Kogenate Bayer.

Recombinant versus plasma-derived factor VIII products and the development of inhibitors in previously untreated patients with severe hemophilia A: the CANAL cohort study

It has been suggested that plasma-derived factor VIII products induce fewer inhibitors than recombinant factor VIII products. We investigated the relationship of factor VIII product type and switching between factor VIII products with the risk to develop inhibitors. This multicenter retrospective cohort study included 316 patients with severe hemophilia A born between 1990 and 2000. The outcome was clinically relevant inhibitor development, defined as the occurrence of at least 2 positive inhibitor titers with decreased recovery. The risk of inhibitor development was not clearly lower in plasma-derived compared with recombinant factor VIII products (relative risk [RR], 0.8; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.5-1.3). Among high-titer inhibitors, the possible reduction in risk was even less pronounced (RR, 0.9; CI, 0.5-1.5). Plasma-derived products with considerable quantities of von Willebrand factor (VWF) carried the same risk for inhibitor development as recombinant factor VIII products (RR, 1.0; CI, 0.6-1.6). Switching between factor VIII products did not increase the risk for inhibitors (RR, 1.1; CI, 0.6-1.8). In conclusion, our findings support neither the notion that plasma-derived factor VIII products with considerable concentrations of VWF confer a lower risk to develop inhibitory antibodies than recombinant factor VIII products, nor that switching between factor VIII product brands increases inhibitor risks in previously untreated patients with severe hemophilia A.

Immune tolerance induction with a high purity von Willebrand factor/VIII complex concentrate in haemophilia A patients with inhibitors at high risk of a poor response

Immune tolerance induction (ITI) is effective in approximately 70% of haemophilia patients with inhibitors. Poor prognostic factors are age >6 years, ITI started >1 year from inhibitor development, inhibitor peaks >200 BU, inhibitor titre >10 BU when ITI is started and previously failed ITI. The objective of this study was to identify the effectiveness in ITI of a high purity von Willebrand factor/factor VIII (VWF/FVIII) complex concentrate in inhibitor patients at high risk of failure. Patients with severe or moderate haemophilia A and high responding inhibitors who had at least one poor prognostic factor for ITI failure were prospectively followed-up. Success was defined by undetectable inhibitor, recovery and half life >66% of expected values. ITI dose regimens were chosen by each haemophilia centre. Seventeen haemophiliacs (16 severe, one moderate), aged 4-54 years (median 23) were followed-up for 6-71 months. Poor prognostic factors were delayed-onset ITI (n = 16), age >6 years (n = 16), previously failed ITI (n = 4), inhibitor peak >200 BU (n = 2) and inhibitor >10 BU when ITI was started (n = 4). Complete success was obtained in nine patients (53%) after 4-30 months of treatment (median 24), including two of four patients who had previously failed ITI. Seven patients achieved a partial success, with sustained low inhibitor titres (median 1.5 BU, range 1.1-2.8) but abnormal recovery and/or half-life, while the remaining patient withdrew ITI after 12 months when the inhibitor titer was still 70 BU. These findings suggest that high purity VWF/FVIII complex concentrates are effective in ITI, even in patients at high risk of failure.

Human Plasma von Willebrand Factor/Factor VIII Complex (Haemate?? P/Humate-P??)

Haemate P/Humate-P is a pasteurised human plasma-derived concentrate containing coagulation factor VIII and a near-normal spectrum of von Willebrand factor multimers, including high-molecular weight multimers, for intravenous use in patients with von Willebrand disease or haemophilia A. Extensive clinical experience over the past 25 years has shown that Haemate P/Humate-P provides effective haemostatic control for the prevention and treatment of bleeds in patients with these conditions, with no confirmed cases of viral or prion transmission occurring during this time. In small prospective and retrospective noncomparative studies, Haemate P/Humate-P provided effective haemostatic control for the prevention and treatment of bleeding episodes in the vast majority of paediatric and adult patients with von Willebrand disease. Haemate P/Humate-P was generally well tolerated in patients with von Willebrand disease or haemophilia A.

