Dorsal Horn Plasticity Following Re-routeing of Peripheral Nerves: Evidence for Tissue-Specific Neurotrophic Influences from the Periphery

The histology, physiology, neurochemistry and circuitry of the substantia gelatinosa Rolandi (lamina II) in mammalian spinal cord

The substantia gelatinosa Rolandi (SGR) was first described about two centuries ago. In the following decades an enormous amount of information has permitted us to understand - at least in part - its role in the initial processing of pain and itch. Here, I will first provide a comprehensive picture of the histology, physiology, and neurochemistry of the normal SGR. Then, I will analytically discuss the SGR circuits that have been directly demonstrated or deductively envisaged in the course of the intensive research on this area of the spinal cord, with particular emphasis on the pathways connecting the primary afferent fibers and the intrinsic neurons. The perspective existence of neurochemically-defined sets of primary afferent neurons giving rise to these circuits will be also discussed, with the proposition that a cross-talk between different subsets of peptidergic fibers may be the structural and functional substrate of additional gating mechanisms in SGR. Finally, I highlight the role played by slow acting high molecular weight modulators in these gating mechanisms.

Nerve growth factor and nociception: from experimental embryology to new analgesic therapy

Nerve growth factor (NGF) is central to the development and functional regulation of sensory neurons that signal the first events that lead to pain. These sensory neurons, called nociceptors, require NGF in the early embryo to survive and also for their functional maturation. The long road from the discovery of NGF and its roles during development to the realization that NGF plays a major role in the pathophysiology of inflammatory pain will be reviewed. In particular, we will discuss the various signaling events initiated by NGF that lead to long-lasting thermal and mechanical hyperalgesia in animals and in man. It has been realized relatively recently that humanized function blocking antibodies directed against NGF show remarkably analgesic potency in human clinical trials for painful conditions as varied as osteoarthritis, lower back pain, and interstitial cystitis. Thus, anti-NGF medication has the potential to make a major impact on day-to-day chronic pain treatment in the near future. It is therefore all the more important to understand the precise pathways and mechanisms that are controlled by NGF to both initiate and sustain mechanical and thermal hyperalgesia. Recent work suggests that NGF-dependent regulation of the mechanosensory properties of sensory neurons that signal mechanical pain may open new mechanistic avenues to refine and exploit relevant molecular targets for novel analgesics.

Experiments on the nature of the signal that induces spinal neuroplastic changes following a peripheral lesion

This study aimed at identifying the signal(s) that elicit myositis-induced neuroplastic changes in background activity and responsiveness of spinal neurones. It is based on previous data suggesting that in dorsal horn neurones, responsiveness to peripheral input on one hand and background activity on the other are probably controlled by different mechanisms. In anaesthetized rats, myositis was induced in the gastrocnemius-soleus muscle and the activity of single dorsal horn neurones was recorded in segment L3. Impulse traffic and axoplasmatic transport in dorsal roots L4 and L5 were selectively blocked by lignocaine or vinblastine for various time periods relative to the induction of the myositis. The results show that the main triggering signal for the myositis-induced changes in both responsiveness and background activity is the altered impulse activity in primary afferent fibres. In contrast, 'no axonally transported chemical signal controlling the discharge behaviour of dorsal horn neurones was found. However, the time course of the electrical signals that cause the myositis-induced changes in background activity and responsiveness is different. For changes in responsiveness, a rather narrow time window of 2 h directly after induction of the myositis existed, during which the impulses from the inflamed muscle must reach the spinal cord. Accordingly, to prevent the increase in responsiveness, the electrical input had to be blocked during the first 2 h; a block of the same duration at another time had no effect. The change in background activity seems to be due to a continuous input from the inflamed muscle which adds up over the hours. Therefore, with regard to background activity, blocking the electrical signals is effective at any time, but only a block of long duration has a significant effect.

