Equilibrium unfolding studies of horse muscle acylphosphatase

Type III secretion system effector proteins are mechanically labile

Multiple gram-negative bacteria encode type III secretion systems (T3SS) that allow them to inject effector proteins directly into host cells to facilitate colonization. To be secreted, effector proteins must be at least partially unfolded to pass through the narrow needle-like channel (diameter <2 nm) of the T3SS. Fusion of effector proteins to tightly packed proteins-such as GFP, ubiquitin, or dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR)-impairs secretion and results in obstruction of the T3SS. Prior observation that unfolding can become rate-limiting for secretion has led to the model that T3SS effector proteins have low thermodynamic stability, facilitating their secretion. Here, we first show that the unfolding free energy ([Formula: see text]) of two Salmonella effector proteins, SptP and SopE2, are 6.9 and 6.0 kcal/mol, respectively, typical for globular proteins and similar to published [Formula: see text] for GFP, ubiquitin, and DHFR. Next, we mechanically unfolded individual SptP and SopE2 molecules by atomic force microscopy (AFM)-based force spectroscopy. SptP and SopE2 unfolded at low force (F _unfold ≤ 17 pN at 100 nm/s), making them among the most mechanically labile proteins studied to date by AFM. Moreover, their mechanical compliance is large, as measured by the distance to the transition state (Δx ^‡ = 1.6 and 1.5 nm for SptP and SopE2, respectively). In contrast, prior measurements of GFP, ubiquitin, and DHFR show them to be mechanically robust (F _unfold > 80 pN) and brittle (Δx ^‡ < 0.4 nm). These results suggest that effector protein unfolding by T3SS is a mechanical process and that mechanical lability facilitates efficient effector protein secretion.

Stabilization of a protein conferred by an increase in folded state entropy

Entropic stabilization of native protein structures typically relies on strategies that serve to decrease the entropy of the unfolded state. Here we report, using a combination of experimental and computational approaches, on enhanced thermodynamic stability conferred by an increase in the configurational entropy of the folded state. The enhanced stability is observed upon modifications of a loop region in the enzyme acylphosphatase and is achieved despite significant enthalpy losses. The modifications that lead to increased stability, as well as those that result in destabilization, however, strongly compromise enzymatic activity, rationalizing the preservation of the native loop structure even though it does not provide the protein with maximal stability or kinetic foldability.

Mechanical unfolding of acylphosphatase studied by single-molecule force spectroscopy and MD simulations

Single-molecule manipulation methods provide a powerful means to study protein transitions. Here we combined single-molecule force spectroscopy and steered molecular-dynamics simulations to study the mechanical properties and unfolding behavior of the small enzyme acylphosphatase (AcP). We find that mechanical unfolding of AcP occurs at relatively low forces in an all-or-none fashion and is decelerated in the presence of a ligand, as observed in solution measurements. The prominent energy barrier for the transition is separated from the native state by a distance that is unusually long for alpha/beta proteins. Unfolding is initiated at the C-terminal strand (beta(T)) that lies at one edge of the beta-sheet of AcP, followed by unraveling of the strand located at the other. The central strand of the sheet and the two helices in the protein unfold last. Ligand binding counteracts unfolding by stabilizing contacts between an arginine residue (Arg-23) and the catalytic loop, as well as with beta(T) of AcP, which renders the force-bearing units of the protein resistant to force. This stabilizing effect may also account for the decelerated unfolding of ligand-bound AcP in the absence of force.

A molecular dynamics study of the correlations between solvent-accessible surface, molecular volume, and folding state

We analyzed the correlations between molecular volume, solvent-accessible surface, and folding state (secondary structure content) for unfolded conformers of alpha (holo- and apomyoglobin) and beta (retinal-binding protein) proteins and a small water-soluble alanine-rich alpha-helical peptide. Conformers with different degrees of folding were obtained using molecular dynamics at constant temperature and pressure with implicit solvent (dielectric constant adjustment) for all four systems and with explicit solvent for the single helix peptide. Our results support the view that unfolded conformations are not necessary extended, that volume variation is not a good indication of folding state and that the simple model of water penetrating the interior of the protein does not explain the increase in volume upon unfolding.

