Genetic and biochemical characterization of Bacillus subtilis mutants defective in expression and function of cytochrome b-558

Mutations in the Membrane-Anchored SdhC Subunit Affect Fitness and Sensitivity to Succinate Dehydrogenase Inhibitors in Botrytis cinerea Populations from Multiple Hosts

Succinate dehydrogenase inhibitors (SDHIs) are an essential group of fungicides for managing gray mold, caused by Botrytis cinerea, in numerous crops. Resistance to boscalid, an early-generation SDHI, is widespread worldwide and was linked to mutations in the iron-sulfur protein encoding the SdhB subunit of the SDH complex. Herein, we report on four simultaneous dependent mutations at codons 85 (G85A), 93 (I93V), 158 (M158V), and 168 (V168I) of the membrane-anchored SdhC subunit of B. cinerea. Isolates without and with mutations in SdhC were referred to as C^- and C⁺ genotypes, respectively. The C⁺ genotype was found in all the five surveyed hosts from different U.S. regions but its frequency was higher, 25 to 40%, in the tree fruit isolates compared with 12 to 25% in the small fruit populations. The four SdhC mutations were found in isolates without mutations in SdhB or with mutations known to confer resistance to the SDHIs in SdhB. However, the frequency of C⁺ isolates was significantly higher in the SdhB wild-type isolates, which suggests that SDHI sprays may have played a role in selecting for the C^- over the C⁺ genotype. Field C⁺ isolates exhibited reduced sensitivity to fluopyram and increased sensitivity to boscalid and penthiopyrad in vitro and on detached fruit. Homology modeling confirmed the positioning of the four mutations in the ubiquinone-binding pocket. The SdhC^G85A is found in the proximal ubiquinone binding site and SdhC^M158V is positioned in the iron sulfur protein interface next to the [3Fe-4S] cluster, whereas SdhC^I93V is positioned next to the heme b with vital functions in the SDH enzyme. Beside the differential sensitivity to the SDHIs, these mutations caused a significant fitness cost in the C⁺ isolates including sporulation and increased sensitivity to reactive oxygen species. The presence of Botrytis populations differentially sensitive to the SDHIs suggests increased risks for resistance development but also opens up new perspective for future gray mold management using different SDHI fungicides.

Succinate:quinone oxidoreductase in the bacteria Paracoccus denitrificans and Bacillus subtilis

An overview of the present knowledge about succinate:quinone oxidoreductase in Paracoccus denitrificans and Bacillus subtilis is presented. P. denitrificans contains a monoheme succinate:ubiquinone oxidoreductase that is similar to that of mammalian mitochondria with respect to composition and sensitivity to carboxin. Results obtained with carboxin-resistant P. denitrificans mutants provide information about quinone-binding sites on the enzyme and the molecular basis for the resistance. B. subtilis contains a diheme succinate:menaquinone oxidoreductase whose activity is dependent on the electrochemical gradient across the cytoplasmic membrane. Data from studies of mutant variants of the B. subtilis enzyme combined with available crystal structures of a similar enzyme, Wolinella succinogenes fumarate reductase, substantiate a proposed explanation for the mechanism of coupling between quinone reductase activity and transmembrane potential.

The distal heme center in Bacillus subtilis succinate:quinone reductase is crucial for electron transfer to menaquinone

