Protein-nucleoside contacts in the interaction between the replication terminator protein of Bacillus subtilis and the DNA terminator

Control of Initiation of DNA Replication in Bacillus subtilis and Escherichia coli

Initiation of DNA Replication is tightly regulated in all cells since imbalances in chromosomal copy number are deleterious and often lethal. In bacteria such as Bacillus subtilis and Escherichia coli, at the point of cytokinesis, there must be two complete copies of the chromosome to partition into the daughter cells following division at mid-cell during vegetative growth. Under conditions of rapid growth, when the time taken to replicate the chromosome exceeds the doubling time of the cells, there will be multiple initiations per cell cycle and daughter cells will inherit chromosomes that are already undergoing replication. In contrast, cells entering the sporulation pathway in B. subtilis can do so only during a short interval in the cell cycle when there are two, and only two, chromosomes per cell, one destined for the spore and one for the mother cell. Here, we briefly describe the overall process of DNA replication in bacteria before reviewing initiation of DNA replication in detail. The review covers DnaA-directed assembly of the replisome at oriC and the multitude of mechanisms of regulation of initiation, with a focus on the similarities and differences between E. coli and B. subtilis.

Mechanism and physiological significance of programmed replication termination

Replication forks in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic systems pause at random sites due to depletion of dNTP pools, DNA damage, tight binding nonhistone proteins or unusual DNA sequences and/or structures, in a mostly non-polar fashion. However, there is also physiologically programmed replication termination at sequence-specific authentic replication termini. Here, the structure and functions of programmed replication termini, their mechanism of action and their diverse physiological functions in prokaryotes and eukaryotes have been reviewed.

Random and site-specific replication termination

Bi-directionality is a common feature observed for genomic replication for all three phylogenetic kingdoms: Eubacteria, Archaea, and Eukaryotes. A consequence of bi-directional replication, where the two replication forks initiated at an origin move away from each other, is that the replication termination will occur at positions away from the origin sequence(s). The replication termination processes are therefore physically and mechanistically dissociated from the replication initiation. The replication machinery is a highly processive complex that in short time copies huge numbers of bases while competing for the DNA substrate with histones, transcription factors, and other DNA-binding proteins. Importantly, the replication machinery generally wins out; meanwhile, when converging forks meet termination occurs, thus preventing over-replication and genetic instability. Very different scenarios for the replication termination processes have been described for the three phylogenetic kingdoms. In eubacterial genomes replication termination is site specific, while in archaea and eukaryotes termination is thought to occur randomly within zones where converging replication forks meet. However, a few site-specific replication barrier elements that mediate replication termination have been described in eukaryotes. This review gives an overview about what is known about replication termination, with a focus on these natural site-specific replication termination sites.

Replication fork stalling at natural impediments

Accurate and complete replication of the genome in every cell division is a prerequisite of genomic stability. Thus, both prokaryotic and eukaryotic replication forks are extremely precise and robust molecular machines that have evolved to be up to the task. However, it has recently become clear that the replication fork is more of a hurdler than a runner: it must overcome various obstacles present on its way. Such obstacles can be called natural impediments to DNA replication, as opposed to external and genetic factors. Natural impediments to DNA replication are particular DNA binding proteins, unusual secondary structures in DNA, and transcription complexes that occasionally (in eukaryotes) or constantly (in prokaryotes) operate on replicating templates. This review describes the mechanisms and consequences of replication stalling at various natural impediments, with an emphasis on the role of replication stalling in genomic instability.

An asymmetric structure of the Bacillus subtilis replication terminator protein in complex with DNA

In Bacillus subtilis, the termination of DNA replication via polar fork arrest is effected by a specific protein:DNA complex formed between the replication terminator protein (RTP) and DNA terminator sites. We report the crystal structure of a replication terminator protein homologue (RTP.C110S) of B. subtilis in complex with the high affinity component of one of its cognate DNA termination sites, known as the TerI B-site, refined at 2.5 A resolution. The 21 bp RTP:DNA complex displays marked structural asymmetry in both the homodimeric protein and the DNA. This is in contrast to the previously reported complex formed with a symmetrical TerI B-site homologue. The induced asymmetry is consistent with the complex's solution properties as determined using NMR spectroscopy. Concomitant with this asymmetry is variation in the protein:DNA binding pattern for each of the subunits of the RTP homodimer. It is proposed that the asymmetric "wing" positions, as well as other asymmetrical features of the RTP:DNA complex, are critical for the cooperative binding that underlies the mechanism of polar fork arrest at the complete terminator site.