Crystal structure and structural stability of acylphosphatase from hyperthermophilic archaeon Pyrococcus horikoshii OT3

To elucidate the structural basis for the high stability of acylphosphatase (AcP) from Pyrococcus horikoshii OT3, we determined its crystal structure at 1.72 A resolution. P. horikoshii AcP possesses high stability despite its approximately 30% sequence identity with eukaryotic enzymes that have moderate thermostability. The overall fold of P. horikoshii AcP was very similar to the structures of eukaryotic counterparts. The crystal structure of P. horikoshii AcP shows the same fold betaalphabetabetaalphabeta topology and the conserved putative catalytic residues as observed in eukaryotic enzymes. Comparison with the crystal structure of bovine common-type AcP and that of D. melanogaster AcP (AcPDro2) as representative of eukaryotic AcP revealed some significant characteristics in P. horikoshii AcP that likely play important roles in structural stability: (1) shortening of the flexible N-terminal region and long loop; (2) an increased number of ion pairs on the protein surface; (3) stabilization of the loop structure by hydrogen bonds. In P. horikoshii AcP, two ion pair networks were observed one located in the loop structure positioned near the C-terminus, and other on the beta-sheet. The importance of ion pairs for structural stability was confirmed by site-directed mutation and denaturation induced by guanidium chloride.

Conformational constraints for amyloid fibrillation: the importance of being unfolded

Recent reports give strong support to the idea that amyloid fibril formation and the subsequent development of protein deposition diseases originate from conformational changes in corresponding amyloidogenic proteins. In this review, recent findings are surveyed to illustrate that protein fibrillogenesis requires a partially folded conformation. This amyloidogenic conformation is relatively unfolded, and shares many structural properties with the pre-molten globule state, a partially folded intermediate frequently observed in the early stages of protein folding and under some equilibrium conditions. The inherent flexibility of such an intermediate is essential in allowing the conformational rearrangements necessary to form the core cross-beta structure of the amyloid fibril.

Small amounts of urea and guanidine hydrochloride can be detected by a far-UV spectrophotometric method in dialysed protein solutions

The quantization of small amounts of chemical denaturants as urea or guanidine hydrochloride in protein solutions after dialysis is a difficult task in the molecular biology laboratory practice. Refractometric methods are useful to quantify a denaturant in the molar range but this methodology is not helpful when the denaturant is present in small amounts. The method herein described is a new comparative method that requires, a priori, the quantification of the stock solutions of urea (8 M) and guanidine hydrochloride (6 M) by refractometry to prepare by sequential dilution the standards used for comparison in the spectropolarimeter. The method is based on the observation that the wavelengths, at which the absorbance of polarized light increases in the far-UV region, as observed by spectropolarimetry, is related to the concentration of the chemical denaturant present in the protein solution. In the quantitation method herein reported, the urea and guanidine hydrochloride detection limits range from 1.2 x 10(-4) to 6 x 10(-6) M depending on the protein dialysis buffer used for a standard cell path length of 1 cm. The sensibility of this method results to be comprised in a range 4-5 orders of magnitude higher than that measured by refractometry. The determinations in both the sample and the control preparations are virtually completed within approximately 10 min.

Stabilisation of alpha-helices by site-directed mutagenesis reveals the importance of secondary structure in the transition state for acylphosphatase folding

The effects of stabilising mutations on the folding process of common-type acylphosphatase have been investigated. The mutations were designed to increase the helical propensity of the regions of the polypeptide chain corresponding to the two alpha-helices of the native protein. Various synthetic peptides incorporating the designed mutations were produced and their helical content estimated by circular dichroism. The most substantial increase in helical content is found for the peptide carrying five mutations in the second alpha-helix. Acylphosphatase variants containing the corresponding mutations display, to different extents, enhanced conformational stabilities as indicated by equilibrium urea denaturation experiments monitored by changes of intrinsic fluorescence. All the protein variants studied here refold with apparent two-state kinetics. Mutations in the first alpha-helix are responsible for a small increase in the refolding rate, accompanied by a marked decrease in the unfolding rate. On the other hand, multiple mutations in the second helix result in a considerable increase in the refolding rate without any significant effect on the unfolding rate. Addition of trifluoroethanol was found to accelerate the folding of the acylphosphatase variants, the extent of the acceleration being inversely proportional to the intrinsic rate of folding of the corresponding mutant. The trifluoroethanol-induced acceleration is far less marked for those variants whose alpha-helical structure is efficiently stabilised by amino acid replacements. This observation suggests that trifluoroethanol acts in a similar manner to the stabilising mutations in promoting native-like secondary structure. Analysis of the kinetic data indicates that the second helix is fully consolidated in the transition state for folding of acylphosphatase, whereas the first helix is only partially formed. These data suggest that the second helix is an important element in the folding process of the protein.