Succinate:quinone reductases are membrane-bound enzymes that catalyze electron transfer from succinate to quinone. Some enzymes in vivo reduce ubiquinone (exergonic reaction) whereas others reduce menaquinone (endergonic reaction). The succinate:menaquinone reductases all contain two heme groups in the membrane anchor of the enzyme: a proximal heme (heme b(P)) located close to the negative side of the membrane and a distal heme (heme b(D)) located close to the positive side of the membrane. Heme b(D) is a distinctive feature of the succinate:menaquinone reductases, but the role of this heme in electron transfer to quinone has not previously been analyzed. His28 and His113 are the axial ligands to heme b(D) in Bacillus subtilis succinate:menaquinone reductase. We have individually replaced these His residues with Leu and Met, respectively, resulting in assembled membrane-bound enzymes. The H28L mutant enzyme lacks succinate:quinone reductase activity probably due to a defective quinone binding site. The H113M mutant enzyme contains heme b(D) with raised midpoint potential and is impaired in electron transfer to menaquinone. Our combined experimental data show that the heme b(D) center, into which we include a quinone binding site, is crucial for succinate:menaquinone reductase activity. The results support a model in which menaquinone is reduced on the positive side of the membrane and the transmembrane electrochemical potential provides driving force for electron transfer from succinate via heme b(P) and heme b(D) to menaquinone.

Localization of histidine residues responsible for heme axial ligation in cytochrome b556 of complex II (succinate:ubiquinone oxidoreductase) in Escherichia coli

Complex II (succinate:ubiquinone oxidoreductase) from Escherichia coli contains four different subunits. Two of the subunits (SDHC and SDHD) are hydrophobic and anchor the two more hydrophilic (flavin and iron-sulfur) subunits (SDHA and SDHB) to the cytoplasmic membrane. Previous studies have shown that the complex of SDHC/SDHD is required to maintain the heme B component of the enzyme and that the heme B is ligated to the protein by two histidine ligands. In the current work, the histidines within SDHC and SDHD have been systematically mutated. SDHC-His91 and SDHD-His14 were eliminated as potential ligands by these studies. SDHC-His84 and SDHD-His71 have been identified as the most likely heme axial ligands in the E. coli enzyme, suggesting that the heme bridges these two subunits in the membrane. Furthermore, the results show that the four-subunit Complex II assembles and retains function despite the absence of the heme B prosthetic group in the membrane. The results do not rule out completely SDHC-His30 as a candidate for heme ligation, but do show that mutation at this position prevents assembly of Complex II in the membrane.

Biogenesis of respiratory cytochromes in bacteria

Biogenesis of respiratory cytochromes is defined as consisting of the posttranslational processes that are necessary to assemble apoprotein, heme, and sometimes additional cofactors into mature enzyme complexes with electron transfer functions. Different biochemical reactions take place during maturation: (i) targeting of the apoprotein to or through the cytoplasmic membrane to its subcellular destination; (ii) proteolytic processing of precursor forms; (iii) assembly of subunits in the membrane and oligomerization; (iv) translocation and/or modification of heme and covalent or noncovalent binding to the protein moiety; (v) transport, processing, and incorporation of other cofactors; and (vi) folding and stabilization of the protein. These steps are discussed for the maturation of different oxidoreductase complexes, and they are arranged in a linear pathway to best account for experimental findings from studies concerning cytochrome biogenesis. The example of the best-studied case, i.e., maturation of cytochrome c, appears to consist of a pathway that requires at least nine specific genes and more general cellular functions such as protein secretion or the control of the redox state in the periplasm. Covalent attachment of heme appears to be enzyme catalyzed and takes place in the periplasm after translocation of the precursor through the membrane. The genetic characterization and the putative biochemical functions of cytochrome c-specific maturation proteins suggest that they may be organized in a membrane-bound maturase complex. Formation of the multisubunit cytochrome bc, complex and several terminal oxidases of the bo3, bd, aa3, and cbb3 types is discussed in detail, and models for linear maturation pathways are proposed wherever possible.

