Diabetes and autonomic neuropathy: an immunological association?

Diabetic uveopathy

Diabetes can involve several ocular structures -- including the cornea, lens, and retina -- and cause vascular and neural changes in these tissues. Although retinopathy is the most common ocular complication of diabetes, uveopathy can also be observed. This includes vascular, neural, muscular, and basement membrane changes. The main clinical manifestations of diabetic uveopathy are anterior uveitis and abnormal pupillary dynamics. Fluorescein angiography, optical coherence tomography, and optical coherence tomography angiography are ideal for the imaging of vascular changes of the iris and choroid, while dynamic pupillometry is a simple screening tool to detect neuropathy. Additionally, ultrasound biomicroscopy can provide clear images of the ciliary body. Iris abnormalities, primarily angiopathy and neuropathy, can appear as alterations in vascular diameter, neovascularization, and abnormal pupillary dynamics. Choroidal abnormalities primarily affect blood vessels, including alterations in vascular diameter, microaneurysm formation, and neovascularization. The abnormal manifestations in the ciliary body include a decrease in vessel count, alterations in their diameter, isolated angiomatous dilatation, and diffuse thickening of the basal membrane of the pigment epithelium.

Pathophysiology and management of gastroparesis

Gastroparesis is characterized by upper gastrointestinal symptoms associated with delayed gastric emptying, without mechanical obstruction. However, symptoms do not correlate well with the magnitude of delay in gastric emptying. Diabetes mellitus and surgery are the most common causes, although more than 30% of cases are idiopathic. Coordination of insulin action with nutrient delivery is important in diabetics, as postprandial blood glucose levels and gastric emptying are interdependent, and gastroparesis probably represents a major cause of poor glycemic control. Scintigraphy is the gold standard for measuring gastric emptying. Current treatment mainly involves the use of prokinetic drugs. Pyloric botulinum toxin injection and gastric electrical stimulation require more evidence from controlled studies before their use can be recommended. Surgical options remain inadequately studied.

Immunological responses to exogenous insulin

Regardless of purity and origin, therapeutic insulins continue to be immunogenic in humans. However, severe immunological complications occur rarely, and less severe events affect a small minority of patients. Insulin autoantibodies (IAAs) may be detectable in insulin-naive individuals who have a high likelihood of developing type 1 diabetes or in patients who have had viral disorders, have been treated with various drugs, or have autoimmune disorders or paraneoplastic syndromes. This suggests that under certain circumstances, immune tolerance to insulin can be overcome. Factors that can lead to more or less susceptibility to humoral responses to exogenous insulin include the recipient's immune response genes, age, the presence of sufficient circulating autologous insulin, and the site of insulin delivery. Little proof exists, however, that the development of insulin antibodies (IAs) to exogenous insulin therapy affects integrated glucose control, insulin dose requirements, and incidence of hypoglycemia, or contributes to beta-cell failure or to long-term complications of diabetes. Studies in which pregnant women with diabetes were monitored for glycemic control argue against a connection between IAs and fetal risk. Although studies have shown increased levels of immune complexes in patients with diabetic microangiopathic complications, these immune complexes often do not contain insulin or IAs, and insulin administration does not contribute to their formation. The majority of studies have shown no relationship between IAs and diabetic angiopathic complications, including nephropathy, retinopathy, and neuropathy. With the advent of novel insulin formulations and delivery systems, such as insulin pumps and inhaled insulin, examination of these issues is increasingly relevant.

An update on autonomic neuropathy affecting the gastrointestinal tract

Gastrointestinal symptoms and disordered gut motility occur frequently in the diabetic population and are generally regarded as manifestations of gastrointestinal "autonomic dysfunction," although the relationships between both symptoms and dysmotility with abnormal cardiovascular autonomic function are weak. It is now recognized that the blood glucose concentration is both a determinant of and determined by gastrointestinal function. An improved definition of the underlying pathophysiology should facilitate the development of therapies that are targeted more effectively.

