Differential expression of muscle-specific enolase in embryonic and fetal myogenic cells during mouse development

Human skeletal muscle organoids model fetal myogenesis and sustain uncommitted PAX7 myogenic progenitors

In vitro culture systems that structurally model human myogenesis and promote PAX7+ myogenic progenitor maturation have not been established. Here we report that human skeletal muscle organoids can be differentiated from induced pluripotent stem cell lines to contain paraxial mesoderm and neuromesodermal progenitors and develop into organized structures reassembling neural plate border and dermomyotome. Culture conditions instigate neural lineage arrest and promote fetal hypaxial myogenesis toward limb axial anatomical identity, with generation of sustainable uncommitted PAX7 myogenic progenitors and fibroadipogenic (PDGFRa+) progenitor populations equivalent to those from the second trimester of human gestation. Single-cell comparison to human fetal and adult myogenic progenitor /satellite cells reveals distinct molecular signatures for non-dividing myogenic progenitors in activated (CD44High/CD98+/MYOD1+) and dormant (PAX7High/FBN1High/SPRY1High) states. Our approach provides a robust 3D in vitro developmental system for investigating muscle tissue morphogenesis and homeostasis.

Pax7 as molecular switch regulating early and advanced stages of myogenic mouse ESC differentiation in teratomas

Background

Pluripotent stem cells present the ability to self-renew and undergo differentiation into any cell type building an organism. Importantly, a lot of evidence on embryonic stem cell (ESC) differentiation comes from in vitro studies. However, ESCs cultured in vitro do not necessarily behave as cells differentiating in vivo. For this reason, we used teratomas to study early and advanced stages of in vivo ESC myogenic differentiation and the role of Pax7 in this process. Pax7 transcription factor plays a crucial role in the formation and differentiation of skeletal muscle precursor cells during embryonic development. It controls the expression of other myogenic regulators and also acts as an anti-apoptotic factor. It is also involved in the formation and maintenance of satellite cell population.

Methods

In vivo approach we used involved generation and analysis of pluripotent stem cell-derived teratomas. Such model allows to analyze early and also terminal stages of tissue differentiation, for example, terminal stages of myogenesis, including the formation of innervated and vascularized mature myofibers.

Results

We determined how the lack of Pax7 function affects the generation of different myofiber types. In Pax7−/− teratomas, the skeletal muscle tissue occupied significantly smaller area, as compared to Pax7+/+ ones. The proportion of myofibers expressing Myh3 and Myh2b did not differ between Pax7+/+ and Pax7−/− teratomas. However, the area of Myh7 and Myh2a myofibers was significantly lower in Pax7−/− ones. Molecular characteristic of skeletal muscles revealed that the levels of mRNAs coding Myh isoforms were significantly lower in Pax7−/− teratomas. The level of mRNAs encoding Pax3 was significantly higher, while the expression of Nfix, Eno3, Mck, Mef2a, and Itga7 was significantly lower in Pax7−/− teratomas, as compared to Pax7+/+ ones. We proved that the number of satellite cells in Pax7−/− teratomas was significantly reduced. Finally, analysis of neuromuscular junction localization in samples prepared with the iDISCO method confirmed that the organization of neuromuscular junctions in Pax7−/− teratomas was impaired.

Conclusions

Pax7−/− ESCs differentiate in vivo to embryonic myoblasts more readily than Pax7+/+ cells. In the absence of functional Pax7, initiation of myogenic differentiation is facilitated, and as a result, the expression of mesoderm embryonic myoblast markers is upregulated. However, in the absence of functional Pax7 neuromuscular junctions, formation is abnormal, what results in lower differentiation potential of Pax7−/− ESCs during advanced stages of myogenesis.

Nuclear factor one transcription factors: Divergent functions in developmental versus adult stem cell populations

Nuclear factor one (NFI) transcription factors are a group of site-specific DNA-binding proteins that are emerging as critical regulators of stem cell biology. During development NFIs promote the production of differentiated progeny at the expense of stem cell fate, with Nfi null mice exhibiting defects such as severely delayed brain and lung maturation, skeletomuscular defects and renal abnormalities, phenotypes that are often consistent with patients with congenital Nfi mutations. Intriguingly, recent research suggests that in adult tissues NFI factors play a qualitatively different role than during development, with NFIs serving to promote the survival and maintenance of slow-cycling adult stem cell populations rather than their differentiation. Here we review the role of NFI factors in development, largely focusing on their role as promoters of stem cell differentiation, and attempt to reconcile this with the emerging role of NFIs in adult stem cell niches.

