Methanogenesis and ATP synthesis in methanogenic bacteria at low electrochemical proton potentials. An explanation for the apparent uncoupler insensitivity of ATP synthesis

The Historical Development of Cultivation Techniques for Methanogens and Other Strict Anaerobes and Their Application in Modern Microbiology

The cultivation and investigation of strictly anaerobic microorganisms belong to the fields of anaerobic microbial physiology, microbiology, and biotechnology. Anaerobic cultivation methods differ from classic microbiological techniques in several aspects. The requirement for special instruments, which are designed to prevent the contact of the specimen with air/molecular oxygen by different means of manipulation, makes this field more challenging for general research compared to working with aerobic microorganisms. Anaerobic microbiological methods are required for many purposes, such as for the isolation and characterization of new species and their physiological examination, as well as for anaerobic biotechnological applications or medical indications. This review presents the historical development of methods for the cultivation of strictly anaerobic microorganisms focusing on methanogenic archaea, anaerobic cultivation methods that are still widely used today, novel methods for anaerobic cultivation, and almost forgotten, but still relevant, techniques.

A1Ao-ATP synthase of Methanobrevibacter ruminantium couples sodium ions for ATP synthesis under physiological conditions

An unresolved question in the bioenergetics of methanogenic archaea is how the generation of proton-motive and sodium-motive forces during methane production is used to synthesize ATP by the membrane-bound A(1)A(o)-ATP synthase, with both proton- and sodium-coupled enzymes being reported in methanogens. To address this question, we investigated the biochemical characteristics of the A(1)A(o)-ATP synthase (MbbrA(1)A(o)) of Methanobrevibacter ruminantium M1, a predominant methanogen in the rumen. Growth of M. ruminantium M1 was inhibited by protonophores and sodium ionophores, demonstrating that both ion gradients were essential for growth. To study the role of these ions in ATP synthesis, the ahaHIKECFABD operon encoding the MbbrA(1)A(o) was expressed in Escherichia coli strain DK8 (Δatp) and purified yielding a 9-subunit protein with an SDS-stable c oligomer. Analysis of the c subunit amino acid sequence revealed that it consisted of four transmembrane helices, and each hairpin displayed a complete Na(+)-binding signature made up of identical amino acid residues. The purified MbbrA(1)A(o) was stimulated by sodium ions, and Na(+) provided pH-dependent protection against inhibition by dicyclohexylcarbodiimide but not tributyltin chloride. ATP synthesis in inverted membrane vesicles lacking sodium ions was driven by a membrane potential that was sensitive to cyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone but not to monensin. ATP synthesis could not be driven by a chemical gradient of sodium ions unless a membrane potential was imposed. ATP synthesis under these conditions was sensitive to monensin but not cyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone. These data suggest that the M. ruminantium M1 A(1)A(o)-ATP synthase exhibits all the properties of a sodium-coupled enzyme, but it is also able to use protons to drive ATP synthesis under conditions that favor proton coupling, such as low pH and low levels of sodium ions.

Methanogenic archaea: ecologically relevant differences in energy conservation

Most methanogenic archaea can reduce CO(2) with H(2) to methane, and it is generally assumed that the reactions and mechanisms of energy conservation that are involved are largely the same in all methanogens. However, this does not take into account the fact that methanogens with cytochromes have considerably higher growth yields and threshold concentrations for H(2) than methanogens without cytochromes. These and other differences can be explained by the proposal outlined in this Review that in methanogens with cytochromes, the first and last steps in methanogenesis from CO(2) are coupled chemiosmotically, whereas in methanogens without cytochromes, these steps are energetically coupled by a cytoplasmic enzyme complex that mediates flavin-based electron bifurcation.

