Discordant liver transplantation in the guinea pig to rat model does not lead to classical hyperacute rejection

Naturally acquired anti-alpha Gal antibodies in a murine allograft model similar to delayed xenograft rejection

Antibodies directed against galactose-alpha1,3-galactose (alphaGal) are believed to play an important role in the pathogenesis of delayed xenograft rejection (DXR). This study was designed to determine whether alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase-deficient (Gal KO) mice can naturally acquire a sufficient anti-alphaGal titre to cause the delayed type rejection of alphaGal-expressing hearts. Gal KO mice of various ages were assessed for anti-alphaGal antibody levels. alphaGal-expressing hearts were transplanted heterotopically into these mice and monitored daily. Rejecting and surviving hearts were evaluated histologically. In Gal KO mice greater than 6-month-old, 64% had an anti-alphaGal antibody titre above the background level. When wild-type alphaGal-expressing hearts were transplanted into this group, 45% of grafts rejected within 5 to 13 days. Histological examination of the rejected hearts displayed marked tissue damage and an inflammatory infiltrate of predominantly macrophage/monocytes. Surviving grafts showed preserved morphology. Like humans, Gal KO mice naturally develop anti-alphaGal antibodies with age. The titre in these mice was sufficient to cause a "delayed-type" rejection of a significant proportion of alphaGal-expressing cardiac grafts. This model thus provides an opportunity to investigate the role of naturally acquired anti-alphaGal antibodies in the pathogenesis of DXR.

Impaired recoloration of a discordant liver xenograft in the guinea pig-to-rat combination: physiological insults or immunological responses

BACKGROUND

The aim of this study was to clarify, using guinea pig (GP) syngeneic and xenogeneic liver graft models, the mechanisms of impaired recoloration caused by immunological responses or physiological insults; and to examine the effect of an anti-complement agent, FC43 emulsion, on xenograft rejection.

METHODS AND RESULTS

GP syngeneic and xenogeneic liver grafts flushed with 4 degrees C lactated Ringer's solution were poorly perfused around the porta hepatis, whereas those flushed with 15 degrees C solution were immediately recolored, and the portal venography confirmed homogeneous perfusion throughout the GP livers. Impaired recoloration of GP xenografts was also ameliorated by reduction of ischemic time. Pretreatments with FC43 emulsion significantly extended xenograft survivals. Rejected GP liver xenografts showed C3 deposits on sinusoids and central veins and IgM deposits faintly stained only on some small vessels, but there were no detectable deposits of IgG.

CONCLUSIONS

The impaired recoloration in this model may be caused by physiological insults during the initial stage of revascularization, and the immunological responses that probably followed.

Delayed hyperacute xenograft rejection in porcine to canine fetal liver transplantation

Fetal tissues are generally considered to express weaker antigenic cell-surface molecules than adult tissues. We have reported that transplantation of porcine fetal liver tissue (fragments) is useful for acute and chronic hepatic failure in rats. We further investigated, in the present study, whether transplantation of a porcine fetal liver has the advantage of delayed hyperacute xenograft rejection (HAR) in comparison with that of an adult liver. Porcine fetal liver heterotopically transplanted into dogs was compared. Haematoxylin-eosin (HE) and immunohistochemical studies using IgM, C3, IgG antibodies were performed in serial biopsies of the liver grafts. Lectin binding to target antigen epitopes on pig and dog tissues was studied by flow cytometry. Carbohydrate expression on the liver was also studied by immunohistochemistry. The macroscopic and HE section findings indicate that HAR started 15 min postgraft in fetal and adult liver grafts. Thereafter, vascular changes and parenchymal damage progressed more rapidly in the adult grafts. The final HAR time in adult liver transplantation was determined to be 60 min, while it was determined to be 180 min in fetal liver transplantation. IgM, C3 and IgG were deposited more strongly in the adult grafts than in the fetal grafts up until 60 min after xenografting. Phaseolus vulgaris erythroagglutinin lectin competitively blocked dog sera binding to porcine PBLs. The fetal liver expressed oligosaccharide at a significantly lower level than the adult liver. We conclude that porcine fetal liver xenografts had a significantly delayed HAR.