Identification of genes expressed during early somatic embryogenesis in Pinus radiata

Analysis of cDNA-AFLPs was used to study gene expression underlying the early embryogenic process in the gymnosperm Pinus radiata. Somatic embryogenesis in this species was used as a model as it resulted in the generation of a large number of embryos at defined stages of development. The gene expression patterns of three embryogenic stages were compared with non-embryogenic cells. Fifty transcript-derived fragments (TDFs) that are upregulated and 32 TDFs that are down-regulated in the embryogenic stages were selected, sequenced and their homologies sought in the databases. Expression of a selected subset of differentially expressed genes was confirmed by RT-PCR and their levels of expression were quantified. Of the 50 up-regulated TDFs, 16 are homologous to genes encoding either known or putative proteins in higher plants, 19 are homologous to conifer ESTs and 15 did not show significant matches. Of the down-regulated TDFs, 8 are homologous to genes encoding either known or putative proteins, 20 are homologous to conifer ESTs and 4 of them did not show significant matches in DNA or protein sequence database. The known up-regulated genes were similar to genes involved in cellular metabolism and in the stress response and the known down-regulated genes were similar to genes involved in proteolysis, cell wall modification and signaling pathways. Their putative individual function is briefly reviewed based on published information, and the potential roles of these genes in embryo development are discussed.

Integration of embryonic and fetal skeletal myogenic programs at the myosin light chain 1f/3f locus

The genetic control of skeletal muscle differentiation at the onset of myogenesis in the embryo is relatively well understood compared to the formation of muscle during the fetal period giving rise to the bulk of skeletal muscle fibers at birth. The Mlc1f/3f (Myl1) locus encodes two alkali myosin light chains, Mlc1f and Mlc3f, from two promoters that are differentially regulated during development. The Mlc1f promoter is active in embryonic, fetal and adult fast skeletal muscle whereas the Mlc3f promoter is upregulated during fetal development and remains on in adult fast skeletal muscle. Two enhancer elements have been identified at the mammalian Mlc1f/3f locus, a 3' element active at all developmental stages and an intronic enhancer activated during fetal development. Here, using transgenesis, we demonstrate that these enhancers act combinatorially to confer the spatial, temporal and quantitative expression profile of the endogenous Mlc3f promoter. Using double reporter transgenes we demonstrate that each enhancer can activate both Mlc1f and Mlc3f promoters in vivo, revealing enhancer sharing rather than exclusive enhancer-promoter interactions. Finally, we demonstrate that the fetal activated enhancer contains critical E-box myogenic regulatory factor binding sites and that enhancer activation is impaired in vivo in the absence of myogenin but not in the absence of innervation. Together our observations provide insights into the regulation of fetal myogenesis and the mechanisms by which temporally distinct genetic programs are integrated at a single locus.

Cellular heterogeneity during vertebrate skeletal muscle development

Although skeletal muscles appear superficially alike at different anatomical locations, in reality there is considerably more diversity than previously anticipated. Heterogeneity is not only restricted to completely developed fibers, but is clearly apparent during development at the molecular, cellular and anatomical level. Multiple waves of muscle precursors with different features appear before birth and contribute to muscular diversification. Recent cell lineage and gene expression studies have expanded our knowledge on how skeletal muscle is formed and how its heterogeneity is generated. This review will present a comprehensive view of relevant findings in this field.

Interactions of enolase isoforms with tubulin and microtubules during myogenesis

Enolase is a glycolytic enzyme, expressed as cell-type specific isoforms in higher vertebrates. Herein we demonstrated for the first time that enolase isoforms interact with microtubules during muscle satellite cell differentiation. While in undifferentiated myoblasts the ubiquitous alphaalpha enolase isoform, expressed at high level, exhibited extensive co-localization with microtubules, the muscle-specific betabeta isoform, expressed at low level, did not. During differentiation, the level of beta subunit increased significantly; the alpha and beta enolase immunoreactivities were detected both in cytosol and along the microtubules. We identified tubulin from muscle extract as an interacting protein for immobilized betabeta enolase. ELISA and surface plasmon resonance measurements demonstrated the direct binding of enolase isoforms to tubulin with an apparent KD below the micromolar range, and indicated that the presence of 0.8 mM 2-phosphoglycerate abolished the interaction. Our data showed that, at various stages of myogenic differentiation, microtubules were decorated by different enolase isoforms, which was controlled by the abundance of both partners. We suggest that the binding of enolase to microtubules could contribute to the regulation of the dynamism of the cytoskeletal filaments known to occur during the transition from myoblast to myotubes.