Bioenergetics of the formyl-methanofuran dehydrogenase and heterodisulfide reductase reactions in Methanothermobacter thermautotrophicus

The synthesis of formyl-methanofuran and the reduction of the heterodisulfide (CoM-S-S-CoB) of coenzyme M (HS-CoM) and coenzyme B (HS-CoB) are two crucial, H2-dependent reactions in the energy metabolism of methanogenic archaea. The bioenergetics of the reactions in vivo were studied in chemostat cultures and in cell suspensions of Methanothermobacter thermautotrophicus metabolizing at defined dissolved hydrogen partial pressures ( pH2). Formyl-methanofuran synthesis is an endergonic reaction (DeltaG degrees ' = +16 kJ.mol-1). By analyzing the concentration ratios between formyl-methanofuran and methanofuran in the cells, free energy changes under experimental conditions (DeltaG') were found to range between +10 and +35 kJ.mol-1 depending on the pH2 applied. The comparison with the sodium motive force indicated that the reaction should be driven by the import of a variable number of two to four sodium ions. Heterodisulfide reduction (DeltaG degrees ' = -40 kJ.mol-1) was associated with free energy changes as high as -55 to -80 kJ.mol-1. The values were determined by analyzing the concentrations of CoM-S-S-CoB, HS-CoM and HS-CoB in methane-forming cells operating under a variety of hydrogen partial pressures. Free energy changes were in equilibrium with the proton motive force to the extent that three to four protons could be translocated out of the cells per reaction. Remarkably, an apparent proton translocation stoichiometry of three held for cells that had been grown at pH2<0.12 bar, whilst the number was four for cells grown above that concentration. The shift occurred within a narrow pH2 span around 0.12 bar. The findings suggest that the methanogens regulate the bioenergetic machinery involved in CoM-S-S-CoB reduction and proton pumping in response to the environmental hydrogen concentrations.

Convenient fluorescence-based methods to measure membrane potential and intracellular pH in the Archaeon Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum

New and improved methods to determine the membrane potential (Delta Psi) and the Delta pH in methanogenic archaea were developed and tested in Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum strain Delta H. The Delta pH measurements took advantage of the pH-dependent fluorescence properties of coenzyme F(420), the major intracellular electron carrier in the organism. The protonophore p-nitrophenol did not show any interference with the F(420) fluorescence spectra and was therefore suitable to equalize internal and external pH. The method developed allowed the determination of the intracellular pH with an error of less than 0.05 pH units.Membrane potentials could easily be assessed using the fluorescent probe bis-(1,3-dibutylbarbituric acid)trimethine oxonol (DiBAC(4)(3)) with an accuracy of approximately 10 mV. Both methods were tested with cell suspensions of M. thermoautrophicum incubated at medium pH values between 5.5 and 8. It was found that Delta Psi and Delta pH values remained constant under these conditions. Membrane potentials were about -160 mV and Delta pH was kept at 0.35 pH units (inside minus outside) resulting in a total proton motive force of about -180 mV (inside negative).

Low-affinity potassium uptake system in the archaeon Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum: overproduction of a 31-kilodalton membrane protein during growth on low-potassium medium

During growth on low-K+ medium (1 mM K+), Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum accumulated K+ up to concentration gradients ([K+]intracellular/[K+]extracellular) of 25,000- to 50,000-fold. At these gradients ([K+]extracellular of < 20 microM), growth ceased but could be reinitiated by the addition of K+ or Rb+. During K+ starvation, the levels of a protein with an apparent molecular weight of 31,000 increased about sixfold. The protein was associated with the membrane and could be extracted by detergents. Cell suspensions of M. thermoautotrophicum obtained after K+-limited growth catalyzed the transport of both K+ and Rb+ with apparent Km and Vmax values of 0.13 mM and 140 nmol/min/mg, respectively, for K+ and 3.4 mM and 140 nmol/min/mg, respectively, for Rb+. Rb+ competitively inhibited K+ uptake with an inhibitor constant of about 10 mM. Membranes of K+-starved cells did not exhibit K+-stimulated ATPase activity. Immunoblotting with antisera against Escherichia coli Kdp-ATPase did not reveal any specific cross-reactivity against membrane proteins of K+-starved cells. Cells of M. thermoautotrophicum grown at a high potassium concentration (50 mM) catalyzed K+ and Rb+ transport at similar apparent Km values (0.13 mM for K+ and 3.3 mM for Rb+) but at significantly lower apparent Vmax values (about 60 nmol/min/mg for both K+ and Rb+) compared with K+-starved cells. From these data, it is concluded that the archaeon M. thermoautotrophicum contains a low-affinity K+ uptake system which is overproduced during growth on low-K+ medium.

