An historical account of the development and applications of the negative staining technique to the electron microscopy of viruses

Negative-Stain Transmission Electron Microscopy of Molecular Complexes for Image Analysis by 2D Class Averaging

Negative-stain transmission electron microscopy (EM) is a technique that has provided nanometer resolution images of macromolecules for about 60 years. Developments in cryo-EM image processing have maximized the information gained from averaging large numbers of particles. These developments can now be applied back to negative-stain image analysis to ascertain domain level molecular structure (10 to 20 Å) more quickly and efficiently than possible by atomic resolution cryo-EM. Using uranyl acetate stained molecular complexes of influenza hemagglutinin bound to Fab 441D6, we describe a simple and efficient means to collect several hundred micrographs with SerialEM. Using RELION, we illustrate how tens of thousands of complexes can be auto-picked and classified to accurately describe the domain level topology of this unconventional hemagglutinin head-domain epitope. By comparing to the cryo-EM density map of the same complex, we show that questions about epitope mapping and conformational heterogeneity can readily be answered by this negative-stain method. © 2019 The Authors.

IgG Antibody 3D Structures and Dynamics

Antibodies are vital for human health because of their ability to function as nature's drugs by protecting the body from infection. In recent decades, antibodies have been used as pharmaceutics for targeted therapy in patients with cancer, autoimmune diseases, and cardiovascular diseases. Capturing the dynamic structure of antibodies and characterizing antibody fluctuation is critical for gaining a deeper understanding of their structural characteristics and for improving drug development. Current techniques for studying three-dimensional (3D) structural heterogeneity and variability of proteins have limitations in ascertaining the dynamic structural behavior of antibodies and antibody-antigen complexes. Here, we review current techniques used to study antibody structures with a focus on the recently developed individual-particle electron tomography (IPET) technique. IPET, as a particle-by-particle methodology for 3D structural characterization, has shown advantages in studying structural variety and conformational changes of antibodies, providing direct imaging data for biomolecular engineering to improve development and clinical application of synthetic antibodies.

Cellular structural biology as revealed by cryo-electron tomography

Understanding the function of cellular machines requires a thorough analysis of the structural elements that underline their function. Electron microscopy (EM) has been pivotal in providing information about cellular ultrastructure, as well as macromolecular organization. Biological materials can be physically fixed by vitrification and imaged with cryo-electron tomography (cryo-ET) in a close-to-native condition. Using this technique, one can acquire three-dimensional (3D) information about the macromolecular architecture of cells, depict unique cellular states and reconstruct molecular networks. Technical advances over the last few years, such as improved sample preparation and electron detection methods, have been instrumental in obtaining data with unprecedented structural details. This presents an exciting opportunity to explore the molecular architecture of both individual cells and multicellular organisms at nanometer to subnanometer resolution. In this Commentary, we focus on the recent developments and in situ applications of cryo-ET to cell and structural biology.

Viral taxonomy needs a spring clean; its exploration era is over

The International Committee on Taxonomy of Viruses has recently changed its approved definition of a viral species, and also discontinued work on its database of virus descriptions. These events indicate that the exploration era of viral taxonomy has ended; over the past century the principles of viral taxonomy have been established, the tools for phylogenetic inference invented, and the ultimate discriminatory data required for taxonomy, namely gene sequences, are now readily available. Further changes would make viral taxonomy more informative. First, the status of a ‘taxonomic species’ with an italicized name should only be given to viruses that are specifically linked with a single ‘type genomic sequence’ like those in the NCBI Reference Sequence Database. Secondly all approved taxa should be predominately monophyletic, and uninformative higher taxa disendorsed. These are ‘quality assurance’ measures and would improve the value of viral nomenclature to its users. The ICTV should also promote the use of a public database, such as Wikipedia, to replace the ICTV database as a store of the primary metadata of individual viruses, and should publish abstracts of the ICTV Reports in that database, so that they are ‘Open Access’.