Intrinsic phenotypic diversity of embryonic and fetal myoblasts is revealed by genome-wide gene expression analysis on purified cells

Skeletal muscle development occurs asynchronously and it has been proposed to be dependent upon the generation of temporally distinct populations of myogenic cells. This long-held hypothesis has not been tested directly due to the inability to isolate and analyze purified populations of myoblasts derived from specific stages of prenatal development. Using a mouse strain with the GFP reporter gene targeted into the Myf5 locus, a cell-sorting method was developed for isolating embryonic and fetal myoblasts. The two types of myoblasts show an intrinsic difference in fusion ability, proliferation, differentiation and response to TGFbeta, TPA and BMP-4 in vitro. Microarray and quantitative PCR were used to identify differentially expressed genes both before and after differentiation, thus allowing a precise phenotypic analysis of the two populations. Embryonic and fetal myoblasts differ in the expression of a number of transcription factors and surface molecules, which may control different developmental programs. For example, only embryonic myoblasts express a Hox code along the antero-posterior axis, indicating that they possess direct positional information. Taken together, the data presented here demonstrate that embryonic and fetal myoblasts represent intrinsically different myogenic lineages and provide important information for the understanding of the molecular mechanisms governing skeletal muscle development.

A comparative proteome and phosphoproteome analysis of differentially regulated proteins during fertilization in the self-incompatible speciesSolanum chacoense Bitt

We have used 2-DE for a time-course study of the changes in protein and phosphoprotein expression that occur immediately after fertilization in Solanum chacoense. The phosphorylation status of the detected proteins was determined with three methods: in vivo labeling, immunodetection, and phosphoprotein-specific staining. Using a pI range of 4-7, 262 phosphorylated proteins could be mapped to the 619 proteins detected by Sypro Ruby staining, representing 42% of the total proteins. Among these phosphoproteins, antibodies detected 184 proteins from which 78 were also detected with either of the other two methods (42%). Pro-Q Diamond phosphoprotein stain detected 111 proteins, of which 76 were also detected with either of the other two methods (68%). The 32P in vivo labeling method detected 90 spots from which 78 were also detected with either of other two methods (87%). On comparing before and after fertilization profiles, 38 proteins and phosphoproteins presented a reproducible change in their accumulation profiles. Among these, 24 spots were selected and analyzed by LC-MS/MS using a hybrid quadrupole-TOF (Q-TOF) instrument. Peptide data were searched against publicly available protein and EST databases, and the putative roles of the identified proteins in early fertilization events are discussed.

Proteome analysis of early somatic embryogenesis in Picea glauca

Forestry is a valuable natural resource for many countries. Rapid production of large quantities of genetically improved and uniform seedlings for restocking harvested lands is a key component of sustainable forest management programs. Clonal propagation through somatic embryogenesis has the potential to meet this need in conifers and can offer the added benefit of ensuring consistent seedling quality. Although in commercial use, mass production of conifers through somatic embryogenesis is relatively new and there are numerous biological unknowns regarding this complex developmental pathway. To aid in unravelling the embryo developmental process, two-dimensional electrophoresis was employed to quantitatively assess the expression levels of proteins across four stages of somatic embryo maturation in white spruce (0, 7, 21 and 35 days post abscisic acid treatment). Forty-eight differentially expressed proteins have been identified, which display a significant change in abundance as early as day 7 of embryo development. These proteins are involved in a variety of cellular processes, many of which have not previously been associated with embryo development. The identification of these proteins was greatly assisted by the availability of a substantial expressed sequence tag (EST) resource developed for white, sitka and interior spruce. The combined use of these spruce ESTs in conjunction with GenBank accessions for other plants improved the rate of protein identification from 38% to 62% when compared with GenBank alone using automated, high-throughput techniques. This underscores the utility of EST resources in a proteomic study of any species for which a genome sequence is unavailable.

The muscle-specific enolase is an early marker of human myogenesis

In higher vertebrates, the glycolytic enzyme enolase (2-phospho-D-glycerate hydrolase; EC 4.2.1.11) is active as a dimer formed from three different subunits, alpha, beta and gamma, encoded by separate genes. The expression of these genes is developmentally regulated in a tissue-specific manner. A shift occurs during development, from the unique embryonic isoform alphaalpha, towards specific isoforms in two tissues with high energy demands: alphagamma and gammagamma in the nervous system, alphabeta and betabeta in striated muscles. The alphaalpha remains widely distributed in adult tissues. Here we report the results of the first extensive study of beta enolase expression during human development. Indeed, the beta subunit is specifically expressed at early stages of human myogenesis. Immunocytochemical analyses demonstrated that it is first detected in the heart of 3-week-old embryos and in the myotomal compartment of somites from 4-week-old embryos. At this stage, the muscle-specific sarcomeric protein titin is expressed in this structure, which will give rise to all body skeletal muscles, but embryonic myosin heavy chain is not yet present. Analyses at the protein level show that, during human ontogenesis, myogenesis is accompanied by an increase in beta enolase expression and by a decrease in the expression of the two other alpha and gamma subunits. Furthermore, beta enolase subunit is expressed in proliferating myoblasts from both embryonic and post-natal muscles. In addition, clonal analysis of primary cell cultures, obtained from the leg muscle of a 7-week-old human embryo, revealed that the beta subunit is present in the dividing myoblasts of all four types, according to the classification of Edom-Vovard et al. [(1999) J Cell Sci 112: 191-199], but not in cells of the non-myogenic lineage. Myoblast fusion is accompanied by a large increase in beta enolase expression. Our results demonstrate that this muscle-specific isoform of a glycolytic enzyme (beta enolase) is among the earliest markers of myogenic differentiation in humans.