Transmembrane topology and axial ligands to hemes in the cytochrome b subunit of Bacillus subtilis succinate:menaquinone reductase

The membrane-anchoring subunit of Bacillus subtilis succinate:menaquinone reductase is a protein of 202 residues containing two protoheme IX groups with bis-histidine axial ligation. Residues His13, His28, His70, His113, and His155 are the possible heme ligands. The transmembrane topology of this cytochrome was analyzed using fusions to alkaline phosphatase. The results support a proposed model with five transmembrane polypeptide segments and the N-terminus exposed to the cytoplasm. Mutant B. subtilis cytochromes containing a His13-->Tyr, a His28-->Tyr, and a His113-->Tyr mutation, respectively, were produced in Escherichia coli, partially purified, and analyzed. In addition, succinate: menaquinone reductase containing the His13-->Tyr mutation in the anchor subunit was overproduced in B. subtilis, purified, and characterized. The data demonstrate that His13 is not an axial heme ligand. Thermodynamic and spectroscopic properties of the cytochrome are, however, affected by the His13-->Tyr mutation; compared to wild type, the redox potentials of both hemes are negatively shifted and the gmax signal in the EPR spectrum of the high-potential heme is shifted from 3.68 to 3.50. From the combined results we conclude that His28 and His113 function as axial ligands to the low-potential heme, which is located in the membrane near the outer surface of the cytoplasmic membrane. Residues His70 and His155 ligate the high-potential heme, which is positioned close to His13 in the protein, near the inner surface of the membrane.

Bacillus subtilis CtaA is a heme-containing membrane protein involved in heme A biosynthesis

Heme A is a prosthetic group of many respiratory oxidases. It is synthesized from protoheme IX (heme B) seemingly with heme O as a stable intermediate. The Bacillus subtilis ctaA and ctaB genes are required for heme A and heme O synthesis, respectively (B. Svensson, M. Lübben, and L. Hederstedt, Mol. Microbiol. 10:193-201, 1993). Tentatively, CtaA is involved in the monooxygenation and oxidation of the methyl side group on porphyrin ring D in heme A synthesis from heme B. B. subtilis ctaA and ctaB on plasmids in both B. subtilis and Escherichia coli were found to result in a novel membrane-bound heme-containing protein with the characteristics of a low-spin b-type cytochrome. It can be reduced via the respiratory chain, and in the reduced state it shows light absorption maxima at 428, 528, and 558 nm and the alpha-band is split. Purified cytochrome isolated from both B. subtilis and E. coli membranes contained one polypeptide identified as CtaA by amino acid sequence analysis, about 0.2 mol of heme B per mol of polypeptide, and small amounts of heme A.

The secretory S complex in Bacillus subtilis is identified as pyruvate dehydrogenase

We have cloned the operon for the Bacillus subtilis S complex, which has been suggested to be a component of the protein secretion machinery. The S-complex operon was found to encode 4 proteins, which were identified as subunits of pyruvate dehydrogenase (PDH). The Staphylococcus aureus membrane-bound ribosome protein (MBRP) complex has been considered to be a counterpart of the B. subtilis S complex. Here, we sequenced a fragment of the MBRP operon encoding the C-terminal part of E1 beta, the entire E2 and the N-terminal part of the E3 subunit of PDH, thus conclusively confirming the PDH identity of the MBRP complex as well. It appeared unlikely that PDH could be a primary component in protein secretion, thus disproving the previous hypothesis of the role of the S complex. However, attachment of the S complex (PDH) to the membrane and ribosomes may produce a biologically significant interaction.

Low temperature EPR and MCD studies on cytochrome b-558 of the Bacillus subtilis succinate: quinone oxidoreductase indicate bis-histidine coordination of the heme iron

Bacillus subtilis cytochrome b-558 was expressed in high amounts in Escherichia coli, solubilized from membranes with detergent and purified free from other hemoproteins. The cytochrome possibly contains two heme groups. To determine the axial ligands to the low-spin heme and the heme rhombicity, the cytochrome was analyzed using low-temperature electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and magnetic circular dichroism (MCD) spectroscopy. The combined results exclude bis-methionine, bis-lysine and histidine-methionine coordination. Bis-histidine coordination of the heme(s) with a near perpendicular orientation of the imidazole planes is strongly suggested by the highly axial low-spin EPR signals and the intense near infrared MCD spectrum (delta epsilon = 380 M-1.cm-1 at 4.2 K and 5 T) of the charge-transfer band at 1600 nm.

