Structural basis for operator and antirepressor recognition by Myxococcus xanthus CarA repressor

Vitamin B12 photoreceptors

Photoreceptor proteins enable living organisms to sense light and transduce this signal into biochemical outputs to elicit appropriate cellular responses. Their light sensing is typically mediated by covalently or noncovalently bound molecules called chromophores, which absorb light of specific wavelengths and modulate protein structure and biological activity. Known photoreceptors have been classified into about ten families based on the chromophore and its associated photosensory domain in the protein. One widespread photoreceptor family uses coenzyme B₁₂ or 5'-deoxyadenosylcobalamin, a biological form of vitamin B₁₂, to sense ultraviolet, blue, or green light, and its discovery revealed both a new type of photoreceptor and a novel functional facet of this vitamin, best known as an enzyme cofactor. Large strides have been made in our understanding of how these B₁₂-based photoreceptors function, high-resolution structural descriptions of their functional states are available, as are details of their unusual photochemistry. Additionally, they have inspired notable applications in optogenetics/optobiochemistry and synthetic biology. Here, we provide an overview of what is currently known about these B₁₂-based photoreceptors, their discovery, distribution, molecular mechanism of action, and the structural and photochemical basis of how they orchestrate signal transduction and gene regulation, and how they have been used to engineer optogenetic control of protein activities in living cells.

Coenzyme B12 -dependent and independent photoregulation of carotenogenesis across Myxococcales

Light-induced carotenogenesis in Myxococcus xanthus is controlled by the B₁₂ -based CarH repressor and photoreceptor, and by a separate intricate pathway involving singlet oxygen, the B₁₂ -independent CarH paralog CarA and various other proteins, some eukaryotic-like. Whether other myxobacteria conserve these pathways and undergo photoregulated carotenogenesis is unknown. Here, comparative analyses across 27 Myxococcales genomes identified carotenogenic genes, albeit arranged differently, with carH often in their genomic vicinity, in all three Myxococcales suborders. However, CarA and its associated factors were found exclusively in suborder Cystobacterineae, with carA-carH invariably in tandem in a syntenic carotenogenic operon, except for Cystobacter/Melittangium, which lack CarA but retain all other factors. We experimentally show B₁₂ -mediated photoregulated carotenogenesis in representative myxobacteria, and a remarkably plastic CarH operator design and DNA binding across Myxococcales. Unlike the two characterized CarH from other phyla, which are tetrameric, Cystobacter CarH (the first myxobacterial homolog amenable to analysis in vitro) is a dimer that combines direct CarH-like B₁₂ -based photoregulation with CarA-like DNA-binding and inhibition by an antirepressor. This study provides new molecular insights into B₁₂ -dependent photoreceptors. It further establishes the B₁₂ -dependent pathway for photoregulated carotenogenesis as broadly prevalent across myxobacteria and its evolution, exclusively in one suborder, into a parallel complex B₁₂ -independent circuit. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

Light-Triggered Carotenogenesis in Myxococcus xanthus: New Paradigms in Photosensory Signaling, Transduction and Gene Regulation

Myxobacteria are Gram-negative δ-proteobacteria found predominantly in terrestrial habitats and often brightly colored due to the biosynthesis of carotenoids. Carotenoids are lipophilic isoprenoid pigments that protect cells from damage and death by quenching highly reactive and toxic oxidative species, like singlet oxygen, generated upon growth under light. The model myxobacterium Myxococcus xanthus turns from yellow in the dark to red upon exposure to light because of the photoinduction of carotenoid biosynthesis. How light is sensed and transduced to bring about regulated carotenogenesis in order to combat photooxidative stress has been extensively investigated in M. xanthus using genetic, biochemical and high-resolution structural methods. These studies have unearthed new paradigms in bacterial light sensing, signal transduction and gene regulation, and have led to the discovery of prototypical members of widely distributed protein families with novel functions. Major advances have been made over the last decade in elucidating the molecular mechanisms underlying the light-dependent signaling and regulation of the transcriptional response leading to carotenogenesis in M. xanthus. This review aims to provide an up-to-date overview of these findings and their significance.