Crystallization and preliminary X-ray diffraction analysis of the Bacillus subtilis replication termination protein in complex with the 37-base-pair TerI-binding site

The replication terminator protein (RTP) of Bacillus subtilis binds to specific DNA sequences that halt the progression of the replisome in a polar manner. These terminator complexes flank a defined region of the chromosome into which they allow replication forks to enter but not exit. Forcing the fusion of replication forks in a specific zone is thought to allow the coordination of post-replicative processes. The functional terminator complex comprises two homodimers each of 29 kDa bound to overlapping binding sites. A preparation of RTP and a 37-base-pair TerI sequence (comprising two binding sites for RTP) has been purified and crystallized. A data set to 3.9 A resolution with 97.0% completeness and an R(sym) of 12% was collected from a single flash-cooled crystal using synchrotron radiation. The diffraction data are consistent with space group P622, with unit-cell parameters a = b = 118.8, c = 142.6 A.

Molecular architecture of a eukaryotic DNA replication terminus-terminator protein complex

DNA replication forks pause at programmed fork barriers within nontranscribed regions of the ribosomal DNA (rDNA) genes of many eukaryotes to coordinate and regulate replication, transcription, and recombination. The mechanism of eukaryotic fork arrest remains unknown. In Schizosaccharomyces pombe, the promiscuous DNA binding protein Sap1 not only causes polar fork arrest at the rDNA fork barrier Ter1 but also regulates mat1 imprinting at SAS1 without fork pausing. Towards an understanding of eukaryotic fork arrest, we probed the interactions of Sap1 with Ter1 as contrasted with SAS1. The Sap1 dimer bound Ter1 with high affinity at one face of the DNA, contacting successive major grooves. The complex displayed translational symmetry. In contrast, Sap1 subunits approached SAS1 from opposite helical faces, forming a low-affinity complex with mirror image rotational symmetry. The alternate symmetries were reflected in distinct Sap1-induced helical distortions. Importantly, modulating protein-DNA interactions of the fork-proximal Sap1 subunit with the nonnatural binding site DR2 affected blocking efficiency without changes in binding affinity or binding mode but with alterations in Sap1-induced DNA distortion. The results reveal that Sap1-DNA affinity alone is insufficient to account for fork arrest and suggest that Sap1 binding-induced structural changes may result in formation of a competent fork-blocking complex.

DNA Replication Fork Arrest by the Bacillus subtilis RTP–DNA Complex Involves a Mechanism that Is Independent of the Affinity of RTP–DNA Binding

In order to elucidate the mechanism of DNA replication fork arrest by the replication terminator protein (RTP)-DNA complex, a set of RTP fusion proteins were constructed in which peptides of various sizes were fused to the C terminus; this placed the peptides at a surface location that was predicted to come into contact with the DNA replication machinery during fork arrest. The fusion proteins were capable of replication fork arrest in vivo, but they had a significantly reduced efficiency compared to wild-type RTP, which was not directly proportional to peptide size or sequence. Importantly, the fusion proteins retained completely normal RTP-DNA binding affinity. These findings rule out the molecular clamp model as the sole explanation for fork arrest by RTP, and suggest that RTP interacts with the replication machinery in a manner that directly contributes to the fork arrest mechanism.

Interaction of the replication terminator protein of Bacillus subtilis with DNA probed by NMR spectroscopy

Termination of DNA replication in Bacillus subtilis involves the polar arrest of replication forks by a specific complex formed between the dimeric 29 kDa replication terminator protein (RTP) and DNA terminator sites. We have used NMR spectroscopy to probe the changes in 1H-15N correlation spectra of a 15N-labelled RTP.C110S mutant upon the addition of a 21 base pair symmetrical DNA binding site. Assignment of the 1H-15N correlations was achieved using a suite of triple resonance NMR experiments with 15N,13C,70% 2H enriched protein recorded at 800 MHz and using TROSY pulse sequences. Perturbations to 1H-15N spectra revealed that the N-termini, alpha3-helices and several loops are affected by the binding interaction. An analysis of this data in light of the crystallographically determined apo- and DNA-bound forms of RTP.C110S revealed that the NMR spectral perturbations correlate more closely to protein structural changes upon complex formation rather than to interactions at the protein-DNA interface.