Synaptic plasticity in the adult spinal dorsal horn: The appearance of new functional connections following peripheral nerve regeneration

Peripherally regenerated fibers were impaled in the dorsal columns. Each impaled fiber's adequate stimulus was determined and the fiber was activated by passing brief (200 ms) current pulses through the microelectrode. Cord dorsum potentials (CDPs) elicited by fiber stimulation were recorded at 8 sites, and then the fiber was injected with Neurobiotin (NB). In the same preparations, dorsal horn cells were impaled and their receptive fields (RFs) mapped; areas of skin from which the most vigorous responses were elicited were noted. Needle electrodes inserted into these cutaneous "hot spots" were used to electrically activate minimal numbers of peripherally regenerated fibers while simultaneously recording the resulting CDPs and any intracellular EPSPs. This allowed determination of connectivity between regenerated fibers and dorsal horn cells with overlapping RFs. In agreement with findings in intact animals, NB revealed long-ranging collaterals which were not seen using intraaxonally injected horseradish peroxidase (HRP). Although there was no qualitative difference in their morphology compared to those seen in controls, the correlation between spatial distribution of boutons and amplitudes of the monosynaptic CDPs of peripherally regenerated fibers revealed significant shifts in the functional efficacy of many central connections. Transcutaneous electrical stimulation revealed a significantly higher incidence of connectivity between regenerated fibers and cells with overlapping RFs at 9-12 months (86%) than at 5-6 months (34%). Although there was no obvious anatomical reorganization of afferent projections in the dorsal horn, the observed functional changes with time following transection show the formation of new functional central connections.

Neurotrophins in spinal cord nociceptive pathways

Neurotrophins are a well-known family of growth factors for the central and peripheral nervous systems. In the course of the last years, several lines of evidence converged to indicate that some members of the family, particularly NGF and BDNF, also participate in structural and functional plasticity of nociceptive pathways within the dorsal root ganglia and spinal cord. A subpopulation of small-sized dorsal root ganglion neurons is sensitive to NGF and responds to peripheral NGF stimulation with upregulation of BDNF synthesis and increased anterograde transport to the dorsal horn. In the latter, release of BDNF appears to modulate or even mediate nociceptive sensory inputs and pain hypersensitivity. We summarize here the status of the art on the role of neurotrophins in nociceptive pathways, with special emphasis on short-term synaptic and intracellular events that are mediated by this novel class of neuromessengers in the dorsal horn. Under this perspective we review the findings obtained through an array of techniques in naïve and transgenic animals that provide insight into the modulatory mechanisms of BDNF at central synapses. We also report on the results obtained after immunocytochemistry, in situ hybridization, and monitoring intracellular calcium levels by confocal microscopy, that led to hypothesize that also NGF might have a direct central effect in pain modulation. Although it is unclear whether or not NGF may be released at dorsal horn endings of certain nociceptors in vivo, we believe that these findings offer a clue for further studies aiming to elucidate the putative central effects of NGF and other neurotrophins in nociceptive pathways.

Regulation of afferent connectivity in the adult spinal cord by nerve growth factor

During development, nerve growth factor (NGF) regulates the density and character of peripheral target innervation (Barde, Neuron, 2, 1525 - 1534, 1989; Ritter et al., Soc. Neurosci. Abstr., 17, 546.2, 1991); its role in adult animals is less well defined. Here we have asked if the availability of growth factors such as NGF in peripheral tissues can influence the pattern of primary afferent connections in the CNS. Using osmotic minipumps, we raised the levels of NGF in rat skeletal muscle in vivo, a tissue where the levels of this factor are normally very low (Korsching and Thoenen, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 80, 3513 - 3516, 1983; Shelton and Reichardt, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 81, 7951 - 7955, 1984; Goedert et al., Mol. Brain Res., 1, 85 - 92, 1986). After 2 weeks of treatment we asked if the sensory neurons innervating this tissue showed an altered strength and distribution of connections with dorsal horn neurons. The contralateral (vehicle-treated) muscle, and totally untreated animals, served as controls. In normal and vehicle-treated animals, electrical stimulation of muscle afferents excited relatively few neurons in the dorsal horn, and these generally showed only weak responses. In contrast, on the NGF-treated side many more dorsal horn neurons in the lumbar enlargement of the spinal cord were excited by muscle afferents. The increased responsiveness could not be explained by a generalized increase in dorsal horn excitability, since spontaneous activity was not enhanced, nor by a change in A-fibre-mediated inhibitions from the treated afferents. Thus, these afferents appeared to establish new synaptic connections or strengthened previously weak ones as a result of increased neurotrophic factor availability. The data suggest that, in the adult rat, the levels of growth factors in peripheral targets may be used to regulate an appropriate degree of afferent connectivity within the central nervous system.