The importance of the 5'-region in regulating the stability of sdh mRNA in Bacillus subtilis

The decay of the polycistronic Bacillus subtilis sdh mRNA was analysed using probes specific for each of the component cistrons, sdhC, sdhA and sdhB. In exponentially growing cells, the entire sdh mRNA seems to decay with an 'all or nothing' mechanism and with a uniform half-life of 2-3 min for all cistrons. In stationary-phase cells, the half-life of the 5'-part had dropped to about 0.6 min whereas that of the 3'-part was about 1.2 min. Decay of sdh mRNA was also measured in exponentially growing cells containing a 'down-mutation' in the ribosomal binding site preceding sdhC which decreases the expression of sdhC by about 90%. The mutation has a moderate effect on expression of the downstream cistron sdhA. In this mutant, the half-life of the 5'-part of sdh mRNA was about 0.5 min (i.e. the same as in stationary phase wild-type cells) and the half-life of the 3'-part about 1.3 min. Also, analysis of the decay of an sdh-cat fusion transcript revealed that the sdh (5') part decayed more rapidly than the cat part and this difference was more pronounced in stationary-phase cells compared to exponentially growing cells. The results of these experiments demonstrate the importance of the 5'-segment of sdh mRNA in controlling the stability of the transcript under different growth conditions.

Bacillus subtilis holo-cytochrome c-550 can be synthesised in aerobic Escherichia coli

Bacillus subtilis membrane-bound holo-cytochrome c-550 was found to be expressed from the structural gene cloned on a plasmid vector in aerobically grown Escherichia coli and exhibited normal biochemical properties. This occurs despite the lack of endogenous cytochrome c and suggests that cytochrome c-heme lyase activity is also present in aerobic E. coli. The membrane topology of B. subtilis cytochrome c-550 was studied using fusions to alkaline phosphatase (PhoA). The results show that the heme domain (at least when fused to PhoA) can be translocated as apo-cytochrome and confirm that the N-terminal part of the cytochrome functions as both export signal and membrane anchor for the C-terminal heme domain. A model for the organisation of B. subtilis cytochrome c-550 in the cytoplasmic membrane is presented.

Role of His residues in Bacillus subtilis cytochrome b558 for haem binding and assembly of succinate: quinone oxidoreductase (complex II)

Cytochrome b558 in the cytoplasmic membrane of Bacillus subtilis constitutes the anchor and electron acceptor to the flavoprotein (Fp) and iron-sulphur protein (Ip) in succinate:quinone oxidoreductase, and seemingly contains two haem groups. EPR and MCD spectroscopic data indicate bis-imidazole ligation of the haem. Apo-cytochrome was found in the membrane fraction of haem-deficient B. subtilis, suggesting that during biogenesis of the oxidoreductase the cytochrome b558 polypeptide is embedded into the membrane prior to the incorporation of haem and subsequent binding of Fp and Ip. The six His residues in cytochrome b558 were individually changed to Tyr to attempt identification of residues serving as haem axial ligands and to analyse the role of His residues for assembly and function of the oxidoreductase. From the properties of the mutants, His-47 can be excluded as a haem ligand. The remaining His residues (at positions 13, 28, 70, 113 and 155) are located in or close to four predicted transmembrane segments. The Tyr-28 and Tyr-70 mutant proteins appeared to lack one of the two haems. Only the Tyr-13 and Tyr-47 mutant cytochromes were found to function as anchors for Fp and Ip, but the Tyr-13 mutant cytochrome assembles into an enzymatically defective succinate:quinone oxidoreductase. It is concluded from a combination of the experimental findings, sequence comparisons and membrane topology data that His-28, His-70 and His-155 are probably haem axial ligands in a dihaem cytochrome b558. His-70 and His-155 may be ligands to the same haem.

