Hyalinizing trabecular adenoma-like lesion in multinodular goitre

Hyalinizing Trabecular Adenoma of the Thyroid. Report of two Cases, with Cytologic, Immunohistochemical and Ultrastructural Studies

The cytologic, histologic, immunocytochemical and ultra-structural features of 2 cases of hyalinizing trabecular adenoma (HTA) of the thyroid are described. The difficulty of a cytologic diagnosis and the need for an immunohistochemical profile of the lesions for a final histologic diagnosis are emphasized.

The ultrasonography features of hyalinizing trabecular tumor of the thyroid are more consistent with its benign behavior than cytology or frozen section readings

BACKGROUND

Hyalinizing trabecular tumors of the thyroid (HTT) is a rare entity. Most behave as benign neoplasms, but their cytological features are challenging and can be similar to those of papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC). The aim of this study was to compare the ultrasonography (US) readings of HTT with the cytology and frozen section readings.

METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed the US and cytology features in 10 patients (mean age, 47.5 years, range 26-81; M:F, 1:9) seen between March 2006 and November 2009 who had a histopathological diagnosis of HTT. The US findings were categorized according to the size, shape, margin, echogenicity, echotexture, presence of hypoechoic halo, and microcalcifications. Preoperative fine-needle aspiration cytology, frozen section results, and surgical treatment were reviewed. US features of HTT were compared with those of other tumors including follicular adenomas, follicular variant of PTCs, and conventional PTC.

RESULTS

Out of the 10 patients in our series, 7 underwent total thyroidectomy, and 3 had lobectomy. The sizes of the HTTs ranged from 0.6 to 4.2 cm (mean, 1.77 cm). The most common US features were solid texture (10/10), oval to round shape (10/10), a well-defined aspect (10/10), hypoechoic character (8/10), heterogeneous character (7/10), the presence of a hypoechoic halo (8/10), and no microcalcifications (10/10). The US diagnosis was indeterminate in all but one case and that was read as a benign lesion. As far as the shape and margin US features were concerned, HTT was considered to be most similar to follicular adenomas and follicular variant of PTC, but not to classical PTC. The cytology reading was PTC in 6 of 10 cases, suspicious for PTC in 2, and a HTT versus PTC in 2. The histological diagnosis of frozen sections, when performed, was PTC in three, HTT in three, medullary thyroid carcinoma in two, and deferred in one.

CONCLUSION

HTT often appears similar to follicular neoplasm on US, but it can be misjudged on cytology as PTC, even in frozen sections. HTT should be included in the list of discordant US-cytology readings of thyroid tumors. This rare tumor might be suspected more often preoperatively by careful attention to cytology in the context of the US reading.

Hyalinizing trabecular tumors of the thyroid gland are almost all benign

In 1987, Carney et al reported 11 thyroid tumors with the following features: circumscription or encapsulation, trabecular architecture with intratrabecular hyalin and colloid, polygonal and spindle cells, nuclei with frequent grooves and cytoplasmic inclusions, occasional psammoma bodies, and a low mitotic rate. The neoplasms did not recur or metastasize during a follow-up period that averaged 10 years, and they were titled hyalinizing trabecular adenomas. Subsequently, the nuclear features of the neoplasm led to the introduction of 2 modified titles for it, hyalinizing trabecular tumor and hyalinizing trabecular neoplasm. Later, discovery of RET/PTC mutations in the tumor resulted in it being designated as a type of papillary thyroid carcinoma. We studied 119 neoplasms of the type outlined, collected over a 20-year period, for invasion, recurrence and metastasis, and obtained follow-up in 96% of the cases. One hundred eighteen tumors showed no evidence of aggressive behavior (capsular, vascular, and parenchymal invasion), local recurrence, or metastasis. One tumor showed vascular and capsular invasion, and pulmonary metastasis. We conclude that the overwhelming majority of hyalinizing trabecular tumors of the thyroid behave as benign neoplasms and that, at this time, hyalinizing trabecular adenoma is the most appropriate title for them.

