Cyclic-AMP binding to the cell surface during development of Dictyostelium discoideum

Evolutionary crossroads in developmental biology: Dictyostelium discoideum

Dictyostelium discoideum belongs to a group of multicellular life forms that can also exist for long periods as single cells. This ability to shift between uni- and multicellularity makes the group ideal for studying the genetic changes that occurred at the crossroads between uni- and multicellular life. In this Primer, I discuss the mechanisms that control multicellular development in Dictyostelium discoideum and reconstruct how some of these mechanisms evolved from a stress response in the unicellular ancestor.

The cAMP receptor CAR4 regulates axial patterning and cellular differentiation during late development of Dictyostelium

Pseudoplasmodia of developing Dictyostelium are organized with anteroposterior polarity. We have isolated CAR4, the gene for a new cell-surface, G protein-linked cAMP receptor. CAR4 mRNA is initially expressed during tip elongation and continues to accumulate into culmination. CAR4 is maximally expressed in pseudoplasmodia anteriors which are centers for extracellular cAMP signaling and for organization of cellular patterning. Although car4 null cells progress unperturbed through early development, they exhibit major patterning aberrations as the anteroposterior axis becomes established. Prestalk gene expression is significantly reduced in car4 nulls, whereas prespore-specific markers are overexpressed and detected in zones normally restricted to prestalk cells. Patterning defects are similarly apparent in terminally differentiated fruiting bodies. Our results show that cAMP signaling is required for pattern formation and cellular differentiation during late Dictyostelium development.

CAR2, a prestalk cAMP receptor required for normal tip formation and late development of Dictyostelium discoideum

Extracellular cAMP serves as a primary signaling molecule to regulate the development of Dictyostelium discoideum. It is required for chemotaxis, aggregation, cytodifferentiation, and morphogenetic movement. The receptors for cAMP are members of the family of cell-surface receptors that are linked to G proteins and characterized by seven putative transmembrane domains. Previously, we have isolated the gene for the cAMP receptor subtype 1 (CAR1) from Dictyostelium and suggested that several genes related to CAR1 were present in the genome. Here, we describe a family of cAMP receptor genes of Dictyostelium and the isolation and function of the gene for the cAMP receptor subtype 2, CAR2. CAR2 is structurally similar to CAR1. Overall, their transmembrane and loop domains are approximately 75% identical in amino acid sequence; however, their carboxyl termini are quite dissimilar; CAR2 possesses homopolymeric runs of histidines and asparagines that are absent from the corresponding region in CAR1. Although CAR1 is maximally expressed during the early stages of development, CAR2 is expressed only after cells have aggregated and, then, preferentially in prestalk cells. Transgenic Dictyostelium that have had their wild-type CAR2 gene replaced by a defective copy using homologous recombination proceed through early development but are detained at the tight mound stage. CAR2 may be required for cAMP-directed sorting of prestalk cells during pattern formation within the aggregation mound. Furthermore, although prestalk genes are expressed normally in aggregates that lack CAR2, they exhibit an enhanced expression of prespore-specific mRNA. Previously, we had shown that there was a requirement for CAR1 during early development. The present results demonstrate that the multiple responses of Dictyostelium to cAMP are regulated by distinct cAMP receptors that are encoded by unique genes.

Identification and targeted gene disruption of cAR3, a cAMP receptor subtype expressed during multicellular stages of Dictyostelium development

Extracellular cAMP acts through cell-surface receptors to coordinate the developmental program of Dictyostelium. A cAMP receptor (cAR1), which is expressed during early aggregation, has been cloned and sequenced previously. We have identified a new receptor subtype, cAR3, that has approximately 56% and 69% amino acid identity with cAR1 and cAR2, respectively. cAR1, cAR2, or cAR3 expressed from plasmid in growing Dictyostelium cells can be photoaffinity labeled with 8-N3[32P]cAMP and phosphorylated when stimulated with cAMP. cAR3 RNA was not present during growth but appeared during late aggregation. Its expression peaked at 9 hr and then fell to a reduced level that was maintained until culmination. The expression of cAR3 protein followed a similar pattern, but with a 3-hr lag, and reached a maximum at the mound stage. In contrast, cAR1 protein was expressed predominantly during early aggregation and at low levels during later stages. At their respective peaks of expression, there were approximately 5 x 10(3) cAR3 sites per cell compared with approximately 7 x 10(4) cAR2 sites per cell. The cAR3 gene was disrupted by homologous recombination in several different parental cell lines. Surprisingly, the car3- cell lines display no obvious phenotype.

