Stringent repression and homogeneous de-repression by tetracycline of a modified CaMV 35S promoter in intact transgenic tobacco plants

Optogenetic and Chemical Induction Systems for Regulation of Transgene Expression in Plants: Use in Basic and Applied Research

Continuous and ubiquitous expression of foreign genes sometimes results in harmful effects on the growth, development and metabolic activities of plants. Tissue-specific promoters help to overcome this disadvantage, but do not allow one to precisely control transgene expression over time. Thus, inducible transgene expression systems have obvious benefits. In plants, transcriptional regulation is usually driven by chemical agents under the control of chemically-inducible promoters. These systems are diverse, but usually contain two elements, the chimeric transcription factor and the reporter gene. The commonly used chemically-induced expression systems are tetracycline-, steroid-, insecticide-, copper-, and ethanol-regulated. Unlike chemical-inducible systems, optogenetic tools enable spatiotemporal, quantitative and reversible control over transgene expression with light, overcoming limitations of chemically-inducible systems. This review updates and summarizes optogenetic and chemical induction methods of transgene expression used in basic plant research and discusses their potential in field applications.

Expression of Arabidopsis WEE1 in tobacco induces unexpected morphological and developmental changes

WEE1 regulates the cell cycle by inactivating cyclin dependent protein kinases (CDKs) via phosphorylation. In yeast and animal cells, CDC25 phosphatase dephosphorylates the CDK releasing cells into mitosis, but in plants, its role is less clear. Expression of fission yeast CDC25 (Spcdc25) in tobacco results in small cell size, premature flowering and increased shoot morphogenetic capacity in culture. When Arath;WEE1 is over-expressed in Arabidopsis, root apical meristem cell size increases, and morphogenetic capacity of cultured hypocotyls is reduced. However expression of Arath;WEE1 in tobacco plants resulted in precocious flowering and increased shoot morphogenesis of stem explants, and in BY2 cultures cell size was reduced. This phenotype is similar to expression of Spcdc25 and is consistent with a dominant negative effect on WEE1 action. Consistent with this putative mechanism, WEE1 protein levels fell and CDKB levels rose prematurely, coinciding with early mitosis. The phenotype is not due to sense-mediated silencing of WEE1, as overall levels of WEE1 transcript were not reduced in BY2 lines expressing Arath;WEE1. However the pattern of native WEE1 transcript accumulation through the cell cycle was altered by Arath;WEE1 expression, suggesting feedback inhibition of native WEE1 transcription.

High-level recombinant protein expression in transgenic plants by using a double-inducible viral vector

We describe here a unique ethanol-inducible process for expression of recombinant proteins in transgenic plants. The process is based on inducible release of viral RNA replicons from stably integrated DNA proreplicons. A simple treatment with ethanol releases the replicon leading to RNA amplification and high-level protein production. To achieve tight control of replicon activation and spread in the uninduced state, the viral vector has been deconstructed, and its two components, the replicon and the cell-to-cell movement protein, have each been placed separately under the control of an inducible promoter. Transgenic Nicotiana benthamiana plants incorporating this double-inducible system demonstrate negligible background expression, high (over 0.5 × 10(4)-fold) induction multiples, and high absolute levels of protein expression upon induction (up to 4.3 mg/g fresh biomass). The process can be easily scaled up, supports expression of practically important recombinant proteins, and thus can be directly used for industrial manufacturing.

Expression of RNA-interference/antisense transgenes by the cognate promoters of target genes is a better gene-silencing strategy to study gene functions in rice

Antisense and RNA interference (RNAi)-mediated gene silencing systems are powerful reverse genetic methods for studying gene function. Most RNAi and antisense experiments used constitutive promoters to drive the expression of RNAi/antisense transgenes; however, several reports showed that constitutive promoters were not expressed in all cell types in cereal plants, suggesting that the constitutive promoter systems are not effective for silencing gene expression in certain tissues/organs. To develop an alternative method that complements the constitutive promoter systems, we constructed RNAi and/or antisense transgenes for four rice genes using a constitutive promoter or a cognate promoter of a selected rice target gene and generated many independent transgenic lines. Genetic, molecular, and phenotypic analyses of these RNAi/antisense transgenic rice plants, in comparison to previously-reported transgenic lines that silenced similar genes, revealed that expression of the cognate promoter-driven RNAi/antisense transgenes resulted in novel growth/developmental defects that were not observed in transgenic lines expressing constitutive promoter-driven gene-silencing transgenes of the same target genes. Our results strongly suggested that expression of RNAi/antisense transgenes by cognate promoters of target genes is a better gene-silencing approach to discovery gene function in rice.

