Fetal telemedicine: six month pilot of real-time ultrasound and video consultation between the Isle of Wight and London

Identifying benefits and concerns with using digital health services during COVID-19: Evidence from a hospital-based patient survey

Despite large-scale adoption during COVID-19, patient perceptions on the benefits and potential risks with receiving care through digital technologies have remained largely unexplored. A quantitative content analysis of responses to a questionnaire (N = 6766) conducted at a multi-site acute trust in London (UK), was adopted to identify commonly reported benefits and concerns. Patients reported a range of promising benefits beyond immediate usage during COVID-19, including ease of access; support for disease and care management; improved timeliness of access and treatment; and better prioritisation of healthcare resources. However, in addition to known risks such as data security and inequity in access, our findings also illuminate some less studied concerns, including perceptions of compromised safety; negative impacts on patient-clinician relationships; and difficulties in interpreting health information provided through electronic health records and mHealth apps. Implications for future research and practice are discussed.

The use and role of telemedicine in maternal fetal medicine around the world: an up-to-date

Purpose

The aim of this narrative review is to sumarize data about the use and role of telemedicine in maternal fetal medicine (MFM).

Methods

We searched pubmed and scopus to find articles about telemedicine in MFM by using the terms telmedicine or telehealth and maternal fetal medicine.

Results

Telehealth has been widely used for several medical specialties. During the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, telehealth has gained investment and further research. Even though telemedicine in MFM has not been frequently applied, from 2020 onwards it has increased in both implementation and acceptance worldwide. The need to screen the patients in overloaded centers in a pandemic scenario required telemedicine in MFM, which has exhibited consistently good results concerning health and budget. The aim of this study was to review the telehealth programs and research focused on MFM around the world. Few studies have been applied to MFM and even fewer in developing and undeveloped countries. The majority of studies were concentrated in the USA and in Europe.

Conclusion

Further research is needed, especially in non-developed countries, to comprehend the potential role of telemedicine in MFM for improving the life quality of the patients, health professionals, and to be cost-efficient.

A cost minimization analysis comparing asynchronous tele-expertise with face-to-face consultation for prenatal diagnosis in France

Timely detection of congenital anomalies using ultrasound improves neonatal care. As specialist sonographers are often geographically dispersed, they are sometimes requested to provide a second opinion via tele-expertise. The present study aimed to evaluate the economic impact of asynchronous tele-expertise in obstetric ultrasound care in private medical practice through a comparison with face-to-face consultations. We conducted a cost minimization analysis using decision tree modeling in order to determine whether asynchronous tele-expertise or face-to-face consultation had the lowest cost, under the assumption of equivalent effectiveness in terms of prenatal diagnosis. Costs were measured from the societal perspective. The data for the base case of our modeling came from a retrospective analysis of the clinical practice of an expert who had been conducting asynchronous tele-expertise for 4 years in France. The study included 260 patients for whom 322 requests for expert opinions were made by physicians/midwives from January 2016 to January 2020. The expected average total cost for tele-expertise for a patient was €74.45 (95% CI: €66.36-€82.54) compared to €195.02 (95% CI: €183.90-€206.14) for the conventional face-to-face strategy. Accordingly, using tele-expertise led to a statistically significant reduction of €120.57 in the average total cost per patient. A sensitivity analysis confirmed the robustness of the model produced. The results of the present study underline the efficiency of tele-expertise and highlight related economic benefits. Accordingly, they could inform public health policy on the dissemination of tele-expertise in the field of obstetric ultrasound care.

Asynchronous tele-expertise (ASTE) for prenatal diagnosis is feasible and cost saving: Results of a French case study

Objective

The objective of this study was to assess the potential of the use of asynchronous tele-expertise (ASTE) to provide prenatal diagnosis from a medical and economic point of view.

Population

Patients screened by a midwife at a primary center.

Methods

A technical and clinical evaluation was conducted retrospectively, and a cost minimization study compared asynchronous tele-expertise to face-to-face consultations that would have been performed without ASTE.

Main outcome measures

In our study we assessed the feasibility of ASTE, what were the origins of the requests for expertise, whether patients need to be moved and the reasons for doing so, and the costs of tele-expertise and conventional consultation.

Results

In this retrospective analysis 322 advices from 260 patients were interpreted remotely via a platform. The results revealed a 90.68% feasibility of transmitting in a satisfactory and interpretable way ultrasound images and videos via the tele-expertise platform (292/322 files). In our series, asynchronous analysis allowed the required physician to make an accurate diagnosis and identify 74 (28.5%, 95% CI [23% –33.9%]) pregnancies associated with malformations and rule out abnormalities in 186 (71.5%, 95% CI [66.1% –77%]) of the cases. The ASTE was not associated with face-to-face consultations for 72.7% (189/260) of the patients, who without moving, were able to have access to a precise diagnosis by ruling out the presence of anomalies in 163/189 of these patients and confirming them in 26/189 patients. The practice of ASTE would result from a societal point of view, an average saving of 61.8% (€ 120.57) per patient compared to a face-to-face consultation.

Conclusion

The use of asynchronous tele-expertise (ASTE) using fetal ultrasound, is feasible and may contribute to increased diagnostic accuracy while generating a significant reduction in costs for society.

Detection of Fetal Anomalies by Remotely Directed and Interpreted Ultrasound (Teleultrasound): A Randomized Noninferiority Trial

OBJECTIVE

To determine the accuracy and reliability of remotely directed and interpreted ultrasound (teleultrasound) as compared with standard in-person ultrasound for the detection of fetal anomalies, and to determine participants' satisfaction with teleultrasound.

STUDY DESIGN

This was a single-center, randomized (1:1) noninferiority study. Individuals referred to the maternal-fetal medicine (MFM) ultrasound clinic were randomized to standard in-person ultrasound and counseling or teleultrasound and telemedicine counseling. The primary outcome was major fetal anomaly detection rate (sensitivity). All ultrasounds were performed by registered diagnostic medical sonographers and interpretations were done by a group of five MFM physicians. After teleultrasound was completed, the teleultrasound patients filled out a satisfaction survey using a Likert scale. Newborn data were obtained from the newborn record and statewide birth defect databases.

RESULTS

Of 300 individuals randomized in each group, 294 were analyzed in the remotely interpreted teleultrasound group and 291 were analyzed in the in-person ultrasound group. The sensitivity of sonographic detection of 28 anomalies was 82.14% in the control group and of 20 anomalies in the telemedicine group, it was 85.0%. The observed difference in sensitivity was 0.0286, much smaller than the proposed noninferiority limit of 0.05. Specificity, negative predictive value, positive predictive value, and accuracy were more than 94% for both groups. Patient satisfaction was more than 95% on all measures, and there were no significant differences in patient satisfaction based on maternal characteristics.