A Complex Mechanism Determines Polarity of DNA Replication Fork Arrest by the Replication Terminator Complex of Bacillus subtilis

Two dimers of the replication terminator protein (RTP) of Bacillus subtilis bind to a chromosomal DNA terminator site to effect polar replication fork arrest. Cooperative binding of the dimers to overlapping half-sites within the terminator is essential for arrest. It was suggested previously that polarity of fork arrest is the result of the RTP dimer at the blocking (proximal) side within the complex binding very tightly and the permissive-side RTP dimer binding relatively weakly. In order to investigate this "differential binding affinity" model, we have constructed a series of mutant terminators that contain half-sites of widely different RTP binding affinities in various combinations. Although there appeared to be a correlation between binding affinity at the proximal half-site and fork arrest efficiency in vivo for some terminators, several deviated significantly from this correlation. Some terminators exhibited greatly reduced binding cooperativity (and therefore have reduced affinity at each half-site) but were highly efficient in fork arrest, whereas one terminator had normal affinity over the proximal half-site, yet had low fork arrest efficiency. The results show clearly that there is no direct correlation between the RTP binding affinity (either within the full complex or at the proximal half-site within the full complex) and the efficiency of replication fork arrest in vivo. Thus, the differential binding affinity over the proximal and distal half-sites cannot be solely responsible for functional polarity of fork arrest. Furthermore, efficient fork arrest relies on features in addition to the tight binding of RTP to terminator DNA.

Effects of replication termination mutants on chromosome partitioning in Bacillus subtilis

Many circular genomes have replication termination systems, yet disruption of these systems does not cause an obvious defect in growth or viability. We have found that the replication termination system of Bacillus subtilis contributes to accurate chromosome partitioning. Partitioning of the terminus region requires that chromosome dimers, that have formed as a result of RecA-mediated homologous recombination, be resolved to monomers by the site-specific recombinase encoded by ripX. In addition, the chromosome must be cleared from the region of formation of the division septum. This process is facilitated by the spoIIIE gene product which is required for movement of a chromosome out of the way of the division septum during sporulation. We found that deletion of rtp, which encodes the replication termination protein, in combination with mutations in ripX or spoIIIE, led to an increase in production of anucleate cells. This increase in production of anucleate cells depended on recA, indicating that there is probably an increase in chromosome dimer formation in the absence of the replication termination system. Our results also indicate that SpoIIIE probably enhances the function of the RipX recombinase system. We also determined the subcellular location of the replication termination protein and found that it is a good marker for the position of the chromosome terminus.

Effects of replication termination mutants on chromosome partitioning in Bacillus subtilis

Many circular genomes have replication termination systems, yet disruption of these systems does not cause an obvious defect in growth or viability. We have found that the replication termination system of Bacillus subtilis contributes to accurate chromosome partitioning. Partitioning of the terminus region requires that chromosome dimers, that have formed as a result of RecA-mediated homologous recombination, be resolved to monomers by the site-specific recombinase encoded by ripX . In addition, the chromosome must be cleared from the region of formation of the division septum. This process is facilitated by the spoIIIE gene product which is required for movement of a chromosome out of the way of the division septum during sporulation. We found that deletion of rtp , which encodes the replication termination protein, in combination with mutations in ripX or spoIIIE , led to an increase in production of anucleate cells. This increase in production of anucleate cells depended on recA , indicating that there is probably an increase in chromosome dimer formation in the absence of the replication termination system. Our results also indicate that SpoIIIE probably enhances the function of the RipX recombinase system. We also determined the subcellular location of the replication termination protein and found that it is a good marker for the position of the chromosome terminus.

