Donor-specific growth factors promote swine hematopoiesis in severe combined immune deficient mice

Xenotransplantation tolerance: applications for recent advances in modified swine

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The aim of this study was to review the recent progress in xenotransplantation achieved through genetic engineering and discuss the potential of tolerance induction to overcome remaining barriers to extended xenograft survival.

RECENT FINDINGS

The success of life-saving allotransplantation has created a demand for organ transplantation that cannot be met by the supply of human organs. Xenotransplantation is one possible solution that would allow for a nearly unlimited supply of organs. Recent genetic engineering of swine has decreased the reactivity of preformed antibodies to some, but not all, potential human recipients. Experiments using genetically modified swine organs have now resulted in survival of life-supporting kidneys for over a year. However, the grafts show evidence of antibody-mediated rejection on histology, suggesting additional measures will be required for further extension of graft survival. Tolerance induction through mixed chimerism or thymic transplantation across xenogeneic barriers would be well suited for patients with a positive crossmatch to genetically modified swine or relatively negative crossmatches to genetically modified swine, respectively.

SUMMARY

This review highlights the current understanding of the immunologic processes in xenotransplantation and describes the development and application of strategies designed to overcome them from the genetic modification of the source animal to the induction of tolerance to xenografts.

Transplant Tolerance: Current Insights and Strategies for Long-Term Survival of Xenografts

Xenotransplantation is an attractive solution to the problem of allograft shortage. However, transplants across discordant species barriers are subject to vigorous immunologic and pathobiologic hurdles, some of which might be overcome with the induction of immunologic tolerance. Several strategies have been designed to induce tolerance to a xenograft at both the central (including induction of mixed chimerism and thymic transplantation) and peripheral (including adoptive transfer of regulatory cells and blocking T cell costimulation) levels. Currently, xenograft tolerance has been well-established in rodent models, but these protocols have not yet achieved similar success in nonhuman primates. This review will discuss the major barriers that impede the establishment of immunological tolerance across xenogeneic barriers and the potential solution to these challenges, and provide a perspective on the future of the development of novel tolerance-inducing strategies.

Xenotransplantation: immunological hurdles and progress toward tolerance

The discrepancy between organ need and organ availability represents one of the major limitations in the field of transplantation. One possible solution to this problem is xenotransplantation. Research in this field has identified several obstacles that have so far prevented the successful development of clinical xenotransplantation protocols. The main immunologic barriers include strong T-cell and B-cell responses to solid organ and cellular xenografts. In addition, components of the innate immune system can mediate xenograft rejection. Here, we review these immunologic and physiologic barriers and describe some of the strategies that we and others have developed to overcome them. We also describe the development of two strategies to induce tolerance across the xenogeneic barrier, namely thymus transplantation and mixed chimerism, from their inception in rodent models through their current progress in preclinical large animal models. We believe that the addition of further beneficial transgenes to Gal knockout swine, combined with new therapies such as Treg administration, will allow for successful clinical application of xenotransplantation.

Immune tolerance: mechanisms and application in clinical transplantation

The achievement of immune tolerance, a state of specific unresponsiveness to the donor graft, has the potential to overcome the current major limitations to progress in organ transplantation, namely late graft loss, organ shortage and the toxicities of chronic nonspecific immumnosuppressive therapy. Advances in our understanding of immunological processes, mechanisms of rejection and tolerance have led to encouraging developments in animal models, which are just beginning to be translated into clinical pilot studies. These advances are reviewed here and the appropriate timing for clinical trials is discussed.

Role of VLA-4 and VLA-5 in ex vivo maintenance of human and pig hematopoiesis in human stroma-supported long-term cultures

OBJECTIVE

The advantage of recipient hematopoiesis over that of xenogeneic donors poses a fundamental obstacle to the induction of xenograft tolerance through mixed hematopoietic chimerism. Here we explore the role of beta1 integrins in maintenance of human vs porcine hematopoiesis within a human hematopoietic environment.

METHODS

Porcine and human c-kit+ bone marrow cells were purified and cultured on human bone marrow stroma for 6 weeks. The role of VLA-4 and VLA-5 in the maintenance of porcine vs human hematopoiesis in this human stroma-supported long-term bone marrow culture (LTBMC) system was evaluated by using blocking mAbs that bind to both species.