Hyalinizing trabecular adenoma—an uncommon thyroid tumor frequently misdiagnosed as papillary or medullary thyroid carcinoma

BACKGROUND

Hyalinizing trabecular adenoma (HTA) is an uncommon benign thyroid tumor that can present as a solitary thyroid nodule, a prominent nodule in a multinodular goiter, or as an incidental finding in a thyroidectomy specimen. The clinical significance of the lesion is that it is frequently misdiagnosed as papillary carcinoma on fine-needle aspiration cytology or as papillary or medullary carcinoma on histopathological section. We reviewed our recent experience with 7 patients diagnosed with HTA.

METHODS

Fine-needle aspiration biopsy was performed in 7 patients presenting with a solitary thyroid nodule (n = 4) or a multinodular goiter (n = 3). The patients underwent total thyroidectomy (n = 6) or hemithyroidectomy (n = 1).

RESULTS

In 4 patients, the preoperative cytology was suggestive of papillary carcinoma, in 2 patients suspicious, and in 1 patient positive for papillary carcinoma. On histopathological section, 2 patients had a microscopic HTA, 2 patients had HTA in 1 or 2 nodules of a multinodular goiter, and 3 patients had HTA in a solitary nodule. Except in 1 patient, who had a microscopic focus (3.2 mm) of papillary carcinoma, there was no evidence of malignancy in the surgical specimens on permanent histopathological section.

CONCLUSIONS

Although HTA is a rare condition of the thyroid, the surgeon needs to be aware of this entity to be able to better discuss the pathological findings with the patient, particularly since some pathologists and endocrinologists believe that HTA may represent a malignant neoplasm of low metastatic potential.

Lack of BRAF mutations in hyalinizing trabecular neoplasm

The hyalinizing trabecular neoplasm (HTN) of the thyroid is an unusual and controversial lesion. Some consider it a peculiar type of papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC) because of its nuclear features and presence of psammoma bodies. Others consider it an adenoma. Molecular studies have found RET/PTC translocations in some examples, supporting HTN as a PTC; however mutations in BRAF (another marker for PTC) have not been found.

We report two cases of classic HTN and a case of trabecular PTC and show BRAF mutations in the latter and not in HTN. Trabecular growth pattern is insufficient for a diagnosis of HTN and lesions with such a pattern and nuclear features of PTC are cancers. Morphologically classic HTN are not associated with metastatic potential and should be considered adenomas.

[Thyroid tumors]

The vast majority of thyroid tumours are epithelial. In contrast to thyroid adenoma, which is a common tumour, thyroid carcinomas make up only 1% of all human malignancies. Routine pathology is regularly confronted with a differential diagnosis involving thyroid adenoma and carcinoma, as well as particular variants of these tumours. This paper deals with the standardised gross and histological examination, as well as the impact of immunohistochemistry and intraoperative frozen sections on thyroid pathology.

Etiology and significance of the optically clear nucleus

Papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC) is diagnosed in both cytology and surgical pathology specimens on the basis of distinct nuclear morphology, characterized by nuclear elongation, chromatin clearing, intranuclear grooves, and inclusions. Although these nuclear features are specific to papillary carcinoma, they can be mimicked in some benign conditions. The majority of PTC cases do not pose diagnostic problems. However, a distinct subset of cases has generated controversy among experts. These cases are follicular patterned tumors that show minimal nuclear changes in PTC. Several investigators have explored the role of immunohistochemical markers in the histologic diagnosis of PTC. Somatic rearrangements of the RET protooncogene are the most frequent genetic abnormality found in PTC. The frequency of these rearrangements has varied according to the geographic region, radiation exposure, and methodologies used and histologic variant of PTC. Recent studies have suggested that RET/PTC may be the cause of this specific nuclear change in PTC; however, the role of RET/PTC in tumor progression still needs to be defined.

Hyalinizing trabecular adenoma of the thyroid diagnosed by fine-needle aspiration biopsy

Two cases of hyalinizing trabecular adenoma of the thyroid are presented. The diagnosis was established on initial assessment by fine-needle aspiration biopsy. Histologic evaluation of the surgical specimens confirmed the diagnosis of hyalinizing trabecular adenoma.