Growth of Methanosarcina barkeri (Fusaro) under nonmethanogenic conditions by the fermentation of pyruvate to acetate: ATP synthesis via the mechanism of substrate level phosphorylation

A mutant of Methanosarcina barkeri (Fusaro) is able to grow on pyruvate as the sole carbon and energy source. During growth, pyruvate is converted to CH4 and CO2, and about 1.5 mol of ATP per mol of CH4 is formed (A.-K. Bock, A. Prieger-Kraft, and P. Schönheit, Arch. Microbiol. 161:33-46, 1994). The pyruvate-utilizing mutant of M. barkeri could also grow on pyruvate when methanogenesis was completely inhibited by bromoethanesulfonate (BES). The mutant grew on pyruvate (80 mM) in the presence of 2 mM BES with a doubling time of about 30 h up to cell densities of about 400 mg (dry weight) of cells per liter. During growth on pyruvate, the major fermentation products were acetate and CO2 (about 0.9 mol each per mol of pyruvate). Small amounts of acetoin, acetolactate, alanine, leucine, isoleucine, and valine were also detected. CH4 was not formed. The molar growth yield (Yacetate) was about 9 g of cells (dry weight) per mol of acetate, indicating an ATP yield of about 1 mol/mol of acetate formed. Growth on pyruvate in the presence of BES was limited; after six to eight generations, the doubling times increased and the final cell densities decreased. After 9 to 11 generations, growth stopped completely. In the presence of BES, suspensions of pyruvate-grown cells fermented pyruvate to acetate, CO2, and H2. CH4 was not formed. Conversion of pyruvate to acetate, in the complete absence of methanogenesis, was coupled to ATP synthesis. Dicyclohexylcarbodiimide, an inhibitor of H(+)-translocating ATP synthase, did not inhibit ATP formation. In the presence of dicyclohexylcarbodiimide, stoichiometries of up to 0.9 mol of ATP per mol of acetate were observed. The uncoupler arsenate completely inhibited ATP synthesis, while the rates of acetate, CO2, and H2 formation were stimulated up to fourfold. Cell extracts of M. barkeri grown on pyruvate under nonmethenogenic conditions contained pyruvate: ferredoxin oxidoreductase (0.5 U/mg), phosphate acetyltransferase (12 U/mg), and acetate kinase (12 U/mg). From these data it is concluded that ATP was synthesized by substrate level phosphorylation during growth of the M. barkeri mutant on pyruvate in the absence of methanogenesis. This is the first report of growth of a methanogen under nonmethanogenic conditions at the expense of a fermentative energy metabolism.

Ion transport and methane production in Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum

In Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum, the protonmotive force for the H+-translocating ATPase consists mainly of a transmembrane electrical gradient (Deltapsi). These cells do not establish a significant transmembrane pH gradient (inside alkaline) and, in fact, if the suspending medium is of pH >/= 7.0, the pH gradient may be reversed-i.e., inside acid with respect to the extracellular pH. These studies show by both 23Na NMR and 22Na+ distribution that Na+ extrusion with the generation of Deltapsi precedes methanogenesis in Mb. thermoautotrophicum. It is calculated that the newly established Na+ gradients increase Deltapsi by approximately 50 mV (inside negative). There is no detectable H+ extrusion during methane synthesis; instead there is a high rate of H+ consumption for methane synthesis and an increase in internal pH. This was supported by 31P NMR experiments, which showed an internal pH shift from 6.8 to 7.6. With the cells maintained at an external pH of 7.2, the initial transmembrane pH gradient of -0.4 (inside acid) at 60 degrees C is equivalent to Deltapsi of + 27 mV (inside positive); after 20 min of incubation, the transmembrane pH gradient is + 0.4 (inside alkaline), which at 60 degrees C is equivalent to Deltapsi of -27 mV (inside negative). Actively respiring cells generated a protonmotive force of -198 mV. It is proposed that energy for CO2 reduction to the level of formaldehyde (the first step in methane synthesis) in Mb. thermoautotrophicum is derived from the Deltapsi generated by electrogenic Na+ extrusion. The protonmotive force required for ATP synthesis consists primarily of Deltapsi and appears to be the result of both an electrogenic Na+ extrusion and a pH gradient (inside alkaline) which develops during methanogenesis.