RESULTS

Blocking VLA-4 with HP2/1 inhibited both human and porcine hematopoiesis, whereas anti-VLA-5 (SAM-1) suppressed the function of human, but not porcine, hematopoietic cells. In mixed LTBMC of porcine and human cells on a human stroma, porcine hematopoietic cells were at a competitive disadvantage, as seen by a rapid decline in cellularity, including clonogenic progenitors. This disadvantage was substantially overcome by the addition of SAM-1. Furthermore, human, but not porcine, cell adhesion to human fibronectin was inhibited by arginine-glycine-aspartic acid (RGD) peptides.

CONCLUSION

Taken together, these results indicate that VLA-4 plays critical role for porcine hematopoiesis in a human hematopoietic environment, and raise the possibility that porcine VLA-5 might be unable to bind the respective human ligand and/or to initiate adequate post-ligand-binding signaling. Thus, VLA-5 may provide a potential target for developing approaches to improve porcine hematopoiesis in human recipients.

Application of xenogeneic stem cells for induction of transplantation tolerance: present state and future directions

Xenotransplantation using pig organs provides a possible solution to the severe shortage of allogeneic organ donors, one of the major limiting factors in clinical transplantation. However, because of the greater antigenic differences that exist between different species than within a species, the immune response to xenografts is much more vigorous than to allografts. Thus, tolerance induction is essential to the success of clinical xenotransplantation. Tolerance induced by mixed hematopoietic chimerism across the MHC barrier is remarkably robust, but its ability to induce tolerance across highly disparate xenogeneic barriers remains poorly studied. None of the current available regimens of host conditioning, which permit hematopoietic stem cell engraftment and chimerism induction in allogeneic or closely related (concordant) xenogeneic combinations, has been demonstrated to be effective in establishing porcine hematopoietic chimerism in a discordant xenogeneic species. Unlike bone marrow transplantation within the same species, the innate immune system and the species specificity of cytokines and adhesion molecules essential to hematopoiesis pose formidable obstacles to the establishment of donor hematopoiesis across discordant xenogeneic barriers. The genetic incompatibility between species may also impede xenograft tolerance induction by mixed chimerism. While we remain far from achieving tolerance in clinical xenotransplantation, recent studies using a transgenic mouse model have proven the principle that mixed hematopoietic chimerism may induce mouse and human T cell tolerance to porcine xenografts. This review article focuses on the barriers to porcine hematopoietic engraftment in highly disparate xenogeneic species and the possible application of mixed hematopoietic chimerism to xenograft tolerance induction.

Construction of ectopic xenogeneic bone marrow structure associated with persistent multi-lineage mixed chimerism by engraftment of rat bone marrow plugs into mouse kidney capsules

Poor bone marrow (BM) engraftment in a xenogeneic combination results at least in part from the limited engraftment capacity of BM-derived stromal cells, which support hematopoietic repopulation in a species-specific fashion. We attempted to construct a BM stromal microenvironment by engraftment of BM plug fragments into kidney capsules in a rat-to-mouse combination. BM plugs from F344/N Jcl-rnu/rnu (F344 nu) rats were transplanted into the kidney capsules of C.B-17 scid/scid (C.B-17 scid) mice treated with rabbit anti-asialo-GM1 serum to deplete natural killer (NK) cells and then with 3 Gy of whole body irradiation. As a conventional control, an equivalent amount of F344 nu bone marrow cells (BMCs) was intravenously injected into C.B-17 scid mice treated with a similar conditioning regimen. In both mouse recipients of rat BM plug engraftment in the kidney capsules and recipients of intravenous injection of rat BMC suspension, comparable extents of donor rat class I+ cells were persistently detected in the peripheral blood. However, the differentiation of rat-derived B cells in the mouse recipients of rat BM plugs was more rapid than that in the recipients of rat BMC suspension. In the late phase (10 weeks after BM transplantation), the percentage of rat-derived T cells (CD4+ cells) in the mouse recipients of rat BM plugs was significantly higher than that in the recipients of rat BMC suspension. At this time point, ectopic BM structure consisting of bone, mesenchymal cells, and hematopoietic progenitors was constructed in the kidney capsules of mice that received rat BM plugs. Most of the cells in the ectopic BM were derived from the donor rat. Thus, engraftment of BM plugs into the kidney capsules results in the construction of a donor-derived BM microenvironment, facilitating multilineage mixed xenogeneic chimerism.

