Cellular inflammatory responses in skin of sheep selected for resistance or susceptibility to fleece rot and fly strike

The Battle Against Flystrike - Past Research and New Prospects Through Genomics

Flystrike, or cutaneous myiasis, is caused by blow fly larvae of the genus Lucilia. This disease is a major problem in countries with large sheep populations. In Australia, Lucilia cuprina (Wiedemann, 1830) is the principal fly involved in flystrike. While much research has been conducted on L. cuprina, including physical, chemical, immunological, genetic and biological investigations, the molecular biology of this fly is still poorly understood. The recent sequencing, assembly and annotation of the draft genome and analyses of selected transcriptomes of L. cuprina have given a first global glimpse of its molecular biology and insights into host-fly interactions, insecticide resistance genes and intervention targets. The present article introduces L. cuprina, flystrike and associated issues, details past control efforts and research foci, reviews salient aspects of the L. cuprina genome project and discusses how the new genomic and transcriptomic resources for this fly might accelerate fundamental molecular research of L. cuprina towards developing new methods for the treatment and control of flystrike.

The immunobiology of myiasis infections--whatever happened to vaccination?

The current state of myiasis vaccine technologies are reviewed mainly in the primary research genera of Lucilia and Hypoderma. The importance of myiasis flies as primary causes of morbidity and mortality in agricultural species and man has not diminished despite the existence of good control strategies. However, the development of vaccines against myiasis infections has been relatively quiescent for more than 10 years despite the rapid development of genomic and proteomic analysis and of skills in data interpretation. The value of vaccine research in an era of chemical primacy is analysed. In fact, recent findings of drug resistance and the impact of animal welfare concerns should mean a renewed interest in alternative controls. The reasons that this has not been true to date are explored and new possibilities discussed.

Control of the sheep blowfly in Australia and New Zealand--are we there yet?

The last 50 years of research into infections in Australia and New Zealand caused by larvae of the sheep blowfly, Lucilia cuprina, have significantly advanced our understanding of this blowfly and its primary host, the sheep. However, apart from some highly effective drugs it could be argued that no new control methodologies have resulted. This review addresses the major areas of sheep blowfly research over this period describing the significant outcomes and analyses, and what is still required to produce new commercial control technologies. The use of drugs against this fly species has been very successful but resistance has developed to almost all current compounds. Integrated pest management is becoming basic to control, especially in the absence of mulesing, and has clearly benefited from computer-aided technologies. Biological control has more challenges but natural and perhaps transformed biopesticides offer possibilities for the future. Experimental vaccines have been developed but require further analysis of antigens and formulations to boost protection. Genetic technologies may provide potential for long-term control through more rapid indirect selection of sheep less prone to flystrike. Finally in the future, genetic analysis of the fly may allow suppression and perhaps eradication of blowfly populations or identification of new and more viable targets for drug and vaccine intervention. Clearly all these areas of research offer potential new controls but commercial development is perhaps inhibited by the success of current chemical insecticides and certainly requires a significant additional injection of resources.

A genomics-informed, SNP association study reveals FBLN1 and FABP4 as contributing to resistance to fleece rot in Australian Merino sheep

BACKGROUND

Fleece rot (FR) and body-strike of Merino sheep by the sheep blowfly Lucilia cuprina are major problems for the Australian wool industry, causing significant losses as a result of increased management costs coupled with reduced wool productivity and quality. In addition to direct effects on fleece quality, fleece rot is a major predisposing factor to blowfly strike on the body of sheep. In order to investigate the genetic drivers of resistance to fleece rot, we constructed a combined ovine-bovine cDNA microarray of almost 12,000 probes including 6,125 skin expressed sequence tags and 5,760 anonymous clones obtained from skin subtracted libraries derived from fleece rot resistant and susceptible animals. This microarray platform was used to profile the gene expression changes between skin samples of six resistant and six susceptible animals taken immediately before, during and after FR induction. Mixed-model equations were employed to normalize the data and 155 genes were found to be differentially expressed (DE). Ten DE genes were selected for validation using real-time PCR on independent skin samples. The genomic regions of a further 5 DE genes were surveyed to identify single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNP) that were genotyped across three populations for their associations with fleece rot resistance.