Involvement of cyclic AMP cell surface receptors and G-proteins in signal transduction during slug migration of Dictyostelium discoideum

The presence of G-proteins, interacting with cAMP surface receptors, was investigated in vegetative cells, aggregation-competent cells, and migrating slugs of Dictyostelium discoideum. Our results indicate that G-proteins are present in all stages. In vegetative cells there is a limited number of cAMP receptors but no effect of GTP tau S on cAMP binding could be detected; in addition, no effect of cAMP on GTP tau S binding or GTPase activity was observed. In both aggregation-competent cells and slugs GTP tau S inhibits cAMP binding, while cAMP stimulates GTP tau S binding and high-affinity GTPase. Since the presence of G-proteins coupled to cAMP receptors could be demonstrated in slugs, the involvement of the effector enzymes adenylate cyclase and phospholipase C was investigated. The results show that adenylate cyclase activity is stimulated by GTP tau S in both stages and that in cells from migrating slugs the Ins(1,4,5)P3 production is increased upon stimulation with cAMP. The possible involvement of G-proteins in signal transduction during the slug stage of D. discoideum is discussed.

Multiple genes for cell surface cAMP receptors in Dictyostelium discoideum

We have cloned and characterized three genes (CAR1, CAR2, CAR3) encoding potential cell surface, cyclic adenosine 3':5' monophosphate (AMP) receptors from Dictyostelium discoideum. The three proteins are predicted to be substantially similar in amino acid sequence throughout most of their transmembrane (TM) and loop domains but are distinctly different in their carboxyl terminal segments. In addition, all three genes possess an intron which interrupts an equivalent codon of TM3. CAR1 is expressed early in development when the cAMP relay system is being established. As development proceeds multiple size forms of CAR1 RNA are detected which apparently result from differences in their 5'-untranslated regions. Late in development levels of CAR1 RNA decrease. In contrast, CAR2 encodes a single sized RNA which is expressed only during postaggregative development. CAR3 expression is approximately 10% of CAR1 during early development, is maximal during tight aggregate formation but declines thereafter. Only one size class of CAR3 mRNA is detected throughout development. Because RNA for each of the three genes is present in postaggregative cells, it was of interest to determine the cell type distribution of each RNA. Gene-specific probes were hybridized to RNAs isolated from cells of Percoll gradient-enriched prespore and prestalk fractions and relative levels of hybridization compared. CAR1 and CAR3 show approximately the same pattern of accumulation; a 3-4 fold enrichment in prestalk cells. CAR2, however, is highly enriched in prestalk cells, more than 10 fold relative to prespore cells.

Expression of a cAMP receptor gene of Dictyostelium and evidence for a multigene family

We have previously reported the cloning of cDNAs for a Dictyostelium cell-surface cAMP receptor that is a member of the family of G-protein-linked receptors. Here, we report the organization and the developmental expression of this cAMP receptor gene, designated CAR1. CAR1 is a single copy gene that contains two intervening sequences. CAR1 mRNA levels are low in growing cells, rise to peak expression at 5-10 hr of development when the cAMP signaling system is maximally active, and decrease as development proceeds. At 5 hr the predominant mRNA species is approximately 1.9 kb, by 10 hr the mRNA is heterogeneous with sizes of approximately 1.9-2.1 kb, but during culmination only the 2.1 kb mRNA is detected. The variety of mRNA sizes results from differences in 5'-untranslated regions. Studies using developmental mutants with aberrant cAMP-signaling patterns indicate that pulsatile action of cAMP promotes maximal expression of CAR1 during early development. Low stringency hybridization of CAR1 probes to genomic DNA detects additional, related sequences, suggesting that there are several genes that encode a family of structurally similar receptors. Multiple functions previously attributed to the cAMP receptor instead may be fulfilled by distinct receptor subtypes encoded by specific genes.

cAMP regulation of the expression of prespore-specific genes, SP96 and Dp87, in disaggregated slug cells of Dictyostelium discoideum

By Northern transfer and in vitro transcription assays, we examined how cAMP controlled the expression of prespore genes, Dp87 and SP96, in disaggregated slug cells of Dictyostelium discoideum. The transcription of these genes was halted soon after disaggregation and the remaining mRNAs were completely lost within 2 h. Addition of cAMP to cells which had lost the mRNAs induced the transcription of these genes, and the mRNAs were re-accumulated after a lag period of 30 min. The cAMP signal was transduced through the cell surface receptor. Protein synthesis was not needed for the induction of the transcription but was required for the accumulation of the mRNAs. We conclude that prespore gene expression is controlled by cAMP in two different ways: direct induction of transcription of the genes, and stabilization of the transcribed mRNAs by a protein(s) synthesized after addition of cAMP.