B cell tolerance to xenoantigens

Xenotransplantation of pig organs to humans is a possible solution to the shortage of donor organs for transplantation. Multiple immunologic barriers need to be overcome if pig-to-primate transplantation is to be successful. The presence, in humans, of natural antibodies (Abs) directed against Galalpha1-3Galbeta1-4GlcNAc epitopes on pig vascular endothelium provides the major barrier, as antibody-antigen binding initiates the process of hyperacute rejection. Even if hyperacute rejection is prevented, acute vascular rejection develops. Acute vascular rejection is also mediated, in part, by xenoreactive Abs and may be complement-independent. Efforts being made to overcome antibody-mediated rejection include depletion of antibody by extracorporeal immunoadsorption, prevention of an induced Ab response by pharmacologic reagents, B-cell and/or plasma cell depletion, depletion or inhibition of complement, and the use of organs from pigs transgenic for human complement regulatory proteins. The ultimate solution would be the induction of B-cell tolerance to xenogeneic antigens, which is being explored by attempting to induce xenogeneic hematopoietic chimerism. Here, we review the properties of the B cell types responding to xenoantigens and the strategies for tolerizing those B cells.

Porcine mononuclear cells adhere to human fibronectin independently of very late antigen-5: implications for donor-specific tolerance induction in xenotransplantation

To combat the shortage of donor organs, transplantation across species barriers has been proposed. Induction of tolerance would overcome the substantial immunologic barriers to xenotransplantation and would avoid the chronic use of immunosuppressive agents. Successful transplantation of hematopoietic cells induces robust specific tolerance to donor antigens in allogeneic and xenogeneic models. The beta1 integrin class of adhesion molecules and their interactions with extracellular matrix components are thought to be integral to the engraftment and maturation of hematopoietic stem cells. We therefore examined the efficacy of porcine very late antigen-5 (VLA-5) and VLA-4 interactions with the human extracellular matrix (ECM) protein, fibronectin. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) from humans and miniature swine were flourochrome labeled and adhesion to plates coated with whole human fibronectin (whFN) or its 120 KDa fragment containing the VLA-5 binding region was determined. Flow cytometry and immuno- precipitation were used to identify a monoclonal antibody that cross-reacted on porcine VLA-5. Human and pig PBMC adhesion to human fibronectin (hFN) or 120 kDa fragment-coated plates was assessed following incubation with control ab, anti-VLA-4, anti-VLA-5, or soluble fibronectin. Using rabbit complement, cells expressing VLA-5 were purged from PBMC preparations before performing the adhesion assay. Porcine and human PBMC both adhered to hFN in a divalent cation-dependent and activation-dependent manner. Adhesion to hFN of human but not pig PBMC was blocked by anti-VLA-5 monoclonal antibody SAM-1, although this mAb immunoprecipitated a heterodimeric cell surface molecule (155/135 kDa) resembling VLA-5 from pig PBMC. Complement-mediated depletion of VLA-5-expressing cells ablated specific binding of human but not porcine cells to hFN and its 120 kDa fragment. Addition of soluble fibronectin was capable of blocking adhesion of PBMC of both species to hFN. Anti-VLA-4 reduced the binding of PBMC from both species to hFN to a similar extent. Human and pig cells can specifically adhere to hFN and its 120 kDa fragment, suggesting that this critical cell-ECM interaction is preserved across species. While human cells exclusively use VLA-5 for binding to the 120 kDa fragment, porcine cells could not be shown to adhere to whFN or its 120 kDa fragment via VLA-5. However, porcine VLA-4 is capable of mediating adhesion to human FN. We conclude that disparities in the adhesive interactions of beta1 integrins may be a barrier to the use of porcine hematopoietic stem cell transplantation as a means of inducing donor-specific tolerance in the pig to human species combination.

Mixed chimerism induces donor-specific T-cell tolerance across a highly disparate xenogeneic barrier

Induction of tolerance is likely to be essential for successful xenotransplantation because immune responses across xenogeneic barriers are vigorous. Although mixed hematopoietic chimerism leads to stable donor-specific tolerance in allogeneic and closely related xenogeneic (eg, rat-to-mouse) combinations, the ability of this approach to induce tolerance across a highly disparate xenogeneic barrier has not yet been demonstrated. In this study, we investigated the immune responses of murine T cells that developed in mice with pre-established porcine hematopoietic chimerism. Our results show for the first time that induction of porcine hematopoietic chimerism can eliminate the development of antiporcine donor responses in a highly disparate xenogeneic species. Porcine hematopoietic chimeras showed donor-specific nonresponsiveness in the mixed lymphocyte reaction, lack of antidonor IgG antibody production, and acceptance of donor skin grafts. Thus, mixed chimerism is capable of inducing tolerance in a highly disparate xenogeneic combination and may have clinical potential to prevent xenograft rejection. (Blood. 2002;99:3823-3829)

Porcine hematopoiesis on primate stroma in long-term cultures: enhanced growth with neutralizing tumor necrosis factor-alpha and tumor growth factor-beta antibodies

BACKGROUND

Donor hematopoiesis is at a competitive disadvantage when bone marrow transplantation is across species barriers. This could present major limitations to xenogeneic stem cell transplantation as an approach to tolerance induction. An in vitro model of xenogeneic engraftment was established to identify inhibitors of porcine hematopoiesis in a primate environment.