Mechanisms of action of immune tolerance induction against factor VIII in patients with congenital haemophilia A and factor VIII inhibitors

In its most severe form, haemophilia A is a life-threatening haemorrhagic bleeding disorder that is caused by mutations in the factor VIII (FVIII) gene. About 25% of patients who receive replacement therapy with intravenous FVIII products develop neutralising antibodies (FVIII inhibitors) that inhibit the function of substituted FVIII. Long-term application of high or low doses of FVIII has evolved as an effective strategy for eradicating antibodies and inducing long-lasting immune tolerance. Despite clinical experience with the therapy, little is known about the immunological mechanisms that cause the down modulation of FVIII-specific immune responses or the induction of long-lasting immune tolerance against FVIII. This review summarises current knowledge of the immunological mechanisms that might be involved in the induction of immune tolerance against FVIII in patients with haemophilia A who have FVIII inhibitors. In addition to data from patients with haemophilia A, data from patients who have had organ transplants or have immune-related disorders, such as autoimmune diseases, are considered as well as data from animal models.

Inhibitor treatment in haemophilias A and B: inhibitor diagnosis

The clinical diagnosis and quantitative measurement of polyclonal IgG inhibiting antibodies are the subjects of this review. Inhibitors in congenital haemophilia are usually diagnosed either as part of a routine surveillance schedule or following a bleeding episode that responds poorly to standard specific replacement therapy. Routine surveillance schedules for paediatric haemophilia A patients during high-risk incidence periods are variable and the subject of ongoing discussion. There have never been any published recommendations for following haemophilia B patients at high risk for inhibitor development. The Factor VIII/IX Subcommittee of the International Society on Thrombosis and Haemostasis scientifically endorsed the Nijmegen method for inhibitor measurement in 1996. However, there are many unresolved issues surrounding inhibitor diagnosis using these assays. These issues include: (i) questions of accuracy and inter-assay variability inherent to the one-stage clotting assay; (ii) lack of consensus regarding the assay cut-off for negative determination; (iii) lack of assay standardization and (iv) the clinical importance of capturing non-neutralizing antibodies currently not measured in the functional assays. Ongoing efforts to resolve these issues will be discussed.

Options for treating acute bleeds in addition to bypassing agents: extracorporeal immunoadsorption, FVIII/FIX, desmopressin and antifibrinolytics

Inhibitor patients do not always respond satisfactorily to treatment with bypassing agents, and options to the standard practice are sometimes needed. Temporary inhibitor removal may be achieved using extracorporeal immunoadsorption. This technique uses a column system including either protein A or antihuman IgG. Immunoadsorption may be used as part of an immune tolerance protocol, or in the case of acute bleeds or prior to surgery, thus rendering the patient more responsive to ordinary replacement therapy with factor VIII or factor IX. Desmopressin is a valuable haemostatic agent in many situations and can be especially recommended in mild haemophilia complicated by an inhibitor. Antifibrinolytics are often administered as an adjunct therapy to the treatment protocol and have also been reported to have a direct anti-inhibitor effect.

Role of von Willebrand factor in immune tolerance induction

Patients with hemophilia who develop inhibitors present a particular challenge in therapeutic management. Although such patients are at high risk for severe bleeding episodes, the optimal treatment approach--prophylaxis--is ineffective unless inhibitors are eliminated. Several protocols for immune tolerance induction have been used. Success rates may vary depending both on patient variables and on factors related to the therapeutic regimen, including concentrate purity and von Willebrand factor (VWF) content. Several in vitro studies testing inhibitor plasma samples against various factor VIII (FVIII) concentrates have shown lower FVIII inhibitor titer compared with concentrates with greater VWF content. Recent in vivo observations also support the importance of VWF content, based on evidence of reduced rates of success of immune tolerance induction with use of the high-purity FVIII products that became available in the early 1990s. Current data thus support use of FVIII concentrates containing VWF in immune tolerance induction; other variables may also contribute to the relative success of this treatment. Studies are needed to delineate these variables in order to improve management of this potentially devastating complication of hemophilia treatment.