The contribution of acidic residues to the conformational stability of common-type acylphosphatase

Common-type acylphosphatase is a small cytosolic enzyme whose catalytic properties and three-dimensional structure are known in detail. All the acidic residues of the enzyme have been replaced by noncharged residues in order to assess their contributions to the conformational stability of acylphosphatase. The enzymatic activity parameters and the conformational free energy of each mutant were determined by enzymatic activity assays and chemically induced unfolding, respectively. Some mutants exhibit very similar conformational stability, DeltaG(H2O), and specific activity values as compared to the wild-type enzyme. By contrast, six mutants show a significant reduction of conformational stability and two mutants are more stable than the wild-type protein. Although none of the mutated acidic residues is directly involved in the catalytic mechanism of the enzyme, our results indicate that mutations of residues located on the surface of the protein are responsible for a structural distortion which propagate up to the active site. We found a good correlation between the free energy of unfolding and the enzymatic activity of acylphosphatase. This suggests that enzymatic activity measurements can provide valuable indications on the conformational stability of acylphosphatase mutants, provided the mutated residue lies far apart from the active site. Moreover, our results indicate that the distortion of hydrogen bonds rather than the loss of electrostatic interactions, contributes to the decrease of the conformational stability of the protein.

Structural characterization of the transition state for folding of muscle acylphosphatase

The transition state for folding of a small protein, muscle acylphosphatase, has been studied by measuring the rates of folding and unfolding under a variety of solvent conditions. A strong dependence of the folding rate on the concentration of urea suggests the occurrence in the transition state of a large shielding of those groups that are exposed to interaction with the denaturant in the unfolded state (mainly hydrophobic moieties and groups located on the polypeptide backbone). The heat capacity change upon moving from the unfolded state to the transition state is small and is indicative of a substantial solvent exposure of hydrophobic groups. The solvent-accessibility of such groups in the transition state has also been found to be significant by measuring the rates of folding and unfolding in the presence of sugars. These rates have also been found to be accelerated by the addition of small quantities of alcohols. Trifluoroethanol and hexafluoroisopropanol were particularly effective, suggesting that stabilisation of local hydrogen bonds lowers the energy of the transition state relative to the folded and unfolded states. Finally, a study with a competitive inhibitor of acylphosphatase has provided evidence for the complete loss of ligand binding affinity in the transition state, indicating that specific long-range interactions at the level of the active site are not yet formed at this stage of the folding reaction. A model of the transition state for acylphosphatase folding, in which beta-turns and one or both alpha-helices are formed to a significant extent but in which the persistent long-range interactions characteristic of the folded state are largely absent, accounts for all our data. These results are broadly consistent with models of the transition states for folding of other small proteins derived from mutagenesis studies, and suggest that solvent perturbation methods can provide complementary information about the transition region of the energy surfaces for protein folding.

