Results of Tests with Different Cellular Bioassays in Relation to Severity of RhD Haemolytic Disease

Clinical value of an antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity assay in the management of Rh D alloimmunization

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the clinical value of an antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity assay relative to the indirect antiglobulin test titer in the management of Rh D-alloimmunized pregnancies.

STUDY DESIGN

Data from 172 Rh D-alloimmunized pregnancies were analyzed retrospectively. The accuracies of the highest antibody titer and of the highest antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity assay result during pregnancy to predict fetal and neonatal Rh disease, defined as the need for intrauterine (n = 30) or neonatal (n = 37) blood transfusion, respectively, were assessed.

RESULTS

At different cutoff levels with equal sensitivities the antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity assay consistently showed a higher specificity than the antibody titer for the prediction of fetal disease. No difference was found between the receiver operating characteristic curves of the 2 tests for the prediction of neonatal disease.

CONCLUSIONS

Selection of patients for referral and invasive testing for Rh D alloimmunization may be improved with the use of an antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity assay.

Variation in IgG1 heavy chain allotype does not contribute to differences in biological activity of two human anti-Rhesus (D) monoclonal antibodies

BACKGROUND

Pooled human anti-Rhesus D antiserum is currently administered for the prevention of RhD alloimmunization. Increased demand, and decreased supply, of donated pooled antiserum has led to the investigation of the suitability of human monoclonal anti-RhD antibodies for use in its place. However, it is unclear which biological properties of monoclonal antibodies are important for function in RhD-positive foetal red cell clearance and the prevention of alloimmunization. Various antibodies behave differently in a number of in vitro assays of biological function.

OBJECTIVES

To compare the function and structure of two human anti-RhD IgG1 monoclonal antibodies which differ in their ability to promote red cell lysis in vitro. In particular to examine whether the functional differences correlate to differences in the IgG1 heavy chain constant region (allotype).

STUDY DESIGN

We report here the cloning, characterization and re-expression in stable myeloma cell transformants of cDNAs coding for two such antibodies, secreted by the heterohybridoma cell lines ESD-1 (THERAD 03) and LHM 70/45.3 (THERAD 06). The cDNAs were then recombined to exchange portions of the Fc encoding regions and the recombinant antibodies were assayed in vitro to determine RhD-positive red cell-dependent activity.

RESULTS

Recombinant THERAD 03 and 06 antibodies behaved identically to the parent antibodies. The 'inactive' THERAD 06 did not have biological activity reconstituted by exchange with the THERAD 03 Fc regions, nor was THERAD 03 activity abolished by the reciprocal Fc region exchange.

CONCLUSIONS

Human monoclonal anti-RhD antibodies can be cloned and re-expressed in stable cell lines, and exhibit identical properties to the parent antibodies. Differences in biological activity cannot be attributed to differences in IgG1 heavy chain allotype.

Prediction of the severity of haemolytic disease of the newborn. Quantitative IgG anti-D subclass determinations explain the correlation with functional assay results

Sera containing anti-D, taken from 44 RhD-negative women with RhD-positive infants, were tested in antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) and monocyte monolayer assays (MMA) which used similar target and effector cell populations. In addition, the anti-D concentration was measured in the Auto Analyzer and the number of IgG1 and IgG3 anti-D molecules bound to the target red cells was measured by flow cytometry. The results of the functional assays and Auto Analyzer quantitation were examined for correlation with IgG subclass quantitation and all results were compared for their ability to predict the severity of haemolytic disease of the newborn (HDN). ADCC correctly predicted HDN in 39/44 (88.6%) cases, Auto Analyzer quantitation in 35/44 (79.5%) and the MMA in 32/44 (72.7%). For all three assays, the number of correct predictions was highest when the maternal serum contained both IgG1 and IgG3 anti-D. ADCC activity and HDN were correlated with the number of cell-bound IgG1 molecules (r > or = 0.58), but MMA activity was most closely correlated with the number of cell-bound IgG3 molecules (r = 0.68). Hence the superior predictive value of ADCC is due to its ability to reflect the IgG1 component of maternal anti-D, which has a better correlation than IgG3 anti-D with the severity of HDN.