CONCLUSION

Teleultrasound is not inferior to standard in-person ultrasound for the detection of fetal anomalies. Teleultrasound was uniformly well received by patients, regardless of demographics. These key findings support the continued expansion of telemedicine services.

KEY POINTS

· For detection of major anomalies, teleultrasound is comparable to standard ultrasound.. · Teleultrasound was well accepted by patients.. · Teleultrasound use should be expanded..

A brief history of telemedicine and the evolution of teleneonatology

Over a century of innovations in technology and medical care have led to the current day capabilities in telemedicine. In this chapter, we discuss the evolution of telemedicine over the last century and highlight various applications in neonatal care. We hope this chapter demonstrates the exponential adoption of telemedicine, particularly in neonatology, and the breadth and depth of the technology being used.

[Asynchronous Tele-Expertise (ASTE) in obstetrical ultrasound: Is it equivalent to face-to-face consultation?]

INTRODUCTION

The demand for remote advice has expanded since the advent of information and communication technology. This study aims to evaluate the use of asynchronous tele-expertise (ASTE) in providing a quality expert opinion in the field of obstetric ultrasound.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Requests for expert opinions on pregnant patients were considered retrospectively over a 24-month period (01/09/2018 to 01/21/2020). All patients were initially seen in consultation with a midwife sonographer, located in Hyères, 82km from the expert's centre. In the event of unusual images, including one or more malformations on ultrasound screening, a second opinion was necessary. Responses were characterized as follows : possible or impossible to analyse images; ASTE alone or combined with a face-to-face consultation; and absence or presence of unusual images. Unusual images were classified as normal variants or recognised malformations. We analysed the outcomes of these pregnancies and assessed concordance between prenatal advice and postnatal outcome.

RESULTS

During the study period, we identified 174 referrals from 141 patients. Requests for advice were made by 3/174 (1.7%), 69/174 (39.7%), and 102/174 (58.6%) in the first, second, and third trimester of pregnancy, respectively. Overall, 115/141 (81.6%), 21/141 (14.9%), 4/141 (2.8%), and 1/141 (0.7%) patients were provided with one, two, three, and five opinions, respectively. In total, 37/141 (26.2%) patients required a face-to-face consultation, resulting in 38/174 (21.8%) opinions (one patient was seen twice). At least one unusual image was found for 27/141 (19.2%) patients and no unusual images were reported for 114/141 (80.8%) patients. Analysis of the pregnancy outcomes revealed a perfect correlation between prenatal advice and postnatal data, both for cases with unusual images and those without.

CONCLUSION

The preliminary results of our study reveal that ASTE is safe in terms of enabling an expert to answer a precise question formulated by a screener when confronted with images deemed to be unusual. Using this mode of communication, a tailored healthcare pathway may be defined for the mother and her foetus. This new type of practice cannot exist without establishing a genuine relationship of trust between the person requesting the opinion and the person who is asked to provide the opinion.

Implementation of a fetal ultrasound telemedicine service: women's views and family costs

Background

The complexity of fetal medicine (FM) referrals that can be managed within obstetric units is dependent on the availability of specialist ultrasound expertise. Telemedicine can effectively transfer real-time ultrasound images via video-conferencing. We report the successful introduction of a fetal ultrasound telemedicine service linking a specialist fetal medicine (FM) centre and a remote obstetric unit.

Methods

Over a four-year period from October 2015, all women referred for FM consultation from the obstetric unit were seen via telemedicine, excluding cases where invasive testing, intrauterine therapy or cardiac anomalies were anticipated. The outcomes measured included the indication for FM referral; scan duration and image and sound quality during the consultation. Women’s perceptions of the telemedicine consultation and estimated costs to attend the FM centre were measured by a structured questionnaire completed following the first telemedicine appointment during the Phase 1 of the project.

Results

Overall, 297 women had a telemedicine consultation during Phase 1 (pilot and evaluation) and Phase 2 (embedding and adoption) of the project, which covered a 4 year period 34 women completed questionnaires during the Phase 1 of the study. Travel to the telemedicine consultation took a median (range) time of 20 min (4150), in comparison to an estimated journey of 230 min (120,450) to the FM centre. On average, women would have spent approximately £28 to travel to the FM centre per visit. The overall costs for the woman and her partner/ friend to attend the FM centre was estimated to be £439.

Women were generally satisfied with the service and valued the opportunity to have a FM consultation locally.

Conclusions

We have demonstrated that a fetal ultrasound telemedicine service can be successfully introduced to provide FM ultrasound of sufficient quality to allow fetal diagnosis and specialist consultation with parents. Furthermore, the service is acceptable to parents, has shown a reduction in family costs and journey times.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12884-020-03532-4.

Telemedicine in Obstetrics

Telemedicine is an important modality of care delivery in the twenty-first century and has many applications for the obstetric population. Existing research has shown the clinical efficacy and improved patient satisfaction of many telemedicine platforms in obstetrics. Telemedicine has the potential to reduce racial and geographic disparities in pregnancy care, but more research is necessary to inform best practices. Developing cost-effective telemedicine programs and establishing health care policy that standardizes insurance reimbursement are some of the most important steps toward scaling up telemedicine offerings for obstetric patients in the United States.

Reducing Infant Mortality Using Telemedicine and Implementation Science

Optimal perinatal regionalization is a proven evidence-based strategy to lower infant mortality. Telemedicine can engage community stakeholders, providers, and patients to facilitate optimal perinatal regionalization leading to lower infant mortality. Rural community caregivers and administrators can participate in forming optimal perinatal guidelines without leaving their community. The visual picture created by telemedicine facilitates better transport decisions; ensuring infants who are transferred to larger centers truly need it while supporting smaller nurseries by providing better consultation services and back transport of patients when appropriate. Telemedicine can also provide educational opportunities to community practices, leading to better evidence-based care.

Service user and staff acceptance of fetal ultrasound telemedicine

Objective

We present qualitative findings from interviews with frontline clinicians and service users of a fetal telemedicine service.

Methods

Semi-structured interviews with clinical stakeholders and service users were conducted, undertaken as part of a service evaluation. Data collection was undertaken by different teams, using interview schedules aligned to independent evaluation aims. Data were subjected to thematic analysis.

Results

Sonographers reported four main challenges: delivering a shared consultation; the requirement to resist scanning intuitively; communications during the scan; and restricted room space. Notwithstanding, all clinicians reported that participating women were accepting of the technology. Service users reported few concerns. The main benefits of fetal telemedicine were identified as upskilled staff, increased access to specialist support and improved management of complex pregnancies. Convenience was identified as the main benefit by service users, including savings in time and money from not having to travel, take time off work, and arrange childcare.

