Antinociception induced by stimulating the anterior pretectal nucleus in two models of pain in rats

The role of the anterior pretectal nucleus in pain modulation: A comprehensive review

Descending pain modulation involves multiple encephalic sites and pathways that range from the cerebral cortex to the spinal cord. Behavioral studies conducted in the 1980s revealed that electrical stimulation of the pretectal area causes antinociception dissociation from aversive responses. Anatomical and physiological studies identified the anterior pretectal nucleus and its descending projections to several midbrain, pontine, and medullary structures. The anterior pretectal nucleus is morphologically divided into a dorsal part that contains a dense neuron population (pars compacta) and a ventral part that contains a dense fiber band network (pars reticulata). Connections of the two anterior pretectal nucleus parts are broad and include prominent projections to and from major encephalic systems associated with somatosensory processes. Since the first observation that acute or chronic noxious stimuli activate the anterior pretectal nucleus, it has been established that numerous mediators participate in this response through distinct pathways. Recent studies have confirmed that at least two pain inhibitory pathways are activated from the anterior pretectal nucleus. This review focuses on rodent anatomical, behavioral, molecular, and neurochemical data that have helped to identify mediators of the anterior pretectal nucleus and pathways related to its role in pain modulation.

Coping with Phantom Limb Pain

Phantom limb pain is a chronic neuropathic pain that develops in 45-85% of patients who undergo major amputations of the upper and lower extremities and appears predominantly during two time frames following an amputation: the first month and later about 1 year. Although in most patients the frequency and intensity of pain diminish over time, severe pain persists in about 5-10%. It has been proposed that factors in both the peripheral and central nervous systems play major roles in triggering the development and maintenance of pain associated with extremity amputations. Chronic pain is physically and mentally debilitating, affecting an individual's capacity for self-care, but also diminishing an individual's daily capacity for personal and economic independence. In addition, the pain may lead to depression and feelings of hopelessness. A National Center for Biotechnology Information study found that in the USA alone, the annual cost of dealing with neuropathic pain is more than $600 billion, with an estimated 20 million people in the USA suffering from this condition. Although the pain can be reduced by antiepileptic drugs and analgesics, they are frequently ineffective or their side effects preclude their use. The optimal approach for eliminating neuropathic pain and improving individuals' quality of life is the development of novel techniques that permanently prevent the development and maintenance of neuropathic pain, or that eliminate the pain once it has developed. What is still required is understanding when and where an effective novel technique must be applied, such as onto the nerve stump of the transected peripheral axons, dorsal root ganglion neurons, spinal cord, or cortex to induce the desired influences. This review, the second of two in this journal volume, examines the techniques that may be capable of reducing or eliminating chronic neuropathic pain once it has developed. Such an understanding will improve amputees' quality of life by blocking the mechanisms that trigger and/or maintain PLP and chronic neuropathic pain.

The ventral portion of the anterior pretectal nucleus controls descending mechanisms that initiate neuropathic pain in rats

Stimulating the dorsal anterior pretectal nucleus (dAPtN) in rats is more effective than stimulating the ventral APtN (vAPtN) at reducing tail-flick latency, whereas stimulation of the vAPtN is more effective at reducing postoperative pain behaviour. This study examines whether a cell lesion caused by injecting N-methyl-D-aspartate into the dAPtN or vAPtN changes the withdrawal threshold of a rat hind paw during different phases of the tactile hypersensitivity induced by a chronic constriction injury (CCI) of the contralateral sciatic nerve. The number of Fos immunoreactive cells in the APtN was also evaluated. The rats whose vAPtN was lesioned 2 days before CCI had more intense tactile hypersensitivity 2 days after CCI than that of the control group, but the groups were not different 7 days after the CCI. The rats whose vAPtN was lesioned 5 days after CCI had withdrawal thresholds that did not differ significantly 7 days after the CCI. The tactile hypersensitivity of the rats whose dAPtN was lesioned 2 days before or 5 days after CCI was not different from that of the control on the second and seventh days after the CCI. The number of Fos immunoreactive cells in the vAPtN and dAPtN increased 2 days after CCI, but did not differ from that in the control 7 days after CCI. We conclude that vAPtN and dAPtN cells are activated by nerve injury; the vAPtN exerts inhibitory control of the initial phase of neuropathic pain whereas the dAPtN does not appear to exert an inhibitory effect in neuropathic processing.