Autoantibodies to autonomic nerves associated with cardiac and peripheral autonomic neuropathy

OBJECTIVE

This study examines whether autonomic nerve autoantibodies (ANabs) are associated with development of autonomic neuropathy using a prospective study design.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

A group of type 1 diabetic patients were followed prospectively with regard to autonomic nerve function on four occasions. At the third examination, 41 patients were tested for ANabs (complement-fixing autoantibodies to the sympathetic ganglion, vagus nerve, and adrenal medulla), and the results were related to cardiac autonomic nerve function (heart rate variation during deep breathing [expiration/inspiration ratio] and heart-rate reaction to tilt [acceleration and brake index]) and to peripheral sympathetic nerve function (vasoconstriction after indirect cooling [vasoconstriction index]).

RESULTS

ANabs were detected in 23 of 41 (56%) patients at the third examination. Compared with patients without ANabs (ANabs-), patients with ANabs (ANabs+) showed significantly higher frequencies of at least one abnormal cardiac autonomic nerve function test at the third examination (17 of 23 [74%] vs. 7 of 18 [39%]; P = 0.03) and fourth examination (15 of 21 [71%] vs. 4 of 16 [25%]; P < 0.01). In contrast, there was no similar difference at the first or second examination. The relative risk for ANabs(+) patients to develop cardiac autonomic neuropathy at follow-up was 7.5 (95% CI 1.72-32.80). The vasoconstriction index was more abnormal in ANabs+ than in ANabs- patients at the fourth examination (median 1.40 [interquartile range 1.58] vs. 0.35 [2.05]; P = 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

ANabs were associated with future development of cardiac and peripheral autonomic neuropathy in diabetic patients, implying an etiological relationship between nervous tissue autoimmunity and these diabetes complications.

Severe and disabling diabetic autonomic neuropathy: a case report

We report a case of a woman with several and severe disabling manifestations of autonomic neuropathy in whom reasonable quality of life was established by combining continuous insulin infusion, jejunal feeding, colostomy and bladder self-catheterisation. We discuss the prevalence rates, pathophysiology, management and prognosis of this disabling condition.

Prevalence of autoantibodies to autonomic nervous tissue structures in Type 1 diabetes mellitus

AIMS

The pathogenesis of diabetic autonomic neuropathy is multifactorial, but recent studies have suggested a link between the presence of autoantibodies to nervous tissue structures and severe, symptomatic autonomic neuropathy. The present study was designed to examine the true prevalence of these autoantibodies in a large clinic-based population of Type 1 diabetic patients compared to nondiabetic controls.

METHODS

The presence of complement fixing autoantibodies to vagus nerve (CF-VN), sympathetic ganglion (CF-SG) and adrenal medulla (CF-ADM) was assessed by immunofluorescence in a large cohort of patients (n = 394) of varying duration of Type 1 DM (median 28 years, range 6 months to 73 years) and 160 age and sex-matched nondiabetic control subjects.

RESULTS

All three autoantibodies were frequently detected in Type 1 DM (CF-VN, 22.1%; CF-SG, 30.7%; CF-ADM, 13.2%) but only rarely in healthy control subjects (4.4%, 4.4% and 3.1%, respectively; P < 0.0005 for all). There was no association between any of the autoantibodies and retinopathy (fundoscopy), peripheral somatic neuropathy (biothesiometry) or nephropathy (urinary albumin-creatinine ratio).

CONCLUSIONS

Our results on this large cohort establish the extensive presence of autonomic nervous tissue autoantibodies in Type 1 DM. Their role in reflecting, causing or predicting autonomic neuropathy remains to be determined.