Coregulation of fast contractile protein transgene and glycolytic enzyme expression in mouse skeletal muscle

Little is known of the gene regulatory mechanisms that coordinate the contractile and metabolic specializations of skeletal muscle fibers. Here we report a novel connection between fast isoform contractile protein transgene and glycolytic enzyme expression. In quantitative histochemical studies of transgenic mouse muscle fibers, we found extensive coregulation of the glycolytic enzyme glycerol-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GPDH) and transgene constructs based on the fast skeletal muscle troponin I (TnIfast) gene. In addition to a common IIB > IIX > IIA fiber type pattern, TnIfast transgenes and GPDH showed correlated fiber-to-fiber variation within each fast fiber type, concerted emergence of high-level expression during early postnatal muscle maturation, and parallel responses to muscle under- or overloading. Regulatory information for GPDH-coregulated expression is carried by the TnIfast first-intron enhancer (IRE). These results identify an unexpected contractile/metabolic gene regulatory link that is amenable to further molecular characterization. They also raise the possibility that the equal expression in all fast fiber types observed for the endogenous TnIfast gene may be driven by different metabolically coordinated mechanisms in glycolytic (IIB) vs. oxidative (IIA) fast fibers.

Beta-enolase deficiency, a new metabolic myopathy of distal glycolysis

A severe muscle enolase deficiency, with 5% of residual activity, was detected in a 47-year-old man affected with exercise intolerance and myalgias. No rise of serum lactate was observed with the ischemic forearm exercise. Ultrastructural analysis showed focal sarcoplasmic accumulation of glycogen beta particles. The enzyme enolase catalyzes the interconversion of 2-phosphoglycerate and phosphoenolpyruvate. In adult human muscle, over 90% of enolase activity is accounted for by the beta-enolase subunit, the protein product of the ENO3 gene. The beta-enolase protein was dramatically reduced in the muscle of our patient, by both immunohistochemistry and immunoblotting, while alpha-enolase was normally represented. The ENO3 gene of our patient carries two heterozygous missense mutations affecting highly conserved amino acid residues; a G467A transition changing a glycine residue at position 156 to aspartate, in close proximity to the catalytic site, and a G1121A transition changing a glycine to glutamate at position 374. These mutations were probably inherited as autosomal recessive traits since the mother was heterozygous for the G467A and a sister was heterozygous for the G1121A transition. Our data suggest that ENO3 mutations result in decreased stability of mutant beta-enolase. Muscle beta-enolase deficiency should be considered in the differential diagnosis of metabolic myopathies due to inherited defects of distal glycolysis.

Role of mRNA stability and translation in the expression of cytochrome c oxidase during mouse myoblast differentiation: instability of the mRNA for the liver isoform of subunit VIa

The role of mRNA stability and translation in mediating the expression of selected subunits of cytochrome c oxidase (COX) was examined during the differentiation of mouse myoblasts into myotubes in cell culture. The expression of the liver (L) and heart (H) isoforms of COX VIa, which undergo an isoform switch during muscle development, as well as of the Va subunit, which is expressed in all tissues, was analysed. The translational efficiencies of COX Va, VIa-L and VIa-H, as well as of mitochondrially encoded COX mRNAs, were inferred from their distribution in polysome gradients. These experiments suggest that the translational efficiencies of these mRNAs do not change during myoblast differentiation, although the nuclear mRNAs for COX Va, VIa-L and VIa-H are translated more efficiently than the mitochondrial mRNAs. Analysis of mRNA stability using the tetracycline-repressible promoter system and/or actinomycin D indicates that COX VIa-L mRNA decays with a half-life of approximately 5-6 h in both myoblasts and myotubes, whereas COX VIa-H and Va mRNAs decay with half-lives of > 15 h in myotubes. This relative instability of COX VIa-L mRNA serves to limit the accumulation of COX VIa-L mRNA in these myogenic cells, as compared with mRNAs for other COX subunits. Deletion/replacement mapping experiments suggest that the COX VIa-L 3' untranslated region contains a destabilization element. Analysis of the rate of poly(A) tail shortening on COX VIa-L and stable alpha-globin mRNAs suggests that the overall rate of poly(A) shortening per se is not rate limiting for the degradation of COX VIa-L mRNA.