Identification and characterization of Vibrio harveyi associated with diseased abalone Haliotis diversicolor

Mass mortality of farmed small abalone Haliotis diversicolor occurred in Fujian, China, from 2009 to 2011. Among isolates obtained from moribund abalones, the dominant species AP37 exhibited the strongest virulence. After immersion challenge with 106 CFU ml-1 of AP37, abalone mortalities of 0, 53 and 67% were induced at water temperatures of 20°C, 24°C, and 28°C, respectively. Following intramuscular injection, AP37 showed a low LD50 (median lethal concentration) value of 2.9 × 102 CFU g-1 (colony forming units per gram abalone wet body weight). The LT50 (median lethal time) values were 5.2 h for 1 × 106 CFU abalone-1, 8.4 h for 1 × 105 CFU abalone-1, and 21.5 h for 1 × 104 CFU abalone-1. For further analysis of virulence, AP37 was screened for the production of extracellular factors. The results showed that various factors including presence of flagella and production of extracellular enzymes, such as lipase, phospholipase and haemolysin, could be responsible for pathogenesis. Based on its 16S rRNA gene sequence, strain AP37 showed >98.8% similarity to Vibrio harveyi, V. campbellii, V. parahaemolyticus, V. alginolyticus, V. natriegens and V. rotiferianus, so it could not be identified by this method. However, multi-locus sequence analysis (MLSA) of concatenated sequences, including the rpoD, rctB, gyrB, toxR and pyrH genes, identified strain AP37 as V. harveyi. Phenotypic characters of AP37 were identified by API 20E. In antibiotic susceptibility tests, strain AP37 exhibited susceptibility to 7 antibiotics and resistance to 13. This is the first report of a V. harveyi-related species being linked with the mass mortality of adult abalone H. diversicolor in southern China.

Principles of virus structural organization

Viruses, the molecular nanomachines infecting hosts ranging from prokaryotes to eukaryotes, come in different sizes, shapes, and symmetries. Questions such as what principles govern their structural organization, what factors guide their assembly, how these viruses integrate multifarious functions into one unique structure have enamored researchers for years. In the last five decades, following Caspar and Klug's elegant conceptualization of how viruses are constructed, high-resolution structural studies using X-ray crystallography and more recently cryo-EM techniques have provided a wealth of information on structures of a variety of viruses. These studies have significantly -furthered our understanding of the principles that underlie structural organization in viruses. Such an understanding has practical impact in providing a rational basis for the design and development of antiviral strategies. In this chapter, we review principles underlying capsid formation in a variety of viruses, emphasizing the recent developments along with some historical perspective.

Influenza virus A subtype H1N1 is inhibited by methylated β-lactoglobulin

Addition of methylated β-lactoglobulin (Met-BLG) in the medium of MDCK cell lines infected with influenza virus subtype H1N1 reduced hemagglutination activity (HA) in a concentration dependent manner. Antiviral activity of Met-BLG depended on its concentration, viral load, and duration of infection. Using 17 μg/ml of Met-BLG inhibited 50% of HA of H1N1 grown in MDCK cells at 1 MOI after 24 h incubation at 37°C and in 5% CO₂. Extension of incubation time enhanced antiviral action since the same concentration of Met-BLG inhibited about 61% of viral activity after 48 h. This viral inhibition was accompanied by a protection of MDCK cells as observed by using neutral red or by direct microscope examination. Reduction of viral RNA replication upon the addition of Met-BLG (50 μg/ml) was observed by real time-PCR showing a reduction of viral log value of about 0·9. When viral stock solution was mixed with 25 μg/ml Met-BLG in absence of cell lines, the morphology and viability of virus particles were significantly affected as observed by electron microscopy, and the number of intact virus particles was reduced by roughly 65%.

The role of electron microscopy in the rapid diagnosis of viral infections--review

Electron microscopy (EM) allows fast visualization of viruses in a wide range of clinical specimens. Viruses are grouped into families based on their morphology. Viruses from various families look distinctly and these morphological variances are the basis for identification of viruses by EM. The identification to the family level is often sufficient for the clinician or recognition of an unknown infectious agent. Diagnostic EM has two advantages over enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and nucleic acid amplification tests. After a simple and fast negative staining, EM allows fast morphological identification and differential diagnosis of infectious agents contained in the specimen without the need for special considerations and/or reagents. Nevertheless, EM has the disadvantage of being unsuitable as a screening method.