Chemically regulated expression systems and their applications in transgenic plants

In the past 20 years, several systems have been developed to control transgene expression in plants using chemicals. The components used to construct these systems are derived from regulatory sequences mostly from non-plant organisms such as bacteria, fungi, insects and mammals. These constructs allowed transgene expression to be controlled temporally, spatially and quantitatively with the help of exogenous chemicals, without disturbing endogenous plant gene expression. Various chemically regulated transgene expression systems, their advantages/disadvantages and their potential for large-scale field application are reviewed.

A ROS repressor-mediated binary regulation system for control of gene expression in transgenic plants

We describe a novel binary system to control transgene expression in plants. The system is based on the prokaryotic repressor, ROS, from Agrobacterium tumefaciens, optimized for plant codon usage and for nuclear targeting (synROS). The ROS protein bound in vitro to double stranded DNA comprising the ROS operator sequence, as well as to single stranded ROS operator DNA sequences, in an orientation-independent manner. A synROS-GUS fusion protein was localized to the nucleus, whereas wtROS-GUS fusion remained in the cytoplasm. The ability of synROS to repress transgene expression was validated in transgenic Arabidopsis thaliana and Brassica napus. When expressed constitutively under the actin2 promoter, synROS repressed the expression of the reporter gene gusA linked to a modified CaMV35S promoter containing ROS operator sequences in the vicinity of the TATA box and downstream of the transcription initiation signal. Repression ranged from 32 to 87% in A. thaliana, and from 23 to 76% in B. napus. These results are discussed in relation to the potential application of synROS in controlling the expression of transgenes and endogenous genes in plants and other organisms.

Control of seed germination in transgenic plants based on the segregation of a two-component genetic system

We have developed a repressible seed-lethal (SL) system aimed at reducing the probability of transgene introgression into a population of sexually compatible plants. To evaluate the potential of this method, tobacco plants were transformed with an SL construct comprising gene 1 and gene 2 from Agrobacterium tumefaciens whereby gene 1 was controlled by the seed-specific phaseolin promoter modified to contain a binding site for the Escherichia coli TET repressor (R). The expression of this construct allows normal plant and seed development but inhibits seed germination. Plants containing the SL construct were crossed with plants containing the tet R gene to derive plant lines where the expression of the SL construct is repressed. Plant lines that contained both constructs allowed normal seed formation and germination, whereas seeds in which the SL construct was separated from the R gene through segregation did not germinate. The requirements of such a method to efficiently control the flow of novel traits among sexually compatible plants are discussed.

Chemical-inducible, ecdysone receptor-based gene expression system for plants

We have developed an inducible gene expression system with potential for field application using the ecdysone receptor (EcR) from the spruce budworm and the non-steroidal EcR agonist, methoxyfenozide. Chimeric transcription activators were constructed with EcR ligand binding domain, GAL4 and LexA DNA binding domains, and VP16 activation domain. In the presence of methoxyfenozide, the transcription activators induced expression of the luciferase reporter gene cloned downstream of a promoter containing GAL4A- or LexA-response element and a minimal 35S promoter. Low basal and high induced luciferase expression was optimized by cloning the activator and the reporter genes in different tandem orientations. Many transgenic Arabidopsis and tobacco plants were obtained with little or no basal expression in the absence of methoxyfenozide and inducible expression that was several fold higher than that observed with the constitutive 35S promoter. Moreover, gene expression was controlled over a wide range of methoxyfenozide concentration. Our results demonstrate that the inducible gene expression system based on the spruce budworm EcR ligand binding domain with methoxyfenozide as a ligand is very effective in regulating transgenes in plants. It is suitable for field applications because methoxyfenozide is commercially available and has an exceptional health and environmental safety profile.