Localization of chemoattractant receptors on Dictyostelium discoideum cells during aggregation and down-regulation

cAMP chemoattractant receptors on the surface of Dictyostelium discoideum cells are visualized by means of immunocytochemistry. Receptor antigen is virtually absent from growing cells and begins to accumulate after about 6 hr of starvation, concomitant with the increase in surface cAMP binding activity. In aggregating cells, the antigen is uniformly distributed over the cell surface. Persistent cAMP stimulation, which leads to down-regulation of cAMP binding activity, induces a striking rearrangement of receptor antigen into patches or internal vesicles. A similar patching of receptor antigen is observed during tight aggregate formation, when surface cAMP binding activity decreases. These observations indicate that receptor down-regulation involves receptor agglomeration and suggest that receptor down-regulation takes place in vivo, when tight aggregates are being formed.

The requirement for DIF for prestalk and stalk cell formation in Dictyostelium discoideum: a comparison of in vivo and in vitro differentiation conditions

In Dictyostelium discoideum stalk cell formation is induced by cyclic AMP and differentiation-inducing factor (DIF) when cells are plated in in vitro monolayers (Kay et al., 1979, Differentiation 13: 7-14). The in vivo developmental stages at which cells became independent of these factors were determined. Independence was defined as the stage at which dispersed cells no longer required the factors for stalk cell formation in low density monolayers. Cyclic AMP independent cells were first detected at around 12 hr of development, a time that corresponds to the transition between the tipped aggregate and the first finger stages. In contrast cells did not become independent of DIF until late culmination. The prestalk cell-specific isozyme acid phosphatase II and a stalk cell-specific 41,000 Mr antigen (ST 41) were expressed during differentiation in low density monolayers in the presence of both cyclic AMP and DIF, but neither component was expressed in the presence of cyclic AMP alone. This result implies that DIF is essential for both prestalk and stalk cell formation. The two components were expressed within 2 hr of each other during differentiation in vitro, whereas during development in vivo acid phosphatase II was first detected at the first finger stage and ST 41 was first detected during late culmination, 8-12 hr later. These contrasting results suggest that the conversion of prestalk cells to stalk cells is unrestrained in monolayers, following directly after prestalk cell induction, but restrained in vivo until the culmination stage. This interpretation is consistent with the finding that cells become independent of DIF early during in vitro differentiation (A. Sobolewski, N. Neave, and G. Weeks, 1983, Differentiation 25, 93-100), but do not become independent of DIF until the culmination stage when differentiating in vivo.

Opposite effects of adenosine on two types of cAMP-induced gene expression in Dictyostelium indicate the involvement of at least two different intracellular pathways for the transduction of cAMP signals

Adenosine promotes the cAMP-induced increase of mRNAs, probed with the cDNAs D11 and D14, which are preferentially expressed in prestalk cells, while it inhibits cAMP-induced prespore gene expression. Half-maximal inhibition of prespore gene expression occurs at about 300 muM, while prestalk stimulation by adenosine occurs at about 100-fold lower concentrations and requires the presence of cAMP. These results indicate that adenosine interferes with the transduction to cAMP to gene expression and suggest the involvement of two different adenosine target sites. Our data furthermore indicate that the transduction of extracellular cAMP to prespore gene or prestalk gene expression occurs via divergent pathways.

Cell cycle phase in Dictyostelium discoideum is correlated with the expression of cyclic AMP production, detection, and degradation. Involvement of cyclic AMP signaling in cell sorting

Cell cycle phase in Dictyostelium is correlated with a different preference for either spore or stalk differentiation. Cells which start development early in the cell cycle (E cells) exhibit a strong tendency to sort to the prestalk region of slugs, while late cell cycle cells (L cells) sort to the prespore region. We investigated the expression of the cAMP chemotactic system during development of synchronized E and L cells and found that E cells exhibit cAMP-binding activity, cell surface cAMP-phosphodiesterase (mPDE) activity, and the ability to relay cAMP signals at least 2 hr earlier and to higher levels than L cells. We hypothesize that E cells are prestalk sorters because they are the first to initiate aggregation centers and respond most effectively with chemotaxis and signal relay.