The predictive value of maternal serum testing for detection of fetal anemia in red blood cell alloimmunization

OBJECTIVE

Current management protocols for pregnancies complicated by red blood cell alloimmunization use the maternal antibody titer to predict the need for invasive testing for detection of fetal anemia. We investigated the use of three maternal serum tests to assess their usefulness in predicting fetal disease: indirect Coombs' titer, Marsh score, and monocyte monolayer assay.

STUDY DESIGN

Forty-seven serum samples from pregnant women with red blood cell antibodies associated with fetal anemia were analyzed at cordocentesis. Fetal blood was analyzed for hematocrit (corrected for gestational age) and antigen status. Fetal anemia was defined as a hematocrit value of < 2 SD from the mean value for gestational age. Fetuses were classified into three groups: Antigen positive with anemia (n = 19), antigen positive without anemia (n = 17), antigen negative (n = 11). Statistical methods included Kruskal-Wallis test, Newman-Keuls test, Spearman's rank correlation, and receiver-operator characteristic curves; p < 0.05 was considered significant.

RESULTS

The median monocyte monolayer assay (phagocytosis, adherence, and association) did not differ among the three groups. Both maternal titers and Marsh scores were significantly higher in fetuses with anemia compared with the other two groups of fetuses (256 vs 64 vs 64, p < 0.001, and 86 vs 69 vs 64, p = 0.02, respectively). Both titer and Marsh score exhibited significant correlations with corrected fetal hematocrit (r = -0.70, p < 0.001; r = -0.63, p < 0.001, respectively). Comparison of the overall receiver-operator characteristic curves for titer and Marsh score revealed no statistical difference; however, a Marsh score of 57 was noted to have a superior specificity than a titer of 16 (p = 0.02).

CONCLUSION

The maternal Marsh score can be performed in conjunction with standard indirect Coombs' titers to enhance the predictability of fetal anemia.

Transplacental IgG subclass concentrations in pregnancies at risk of haemolytic disease of the newborn

The relationship of haemolytic disease of the newborn (HDN) to the transplacental passage of the four IgG subclasses was assessed at various gestational ages by comparing the maternal and fetal IgG subclass concentrations in 34 pregnancies at risk of HDN with those in 30 pregnancies not at risk. Higher maternal and fetal IgG1 levels were attained in pregnancies at risk of HDN than in pregnancies not at risk. In contrast, a slight decrease in maternal IgG2 and IgG4 levels occurred in pregnancies at risk of HDN, as compared with a slight rise in maternal IgG2 and IgG4 levels in pregnancies not at risk of HDN. Changes in fetal IgG2 and 4 concentrations in either type of pregnancy were very similar, showing only slight increases between the 19th and 34th week of gestation. A slight decrease in maternal IgG3 occurred in both types of pregnancy. In contrast, higher and fairly steady levels of fetal IgG3 were observed in fetuses not at risk of HDN throughout gestation, when compared with those in 'at risk' pregnancies. However, the statistical reliability of these results is not clear since only small numbers of samples were tested and because wide variations in IgG concentrations were observed. The IgG subclass concentrations in 50 paired maternal and cord blood samples were also measured and revealed that IgG1 levels were substantially higher in cord rather than maternal blood; cord and maternal IgG2, 3 and 4 levels, on the other hand, were fairly similar.

Clinical application of functional assays for assessing the red cell antibody activity

Functional assays (the monocyte monolayer assay, the chemiluminescence test, and the antibody dependent cellular cytotoxicity assay) aim to reflect an interaction between sensitized red calls and Fc-gamma receptor bearing mononuclear cells, which plays the main role in immune destruction of erythrocytes in vivo. These assays have been used for predicting the clinical significance of antibodies in hemolytic disease of the newborn, in patients with alloantibodies requiring transfusion and patients suspected of autoimmune hemolytic anemia. This review presents a brief summary of the literature on this subject. In many cases (especially in hemolytic disease of the newborn, RhD) the results of bioassays can assess the functional activity of antibodies in vivo, but further investigation is needed to establish their real value for clinical practice.