Stability and plasticity of primary afferent projections following nerve regeneration and central degeneration

Sensory neurons of the dorsal root ganglia (DRG) regenerate their peripheral axons with relative ease following a nerve lesion. The capacity for central regeneration appears more limited. However, after nerve lesion, some DRG neurons gain a regenerative advantage to sprout centrally. We developed a lesion model in the rat to test whether, after prior lesion of their peripheral axons, subsets of cutaneous afferents benefit differently in their ability to sprout into adjacent spinal segments denervated by dorsal rhizotomy. We found that under identical circumstances, myelinated sensory neurons, small-diameter peptidergic sensory neurons containing calcitonin gene related peptide (CGRP), and small-diameter nonpeptidergic neurons that bind the lectin from the plant Griffonia simplificolia, isolectin B4 (IB4) differ dramatically in their ability to regenerate centrally. Myelinated afferent terminals labelled transganglionically with cholera-toxin beta-subunit gain a small advantage in collaterally sprouting into the adjacent denervated neuropil in lamina III after prior peripheral nerve lesion. This central regenerative response was not mimicked by experimentally induced inflammation of sensory neuron cell bodies. Intact and unlesioned sensory neurons positive for CGRP sprout vigorously into segments denervated by rhizotomy in a nonsomatotopic manner. In contrast, IB4-positive sensory neurons maintain a somatotopic distribution centrally, which is not altered by prior nerve lesion. These data reveal a remarkably heterogeneous response to regeneration-promoting stimuli amongst three different types of cutaneous sensory neurons. In particular, the divergent responses of peptidergic and nonpeptidergic sensory neurons suggests profound functional differences between these neurochemically distinct neurons.

Maintenance of modality-specific connections in the spinal cord after neonatal nerve growth factor deprivation

We have investigated the properties of antidromically identified lamina I neurons in the rat dorsal horn (in vivo) after neonatal administration of antibody to nerve growth factor (anti-NGF). Treatment from postnatal day (P) 2 to P9 yielded normal lamina I cell physiology; most cells responded to mechanical nociception and the remainder had a wide dynamic range (WDR). Extending anti-NGF treatment to P14 reduced the proportion of cells responding to mechanical nociception, increased the proportion of WDR cells, and caused the emergence of cells not driven by cutaneous inputs. Both nociceptive-specific and WDR cells had larger receptive fields, suggestive of enhanced central action of the remaining nociceptive afferents. These findings cannot be explained by direct action of anti-NGF on spinal cord neurons since both P2-9 and P2-14 treatments should have had similar effects given the time course of development of the blood-brain barrier. The results are discussed in terms of previous findings indicating normal numbers of D-hairs and high-threshold mechanoreceptors (HTMRs) after anti-NGF treatment from P2 to P9, but a decline in the number of HTMRs and an increase in the number of D-hairs after treatment from P2 to P14. It is suggested that the reduction in nociceptive neurons and the appearance of neurons not driven by cutaneous stimulation in lamina I results from the reduction in HTMR input. However, D-hair input to lamina I did not increase despite the larger number of these afferents, suggesting that their central action was regulated to maintain appropriate modality relationships between periphery and centre.