Stimulation of nerve growth-factor and substance P expression in the iris-trigeminal axis of diabetic rats--involvement of oxidative stress and effects of aldose reductase inhibition

In rats with streptozotocin-induced diabetes, we measured increased (by 61%; P < 0.05) mRNA for nerve growth factor (NGF) in the iris together with increased (by 82%; P < 0.05) mRNA for preprotachykinin (the substance P precursor) in the trigeminal ganglion, suggesting that increased NGF was driving increased substance P gene expression. In other diabetic rats, these changes were prevented by treatment with either an antioxidant (butylated hydroxytoluene; 1% by diet) or an aldose reductase inhibitor (ARI) (sorbinil; 25 mg/kg/day p.o.) and the sorbinil treatment was associated with significant inhibition of polyol pathway intermediates in both lens and sciatic nerve. This suggests that polyol pathway activity in the lens may translate to oxidative stress-driving stimulation of NGF gene expression in the iris. The change is selective for NFG, because expression of the analogous neurotrophin, neurotrophin-3 (NT-3), was unaltered in the same irises. These changes suggest that oxidative stress and/or inflammation can drive up NGF expression in diabetes--a mechanism that might participate in iritis.

Autonomic function and autoantibodies to autonomic nervous structures, glutamic acid decarboxylase and islet tyrosine phosphatase in adolescent patients with IDDM

Recent studies have linked autoimmunity to nervous tissue structures and diabetic autonomic neuropathy, but data on the early stage of IDDM and on the natural history of this association are not available. For this reason, we investigated autonomic nervous function, and the presence of autoantibodies to sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous structures, to glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD) and tyrosine phosphatase (IA-2/ICA512) in 85 adolescents with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) (mean age 14.7+/-1.6 yr, mean duration of diabetes 6.8+/-3.5 yr), and 45 age and sex-matched healthy subjects. Nervous tissues autoantibodies were detected using an indirect immunofluorescent complement-fixation technique, with monkey adrenal gland, rabbit cervical ganglia and vagus nerve as substrates. GAD and IA-2/ICA512 autoantibodies were detected by radioimmunoprecipitation assay. Seven patients (8%) had anti-vagus nerve autoantibodies, 7 other patients (8%) had anti-cervical ganglia autoantibodies, while all controls were negative (P < 0.05). Anti-adrenal medulla antibodies were detected in 16 patients (19%) and in 2 control subjects (P<0.02). None of the patients had autonomic symptoms. When patients were divided according to the presence or absence of autoantibodies, values of the cardiovascular tests (deep breathing, 30:15 ratio, Valsalva ratio) were similar in the two groups and similar to those in healthy subjects. However, when considered together, patients positive for one or more autoantibody showed a trend for lower values of deep breathing test and 30:15 ratio test, compared with healthy control subjects, which failed to reach conventional significance values (P=0.17 and P=0.07, respectively). No correlation was found between cardiovascular parameters and metabolic control or diabetes duration. There was no association between autoimmunity to nervous tissue structures and presence of GAD and IA-2/ICA512 Ab, and no correlation between these two autoantibodies and values of cardiovascular tests. Our data indicate that autonomic dysfunction is not a characteristic of young diabetic patients, but that autoantibodies against autonomic nervous structures are present during the first 1 to 15 yr of diabetes. GAD and tyrosine phosphatase appear to be excluded as target autoantigens within autonomic structures. Follow-up studies are required to evaluate future autonomic dysfunction and symptoms in these patients, and to establish whether the subtle autonomic dysfunction detected and/or the nervous tissue autoantibodies, are predictive of the development of this complication.

Autoantibodies against sympathetic ganglia and evidence of cardiac sympathetic dysinnervation in newly diagnosed and long-term IDDM patients