Conclusions

Service users and clinical stakeholders were accepting of the service. Service users reported satisfaction with communications during the consultation and awareness that telemedicine had facilitated local access to clinical expertise. Whilst clinical stakeholders reported challenges, the iterative nature of the evaluation meant that concerns were discussed, responded to, and overcome as the pilot developed. Clinical stakeholders’ perception of benefits for service users encouraged their acceptance. Moreover, the evaluation established that fetal ultrasound telemedicine is a viable method to access expertise safely and remotely. It provided demonstrable evidence of a potential solution to some of the healthcare challenges facing rural hospitals.

Telemedicine in High-Risk Obstetrics

Telemedicine involves the use of technology to provide services to patients and share medical information. Telemedicine's use has increased as technology has advanced. It allows for medicine to be practiced from a distance to reach patients in rural or underserved areas. Telemedicine has widespread uses in high-risk obstetrics, including management of diabetes, diagnosis and management of hypertensive disorders of pregnancy, screening for fetal malformations with teleultrasound, delivering care to underserved areas, and more. The use of telemedicine to provide care to patients and information to health care providers at a distance has been well accepted by the patients and providers.

Sound sight: seeing with ultrasound

Recent advances in medical imaging, information and communication technology promise to support medical visual practice as well as everyday healthcare experience. However, this potential is not easy to realize. A better understanding of existing practices can inform socio-technical innovation. We draw on ethnographic observations and our involvement in the design of `palpable computing' to examine the use of ultrasound imaging technologies in consultations with pregnant women with a view to ideas and implications for socio-technical innovation.

Trans-Pacific tele-ultrasound image transmission of fetal central nervous system structures

OBJECTIVE

To assess the quality of images and video clips of fetal central nervous (CNS) structures obtained by ultrasound and transmitted via tele-ultrasound from Brazil to Australia.

METHODS

In this cross-sectional study, 15 normal singleton pregnant women between 20 and 26 weeks were selected. Fetal CNS structures were obtained by images and video clips. The exams were transmitted in real-time using a broadband internet and an inexpensive video streaming device. Four blinded examiners evaluated the quality of the exams using the Likert scale. We calculated the mean, standard deviation, mean difference, and p values were obtained from paired t tests.

RESULTS

The quality of the original video clips was slightly better than that observed by the transmitted video clips; mean difference considering all observers = 0.23 points. In 47/60 comparisons (78.3%; 95% CI = 66.4-86.9%) the quality of the video clips were judged to be the same. In 182/240 still images (75.8%; 95% CI = 70.0-80.8%) the scores of transmitted image were considered the same as the original.

CONCLUSION

We demonstrated that long distance tele-ultrasound transmission of fetal CNS structures using an inexpensive video streaming device provided images of subjective good quality.

Securing Remote Obstetrics Monitoring Systems

Reports from many countries describe remote obstetrics monitoring systems as a means of improving the quality of prenatal care. The next generation of remote obstetrics monitoring systems incorporate off-the-shelf equipment like commercial smartphones into their design, to not only reduce the cost of the monitoring equipment, but also to allow for greater flexibility by letting the patient perform monitoring herself, in the comfort of her own home. In this paper, the authors analyzed the security protections of recently proposed monitoring systems and proposed recommendations to improve the security of these systems.

The Cost-Effectiveness of Prenatal Detection for Congenital Heart Disease Using Telemedicine Screening

We estimated the longer-term cost-effectiveness of using telemedicine screening for prenatal detection of congenital heart disease (CHD). One hospital in south-east England with a telemedicine service was connected to a fetal cardiology unit in London. A UK health service perspective was adopted. Evidence on costs and outcomes for standard-risk pregnant women during the antenatal period was based on patient-level data. Extrapolation beyond the end of the study (just after delivery) was carried out for the lifetime of children born with and without CHD. Expert opinion and data from published sources was used to populate a decision model. Future costs and benefits were discounted. The main outcome was quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) and results were expressed as cost per QALY gained. Various one-way sensitivity analyses were conducted. The model showed that offering telemedicine screening by specialists to all standard-risk pregnant women was the dominant strategy (i.e. cheaper and more effective). The sensitivity analyses found that the model was robust, and that telemedicine remained the most cost-effective strategy. The study showed that it would be cost-effective to provide telemedicine examinations as part of an antenatal screening programme for all standard-risk women.

A fetal telecardiology service: patient preference and socio-economic factors

OBJECTIVE

The aims of this study were to evaluate patients' opinions on a fetal cardiology telemedicine service compared with usual outpatient care, the effect of the telemedicine consultation on maternal anxiety and its impact on travel times and time absent from work.

METHODS

Prospective study over 20 months. Eligible patients attended for routine anomaly scan followed by fetal echocardiogram transmitted to the regional centre with live guidance by a fetal cardiologist, followed by parental counselling. All patients were offered a fetal cardiology appointment at the regional centre. Structured questionnaires assessing maternal satisfaction, travel times/days off and anxiety scores completed at time of both fetal echocardiograms.

RESULTS

Sixty-seven patients were recruited and 66 completed the study. Participants expressed very high satisfaction rates with fetal telecardiology, equivalent to face-to-face consultation. The telecardiology appointments were associated with significantly reduced travel times and days off work (p < 0.01). Expectant mothers expressed a clear inclination for a fetal cardiology appointment at the local hospital facilitated by telemedicine (p < 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

Fetal telecardiology is highly acceptable to patients and is even preferred compared with travelling to a regional centre. There are additional socio-economic benefits that should encourage the development of remote fetal cardiology services.

Inexpensive, realtime tele-ultrasound using a commercial, web-based video streaming device

We have devised an inexpensive, web-based tele-ultrasound system using commercially-available video streaming equipment. We examined the spatial and grey scale resolution, and the delay time of the system. The receiving PC was tested at various distances from the transmitting site, from 3.2 km to 4828 km. Standard resolution targets and echocardiography movie strips recorded on DVDs were used to assess the image quality. A qualitative assessment was made by an expert sonographer. As the distance between the transmitter and the receiver increased, the scan smoothness decreased and the delay increased. At a distance of 3.2 km the delay was 2–3 s, and at 4828 km it was 10–15 s. The delay was short enough to allow realtime guidance of the scanning technician by telephone. The system allows inexpensive, readily available, realtime tele-ultrasonography.

The clinical and technical evaluation of a remote telementored telesonography system during the acute resuscitation and transfer of the injured patient

BACKGROUND

Ultrasound (US) has an ever increasing scope in the evaluation of trauma, but relies greatly on operator experience. NASA has refined telesongraphy (TS) protocols for traumatic injury, especially in reference to mentoring inexperienced users. We hypothesized that such TS might benefit remote terrestrial caregivers. We thus explored using real-time US and video communication between a remote (Banff) and central (Calgary) site during acute trauma resuscitations.