A New Facet of Vitamin B12: Gene Regulation by Cobalamin-Based Photoreceptors

Living organisms sense and respond to light, a crucial environmental factor, using photoreceptors, which rely on bound chromophores such as retinal, flavins, or linear tetrapyrroles for light sensing. The discovery of photoreceptors that sense light using 5'-deoxyadenosylcobalamin, a form of vitamin B12 that is best known as an enzyme cofactor, has expanded the number of known photoreceptor families and unveiled a new biological role of this vitamin. The prototype of these B12-dependent photoreceptors, the transcriptional repressor CarH, is widespread in bacteria and mediates light-dependent gene regulation in a photoprotective cellular response. CarH activity as a transcription factor relies on the modulation of its oligomeric state by 5'-deoxyadenosylcobalamin and light. This review surveys current knowledge about these B12-dependent photoreceptors, their distribution and mode of action, and the structural and photochemical basis of how they orchestrate signal transduction and control gene expression.

Structural basis for gene regulation by a B12-dependent photoreceptor

Photoreceptor proteins enable organisms to sense and respond to light. The newly discovered CarH-type photoreceptors use a vitamin B₁₂ derivative, adenosylcobalamin, as the light-sensing chromophore to mediate light-dependent gene regulation. Here, we present crystal structures of Thermus thermophilus CarH in all three relevant states: in the dark, both free and bound to operator DNA, and after light exposure. These structures provide a visualization of how adenosylcobalamin mediates CarH tetramer formation in the dark, how this tetramer binds to the promoter −35 element to repress transcription, and how light exposure leads to a large-scale conformational change that activates transcription. In addition to the remarkable functional repurposing of adenosylcobalamin from an enzyme cofactor to a light sensor, we find that nature also repurposed two independent protein modules in assembling CarH. These results expand the biological role of vitamin B₁₂ and provide fundamental insight into a new mode of light-dependent gene regulation.

QsIA disrupts LasR dimerization in antiactivation of bacterial quorum sensing

The human pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa coordinates the expression of virulence factors by using quorum sensing (QS), a signaling cascade triggered by the QS signal molecule and its receptor, a member of the LuxR family of QS transcriptional factors (LasR). The QS threshold and response in P. aeruginosa is defined by a QS LasR-specific antiactivator (QslA), which binds to LasR and prevents it from binding to its target promoter. However, how QslA binds to LasR and regulates its DNA binding activity in QS remains elusive. Here we report the crystal structure of QslA in complex with the N-terminal ligand binding domain of LasR. QsIA exists as a functional dimer to interact with the LasR ligand binding domain. Further analysis shows that QsIA binding occupies the LasR dimerization interface and consequently disrupts LasR dimerization, thereby preventing LasR from binding to its target DNA and disturbing normal QS. Our findings provide a structural model for understanding the QslA-mediated antiactivation mechanism in QS through protein-protein interaction.

Analytical ultracentrifugation studies of oligomerization and DNA-binding of TtCarH, a Thermus thermophilus coenzyme B12-based photosensory regulator

Thermus thermophilus transcriptional factor TtCarH belongs to a newly discovered class of photoreceptors that use 5'-deoxyadenosylcobalamin (AdoB12) as the light-sensing chromophore. Photoregulation relies on the repressor activity of AdoB12-bound oligomers in the dark, which light counteracts by oligomer disruption due to AdoB12 photolysis. In this study, we investigated TtCarH self-association and binding to DNA in the dark and in the light using analytical ultracentrifugation (AUC) methods, both sedimentation velocity (SV) as well as equilibrium (SE). From a methodological point of view, this study shows that AUC can provide hydrodynamic insights in cases where light is a crucial determinant of solution properties. For the light-sensitive TtCarH, absorbance as well as interference AUC data yielded comparable results. Sedimentation coefficients and whole-body hydrodynamic analysis from SV experiments indicate that in solution apo-TtCarH and light-exposed AdoB12-TtCarH are predominantly aspherical, ellipsoidal monomers, in accord with SE data. By comparison, AdoB12-TtCarH exists as a more compact tetramer in the dark, with smaller forms such as dimers or monomers remaining undetected and low levels of larger oligomers appearing at higher protein concentrations. AUC analyses indicate that in the dark AdoB12-TtCarH associates as a tetramer with DNA but forms smaller complexes in the apo form or if exposed to light. The self-association and DNA-binding properties of TtCarH deduced from AUC are consistent with data from size-exclusion and DNA-binding gel-shift assays. AUC analyses together with hydrodynamic modeling provide insights into the AdoB12- and light-dependent self-association and DNA-binding of TtCarH.