Evidence for the protective effect of maternal FcR-blocking IgG alloantibodies HLA-DR in Rh D-haemolytic disease of the newborn

In cases of Rh D alloimmunization, strong results in the antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity (ADCC) assay (> 80% lysis as compared to that of the standard anti-D serum) are indicative of severe hemolytic disease to occur in the newborn (HDN). However, discrepant cases were found in which the maternal anti-D gave strong ADCC results and the newborns had no or only mild hemolysis. In the majority of these cases the mother had produced monocyte-reactive IgG alloantibodies, mostly with HLA-DR specificity. Such antibodies may be capable of blocking FcR-mediated functions of the fetal MPS, and it has been postulated that they inhibit destruction of anti-D-sensitized red cells. We here describe 2 families in which such discrepancies were noticed. In 1 family, in spite of ADCC results of > 80%, the Rh D-positive second child was born without signs of hemolysis. However, the Rh D-positive third child suffered from very severe hemolytic disease. The mother had produced monocyte-reactive HLA-DR antibodies in the second pregnancy which, however, did not react with the cells of the third child. In the other family, the severely Rh D-alloimmunized mother had lost her fourth child because of intrauterine death due to HDN. The Rh D-positive fifth child was born with only mild HDN and only in this pregnancy had the mother produced such antibodies. These 2 case histories give further evidence that maternal monocyte-reactive alloantibodies, in both these cases directed against HLA-DR antigens, can protect the Rh D-positive child against hemolytic disease in case of severe Rh D alloimmunization.

The role of Rh antibodies in haemolytic disease of the newborn

Recent insights into the structure-function relationship of IgG, the nature of Fc receptors and their interactions with antibodies, and the cellular mechanisms involved in the immune destruction of IgG-sensitized cells have all contributed to a fuller understanding of the role of Rh antibodies in HDN. As this understanding has increased, so different diagnostic and therapeutic approaches have been developed and evaluated in order either to predict or ameliorate disease severity. The role of Rh antibodies in HDN can be considered in three contexts: maternal anti-D, monoclonal anti-D and prophylactic anti-D. Anti-D formed after maternal alloimmunization may be transported across the placenta, resulting in destruction of sensitized red cells by mononuclear phagocytes in the fetus and infant. The use of monoclonal anti-D has given an insight into the cellular and molecular mechanisms involved in red cell destruction, and has facilitated the development and evaluation of assays which use maternal anti-D to predict the severity of HDN. Polyclonal anti-D, given prophylactically, can prevent maternal alloimmunization to D-positive fetal red cells. Future developments are likely in several areas. Prophylactic polyclonal anti-D may be replaced, wholly or partially, with monoclonal anti-D. The development and introduction of cellular assays as non-invasive tests for predicting disease severity is likely to continue as preliminary results are encouraging. Finally, new strategies for ameliorating disease severity may be assessed including the role of ivIgG and Fc gamma R-blocking antibodies.

Protection against immune haemolytic disease of newborn infants by maternal monocyte-reactive IgG alloantibodies (anti-HLA-DR)

The extent to which maternal anti-Rh(D) antibodies support lysis of erythrocytes by monocytes in the antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity (ADCC) assay is closely correlated with the severity of Rh(D) haemolytic disease of the newborn infant (HDN). However, in some cases HDN is much milder than would be predicted from the ADCC value. We postulated that maternal ADCC-blocking alloantibodies against paternal antigens on monocytes can protect these infants against severe haemolysis. We studied 13 severely Rh(D)-alloimmunised mothers whose infants showed unexpectedly mild HDN (group I) and 14 women with similar ADCC values but whose infants had severe HDN (group II). 7 group-I women had monocyte-reactive IgG alloantibodies that inhibited lysis by paternal monocytes in the ADCC. No such antibodies were found in group II (p less than 0.01). In 6 of the 7 serum samples with monocyte-reactive antibodies, the antibodies had HLA-DR specificity. Our findings suggest that Rh(D)-positive children of some severely Rh(D)-alloimmunised women may be protected from severe HDN by maternal non-HLA-class-I, IgG alloantibodies against paternal monocyte blood-group antigens. These antibodies may inhibit the mononuclear phagocyte system of the fetus.