METHODS

A existing internet link, allowing bidirectional videoconferencing and unidirectional US transmission was used between the Banff and Calgary ERs. Protocols to direct or observe an extended focused assessment with sonography for trauma (EFAST) were adapted from NASA algorithms. A call rota was established. Technical feasibility was ascertained through review of completed checklists. Involved personnel were interviewed with a semistructured interview.

RESULTS

In addition to three normal volunteers, 20 acute clinical examinations were completed. Technical challenges requiring solution included initiating US; audio and video communications; image freezing; and US transmission delays. FAST exams were completed in all cases and EFASTs in 14. The critical anatomic features of a diagnostic examination were identified in 98% of all FAST exams and a 100% of all EFASTs that were attempted. Enhancement of clinical care included confirmation of five cases of hemoperitoneum and two pneumothoraces (PTXs), as well as educational benefits. Remote personnel were appreciative of the remote direction particularly when instructions were given sequentially in simple, nontechnical language.

CONCLUSIONS

The remote real-time guidance or observation of an EFAST using TS appears feasible. Most technical problems were quickly overcome. Further evaluation of this approach and technology is warranted in more remote settings with less experienced personnel.

Cost implications of introducing a telecardiology service to support fetal ultrasound screening

A district hospital in south-east England used a telecardiology service for fetal cardiac diagnosis alongside an existing arrangement for referring pregnant women directly to perinatal cardiologists in London for detailed fetal echocardiography. Women were identified for referral according to local protocols when having a second trimester anomaly scan. For the telemedicine referrals, the sonographers video-recorded images from the anomaly scans for transmission during monthly videoconferences. The cost of the women's antenatal care was calculated from the specialist assessment until delivery, while family costs were collected in a postal survey. Over 15 months, telemedicine was used in 52 cases, while 24 women were seen in London. The London women were more likely to have had an ultrasound abnormality (29% v 10%, P = 0.047). A telemedicine assessment of 5 min duration was more costly than an examination in London (mean cost per referral of £206 v £74, P < 0.001). However, the telecardiology service was cost neutral after 14 days and for the extended period until delivery. Travel costs for London women averaged £37 compared with £5.50 for the telemedicine referrals. Telemedicine may be useful to support perinatal cardiologists in the UK whose workloads are expanding in response to improved standards in antenatal ultrasound screening.

Telemedicine in pediatric and perinatal cardiology: Economic evaluation of a service in English hospitals

Objectives:Pediatric cardiology has an expanding role in fetal and pediatric screening. The aims of this study were to observe how district hospitals use a pediatric telecardiology service, and to compare the costs and outcomes of patients referred to specialists by means of this service or conventionally.

Methods:A telemedicine service was set up between a pediatric cardiac center in London and four district hospitals for referrals of second trimester women, newborn babies, and older children. Clinicians in each hospital decided on the role for their service. Clinical events were audited prospectively and costed, and patient surveys were conducted.

Results:The hospitals differed in their selection of patient groups for the service. In all, 117 telemedicine patients were compared with 387 patients seen in London or in outreach clinics. Patients selected for telemedicine were generally healthier. For all patients, the mean cost for the initial consultation was £411 for tele-referrals and £277 for conventional referrals, a nonsignificant difference. Teleconsultations for women and children were significantly more expensive because of technology costs, whereas for babies, ambulance transfers were much more costly. After 6-months follow-up, the difference between referral methods for all patients was nonsignificant (telemedicine, £3,350; conventional referrals, £2,172), and nonsignificant within the patient groups.

Conclusions:Telemedicine was perceived by cardiologists, district clinicians, and families as reliable and efficient. The equivocal 6-month cost results indicate that investment in the technology is warranted to enhance pediatric and perinatal cardiology services.

Clinical outcomes associated with telemedicine/telehealth

This paper is a comprehensive review and synthesis of the literature concerning clinical outcomes associated with various telemedicine applications. It starts out with a brief description of the findings reported by similar literature reviews already published. Subsequently, it proposes a conceptual model for assessing clinical outcomes based on Donabedian's formulation of the Medical Care Process. Accordingly, research findings are reported in terms of the relevant components of the medical care process, namely, diagnosis, clinical management, and clinical outcomes. Specific findings are organized according to the designated clinical and diagnostic application. This is followed by a general report of studies dealing with patient satisfaction.

Prenatal diagnosis of congenital heart disease using four-dimensional spatio-temporal image correlation (STIC) telemedicine via an Internet link: a pilot study

OBJECTIVE

To assess whether the spatio-temporal image correlation (STIC) acquisition technique can be taught to a general obstetrician by e-mail; whether STIC volume datasets can be transmitted over the Internet; and whether STIC volume datasets analyzed offline at a remote setting can be used to confirm or exclude major cardiac defects (TELE-STIC).

METHODS

This was a prospective study involving 50 pregnant women with gestational ages ranging between 20 and 36 weeks. These patients were selected by two general obstetricians (operators) working in geographically remote areas of Chile. Although both obstetricians were users of equipment capable of four-dimensional (4D) ultrasound with STIC, they lacked skill in the performance of fetal cardiac examination. A dedicated web disk was created to upload the acquired volume datasets using an Internet broadband connection. Offline analysis was performed by a single investigator experienced in fetal echocardiography (the administrator).

RESULTS

A telemedicine link via the Internet was possible in all cases. Seventy-seven volume datasets were sent to the web server. A complete cardiac examination according to set criteria was achieved by the administrator in 86% of the cases scanned by one operator and 95% of the cases scanned by the other operator. Three patients had cardiac defects confirmed postnatally, two fetuses had extracardiac anomalies and one fetus had a suspected cardiac defect unconfirmed by second-opinion TELE-STIC. There were two isolated major congenital heart defects. Both patients were given advice by e-mail and teleconference using a web camera about the likely outcome and benefits of scheduling in utero transport to a tertiary care center.

CONCLUSIONS

STIC volumes can be obtained by operators inexperienced in fetal echocardiography, transmitted via the Internet, and their analysis enables recognition of most of the structures and views necessary to assess fetal cardiac anatomy. The preliminary use of TELE-STIC allowed us to demonstrate that some intracardiac anomalies can be ruled out and others confirmed, allowing perinatal management to be tailored accordingly.