A Ca2+-dependent signal transduction system participates in coupling expression of some cAMP-dependent prespore genes to the cell surface receptor

Elevated levels of cAMP are essential for the expression of many postaggregation prespore and prestalk mRNA species and for the suppression of some growth phase mRNAs. Here we review evidence that this regulation is mediated by cAMP interacting at the cell surface receptor. These effects of cAMP on gene expression can occur under conditions where the receptor-associated adenylate cyclase is inactivated and in concentrations that are consistent with receptor-binding. A number of differences are noted in the mechanism by which cAMP regulates prespore and prestalk genes. Finally, evidence is reviewed for the role of a Ca2+-dependent signal transduction system in coupling the expression of some of the prespore mRNAs to the cAMP receptor. This signal transduction system does not appear to be involved in the expression of the cAMP-dependent prestalk gene.

Lithium respecifies cyclic AMP-induced cell-type specific gene expression in Dictyostelium

We investigated the effect of LiCl on pattern formation and cAMP-regulated gene expression in Dictyostelium discoideum. In intact slugs, 5 mM LiCl induces an almost complete redifferentiation of prespore into prestalk cells. We found that LiCl acts by interfering with the transduction of extracellular cAMP to cell-type-specific gene expression; LiCl inhibits the induction of prespore-specific gene expression by cAMP, while it promotes the induction of prestalk-associated gene expression by cAMP. Our results indicate that two divergent pathways transduce the extracellular cAMP signal to, respectively, prestalk and prespore gene expression.

Stalk cell formation in monolayers of Dictyostelium discoideum V12-M2

Stalk cell formation in low-cell-density monolayers of Dictyostelium discoideum, strain V12-M2, occurs following the sequential addition of cyclic AMP and the differentiation-inducing factor (DIF). Both cyclic AMP and DIF are essential for the appearance of the prestalk-specific isozyme alkaline phosphatase-II, which suggests that both factors are necessary for prestalk cell formation. The available evidence suggests that the cyclic AMP requirement for stalk cell formation is mediated through the cell surface cyclic AMP receptor. However, stalk cell formation is inhibited by caffeine and this inhibition is reversed by the cell-permeable analogue 8-Br-cyclic AMP, which suggests in addition a possible involvement for elevated intracellular cyclic AMP concentrations in stalk cell formation. During in vivo development cells first become independent of cyclic AMP at the tipped aggregate stage, but the acquisition of cyclic AMP independence is advanced by several hours when cells are incubated in the presence of cyclic AMP for 2 hours. Cells do not become independent of DIF until the culmination stage of development, which suggests the possibility that DIF is required for the conversion of prestalk cells to stalk cells. There is an absolute requirement for DIF for stalk cell formation in low-density monolayers of prestalk cells but only part of population exhibits a requirement for cyclic AMP, which suggests that the prestalk cell population consists of two distinct cell types. Stalk cell formation from prespore cells is totally dependent on both cyclic AMP and DIF.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Developmental regulation of the pathways of folate-receptor-mediated stimulation of cAMP and cGMP synthesis in Dictyostelium discoideum

Recently, we demonstrated the presence of multiple folate-binding sites on the cell surface of Dictyostelium discoideum. These sites were divided into two major classes, with different ligand specificities (A and B). Each major class consists of several interconvertible subtypes. In the present report, the ability of 13 folate analogs to activate both adenylate and guanylate cyclase in pre- as well as postaggregative cells is examined. The patterns of correlation between binding and activation data indicate that guanylate cyclase activation is mediated by the B-sites in both developmental stages (P less than 0.001). In postaggregative cells, adenylate cyclase also seems to be activated by the B-sites (P less than 0.001). In contrast, adenylate cyclase activation in preaggregative cells was well correlated with the specificity of A-sites (P less than 0.01). Remarkably, the potencies of activation were less affected by molecular modifications than the binding affinities were, as suggested by a slope of 0.4 in a plot of K0.5 values of activation vs. binding. This observation argues against the existence of a transduction mechanism in which the response is proportional to receptor occupancy. For the B-receptor, however, the degree of receptor occupancy appears to determine the response. The existence of folic acid antagonists is demonstrated, some of which are specific for either A-sites coupled to adenylate cyclase or for B-sites coupled to guanylate cyclase.