A chimeric ecdysone receptor facilitates methoxyfenozide-dependent restoration of male fertility in ms45 maize

A mutation in the maize Ms45 gene results in abortion of microspore development and a male-sterile phenotype. MS45 protein has been localized to the tapetum and maximally expressed in anthers at the early vacuolate stage of microspore development. Molecular complementation analysis determined that a transformed copy of the gene fully restored fertility to ms45 maize. In this report, using phenotypic complementation as an assay, chimeric transcriptional activators were expressed to regulate a gal:MS45 gene and test the ability of a multi-component system to restore male fertility. A high frequency of phenotypic complementation was observed when either C1-GAL4 or VP16-GAL4 activators were transcribed by promoters that expressed at a stage of anther development that precedes the early vacuolate stage of microsporogenesis. For the conditional regulation of male fertility, these transcriptional activators were modified by the addition of regions that include the ligand-binding domain from the European corn borer ecdysone receptor to generate the nuclear receptors C1-GAL4-EcR (CGEcR) and VP16-GAL4-EcR (VGEcR). These chimeric receptors were introduced with the gal:MS45 gene into ms45 maize, and in the absence of ligand, these plants were male sterile. In contrast, application of the ecdysone agonist, methoxyfenozide, to plants containing either a constitutive (Ubiquitin1) or anther-specific (maize 5126) VGEcR resulted in the restoration of fertility to ms45 plants grown in either the greenhouse or in the field.

High molecular weight RNAs and small interfering RNAs induce systemic posttranscriptional gene silencing in plants

Posttranscriptional gene silencing (PTGS) in transgenic plants is an epigenetic form of RNA degradation related to PTGS and RNA interference (RNAi) in fungi and animals. Evidence suggests that transgene loci and RNA viruses can generate double-stranded RNAs similar in sequence to the transcribed region of target genes, which then undergo endonucleolytic cleavage to generate small interfering RNAs (siRNA) that promote degradation of cognate RNAs. The silent state in transgenic plants and in Caenorhabditis elegans can spread systemically, implying that mobile silencing signals exist. Neither the chemical nature of these signals nor their exact source in the PTGS pathway is known. Here, we use a positive marker system and real-time monitoring of green fluorescent protein expression to show that large sense, antisense, and double-stranded RNAs as well as double-stranded siRNAs delivered biolistically into plant cells trigger silencing capable of spreading locally and systemically. Systemically silenced leaves show greatly reduced levels of target RNA and accumulate siRNAs, confirming that RNA can induce systemic PTGS. The induced siRNAs represent parts of the target RNA that are outside of the region of homology with the triggering siRNA. Our results imply that siRNAs themselves or intermediates induced by siRNAs could comprise silencing signals and that these signals induce self-amplifying production of siRNAs.

Local expression of expansin induces the entire process of leaf development and modifies leaf shape

Expansins are a family of extracellular proteins proposed to play a key role in wall stress relaxation and, thus, in cell and tissue growth. To test the possible function of expansins in morphogenesis, we have developed a technique that allows transient local microinduction of gene expression in transgenic plants. We have used this system to manipulate expansin gene expression in various tissues. Our results indicate that local expansin expression within the meristem induces a developmental program that recapitulates the entire process of leaf formation. Moreover, local transient induction of expansin expression on the flank of developing primordia leads to the induction of ectopic lamina tissue and thus modulation of leaf shape. These data describe an approach for the local manipulation of gene expression and indicate a role for expansin in the control of both leaf initiation and shape. These results are consistent with the action of cell division-independent mechanisms in plant morphogenesis.

Regulation of plant growth by cytokinin

Cytokinins are a class of plant-specific hormones that play a central role during the cell cycle and influence numerous developmental programs. Because of the lack of biosynthetic and signaling mutants, the regulatory roles of cytokinins are not well understood. We genetically engineered cytokinin oxidase expression in transgenic tobacco plants to reduce their endogenous cytokinin content. Cytokinin-deficient plants developed stunted shoots with smaller apical meristems. The plastochrone was prolonged, and leaf cell production was only 3-4% that of wild type, indicating an absolute requirement of cytokinins for leaf growth. In contrast, root meristems of transgenic plants were enlarged and gave rise to faster growing and more branched roots. These results suggest that cytokinins are an important regulatory factor of plant meristem activity and morphogenesis, with opposing roles in shoots and roots.

