Role of steric interactions in the delta opioid receptor selectivity of [D-Pen2, D-Pen5]enkephalin

Cyclic enkephalins with a diversely substituted guanidine bridge or a thiourea bridge: synthesis, biological and structural evaluations

Two series of 22 and 15 atom cyclic enkephalins incorporating a diversely substituted guanidine bridge have been prepared to assess the potential effect of the bridge substitutions on their opioid activity profile. The most notable results were obtained with the shortest cyclic analogues, which showed a significant variation of their binding affinity toward μ and δ opioid receptors in relation to bridge substitution. NMR studies were performed to rationalize these data. Some small analogues were found to exist as at least one major and one minor stable forms, which could be separated by chromatography. In particular, the compounds 13 and 14 with a cyclic substituent were separated in three isomers and the basis of this multiplicity was explored by 2D NMR spectroscopy. All compounds were agonists with slight selectivity for the μ opioid receptor. Compounds 7a (thiourea bridge) and 10a (N-Me-guanidine bridge) showed nanomolar affinity toward μ receptor, the latter being the more selective for this receptor (40-fold).

N-methylated cyclic enkephalin analogues retain high opioid receptor binding affinity

In an effort to improve the bioavailability of the non-selective, cyclic enkephalin analogues H-Dmt-c[d-Cys-Gly-Phe-d(or L)-Cys]NH(2) (Dmt = 2',6'-dimethyltyrosine), analogues N-methylated at the Phe(4) and/or Cys(5) residue were synthesized. In comparison with the non-methylated parent peptides, all mono- and N-di-methylated analogues in general retained high binding affinities at all three opioid receptors and high opioid agonist potencies in functional opioid activity assays. The results indicate that the progressive conformational restriction in these compounds upon mono- and di-N-methylation did not significantly affect the in vitro opioid activity profile. A low-energy conformer identified for the conformationally most restricted analogue of the series, H-Dmt-c[D-Cys-Gly-Phe(NMe)-L-Cys(NMe)]NH(2) (6), showed good spatial overlap of the essential pharmacophoric moieties with those in the proposed mu receptor-bound conformation of the mu-selective opioid peptide JOM-6 [H-Tyr-c(S-Et-S)[D-Cys-Phe-D-Pen]NH(2)] (Pen = penicillamine) [Mosberg M.I. and Fowler C.B. (2002) J Peptide Res; 60:329-335], in agreement with the moderate mu selectivity determined for this compound. An analogue of 6 containing (2S)-2-methyl-3-(2,6-dimethyl-4-hydroxyphenyl)propanoic acid [(2S)-Mdp] in place of Dmt(1) was an opioid antagonist with quite high opioid receptor binding affinities and can be expected to show improved bioavailability because of its further increased lipophilicity and reduced hydrogen-bonding capacity.

Assessment of delta-opioid receptor activation by a series of peptides in cultured cells

This study was designed to investigate the relative ability of a series of cyclic opioid peptides to initiate the first activation steps following their binding of delta-opioid receptors. The extent of stimulation of low Km guanosine-triphosphatase (GTPase activity) and inhibition of hormonally-stimulated cAMP accumulation in the NG108-15 (neuroblastoma-glioma) hybrid cell line were determined and compared for six closely related peptides. In addition, their binding affinity was assessed by competition with 3H-[D-Pen2D-Pen5]-enkephalin (3H-DPDPE) in membranes from these cells. All peptides tested elicited comparable maximal effects for both functional responses. Different potencies in stimulating the low Km GTPase was observed at sub-maximal agonist concentrations, although the shallow dose-response behavior did not allow accurate determination of ED50s. Estimation of ED50s for inhibition of cAMP accumulation could be made by curve fitting and were similar for four of these peptides, while DCDPE and 3R-methylDCDPE, the highest affinity analogs, were considerably more potent. In general, the observed differences in hormonal activity somewhat parallel the rank order of binding affinities, but no strict relationship was found between receptor binding and activation.

Comparative conformational analysis of [D-Pen2,D-Pen5]enkephalin (DPDPE): a molecular mechanics study

A theoretical conformational analysis (molecular mechanics study) of the delta opioid receptor-selective enkephalin analog H-Tyr-D-Pen-Gly-Phe-D-Pen-OH (DPDPE) was performed, based on the use of the SYBYL software. The study led to the identification of several conformers that were significantly lower in energy than previously reported candidate conformers of DPDPE which, for comparative purposes, were also minimized by using the standard SYBYL force field. The results revealed a considerable degree of conformational flexibility of the DPDPE molecule, and suggested that incorporation of further conformational constraints into this enkephalin analog will be necessary in order to elucidate its receptor-bound conformation.

Topographical requirements for delta-selective opioid peptides

The conformational possibilities of three different delta-selective opioid peptides, which are DPDPE (Tyr-D-Pen-Gly-Phe-D-Pen), DCFPE (Tyr-D-Cys-Phe-D-Pen), and DRE (Tyr-D-Met-Phe-His-Leu-Met-Asp-NH2, dermenkephalin), were explored using energy calculations. Sets of low-energy conformers were obtained for each of these peptides. The sets consisted of 61 structures for DPDPE, 32 for DCFPE, and 38 for DRE, including various types of rotamers of the Tyr and Phe side-chain groups. Comparison of the geometrical shapes of the conformers was performed for these sets using topographical considerations, i.e., examination of the mutual spatial arrangement of the N-terminal alpha-amino group, and of the Tyr and Phe side-chain groups. The results obtained suggest a model for the delta-receptor-bound conformer(s) for opioid peptides. The model suggests the placement of the Phe side chain in a definite position in space corresponding to the g- rotamer of Phe for peptides containing Phe4 and to the t rotamer for peptides containing Phe. The position of the Tyr1 side chain cannot be specified so precisely. The proposed model is in a good agreement with the results of biological testing of beta-Me-Phe4-substituted DPDPE analogues that were not considered in the process of model construction.