The replication checkpoint control in Bacillus subtilis: identification of a novel RTP-binding sequence essential for the replication fork arrest after induction of the stringent response

We have shown previously that induction of the stringent response in Bacillus subtilis resulted in the arrest of chromosomal replication between 100 and 200 kb either side of oriC at distinct stop sites, designated LSTer and RSTer, left and right stringent terminators respectively. This replication checkpoint was also shown to involve the RTP protein, normally active at the chromosomal terminus. In this study, we show that the replication block is absolutely dependent upon RelA, correlated with high levels of ppGpp, but that efficient arrest at STer sites also requires RTP. DNA-DNA hybridization data indicated that one or more such LSTer sites mapped to gene yxcC (-128 kb from oriC). A 7.75 kb fragment containing this gene was cloned into a theta replicating plasmid, and plasmid replication arrest, requiring both RelA and RTP, was demonstrated. This effect was polar, with plasmid arrest only detected when the fragment was orientated in the same direction with respect to replication, as in the chromosome. This LSTer2 site was further mapped to a 3.65 kb fragment overlapping the next40 probe. Remarkably, this fragment contains a 17 bp sequence (B'-1) showing 76% identity with an RTP binding site (B sequence) present at the chromosomal terminus. This B'-1 sequence, located in the gene yxcC, efficiently binds RTP in vitro, as shown by DNA gel retardation studies and DNase I footprinting. Importantly, precise deletion of this sequence abolished the replication arrest. We propose that this modified B site is an essential constituent of the LSTer2 site. The differences between arrest at the normal chromosomal terminus and arrest at LSTer site are discussed.

Replication fork arrest and termination of chromosome replication in Bacillus subtilis

Sporulation in Bacillus subtilis provided the first evidence for the presence of sequence-specific replication fork arrest (Ter) sites in the terminus region of the bacterial chromosome. These sites, when complexed with the replication terminator protein (RTP), block movement of a replication fork in a polar manner. The Ter sites are organized into two opposed groups which force the approaching forks to meet and fuse within a restricted terminus region. While the precise advantage provided to the cell through the presence of the so-called replication fork trap is not patently obvious, the same situation appears to have evolved independently in Escherichia coli. The molecular mechanism by which the RTP-Ter complex of B. subtilis (or the analogous but apparently unrelated complex in E. coli) functions is currently unresolved and subject to intense investigation. Replication fork arrest in B. subtilis, requiring RTP, also occurs under conditions of the stringent response at so-called STer sites that lie close to and on both sides of oriC. These sites are yet to be identified and characterized. How they are induced to function under stringent conditions is of considerable interest, and could provide vital clues about the mechanism of fork arrest by RTP-terminator complexes in general.

Search for additional replication terminators in the Bacillus subtilis 168 chromosome

The Bacillus subtilis 168 chromosome is known to contain at least six DNA replication terminators in the terminus region of the chromosome. By using a degenerate DNA probe for the consensus terminator sequence and low-stringency hybridization conditions, several additional minor hybridizing bands were identified. DNA corresponding to the most intense of these bands was cloned and characterized. Although localized in the terminus region, it could not bind RTP and possibly represents a degenerate terminator. A search of the SubtiList database identified an additional terminator sequence in the terminus region, near glnA. It was shown to bind RTP and to function in blocking replication fork movement in a polar manner. Its orientation conformed to the replication fork trap arrangement of the other terminators. The low-stringency hybridization experiments failed to identify any terminus region-type terminators in the region of the chromosome where postinitiation control sequences (STer sites) are known to reside. The two most likely terminators in STer site regions, in terms of sequence similarity to terminus region terminators, were identified through sequence searching. They were synthesized and were found not to bind RTP under conditions that allowed binding to terminus region terminators. Neither did they elicit fork arrest, when present in a plasmid, under stringent conditions. It is concluded that the STer site terminators, at least the first two to the left of oriC, do not have the typical consensus A+B site makeup of terminus region terminators.

Reorganization of terminator DNA upon binding replication terminator protein: implications for the functional replication fork arrest complex