To investigate the presence of autoantibodies against sympathetic nervous tissue and their correlation with cardiac sympathetic dysinnervation in insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM), 20 newly diagnosed (age 26 +/- 6 years) and 48 long-term IDDM patients (age 40 +/- 13 years, duration of diabetes 22 +/- 12 years) without myocardial perfusion abnormalities (normal 99mTC-methoxyisobutylisonitrile uptake) were assessed for myocardial 123I-metaiodo benzylguanidine (123I-MIBG) uptake and complement-fixing sympathetic ganglia (CF-SG) autoantibodies. Both groups of patients were also studied for islet cell antibodies (ICA) and ECG-based cardiac autonomic neuropathy. Eighty control subjects (age 18-49 years) were investigated for CF-SG autoantibodies. Eight newly diagnosed (40%) and 12 long-term (25%) IDDM patients exhibited CF-SG autoantibodies, compared to 4 control subjects (5%; p < 0.01, p < 0.05). In long-term diabetic patients, the reduction of global but not of regional myocardial 123I-MIBG uptake correlated with CF-SG autoantibodies (r = 0.34, p = 0.02). Newly diagnosed diabetic patients did not show an association between CF-SG autoantibodies and global or regional myocardial 123I-MIBG uptake. ECG-based cardiac autonomic neuropathy (> or = two of five cardiac reflex tests abnormal) was present in 22 and absent in 26 long-term IDDM patients, of whom 9 (41%) and 3 (12%), respectively were positive for CF-SG autoantibodies (p = 0.02). Only 1 newly diagnosed IDDM patient demonstrated ECG-based cardiac autonomic neuropathy and was also positive for CF-SG autoantibodies. Although they are somewhat suggestive, results concerning autoantibodies against sympathetic nervous tissue and cardiac sympathetic dysinnervation do not strongly support the view that autoimmune mechanisms play a major role in the pathogenesis of cardiac sympathetic neuropathy in IDDM.

An investigation of antibodies to nerve growth factor in diabetic autonomic neuropathy

Nerve growth factor (NGF) is required for development and maintenance of autonomic nervous function and is highly expressed in the iris. An association between sensory and autonomic diabetic neuropathy and NGF function has been postulated. In light of the evidence for an autoimmune component to the pathogenesis of autonomic neuropathy in Type 1 diabetes mellitus, an enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) was established to investigate the presence of autoantibodies to mNGF in: 20 patients with long-standing Type 1 diabetes with abnormal autonomic function tests, of whom 14 had symptomatic autonomic neuropathy, 3 had an episode of iritis, and 6 had no autonomic symptoms; 9 age-matched patients with Type 1 diabetes and no complications; 10 healthy control subjects. Insulin antibodies by ELISA and autoantibodies to other endocrine targets were also measured. The specificity of anti-mNGF autoantibody ELISA was further confirmed by immunodepletion on mNGF-Sepharose 4B. No differences in antibody binding to mNGF were detected, between any of the patient groups and control subjects. There was no relationship between age, sex, and diabetes duration and mNGF binding. High levels of anti-mNGF autoantibodies were found in only one diabetic patient who had no evidence of neuropathy, raising the possibility that an autoimmune component to NGF might precede the development of autonomic dysfunction. It remains to be established whether autoantibodies to NGF play a role in diabetic autonomic neuropathy and prospective studies will be required to investigate whether the autoantibodies are a feature of evolving but not established neuropathy.

Glutamic acid decarboxylase antibodies, autonomic nerve antibodies and autonomic neuropathy in diabetic patients

To clarify whether GAD-ab are associated with diabetic autonomic neuropathy and/or complement fixing antibodies against sympathetic ganglia, adrenal medulla, and vagus nerve, we examined 133 diabetic patients (95 with IDDM). GAD-ab were determined by a radioligand binding assay using in vitro expression of recombinant GAD-65 whereas sympathetic ganglia antibodies, adrenal medulla antibodies, vagus nerve, and ICA were evaluated by indirect immunofluorescence assays. Autonomic nerve function was evaluated by objective tests (heart rate reactions to deep breathing and to tilt). In the total material of 133 patients, GAD-ab were detected in 36 patients, all of whom had IDDM. The frequency of GAD-ab was similar (38%) in IDDM patients with and without signs of autonomic neuropathy (21 of 55 vs 15 of 40). In addition, there were no significant associations between GAD-ab and autonomic nerve antibodies; GAD-ab were detected in 9 of 21 (43%) of patients with and in 27 of 112 (24%) of patients without sympathetic ganglia antibodies, in 5 of 15 (33%) of patients with and 31 of 118 (26%) without adrenal medulla antibodies, and in 5 of 15 (33%) with and 31 of 118 (26%) of patients without vagus nerve antibodies. The frequency of ICA, however, was significantly increased in patients with sympathetic ganglia antibodies compared with those without sympathetic ganglia antibodies (10 of 21 [48%] vs 21 of 112 [19%]; p < 0.01). In conclusion, GAD-ab were neither associated with disturbed autonomic nerve function nor with antibodies against autonomic nerve structures.