Opioid receptor affinity and selectivity effects of second residue and carboxy terminal residue variation in a cyclic disulfide-containing opioid tetrapeptide

The previously described cyclic, delta opioid receptor-selective tetrapeptide H-Tyr-D-Cys-Phe-D-Pen-OH, where Pen, penicillamine, is beta-beta-dimethylcysteine, was modified at residues 2 and 4 by varying combinations of D- and L-Cys and D- and L-Pen, and effects on mu and delta opioid receptor binding affinities and on potency in the mouse vas deferens (MVD) smooth muscle assay were evaluated. A comparison was drawn between consequences of alterations in this series of analogs and those of analogous modifications in the related cyclic pentapeptide series which includes the highly delta receptor-selective [D-Pen2,D-Pen5]enkephalin, DPDPE. Unlike effects observed in the cyclic pentapeptide series, the mu receptor binding affinities of the cyclic tetrapeptides are not dramatically influenced by substitution of Pen for Cys at residue 2. Conversely, while binding of the pentapeptides is only slightly affected by alteration of the chirality of the carboxy-terminal residue, modification of stereochemistry at the carboxy terminus in the tetrapeptides critically alters binding behavior at both mu and delta sites. In contrast with the pentapeptide series, the tetrapeptides appear to be highly dependent upon primary sequence for binding and activity, as only the lead compound binds with high affinity to the delta site. Results suggest that the less flexible cyclic tetrapeptides, lacking the Gly3 residue, display more stringent structural requirements for binding and activity than do the corresponding cyclic pentapeptides.

Single residue modifications of the delta opioid receptor selective peptide, [D-Pen2,D-Pen5]-enkephalin (DPDPE). Correlation of pharmacological effects with structural and conformational features

Six analogs of the highly delta opioid receptor selective, conformationally restricted, cyclic peptide [D-Pen2,D-Pen5]enkephalin, Tyr-D-Pen-Gly-Phe-D-PenOH (DPDPE), were synthesized and evaluated for opioid activity in rat brain receptor binding and mouse vas deferens (MVD) smooth muscle assays. All analogs were single amino acid modifications of DPDPE and employed amino acid substitutions of known effects in linear enkephalin analogs. The effect on binding affinity and MVD potency of each modification within the DPDPE structural framework was consistent with the previous reports on similarly substituted linear analogs. Conformational features of four of the modified DPDPE analogs were examined by 1H NMR spectroscopy and compared with DPDPE. From these studies it was concluded that the observed pharmacological differences with DPDPE displayed by diallyltyrosine1-DPDPE ([DAT1]DPDPE) and phenylglycine4-DPDPE ([Pgl4]DPDPE) are due to structural and/or conformational differences localized near the substituted amino acid. The observed enhanced mu receptor binding affinity of the carboxamide terminal DPDPE-NH2 appears to be founded solely upon electronic differences, the NMR data suggesting indistinguishable conformations. The observation that the alpha-aminoisobutyric acid substituted analog [Aib3]DPDPE displays similar in vitro opioid behavior as DPDPE while apparently assuming a significantly different solution conformation suggests that further detailed conformational analysis of this analog will aid the elucidation of the key structural and conformational features required for action at the delta opioid receptor.

Conformational search in enkephalin analogues containing a disulfide bond

A systematic conformational search has been performed for the 14-membered ring in model compounds for disulfide-containing enkephalin analogues. The model compounds examined are [formula: see text], and the corresponding compounds with L-amino acids at the C-terminus. About 100 starting conformations were generated for each compound with the RNGCFM program and energy minimized with the AMBER program. Between 21 and 38 conformers within 3 kcal/mole of the apparent global minimum were found for each compound. There appeared to be fewer possible conformations of the disulfide-containing side chain than of the main chain. [formula: see text], whose parent compound is selective for opioid delta receptors, was found to prefer conformers with a positive dihedral angle of the disulfide bond, which is consistent with the previous proposal that delta-receptor selectivity may be associated with this conformational preference. Additional calculations were performed on the complete structure of [formula: see text] (DPDPE) with various possible conformations of the tyrosine and phenylalanine side chains. Conformational free energies and entropies were computed for these conformers from the molecular vibrations obtained from a normal mode analysis. As was found previously, conformers with low energies tended to have lower entropies, which resulted in a narrowing of the free energy differences between conformers. A conformer is identified that has the lowest energy hitherto found for DPDPE. It is suggested that DPDPE may be a useful compound for evaluating conformational search strategies because of its relatively small size and the number of conformers that have already been identified. Conformational energy calculations are also reported for naltrindole using the MM2(87) program. Naltrindole, which incorporates two aromatic 6-membered rings in a rigid structure, is a highly selective and potent opioid delta-receptor antagonist and may be an important clue regarding the biologically active conformer of DPDPE. Various conformers of DPDPE have been superimposed quantitatively onto the structure of naltrindole using the SUPER program and those conformers of DPDPE that are the best fit to naltrindole are reported.