RESULTS

The majority of the DE genes originated from the fleece rot subtracted libraries and over-representing gene ontology terms included defense response to bacterium and epidermis development, indicating a role of these processes in modulating the sheep's response to fleece rot. We focused on genes that contribute to the physical barrier function of skin, including keratins, collagens, fibulin and lipid proteins, to identify SNPs that were associated to fleece rot scores.

CONCLUSIONS

We identified FBLN1 (fibulin) and FABP4 (fatty acid binding protein 4) as key factors in sheep's resistance to fleece rot. Validation of these markers in other populations could lead to vital tests for marker assisted selection that will ultimately increase the natural fleece rot resistance of Merino sheep.

Ovine IgE and its role in immunological protection and disease

The importance of internal and external parasites in limiting productivity and compromising the welfare of sheep has provided the impetus for extensive research on ovine IgE with the objectives of better understanding protective immunological responses and developing novel methods of control; particularly vaccination. The molecular structures of ovine IgE and its high affinity receptor have been determined and the former information has assisted the development of monoclonal antibodies (mAb) to ovine IgE by 2 of 3 groups who have produced these reagents. The availability of these mAbs has enabled the description of IgE responses following infections with a wide variety of parasites in sheep and in an ovine model of atopic asthma. While IgE responses are consistently associated with parasitic diseases of sheep, it has not been proven that this antibody isotype is involved in protection. The foundation of present knowledge and reagents, together with new emerging technologies, should allow the role of IgE in parasitic diseases of sheep to be determined.

Fleece rot and dermatophilosis in sheep

Fleece rot and dermatophilosis reduce health and production of sheep and predispose them to blow fly strike. This paper reviews aetiology, prevalence, pathogenesis, resistance, attempts to develop vaccines and prospects for new control strategies to these important skin diseases. Although the severity of fleece rot is associated with the abundance of Pseudomonas aeruginosa on skin, microbial ecology studies are providing new insights into the contribution of other bacteria to the disease. Wool traits and body conformation traits that predispose sheep to fleece rot and dermatophilosis are heritable and have been used as indirect selection criteria for resistance for many years. Selection against BoLA-DRB3-DQB class II haplotype in cattle can substantially reduce the prevalence of dermatophilosis and holds promise for identification of gene markers for resistance to these bacterial diseases in sheep. Immune responses in skin and systemic antibody responses to bacterial antigens are acquired through natural infection and contribute to resistance; however, prototype antibacterial vaccines have to date failed to provide protection against the diversity of isolates of Dermatophilus congolensis and Pseudomonas species present in the field. Opportunities for future control through breeding for resistance, vaccines and non-vaccine strategies for controlling the microbial ecology of fleece are discussed. In combination, control strategies need to reduce the risk of transmission, minimise exposure of animals to stressors that enhance the risk of infection, and enhance resistance though genetics or vaccines.

Vaccination against ectoparasites

Ectoparasites of livestock are of great economic and social importance but their effective control remains difficult. The feasibility of vaccination as a novel control measure was established over a decade ago with the commercial release of a recombinant vaccine against the cattle tick Boophilus microplus. Since then, research has continued on ticks and other ectoparasites. While some ectoparasite species will undoubtedly be refractory to immunological control, for others there has been a steady accumulation of knowledge of partially protective antigens, now accelerating through the application of genomic technologies. Nevertheless, progress towards usable, commercially available vaccines has been limited by a number of factors. The number of highly effective antigens is still very small. Although some classes of antigen have been investigated in more detail than others, we have no systematic knowledge of what distinguishes an effective antigen. Much hope has been placed on the potential of multi-antigen mixtures to deliver the efficacy required of a successful vaccine but with little experimental evidence. The application of current knowledge across parasite and host species needs to be explored but little has been done. In most cases, the path to commercial delivery is uncertain. Although many constraints and challenges remain, the need for vaccines and our capacity to develop them can only increase.

