Applications of medium-voltage STEM for the 3-D study of organelles within very thick sections

Development and application of STEM for the biological sciences

The design of the scanning transmission electron microscope (STEM), as conceived originally by Crewe and coworkers, enables the highly efficient and flexible collection of different elastic and inelastic signals resulting from the interaction of a focused probe of incident electrons with a specimen. In the present paper we provide a brief review for how the STEM today can be applied towards a range of different problems in the biological sciences, emphasizing four main areas of application. (1) For three decades, the most widely used STEM technique has been the mass determination of proteins and other macromolecular assemblies. Such measurements can be performed at low electron dose by collecting the high-angle dark-field signal using an annular detector. STEM mass mapping has proven valuable for characterizing large protein assemblies such as filamentous proteins with a well-defined mass per length. (2) The annular dark-field signal can also be used to image ultrasmall, functionalized nanoparticles of heavy atoms for labeling specific amino-acid sequences in protein assemblies. (3) By acquiring electron energy loss spectra (EELS) at each pixel in a hyperspectral image, it is possible to map the distributions of specific bound elements like phosphorus, calcium and iron in isolated macromolecular assemblies or in compartments within sectioned cells. Near single atom sensitivity is feasible provided that the specimen can tolerate a very high incident electron dose. (4) Electron tomography is a new application of STEM that enables three-dimensional reconstruction of micrometer-thick sections of cells. In this technique a probe of small convergence angle gives a large depth of field throughout the thickness of the specimen while maintaining a probe diameter of <2 nm; and the use of an on-axis bright-field detector reduces the effects of beam broadening and thus improves the spatial resolution compared to that attainable by STEM dark-field tomography.

Three-dimensional reconstruction of nucleolar components by electron microscope tomography

The nucleus is a complex volume constituted of numerous subcompartments in which specific functions take place due to a specific spatial organization of their molecular components. To understand how these molecules are spatially organized within these machineries, it is necessary to investigate their three-dimensional organization at high resolution. To reach this goal, electron tomography appears to be a method of choice; it can generate tomograms with a resolution of a few nanometers by using multiple projections of a tilted section several hundred to several thousand nanometers in thickness imaged by transmission electron microscopy (TEM).Specific identification of molecules of interest contained within such thick sections requires their specific immunocytochemical labelling using electron-dense markers. We recently demonstrated that electron tomography of proteins immunostained with nanogold particles before embedding, and subsequently amplified with silver, was very fruitful due to the inherently high spatial resolution of the medium-voltage scanning and transmission electron microscope (STEM). Here we describe this approach, which is very efficient for tracing the 3D organization of proteins within complex machineries by using antibodies raised against one of the proteins, or against GFP to analyse GFP-tagged proteins.

Intracellular membrane traffic at high resolution

Membrane traffic between organelles is essential for a multitude of processes that maintain cell homeostasis. Many steps in these tightly regulated trafficking pathways take place in microdomains on the membranes of organelles, which require analysis at nanometer resolution. Electron microscopy (EM) can visualize these processes in detail and is mainly responsible for our current view of morphology on the subcellular level. This review discusses how EM can be applied to solve many questions of intracellular membrane traffic, with a focus on the endosomal system. We describe the expansion of the technique from purely morphological analysis to cryo-immuno-EM, correlative light electron microscopy (CLEM), and 3D electron tomography. In this review we go into some technical details of these various techniques. Furthermore, we provide a full protocol for immunolabeling on Lowicryl sections of high-pressure frozen cells as well as a detailed description of a simple CLEM method that can be applied to answer many membrane trafficking questions. We believe that these EM-based techniques are important tools to expand our understanding of the molecular details of endosomal sorting and intracellular membrane traffic in general.

Monte Carlo electron-trajectory simulations in bright-field and dark-field STEM: implications for tomography of thick biological sections

A Monte Carlo electron-trajectory calculation has been implemented to assess the optimal detector configuration for scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) tomography of thick biological sections. By modeling specimens containing 2 and 3 at% osmium in a carbon matrix, it was found that for 1-microm-thick samples the bright-field (BF) and annular dark-field (ADF) signals give similar contrast and signal-to-noise ratio provided the ADF inner angle and BF outer angle are chosen optimally. Spatial resolution in STEM imaging of thick sections is compromised by multiple elastic scattering which results in a spread of scattering angles and thus a spread in lateral distances of the electrons leaving the bottom surface. However, the simulations reveal that a large fraction of these multiply scattered electrons are excluded from the BF detector, which results in higher spatial resolution in BF than in high-angle ADF images for objects situated towards the bottom of the sample. The calculations imply that STEM electron tomography of thick sections should be performed using a BF rather than an ADF detector. This advantage was verified by recording simultaneous BF and high-angle ADF STEM tomographic tilt series from a stained 600-nm-thick section of C. elegans. It was found that loss of spatial resolution occurred markedly at the bottom surface of the specimen in the ADF STEM but significantly less in the BF STEM tomographic reconstruction. Our results indicate that it might be feasible to use BF STEM tomography to determine the 3D structure of whole eukaryotic microorganisms prepared by freeze-substitution, embedding, and sectioning.