Modular regulation of the MLC1F/3F gene and striated muscle diversity

Isoform diversity in striated muscle is largely controlled at the level of transcription. In this review we will concentrate on studies concerning transcriptional regulation of the alkali myosin light chain 1F/3F gene. Uncoupled activity of the MLC1F and 3F promoters, together with complex patterns of transcription in developing skeletal and cardiac muscle, combine to make analysis of this gene particularly intriguing. In vitro and transgenic studies of MLC1F/3F regulatory elements have revealed an array of cis-acting modules that each drive a subset of the expression pattern of the two promoters. These cis-acting regulatory modules, including the MLC1F and 3F promoter regions and two skeletal muscle enhancers, control tissue-specificity, cell or fibre-type specificity, and the spatiotemporal regulation of gene expression, including positional information. How each of these regulatory modules acts and how their individual activites are integrated to coordinate transcription at this locus are discussed.

Maturation of the myogenic program is induced by postmitotic expression of insulin-like growth factor I

The molecular mechanisms underlying myogenic induction by insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) are distinct from its proliferative effects on myoblasts. To determine the postmitotic role of IGF-I on muscle cell differentiation, we derived L6E9 muscle cell lines carrying a stably transfected rat IGF-I gene under the control of a myosin light chain (MLC) promoter-enhancer cassette. Expression of MLC-IGF-I exclusively in differentiated L6E9 myotubes, which express the embryonic form of myosin heavy chain (MyHC) and no endogenous IGF-I, resulted in pronounced myotube hypertrophy, accompanied by activation of the neonatal MyHC isoform. The hypertrophic myotubes dramatically increased expression of myogenin, muscle creatine kinase, beta-enolase, and IGF binding protein 5 and activated the myocyte enhancer factor 2C gene which is normally silent in this cell line. MLC-IGF-I induction in differentiated L6E9 cells also increased the expression of a transiently transfected LacZ reporter driven by the myogenin promoter, demonstrating activation of the differentiation program at the transcriptional level. Nuclear reorganization, accumulation of skeletal actin protein, and an increased expression of beta1D integrin were also observed. Inhibition of the phosphatidyl inositol (PI) 3-kinase intermediate in IGF-I-mediated signal transduction confirmed that the PI 3-kinase pathway is required only at early stages for IGF-I-mediated hypertrophy and neonatal MyHC induction in these cells. Expression of IGF-I in postmitotic muscle may therefore play an important role in the maturation of the myogenic program.

The beta enolase subunit displays three different patterns of microheterogeneity in human striated muscle

In higher vertebrates, the glycolytic enzyme enolase (2-phospho-D-glycerate hydrolyase; EC 4.2.1.11) is active as a dimeric protein formed from three subunits--alpha: ubiquitous, beta: muscle specific, and gamma: neuron specific--encoded by different genes. In the present study, we have shown that an antiserum previously produced against the mouse beta beta enolase is also a specific reagent for the muscle specific human enolase. Using this antiserum to study human muscles, we demonstrated novel patterns of the beta subunit microheterogeneity which are distinctive from those observed previously in rodents and which appear to be independent of age, gender and muscular activity. Two variants of the beta subunit differing by their size have been detected: one heavy form of 46 kDa (beta H) and one light form of 45 kDa (beta L). Muscle biopsies expressed either beta H or beta L or beta H + beta L, and all muscles of an individual expressed the same variants. The products of in vitro translation of RNA prepared from human muscle displayed beta subunit variants identical to those of the protein present in the biopsy. Therefore the differences observed between individuals reveal a difference already present at the level of the RNA transcripts. These observations suggest the existence of an yet undescribed polymorphism of the human beta enolase gene which could affect the coding sequence. Comparative immunocytochemical and histochemical analyses of biopsies demonstrated that the beta subunit was expressed in all fast fibres (type II), but not in slow fibres (type I). No difference was observed in the intensity of beta enolase immunolabelling between the various types (IIA, IIAB, IIB) of fast fibres. No significant difference in fibre type composition and histological appearance was visible between muscles presenting either one of the three patterns of microheterogeneity.