Outcomes and Methods in Telemedicine Evaluation

One hundred and four articles, published from 1966 to 2000, were reviewed to investigate telemedicine evaluation studies in terms of methods and outcomes. A total of 112 evaluations were reported in these 104 articles. Two types of evaluations were evaluated: clinical and nonclinical. Within the clinical evaluations, three were on clinical effectiveness, 26 on patient satisfaction, 49 on diagnostic accuracy, and nine on cost. In the non-clinical evaluations, 15 articles discussed technical issues relating to digital images, such as bandwidth, resolution, and color, and 10 articles assessed management issues concerning efficiency of care, such as avoiding unnecessary patient transfer, or saving time. Of the 112 evaluations, 72 were descriptive in nature. The main methods used in the remaining 40 articles used quantitative methods. Nineteen articles employed statistical techniques, such as receiver operating characteristics curve (three evaluations) and kappa values (seven evaluations). Only one article utilized a qualitative approach to describe a telemedicine system. Currently, there are a number of good reports on diagnostic accuracy, satisfaction, and technological evaluation. However, clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness are important parameters, and they have received limited attention. Since telemedicine evaluations tend to explore various outcomes, it may be appropriate to evaluate from a multidisciplinary perspective, and to utilize various methodologies.

Screening fetal echocardiography by telemedicine: efficacy and community acceptance

OBJECTIVE

Our aim was to assess whether tertiary level screening fetal echocardiography can be extended to primary care facilities with telemedicine assistance.

METHODS

Assessment of image quality and the adequacy of fetal echocardiograms recorded after random transmission at 128, 384, or 768 kbits/s was performed. Live fetal echocardiograms were transmitted at 384 kbits/s (3 integrated services digital network lines) from the remote primary care center. Patient satisfaction was assessed by surveys obtained after office-based and telemedicine consultations.

RESULTS

A total of 58 recorded normal studies had similar image quality and adequacy on transmission at 384 and 768 kbits/s (P =.08 and.49, respectively) and were significantly better than 128 kbits/s (P <.01). During live screening transmitted at 384 kbits/s from the primary care center, 3 of 34 fetuses were diagnosed with heart disease. Surveys from patients with direct physician contact and by telemedicine showed a high satisfaction with telemedicine-assisted screening and counseling.

CONCLUSION

Adequate screening for fetal heart disease is technically feasible at or above data transmission rates of 384 kbits/s. Community acceptance for telemedicine-assisted screening and counseling is not adversely affected by a lack of direct personal contact with the specialist.

Realtime fetal ultrasound by telemedicine in Queensland. A successful venture?

We have established a realtime fetal tele-ultrasound consultation service in Queensland, which has been integrated into our routine clinical practice. The service, which uses ISDN transmission at 384 kbit/s, allows patients in Townsville to be examined by subspecialists in Brisbane, 1500 km away. For the 90 tele-ultrasound consultations performed for the first 71 patients, 90% of the babies have been delivered, and outcome data have been received on all the pregnancies. All significant anomalies and diagnoses have been confirmed. The referring clinicians would have physically referred 24 of the 71 patients to Brisbane in the absence of telemedicine. A crude cost-benefit calculation suggests that the tele-ultrasound service resulted in a net saving of A$6340, and at the same time enabled almost four times the number of consultations to be carried out.

Detailed three-dimensional fetal echocardiography facilitated by an Internet link

OBJECTIVES

To assess whether a complete virtual cardiological examination can be achieved in stored three-dimensional volumes of the fetal heart, transmitted to a tertiary fetal cardiology center via the Internet.

METHODS

Thirty sequential normal singleton pregnancies were included in the study. Four cardiac volumes were acquired using a three-dimensional ultrasound system. The volumes were sent via the Internet to a tertiary fetal cardiology center, where a detailed fetal cardiac examination was attempted using the three-dimensional volumetric dataset.

RESULTS

The median gestational age was 24 (range, 22-28) weeks. A complete heart examination was accomplished in 23 of 30 cases (76.7%; 95% confidence interval, 58-90%). The four-chamber view and the cardiac situs were seen in all cases. The right ventricular outflow tract was seen in 29 (96.7%) cases and the left ventricular outflow tract in 25 (83.3%) cases. The long-axis view of the aortic arch, superior vena cava, inferior vena cava and pulmonary veins were visualized in more than 80% of cases. The mean time of volume acquisition was 9.5 (standard deviation, 2.3) min and the mean examination time by the fetal cardiologist was 17 (standard deviation, 4.8) min.

CONCLUSIONS

These preliminary results demonstrate that a three-dimensional virtual examination of the fetal heart is possible. There are limitations such as the lack of flow and functional information but complete ascertainment of the main cardiac connections was possible in the majority of cases. The use of an Internet link has major implications, particularly for situations in which the scanning center is geographically remote from the tertiary referral center.

Real-time radiology--new concepts for teleradiology

We propose two new concepts for teleradiology: 'real-time radiology' and 'seamless operation of a workstation to view images from both local and remote hospitals'. In this paper, we describe an experimental real-time radiology system with a new multimedia diagnostic workstation, which has been established under teleradiology concepts and can be used for cooperative diagnosis by interchanging radiographic images bilaterally in real-time during an audio-visual discussion. The clinical evaluation of real-time radiology using a newly developed diagnostic workstation demonstrated the system to be practical and routinely available to enhance the radiological diagnostic quality of teleradiology.

Remote sonographic interpretation using a laser printer network: system performance and diagnostic accuracy in actual clinical practice

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of our study was to evaluate the technical and clinical performance of remote sonographic interpretation using a laser printer network connecting a community-based imaging center and an academic medical center.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

During a 3-month period, 161 consecutive sonographic examinations were performed at a community-based imaging center and all 161 patients were enrolled in the study. Seventy-one (44%) of 161 examinations were interpreted on-site at the community-based imaging center, and 90 (56%) of 161 were transmitted over a T-1 line to an academic medical center where the static images were interpreted remotely. For the purposes of this study, the examination time was defined as the interval from the time the technologist started to scan the patient to the time the patient was dismissed from the radiology department. Examination times were recorded for each patient. Follow-up was available for 92 (57%) of 161 studies. Sensitivity and specificity for studies interpreted at the community-based imaging center and at the academic medical center were calculated.

RESULTS

The mean examination time for pelvic sonographic examinations interpreted at the academic medical center (43 min) was significantly longer than for scans interpreted at the community-based imaging center (31 min) (p < 0.01). However, no significant difference was noted in the examination time for abdominal sonography. For all examinations interpreted on-site at the community-based imaging center for which follow-up was available, the sensitivity and specificity were 95% and 100%, respectively. For all examinations interpreted remotely at the academic medical center for which follow-up was available, the sensitivity and specificity were 93% and 90%, respectively. No significant difference was seen in the sensitivity (p = 1.00) or specificity (p = 0.24) of studies interpreted on-site versus remotely.

CONCLUSION

Static sonographic images can be interpreted remotely without loss of sensitivity, but with decreased specificity. However, more time must be allotted for performing pelvic sonography when these examinations are to be interpreted remotely.