Biochemistry of methanogenesis

Methane is a product of the energy-yielding pathways of the largest and most phylogenetically diverse group in the Archaea. These organisms have evolved three pathways that entail a novel and remarkable biochemistry. All of the pathways have in common a reduction of the methyl group of methyl-coenzyme M (CH3-S-CoM) to CH4. Seminal studies on the CO2-reduction pathway have revealed new cofactors and enzymes that catalyze the reduction of CO2 to the methyl level (CH3-S-CoM) with electrons from H2 or formate. Most of the methane produced in nature originates from the methyl group of acetate. CO dehydrogenase is a key enzyme catalyzing the decarbonylation of acetyl-CoA; the resulting methyl group is transferred to CH3-S-CoM, followed by reduction to methane using electrons derived from oxidation of the carbonyl group to CO2 by the CO dehydrogenase. Some organisms transfer the methyl group of methanol and methylamines to CH3-S-CoM; electrons for reduction of CH3-S-CoM to CH4 are provided by the oxidation of methyl groups to CO2.

Purification and properties of N5, N10-methylenetetrahydromethanopterin reductase from Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum (strain Marburg)

The reduction of N5,N10-methylenetrahydromethanopterin (CH2 = H4MPT) to N5-methyltetrahydromethanopterin (CH3-H4MPT) is an intermediate step in methanogenesis from CO2 and H2. The reaction is catalyzed by CH2 = H4MPT reductase. The enzyme from Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum (strain Marburg) was found to be specific for reduced coenzyme F420 as electron donor; neither NADH or NADPH nor reduced viologen dyes could substitute for the reduced 5-deazaflavin. The reductase was purified over 100-fold to apparent homogeneity. Sodium dodecyl sulfate/polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis revealed only one protein band at the 36-kDa position. The apparent molecular mass of the native enzyme was determined by gel filtration to be in the order of 150 kDa. The purified enzyme was colourless. It did not contain flavin or iron. The ultraviolet visible spectrum was almost identical to that of albumin, suggesting the absence of a chromophoric prosthetic group. Reciprocal plots of the enzyme activity versus the substrate concentration at different constant concentrations of the second substrate yielded straight lines intersecting at one point on the abscissa to the left of the vertical axis. This intersecting pattern is characteristic of a ternary complex catalytic mechanism. The Km for CH2 = H4MPT and for the reduced coenzyme F420 were determined to be 0.3 mM and 3 microM, respectively. Vmax was 6000 mumol.min-1.mg protein-1 (kcat = 3600 s-1). The CH2 = H4MPT reductase was stable in the presence of air; at 4 C less than 10% activity was lost within 24 h.

Uncoupler-resistant mutants of bacteria

The chemiosmotic model of energy transduction offers a satisfying and widely confirmed understanding of the action of uncouplers on such processes as oxidative phosphorylation; the uncoupler, by facilitating the transmembrane movement of protons or other compensatory ions, reduces the electrochemical proton gradient that is posited as the energy intermediate for many kinds of bioenergetic work. In connection with this formulation, uncoupler-resistant mutants of bacteria that neither exclude nor inactivate these agents represent a bioenergetic puzzle. Uncoupler-resistant mutants of aerobic Bacillus species are, in fact, membrane lipid mutants with bioenergetic properties that are indeed challenging in connection with the chemiosmotic model. By contrast, uncoupler-resistant mutants of Escherichia coli probably exclude uncouplers, sometimes only under rather specific conditions. Related phenomena in eucaryotic and procaryotic systems, as well as various observations on uncouplers, decouplers, and certain other membrane-active agents, are also briefly considered.