A blowfly strike vaccine requires an understanding of host-pathogen interactions

The phase-out of Mulesing by 2010 means the Australian wool industry requires immediate and viable alternatives for the control and prevention of blowfly strike, an economically important parasitic disease of sheep. In this review we have analysed previous research aimed toward the development of a vaccine against blowfly strike and the reasons why the approaches taken were unsuccessful at the time. Close scrutiny has provided new insight into this host-parasite interaction and identified new opportunities for the development of a vaccine. Here we propose that addressing immunosuppression together with the induction of cellular immunity is likely to result in an anti-blowfly strike vaccine, as opposed to the use of "standard" approaches aimed at inducing humoral immunity.

16S rRNA gene microbial analysis of the skin of fleece rot resistant and susceptible sheep

Fleece rot is a bacterial dermatitis that follows prolonged wetting of the sheep’s skin, and a major pre-disposing condition to body strike in the Australian Merino. Several studies have examined bacterial load of the fleece in relation to fleece rot using traditional culture-based techniques focussing on only a few bacterial species. We examined the natural bacterial diversity of the healthy sheep skin and changes that occurred in fleece-rot resistant and susceptible animals during fleece rot development. Presented is a preliminary molecular genetic analysis of the bacterial ecology of the sheep skin. Eight 16S rRNA gene libraries were constructed from susceptible and resistant sheep both before and after onset of the disease following induction by simulated rainfall. Approximately 75% of the sequences obtained in this study have not been previously identified in fleece-rot studies. Four operational taxonomic units (OTU; groups of >97% sequence similarity) of major interest were present on susceptible animals and absent from resistant animals. Data on these OTU expand current knowledge of bacteria involved in inflammation and wounding of sheep skin tissue, and provide direction for future research that may lead to new treatment options for fleece rot and body strike.

Genetic alternatives to mulesing and tail docking in sheep: a review

A genetic solution to breech strike control is attractive, as it is potentially permanent, cumulative, would not involve increased use of chemicals and may ultimately reduce labour inputs. There appears to be significant opportunity to reduce the susceptibility of Merinos to breech strike by genetic means although it is unlikely that in the short term breeding alone will be able to confer the degree of protection provided by mulesing and tail docking. Breeding programmes that aim to replace surgical techniques of flystrike prevention could potentially: reduce breech wrinkle; increase the area of bare skin in the perineal area; reduce tail length and wool cover on and near the tail; increase shedding of breech wool; reduce susceptibility to internal parasites and diarrhoea; and increase immunological resistance to flystrike. The likely effectiveness of these approaches is reviewed and assessed here. Any breeding programme that seeks to replace surgical mulesing and tail docking will need to make sheep sufficiently resistant that the increased requirement for other strike management procedures remains within practically acceptable bounds and that levels of strike can be contained to ethically acceptable levels.

Development of a new monoclonal antibody to ovine chimeric IgE and its detection of systemic and local IgE antibody responses to the intestinal nematode Trichostrongylus colubriformis