Role of UW solution and sodium nitroprusside in reperfusion of liver xenografts from guinea-pig to rat

Guinea-pig livers are poorly reperfused when transplanted into rats. We have observed that, in contrast to that of the rat, the guinea-pig intrahepatic portal vein (PV) has a thick layer of smooth muscle. It is possible that, after perfusion of the liver with ice-cold saline, this could go into spasm, resulting in poor reperfusion. To test this hypothesis, guinea-pig livers were perfused with different solutions stored at varying temperatures and transplanted into LEW rats. To prevent xenograft hyperacute rejection, all xenograft recipients were treated with 80 U/kg cobra venom factor (CVF) i.v. on days -1 and 0. In addition to the percentage reperfusion, PV resistance and recipient survival were also monitored. In group I, liver xenografts perfused with ice-cold saline (4 degrees C) reperfused poorly (20-30%), resulting in the development of portal hypertension (16.5 cmH2O vs. 12 cmH2O in naive LEW rats) and shortened mean survival time (11.7 +/- 4.2 h). In contrast, group II livers perfused with saline at room temperature (23 degrees C) underwent homogeneous reperfusion (98-100%) with no increase in portal vein resistance, indicating that low temperature was the main trigger for the spasm of the PV. Moreover, recipient survival in this group was significantly prolonged to a mean of 22 + 2.6 h (P < 0.01). Although UW solution (group III) and the vasodilator sodium nitroprusside (NP) (group IV) when used alone improved the degree of hepatic reperfusion, it was still not optimal. The supplementation, however, of UW solution with NP in group V animals resulted in homogeneous reperfusion (98%) with no portal hypertension and consistent prolonged graft survival of 21.0 +/- 1.7 h. Therefore, this study has determined that the riddle of the abnormal reperfusion of guinea-pig liver xenografts by rat blood is nonimmune mediated and is due to the spasm of the strong smooth muscle in the PV tree produced by cold perfusates.

IgG, but not IgM, mediates hyperacute rejection in hepatic xenografting

We reported previously that no classical features of hyperacute rejection (HAR) could be found in liver grafts in the guinea-pig (GP)-to-rat model and that recipients died shortly after transplantation of non-immunologic causes. Thus, the GP-to-rat model is not suitable for studying the mechanisms of discordant liver xenograft rejection. In the hamster to rat model, long-term survival of a liver graft is possible, but extremely low levels of xenoreactive natural antibodies are present. To mimic a discordant situation with pre-formed IgM and IgG antibodies, we sensitized rats 1 or 5 weeks before grafting. Specific anti-hamster IgM antibodies were found in recipients sensitized at week -1 but not week -5. Anti-hamster IgG was present in all recipients, albeit considerably higher in animals sensitized 5 weeks before grafting. In these two models, we examined the mechanism of HAR of liver grafts and compared this with heart xenografts. Control heart and liver grafts were rejected 4 and 7 days after transplantation respectively. Liver grafts in recipients sensitized at week -5 showed venous congestion and bleeding after reperfusion, indicating HAR, however this was not observed after sensitization at week -1. This surprising finding was confirmed by histology. Massive extravasation, edema, and acute liver cell degradation were noticed in grafts subjected to HAR. Liver grafts of recipients sensitized at week -1 showed only minimal changes. Heart grafts were rejected hyperacutely in both sensitization models. IgG antibodies could be detected on liver grafts in the group sensitized at week -5 but not in the group sensitized at week -1. Minimal IgM depositions were found on liver grafts of animals sensitized 1 week before grafting. Rejected heart grafts from similar sensitization groups showed identical antibody depositions; only IgM depositions were massive. Complement depositions were found in all groups. These results indicate that IgG, but not IgM, mediates HAR in hepatic xenografting. Such a predominance of IgG over IgM does not exist for heart grafts.