Leukemia inhibitory factor induces mechanical allodynia but not thermal hyperalgesia in the juvenile rat

Systemic administration or local injection to the rat hindpaw of leukemia inhibitory factor induced a prolonged, dose dependent, mechanical hypersensitivity of the hindpaw flexion withdrawal reflex. Mechanical stimuli which were innocuous prior to leukemia inhibitory factor administration, evoked a rapid hindpaw withdrawal reflex indicative of mechanical allodynia. Pre-administration of anti-leukemia inhibitory factor antibodies prevented this behavioural hypersensitivity. Hindpaw sensitivity to a noxious thermal stimulus was unaffected by leukemia inhibitory factor administration. Anti-leukemia inhibitory factor had no effect upon hindpaw withdrawal thresholds when injected alone nor influenced the mechanical hypersensitivity produced by a subcutaneous injection of nerve growth factor. Injection of the closely related cytokine ciliary neurotrophic factor did not affect mechanical or thermal reflex withdrawal thresholds. Elevation of the neuroactive cytokine leukemia inhibitory factor following peripheral nerve injury may be a contributory factor to the pathogenesis of neuropathic pain.

Functional reorganization in the rat dorsal horn during an experimental myositis

In anaesthetized rats, the influence of an acute inflammation (2-8 h duration) of the gastrocnemius-soleus (GS) muscle on the excitability of dorsal horn neurones was studied using a mapping procedure. One of the main effects of the myositis was that the neurone population responding to GS A-fibre input increased in size. The increase was most marked in the lateral segments L6-L3 which received little input from the GS muscle in control animals. Excitability testing showed a myositis-induced lowering in threshold, combined with an increase in latency, jitter and input convergence. This suggests that new oligo- or polysynaptic connections become functional under the influence of a myositis. Neuronal effects induced by C fibres in the GS nerves were not significantly altered by a myositis, but C fibre-induced activations from the peroneal and sural nerves increased in the lateral dorsal horn. The results show that an acute myositis leads to marked changes in the functional connectivity of the dorsal horn within a few hours. The main increase in excitability took place in the lateral dorsal horn, where many neurones acquired a new input from the GS muscle. This mechanism may be involved in the spread or referral of muscle pain.

The resolution of neuropathic hyperalgesia following motor and sensory functional recovery in sciatic axonotmetic mononeuropathies

Nerve lesions producing extensive axonal loss can induce painful hyperalgesic states in man. The affect of axonal regeneration and end-organ reinnervation on hyperalgesia and pain is controversial. This study used two axonotmetic models, the sciatic crush injury (CI) and the sciatic chronic constrictive injury (CCI), to investigate the affects of nerve regeneration and reinnervation on hyperalgesia and presumed painful behavior in rats. The sciatic CI resulted in a transient loss of both sciatic motor function and the withdrawal response to pinch and heat in the sciatic distribution. Extensive recovery of motor function, pinch and heat response occurred over days 23-38 post-crush injury. This temporally corresponded with a plateau in the hindpaw autotomy score and a resolution of the saphenous-mediated pressure and heat hyperalgesia (adjacent neuropathic hyperalgesia; ANH) which developed over the medial dorsum of the hindpaw following the sciatic CI. In contrast, with sciatic transection and distal stump excision, no motor recovery occurs, large areas of the hindpaw remain unresponsive to heat and pinch, and the saphenous mediated ANH fails to resolve over a period of 3 months. When sciatic CI was compared to contralateral sciatic transection within the same rat, the bilateral saphenous-mediated pressure and heat thresholds were initially identical, but by 23-27 days post-crush, the crush side thresholds became hypoalgesic relative to the section side. This demonstrates an attenuation of the crush-induced ANH which temporally corresponds to the recovery of motor and sensory function. When the sciatic nerve was proximally crushed and distally transected (3 cm below the crush site), the saphenous-mediated pressure and heat threshold changes were identical (over 6 weeks of serial testing) to those produced by a contralateral sciatic transection within the same rat. This indicates that the microenvironments surrounding the regenerating axon tips did not differentially affect the development of ANH following sciatic CI or transection. The sciatic CCI resulted in a transient loss of hindpaw motor function without the loss of pinch or heat withdrawal responses in the sciatic distribution. Motor function recovery occurred primarily over days 23-59 post-ligature. During this prolonged period of motor function recovery there was a resolution of the sciatic-mediated plantar surface heat hyperalgesia and the saphenous-mediated heat ANH. The above data support the hypothesis that the successful regeneration of distal axons after axonotmetic lesions can initiate the resolution of neuropathic hyperalgesia.