Impact of inhibitor epitope profile on the neutralizing effect against plasma-derived and recombinant factor VIII concentrates in vitro

The inhibitory capacity of plasma samples from 24 patients with severe haemophilia A and high-responding inhibitors were evaluated in a concentrate-based assay using two plasma-derived (Haemate and Monoclate-P) and three recombinant (Helixate, Recombinate and ReFacto) factor VIII concentrates and correlated with the corresponding epitope profile. In most, but not all, inhibitor plasmas with a relatively low reactivity against the von Willebrand-containing product Haemate, the main epitopes were located in the FVIII light chain. The reactivities within the group of recombinant products varied in that the reactivity against the B-domain deleted ReFacto was in general higher than that against Recombinate and Helixate. This difference did not correlate with any particular epitope profile and indicates that the B-domain, type of formulation and/or purification procedures may have an impact on the inhibitor reactivity in vitro. The ratio between the inhibitor titres in the concentrate-based assay and the Bethesda assay was dependent on the inhibitor plasma and concentrate used. Taken together, our results show that the reactivity of inhibitor plasmas varies considerably between different FVIII concentrates and that it does not fully correlate with the epitope profile. Potential clinical implications of the observed differences in inhibitor reactivity are discussed.

Characterization of inhibitors to FVIII with an ELISA in congenital and acquired haemophilia A

Different methods can be used for the detection and quantification of inhibitors or antibodies to coagulation factor VIII (FVIII). Traditionally, clotting assays have been used, in particular the Bethesda assay. These assays have, however, several shortcomings, due to the complex reaction kinetics of some inhibitors and a low sensitivity to low-titre antibodies. In addition, a universal FVIII inhibitor standard is lacking. Furthermore, clotting assays do not detect noninhibitory antibodies. Use of ELISAs has been described and FVIII from various commercially available FVIII concentrates has been used as target antigen in the assays. In the present study, we systematically explored the influence of different FVIII concentrates on the performance of an ELISA for detection of FVIII antibodies. The described ELISA was also used for further characterization of FVIII inhibitors in patients with acquired and congenital haemophilia A. We found that the source of FVIII had a substantial impact on the frequency of antibody detection. Albumin-free recombinant FVIII as target antigen gave the highest sensitivity for the assay, whereas plasma-derived concentrates containing a high level of von Willebrand factor (vWF) gave the lowest sensitivity. Presumably vWF interferes with the binding of antibodies to FVIII. We suggest that albumin-free recombinant FVIII should be used as target antigen when ELISAs are used for detection of FVIII antibodies.

Acquired hemophilia

Acquired hemophilia is a serious coagulopathy usually affecting the elderly, persons with autoimmune disorders and, infrequently, women in the immediate postpartum period. It is due to autoantibodies directed against specific domains of the factor VIII molecule, leading to inhibition of factor VIII binding to von Willebrand factor, to activated factor IX or to negatively charged phospholipids. This results in bleeding into the skin, muscles, gastrointestinal and genitourinary tracts, and other sites. Mixing patient plasma with normal plasma prolongs the activated partial thromboplastin time of the normal plasma and the Bethesda assay provides a quantitative estimate of the strength of the inhibitor. The selection of therapeutic concentrates for the management of acute bleeding is related to the titer of the inhibitor; if less than 5 Bethesda Units, human factor VIII may be effective, but higher titer inhibitors usually respond only to porcine factor VIII, recombinant factor VIIa or activated prothrombin complex concentrates. Corticosteroid treatment leads to disappearance of the autoantibody in 50% of patients; cyclophosphamide and cyclosporine are effective in many who do not respond to steroids. Occasionally, high dose intravenous immunoglobulin or immunosorbent columns transiently decrease inhibitor titers and enable control of bleeding. Other autoantibodies have been described against factors V, VII, XI and, rarely, factor XIII and prothrombin. New approaches in the management of autoimmune disease and, especially, methods to establish tolerance are in development.