The J558L cell line, previously transfected with the ovine Cepsilon gene, was induced to secrete a chimeric IgE protein composed of the ovine heavy chain and a mouse light chain with MW of approximately 80 and 26 kDa, respectively. After purification, the chimeric protein was used to immunise BALB-c mice and monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) were generated. The mAb 2F1, which had greatest anti-IgE activity in preliminary screens, was chosen for further characterisation and an examination of systemic and local IgE responses to the intestinal nematode, Trichostrongylus colubriformis. The chimeric IgE protein was not recognised in enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) by mAbs raised against ovine IgG1, IgG2, IgA or IgM. However, 2F1 was highly specific to the chimeric IgE protein, and did not cross-react with ovine IgG1, IgG2 or IgA. Western blot analysis also showed that 2F1 and secretory IgA (sIgA) did not cross-react, and that 2F1 and the anti-IgA mAb identified different MW bands from colostrum (approximately 200 and 400 kDa, respectively). 2F1 bound to mucosal mast cells (MMC) isolated from the intestines of lambs infected with T. colubriformis, but cultured bone marrow-derived mast cells (BMMC) required prior incubation with the chimeric IgE protein for this binding to occur. Distinctive staining of plasma cells and putative mast cells were observed using 2F1 on immunohistological sections of mesenteric lymph node and jejunum.ELISA incorporating 2F1 was able to detect >0.4 ng chimeric protein. Total IgE in ovine colostrum and intestinal homogenates was quantified using a capture ELISA, with known amounts of chimeric protein used to produce a standard curve. Colostrum from outbred Merino ewes had 0.55-11.05 ng ml(-1) total IgE, and their lambs, at necropsy after infection with a total of 18,000 T. colubriformis infective larvae over a 9-week period, had 45-620 ng g(-1) total IgE in intestinal tissue. Compared to genetically susceptible lambs, antigen-specific levels of IgE were significantly higher in genetically resistant lambs after infection with 4500 T. colubriformis infective larvae (TcL3) per week for 9 weeks (161.4 versus 44.8 geometric mean titres; P=0.043). In western blots, distinctive bands (19-21 and 27 kDa) from T. colubriformis larval antigen were differentially recognised by IgE, as identified by 2F1, in intestinal homogenates from genetically resistant animals. These results have demonstrated the value of 2F1 for quantification of IgE responses in samples derived from ovine fluids and tissues using ELISA, western blots and immunohistology. In this respect, it recognises native ovine IgE and does not require pre-treatment of the sample with denaturing agents or ammonium sulphate.

The immunology of myiasis: parasite survival and host defense strategies

Infestations by dipterous larvae that feed on dead or living vertebrate tissues for a variable period are known as myiases; these infestations reduce host physiological functions, destroy host tissues and cause significant economic losses to livestock worldwide. Recent advances in understanding the specific and nonspecific immune responses of hosts to infestation by myiasis-causing larvae and the immunological strategies evolved by larvae against the host are reviewed here. The practical implications of immunological knowledge for diagnostic and vaccination strategies are also discussed, with a view to developing environmentally sustainable control methods to be used as an alternative to chemical treatments.

Control of blowfly strike in sheep: current strategies and future prospects

Blowfly strike is a cutaneous myiasis in sheep caused by infestations of larvae principally from the family Calliphoridae, particularly the species Lucilia cuprina and Lucilia sericata. These larval infestations cause considerable economic losses to the wool industry. Established control methods have served the industry well in the past, but there are growing deficiencies with these methods. In particular, there is widespread resistance to organophosphorus insecticides and potential difficulties associated with the presence of chemical residues derived from insecticides in wool and waste products which must be disposed of by the industry. There is also growing opposition to the radical surgical procedures used to decrease the susceptibility of sheep to blowfly strike. Consequently, there is a need for the development of alternative control measures. This review examines critically the present control methods and discusses the range of options available for the development of new control strategies. Many of the latter involve novel approaches which will strongly complement current control measures.

Some relationships between age, immune responsiveness and resistance to parasites in ruminants

In the Australian livestock industries, susceptibility to infectious diseases is generally greater in young than in mature ruminants. The increased susceptibility is manifest as respiratory and intestinal infections (viral and bacterial) of calves, as well as fleece rot, flystrike and, especially, gastrointestinal parasitic infestations of young sheep. Lower resistance to infectious disease in young ruminants appears to be due largely to immunological hyporesponsiveness, and is not simply a consequence of their not having been exposed sufficiently to pathogens to develop active immunity. Young sheep have significantly lower proportions of CD4+ and CD8+ lymphocytes, but similar proportions of T19+ and B lymphocytes in blood, lymph and skin compared with mature sheep. Blood lymphocytes from young sheep produce less interferon-gamma in culture and young sheep invariably mount smaller antibody responses than do mature animals. Taken together, these findings begin to explain why young ruminants are more susceptible to infectious diseases in general, and to gastrointestinal parasites in particular, when compared to mature animals. Haematological markers of disease resistance, the prevalence of non-selected diseases and immune responses to vaccination were examined in the internal parasite-resistance flocks in Armidale NSW and the fleece rot/flystrike selection flocks at Trangie NSW. Any programme that seeks to improve resistance to parasitic or any other disease should have the capacity to make contemporary measurements of resistance to other diseases which are important in, or threaten, the production system.