Molecular function and potential evolution of the biofilm-modulating blue light-signalling pathway of Escherichia coli

Escherichia coli senses blue light via the BLUF-EAL protein BluF (YcgF). The degenerate EAL domain of BluF does not have cyclic-di-GMP phosphodiesterase activity, but BluF directly antagonizes the MerR-like repressor BluR (YcgE), which leads to expression of the ycgZ-ymgABC operon and activation of the Rcs system (Tschowri et al., 2009; Genes Dev 23: 522–534). While bluR, bluF and ycgZ have individual transcriptional start sites, comparative genome analysis indicates that the bluR-bluF-ycgZ-ymgAB region represents a functional unit in various enteric bacteria that is characterized by bluF alleles encoding degenerate EAL domains. Re-introducing conserved amino acids involved in phosphodiesterase activity of EAL domains did not restore enzymatic activity or c-di-GMP binding of BluF, but weakened its ability to antagonize BluR and improved a residual interaction with the BluR paralogue MlrA, which controls expression of the biofilm regulator CsgD and curli fibres. We identified the BluR binding site in the ycgZ promoter and observed that BluR also has residual affinity for the MlrA-dependent csgD promoter. Altogether, we propose that BluF evolved from a blue light-regulated PDE into a specific antagonist of a duplicate of MlrA that became BluR, which controls not only curli but various biofilm functions via the Ymg/Rcs pathway.

Light-dependent gene regulation by a coenzyme B12-based photoreceptor

Cobalamin (B(12)) typically functions as an enzyme cofactor but can also regulate gene expression via RNA-based riboswitches. B(12)-directed gene regulatory mechanisms via protein factors have, however, remained elusive. Recently, we reported down-regulation of a light-inducible promoter in the bacterium Myxococcus xanthus by two paralogous transcriptional repressors, of which one, CarH, but not the other, CarA, absolutely requires B(12) for activity even though both have a canonical B(12)-binding motif. Unanswered were what underlies this striking difference, what is the specific cobalamin used, and how it acts. Here, we show that coenzyme B(12) (5'-deoxyadenosylcobalamin, AdoB(12)), specifically dictates CarH function in the dark and on exposure to light. In the dark, AdoB(12)-binding to the autonomous domain containing the B(12)-binding motif foments repressor oligomerization, enhances operator binding, and blocks transcription. Light, at various wavelengths at which AdoB(12) absorbs, dismantles active repressor oligomers by photolysing the bound AdoB(12) and weakens repressor-operator binding to allow transcription. By contrast, AdoB(12) alters neither CarA oligomerization nor operator binding, thus accounting for its B(12)-independent activity. Our findings unveil a functional facet of AdoB(12) whereby it serves as the chromophore of a unique photoreceptor protein class acting in light-dependent gene regulation. The prevalence of similar proteins of unknown function in microbial genomes suggests that this distinct B(12)-based molecular mechanism for photoregulation may be widespread in bacteria.