Motor cortex stimulation activates the incertothalamic pathway in an animal model of spinal cord injury

We have shown previously that electrical stimulation of the motor cortex reduces spontaneous painlike behaviors in animals with spinal cord injury (SCI). Because SCI pain behaviors are associated with abnormal inhibition in the inhibitory nucleus zona incerta (ZI) and because inactivation of the ZI blocks motor cortex stimulation (MCS) effects, we hypothesized that the antinociceptive effects of MCS are due to enhanced inhibitory inputs from ZI to the posterior thalamus (Po)-an area heavily implicated in nociceptive processing. To test this hypothesis, we used a rodent model of SCI pain and performed in vivo extracellular electrophysiological recordings in single well-isolated neurons in anesthetized rats. We recorded spontaneous activity in ZI and Po from 48 rats before, during, and after MCS (50 μA, 50 Hz; 300-ms pulses). We found that MCS enhanced spontaneous activity in 35% of ZI neurons and suppressed spontaneous activity in 58% of Po neurons. The majority of MCS-enhanced ZI neurons (81%) were located in the ventrorateral subdivision of ZI-the area containing Po-projecting ZI neurons. In addition, we found that inactivation of ZI using muscimol (GABAA receptor agonist) blocked the effects of MCS in 73% of Po neurons. Although we cannot eliminate the possibility that muscimol spread to areas adjacent to ZI, these findings support our hypothesis and suggest that MCS produces antinociception by activating the incertothalamic pathway.

PERSPECTIVE

This article describes a novel brain circuit that can be manipulated, in rats, to produce antinociception. These results have the potential to significantly impact the standard of care currently in place for the treatment of patients with intractable pain.

μ1- and 5-HT1-dependent mechanisms in the anterior pretectal nucleus mediate the antinociceptive effects of retrosplenial cortex stimulation in rats

AIM

This study examines if injection of cobalt chloride (CoCl(2)) or antagonists of muscarinic cholinergic (atropine), μ(1)-opioid (naloxonazine) or 5-HT(1) serotonergic (methiothepin) receptors into the dorsal or ventral portions of the anterior pretectal nucleus (APtN) alters the antinociceptive effects of stimulating the retrosplenial cortex (RSC) in rats.

MAIN METHOD

Changes in the nociceptive threshold were evaluated using the tail flick or incision pain tests in rats that were electrically stimulated at the RSC after the injection of saline, CoCl(2) (1 mM, 0.10 μL) or antagonists into the dorsal or ventral APtN.

KEY FINDINGS

The injection of CoCl(2), naloxonazine (5 μg/0.10 μL) or methiothepin (3 μg/0.10 μL) into the dorsal APtN reduced the stimulation-produced antinociception from the RSC in the rat tail flick test. Reduction of incision pain was observed following stimulation of the RSC after the injection of the same substances into the ventral APtN. The injection of atropine (10 ng/0.10 μL) or ketanserine (5 μg/0.10 μL) into the dorsal or ventral APtN was ineffective against the antinociception resulting from RSC stimulation.

SIGNIFICANCE

μ(1)-opioid- and 5-HT(1)-expressing neurons and cell processes in dorsal and ventral APtN are both implicated in the mediation of stimulation-produced antinociception from the RSC in the rat tail flick and incision pain tests, respectively.