Methods of measurement of image quality in teleultrasound

In recent years, teleultrasound has emerged as a potentially effective method of provision of ultrasound services to remote areas of the community. Transmission of teleultrasound, however, requires a high degree of compression when utilizing the relatively low bandwidth ISDN connections available within the UK. The actual amount of compression occurring varies both with the connection and the image content, often on a frame to frame basis. For this reason, traditional measurements of image quality using test tools are ineffective. Most studies to date have assessed equipment performance by testing diagnostic performance. Although this is the most important method of assessing the results of image degradation, few studies have attempted to perform physical measurements of degradation. The aims of this study were to measure the amount of degradation within a teleultrasound system and, using a number of methods, to ascertain the most useful indicators of loss of image quality. Groups of successive abdominal ultrasound images were captured and digitized both before and after degradation via an ISDN6 teleultrasound system. Normalized mean squared error (NMSE), pixel histograms, line and surface plots, Fourier spectra and contrast measurements were carried out on regions of interest in both sets of images. The NMSE was most sensitive to degradation, with alterations in the NMSE value depending on image content and degree of degradation. Fourier analysis was also indicative, showing consistent changes in high frequency content again varying with image content.

Development and clinical application of a telemedicine support system in the field of perinatal patient management

In recent years, perinatal patient management has been greatly improved due to the advance of medical technologies in various fields. The primary objectives of perinatal patient management are to discover signs and symptoms of fetal asphyxia and threatened premature delivery at an early stage and to initiate treatment as soon as possible. For this purpose, continuous monitoring of the fetal heart rate and uterine contractions is most effective. We developed a telemedicine support system for pregnant women and evaluated it to see if that makes it possible 1) to manage pregnant women monitored at home in the same way as those who visit hospitals on an ambulatory basis, and 2) to prevent adverse events in women in a high-risk pregnancy. The findings obtained in the present study showed that this system is useful for both purposes. Perinatal telemedicine is expected to progress significantly in the next few years, although there are a number of issues that need to be resolved in this area.

Clinical value of real-time tertiary fetal ultrasound consultation by telemedicine: preliminary evaluation

Congenital fetal abnormalities are major causes of perinatal mortality and morbidity. The performance of ultrasound in the diagnosis and assessment of fetal anomalies varies enormously between tertiary referral centers and general units. Telemedicine offers a chance for tertiary realtime ultrasound consultations using standard telephone lines for remote sites. Preliminary investigations by our group have shown that real-time transmission of fetal ultrasound images over long distances via telephone (integrated systems digital network [ISDN]) lines is technically feasible. A live link of up to 2 Mb/s was established between Mater Mothers Hospital in Brisbane and Kirwan Hospital for Women in Townsville, which are 1,500 km apart. The objective of the current study was to evaluate the clinical value of a tertiary teleultrasound consultation service. Patients requiring tertiary ultrasound consultations were recruited from North Queensland. Clinicians from the referral site established an initial diagnosis and management plan. Using standard ISDN lines, the real-time ultrasound images were transmitted to the maternal fetal medicine subspecialists in Brisbane. The ultrasound examination was completed under the direction of the subspecialist. The subspecialist explained the findings to the patient at the end of the session, and discussed the diagnosis and management plans with the clinicians involved. Any diagnosis and management variations were classified into minor and major upon agreement by the two teams of clinicians involved. The clinicians and patients in Townsville rated the value of the consultation, and the subspecialists rated the confidence of their diagnoses on five-point scales. Pregnancy outcomes were obtained and the data analyzed. Over a 3-month period, 24 teleultrasound consultations were carried out. The indications for referral were: assessment of growth restriction/fetal wellbeing in the third trimester (6); detailed assessment for high-risk patients (5); evaluation of markers for anomalies (5); isolated fetal anomalies (1); and complex fetal problems such as twin/twin transfusion, multiple anomalies, etc. (7). Overall, the consultations resulted in some modifications to the clinical diagnosis in 45.8% of the cases, and modifications to the management plan in 33.3% of the cases (about half of which were minor variations). The clinicians rated the teleconsultations highly (mean rating 4.7, SD 0.44). The patients also rated the consultations highly, and were comfortable that their privacy and confidentiality were maintained during the consultation. The subspecialists were confident in making their diagnoses by telemedicine (mean score for confidence 4.2, SD 0.43). All the pregnancies have now been completed, with all antenatal diagnoses confirmed to be correct postnatally. Tertiary real-time ultrasound consultation by telemedicine is not only technically feasible, it is welcomed by the clinicians and patients involved. It also contributes to diagnostic and management differences. Larger scale clinical trials are needed to evaluate the true benefits and costs involved. The social benefits in bridging the healthcare gap between the country and the city, and in enabling patients in remote areas to stay close to their family under times of stress is well recognized by all involved.

Evaluation of the effectiveness of portable low-bandwidth telemedical applications for postoperative followup: initial results

BACKGROUND

The idea of using telemedical applications to evaluate patients remotely is several decades old. It has already been established that x-ray images (and magnetic resonance images) can be transferred using a personal computer and a modem, and many other such applications have been implemented. Over the past 50 years the expense and technical demands of the equipment involved in telemedicine have hindered its widespread deployment. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the ability of a mobile, low-bandwidth telemedicine platform to achieve real-time postoperative visits in the home.

STUDY DESIGN

This evaluation was designed to evaluate the feasibility of performing a real-time clinical visit with computer and telecommunications hardware and software. A nurse and medical student (for information gathering only) made postoperative visits at patients' homes while the physician stayed at the office. Clinical evaluations were performed by using low-resolution and frame-rate video, high-resolution still images, and simultaneous telephony over a standard telephone line. These remote visits were followed by a standard visit in the office. Eleven patients were included, all of whom had undergone various laparoscopic procedures. They lived 5 to 240 miles from their surgeon. Efficiency was measured by recording the time required to capture and send data required by the physician to make a clinical decision. The time expense was measured at both the patients' and physician's locations. Technical issues were evaluated and patient satisfaction was assessed by standardized objective questionnaires. The accuracy of the evaluation at the remote visit was determined with a standard office visit.

RESULTS

No technical problems were observed. The mean total time of the housecall at the remote site was 86 minutes (range 60 to 160 minutes) and at the base station site was 41 minutes (range 21 to 71 minutes). After personnel became familiar with the system, the last three visits averaged 61 and 25 minutes at the two sites, respectively. This corresponds favorablywith current time requirements for visiting nurses and office visits. The patients were highly satisfied with the home visit and, on average, rated the experience as 4.8 out of a maximum of 5.

CONCLUSIONS

Followup visits in patients' homes after laparoscopic procedures can be accomplished by transmitting simultaneous voice, low-resolution video, and high-resolution still images to accurately perform postoperative evaluations over standard telephone lines, with time requirements and clinical accuracy similar to those of standard visits.