Negative regulation of beta enolase gene transcription in embryonic muscle is dependent upon a zinc finger factor that binds to the G-rich box within the muscle-specific enhancer

We have previously identified a muscle-specific enhancer within the first intron of the human beta enolase gene. Present in this enhancer are an A/T-rich box that binds MEF-2 protein(s) and a G-rich box (AGTGGGGGAGGGGGCTGCG) that interacts with ubiquitously expressed factors. Both elements are required for tissue-specific expression of the gene in skeletal muscle cells. Here, we report the identification and characterization of a Kruppel-like zinc finger protein, termed beta enolase repressor factor 1, that binds in a sequence-specific manner to the G-rich box and functions as a repressor of the beta enolase gene transcription in transient transfection assays. Using fusion polypeptides of beta enolase repressor factor 1 and the yeast GAL4 DNA-binding domain, we have identified an amino-terminal region responsible for the transcriptional repression activity, whereas a carboxyl-terminal region was shown to contain a potential transcriptional activation domain. The expression of this protein decreases in developing skeletal muscles, correlating with lack of binding activity in nuclear extract from adult skeletal tissue, in which novel binding activities have been detected. These results suggest that in addition to the identified factor, which functionally acts as a negative regulator and is enriched in embryonic muscle, the G-rich box binds other factors, presumably exerting a positive control on transcription. The interplay between factors that repress or activate transcription may constitute a developmentally regulated mechanism that modulates beta enolase gene expression in skeletal muscle.

Transcription of the human beta enolase gene (ENO-3) is regulated by an intronic muscle-specific enhancer that binds myocyte-specific enhancer factor 2 proteins and ubiquitous G-rich-box binding factors

To provide evidence for the cis-regulatory DNA sequences and trans-acting factors involved in the complex pattern of tissue- and stage-specific expression of the beta enolase gene, constructs containing fragments of the gene fused to the chloramphenicol acetyltransferase gene were used in transient-transfection assays of C2C12 myogenic cells. Deletion analysis revealed the presence of four major regions: two negative regions in the 5'-flanking sequence, a basal promoter region which directs expression at low levels in proliferating and differentiated muscle cells, and a positive region within the first intron that confers cell-type-specific and differentiation-induced expression. This positive regulatory element is located in the 3'-proximal portion of the first intron (nucleotides +504 to +637) and acts as an enhancer irrespective of orientation and position from the homologous beta enolase promoter or the heterologous thymidine kinase promoter, conferring in both cases muscle-specific expression to the linked reporter gene. Deletion of a putative myocyte-specific enhancer factor 1 (MEF-1) binding site, containing a canonical E-box motif, had no effects on muscle-specific transcription, indicating that this site is not required for the activity of the enhancer. Gel mobility shift assays, competition analysis, DNase I footprinting, and mutagenesis studies indicated that this element interacts through an A/T-rich box with a MEF-2 protein(s) and through a G-rich box with a novel ubiquitous factor(s). Mutation of either the G-rich box or the A/T-rich box resulted in a significantly reduced activity of the enhancer in transient-transfection assays. These data indicate that MEF-2 and G-rich-box binding factors are each necessary for tissue-specific expression of the beta enolase gene in skeletal muscle cells.

Conserved alternative splicing in the 5'-untranslated region of the muscle-specific enolase gene. Primary structure of mRNAs, expression and influence of secondary structure on the translation efficiency

We report here the isolation and characterization of cDNAs covering the 5'-end region of mouse and rat mRNAs that encode the beta or muscle-specific isoform of the glycolytic enzyme enolase. As previously determined for humans, two classes of beta-enolase transcripts with distinct sequences in their 5'-untranslated regions are present in both mouse and rat muscles. A mechanism of alternative splicing, conserved from mouse to man, generates the two forms of mRNA. Secondary-structure predictions indicated that, in all cases, a more stable secondary structure could exist in the 5' end of the message with the longer leader. In vitro transcripts containing defined human or mouse 5'-untranslated sequences were obtained by fusion of the different cDNA clones and tested for their relative translational efficiencies in rabbit reticulocyte lysates. Transcripts containing the human long and short leader sequences showed differences in the translational rate, suggesting a role for the 5'-untranslated region in the regulation of translation. No detectable difference was found between transcripts with the two distinct mouse leader sequences. In addition, both transcripts are bound to polysomes and are equally distributed along differently sized polysomes in C2C12 myogenic cells. The relative expression of the two spliced forms in developing and adult muscle tissues by means of reverse transcription and polymerase chain reaction did not show a stage-specific or a tissue-type-specific pattern. A putative functional role for the 5'-untranslated sequences of beta-enolase transcripts is discussed.