Slow folding of muscle acylphosphatase in the absence of intermediates

The folding of a 98 residue protein, muscle acylphosphatase (AcP), has been studied using a variety of techniques including circular dichroism, fluorescence and NMR spectroscopy following transfer of chemically denatured protein into refolding conditions. A low-amplitude phase, detected in concurrence with the main kinetic phase, corresponds to the folding of a minor population (13%) of molecules with one or both proline residues in a cis conformation, as shown from the sensitivity of its rate to peptidyl prolyl isomerase. The major phase of folding has the same kinetic characteristics regardless of the technique employed to monitor it. The plots of the natural logarithms of folding and unfolding rate constants versus urea concentration are linear over a broad range of urea concentrations. Moreover, the initial state formed rapidly after the initiation of refolding is highly unstructured, having a similar circular dichroism, intrinsic fluorescence and NMR spectrum as the protein denatured at high concentrations of urea. All these results indicate that AcP folds in a two-state manner without the accumulation of intermediates. Despite this, the folding of the protein is extremely slow. The rate constant of the major phase of folding in water, kfH2O, is 0.23 s-1 at 28 degreesC and, at urea concentrations above 1 M, the folding process is slower than the cis-trans proline isomerisation step. The slow refolding of this protein is therefore not the consequence of populated intermediates that can act as kinetic traps, but arises from a large intrinsic barrier in the folding reaction.

Conformational stability of muscle acylphosphatase: the role of temperature, denaturant concentration, and pH

The conformational stability (delta G) of muscle acylphosphatase, a small alpha/beta globular protein, has been determined as a function of temperature, urea concentration, and pH. A combination of thermally induced and urea-induced unfolding, monitored by far-UV circular dichroism, was used to define the conformational stability over a wide range of temperature. Through analysis of all these data, the heat capacity change upon unfolding (delta Cp) could be estimated, allowing the determination of the temperature dependence of the main thermodynamic functions (delta G, delta H, delta S). Thermal unfolding in the presence of urea made it possible to extend such thermodynamic analysis to examine these parameters as a function of urea concentration. The results indicate that acylphosphatase is a relatively unstable protein with a delta G(H2O) of 22 +/- 1 kJ mol-1 at pH 7 and 25 degrees C. The midpoints of both thermal and chemical denaturation are also relatively low. Urea denaturation curves over the pH range 2-12 have allowed the pH dependence of delta G to be determined and indicate that the maximum stability of the protein occurs near pH 5.5. While the dependence of delta G on urea (the m value) does not vary with temperature, a significant increase has been found at low pH values, suggesting that the overall dimensions of the unfolded state are significantly affected by the number of charges within the polypeptide chain. The comparison of these data with those from other small proteins indicates that the pattern of conformational stability is defined by individual sequences and not by the overall structural fold.

Structural and kinetic investigations on the 15-21 and 42-45 loops of muscle acylphosphatase: evidence for their involvement in enzyme catalysis and conformational stabilization

The structural and catalytic importance of the 15-21 and 42-45 loop residues of the acylphosphatase muscular isoenzyme has been investigated by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis. Seven mutants involving conserved residues of the two loops have been prepared and characterized for structural, kinetic, and stability features by using different spectroscopic techniques and compared to the wild-type enzyme. The results are discussed in light of the crystal structure of the highly homologous common type acylphosphatase [Thunnissen et al. (1997) Structure 5, 69-79]. A differential role of the two loops has emerged: the 15-21 and the 42-45 loops appear mainly involved in active site formation and enzyme structural stabilization, respectively. These conclusions are supported by a strong impairment of the catalytic efficiency, in terms of enzymatic activity and substrate binding capability, for most of the 15-21 loop mutants. In particular, the Gly15Ala mutant is completely inactive and displays a native-like overall fold, indicating that the correct geometry of the 15-21 loop is an essential requisite for optimal enzymatic catalysis. Instead, the Gly45Ala mutant, though revealing unchanged catalytic properties, shows a considerably reduced conformational stability, as judged by circular dichroism and 1H NMR spectroscopy. This finding confirms previous results relative to Thr42 and Thr46 residues [Taddei et al. (1996) Biochemistry 35, 7077-7083] underlining the structural importance of the 42-45 loop as a linker for the two beta alpha beta units constituting the overall enzyme structure.