METHODS

Porcine bone marrow cells (BMC), in the presence or absence of primate CD34+ positive cells, were cultured for 4-6 weeks on primate stroma with porcine cytokines. Cellularity and growth of colony-forming cells were indicators of hematopoietic growth. Effects of soluble factors were determined by using Transwell inserts to separate porcine cells from stroma. Neutralizing antibodies for human transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) were added to cultures.

RESULTS

Porcine hematopoiesis can be maintained in long-term cultures on primate stroma with pig cytokines. Adding BMC to the stroma below Transwell-containing porcine cells dramatically inhibited porcine hematopoiesis, showing an inhibitory role for soluble factors. Neutralizing antibodies against TNF-alpha or TGF-beta caused a modest enhancement of porcine hematopoiesis; however, the combination of both led to a substantial increase. Inhibitory effects of these cytokines were confirmed by adding TNF-alpha and TGF-beta to porcine cultures.

CONCLUSIONS

Porcine cells may be more sensitive to inhibitory effects of TNF-alpha and TGF-beta than primate cells and are at a disadvantage when in a primate environment. Potential implications of this observation are discussed in the context of establishing specific immune tolerance via mixed chimerism to facilitate xenotransplantation.

Elimination of porcine hemopoietic cells by macrophages in mice

The difficulty in achieving donor hemopoietic engraftment across highly disparate xenogeneic species barriers poses a major obstacle to exploring xenograft tolerance induction by mixed chimerism. In this study, we observed that macrophages mediate strong rejection of porcine hemopoietic cells in mice. Depletion of macrophages with medronate-encapsulated liposomes (M-liposomes) markedly improved porcine chimerism, and early chimerism in particular, in sublethally irradiated immunodeficient and lethally irradiated immunocompetent mice. Although porcine chimerism in the peripheral blood and spleen of M-liposome-treated mice rapidly declined after macrophages had recovered and became indistinguishable from controls by wk 5 post-transplant, the levels of chimerism in the marrow of these mice remained higher than those in control recipients at 8 wks after transplant. These results suggest that macrophages that developed in the presence of porcine chimerism were not adapted to the porcine donor and that marrow-resident macrophages did not phagocytose porcine cells. Moreover, M-liposome treatment had no effect on the survival of porcine PBMC injected into the recipient peritoneal cavity, but was essential for the migration and relocation of these cells into other tissues/organs, such as spleen, bone marrow, and peripheral blood. Together, our results suggest that murine reticuloendothelial macrophages, but not those in the bone marrow and peritoneal cavity, play a significant role in the clearance of porcine hemopoietic cells in vivo. Because injection of M-liposomes i.v. mainly depletes splenic macrophages and liver Kupffer cells, the spleen and/or liver are likely the primary sites of porcine cell clearance in vivo.

Mixed chimerism

Induction of mixed chimerism has the potential to overcome the current limitations of transplantation, namely chronic rejection, complications of immunosuppressive therapy and the need for xenografts to overcome the current shortage of allogeneic organs. Successful achievement of mixed chimerism had been shown to tolerize T cells, B cells and possibly natural killer cells, the lymphocyte subsets that pose major barriers to allogeneic and xenogeneic transplants. Current understanding of the mechanisms involved in tolerization of each cell type is reviewed. Considerable advances have been made in reducing the potential toxicity of conditioning regimens required for the induction of mixed chimerism in rodent models, and translation of these strategies to large animal models and in a patient are important advances toward more widespread clinical application of the mixed chimerism approach for tolerance induction.

T cell and B cell tolerance to GALalpha1,3GAL-expressing heart xenografts is achieved in alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase-deficient mice by nonmyeloablative induction of mixed chimerism

BACKGROUND

We have previously demonstrated that mixed xenogeneic chimerism and donor-specific T-cell tolerance can be induced in the rat-to-mouse species combination by using a relatively nontoxic, nonmyeloablative conditioning regimen. However, natural antibodies (NAbs) against Galalpha1,3Gal (Gal) pose an additional major barrier to pig-to-human vascularized xenograft acceptance.