Referral patterns and the referral system for oral surgery care. Part 2: The referral system and telemedicine

OBJECTIVE

To investigate GDP opinions of the current referral system and to investigate the need and demand for telemedicine in oral surgery referrals.

DESIGN

Postal questionnaire.

SETTING

400 GDPs in Greater Manchester.

RESULTS

84% participation rate. 48% were not satisfied overall with the service of their current specialist oral surgery referral site. The principal reason was the length of the waiting time for consultation and treatment. Distance for patients to travel to the specialist unit was also of concern, even though most patients (89%) travelled short distances (return journey of twelve miles or less). 23% of respondents wished to improve their ability to communicate with the oral surgeon and 70% wanted involvement in the patient consultation. Both of these requirements were more likely in younger practitioners.

CONCLUSION

There is a need and demand for change in the referral system for oral surgery specialist care. Telemedicine could conceivably be one way to improve access to specialist oral surgery care.

Telemedicine and isolated communities: a UK perspective

There are still considerable inequalities in the provision of primary care in the UK in relation to need. Recruitment and retention of general practitioners (GPs) is a problem, although this is worse in inner-city than in rural areas. The main problem in rural areas of the UK is the accessibility of health services. GP consultation rates, hospital outpatient attendance rates and inpatient admissions all decline with distance both to the doctors' surgeries and to hospitals. There is evidence that health services can be successfully and effectively delivered to isolated communities by telemedicine, but almost all of it relates to work done outside the UK. The experience has been generally good and should certainly be taken into account when planning future physician requirements and distribution.

Use of mobile low-bandwith telemedical techniques for extreme telemedicine applications

BACKGROUND

Telemedicine is traditionally associated with the use of very expensive and bulky telecommunications equipment along with substantial bandwidth requirements (128 kilobytes per second [kbps] or greater). Telementoring is an educational technique that involves real-time guidance of a less experienced physician through a procedure in which he or she has limited experience. This technique has been especially dependent on the aforementioned requirements. Traditionally, telemedicine and telementoring have been restricted to technically sophisticated sites. The telemedicine applications through the existing telecommunication infrastructure has not been possible for underdeveloped parts of the world.

STUDY DESIGN

Telemedicine and telementoring were applied using low-bandwidth mobile telemedicine applications to support a mobile surgery program in rural Ecuador run by the Cinterandes Foundation and headed by Edgar Rodas, MD. A mobile operating room traveled to a remote region of Ecuador. Using a laptop computer equipped with telemedicine software, a videoconferencing system, and a digital camera, surgical patients were evaluated and operative decisions were made over low-bandwidth telephone lines. Similarly, surgeons in the mobile unit in Ecuador were telementored by an experienced surgeon located thousands of miles away at Yale University School of Medicine.

RESULTS

Five preoperative evaluations were conducted from Sucua to Cuenca, Ecuador, with excellent clinical correlation. Additionally, a laparoscopic cholecystectomy was successfully telementored from the department of surgery at Yale University School of Medicine to the mobile surgery unit in Ecuador. The telementored surgery was performed using a telephone line with a baud rate of 12 kbps.

CONCLUSIONS

Mobile, low-bandwidth telemedicine applications used in the proper technical and clinical algorithms can be very effective in supporting remote health care delivery efforts. Advantages of such applications include increased cost-effectiveness by limiting travel, expanding services to patients, and increased patient quality assurance.

Optimizing utilization of pediatric echocardiography and implications for telemedicine

Telemedicine can deliver tertiary level services to remote communities where subspecialty care is limited. Locally performed echocardiography has been initiated at several locations around Iowa. The goal of this study was to examine utilization and diagnostic yield of community-based echocardiographic services. Community physicians selected patients for remote echocardiograms (echoes), and studies were performed locally by sonographers trained in recording pediatric echoes. Echoes were sent to the pediatric echocardiography laboratory by mail or via telemedicine systems. Echoes were also ordered locally by pediatric cardiologists during outreach clinics in the same communities. Numbers of normal and abnormal echoes ordered by community physicions and pediatric cardiologists were compared by chi-square analysis. Since January 1996, community physicians ordered 378 echoes, whereas 154 echoes were ordered by pediatric cardiologists at outreach clinics. Stratifying echoes by patient age found that the percentage of normal studies in patients < 1 year of age was no different between groups (27% normal by community physicians vs 15%; chi-square 0.92; p = 0.34). The percentage of normal studies ordered by community physicians was significantly greater in patients > 1 year of age (83% normal by community physicians vs 25%; chi-square 80.2; p <0.0001). Thus, (1) community physicians effectively identified patients < 1 year of age with abnormal echoes, (2) significantly fewer echoes may be required in patients > 1 year of age if patients are first evaluated by a pediatric cardiologist, and (3) patient selection will impact cost effectiveness of remotely obtained echoes.

Technical dependability of obstetric ultrasound transmission via ISDN

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the dependability of a live telemedicine link for the transmission of obstetric ultrasonograms using a commercial telephone network.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We established an integrated services digital network (ISDN), consisting of three dedicated telephone lines from three satellite offices, to our central prenatal diagnostic center. All patients had a sonographic evaluation recorded on videotape by a trained sonographer. A live interactive video telemedicine link was then established, and a perinatologist directed the sonographer through the scan. A report was issued on the basis of the telemedicine examination. The number of calls required to obtain satisfactory real-time images was recorded, as were the reasons for suboptimal transmissions. The first 150 transmissions were excluded from this study. The results in the subsequent 100 patients who agreed to participate were analyzed.

RESULTS

We were able to provide obstetric interpretations in all 100 patients scheduled to be examined using the telemedicine link. A single connection was required in 85 cases, two calls in 5 cases, three calls in 8 cases, four calls in 1 case, and five calls in another case. A repeat call was required in 20 cases because of poor image transmission; other repeat calls were caused by failure to connect (5 cases), calls disconnected (2 cases), and no image transmission (2 cases).

CONCLUSIONS

The provision of telemedicine services for obstetric ultrasonography in the community is feasible, but the need for repeat connections because of technical failures needs to be incorporated into cost and time analyses in order to provide a measure of the system's efficiency.

Diagnostic accuracy with US: remote radiologists' versus on-site radiologists' interpretations

PURPOSE

To compare the diagnostic accuracy of radiologists interpreting static ultrasonographic (US) images electronically transmitted to an academic medical center (remote radiologists) with that of radiologists performing "hands-on" US at a community-based outpatient site (on-site radiologists).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

During 8 months, 80 patients underwent pelvic US at a community-based outpatient site. Images were electronically transmitted to a remote medical center as they were acquired at the community site and were printed on a laser printer identical to the one used at the outpatient site. The reference standard for correct diagnosis was based on histopathologic findings (n = 13), additional imaging results (n = 34), or review by a second independent observer (n = 33). Both an on-site and a remote radiologist interpreted the images, and their interpretations were rated as agree, both correct; agree, both incorrect; or disagree. Cases of disagreement were rated as major or minor.