Production and turnover of cAMP signals by prestalk and prespore cells in Dictyostelium discoideum cell aggregates

Dictyostelium discoideum prestalk cells and prespore cells from migrating slugs and culminating cell aggregates were isolated by Percoll density centrifugation. Several activities relevant to the generation, detection, and turnover of extracellular cyclic AMP (cAMP) signals were determined. It was found that: the two cell types have the same basal adenylate cyclase activity; prespore cells and prestalk cells are able to relay the extracellular cAMP signal equally well; intact prestalk cells show a threefold higher cAMP phosphodiesterase activity on the cell surface than prespore cells, whereas their cytosolic activity is the same; intact prestalk cells bind three to four times more cAMP than prespore cells; no large differences in cAMP metabolism and detection were observed between cells derived from migrating slugs and culminating aggregates. The results are discussed in relation to the possible morphogenetic role of extracellular cAMP in Dictyostelium cell aggregates. On the basis of the properties of the isolated cells we assume that a gradient of extracellular cAMP exists in Dictyostelium aggregates. This gradient appears to be involved in the formation and stabilization of the prestalk-prespore cell pattern.

Postaggregative differentiation induction by cyclic AMP in Dictyostelium: intracellular transduction pathway and requirement for additional stimuli

Cyclic AMP induces postaggregative differentiation in aggregation competent cells of Dictyostelium by interacting with cell surface cAMP receptors. We investigated the transduction pathway of this response and additional requirements for the induction of postaggregative differentiation. Optimal induction of postaggregative gene expression requires that vegetative cells are first exposed to 2-4 hr of nanomolar cAMP pulses, and subsequently for 4-6 hr to steady-state cAMP concentrations in the micromolar range. Cyclic AMP pulses, which are endogenously produced before and during aggregation, induce full responsiveness to cAMP as a morphogen. The transduction pathway from the cell surface cAMP receptor to postaggregative gene expression may involve Ca2+ ions as intracellular messengers. A cAMP-induced increase in intracellular cAMP or cGMP levels is not involved in the transduction pathway.

Phenotypic changes induced by a mutated ras gene during the development of Dictyostelium transformants

The ras proto-oncogene, found in all eukaryotes so far examined, encode s a protein with guanine nucleotide-binding and GTPase activity. Gene disruption experiments in yeast indicate that ras is essential for cell growth. Anit-sense mutagenesis approaches suggest that this is also true for Dictyostelium. Most mutations causing an amino-acid substitution for Gly 12 result in decreased GTPase activity and produce a transforming phenotype. In yeast, a Gly 19---- Val 19, missense mutation (Gly 19 is similar to Gly 12 in mammalian and Dictyostelium ras proteins) causes a series of dominant phenotypes, including elevated adenylate cyclase activity. In mammalian cells there is no evidence that ras activates adenylate cyclase activity. D. discoideum contains a single ras gene (Dd-ras) that encodes a protein very similar to the mammalian ras protein and identical to c-ras at the potentially transforming positions. Dd-ras is expressed in vegetative cells and later in development in prestalk cells whereas ras protein is found in vegetative and developing cells. In the migrating pseudoplasmodium, ras protein is found in prestalk but not prespore cells, suggesting it is involved in the function and/or differentiation of the anteriorly localized prestalk cells. In this report we examine the effects of expression of a Dd-ras gene carrying a Gly-12----Thr 12 missense mutation.

Interactions between adenosine and oscillatory cAMP signaling regulate size and pattern in Dictyostelium

We present evidence for the hypothesis that in multicellular structures of Dictyostelium, production of adenosine by hydrolysis of cAMP near the tip region prevents both generation of competing tips and differentiation of prespore cells near the tip, and thus establishes a "prestalk" region. We demonstrate that adenosine affects the immunological prespore specific staining pattern in slugs in a manner opposite to cAMP:cAMP induces an increase of prespore antigen; adenosine induces a decrease. When endogenous adenosine is removed from slugs, prespore vacuoles are synthesized throughout the prestalk region. Adenosine was found to inhibit the induction of prespore differentiation by cAMP in an apparently competitive manner. It was also found that adenosine specifically increased the amount of tissue controlled by one tip, probably by inhibiting generation of competing oscillators. Removing endogenous adenosine from slugs resulted in a decrease of tip dominance.