METHODS

To determine whether the mixed chimerism approach could also overcome this humoral barrier, T cell-depleted rat (GalT+/+) bone marrow cells (BMC) were transplanted to alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase deficient (GalT-/-) mice conditioned with a nonmyeloablative regimen, consisting of transient T cell and natural killer (NK) cell depletion, 3 Gy whole body irradiation, and 7 Gy thymic irradiation.

RESULTS

By giving a high dose (180x106) of rat BMC, persistent mixed chimerism could be induced in GalT-/- mice, although the level of donor-type hematopoietic repopulation declined over time. Induction of mixed chimerism was associated with a rapid disappearance of anti-Gal and anti-rat NAb in the sera. Both anti-Gal Ab-producing cells and B cells with receptors recognizing Gal were undetectable in mixed chimeras, even when the chimerism levels declined, suggesting that a very low level of chimerism could effectively maintain B-cell tolerance to Gal, probably by clonal deletion and/or receptor editing. Mixed chimeras accepted subsequently transplanted donor-type rat hearts (>100 days) without immunosuppressive therapy, whereas delayed vascular and even hyperacute rejection of rat hearts occurred in conditioned control GalT-/- mice. Cellular rejection occurred by 5-6 days in conditioned control wild-type mice.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings demonstrate that induction of mixed chimerism with a nonmyeloablative regimen can prevent vascularized xenograft rejection by cellular and anti-Gal Ab-dependent pathways in GalT+/+-to-GalT-/- species combinations.

Mixed chimerism and transplantation tolerance

Achieving transplantation tolerance is an important goal in the effort to reduce long-term morbidity and mortality in organ transplant recipients. Robust, lifelong, donor-specific tolerance can be reliably achieved by induction of mixed chimerism in various animal models. To date, the clinical application of these proto-cols has been impeded partly by the potential toxicity of the required host conditioning regimens and the lack of successful studies in large animals. This article reviews the progress achieved in recent years in developing considerably milder conditioning protocols in rodents, and in extending some of these models to achieve permanent mixed chimerism and tolerance in large animals. Advances in the induction of xenogeneic tolerance through mixed chimerism are also discussed.

Xenogeneic transplantation

This review summarizes the clinical history and rationale for xenotransplantation; recent progress in understanding the physiologic, immunologic, and infectious obstacles to the procedure's success; and some of the strategies being pursued to overcome these obstacles. The problems of xenotransplantation are complex, and a combination of approaches is required. The earliest and most striking immunologic obstacle, that of hyperacute rejection, appears to be the closest to being solved. This phenomenon depends on the binding of natural antibody to the vascular endothelium, fixation of complement by that antibody, and finally, activation of the endothelium and initiation of coagulation. Therefore, these three pathways have been targeted as sites for intervention in the process. The mechanisms responsible for the next immunologic barrier, that of delayed xenograft/acute vascular rejection, remain to be fully elucidated. They probably also involve multiple pathways, including antibody and/or immune cell binding and endothelial cell activation. The final immunologic barrier, that of the cellular immune response, involves mechanisms that are similar to those involved in allograft rejection. However, the strength of the cellular immune response to xenografts is so great that it is unlikely to be controlled by the types of nonspecific immunosuppression used routinely to prevent allograft rejection. For this reason, it may be essential to induce specific immunologic unresponsiveness to at least some of the most antigenic xenogeneic molecules.

Porcine stem cell engraftment and seeding of murine thymus with class II+ cells in mice expressing porcine cytokines: toward tolerance induction across discordant xenogeneic barriers

BACKGROUND

Mixed hematopoietic chimerism is a reliable means of tolerance induction, but its utility has not been demonstrated in discordant xenogeneic combinations because of the difficulty in achieving lasting hematopoietic engraftment. Miniature swine are likely to be suitable organ donors for humans. To evaluate the ability of mixed chimerism to induce swine-specific tolerance in widely disparate xenogeneic recipients, this study aimed to achieve long-lasting chimerism in a pig to mouse combination.

METHODS

Immunodeficient transgenic mice were developed by crossing transgenic founders carrying porcine interleukin-3, granulocyte macrophage-colony stimulating factor, and stem cell factor genes with severe combined immunodeficient mice or non-obese diabetic/severe combined immunodeficient mice. Swine bone marrow transplantation was performed in these mice, and porcine chimerism was followed for 20 weeks.