Transcriptional up-regulation of the mouse gene for the muscle-specific subunit of enolase during terminal differentiation of myogenic cells

The glycolytic enzyme enolase (EC 4.2.1.11) exists as dimers formed from three structurally related subunits alpha, beta, and gamma, encoded by separate genes. The gene encoding the beta-subunit is expressed only in striated muscles. We have previously shown that the beta-enolase gene belongs to a small subset of muscle-specific genes showing transcriptional activity in cultured myoblasts, prior to withdrawal from the cell cycle. An increase in the level of beta-enolase mRNA occurs during terminal differentiation of myoblasts. To investigate the mechanisms underlying this increase, we have simultaneously estimated, under steady state conditions, the rate of synthesis and the stability of beta-enolase mRNA in proliferating C2.7 myoblasts as well as in differentiating myotubes. The method used is based on the isolation of newly synthesized RNA from the total RNA pool, following pulse-labeling of intact cells in the presence of 4-thiouridine. The results described here demonstrate a coordinate increase in newly synthesized and total beta-enolase mRNA, while the mRNA half-life, about 4 hr, remains unchanged in the course of terminal differentiation. The expression of the gene for insulin-like growth factor-II (IGF-II), a major positive regulator of myogenesis, was analyzed using the same approach. It is concluded that the up-regulation of beta-enolase as well as IGF-II gene expression in differentiating muscle cells reflects an increased rate of entry of newly synthesized mRNAs into the general pool of transcripts without changes in their respective half-lives.

Regulation of the myoblast-specific expression of the human beta-enolase gene

The muscle-specific beta-enolase gene is expressed in proliferating adult myoblasts as well as in differentiated myotubes. Through deletion-transfection analysis, we identified a 79-base pair enhancer from the beta-enolase gene that leads to high level expression of a reporter gene in myoblasts, but not in fibroblasts. Following myoblast differentiation into myotubes, the activity of the enhancer declined, indicating that beta-enolase gene expression in myotubes is mediated by other regulators, possibly the myogenic helix-loop-helix family of transcription factors. Electrophoretic mobility shift assays indicated that proteins present in myoblast nuclear extracts specifically bind to the 3' half of the 79-base pair enhancer. This region contains an ets DNA-binding motif which is required not only for high level activity in myoblasts, but also for repressing activity in fibroblasts. Furthermore, the beta-enolase myoblast-specific enhancer shows limited similarity to the myoblast-specific enhancer associated with the human desmin gene, suggesting that gene expression in adult myoblasts may be coordinately regulated.

Skeletal muscle satellite cells

Evidence now suggests that satellite cells constitute a class of myogenic cells that differ distinctly from other embryonic myoblasts. Satellite cells arise from somites and first appear as a distinct myoblast type well before birth. Satellite cells from different muscles cannot be functionally distinguished from one another and are able to provide nuclei to all fibers without regard to phenotype. Thus, it is difficult to ascribe any significant function to establishing or stabilizing fiber type, even during regeneration. Within a muscle, satellite cells exhibit marked heterogeneity with respect to their proliferative behavior. The satellite cell population on a fiber can be partitioned into those that function as stem cells and those which are readily available for fusion. Recent studies have shown that the cells are not simply spindle shaped, but are very diverse in their morphology and have multiple branches emanating from the poles of the cells. This finding is consistent with other studies indicating that the cells have the capacity for extensive migration within, and perhaps between, muscles. Complexity of cell shape usually reflects increased cytoplasmic volume and organelles including a well developed Golgi, and is usually associated with growing postnatal muscle or muscles undergoing some form of induced adaptive change or repair. The appearance of activated satellite cells suggests some function of the cells in the adaptive process through elaboration and secretion of a product. Significant advances have been made in determining the potential secretion products that satellite cells make. The manner in which satellite cell proliferative and fusion behavior is controlled has also been studied. There seems to be little doubt that cellcell coupling is not how satellite cells and myofibers communicate. Rather satellite cell regulation is through a number of potential growth factors that arise from a number of sources. Critical to the understanding of this form of control is to determine which of the many growth factors that can alter satellite cell behavior in vitro are at work in vivo. Little work has been done to determine what controls are at work after a regeneration response has been initiated. It seems likely that, after injury, growth factors are liberated through proteolytic activity and initiate an activation process whereby cells enter into a proliferative phase. After myofibers are formed, it also seems likely that satellite cell behavior is regulated through diffusible factors arising from the fibers rather than continuous control by circulating factors.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Structural features of the human gene for muscle-specific enolase. Differential splicing in the 5'-untranslated sequence generates two forms of mRNA

We report here the isolation and characterization of the human gene for the beta or muscle-specific isoform of the glycolytic enzyme enolase. The nucleotide sequence analysis revealed structural features, such as organization as 11 coding exons, the first exon consisting of an untranslated sequence and hence resembling sequences of the other two members of the gene family, the alpha and gamma enolase genes. The beta enolase locus spans about 6 kbp genomic DNA. Sequences matching the consensus sequence for muscle-specific regulatory factors are present in the 5'-flanking region and within the first intron. A combination of primer extension, S1 nuclease protection and RNA-sequencing experiments indicates that the gene has a unique transcriptional start site, 26 bp downstream of a TATA-like box; the differential usage of two donor sites within the untranslated exon I generates two alternatively spliced transcripts. The existence of the two mRNA, differing from one another in the presence or absence of a 42-nucleotide fragment in the leader sequence, was confirmed by cloning the corresponding cDNA using the rapid amplification of cDNA ends strategy. Secondary-structure predictions indicated that the leader sequences of the spliced forms could form hairpin structures with different free energies of formation, suggesting translational control.