Thyroid pathologic findings in patients with Cowden disease

We describe the histologic findings in thyroid glands from six female and five male patients with Cowden disease. The patients were aged 9 to 43 years (mean age, 26 years). The salient thyroid lesions in this syndrome were multicentric follicular adenomas and adenomatous (parenchymatous, hyperplastic) nodules showing a wide range of nonspecific cytoarchitectural patterns. Multiple tiny cellular foci, so-called microadenomas, were also a feature. Specific lesions composed of oxyphil or clear cells, a tumor with features of hyalinizing trabecular adenoma, and an adenolipoma also occurred. Two cases showed a follicular carcinoma in addition to multiple benign follicular cell proliferations. The follicular carcinomas occurred at an older age and were larger in size than the clinically significant benign nodular lesions, suggesting tumor progression. All tumors showed thyroglobulin immunoreactivity and were negative for calcitonin. The histologic findings of a multiple adenomatous goiter or multiple follicular adenomas, particularly in children and young adults, should alert the pathologist and physician to the possibility of an inherited trait, such as Cowden disease, with its implications for family screening. The tumors are usually benign and well demarcated, but, because of multicentricity and increased risk of recurrence or progression to carcinoma, total thyroidectomy should be advocated.

Histology of familial thyroid tumours linked to a gene mapping to chromosome 19p13.2

This paper describes the pathology of thyroid tumours showing an autosomal mode of inheritance linked to a gene that maps to chromosome 19p13.2. All the affected members from the family (seven males and two females; mean age 23 years) were clinically euthyroid and presented with nodular goitre; tumour recurrence after thyroidectomy was observed in four. In four of the five patients studied, the tumours were multifocal, bilateral well demarcated or encapsulated and composed of follicles, papillae, trabeculae/solid areas (often resembling hyalinizing trabecular adenoma of the thyroid) or an admixture, formed by cells with pale to intense cytoplasmic eosinophilia. A diagnosis of multiple adenomatous goitre was made in the thyroidectomy specimen from two patients, while the other two patients showed, in addition to multiple adenomas, a co-existent oxyphil papillary carcinoma. The fifth patient had an oxyphil cell carcinoma. All tumours were of follicular cell origin as shown by immunocytochemistry. Less than a third of the benign tumours and all three carcinomas showed a variable number of neoplastic cells diffusely immunostained for mitochondria. Histological findings of a 'multiple adenomatous goitre', non-endemic 'multinodular goitre' or multiple neoplasms of follicular cell origin with the morphology of those described here, particularly in young patients, should alert the pathologist and physician to the possibility of an inherited trait, with its implications for family screening. The tumours are usually benign and well demarcated but because of multicentricity and consequently increased risk of recurrence and/or progression to carcinoma, total thyroidectomy should be advocated.

Hyalinizing trabecular carcinoma of the thyroid gland: report of two cases of follicular cell thyroid carcinoma with hyalinizing trabecular pattern

Recently tumors have been reported that have an architectural pattern and cellularity similar to hyalinizing trabecular adenoma and show either parafollicular differentiation or histological findings suggestive of malignant neoplasm of the follicular cells. This study describes two cases of thyroid carcinoma of follicular cells that displayed a hylinizing trabecular pattern. The first case was a 25-year-old euthyroid woman with a cold thyroid nodule in the right lobe. On fine needle aspiration a diagnosis of papillary carcinoma was rendered. The thyroidectomy disclosed a 2-cm, firm, brown, encapsulated tumor in the right lobe. The tumor had a growth pattern and cytologic features similar to those described in hyalinizing trabecular adenoma. The differences between these neoplasms were the presence of mitotic figures, prominence of the nucleolus, capsular blood vessel invasion, and microtubule groups in the endoplasmic reticulum. The second case was a 19-year-old euthyroid woman with a cold thyroid nodule in the left lobe. A cytologic diagnosis of follicular proliferation was rendered. A 4-cm, firm, whitish, encapsulated nodule was found in the left lobectomy. The tumor cells were arranged in two clear-cut patterns: a trabecular hyalinizing pattern with a small focus of papillary growth, and a follicular pattern. These findings confirm the existence of malignant thyroid tumors with a hyalinizing trabecular pattern and illustrate the nonspecificity of this peculiar pattern, since it may also be seen in papillary carcinomas of the thyroid. The relationship between hyalinizing trabecular adenoma and papillary carcinoma of the thyroid is commented on.