Autoantibodies to nervous tissue structures are associated with autonomic neuropathy in type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus

There is evidence that the immune system may play a role in the pathogenesis of autonomic neuropathy in Type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus. In the present study, we investigated the presence of autoantibodies to sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous structures and their correlation with other conventional autoantibodies in well-characterised diabetic populations, with or without diabetic neuropathy, and normal subjects. An indirect immunofluorescent complement-fixation technique was used, with monkey adrenal gland, rabbit cervical ganglia and vagus nerve as substrates. Of the patients with symptomatic autonomic neuropathy 33% were positive for at least one autoantibody (20% anti-sympathetic ganglia, 10% anti-vagus nerve and 13% anti-adrenal medulla). The frequency of having one or more antibodies to nervous tissues and the prevalence of anti-cervical ganglia antibodies were significantly higher in the neuropathic patients than in the diabetic control subjects with disease of similar duration and in the normal subjects (p < 0.05). Of the patients without complications with diabetes of shorter duration 33% were also positive for at least one autoantibody (13% anti-ganglia, 13% anti-vagus nerve and 13% anti-adrenal medulla). No correlation was found with other tissue autoantibodies, including islet cell antibodies. Our data indicate that nervous tissue autoantibodies are associated with symptomatic autonomic neuropathy. Anti-sympathetic ganglia and anti-vagus nerve antibodies seem to be more disease-specific. Patients with diabetes of shorter duration who were positive for these autoantibodies may represent pre-neuropathic patients.

Clinical observations and experiments in diabetic neuropathy

Diabetic neuropathies form a group of diverse conditions, which can be distinguished between those which recover (acute painful neuropathies, radiculopathies, mononeuropathies) and those which progress (sensory and autonomic neuropathies). These two main groups can be distinguished in several ways: sensory and autonomic neuropathies are classic diabetic complications progressing gradually in patients with long-standing diabetes who often have other specific complications, while the reversible neuropathies do not have these features. The latter are characterised by their occurrence at any stage of diabetes, often at diagnosis, they may be precipitated on starting insulin treatment, and they are more common in men; they can occur at any age, though more often in older patients, and are unrelated to other diabetic complications. The two groups of neuropathies also show differences in nerve structural abnormalities and with regard to distinctive blood flow responses. The underlying mechanisms responsible for these very different forms of neuropathy remain speculative, but evidence for an immunological basis for the development of severe symptomatic autonomic neuropathy is presented.

Autonomic nerve antibodies and autonomic nerve function in type 1 and type 2 diabetic patients

Complement-fixing adrenal medulla (CF-ADM), sympathetic ganglion (CF-SG), and vagal (CF-V) nerve antibodies were determined in diabetic patients. Among 74 patients with Type 1 diabetes, CF-ADM was detected in 7 (10%) cases, CF-SG in 14 (19%) cases, and CF-V in 8 (11%) cases. Among 38 patients with Type 2 diabetes, CF-ADM was detected in 5 (13%) cases, CF-SG in 4 (11%) cases, and CF-V in 6 (16%) cases. There were associations between autonomic nerve antibodies and autonomic nerve function. CF-ADM and/or CF-SG were significantly (P less than 0.002) less prevalent in Type 1 diabetic patients with autonomic neuropathy than in those without [5/44 (11%) vs. 14/30 (47%)] and, in agreement with this, the brake index, a sign of parasympathetic and sympathetic autonomic nerve function, was significantly (P less than 0.005) higher (more normal) in these patients (-0.56 +/- 0.13 vs. -1.04 +/- 0.12). In Type 2 diabetic patients, the E/I ratio, an index of parasympathetic nerve function, was significantly (P less than 0.03) lower (more abnormal) in those with CF-V than in those without (-1.81 +/- 0.17 vs. -1.20 +/- 0.11). In conclusion, the frequency of sympathetic nerve antibodies was decreased in Type 1 diabetic patients with autonomic neuropathy, while in Type 2 diabetic patients parasympathetic nerve antibodies were related to severe parasympathetic neuropathy.