RESULTS

Whereas swine cells became undetectable in all non-Tg littermates by 7 weeks, high levels of porcine hematopoietic chimerism, including the presence of porcine class II+ cells in the host thymus were maintained in Tg mice for >20 weeks. Colony-forming assays revealed the presence of large numbers of swine hematopoietic progenitor cells in the marrow of these mice at 20 weeks after bone marrow transplantation.

CONCLUSIONS

These transgenic mice demonstrate for the first time that spontaneous migration of marrow donor antigen-presenting cells to an intact recipient thymus can occur and that porcine stem cells can persist in this highly disparate species combination. These data therefore support the feasibility of the eventual goal of tolerance induction by mixed chimerism in discordant xenogeneic combinations.

Mixed chimerism as an approach to transplantation tolerance

The induction of tolerance to transplanted organs could make transplantation safer and more uniformly successful. One of the most promising approaches currently being investigated involves the induction of deletional tolerance through the establishment of "mixed chimerism." In this laboratory, we first studied mixed chimerism as an approach to transplantation tolerance in mice, using a nonmyeloablative preparative regimen consisting of 300 R whole-body irradiation, 700 R thymic irradiation, and treatment with monoclonal antibodies to CD4 and CD8. This approach has subsequently been extended successfully to the induction of tolerance to renal transplants in fully mismatched cynomolgus monkeys. In addition, the same approach, with minor modifications, has been found effective in producing mixed chimerism and transplantation tolerance in the concordant xenogeneic baboon to cynomolgus monkey species combination. Because pigs have many advantages as a potential xenograft donor for humans, we are also trying to extend our nonmyeloablative regimen for production of mixed chimerism to the discordant pig --> primate combination. We have used absorption of natural antibodies to prevent hyperacute rejection and then proceeded with a mixed chimerism approach. Administration of pig hematopoietic stem cells along with pig recombinant cytokines (SCF and IL-3) to primates has enabled the pig bone marrow to survive in these xenogeneic hosts for over 6 months. This chimerism has apparently been sufficient to markedly diminish T cell immunity and the induction of new T-cell-dependent responses. However, to date we have not succeeded in preventing the return of natural antibodies, which appear to be the cause of eventual loss of organ transplants and are the subject of further intensive investigations.

Role of antibody-independent complement activation in rejection of porcine bone marrow cells in mice

BACKGROUND

Although complement activation has been shown to be important in the rejection of solid organs in some xenogeneic species combinations, its role in the rejection of xenogeneic marrow engraftment is unknown.

METHODS

The effect of complement depletion with cobra venom factor on porcine bone marrow cell (BMC) engraftment was examined in 3 Gy-irradiated C.B-17 severe combined immunodeficiency mice receiving 10(8) pig BMC.

RESULTS

At 26 days after transplantation, the percentages of swine class I+, myeloid, and CD2+ cells in marrow, spleen, and peripheral blood, and the numbers of porcine myeloid progenitor cells in marrow, were increased in cobra venom factor-treated recipients compared with simultaneous control recipients. Consistent with the in vivo results, preheating serum (56 degrees C for 30 min) reduced the inhibitory effect of severe combined immunodeficiency mouse serum on the proliferation of pig BMC in vitro.

CONCLUSION

Murine complement is capable of resisting xenogeneic hematopoietic engraftment through an antibody-independent mechanism.

Xenotransplantation

BACKGROUND

Over the past 10 years xenotransplantation has generated much interest in the hope that it will enable us to overcome the current lack of human organ donors. This review examines the evolution and current therapeutic strategies that have been developed to overcome the predominant problem of graft rejection.

METHODS

A literature review was undertaken using a Medline search from January 1966 to August 1999.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSION

Despite the considerable advances that have been made in molecular biological techniques, xenograft rejection cannot be prevented without significant immunosuppression and toxic side-effects. The problem of delayed rejection, in particular, will probably be very difficult to overcome, although some of the difficulties associated with hyperacute rejection have been resolved. The potential risk of porcine endogenous retrovirus transmission has generated much debate recently, but it is likely that some of the important issues relating to xenotransplantation will never be resolved until carefully regulated clinical trials are allowed to begin.