Termination of DNA replication in Bacillus subtilis involves the polar arrest of replication forks by a specific complex formed between the replication terminator protein (RTP) and DNA terminator sites. While determination of the crystal structure of RTP has facilitated our understanding of how a single RTP dimer interacts with terminator DNA, additional information is required in order to understand the assembly of a functional fork arrest complex, which requires an interaction between two RTP dimers and the terminator site. In this study, we show that the conformation of the major B.subtilis DNA terminator,TerI, becomes considerably distorted upon binding RTP. Binding of the first dimer of RTP to the B site of TerI causes the DNA to become slightly unwound and bent by approximately 40 degrees. Binding of a second dimer of RTP to the A site causes the bend angle to increase to approximately 60 degrees . We have used this new data to construct two plausible models that might explain how the ternary terminator complex can block DNA replication in a polar manner. In the first model, polarity of action is a consequence of the two RTP-DNA half-sites having different conformations. These different conformations result from different RTP-DNA contacts at each half-site (due to the intrinsic asymmetry of the terminator DNA), as well as interactions (direct or indirect) between the RTP dimers on the DNA. In the second model, polar fork arrest activity is a consequence of the different affinities of RTP for the A and B sites of the terminator DNA, modulated significantly by direct or indirect interactions between the RTP dimers.

A tale of two terminators: crystal structures sharpen the debate on DNA replication fork arrest mechanisms

The structure of the Tus-Ter DNA replication fork arrest complex of Escherichia coli reveals a novel architecture for the bound Tus protein and a new type of DNA-binding motif. The structure of the complex may explain how Tus can block movement of a replication fork approaching from one direction and not the other.

Role of the EBNA-1 protein in pausing of replication forks in the Epstein-Barr virus genome

We have previously shown that replication forks stall at a family of repeated sequences (FR) within the Epstein-Barr virus latent origin of replication oriP, both in a small plasmid and in the intact Epstein-Barr virus genome. Each of the 20 repeated sequences within the FR contains a binding site for Epstein-Barr nuclear antigen 1 (EBNA-1), the only viral protein required for latent replication. We showed that the EBNA-1 protein enhances the accumulation of paused replication forks at the FR. In this study, we have investigated a series of truncated EBNA-1 proteins to determine the portion of the EBNA-1 protein that is responsible for pausing of forks at the FR. Two-dimensional agarose gel electrophoresis was performed on the products of in vitro replication reactions in the presence of full-length EBNA-1 or proteins with various deletions to assess the extent of fork pausing at the FR. We conclude that a portion of the DNA binding domain is important for fork pausing. We also present evidence indicating that phosphorylation of the EBNA-1 protein or EBNA-1-truncated derivatives is not essential for pausing. To investigate the mechanism of EBNA-1-mediated pausing of replication forks, we asked whether EBNA-1 could inhibit the DNA unwinding activity of replicative helicases. We found that EBNA-1, when bound to the FR, inhibits DNA unwinding in vitro by SV40 T antigen and Escherichia coli dnaB helicases in an orientation-independent manner.

Helicase-contrahelicase interaction and the mechanism of termination of DNA replication

Termination of DNA replication at a sequence-specific replication terminus is potentiated by the binding of the replication terminator protein (RTP) to the terminus sequence, causing polar arrest of the replicative helicase (contrahelicase activity). Two alternative models have been proposed to explain the mechanism of replication fork arrest. In the first model, the RTP-terminus DNA interaction simply imposes a polar barrier to helicase movement without involving any specific interaction between the helicase and the terminator proteins. The second model proposes that there is a specific interaction between the two proteins, and that the DNA-protein interaction both restricts the fork arrest to the replication terminus and determines the polarity of the process. The evidence presented in this paper strongly supports the second model.

Structure of the replication terminus-terminator protein complex as probed by affinity cleavage

The replication terminator protein (RTP) of Bacillus subtilis is a homodimer that binds to each replication terminus and impedes replication fork movement in only one orientation with respect to the replication origin. The three-dimensional structure of the RTP-DNA complex needs to be determined to understand how structurally symmetrical dimers of RTP generate functional asymmetry. The functional unit of each replication terminus of Bacillus subtilis consists of four turns of DNA complexed with two interacting dimers of RTP. Although the crystal structure of the RTP apoprotein dimer has been determined at 2.6-A resolution, the functional unit of the terminus is probably too large and too flexible to lend itself to cocrystallization. We have therefore used an alternative strategy to delineate the three dimensional structure of the RTP-DNA complex by converting the protein into a site-directed chemical nuclease. From the pattern of base-specific cleavage of the terminus DNA by the chemical nuclease, we have mapped the amino acid to base contacts. Using these contacts as distance constraints, with the crystal structure of RTP, we have constructed a model of the DNA-protein complex. The biological implications of the model have been discussed.