Diabetic autonomic neuropathy

One of the earliest manifestations of diabetic neuropathy is denervation of the cardiovascular system; loss of heart rate variability may have a prevalence as high as 21.5% in diabetic patients, and declines at 1 beat/min/year, which is 3 times faster than in normal subjects. The cause of this neuropathy is unknown: attempts at decreasing the excess quantities of sorbitol, glucose and fructose in nerve tissue have lead to little functional improvement in man. Nerve ischaemia and immunological damage have stimulated increased interest lately, the latter particularly because of the structural homology of nerve growth factor and insulin. Symptoms from autonomic neuropathy are rare. When present they may well be intermittent, but never remit; they rarely progress or become disabling. One uncommon consequente of loss of sympathetic vascular tone is postural hypotension. This may result from failure of splanchnic vasoconstriction on standing. Food and insulin can greatly exacerbate the postural blood pressure fall. Reduced vascular tone in the neuropathic foot leads to increased arterio-venous shunt flow. The local reflex control of this shunt flow is also abnormal: paradoxical vasoconstriction occurs in response to local skin heating and postural reflexes are reduced. This high shunt flow together with its abnormal vascular control may be important in the pathogenesis of neuroarthropathy and foot ulceration. The prognosis of patients with autonomic neuropathy is better than previously reported. Abnormal heart rate variability alone is of no prognostic value. The presence of symptoms, in particular postural hypotension, significantly reduces survival. The majority of deaths however, result from concurrent renal disease and macrovessel atheroma.

Cell-mediated immunity and symptomatic diabetic autonomic neuropathy

T lymphocytes have been implicated in the nerve damage observed in allergic experimental neuritis and in idiopathic polyneuritis. Symptomatic autonomic neuropathy in long-standing Type 1 diabetes is a rare and unexplained complication, and some preliminary evidence has suggested a pathogenetic role for the immune system. We have measured levels of activated T lymphocytes in 18 Type 1 diabetic patients with symptomatic autonomic neuropathy and in 16 matched patients with uncomplicated Type 1 diabetes. Purified T lymphocytes from peripheral blood were stained with a fluorescein-labelled monoclonal antibody directed to the activation marker HLA-DR and counted under UV microscopy. Percent DR positive T lymphocytes were significantly raised in the patients with autonomic neuropathy when compared with long-standing uncomplicated diabetic patients (8.2 +/- 4.2 vs 4.9 +/- 3.3%, p less than 0.01). This finding lends support for a role of the immune system in the development of autonomic neuropathy.

Complements in non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus with complications

A relation of the complement system to the development of complications in non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (NIDDM) was evaluated by measuring some components of the complement system. CH50, C3, C4 and C3bINA were significantly elevated in subjects with NIDDM as compared with healthy non-diabetic controls. However, CH50 and C3 did not differ between diabetics with and without complications. C4 was higher in diabetics with retinopathy as well as with retinopathy and neuropathy than in diabetics without these complications. ACH50, beta 1Hg1 and C3d were similar in subjects with NIDDM and non-diabetics, and not associated with complications of NIDDM. C3d/C3 in NIDDM without complications was lower than in healthy subjects, but did not significantly differ between the types of complications. These results suggest that the high level of complements in NIDDM might be due to enhanced production of complements and the development of diabetic complications would be related to the elevated level of complements.