Automated electron tomography with scanning transmission electron microscopy

We report the successful implementation of a fully automated tomographic data collection system in scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) mode. Autotracking is carried out by combining mechanical and electronic corrections for specimen movement. Autofocusing is based on contrast difference of a focus series of a small sample area. The focus gradient that exists in normal images due to specimen tilt is effectively removed by using dynamic focusing. An advantage of STEM tomography with dynamic focusing over TEM tomography is its ability to reconstruct large objects with a potentially higher resolution.

STEM tomography in cell biology

Transmission electron tomography has been used in biological sciences for quite some time and proven to be a valuable tool. However, to date, the different Scanning Transmission modes are almost not used for electron tomography on resin-embedded biological material. We explored different STEM modes on epon-embedded, osmium-uranyl-lead-stained biological material. Bright Field-TEM and High Angle Annular Dark Field-STEM tomograms from the same areas were recorded and compared. Contrast and signal-to-noise ratios were calculated. Template matching was used to validate results obtained in Bright Field-TEM and High Angle Annular Dark Field-STEM tomograms. It is concluded that High Angle Annular Dark Field-STEM gives a five times better contrast and signal-to-noise ratio than Bright Field-TEM. Template matching showed that 1.3 times more information could be extracted from High Angle Annular Dark Field-STEM tomograms than from Bright Field-TEM tomograms.

Electron tomography of amplified nanogold immunolabelling: Improvement of quality based on alignment of projections with sinograms and use of post-reconstruction deconvolution

Electron tomography of immunolabelled proteins identified with amplified nanogold particles imaged by Scanning and Transmission Electron Microscopy within thick sections is a powerful method to investigate the three-dimensional organization of complex cellular machineries. In order to increase the overall quality of the reconstructed cube, we have developed two methods that improve the tomographic reconstruction process. We first performed a very precise alignment of the projections before reconstruction with a technique using sinograms. After reconstruction, we propose to compute image restoration by calculating the Point Spread Function of the projection/back-projection system and to use it to deblur the reconstructed cubes. Improvement in the quality of the reconstructed cubes is demonstrated on images of nucleolar proteins tagged with EGFP and immunolabelled with nanogold particles.

Three-dimensional organization of pKi-67: a comparative fluorescence and electron tomography study using FluoroNanogold

The monoclonal antibody (MAb) Ki-67 is routinely used in clinical studies to estimate the growth fraction of tumors. However, the role of pKi-67, the protein detected by the Ki-67 MAb, remains elusive, although some biochemical data strongly suggest that it might organize chromatin. To better understand the functional organization of pKi-67, we studied its three-dimensional distribution in interphase cells by confocal microscopy and electron tomography. FluoroNanogold, a single probe combining a dense marker with a fluorescent dye, was used to investigate pKi-67 organization at the optical and ultrastructural levels. Observation by confocal microscopy followed by 3D reconstruction showed that pKi-67 forms a shell around the nucleoli. Double labeling experiments revealed that pKi-67 co-localizes with perinucleolar heterochromatin. Electron microscopy studies confirmed this close association and demonstrated that pKi-67 is located neither in the fibrillar nor in the granular components of the nucleolus. Finally, spatial analyses by electron tomography showed that pKi-67 forms cords 250-300 nm in diameter, which are themselves composed of 30-50-nm-thick fibers. These detailed comparative in situ analyses strongly suggest the involvement of pKi-67 in the higher-order organization of perinucleolar chromatin.