Chemiosmotic energy conversion and the membrane ATPase of Methanolobus tindarius

Electron transport phosphorylation has been demonstrated to drive ATP synthesis for the methanogenic archaebacterium Methanolobus tindarius: Protonophores evoked uncoupler effects and lowered the membrane potential delta psi. Under the influence of N,N'-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide [(cHxN)2C] the membrane potential increased while methanol turnover was inhibited. 2-Bromoethanesulfonate, an inhibitor of methanogenesis, had no effect on the membrane potential but, like (cHxN)2C and protonophores, decreased the intracellular ATP concentration. Labeling experiments with (cHxN)2(14)C showed membranes to contain a proteolipid, with a molecular mass of 5.5 kDa, that resembles known (cHxN)2C-binding proteins of F0-F1 ATPases. The (cHxN)2-sensitive membrane ATPase hydrolysed Mg.ATP at a pH optimum of 5.0 with a Km (ATP) of 2.5 mM (V = 77 mU/mg). It was inhibited competitively by ADP; Ki (ADP) = 0.65 mM. Azide or vanadate caused no significant loss in ATPase activity, but millimolar concentrations of nitrate showed an inhibitory effect, suggesting a relationship to ATPases from vacuolar membranes. In contrast, no inhibition occurred in the presence of bafilomycin A1. The ATPase was extractable with EDTA at low salt concentrations. The purified enzyme consists of four different subunits, alpha (67 kDa), beta (52 kDa), gamma (20 kDa) and beta (less than 10 kDa), as determined from SDS gel electrophoresis.

ATP synthesis coupled to methane formation from methyl-CoM and H2 catalyzed by vesicles of the methanogenic bacterial strain Gö1

Methanogenesis from methyl-CoM and H2, as catalyzed by inside-out vesicle preparations of the methanogenenic bacterium strain Gö1, was associated with ATP synthesis. That this ATP synthesis proceeded via an uncoupler-sensitive transmembrane proton gradient was concluded from the following results: 1. Various inhibitors that affected methane formation (e.g. 2-bromomethanesulfonate) also prevented ATP synthesis. 2. The protonophore 3,5-di-tert-butyl-4-hydroxybenzylidenemalononitrile, in combination with the K+ ionophore valinomycin, inhibited ATP synthesis completely without affecting methanogenesis. 3. The ATP synthase inhibitor diethylstilbestrol inhibited ATP synthesis. 4. Addition of the detergent sulfobetaine inhibited both methane formation and ATP synthesis; the former but not the latter could be restored by adding titanium(III) citrate as electron donor. In addition it was shown that ATP synthesis could also be driven by transmembrane proton gradients artificially imposed on the vesicles. Furthermore net methanogenesis-dependent ATP formation was shown by measuring [32P]phosphate incorporation.

The sodium cycle in methanogenesis. CO2 reduction to the formaldehyde level in methanogenic bacteria is driven by a primary electrochemical potential of Na+ generated by formaldehyde reduction to CH4

CH4 formation from CO2 and H2 rather than from formaldehyde and H2 in methanogenic bacteria is inhibited by uncouplers, indicating that CO2 reduction to the formaldehyde level is energy-driven. We report here that in Methanosarcina barkeri the driving force is a primary electrochemical sodium potential (delta mu Na+) generated by formaldehyde reduction to CH4. This is concluded from the following findings. 1. CO2 reduction to CH4 was insensitive towards protonophores, when the Na+/H+ antiporter was inhibited; under these conditions delta mu Na+ was 120 mV (inside negative), whereas both delta mu H+ and the cellular ATP content were low. 2. CO2 reduction to CH4, rather than formaldehyde reduction, was sensitive towards Na+ ionophores, which dissipated delta mu Na+. 3. CO2 reduction to CH4, in the presence of protonophores and Na+/H+ antiport inhibitors, was coupled with the extrusion of 1-2 mol Na+/mol CH4, and formaldehyde reduction to CH4 was coupled with the extrusion of 3-4 mol Na+/mol CH4. Thus during CO2 reduction to the formaldehyde level 2-3 mol Na+ were consumed.