Prediction and comparison of the haem-binding sites in membrane haemoproteins

This article contains a comparative review of the structural properties of membrane haemoproteins, with particular emphasis on the possible similarities of the haem-binding peptides. A procedure is suggested for identifying the peptides which may bind membrane-buried haems on the basis of the primary sequences of the proteins. The integration of this procedure with the information deduced by refined hydropathy analysis indicates that the basic structural model for the haemoproteins which interact with quinones may be a transmembrane helical bundle containing the haem(s) at its centre. Structural similarities exist in the sequence of hydrophobic segments that are predicted to bind the membrane-buried haems of b-cytochromes which interact with quinones. The predicted haem-binding sites show similarities also with the peptides that bind the non-haem iron in the bacterial reaction centres, and this may be correlated to the common function of interacting with quinones and their intermediates. The analysis of the amino-acid composition of the proposed ligand peptides in the membrane haemoproteins examined has provided a molecular rationale for explaining the highly anisotropic low-spin EPR signal which is characteristic of many membrane-bound b-cytochromes.

EPR characterization of soluble fragments of succinate dehydrogenase from mutant strains of Bacillus subtilis

Succinate dehydrogenase is a membrane-bound metallo-flavo-enzyme containing a bi- (S-1), a tri- (S-3) and a tetranuclear (S-2) iron-sulfur cluster. The catalytic portion of the enzyme contains two distinct subunits designated Fp and Ip. Using concentrated extracts from mutant strains of Bacillus subtilis it was demonstrated, by using low temperature EPR, that cluster S-2 can be assembled in a soluble succinate dehydrogenase. In a mutant with a truncated Ip subunit which lacks 7 of the 11 conserved cysteine residues, cluster S-1 lacked the spin relaxation properties attributable to an adjacent cluster S-2. These data are consistent with a model where one or more cysteine residues from the middle set of 4 conserved cysteines in the Ip subunit are ligands to the tetranuclear cluster.

New properties of Bacillus subtilis succinate dehydrogenase altered at the active site. The apparent active site thiol of succinate oxidoreductases is dispensable for succinate oxidation

Mammalian and Escherichia coli succinate dehydrogenase (SDH) and E. coli fumarate reductase apparently contain an essential cysteine residue at the active site, as shown by substrate-protectable inactivation with thiol-specific reagents. Bacillus subtilis SDH was found to be resistant to this type of reagent and contains an alanine residue at the amino acid position equivalent to the only invariant cysteine in the flavoprotein subunit of E. coli succinate oxidoreductases. Substitution of this alanine, at position 252 in the flavoprotein subunit of B. subtilis SDH, by cysteine resulted in an enzyme sensitive to thiol-specific reagents and protectable by substrate. Other biochemical properties of the redesigned SDH were similar to those of the wild-type enzyme. It is concluded that the invariant cysteine in the flavoprotein of E. coli succinate oxidoreductases corresponds to the active site thiol. However, this cysteine is most likely not essential for succinate oxidation and seemingly lacks an assignable specific function. An invariant arginine in juxtaposition to Ala-252 in the flavoprotein of B. subtilis SDH, and to the invariant cysteine in the E. coli homologous enzymes, is probably essential for substrate binding.

Ligands to the 2Fe iron-sulfur center in succinate dehydrogenase

Membrane-bound succinate oxidoreductases are flavoenzymes containing one each of a 2Fe, a 3Fe and a 4Fe iron-sulfur center. Amino acid sequence homologies indicate that all three centers are located in the Ip (B) subunit. From polypeptide and gene analysis of Bacillus subtilis succinate dehydrogenase-defective mutants combined with earlier EPR spectroscopic data, we show that four conserved cysteine residues in the first half of Ip are the ligands to the [2Fe-2S] center. These four residues have previously been predicted to be the ligands. Our results also suggest that the N-terminal part of B. subtilis Ip constitutes a domain which can incorporate separately the 2Fe center and interact with Fp, the flavin-containing subunit of the dehydrogenase.