The dimer-dimer interaction surface of the replication terminator protein of Bacillus subtilis and termination of DNA replication

The replication terminator protein (RTP) of Bacillus subtilis causes polar fork arrest at replication termini by sequence-specific interaction of two dimeric proteins with the terminus sequence. The crystal structure of the RTP protein has been solved, and the structure has already provide valuable clues regarding the structural basis of its function. However, it provides little information as to the surface of the protein involved in dimer-dimer interaction. Using site-directed mutagenesis, we have identified three sites on the protein that appear to mediate the dimer-dimer interaction. Crystallographic analysis of one of the mutant proteins (Y88F) showed that its structure is unaltered when compared to the wild-type protein. The locations of the three sites suggested a model for the dimer-dimer interaction that involves an association between two beta-ribbon motifs. This model is supported by a fourth mutation that was predicted to disrupt the interaction and was shown to do so. Biochemical analyses of these mutants provide compelling evidence that cooperative protein-protein interaction between two dimers of RTP is essential to impose polar blocks to the elongation of both DNA and RNA chains.

Identification and characterization of a novel type of replication terminator with bidirectional activity on the Bacillus subtilis theta plasmid pLS20

We have sequenced and analysed a 3.1 kb fragment of the 55 kb endogenous Bacillus subtilis plasmid pLS20 containing its replication functions. Just outside the region required for autonomous replication, a segment of 18 bp was identified as being almost identical to part of the major B. subtilis chromosomal replication terminator. Here, we demonstrate that this segment is part of a functional replication terminator. This newly identified element, designated TerLS20, is the first replication terminator identified on a theta plasmid from a Gram-positive bacterium. TerLS20 is distinct from other known replication terminators in the sense that it is functional in both orientations. The region required for bipolar functionality of TerLS20 was delineated to a sequence of 29 bp, which is characterized by an imperfect dyad symmetry.

Progress of 1D protein structure prediction at last

Accuracy of predicting protein secondary structure and solvent accessibility from sequence information has been improved significantly by using information contained in multiple sequence alignments as input to a neural network system. For the Asilomar meeting, predictions for 13 proteins were generated automatically using the publicly available prediction method PHD. The results confirm the estimate of 72% three-state prediction accuracy. The fairly accurate predictions of secondary structure segments made the tool useful as a starting point for modeling of higher dimensional aspects of protein structure.

Crystal structure of the replication terminator protein from B. subtilis at 2.6 A

The crystal structure of the replication terminator protein (RTP) of B. subtilis has been determined at 2.6 A resolution. As previously suggested by both biochemical and biophysical studies, the molecule exists as a symmetric dimer and is in the alpha + beta protein-folding class. The protein has several uncommon features, including an antiparallel coiled-coil, which serves as the dimerization domain, and both an alpha-helix and a beta-ribbon suitably positioned to interact with the major and minor grooves of B-DNA. A site has been identified on the surface of RTP that is biochemically and positionally suitable for interaction with the replication-specific helicase. Other features of the structure are consistent with the polar contrahelicase mechanism of the protein. A model of the interaction between RTP and its cognate DNA is presented.

A checkpoint involving RTP, the replication terminator protein, arrests replication downstream of the origin during the Stringent Response in Bacillus subtilis

Regulation of DNA replication in Bacillus subtilis involves a post-initiation mechanism which is subject to control by the Stringent System, an essential regulatory network, mediated by the alarmone, ppGpp. In detailed studies using DNA-DNA hybridization procedures, we have now shown that, following the induction of the Stringent Response, replication is blocked downstream of the origin, on the left, close to the hut marker (-175 kb) and on the right, beyond the soft10 marker (+199 kb). In addition, we provide evidence that inhibition of replication under these conditions requires the replication terminator protein (RTP). In a mutant lacking RTP, a protein normally involved in termination of chromosomal replication through recognition of specific terminator sequences, replication continues past the sites normally blocked by the Stringent Response. These data strengthen the argument that this second level of control of DNA replication occurs at specific sites, the Strigent Terminus (STer) sites, either side of orlC. Such sites are presumably related to the sequence involved in RTP recognition at the terminus, terC. We propose that the binding of RTP must be modulated, perhaps through the action of ppGpp, to recognize post-initiation control sequences during the Stringent Response, in order to block replisome movement. This, therefore, acts as a checkpoint in chromosome elongation.