Mixed chimerism induced without lethal conditioning prevents T cell- and anti-Gal alpha 1,3Gal-mediated graft rejection

Gal alpha 1,3Gal-reactive (Gal-reactive) antibodies are a major impediment to pig-to-human xenotransplantation. We investigated the potential to induce tolerance of anti-Gal-producing cells and prevent rejection of vascularized grafts in the combination of alpha 1,3-galactosyltransferase wild-type (GalT(+/+)) and deficient (GalT(-/-)) mice. Allogeneic (H-2 mismatched) GalT(+/+) bone marrow transplantation (BMT) to GalT(-/-) mice conditioned with a nonmyeloablative regimen, consisting of depleting CD4 and CD8 mAb's and 3 Gy whole-body irradiation and 7 Gy thymic irradiation, led to lasting multilineage H-2(bxd) GalT(+/+) + H-2(d) GalT(-/-) mixed chimerism. Induction of mixed chimerism was associated with a rapid reduction of serum anti-Gal naturally occurring antibody levels. Anti-Gal-producing cells were undetectable by 2 weeks after BMT, suggesting that anti-Gal-producing cells preexisting at the time of BMT are rapidly tolerized. Even after immunization with Gal-bearing xenogeneic cells, mixed chimeras were devoid of anti-Gal-producing cells and permanently accepted donor-type GalT(+/+) heart grafts (>150 days), whereas non-BMT control animals rejected these hearts within 1-7 days. B cells bearing receptors for Gal were completely absent from the spleens of mixed chimeras, suggesting that clonal deletion and/or receptor editing may maintain B-cell tolerance to Gal. These findings demonstrate the principle that induction of mixed hematopoietic chimerism with a potentially relevant nonmyeloablative regimen can simultaneously lead to tolerance among both T cells and Gal-reactive B cells, thus preventing vascularized xenograft rejection.

Enhancement of swine progenitor chimerism in mixed swine/human bone marrow cultures with swine cytokines

OBJECTIVE

The induction of transplantation tolerance across xenogeneic barriers by bone marrow transplantation holds great promise, but engraftment of xenogeneic stem cells has been difficult to achieve. Part of this difficulty is due to species-specific differences in regulatory cytokines and elements of the stromal microenvironment, which we studied here.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We developed a system where fresh bone marrow cells from swine and human are cultured on human bone marrow stroma in order to study these limiting factors in a clinically relevant species combination.

RESULTS

We report here the ability of recombinant swine interleukin (IL)-3 and c-kit ligand (KL) to specifically enhance swine hematopoietic chimerism in this system. In the absence of exogenous swine cytokines, there were about half as many swine progenitors as human progenitors at 1, 2, and 4 weeks of culture. When used alone, swine IL-3 led to a notable but transient increase in the relative ratio of swine progenitors, while addition of swine KL increased the ratio of swine progenitors only modestly and only at later time points. In contrast, when swine IL-3 and KL were added together, there was a two- to fourfold increase in the ratio of swine to human progenitors at all times tested.

CONCLUSION

These data demonstrate that both swine IL-3 and KL are needed for prolonged enhancement of swine progenitor chimerism under these conditions, and suggest that the species specificity of either one or both of these cytokines may represent an important barrier to prolonged engraftment of swine bone marrow in humans.

Efficacy of adhesive interactions in pig-to-human xenotransplantation

Successful xenotransplantation depends on many factors, one being the interactions of cross-species adhesion molecule-ligand pairs. Depending on the approach used to facilitate xenotransplantation, these interactions can play differing roles. Here, André Simon, Anthony Warrens and Megan Sykes review the existing information on pig-to-human adhesive interactions and its implication for different approaches to pig-to-human xenotransplantation.

Effect of pig-specific cytokines on mobilization of hematopoietic progenitor cells in pigs and on pig bone marrow engraftment in baboons