Influence of von Willebrand factor on the reactivity of human factor VIII inhibitors with factor VIII

In order to determine the difference in reactivity of factor (F) VIII inhibitors against the FVIII/von Willebrand factor (vWF) complex and against vWF-deficient FVIII, we investigated a panel of 10 antibodies to FVIII from multitransfused individuals with severe haemophilia A and other pathologies. Immunoblotting of purified FVIII and purified thrombin-cleaved FVIII revealed that in all cases inhibitor epitopes could be localized in the heavy chain (A2 subunit) while in four cases they were also present in the light chain. One of the FVIII inhibitors remained unclassified. The effect on FVIII:C of purified IgG from inhibitor plasmas was tested against a high purity FVIII/vWF concentrate and a monoclonally purified FVIII concentrate with only trace contents of vWF, by two different functional assays. Our results suggest that for those inhibitors showing A2 plus light chain (LC) reactivity, the IgG concentration required to inhibit 50% of FVIII activity in vitro is higher for the FVIII/vWF complex than for the vWF-deficient FVIII. We conclude that there might be a protective role of vWF (at least in vitro) against FVIII inhibitors with A2 and LC subunit specificity.

von Willebrand factor in factor VIII concentrates protects against neutralization by factor VIII antibodies of haemophilia A patients

We investigated the neutralization activity of factor VIII (FVIII) antibodies of 12 haemophilia A patients, acquired during treatment with plasma-derived FVIII concentrates. All plasma samples, drawn in a clinically stable situation before any immunotolerance treatment, contained anti-A2 domain and anti-light-chain FVIII antibodies. In nine patients' plasmas, containing relatively high amounts of FVIII light-chain antibodies (53-96%), a higher neutralization activity was found against recombinant FVIII concentrate (Recombinate) than against plasma-derived von Willebrand factor (vWF)-containing concentrate (Haemoctin SDH). No difference in neutralization of the two concentrates was found in two patients' plasmas with almost equal content of FVIII light- and heavy-chain antibodies, or one plasma with predominantly heavy-chain antibodies. These results suggest that haemophilia A patients with relatively high amounts of FVIII light-chain antibodies in plasma might benefit by infusion of FVIII concentrates containing vWF because vWF appears to have some protective effect on FVIII. This hypothesis should be tested by a clinical study.

Immune tolerance treatment in haemophilia patients with inhibitors: the Spanish Registry

We present a retrospective study of immune tolerance treatment (ITT) carried out in 42 Spanish haemophiliac patients. Most of the patients were high responders (39/42), with a median maximum titre of 67 Bethesda units (BU) (range 6-2984). The median inhibitor titre at the start the ITT was 11 BU (range 1-256 BU) and the median age of the patients was 7 years (range 0-57). The mean factor dosage was 140 IU kg bodyweight(-1) day(-1) (range 25-500). In most of the ITTs, plasma-derived factor concentrate of intermediate and high purity was used. The inhibitor was eradicated in 26/38 (68%) of the patients who completed the treatment and two patients changed their status from high to low responders. Multivariate logistic regression analysis showed that three significant variables were associated with the highest probability of success: (i) the use of low factor doses for ITT (< or = 100 IU kg(-1) day(-1); P = 0.0106; 95% CI 0.000289-0.342); (ii) a titre of < 10 BU at start of ITT (P = 0.0286; 95% CI 0.00253-0.7189) and (iii) a lower maximum titre (P = 0.0214; 95% CI 0.98-0.9994).

Immune tolerance induction: recombinant vs. human-derived product

The ultimate goal in the treatment of high-responding inhibitors in congenital haemophilia is to induce immune tolerance (IT). Since the advent of highly purified factor VIII products, especially recombinant ones, the issue has been raised of whether the type of product has an impact on treatment success. It is clear that IT induction is possible to achieve with both recombinant products and human-derived products, but there is a lack of comparative studies. Different theoretical aspects indicate that human-derived concentrate, especially of low purity, and with a high content of von Willebrand factor, may have a better tolerizing effect.

The Malmö model for immune tolerance induction: impact of previous treatment on outcome

Ten patients, who had been treated according to the Malmö model for immune tolerance induction (ITI), were analysed regarding treatment with clotting factors and chemotherapy during the time period between inhibitor detection and ITI. Of the patients who were successfully rendered tolerant (n=6) all but one had received treatment with FVIII, either alone (n=1), or combined with cyclophosphamide (n=4). Of the patients who did not become tolerant, three of four had received treatment with FVIII during the inhibitor period but only one with FVIII and chemotherapy. The total amount of treatment received was in general much lower in the group that did not become tolerant. In individual cases, it appeared very clear that the inhibitor level and anamnestic response was substantially reduced prior to the ITI using the Malmö treatment model. We conclude that treatment of acute bleeds during the inhibitor period may be of importance for ITI and that the different response rates published for different immune tolerance regimens most likely do not reflect the true response rate for the respective regimen.