Paraganglioma-Like Adenomas of the Thyroid (PLAT): Incidental Lesions with Unusual Features in a Patient with Nodular Goiter

We discovered two well-demarcated nodules incidentally in a thyroid removed because of a nodular goiter. Histologically, the nodules showed a pattern of paraganglioma or so-called paraganglioma-like adenoma of the thyroid (PLAT), with lobules of polygonal and oval cells in a vascular stroma, but the immunohistochemical markers typical of paraganglioma, including chromogranin, synaptophysin, Leu 7 and 5-100, and thyroglobulin, characteristic of PLAT, were negative in the tumor cells. C-cell markers calcitonin and somatostatin were also negative. Stain for neuron-specific enolase (NSE), however, showed a distinctive pattern of reactivity within cells at the periphery of the lobules, whereas all tumor cells stained positively for keratins. Stain for carcinoembryonic antigen showed a focal interstitial pattern that corresponded to small intercellular spaces filled by microvilli identified ultrastructurally. This pattern of immunohistochemical staining has not been previously described in paraganglioma or in PLAT, and may have implications about the origin and nature of these controversial entities.

Paraganglioma-like (hyalinizing trabecular) adenoma of the thyroid revisited

The aim of the present study was to explore the association between paraganglioma-like adenomas of the thyroid (PLAT) and chronic lymphocytic thyroiditis (CLT) or Hashimoto's thyroiditis, and to discuss its possible relationship to papillary thyroid carcinoma. Six cases were analyzed by standard histopathological and immunohistochemical techniques. All 6 cases (all females) had clinical and/or histological evidence of CLT. Only one patient had 2 PLATs. The PLATs were devoid of inflammation and sharply demarcated from the surrounding CLT. There is cyto-morphological overlap with papillary thyroid carcinoma (nuclear grooves and pseudo-inclusions). We conclude that PLAT is associated with CLT more frequently than any other thyroid lesion, and feel that this is more than merely a chance association. PLAT shares several cytological features with papillary carcinoma and cases have been seen where they have occurred in the same thyroid. PLAT could therefore represent an unusual variant of papillary carcinoma.

Hyalinizing trabecular adenoma: A misnomer for a peculiar tumor of the thyroid gland

We describe the clinical, histological, immunohistochemical, and electron microscopical features of 9 tumors fulfilling the criteria of the so-called hyalinizing trabecular adenoma (HTA) of the thyroid. Six tumors had the characteristic histology of HTA throughout, whereas in the remaining 3 tumors the classic pattern was identified focally in otherwise typical or atypical follicular adenomas. In one case, there was a focus of tumoral tissue outside the capsule, and in another there was a regional lymph node metastasis. Seven tumors were immunoreactive for thyroglobulin and cytokeratins, 1 tumor was positive for thyroglobulin and negative for cytokeratins, and another was negative for thyroglobulin and positive for cytokeratins. Scattered cells immunoreactive for neurotensin and somatostatin were found in 2 cases. Every tumor stained for S100 protein and neuron-specific enolase, but none showed immunoreactivity for calcitonin, calcitonin gene-related peptide, or chromogranin. The irregularity of the nuclear contours, the prominence of the cytoplasmic bundles of intermediate filaments, and the accumulation of basal lamina material around the neoplastic cells without the interposition of a well-defined basal lamina were the most distinctive electron microscopical features. The cytogenetic study performed in one case revealed, apart from cells with a normal karyotype, two abnormal clones: one with a translocation of chromosomes 2-3 and another with the same translocation and trisomies of chromosomes 7 and 12. Our results show that most HTAs display follicular cell differentiation and very low clinical aggressiveness. They also show that some HTAs are able to coexpress follicular cell and neuroendocrine markers and may behave like malignant neoplasms. We conclude that hyalinizing trabecular tumor is a more appropriate generic term than HTA to designate this relatively heterogenous group of lesions of the thyroid gland.