Looking for residues involved in the muscle acylphosphatase catalytic mechanism and structural stabilization: role of Asn41, Thr42, and Thr46

Asn41, Thr42, and Thr46 are invariant residues in both muscle and erythrocyte acylphosphatases isolated so far. Horse muscle acylphosphatase solution structure suggests their close spatial relationship to Arg23, the main substrate binding site. The catalytic and structural role of such residues, as well as their influence on muscle acylphosphatase stability, was investigated by preparing several gene mutants (Thr42Ala, Thr46Ala, Asn41Ala, Asn41Ser, and Asn41Gln) by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis. The mutated genes were cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli, and the mutant enzymes were purified by affinity chromatography and investigated as compared to the wild-type enzyme. The specific activity and substrate affinity of Thr42 and Thr46 mutants were not significantly affected. On the contrary, Asn41 mutants showed a residual negligible activity (about 0.05-0.15% as compared to wild-type enzyme), though maintaining an unchanged binding capability of both substrate and inorganic phosphate, an enzyme competitive inhibitor. According to the 1H nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and circular dichroism results, all mutants elicited well-constrained native-like secondary and tertiary structures. Thermodynamic parameters, as calculated from circular dichroism data, demonstrated a significantly decreased stability of the Thr42 mutant under increasing temperatures and urea concentrations. The reported results strongly support a direct participation of Asn41 to the enzyme catalytic mechanism, indicating that Asn41 mutants may well represent a useful tool for the investigation of the enzyme physiological function by the negative dominant approach.

C-terminal region contributes to muscle acylphosphatase three-dimensional structure stabilisation

Ser-Ala and Ser-Ala-Ser-Ala C-terminus elongated (delta+2 and delta+4, respectively) and two C-terminus deleted (delta-2 and delta-3) muscle acylphosphatase mutants were investigated to assess the catalytic and structural roles of the C-terminal region. The kinetic analysis of these mutants shows that the removal of two or three C-terminal residues reduces the catalytic activity to 7% and 4% of the value measured for the wild-type enzyme, respectively; instead, the elongation of the C-terminus does not significantly change the enzyme behaviour. 1H Nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy indicates that all mutants display a native-like fold though they appear less stable, particularly delta-2 and delta-3 mutants, as compared to the wild-type enzyme. Such destabilisation of the C-terminal modified mutants is further confirmed by urea inactivation experiments. The results here presented account for an involvement of the C-terminal region in the stabilisation of the three-dimensional structure of acylphosphatase, particularly at the active-site level. Moreover, a participation of the C-terminal carboxyl group to the catalytic mechanism can be excluded.

First-principles calculation of the folding free energy of a three-helix bundle protein

The folding and unfolding of a three-helix bundle protein were explored with molecular-dynamics simulations, cluster analysis, and weighted-histogram techniques. The folding-unfolding process occurs by means of a "folding funnel," in which a uniform and broad distribution of conformational states is accessible outside of the native manifold. This distribution narrows near a transition region and becomes compact within the native manifold. Key thermodynamic steps in folding include initial interactions around the amino-terminal helix-turn-helix motif, interactions between helices I and II, and, finally, the docking of helix III onto the helix I-II subdomain. A metastable minimum in the calculated free-energy surface is observed at approximately 1.5 times the native volume. Folding-unfolding thermodynamics are dominated by the opposing influences of protein-solvent energy, which favors unfolding, and the overall entropy, which favors folding by means of the hydrophobic effect.

Properties of N-terminus truncated and C-terminus mutated muscle acylphosphatases

Enzymatic activity and structure of N-terminus truncated and C-terminus substituted muscle acylphosphatase mutants were investigated by kinetic studies under different conditions and 1H NMR spectroscopy, respectively. The N-terminus truncated mutant lacked the first six residues (delta 6), whereas arginine 97 and tyrosine 98 were replaced by glutamine giving two C-terminus substituted mutants (R97Q and Y98Q, respectively). All acylphosphatase forms were obtained by modifications of a synthetic gene coding for the human muscle enzyme which was expressed in E. coli. The delta 6 deletion mutant elicited a reduced specific activity and a native-like structure. The kinetic and structural properties of R97Q and Y98Q mutants indicate a possible role of Arg-97 in the stabilisation of the active site correct conformation, most likely via back-bone and side chain interactions with Arg-23, the residue involved in phosphate binding by the enzyme. This study also suggests a possible involvement of Tyr-98 in the stabilisation of the acylphosphatase overall structure.