Retrospective on the early development of cryoelectron microscopy of macromolecules and a prospective on opportunities for the future

Methods for preserving specimen hydration in protein crystals were pursued in the early 1970s as a prerequisite for protein crystallography using an electron microscope. Three laboratories approached this question from very different directions. One built a differentially pumped hydration chamber that could maintain the crystal in a liquid water environment, a second maintained hydration by rapidly freezing the protein crystal and examining it in a cold stage, and the third replaced the water of hydration by using glucose in the same way as one had previously used "negative stains". Each of these early efforts succeeded in preserving the structures of protein crystals at high resolution within the vacuum of the electron microscope, as demonstrated by electron diffraction patterns. The next breakthrough came in the early 1980s when a technique was devised to preserve noncrystalline specimens by freezing them within vitreous ice. Since then, with the development of high stability cold stages and transfer mechanisms compatible with many instrument platforms, and by using commercially provided low dose imaging techniques to avoiding radiation damage, there has been an explosion of applications. These now include single particles, helical filaments, 2-D arrays and even whole cells, where the most exciting recent applications involve cryoelectron tomography. These achievements and possibilities generate a new set of research opportunities associated with increasing the reliability and throughput with which specimens can be studied by cryoEM.

On the experimental use of light metal salts for negative staining

All common negative stains are salts of heavy metals. To remedy several technical defects inherent in the use of heavy metal compounds, this study investigates whether salts of the light metals sodium, magnesium, and aluminum can function as negative stains. Screening criteria require aqueous solubility at pH 7.0, formation of a smooth amorphous layer upon drying, and transmission electron microscope imaging of the 87-A (8.7-nm) lattice periodicity in thin catalase crystals. Six of 23 salts evaluated pass all three screens; detection of the protein shell in ferritin macromolecules indicates that light metal salts also provide negative staining of single particle specimens. Appositional contrast is less than that given by heavy metal negative stains; image density can be raised by increasing electron phase contrast and by selecting salts with phosphate or sulfate anions, thereby adding strong scattering from P or S atoms. Low-dose electron diffraction of catalase crystals negatively stained with 200 mM magnesium sulfate shows Bragg spots extending out to 4.4 A. Future experimental use of sodium phosphate buffer and magnesium sulfate for negative staining is anticipated, particularly in designing new cocktail (multicomponent) negative stains able to support and protect protein structure to higher resolution levels than are currently achieved.

Application of transmission electron microscopy to the clinical study of viral and bacterial infections: present and future

Transmission electron microscopy has had a profound impact on our knowledge and understanding of viruses and bacteria. The 1000-fold improvement in resolution provided by electron microscopy (EM) has allowed visualization of viruses, the existence of which had previously only been suspected as the causative agents of transmissible infectious disease. Viruses are grouped into families based on their morphology. Viruses from different families look different and these morphological variances are the basis for identification of viruses by EM.

Electron microscopy initially came to prominence in diagnostic microbiology in the late 1960s when it was used in the rapid diagnosis of smallpox, by differentiating, on a morphological basis, poxviruses from the less problematic herpesviruses in skin lesions. Subsequently, the technique was employed in the diagnosis of other viral infections, such as hepatitis B and parvovirus B19. Electron microscopy has led to the discovery of many new viruses, most notably the various viruses associated with gastroenteritis, for which it remained the principal diagnostic method until fairly recent times. Development of molecular techniques, which offer greater sensitivity and often the capacity to easily process large numbers of samples, has replaced EM in many areas of diagnostic virology. Hence the role of EM in clinical virology is evolving with less emphasis on diagnosis and more on research, although this is likely only to be undertaken in specialist centres. However, EM still offers tremendous advantages to the microbiologist, both in the speed of diagnosis and the potential for detecting, by a single test, any viral pathogen or even multiple pathogens present within a sample.

There is continuing use of EM for the investigation of new and emerging agents, such as SARS and human monkeypox virus. Furthermore, EM forms a vital part of the national emergency response programme of many countries and will provide a frontline diagnostic service in the event of a bioterrorism incident, particularly in the scenario of a deliberate release of smallpox virus.

In the field of bacteriology, EM is of little use diagnostically, although some bacterial pathogens can be identified in biopsy material processed for EM examination. Electron microscopy has been used, however, to elucidate the structure and function of many bacterial features, such as flagellae, fimbriae and spores and in the study of bacteriophages. The combined use of EM and gold-labelled antibodies provides a powerful tool for the ultrastructural localisation of bacterial and viral antigens.