The fourth barrier

At the entrance of a new era, clinical xenotransplantation is a valued and auspicious option in tackling the problem of donor shortage. Because of ethical and anatomical issues, domestic farm animals are considered the most favourable species for organ donation, but transplantation of their organs leads to a complex process of rejection. Mechanistically, three immunological barriers, namely hyperacute rejection, delayed xenograft rejection and a subsequent cellular rejection, are distinguished. A fifth (microbiological) barrier is also being recognised. This review focuses on problems regarding the fourth barrier, i.e. physiology, in possible clinical settings and their corresponding animal models. Besides anatomical differences and posture, biochemical differences may have a severe impact on recipient survival. Differences in blood components and electrolyte and other biochemical concentrations are easily detected throughout the species considered for xenotransplantation. Enzymes and hormones have complex routes of action, activation and inhibition, and their molecular differences can impede function. As infusion or medicine may correct certain imbalances in electrolytes and proteins, problems with complex interactions might be difficult to retrieve and solve. Experimentally, survival of discordant xenografts show promising results, but the first physiological problems have already been detected. So, based upon the few experimental data available and the comparison of veterinary physiology, one might expect differences between the organs grafted, regarding the possible occurrence of physiological problems. Moreover, precautions must be taken to extrapolate long-term survival, because of species specificity.

Anti-Gal antibody-mediated allograft rejection in alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase gene knockout mice: a model of delayed xenograft rejection

BACKGROUND

The key role of anti-galactose alpha1,3-galactose (anti-alphaGal) xenoantibodies in initiating hyperacute xenograft rejection has been clearly demonstrated using a variety of in vitro and in vivo approaches. However, the role of anti-alphaGal antibodies in mediating post-hyperacute rejection mechanisms, such as antibody-dependent cellular cytoxicity, remains to be determined, primarily because of the lack of a small animal model with which to study this phenomena.

METHODS

Hearts from wild-type mice were transplanted heterotopically into alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase knockout (Gal KO) mice, which like humans develop antibodies to the disaccharide galactose alpha1,3-galactose (Gal). At the time of rejection, hearts were examined histologically to determine the mechanism of rejection.

RESULTS

Hearts from wild-type mice transplanted into high-titer anti-alphaGal recipients were rejected in 8-13 days. Histological examination demonstrated a cellular infiltrate consisting of macrophages (80-90%), natural killer cells (5-10%), and T cells (1-5%). In contrast, wild-type hearts transplanted into low anti-Gal titer recipients demonstrated prolonged (>90 day) survival. However, a significant proportion (30-40%) of these underwent a minor rejection episode between 10 and 13 days, but then recovered ("accommodated").

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this study suggest that the Gal KO mouse is a useful small animal vascularized allograft model, in which the role of anti-alphaGal antibody in graft rejection can be studied in isolation from other rejection mechanisms. The titer of anti-alphaGal antibody was found to be the critical determinant of rejection. The histopathological features of rejection in this model are very similar to other models of delayed xenograft rejection, in both the timing and composition of the cellular infiltrate. The Gal KO mouse therefore provides a new rodent model, which will aid in the identification of the distinct components involved in the pathogenesis of delayed xenograft rejection.

Basic anatomical and physiological differences between species should be considered when choosing combinations for use in models of hepatic xenotransplantation: an investigation of the guinea pig-to-rat combination

Published data on the guinea pig-to-rat hepatic xenotransplant model describe problems concerning poor graft reperfusion. To further investigate this phenomenon, orthotopic liver xenotransplantation between weight-matched guinea pigs and rats were performed using Kamada's technique. On reperfusion, all cases had portal venous inflow block with hypoperfusion of the hepatic parenchyma. Histological examination showed no evidence of hyperacute rejection, although deposits of IgG2a and C3 but not IgM were identified within the central area of the liver. To increase blood inflow, arterialized partial liver grafts were performed without changing the outcome. We hypothesize that the hypoperfusion may be related to anatomical and physiological differences between the species. Guinea pig portal vein branches were found to have muscular walls susceptible to spasm, and portal blood flow is four times greater in the guinea pig than in the rat because the guinea pig intestine is both longer (two times as long) and of greater diameter. The combination of reperfusion injury, early immunological events, and the rat's lower portal blood flow induces spasm of the intrahepatic portal system resulting in hypoperfusion. These findings demonstrate the importance of recognizing basic anatomical and physiological differences between species when selecting xenotransplantation models.