Three-dimensional localization of ultrasmall immuno-gold labels by HAADF-STEM tomography

The localization of scarce antigens in thin sections of biological material can be accomplished by pre-embedment labeling with ultrasmall immuno-gold labels. Moreover, with this method, labeling is not restricted to the section surface but occurs throughout the section volume. Thus, when combined with electron tomography, antigens can be localized in three dimensions in relation to the 3D (three-dimensional) ultrastructure of the cell. However, for visualization in a transmission electron microscope, these labels need to be enlarged by silver or gold enhancement. The increase in particle size reduces the resolution of the antigen detection and the large particles obscure ultrastructural details in the tomogram. In this paper we show for the first time that these problems can be avoided and that ultrasmall gold labels can be localized in three dimensions without the need for gold or silver enhancement by using HAADF-STEM (high angular annular dark-field-scanning transmission electron microscopy) tomography. This method allowed us to three-dimensionally localize Aurion ultrasmall goat anti-rabbit immuno-gold labels on sections of Epon-embedded, osmium-uranium-lead-stained biological material. Calculations show that a 3D reconstruction obtained from HAADF-STEM projection images can be spatially aligned to one obtained from transmission electron microscopy (TEM) projections with subpixel accuracy. We conclude that it is possible to combine the high-fidelity structural information of TEM tomograms with the ultrasmall label localization ability of HAADF-STEM tomograms.

Perspectives of molecular and cellular electron tomography

After a general introduction to three-dimensional electron microscopy and particularly to electron tomography (ET), the perspectives of applying ET to native (frozen-hydrated) cellular structures are discussed. In ET, a set of 2-D images of an object is recorded at different viewing directions and is then used for calculating a 3-D image. ET at a resolution of 2-5 nm would allow the 3-D organization of structural cellular components to be studied and would provide important information about spatial relationships and interactions. The question of whether it is a realistic long-term goal to visualize or--by sophisticated pattern recognition methods--identify macromolecules in cells frozen in toto or in frozen sections of cells is addressed. Because of the radiation sensitivity of biological specimens, a prerequisite of application of ET is the automation of the imaging process. Technical aspects of automated ET as realized in Martinsried and experiences are presented, and limitations of the technique are identified, both theoretically and experimentally. Possible improvements of instrumentation to overcome at least part of the limitations are discussed in some detail. Those means include increasing the accelerating voltage into the intermediate voltage range (300 to 500 kV), energy filtering, the use of a field emission gun, and a liquid-helium-cooled specimen stage. Two additional sections deal with ET of isolated macromolecules and of macromolecular structures in situ, and one section is devoted to possible methods for the detection of structures in volume data.

Electron tomography of metaphase nucleolar organizer regions: evidence for a twisted-loop organization

Metaphase nucleolar organizer regions (NORs), one of four types of chromosome bands, are located on human acrocentric chromosomes. They contain r-chromatin, i.e., ribosomal genes complexed with proteins such as upstream binding factor and RNA polymerase I, which are argyrophilic NOR proteins. Immunocytochemical and cytochemical labelings of these proteins were used to reveal r-chromatin in situ and to investigate its spatial organization within NORs by confocal microscopy and by electron tomography. For each labeling, confocal microscopy revealed small and large double-spotted NORs and crescent-shaped NORs. Their internal three-dimensional (3D) organization was studied by using electron tomography on specifically silver-stained NORs. The 3D reconstructions allow us to conclude that the argyrophilic NOR proteins are grouped as a fiber of 60-80 nm in diameter that constitutes either one part of a turn or two or three turns of a helix within small and large double-spotted NORs, respectively. Within crescent-shaped NORs, virtual slices reveal that the fiber constitutes several longitudinally twisted loops, grouped as two helical 250- to 300-nm coils, each centered on a nonargyrophilic axis of condensed chromatin. We propose a model of the 3D organization of r-chromatin within elongated NORs, in which loops are twisted and bent to constitute one basic chromatid coil.

EM-tomography of section collapse, a non-linear phenomenon

Using back projection for reconstruction and tilt series of Epon or Lowicryl embedded and sectioned material, we demonstrated: (1) a reduction in thickness of 50% for Epon and 80% for Lowicryl sections, and (2) a non-uniform density distribution along the electron-optical axis in sections. The highest density was found at the vacuum exposed side of the section. The formvar side of the section showed a similar increase in density, but not to the same extent. Minimalization of electron exposure, even without pre-exposure, did not affect the reconstructed thickness, nor did it affect the non-uniform density distribution. However, parallax measurements showed that at 150K, collapse of Epon sections does not take place. For EM-tomography of plastic embedded material our findings imply that at the top and bottom portion of the sections the dimensions of the reconstructed structures are distorted, but that in the middle portion the dimensions are reliably retained.

Approaches to large-scale structures

Quantitative three-dimensional (3D) maps of large-scale structures can now be routinely obtained by the use of high- or intermediate-voltage electron tomography. The recent 3D reconstructions of the mitochondrion and the Golgi apparatus highlight both the potential and the shortcomings of this technique. New technological developments, in particular the development of automated low-dose electron tomography, are expected to facilitate the 3D visualization of large structures in the fully hydrated environment, embedded in vitreous ice.