Growth of Lucilia cuprina larvae following treatment of sheep divergently selected for fleece rot and fly strike with monoclonal antibodies to T lymphocyte subsets and interferon gamma

Intensive lymphocytic infiltration of the underlying dermis occurs during cutaneous myiasis caused by larvae of the blow fly, Lucilia cuprina. To determine the effect of this infiltrate on larval growth, monoclonal antibodies (mAb) to CD4, CD8 or WC1 lymphocyte subset determinants were injected intravenously before and during experimental infection of sheep with larvae. The effect of intravenous injection of mAb to ovine interferon (IFN) gamma was also examined. The experiments were performed in 18-month-old maiden ewes with genetic resistance or susceptibility to the disease complex, bacterial dermatitis/cutaneous myiasis. mAbs induced profound depletion of CD8+ and WC1+ subpopulations from blood and skin at sites of larval growth. mAb to CD4+ gave only a moderate reduction in lymphocytes from blood or skin. mAb treatments did not modify larval growth or survival at 20 or 50 h after infection. Larval growth rates did not differ between resistant and susceptible genotypes. No evidence was found for a role of T lymphocyte subpopulations or the cytokine IFN, in modifying larval growth during the first 50 h of infection. It seems unlikely that T lymphocyte-dependent immunological effector mechanisms contribute to the lower prevalence of fly strike seen in the resistant genotype in the field.

Production and characterisation of monoclonal antibodies recognising ovine IgE

Two monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), XB6 and YD3, which recognise ovine immunoglobulin E (IgE) were produced. Mast cells isolated from ovine intestinal mucosa were used as a source of IgE to immunize mice. Culture supernatants of hybridomas were screened by immunoassays on small-intestine tissue sections, isolated mucosal cells, and dot blots of lysed mast cell homogenate. Two mAbs were chosen for their specific binding to mast cells. Antigen bound by these mAbs was purified by immunoaffinity chromatography using XB6 mAb, and this produced two bands consistent with IgE heavy chain (86,000 Daltons) and immunoglobulin light chain (28,000 Daltons) when run under reducing conditions on SDS-PAGE gels. Purified IgE was shown on dot blots to react weakly with mAb to chimeric ovine IgE and strongly to polyclonal anti-sheep antibodies. The two mAbs induced an immediate hypersensitivity-like reaction when injected into the skin of sheep. The mAbs bound to mast cells and other mononuclear cells, presumably IgE-secreting B-cells in mesenteric lymph node sections. These mAbs proved useful for detecting IgE-bearing cells in various ovine tissues, for purifying mast cells from cell isolates by panning and immunomagnetic bead separation, for purifying serum IgE using immunoaffinity chromatography and for detecting IgE in an ELISA. Competitive binding assays showed that the two mAbs bind to different epitopes on IgE. These mAbs will be useful in research applications and in diagnostic assays.

Use of a monoclonal antibody to ovine IgE for fly strike studies in sheep

A new monoclonal raised against sheep IgE was used to examine sera and wound exudates from sheep which had been struck by Lucilia cuprina in the field. The antibody was also used to detect the presence of IgE in sera and skin sections from sheep which had been artificially infected with fly larvae 3 times. Neither total, nor L. cuprina specific circulating IgE could be detected in serum or wound exudates from struck sheep. Cell bound IgE was, however, identified by the monoclonal in skin sections from struck sheep and from a control sheep which had not been struck. No difference in the number of IgE positive cells was observed between the control and 2 of the 3 artificially infected sheep, and none of the latter showed an increase in IgE positive cells even after 3 infections. One sheep showed twice as many IgE positive cells as the other treated sheep and the third larval infection was difficult to establish and limited in size and severity. This suggests a relationship between innate resistance to strike and the number of IgE positive cells present in skin.