Variation in inhibitor reactivity in acquired haemophilia A with different concentrates

Acquired haemophilia A due to the development of auto-antibodies directed against factor VIII (FVIII) is a rare disorder that may result in serious haemorrhagic episodes. Although in many cases no associated underlying disorders are apparent, the condition has been reported in association with autoimmune disorders, haematological malignancies, treatment with certain drugs and pregnancy. The reaction kinetics of auto-antibodies to FVIII differ from those observed with allo-antibodies in congenital haemophilia. Previous studies in congenital haemophilia have raised the possibility that inhibitory antibodies vary in their reactivity with the factor VIII molecules in different concentrates used for treatment. However, the interaction of FVIII in concentrates and inhibitors in acquired haemophilia has never been previously studied. In this study, the effect of different FVIII concentrates was studied on neutralization in vitro by performing inhibitor titres using the New Oxford inhibitor assay method. The inhibitor titre in eight patients with acquired haemophilia A was assayed against five commercially available FVIII concentrates of varying purity. The intermediate purity concentrate 8Y and the high purity concentrate that contains normal amounts of von Willebrand's Factor (vWF) (Alphanate) gave lower titres than the high purity concentrates with low (Monoclate-P) or no (Kogenate) von Willebrand content. All but one antibody had very low reactivity with porcine FVIII. Further work will be required to establish whether concentrates manifesting a low level of in vitro reactivity with the inhibitor have a better haemostatic effect in vivo.

Primary prophylaxis in severe haemophilia should be started at an early age but can be individualized

The frequency of joint bleeds and orthopaedic joint scores were evaluated in 121 patients with severe haemophilia who had started prophylactic treatment with clotting factor concentrates at least once weekly before the age of 10. 75 of the patients started before the age of 3, 31 at the age of 3-5 and 15 at the age of 6-9. Each subgroup was evaluated separately. In addition, a regimen of one infusion weekly was compared with that of two (haemophilia B) or three (haemophilia A) infusions weekly in each patient. A significant decrease in the overall number of joint bleeds per year was found after shortening the infusion interval (P<0.005), but the individual bleeding pattern varied. In survival analysis of the first pathologic joint score event, those who started prophylaxis before the age of 3 had a better outcome overall than those starting at later ages (P=0.001). However, in subgroup analysis, no significant difference was seen in the annual number of joint bleeds and the development of arthropathy between those starting with, or shifting to, the more intensive regimen before the age of 3 and those that were put on this regimen at the age of 3-5. Age at start of prophylaxis was found to be an independent predictor for the development of arthropathy (P=0.0002), whereas dose and infusion interval at start were not. Our data emphasize the importance of starting replacement therapy during the first years of life. However, it seems that when beginning the regimen it can be individualized and adjusted according to the bleeding pattern. In this way, the need for a venous access system may be assessed on an individual basis.

The Malmö-Klaipeda WFH twinning programme: a comparative description of the haemophilia cohorts

In 1994, the Malmö-Klaipeda twinning programme was approved by the World Federation of Hemophilia. One of the first steps in the collaboration has been to set up a registry of the haemophilia patients in the Klaipeda area. In order to collect important clinical data the patients have been examined jointly by experts on haemophilia from the two centres. Seventeen out of 25 patients with severe haemophilia known at the Klaipeda centre were examined and compared to a matched cohort of patients from the Malmö centre. The main differences between the cohorts were that home treatment was not available to the Klaipeda patients, they received less treatment in general, had higher joint scores and more frequent bleeds. The pattern of transmission of blood-borne virus was very similar, with a high prevalence of hepatitis C antibodies. We conclude that the twinning programme between Malmö and Klaipeda has resulted in several achievements, including training of staff and a necessary inventory of the patients. This should not only form a suitable platform for the future development of haemophilia care in Lithuania, but could also serve as an example for liaisons between other haemophilia centres.