Negative staining permits 4.0 A resolution with low-dose electron diffraction of catalase crystals

Low-dose electron diffraction of thin single crystals of catalase that are negatively stained with the light-atom compound, dipotassium glucose-1,6-diphosphate, reveals Bragg reflections extending to 4.0A (= 0.40 nm). Under the same conditions, negative staining with the traditional heavy-metal salt, ammonium molybdate, also gives diffraction spots extending to 4.0 A. These results establish that negative staining of protein crystals preserves periodic structural information into the high-resolution range, unlike the widely accepted current belief that this methodology can give a resolution limited to only 20-25 A.

Light atom derivatives of structure-preserving sugars are unconventional negative stains

Although glucose and certain other sugars are known to greatly reduce distortion and denaturation of proteins during drying, use of this monosaccharide as an experimental negative stain does not permit imaging of lattice periodicities in test specimens of thin catalase crystals. However, the potassium and sodium salts of several forms of monophosphorylated glucose (200 mM), diphosphorylated glucose, monosulfated glucose, maltose-1-phosphate, and trehalose-6-phosphate, all dry into a glassy layer and scatter transmitted electrons sufficiently to show the 86 A major periods in catalase crystals. Glucose-6-phosphate provides sufficient image contrast at concentrations from 2 mM (=0.067%) to 500 mM (= 16.8%). Underfocusing increases visualization of the periodic lattice, indicating a large contribution of phase contrast to these images. Upon exposure to the electron beam, thicker regions of derivatized saccharides or pure glucose develop bubbling; this redistribution of dried stain largely can be precluded by imaging with low-dose exposures. Power spectra of images of catalase crystals contained within 200 mM disodium glucose-6-phosphate show that periodic information can be recorded to 21 A; some individual features of dipotassium glucose-6-phosphate distribution within the protein lattice have a measured width of around 5 A. The experimental results demonstrate that structure-preserving mono- and di-saccharides also serve successfully as negative stains after they are coupled to light atom scatterers.

The adsorption staining technique applied to isolated premessenger ribonucleoprotein particles: a comparison with conventional techniques using electron microscope tomography

A specific type of premessenger RNP particle, Balbiani ring granules from the dipteran Chironomus tentans, was biochemically isolated and visualized in three dimensions with electron microscope tomography. The particles were prepared for electron microscopy in three different ways: positively stained, negatively stained and adsorption-stained (embedded in polyvinyl alcohol, PVA, and concomitantly stained). The results were compared with those obtained for RNP particles studied in situ in ultrathin sections of plastic-embedded cells. The positively stained particles were compacted and heavily deformed with little or no internal structure. The negatively stained and the adsorption-stained particles were well preserved; the outer contours and the central cavities of the particles were outlined. The internal structure, i.e. the folded 7-nm elementary fibre, could not be recognized in the negatively stained particles. In the adsorption-stained particles, however, the fibre was discernable, although not quite as distinctly demarcated as in the plastic-embedded samples. We conclude that embedding in PVA with concomitant staining with uranyl acetate is a rapid method to obtain both good preservation and staining of isolated RNP particles. The PVA-embedded particles were also found to be sufficiently resistant to irradiation to permit a comprehensive tilt-series to be taken for electron microscope tomography.

The capsid of small papova viruses contains 72 pentameric capsomeres: direct evidence from cryo-electron-microscopy of simian virus 40

The three-dimensional structure of the simian virus 40 capsid is remarkably similar to the structure of the polyoma empty capsid. This similarity is apparent despite striking differences in the methods used to determine the two structures: image analysis of electron micrographs of frozen-hydrated samples (SV40 virions) and an unconventional x-ray crystallographic analysis (polyoma empty capsids). Both methods have clearly resolved the 72 prominent capsomere units which comprise the T = 7d icosahedral capsid surface lattice. The 12 pentavalent and 60 hexavalent capsomeres consist of pentameric substructures. A pentameric morphology for hexavalent capsomeres clearly shows that the conserved bonding specificity expected from the quasi-equivalence theory is not present in either SV40 or polyoma capsids. Determination of the SV40 structure from cryo-electron microscopy supports the correctness of the polyoma structure solved crystallographically and establishes a strong complementarity of the two techniques. Similarity between the SV40 virion and the empty polyoma capsid indicates that the capsid is not detectably altered by the loss of the nucleohistone core. The unexpected pentameric substructure of the hexavalent capsomeres and the arrangement of the 72 pentamers in the SV40 and polyoma capsid lattices may be characteristic features of all members of the papova virus family, including the papilloma viruses such as human wart and rabbit papilloma.