Mixed hematopoietic chimerism has been found to be a requirement for achieving specific immunologic hyporesponsiveness. Some of the requirements for in vitro and in vivo coexistence of discordant hematopoietic systems in the pig-to-baboon (or human) model have been investigated. We have tested the efficacy of pig-specific cytokines (PSC) (IL3, SCF, GM-CSF) in the mobilization of porcine bone marrow (BM) progenitors in vivo (i) in the pig and (ii) in baboons that underwent a conditioning regimen and porcine BM transplantation. In a preliminary in vitro study, porcine BM cells were incubated in various media to assess the effect of human plasma on pig progenitors in a colony-forming unit (CFU) assay. In in vivo studies, four pigs received PSC and one control pig did not. Six baboons underwent natural antibody removal, with subsequent pig BM transplantation. Four of these six underwent nonmyeloablative (n=2) or myeloablative (n=2) conditioning and all received PSC treatment. Two baboons did not receive PSC, one of which underwent a nonmyeloablative regimen. Sequential blood samples and BM biopsies in pigs and baboons were analyzed by CFU assay for the detection of porcine cells. Baboon samples were analyzed by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to detect porcine DNA. In the case of the in vitro tests, colony forming by porcine progenitors was not inhibited by media containing human plasma and for the in vivo tests, PSC increased the number of progenitors in pig BM; mobilization of progenitors into the peripheral blood was observed. PSC-treated baboons which experienced transient depletion of leukocytes < 1,000/ml (as an effect of the conditioning regimen) had porcine BM cells detectable by PCR for as long as day 316 after BM transplantation. In conclusion we found that: (i) under the conditions of these studies, in vitro porcine progenitor cell growth was not inhibited by human plasma containing natural antibody and complement; (ii) PSC treatment led to an increased number of progenitors in pig BM and peripheral blood; (iii) the combination of an effective conditioning regimen and treatment with PSC was capable of inducing long-term survival of pig progenitors in baboons, although only a low level of engraftment was achieved.

T cell-mediated xenograft rejection: specific tolerance is probably required for long term xenograft survival

T cell-mediated mechanisms of xenograft rejection appear resistant to standard immunosuppression protocols used to prevent allograft rejection and, consequently, higher doses of immunosuppressive drugs are required to promote xenograft compared to allograft survival. Evidence from recent studies suggests that porcine xenografts may be especially immunogenic in humans because of a prominent and vigorous indirect xenoresponse and because of the ability of porcine endothelium to activate human T cells. This has led to an anxiety that systemic immunosuppressives, used as the mainstay of therapy for clinical xenotransplantation, may not allow the long-term survival of porcine organs transplanted into human recipients. This article will review the biology of T cell xenoresponses, present the case for the development of novel graft-specific immunosuppressive regimes in clinical xenotransplantation, and review recent experimental progress in this area.

Function of porcine adhesion molecules in a human marrow microenvironment

BACKGROUND

One way to circumvent the need for chronic immunosuppression in solid organ xenografting may be to induce donor-specific tolerance using bone marrow transplantation. If this approach is to succeed in the pig-to-human species combination, pig marrow must be capable of maturing into relevant tolerance-inducing cells and replenishing itself in host human marrow. One possible barrier is adhesion molecule incompatibility. We have studied the compatibility across the pig-human species barrier of two well-characterized ligands known to be important in hematopoiesis, CD44 and very late antigen (VLA)-4.

METHODS

In vitro long-term bone marrow cultures were studied in which the effects of blocking antibodies were assessed by measuring cell numbers and colony-forming units.

RESULTS

The blocking of CD44 had a comparable inhibitory effect on the hematopoiesis of human and pig marrow, even if the latter was maintained on a human stromal layer. Both cellular proliferation and colony-forming activity were inhibited by anti-CD44 monoclonal antibody. By contrast, a significant difference was observed in VLA-4 usage by hematopoietic cells of the two species. Blocking VLA-4 markedly inhibited human hematopoietic cellular proliferation but had no effect on pig hematopoiesis, on either porcine or human stroma.

CONCLUSIONS

The data suggest that the incompatibility of either CD44 or VLA-4 is unlikely to limit the efficiency of porcine hematopoiesis in a human marrow environment. However, the difference in VLA-4 utilization between these species raises the possibility that other interactions may be important for effective porcine hematopoiesis and that their failure to function between species may contribute to the poor function of porcine hematopoietic cells in primate marrow microenvironments.

Mixed hematopoietic chimerism and transplantation tolerance

Durable transplantation tolerance can be reliably achieved by inducing engraftment of hematopoietic cells in recipients initially depleted of T-lymphocytes. Engraftment of donor pluripotent hematopoietic stem cells (PPHSC) produces mixed hematopoietic chimeras in which both host and donor cells coexist and are tolerant of each other. The major mechanism of tolerance in these chimeras is central, intrathymic clonal deletion, which is induced and maintained by immigration of both host and donor marrow-derived cells to the host thymus, ensuring the ongoing central deletion of donor- and host-reactive cells. In this article, approaches developed in our laboratory to induce stable mixed hematopoietic chimerism and specific central deletional allogeneic and xenogeneic tolerance without toxic or myeloablative host conditioning are reviewed.