Active expression of the ubiA gene from E. coli in tobacco: influence of plant ER-specific signal peptides on the expression of a membrane-bound prenyltransferase in plant cells

The ubiA gene from E. coli codes for 4-hydroxybenzoate: polyprenyldiphosphate 3-polyprenyltransferase, an integral membrane protein involved in ubiquinone biosynthesis. This prokaryotic membrane protein was stably expressed in tobacco using Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated transformation. Transgenic lines containing a direct fusion of the ubiA structural gene to a 35S-derived promoter gave very low enzyme activity levels (average 0.16 pkat/mg). Inclusion of an N-terminal ER-specific signal peptide from a lectin gene from Phaseolus vulgaris resulted in an average activity of 1.08 pkat/mg in the transgenic tobacco lines. The additional inclusion of a C-terminal HDEL tetrapeptide, responsible for the retention of proteins in the endoplasmic reticulum of eukaryotic cells, increased the activity to 18.6 pkat/mg. When the promotor of this construct was changed from the 35S derivative to the recently described very strong plant promoter (ocs)3mas, the activity increased further to 128.6 pkat/mg. The most active tobacco line showed activities of the introduced enzyme which exceeded those of wild-type E. coli (the source of ubiA) by a factor of 1100. These results demonstrate the efficacy of plant ER-specific signal peptides for the active expression of a prokaryotic membrane protein in plants.

A transcription activation system for regulated gene expression in transgenic plants

A widely applicable promoter system is described that allows a gene of interest to be activated in specific plant tissues after a cross between defined transgenic lines. The promoter, pOp, consists of lac operators cloned upstream of a minimal promoter. No expression was detected from this promoter when placed upstream of a beta-glucuronidase (GUS) reporter gene in transgenic plants. Transcription from the promoter was activated by crossing reporter plants with activator lines that expressed a chimeric transcription factor, LhG4. This factor comprised transcription-activation domain-II from Gal4 of Saccharomyces cerevisiae fused to a mutant lac-repressor that binds its operator with increased affinity. When LhG4 was expressed from the CaMV 35S promoter, the spatial and quantitative expression characteristics of the 35S promoter were exhibited by the GUS reporter. The LhG4/pOp system may be used to study toxic or deleterious gene products, to coordinate the expression of multiple gene products, to restrict transgene phenotypes to the F1 generation, and to generate hybrid seed. The LhG4 system offers spatially regulated gene expression in the tissues of whole plants growing under normal conditions without the need for external intervention. It complements inducible expression systems that offer temporal control of gene expression in tissues that can be treated with inducing chemicals.

Conditional control of gene expression in the mammary gland

Identifying gene function during mammary gland development and function remains a technical challenge. For example, if a gene deletion is lethal during early embryogenesis, there is no opportunity to study its effects on the development or function of the gland. Similarly, if a dominant gain of gene function alters early mammary gland development, then its specific role during lactation cannot be assessed. Conditional gene expression systems can be used to circumvent these problems. Gene deletions or dominant gain experiments can be performed in an organ or cell type specific manner at specific timepoints using inducible gene expression systems. This review focuses on tetracycline responsive transactivation and Cre-lox systems. Other tetracycline regulatable (tet system) or hormone inducible systems and the Flp recombinase system are discussed as alternative approaches. Each system is described. The advantages and disadvantages of each for studying gene function in the mammary gland are discussed. Finally, the role of mammary gland transplantation in these genetic studies is examined.

Genetic elements of plant viruses as tools for genetic engineering

Viruses have developed successful strategies for propagation at the expense of their host cells. Efficient gene expression, genome multiplication, and invasion of the host are enabled by virus-encoded genetic elements, many of which are well characterized. Sequences derived from plant DNA and RNA viruses can be used to control expression of other genes in vivo. The main groups of plant virus genetic elements useful in genetic engineering are reviewed, including the signals for DNA-dependent and RNA-dependent RNA synthesis, sequences on the virus mRNAs that enable translational control, and sequences that control processing and intracellular sorting of virus proteins. Use of plant viruses as extrachromosomal expression vectors is also discussed, along with the issue of their stability.

Tetracycline repressor-regulated gene repression in recombinant human cytomegalovirus