Differential expression of neuron-specific enolase mRNA in mouse neuroblastoma cells in response to differentiation inducing agents

1. The mouse neuroblastoma cell line N-115 was used as a model system to study neuronal differentiation induced by treatment of cells with different agents. 2. The extent of morphological differentiation obtained with dibutyryl cyclic AMP (dbc-AMP), dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), retinoic acid (RA), and serum-free medium was correlated to the expression of the mRNA for the gamma isoform of the glycolytic enzyme enolase, a recognized neuron-specific marker. 3. A 4-day treatment of the cells with any of the differentiation inducing agents used in this study resulted in the extension of long neurites, though differences in cell body shape were observed depending on the agent used. 4. Northern blot analysis revealed that changes in the level of gamma enolase-specific mRNA correlate with the extent of morphological differentiation, with a 5- to 20-fold increase depending on the differentiation inducing agent used. 5. Finally, we found that a high cell density causes a significative increase in the level of the gamma enolase-specific message in cells maintained in growing conditions.

Modulation of embryonic and muscle-specific enolase gene products in the developing mouse hindlimb

During striated muscle development, the glycolytic enzyme enolase (EC 4.2.1.11) undergoes an isozymic transition, from the embryonic alpha alpha form towards the muscle-specific forms alpha beta and beta beta. The regulation of this transition was analyzed in mouse hindlimb muscles from embryonic day 15 (E15) to the adult stage. The quantitative modulations of the levels of the transcripts and subunits of alpha and beta enolase genes were determined. The absolute amounts of alpha and beta enolase mRNAs were estimated using in vitro synthesized transcripts as calibration standards, thus allowing an evaluation of their relative contribution at each stage examined. The muscle-specific beta enolase mRNA is already present at E15. Its level then increases and, from E17, this transcript becomes predominant. This accumulation is biphasic: a steep prenatal rise, corresponding to a net increase per fiber, accompanies the formation of secondary myofibers and the development of innervation; a second rise, beginning at postnatal day 5, is temporally correlated with the definitive specialization of the myofibers. Most of the decrease in alpha mRNA level occurs postnatally. No temporal or quantitative correlation between the up-regulation of beta mRNA and the down-regulation of alpha mRNA levels is observed throughout hindlimb muscle development. Quantitative immunoblotting analyses carried out in parallel show that the enolase isozymic transition is mainly controlled at the mRNA level.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Activation of the gene encoding the glycolytic enzyme beta-enolase during early myogenesis precedes an increased expression during fetal muscle development

We define the spatial and temporal patterns of expression of the gene encoding the glycolytic enzyme, beta-enolase, during mouse ontogenesis. Transcripts were detected by in situ hybridization using 35S labelled cRNA probes. The beta-enolase gene is expressed only in striated muscles. It is first detected in the embryo, in the cardiac tube and in newly formed myotomes. In the muscle masses of the limb, beta gene expression occurs at a low level in primary fibers, and subsequently greatly increases at a time which corresponds to the onset of innervation and secondary fiber formation. Later in development, it becomes undetectable in slow-twitch fibers. Our results demonstrate the multistep regulation of the beta-enolase gene. The regulation of this muscle-specific gene in somites is discussed in terms of the myogenic sequences of the MyoD family shown to be present when it is activated.

Beta-enolase is a marker of human myoblast heterogeneity prior to differentiation

In this report, we define a muscle-specific marker, beta-enolase, that distinguishes proliferating myoblasts from different stages of development. Enolase exists as multiple isoforms and in the course of cardiac and skeletal muscle development the beta isoform progressively replaces the alpha isoform. In skeletal muscle, this change in gene expression, unlike most developmental changes in myogenic gene expression, is evident in undifferentiated myoblasts. Whereas myoblasts from fetal tissues express alpha-enolase mRNA, beta-enolase is the predominant mRNA expressed by myoblasts from postnatal tissues. Our results are consistent with the idea that distinct precursor myoblasts contribute to the diversity of fiber types characteristic of muscle tissue at different stages of development.