Involvement of CarA/LitR and CRP/FNR family transcriptional regulators in light-induced carotenoid production in Thermus thermophilus

Members of the CarA/LitR family are MerR-type transcriptional regulators that contain a C-terminal cobalamin-binding domain. They are thought to be involved in light-induced transcriptional regulation in a wide variety of nonphototrophic bacteria. Based on the distribution of this kind of regulator, the current study examined carotenoid production in Thermus thermophilus, and it was found to occur in a light-induced manner. litR and carotenoid and cobalamin biosynthesis genes were all located on the large plasmid of this organism. litR or cobalamin biosynthesis gene knockout mutants were unable to switch off carotenoid production under dark conditions, while a mutant with a mutation in the downstream gene adjacent to litR (TT_P0055), which encodes a CRP/FNR family transcriptional regulator, was unable to produce carotenoids, irrespective of light conditions. Overall, genetic and biochemical evidence indicates that LitR is bound by cobalamin and associates with the intergenic promoter region between litR and crtB (phytoene synthase gene), repressing the bidirectional transcription of litR and crtB. It is probable that derepression of LitR caused by some photodependent mechanism induces the expression of TT_P0055 protein, which serves as a transcriptional activator for the crtB operon and hence causes the expression of carotenoid biosynthesis and the DNA repair system under light condition.

The regulatory action of the myxobacterial CarD/CarG complex: a bacterial enhanceosome?

A global regulatory complex made up of two unconventional transcriptional factors, CarD and CarG, is implicated in the control of various processes in Myxococcus xanthus, a Gram-negative bacterium that serves as a prokaryotic model system for multicellular development and the response to blue light. CarD has a unique two-domain architecture composed of: (1) a C-terminal DNA-binding domain that resembles eukaryotic high mobility group A (HMGA) proteins, which are relatively abundant, nonhistone components of chromatin that remodel DNA and prime it for the assembly of multiprotein-DNA complexes essential for various DNA transactions, and (2) an N-terminal domain involved in interactions with CarG and RNA polymerase, which is also the founding member of the large CarD_TRCF family of bacterial proteins. CarG, which does not bind DNA directly, has a zinc-binding motif of the type found in the archaemetzincin class of metalloproteases that, in CarG, appears to play a purely structural role. This review aims to provide an overview of the known molecular details and insights emerging from the study of the singular CarD-CarG prokaryotic regulatory complex and its parallels with enhanceosomes, the higher order, nucleoprotein transcription complexes in eukaryotes.

A bacterial antirepressor with SH3 domain topology mimics operator DNA in sequestering the repressor DNA recognition helix

Direct targeting of critical DNA-binding elements of a repressor by its cognate antirepressor is an effective means to sequester the repressor and remove a transcription initiation block. Structural descriptions for this, though often proposed for bacterial and phage repressor–antirepressor systems, are unavailable. Here, we describe the structural and functional basis of how the Myxococcus xanthus CarS antirepressor recognizes and neutralizes its cognate repressors to turn on a photo-inducible promoter. CarA and CarH repress the carB operon in the dark. CarS, produced in the light, physically interacts with the MerR-type winged-helix DNA-binding domain of these repressors leading to activation of carB. The NMR structure of CarS1, a functional CarS variant, reveals a five-stranded, antiparallel β-sheet fold resembling SH3 domains, protein–protein interaction modules prevalent in eukaryotes but rare in prokaryotes. NMR studies and analysis of site-directed mutants in vivo and in vitro unveil a solvent-exposed hydrophobic pocket lined by acidic residues in CarS, where the CarA DNA recognition helix docks with high affinity in an atypical ligand-recognition mode for SH3 domains. Our findings uncover an unprecedented use of the SH3 domain-like fold for protein–protein recognition whereby an antirepressor mimics operator DNA in sequestering the repressor DNA recognition helix to activate transcription.

ExsD inhibits expression of the Pseudomonas aeruginosa type III secretion system by disrupting ExsA self-association and DNA binding activity