Sodium, protons, and energy coupling in the methanogenic bacteria

In this review, I focus on the bioenergetics of the methanogenic bacteria, with particular attention directed to the roles of transmembrane electrochemical gradients of sodium and proton. In addition, the mechanism of coupling ATP synthesis to methanogenic electron transfer is addressed. Evidence is reviewed which suggests that the methanogens possess great diversity in their bioenergetic machinery. In particular, in some methanogens the primary ion which is translocated coupled to metabolic energy is the proton, while others appear to utilize sodium. In addition, ATP synthesis driven by methanogenic electron transfer is accomplished in some organisms by a chemiosmotic mechanism and is coupled by a more direct mechanism in others. A possible explanation for this diversity (which is consistent with the relatedness of these organisms to each other and to other members of the Archaebacteria as determined by molecular biological techniques) is discussed.

The role of sodium ions in methanogenesis. Formaldehyde oxidation to CO2 and 2H2 in methanogenic bacteria is coupled with primary electrogenic Na+ translocation at a stoichiometry of 2-3 Na+/CO2

Cell suspensions of Methanosarcina barkeri were found to oxidize formaldehyde to CO2 and 2H2 (delta G0' = -27 kJ/mol CO2), when methanogenesis was inhibited by 2-bromoethanesulfonate. We report here that this reaction is coupled with (a) primary electrogenic Na+ translocation at a stoichiometry of 2-3 Na+/CO2, (b) with secondary H+ translocation via a Na+/H+ antiporter and (c) with ATP synthesis driven by an electrochemical proton potential. This is concluded from the following findings. Formaldehyde oxidation to CO2 and 2H2 was dependent on Na+ ions, 2-3 mol Na+/mol formaldehyde oxidized were extruded. Na+ translocation was inhibited by Na+ ionophores, but not affected by protonophores of Na+/H+ antiport inhibitors. Formaldehyde oxidation was associated with the build up of a membrane potential in the order of 100 mV (inside negative), which could be dissipated by sodium ionophores rather than by protonophores. Formaldehyde oxidation was coupled with ATP synthesis, which could be inhibited by Na+ ionophores, Na+/H+ antiport inhibitors, by protonophores and by the H+-translocating-ATP-synthase inhibitor, dicyclohexylcarbodiimide. With cell suspensions of Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum similar results were obtained.

Formylmethanofuran dehydrogenase from methanogenic bacteria, a molybdoenzyme

Formylmethanofuran dehydrogenase, a key enzyme of methanogenesis, was purified 100-fold from methanol grown Methanosarcina barkeri to apparent homogeneity and a specific activity of 34 mumol.min-1.mg protein-1. Molybdenum was found to co-migrate with the enzyme activity. The molybdenum content of purified preparations was 3-4 nmol per mg protein equal to 0.6-0.8 mol molybdenum per mol enzyme of apparent molecular mass 200 kDa. Evidence is presented that also formylmethanofuran dehydrogenase from H2/CO2 grown Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum (strain Marburg) is a molybdoenzyme.

Proton translocation coupled to the oxidation of carbon monoxide to CO2 and H2 in Methanosarcina barkeri

Cell suspensions of acetate-grown Methanosarcina barkeri mediate the conversion of CO and H2O to CO2 and H2. The reaction is coupled with the phosphorylation of ADP. Evidence is presented that CO oxidation by the cells is associated with the transient acidification of the suspension medium. Up to 2 mol vectorial protons were measured/mol CO oxidized when the transmembrane electrical gradient was kept low by the addition of valinomycin (20 nmol/mg protein) and KCl (200 mM) or of KSCN (50 mM). No transient acidification was observed in the presence of the protonophore tetrachlorosalicylanilide which stimulated rather than inhibited CO oxidation. Proton extrusion remained unaltered when the proton-translocating ATPase was specifically inhibited by dicyclohexylcarbodiimide. The latter finding indicates that proton translocation is associated with CO conversion to CO2 and H2 rather than with ATP hydrolysis in the cells. The data substantiate that the coupling of CO oxidation with ADP phosphorylation in M. barkeri occurs via a chemiosmotic mechanism.