Muscle afferents innervating skin form somatotopically appropriate connections in the adult rat dorsal horn

We have studied the somatotopic reorganization in dorsal horn neurons after a disruption in the normal spatial arrangement of primary sensory axons in adult rats. Muscle afferents were redirected to skin by cutting and cross-anastomosing the hindlimb gastrocnemius nerve (GN) and sural nerve (SN). It has previously been shown that after 10-12 weeks GN afferents innervate the hairy skin of the lateral ankle and calf (previously innervated by SN afferents) and become potentially capable of relaying information on the location and intensity of stimuli applied to the skin. We determined the receptive field and response properties of dorsal horn neurons in the lumbar spinal cord, in regions where the lower hindlimb is normally represented. In control animals (with intact or self-anastomosed sural nerves) very few neurons (< 8%) received any synaptic input from the GN as assessed by electrical stimulation of the nerve. In contrast, when this nerve innervated skin, many cells responded to GN stimulation, and these nearly all had receptive field components in the former SN territory. Moreover, in animals with cross-anastomosed nerves, cells without GN inputs all had receptive fields outside the former SN skin territory. We have shown that in all likelihood GN afferents substituted for SN afferents in subserving the low and high threshold receptive fields of dorsal horn neurons. Furthermore, for many neurons, receptive fields were formed from inappropriately regrown GN afferents and adjacent intact cutaneous afferents (in the tibial or common peroneal nerves). Therefore, when GN afferents innervate skin in adult animals, they alter their central connectivity in an appropriate manner for their new peripheral terminations, so that an orderly somatotopic representation of the hind limb skin is maintained. We suggest that this plasticity of dorsal horn somatotopy is driven in part by activity-dependent mechanisms.

In vitro and in vivo modulation of 5-hydroxytryptamine-, thyrotropin-releasing hormone- and calcitonin-gene related peptide-like immunoreactivities in adult rat sensory neurons

In a previous work we have shown that culturing adult rat dorsal root ganglia neurons modifies their neurotransmitter phenotype in such a way that cultured neurons synthesize transmitters that are not found in situ, while several other transmitters are expressed in a much higher percentage of neurons in culture than in situ [Schoenen J. et al. (1989) J. Neurosci. Res. 22, 473-487]. The aim of the present study was to investigate the origin and the nature of the relevant environmental signals that allow this plasticity to be expressed, focusing on three neurotransmitters: 5-hydroxytryptamine, thyrotropin-releasing hormone and calcitonin-gene related peptide. The main results can be summarized as follows: (1) culturing cells in fetal calf serum or on feeder layers of astrocytes, Schwann cells or fibroblasts partially inhibits the serotoninergic phenotype of dorsal root ganglia neurons; (2) in vivo disconnection of dorsal root ganglia from their spinal targets but not from their peripheral or supraspinal targets induces a significant increase of the percentage of 5-hydroxytryptamine- and thyrotropin-releasing hormone-positive neurons in disconnected ganglia; (3) growth factors such as ciliary neuronotrophic factor or basic fibroblast growth factor but not nerve growth factor repress 5-hydroxytryptamine and calcitonin gene-related peptide immunoreactivity in cultured sensory neurons. In conclusion, neurotransmitter gene expression of adult dorsal root ganglia neurons is controlled by complex influences. Our data suggest that thyrotropin-releasing hormone and 5-hydroxytryptamine gene expression are tonically repressed in vivo by factors originating from the spinal segmental level and that growth factors such as ciliary neurotrophic factor or basic fibroblast growth factor could be potential vectors of this repressing effect.