Antinociceptive effect of stimulating the zona incerta with glutamate in rats

The zona incerta (ZI) is a subthalamic nucleus connected to several structures, some of them known to be involved with antinociception. The ZI itself may be involved with both antinociception and nociception. The antinociceptive effects of stimulating the ZI with glutamate using the rat tail-flick test and a rat model of incision pain were examined. The effects of intraperitoneal antagonists of acetylcholine, noradrenaline, serotonin, dopamine, or opioids on glutamate-induced antinociception from the ZI in the tail-flick test were also evaluated. The injection of glutamate (7 μg/0.25 μl) into the ZI increased tail-flick latency and inhibited post-incision pain, but did not change the animal performance in a Rota-rod test. The injection of glutamate into sites near the ZI was non effective. The glutamate-induced antinociception from the ZI did not occur in animals with bilateral lesion of the dorsolateral funiculus, or in rats treated intraperitoneally with naloxone (1 and 2 m/kg), methysergide (1 and 2 m/kg) or phenoxybenzamine (2 m/kg), but remained unchanged in rats treated with atropine, mecamylamine, or haloperidol (all given at doses of 1 and 2 m/kg). We conclude that the antinociceptive effect evoked from the ZI is not due to a reduced motor performance, is likely to result from the activation of a pain-inhibitory mechanism that descends to the spinal cord via the dorsolateral funiculus, and involves at least opioid, serotonergic and α-adrenergic mechanisms. This profile resembles the reported effects of these antagonists on the antinociception caused by stimulating the periaqueductal gray or the pedunculopontine tegmental nucleus.

Inhibition of spinal cord dorsal horn neuronal activity by electrical stimulation of the cerebellar cortex

The cerebellum plays a major role in not only modulating motor activity, but also contributing to other functions, including nociception. The intermediate hemisphere of the cerebellum receives sensory input from the limbs. With the extensive connection between the cerebellum to brain-stem structures and cerebral cortex, it is possible that the cerebellum may facilitate the descending system to modulate spinal dorsal horn activity. This study provided the first evidence to support this hypothesis. Thirty-one wide-dynamic-range neurons from the left lumbar and 27 from the right lumbar spinal dorsal horn were recorded in response to graded mechanical stimulation (brush, pressure, and pinch) at the hind paws. Electrical stimulation of the cerebellar cortex of the left intermediate hemisphere significantly reduced spinal cord dorsal horn neuron-evoked responses bilaterally in response to peripheral high-intensity mechanical stimuli. It is concluded that the cerebellum may play a potential antinociceptive role, probably through activating descending inhibitory pathways indirectly.

Abnormal anterior pretectal nucleus activity contributes to central pain syndrome

Central pain syndrome (CPS) is a debilitating condition that affects a large number of patients with a primary lesion or dysfunction in the CNS, most commonly due to spinal cord injury, stroke, and multiple sclerosis lesions. The pathophysiological processes underlying the development and maintenance of CPS are poorly understood. We have recently shown, in an animal model of CPS, that neurons in the posterior thalamic nucleus (PO) have increased spontaneous and evoked activity. We also demonstrated that these changes are due to suppressed inhibitory inputs from the zona incerta (ZI). The anterior pretectal nucleus (APT) is a diencephalic nucleus that projects on both the PO and ZI, suggesting that it might be involved in the pathophysiology of CPS. Here we test the hypothesis that CPS is associated with abnormal APT activity by recording single units from APT in anesthetized rats with CPS resulting from spinal cord lesions. The firing rate of APT neurons was increased in spinal-lesioned animals, compared with sham-operated controls. This increase was due to a selective increase in firing of tonic neurons that project to and inhibit ZI and an increase in bursts in fast bursting and slow rhythmic neurons. We also show that, in normal animals, suppressing APT results in increased PO spontaneous activity and evoked responses in a subpopulation of PO neurons. Taken together, these findings suggest that APT regulates ZI inputs to PO and that enhanced APT activity during CPS contributes to the abnormally high activity of PO neurons in CPS.

Serotonin receptors are involved in the spinal mediation of descending facilitation of surgical incision-induced increase of Fos-like immunoreactivity in rats

Background

Descending pronociceptive pathways may be implicated in states of persistent pain. Paw skin incision is a well-established postoperative pain model that causes behavioral nociceptive responses and enhanced excitability of spinal dorsal horn neurons. The number of spinal c-Fos positive neurons of rats treated intrathecally with serotonin, noradrenaline or acetylcholine antagonists where evaluated to study the descending pathways activated by a surgical paw incision.

Results

The number of c-Fos positive neurons in laminae I/II ipsilateral, lamina V bilateral to the incised paw, and in lamina X significantly increased after the incision. These changes: remained unchanged in phenoxybenzamine-treated rats; were increased in the contralateral lamina V of atropine-treated rats; were inhibited in the ipsilateral lamina I/II by 5-HT_1/2B/2C (methysergide), 5-HT_2A (ketanserin) or 5-HT_{1/2A/2C/5/6/7} (methiothepin) receptors antagonists, in the ipsilateral lamina V by methysergide or methiothepin, in the contralateral lamina V by all the serotonergic antagonists and in the lamina X by LY 278,584, ketanserin or methiothepin.