The tetracycline repressor (TetR)-regulated gene expression system from Escherichia coli was used to control gene expression in recombinant human cytomegalovirus (HCMV). To adapt the TetR system in HCMV, derivatives of the viral US11 (early) gene promoter, which controls the beta-glucuronidase reporter gene, were constructed by systematic insertion of the tetracycline operator (tetO) sequences. Gene expression from constructs containing two or three appropriately placed tetO sequences adjacent to the TATA box were efficiently repressed by a TetR-VP16 fusion protein (tTA) in a transient expression system. Efficient repression (50- to 120-fold) also occurred in tTA-expressing stably transfected human cells which were infected with recombinant HCMV containing a US11 promoter surrounded by three tetO sequences. The tTA-mediated gene repression was relieved in the presence of 1 microgram of tetracycline per ml. The results of this study are significant in three respects. (i) This is the first demonstration that a TetR-derived protein can be used to efficiently repress gene expression in a mammalian system. (ii) Efficient repression was dependent on the presence of the transcriptional activation domain from the herpes simplex virus type 1 VP16 protein. (iii) The ability to regulate gene expression in a controlled fashion in order to elucidate viral gene function is an important development in the HCMV field. The tTA-mediated gene repression system may be extremely useful for creating host-range mutants in essential genes in order to study their role in the HCMV replicative cycle, a system that is otherwise exceedingly difficult to genetically dissect.

Temporal control of gene expression in transgenic mice by a tetracycline-responsive promoter

Promoters whose temporal activity can be directly manipulated in transgenic animals provide a tool for the study of gene functions in vivo. We have evaluated a tetracycline-responsive binary system for its ability to temporally control gene expression in transgenic mice. In this system, a tetracycline-controlled trans-activator protein (tTA), composed of the repressor of the tetracycline-resistance operon (tet from Escherichia coli transposon Tn10) and the activating domain of viral protein VP16 of herpes simplex virus, induces transcription from a minimal promoter (PhCMV*-1; see below) fused to seven tet operator sequences in the absence of tetracycline but not in its presence. Transgenic mice were generated that carried either a luciferase or a beta-galactosidase reporter gene under the control of PhCMV*-1 or a transgene containing the tTA coding sequence under the control of the human cytomegalovirus immediate early gene 1 (hCMV IE1) promoter/enhancer. Whereas little luciferase or beta-galactosidase activity was observed in tissues of mice carrying only the reporter genes, the presence of tTA in double-transgenic mice induced expression of the reporter genes up to several thousand-fold. This induction was abrogated to basal levels upon administration of tetracycline. These findings can be used, for example, to design dominant gain-of-function experiments in which temporal control of transgene expression is required.

A visible marker for antisense mRNA expression in plants: inhibition of chlorophyll synthesis with a glutamate-1-semialdehyde aminotransferase antisense gene

Glutamate 1-semialdehyde aminotransferase [(S)-4-amino-5-oxopentanoate 4,5-aminomutase, EC 5.4.3.8] catalyzes the last step in the conversion of glutamate to delta-aminolevulinate of which eight molecules are needed to synthesize a chlorophyll molecule. Two full-length cDNA clones that probably represent the homeologous Gsa genes of the two tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) genomes have been isolated. The deduced amino acid sequences of the 468-residue-long precursor polypeptides differ by 10 amino acids. The cDNA sequence of isoenzyme 2 was inserted in reverse orientation under the control of a cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter derivative in an expression vector and was introduced by Agrobacterium-mediated transformation into tobacco plants. Antisense gene expression decreased the steady-state mRNA level of glutamate 1-semialdehyde aminotransferase, the translation of the enzyme, and chlorophyll synthesis. Remarkably, partial or complete suppression of the aminotransferase mimics in tobacco a wide variety of chlorophyll variegation patterns caused by nuclear or organelle gene mutations in different higher plants. The antisense gene is inherited as a dominant marker.

Copper-controllable gene expression system for whole plants

We describe a system for gene expression in plants based on the regulation mechanism of the yeast metallothionein (MT) gene. The system consists of two elements: (i) the yeast ace1 (activating copper-MT expression) gene encoding a transcription factor under control of the cauliflower mosaic virus (CaMV) 35S RNA promoter, and (ii) a gene of interest under control of a chimeric promoter consisting of the 90-base-pair domain A of the CaMV 35S RNA promoter linked to the ACE1 transcription factor-binding site. At elevated copper ion concentrations, the ACE1 protein changes conformation, binds to, and activates transcription from the chimeric promoter. To test the functioning of the system in plants, a construct containing the beta-glucuronidase (GUS) reporter gene under control of the chimeric promoter was prepared, and transgenic tobacco plants were produced. It was shown that GUS activity in the leaves of transgenic plants increased up to 50-fold, either after addition of 50 microM CuSO4 to the nutrient solution or after application of 0.5 microM CuSO4 to the plants in a foliar spray. This GUS expression was repressed after the removal of copper ions. The results show that the activity of the described chimeric promoter directly depends on copper ion concentration and that this system can be used in experiments that demand precise timing of expression.