Pseudomonas aeruginosa utilizes a type III secretion system (T3SS) to damage eukaryotic host cells and evade phagocytosis. Transcription of the T3SS regulon is controlled by ExsA, a member of the AraC/XylS family of transcriptional regulators. ExsA-dependent transcription is coupled to type III secretory activity through a cascade of three interacting proteins (ExsC, ExsD, and ExsE). Genetic data suggest that ExsD functions as an antiactivator by preventing ExsA-dependent transcription, ExsC functions as an anti-antiactivator by binding to and inhibiting ExsD, and ExsE binds to and inhibits ExsC. T3SS gene expression is activated in response to low-calcium growth conditions or contact with host cells, both of which trigger secretion of ExsE. In the present study we reconstitute the T3SS regulatory cascade in vitro using purified components and find that the ExsD.ExsA complex lacks DNA binding activity. As predicted by the genetic data, ExsC addition dissociates the ExsD.ExsA complex through formation of an ExsD.ExsC complex, thereby releasing ExsA to bind T3SS promoters and activate transcription. Addition of ExsE to the purified system results in formation of the ExsE.ExsC complex and prevents ExsC from dissociating the ExsD.ExsA complex. Although purified ExsA is monomeric in solution, bacterial two-hybrid analyses demonstrate that ExsA can self-associate and that ExsD inhibits self-association of ExsA. Based on these data we propose a model in which ExsD regulates ExsA-dependent transcription by inhibiting the DNA-binding and self-association properties of ExsA.

1H, 13C and 15N backbone and side chain resonance assignments of a Myxococcus xanthus anti-repressor with no known sequence homologues

The CarS antirepressor activates a photo-inducible promoter in Myxococcus xanthus by physically interacting with the CarA repressor and eliminating the latter's binding to operator DNA. Interestingly, interactions with both CarS and operator are crucially dependent on the DNA recognition helix of the CarA winged-helix DNA-binding domain. The CarA-CarS and the CarA-operator interfaces therefore overlap, and CarS may have structural features that mimic operator DNA. CarS has no known sequence homologues and its Gly and Pro contents are unusually high. Here, we report (1)H, (13)C and (15)N backbone and side chain assignments of CarS1, an 86-residue truncated yet fully functional variant of CarS. Secondary structural elements inferred from these data differ from those predicted from sequence.

The BLUF-EAL protein YcgF acts as a direct anti-repressor in a blue-light response of Escherichia coli

The blue light using FAD (BLUF)-EAL protein YcgF is a known blue-light sensor of Escherichia coli, but its direct regulatory output and physiological function have remained unknown. Here, we demonstrate that unlike other EAL domain proteins, YcgF does not degrade the signaling molecule c-di-GMP, but directly binds to and releases the MerR-like repressor YcgE from its operator DNA upon blue-light irradiation. As a consequence, a distinct regulon of eight small proteins (of 71-126 amino acids) is strongly induced. These include YmgA and YmgB, which, via the RcsC/RcsD/RcsB two-component phosphorelay system, activate production of the biofilm matrix substance colanic acid as well as acid resistance genes and the biofilm-associated bdm gene and down-regulate adhesive curli fimbriae. Thus, small proteins under YcgF/YcgE control seem to act as "connectors" that provide additional signal input into a two-component signaling pathway. Moreover, we found ycgF and ycgE expression to be strongly activated at low temperature, and we elucidate how blue light, cold, and starvation signals are integrated in the expression and activity of the YcgF/YcgE/small protein signaling pathway. In conclusion, this pathway may modulate biofilm formation via the two-component network when E. coli has to survive in an extrahost aquatic environment.

A vitamin B12-based system for conditional expression reveals dksA to be an essential gene in Myxococcus xanthus

Myxococcus xanthus is a prokaryotic model system for the study of multicellular development and the response to blue light. The previous analyses of these processes and the characterization of new genes would benefit from a robust system for controlled gene expression, which has been elusive so far for this bacterium. Here, we describe a system for conditional expression of genes in M. xanthus based on our recent finding that vitamin B12 and CarH, a MerR-type transcriptional repressor, together downregulate a photoinducible promoter. Using this system, we confirmed that M. xanthus rpoN, encoding sigma(54), is an essential gene, as reported earlier. We then tested it with ftsZ and dksA. In most bacteria, ftsZ is vital due to its role in cell division, whereas null mutants of dksA, whose product regulates the stringent response via transcriptional control of rRNA and amino acid biosynthesis promoters, are viable but cause pleiotropic effects. As with rpoN, it was impossible to delete endogenous ftsZ or dksA in M. xanthus except in a merodiploid background carrying another functional copy, which indicates that these are essential genes. B12-based conditional expression of ftsZ was insufficient to provide the high intracellular FtsZ levels required. With dksA, as with rpoN, cells were viable under permissive but not restrictive conditions, and depletion of DksA or sigma(54) produced filamentous, aberrantly dividing cells. dksA thus joins rpoN in a growing list of genes dispensable in many bacteria but essential in M. xanthus.