Conclusions

We conclude: (1) muscarinic cholinergic mechanisms reduce incision-induced response of spinal neurons inputs from the contralateral paw; (2) 5-HT_1/2A/2C/3 receptors-mediate mechanisms increase the activity of descending pathways that facilitates the response of spinal neurons to noxious inputs from the contralateral paw; (3) 5-HT_1/2A/2C and 5-HT_1/2C receptors increases the descending facilitation mechanisms induced by incision in the ipsilateral paw; (4) 5-HT_2A/3 receptors contribute to descending pronociceptive pathways conveyed by lamina X spinal neurons; (5) α-adrenergic receptors are unlikely to participate in the incision-induced facilitation of the spinal neurons.

The integrity of the anterior pretectal nucleus and dorsolateral funiculus is necessary for electroacupuncture-induced analgesia in the rat tail-flick test

Previous studies have indicated that the anterior pretectal nucleus (APtN) is implicated in pathways that descend through the dorsolateral funiculus (DLF) to modulate nociceptive inputs in the spinal dorsal horn. The activation of descending inhibitory mechanisms also seems to be involved in electroacupuncture (EA)-induced analgesia. This study utilized the tail-flick test to examine the changes produced by DLF lesion or injection of 2% lidocaine into the APtN in the analgesia induced by 2 or 100 Hz EA applied to the Zusanli (ST36) and Sanyinjiao (SP6) acupoints in lightly anesthetized rats. Tail-flick latency was significantly increased by EA, the effect of 2 Hz EA lasting longer than that produced by 100 Hz EA. The effect of either 2 or 100 Hz EA did not occur in DLF lesion rats. The effect of 2 Hz EA did not occur in rats with neural block of the whole or dorsal APtN. In contrast, the effect of 100 Hz EA was reduced in rats with neural block of the whole APtN, but remained unchanged in rats with neural block of the dorsal APtN. We thus conclude that the integrity of the APtN and DLF is necessary for EA-induced analgesia in the rat tail-flick test. In addition, the integrity of the dorsal APtN is necessary for the analgesic effect of 2 but not 100 Hz EA.

Zona incerta: a role in central pain

Central pain syndrome (CPS) is a debilitating condition that affects a large number of patients with a primary lesion or dysfunction in the CNS. Despite its discovery over a century ago, the pathophysiological processes underlying the development and maintenance of CPS are poorly understood. We recently demonstrated that activity in the posterior thalamus (PO) is tightly regulated by inhibitory inputs from zona incerta (ZI). Here we test the hypothesis that CPS is associated with abnormal inhibitory regulation of PO by ZI. We recorded single units from ZI and PO in animals with CPS resulting from spinal cord lesions. Consistent with our hypothesis, the spontaneous firing rate and somatosensory evoked responses of ZI neurons were lower in lesioned animals compared with sham-operated controls. In PO, neurons recorded from lesioned rats exhibited significantly higher spontaneous firing rates and greater responses to noxious and innocuous stimuli applied to the hindpaw and to the face. These changes were not associated with increased afferent drive from the spinal trigeminal nucleus or changes in the ventroposterior thalamus. Thus CPS can result from suppressed inputs from the inhibitory nucleus zona incerta to the posterior thalamus.

Heterogeneous output pathways link the anterior pretectal nucleus with the zona incerta and the thalamus in rat