Induction of post-aggregative differentiation in Dictyostelium discoideum by cAMP. Evidence of involvement of the cell surface cAMP receptor

Exogenous cAMP is known to induce post-aggregative differentiation in Dictyostelium discoideum under conditions that normal development is blocked. We have analysed the cyclic nucleotide specificity, the effect of modulation of the cAMP signal and the dose-response relationship of the induction of two independent markers of post-aggregative differentiation, i.e., a prespore cell-specific antigen detected by a monoclonal antibody, and the activity of glycogen phosphorylase. Our results confirm that high concentrations of cAMP (10(-6)-10(-3)M) are required for the induction of these markers. The cells are shown not to adapt to the cAMP signal. The cyclic nucleotide specificity of induction agrees with the specificity of the cell surface cAMP receptor, but is very dissimilar to the specificity of the intracellular cAMP-dependent protein kinase. It is thus unlikely that cAMP leaks into the cell and activates the cAMP-dependent protein kinase directly. Instead, the induction of post-aggregative differentiation by cAMP seems to be mediated by cell surface cAMP receptors.

The modulation of cell surface cAMP receptors from Dictyostelium discoideum by ammonium sulfate

Dictyostelium discoideum cells contain a heterogeneous population of cell surface cAMP receptors with components possessing different affinities (Kd between 15 and 450 nM) and different off-rates of the cAMP-receptor complex (t 1/2 between 0.7 and 150 s). The association of cAMP to the receptor and the dissociation of the cAMP-receptor complex still occur in the presence of 3.4 M ammonium sulfate. However, these processes are strongly altered. (1) Low concentrations of ammonium sulfate (approximately equal to 50 mM) induce an approx. 2-fold increase of the number of cAMP binding sites. The same effect is induced by millimolar concentrations of CaCl2. Ammonium sulfate and CaCl2 are not additive, which suggests that these salts may act via the same mechanism. (2) High concentrations of ammonium sulfate (3.4 M) induce an alteration in the proportioning of the various cAMP binding sites to the components with the highest affinity. (3) High concentrations of ammonium sulfate (3.4 M) retard the dissociation of all binding sites about 3-6-fold, thus giving rise to an increase in the affinity of all cAMP-binding components.

cAMP induces a transient elevation of cGMP levels during early culmination of Dictyostelium minutum

Oscillatory cAMP signals very likely organize the cell movement which leads to fruiting body construction in Dictyostelium minutum [Schaap, P., Konijn, T.M. and Van Haastert, P.J.M.: Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 81, 2122-2126 (1984)]. Stimulation with cAMP induces a transient elevation of cGMP in cells at the early culmination stage, which peaks at 12-18 s. A half maximal cGMP response is induced by 10(-7) M cAMP and saturation of the response is reached at 10(-5) M cAMP. No cGMP accumulation was induced by stimulation of vegetative or aggregative cells of D. minutum by cAMP. Since the transient increase of cGMP is most likely involved in the transduction of chemotactic signals, our results indicate that cAMP signals organize fruiting body formation by inducing chemotaxis inside the aggregate.

The possible involvement of oscillatory cAMP signaling in multicellular morphogenesis of the cellular slime molds

The involvement of pulsatile chemoattractant emission and signal relay in aggregation and multicellular morphogenesis of a variety of cellular slime mold species was investigated. The species differ from each other in the developmental stage when pulsatile signaling first becomes evident. In D. discoideum, D. mucoroides, and D. purpureum pulsatile signal emission starts in the preaggregative field. In D. vinaceo-fuscum, D. mexicanum, P. violaceum, and P. pallidum the aggregation centers shifts from continuous to pulsatile secretion of chemoattractant during the aggregation process. In D. minutum pulsatile signaling starts after the completion of aggregation and slightly before the onset of culmination. Tip formation is a consequence of continued attraction of amoebae inside the aggregate to the center of signal emission. The occurrence of pulsatile signaling at an early stage of development is correlated with the capacity of the tip (signaling center) to organize a relatively large number of cells into a single fruiting body. Several lines of evidence suggest that cAMP is probably involved in the coordination of morphogenetic movement in the multicellular stage of all investigated species.