An anti-antisigma factor in the response of the bacterium Myxococcus xanthus to blue light

Cells of the Gram-negative bacterium Myxococcus xanthus respond to blue light by producing carotenoids, pigments that play a protective role against the oxidative effects of light. Blue light triggers a network of regulatory actions that lead to the transcriptional activation of the structural genes for carotenoid synthesis. The product of carF, similar to a family of proteins of unknown function called Kua, is an early regulator of this process. Previous genetic data indicate that CarF participates in the light-dependent inactivation of the antisigma factor CarR. In the dark, CarR sequesters the ECF-sigma factor CarQ to the membrane, thereby preventing the activation of the structural genes for carotenoid synthesis. Using a bacterial two-hybrid system, we show here that both CarF and CarQ physically interact with CarR. These results, together with the finding that CarF is located at the membrane, support the hypothesis that CarF acts as an anti-antisigma factor. Comparison of CarF with other Kua proteins shows a remarkable conservation of a number of histidine residues. The effects on CarF function of several histidine to alanine substitutions and of the truncation of specific CarF domains are also reported here.

Vitamin B12 partners the CarH repressor to downregulate a photoinducible promoter in Myxococcus xanthus

A light-inducible promoter, P(B), drives expression of the carB operon in Myxococcus xanthus. Repressed by CarA in the dark, P(B) is activated when CarS, produced in the light, sequesters CarA to prevent operator-CarA binding. The MerR-type, N-terminal domain of CarA, which mediates interactions with both operator and CarS, is linked to a C-terminal oligomerization module with a predicted cobalamin-binding motif. Here, we show that although CarA does bind vitamin B12, mutating the motif involved has no effect on its ability to repress P(B). Intriguingly, P(B) could be repressed in the dark even with no CarA, so long as B12 and an intact CarA operator were present. We have discovered that this effect of B12 depends on the gene immediately downstream of carA. Its product, CarH, also consists of a MerR-type, N-terminal domain that specifically recognizes the CarA operator and CarS, linked to a predicted B12-binding C-terminal oligomerization module. The B12-mediated repression of P(B) in the dark is relieved by deleting carH, by mutating the DNA- or B12-binding residues of CarH, or by illumination. Our findings unveil parallel regulatory circuits that control a light-inducible promoter using a transcriptional factor repertoire that includes a paralogous gene pair and vitamin B12.

Structural basis for antiactivation in bacterial quorum sensing

Bacteria can communicate via diffusible signal molecules they generate and release to coordinate their behavior in response to the environment. Signal molecule concentration is often proportional to bacterial population density, and when this reaches a critical concentration, reflecting a bacterial quorum, specific behaviors including virulence, symbiosis, and horizontal gene transfer are activated. Quorum-sensing regulation in many Gram-negative bacteria involves acylated homoserine lactone signals that are perceived through binding to LuxR-type, acylated-homoserine-lactone-responsive transcription factors. Bacteria of the rhizobial group employ the LuxR-type transcriptional activator TraR in quorum sensing, and its activity is further regulated through interactions with the TraM antiactivator. In this study, we have crystallographically determined the 3D structure of the TraR-TraM antiactivation complex from Rhizobium sp. strain NGR234. Unexpectedly, the antiactivator TraM binds to TraR at a site distinct from its DNA-binding motif and induces an allosteric conformational change in the protein, thereby preventing DNA binding. Structural analysis reveals a highly conserved TraR-TraM interface and suggests a mechanism for antiactivation complex formation. This structure may inform alternative strategies to control quorum-sensing-regulated microbial activity including amelioration of infectious disease and antibiotic resistance. In addition, the structural basis of antiactivation presents a regulatory interaction that provides general insights relevant to the field of transcription regulation and signal transduction.