The anterior pretectal nucleus (APT) and the zona incerta (ZI) are diencephalic nuclei that exert a strong inhibitory influence selectively in higher order thalamic relays. The APT is also known to project to the ZI as well as the thalamus, but anatomical details of the APT-ZI projection have not been described. In the present study, the efferent pathways of the APT were examined in the APT-ZI-thalamus network by using anterograde and retrograde tracing in combination with pre- and postembedding immunocytochemical stainings and in situ hybridization. The vast majority of APT fibers selectively innervated the parvalbumin-positive, ventral part of the ZI, which contains ZI neurons with axons projecting to higher order thalamic nuclei. The APT-ZI pathway consisted of both gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA)-negative and GABA-positive components; 38.2% of the terminals in the ZI contained GABA, and 8.6% of the projecting somata in the APT were glutamic acid decarboxylase 67 (GAD67) mRNA positive. The combination of parvalbumin immunostaining with retrograde tracing showed that strongly and weakly parvalbumin-positive as well as parvalbumin-negative neurons were all among the population of APT cells projecting to the ZI. Similar heterogeneity was found among the APT cells projecting to the thalamus. Double retrograde tracing from higher order thalamic nuclei and their topographically matched ZI regions revealed hardly any APT neuron with dual projections. Our data suggest that both ZI and the higher order thalamic relays are innervated by distinct, physiologically heterogeneous APT neurons. These various efferent pathways probably interact via the rich recurrent collaterals of the projecting APT cells. Therefore, the powerful, GABAergic APT and ZI outputs to the thalamus are apparently co-modulated in a synergistic manner via dual excitatory and inhibitory APT-ZI connections.

Modulation of persistent nociceptive inputs in the anterior pretectal nucleus of the rat

The anterior pretectal nucleus (APtN) participates in nociceptive and antinociceptive mechanisms. Drugs were injected into the ventral APtN to evaluate how intrinsic mechanisms interact in the nucleus during persistent allodynia produced by a surgical incision in a rat hind paw. Naloxone (1 and 10 ng/0.08 microl), methysergide (0.037 and 3.7 ng/0.08 microl) or atropine (0.1 and 10 ng/0.08 microl) increased the allodynia. The effect of methysergide was intensified by naloxone or atropine, the effect of atropine was intensified by naloxone or methysergide, but the effect of naloxone was not changed by methysergide or atropine. DAMGO (1.5 microg/0.08 microl), oxotremorine (5 microg/0.08 microl) or serotonin (5 microg/0.08 microl) reduced the allodynia. The effect of DAMGO was less intense in methysergide-treated rats but was not changed in atropine-treated rats, the effect of serotonin was not changed by naloxone or atropine, and the effect of oxotremorine was not changed by naloxone or methysergide. Baclofen (150 ng/0.08 microl) increased, whereas phaclofen (300 ng/0.1 microl) reduced the allodynia. Bicuculline (50 ng/0.08 microl) increased the incision pain, while muscimol (50 ng/0.08 microl) did not change it. Phaclofen was inhibited by methysergide but was unchanged by atropine. The effect of DAMGO was reduced by phaclofen (100 ng/0.1 microl). We interpret these results as indicative that noxious inputs utilize cholinergic and serotonergic pathways in the vAPtN for the activation of descending pain control mechanisms, the serotonergic pathway being under the control of GABAergic neurons which, in turn, are modulated negatively by opioid nerve terminals.

Role for Medullary Pain Facilitating Neurons in Secondary Thermal Hyperalgesia

The rostral ventromedial medulla (RVM) has recently received considerable attention in efforts to understand mechanisms of hyperalgesia and persistent pain states. Three classes of neurons can be identified in the RVM based on responses associated with nocifensive reflexes: on cells, off cells, and neutral cells. There is now direct evidence that on cells exert a net facilitating effect on spinal nociception and that off cells depress nociception. These experiments tested whether the secondary hyperalgesia produced by topical application of mustard oil involves an activation of on cells in RVM. Firing of a characterized RVM neuron and the latencies of withdrawal reflexes evoked by noxious heat were recorded in lightly anesthetized rats before and after application of mustard oil to the shaved skin of the leg above the knee. Mineral oil was applied as a control. Mustard oil produced a significant increase in ongoing and reflex-related discharge of on cells, as well as a decrease in the activity of off cells. neutral cell firing was uniformly unchanged after application of mustard oil. The alterations in on and off cell firing were associated with a significant decrease in the latency to withdraw the paw of the treated limb from the heat stimulus, and this hyperalgesia was blocked by microinjection of lidocaine within the RVM. Withdrawals evoked by heating the contralateral hindpaw, forepaw, and tail were unchanged after mustard oil application. These experiments support a pronociceptive role for on cells and suggest that these neurons contribute to secondary hyperalgesia in inflammation.