RESULTS

On-site and remote radiologists agreed in 69 of 80 patients (86%), and both radiologists were correct in all of these cases. There were 10 minor discrepancies and one major discrepancy. The diagnostic accuracies of the one-site and remote radiologists were 92% and 94%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

High levels of diagnostic accuracy can be achieved by radiologists interpreting static US images. Strict protocols and excellent communication between the radiologist and sonographer are necessary to avoid diagnostic errors.

Participant satisfaction and comfort with multidisciplinary pediatric telemedicine consultations

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to measure both satisfaction and comfort levels and estimates of cost savings of families with children receiving health care services from a distant pediatric tertiary care center by readily available telecommunications technologies.

METHODS

From February 1996 to September 1997, 140 children at a site 840 miles from the tertiary care center were seen during an evaluative trial of telemedicine consultations (TMC). The TMC visit was the initial encounter with the tertiary care specialist for 31 children. After consultation, each family was asked to complete an anonymous quality management survey that asked for estimates of cost savings and assessed their level of comfort and satisfaction with 13 other aspects of the TMC encounter. A 3- or 5-point Likert scale was used for each question. Comfort scores before and after each consultation were compared by chi2 analysis. Logistic regression was used to determine the independent predictors of satisfaction.

RESULTS

104 of the 140 (74%) families responded. Mean patient estimated cost savings was $1,318+/-677. The highest level of comfort was noted by 58% of respondents before TMC and by 77% after (P = .005). On a 5-point scale, 71% scored 5 (completely satisfied). None scored less than 3. The independent statistically significant predictors of satisfaction were concerns about privacy, comfort with the camera, and perceived specialist comfort.

CONCLUSIONS

In addition to providing financial savings, TMC is well accepted by families and children. Those using this new technology must give special attention to issues of patient privacy, camera comfort, and specialist comfort.

Telemedicine in neonatology: lessons from North Queensland

Using videoconferencing technology, educational programs in neonatology were provided for staff at rural hospitals. The technology was also used to reunite babies with their families and its usefulness in long-distance diagnosis was assessed. Eighty-two educational sessions were delivered over a 9 month period and, despite problems with technology, operation and presentation, were considered worthwhile by the audiences. Family reunions were very successful. Neonatal diagnosis was impossible at the narrow bandwidth used (128 kilobits/s). Valuable lessons were learned regarding optimum use of this medium.

Three-dimensional ultrasonography in obstetrics and gynecology: preliminary experience

OBJECTIVE

Technologic advances in ultrasonographic imaging have revolutionized the management of women's health care. We recently began to evaluate the clinical applications of three-dimensional ultrasonography.

STUDY DESIGN

This study prospectively evaluated 161 obstetric and gynecologic patients. Both two- and three-dimensional imaging data were acquired from real-time ultrasonography. Three orthogonal planes were displayed on a monitor and were used to create the rendered three-dimensional images.

RESULTS

To date, 201 three-dimensional ultrasonographic studies have been performed, 165 transabdominally and 36 transvaginally. Transabdominally, an average of eight acquisitions per patient were obtained. Of the clinically suspected abnormalities, 29 of 32 (91%) were confirmed by three-dimensional imaging. Three of 32 (9%) improved the diagnostic capabilities or changed the diagnosis. Of the 36 transvaginal studies, an average of four acquisitions per patient were done. Thirty (83%) of these patients had suspected abnormalities and all were confirmed.

CONCLUSIONS

Three-dimensional ultrasonographic imaging appears to be highly promising in the clinical setting.

Transaction costs economics as a conceptual framework for the analysis of barriers to the diffusion of telemedicine

Telemedecine has been talked about for more than 20 years, without it entering daily use with any success. Based on transaction costs economics, the present analysis of the exchange relationships between health care producers highlights certain characteristics of the current technical and legislative context, which leads to transaction costs. It also demonstrates that the introduction of telemedicine shifts the costs associated with agents' opportunism from patients to health-care producers themselves. All these costs may be considered nowadays to thwart the use of telemedicine. It is argued here that the Public Authorities and professionals of health care could act upon telemedicine in two fields: (1) intervention in the institutional environment aims notably at better defining the property rights of telemedicine, and so constitutes an unavoidable means of encouraging health-care producers to invest in new technology; and (2) implementation of organisational forms and mechanisms susceptible to regulating such telemedical relationships between health care producers-given the present institutional environment-constitutes an essential means for overcoming the immediate barriers blocking the diffusion of telemedicine.

Validation of fetal telemedicine as a new obstetric imaging technique

OBJECTIVE

Our purpose was to establish whether obstetric ultrasonography interpreted by a live video telemedicine link is comparable to interpretation by videotape review in a low-risk patient population.

STUDY DESIGN

An Integrated Services Digital Network (ISDN 6) was established from three satellite offices to our central prenatal diagnostic center. Patients seen at these satellite offices had a complete fetal anatomic survey recorded onto videotape by a trained ultrasonographer. A live interactive video telemedicine link was then established to our center by the digital network, and a perinatologist directed the ultrasonographer through the anatomy survey. Subsequently a different perinatologist, blinded to the telemedicine interpretation, reviewed the videotaped examination. The reports from the videotaped and telemedicine scans were then compared on the basis of a score of 33 anatomic items.

RESULTS

The first 200 patients seen at the satellite offices were included. Telemedicine and videotape interpretations provided similar scores in 84% of scans. In 17 of the 33 anatomic categories telemedicine provided significantly better scores than videotape, whereas in the remaining 16 anatomic categories the scores were equivalent. More videotape than telemedicine examinations required repeat ultrasonography because of suboptimal imaging (10% vs 3%, p = 0.003).

CONCLUSIONS

The interpretation of obstetric ultrasonography with use of live video telemedicine is comparable to videotape review. Fetal telemedicine may prove to be a useful tool for providing ultrasonographic interpretation of fetal anatomy to a network of low-risk obstetric practices.

Telemedicine: a cautious welcome

Telemedicine is a major new development. Having become technically and economically feasible, it deserves proper investigation. Rushing into equipment purchase, however, is almost certain to prove counterproductive. Face to face contact is fundamental to health care and enthusiasts of telemedicine should recognise that it is not as good as the real thing (and unlikely ever to be). However, constraints on time and resources will make face to face consultation increasingly expensive, and telemedicine has the potential to produce major efficiencies in the diagnostic process. The goal of current research is therefore to marry medicine with technology, capitalising on the advantages of telemedicine and producing a robust system that delivers an acceptable service at an appropriate price.