A review of the clinical applications of the pattern electroretinogram

Ambient lighting alters pattern electroretinogram P50 peak time and spatial sensitivity

PURPOSE

Our aim was to explore the effect of ambient lighting on the pattern ERG (PERG).

METHODS

We compared PERGs recorded in two conditions; room lights on and room lights off. PERGs from 21 adult participants were recorded from each eye to high contrast checks of 50' side width, reversing 3rps in a large (30°) and then standard (15°) field. This was performed first in lights-ON conditions, then 2 min after the room lights were switched off. A minimum of 2 averages of 300 trials were acquired for each condition. A subset of 10 participants had PERGs recorded to a 50' check width with a range of stimulus contrasts (96-18%), also to a range of different check widths (100'-12') at high contrast in both ambient lighting conditions in a 30° field.

RESULTS

The lights-ON P50 median peak time (PT) was 3 ms earlier than the lights-OFF P50 from the 30° field (range 0-5 ms) and 15° field (range 0-6 ms). The earlier lights-ON P50 PT was evident at different stimulus contrasts, even after accounting for stimulus contrast reductions associated with stray ambient lighting in lights-ON conditions. Lights-OFF and lights-ON P50 PT were similar to different check widths; the lights-OFF P50 PT to a 50' check width matched the lights-ON P50 PT to a 25' check width.

CONCLUSION

PERG P50 PT in lights-ON ambient light conditions can be earlier than in lights-OFF ambient light conditions. The difference in P50 PT with ambient light may reflect alterations in spatial sensitivity associated with retinal adaptation. These results emphasise the clinical importance of consistent ambient lighting for PERG recording and calibration.

Repeatability and reciprocity of the cone optoretinogram

Optoretinography has enabled noninvasive visualization of physiological changes in cone photoreceptors exposed to light. Understanding the cone optoretinogram in healthy subjects is essential for establishing it as a biomarker for cone function in disease. Here, we measure the population cone intensity optoretinogram in healthy adults, for multiple irradiance/duration combinations of visible stimuli with equal energy. We study the within and between session repeatability and reciprocity of the ORG in five healthy subjects. We find the cone optoretinogram exhibits equivalent amplitudes for equal-energy stimuli. We also find good within-subject repeatability, which allows us to show differences across the five subjects.

Electroretinogram responses in myopia: a review

The stretching of a myopic eye is associated with several structural and functional changes in the retina and posterior segment of the eye. Recent research highlights the role of retinal signaling in ocular growth. Evidence from studies conducted on animal models and humans suggests that visual mechanisms regulating refractive development are primarily localized at the retina and that the visual signals from the retinal periphery are also critical for visually guided eye growth. Therefore, it is important to study the structural and functional changes in the retina in relation to refractive errors. This review will specifically focus on electroretinogram (ERG) changes in myopia and their implications in understanding the nature of retinal functioning in myopic eyes. Based on the available literature, we will discuss the fundamentals of retinal neurophysiology in the regulation of vision-dependent ocular growth, findings from various studies that investigated global and localized retinal functions in myopia using various types of ERGs.

Toward a clinical optoretinogram: a review of noninvasive, optical tests of retinal neural function

The past few years have witnessed rapid development of the optoretinogram—a noninvasive, optical measurement of neural function in the retina, and especially the photoreceptors (Ph). While its recent development has been rapid, it represents the culmination of hundreds of experiments spanning decades. Early work showed measurable and reproducible changes in the optical properties of retinal explants and suspensions of Ph, and uncovered some of the biophysical and biochemical mechanisms underlying them. That work thus provided critical motivation for more recent work based on clinical imaging platforms, whose eventual goal is the improvement of ophthalmic care and streamlining the discovery of novel therapeutics. The first part of this review consists of a selective summary of the early work, and identifies four kinds of stimulus-evoked optical signals that have emerged from it: changes in light scattered from the membranous discs of the Ph’s outer segment (OS), changes in light scattered by the front and back boundaries of the OS, rearrangement of scattering material in and near the OS, and changes in the OS length. In the past decade, all four of these signals have continued to be investigated using imaging systems already used in the clinic or intended for clinical and translational use. The second part of this review discusses these imaging modalities, their potential to detect and quantify the signals of interest, and other factors influencing their translational promise. Particular attention is paid to phase-sensitive optical coherence tomography (OCT) with adaptive optics (AO), a method in which both the amplitude and the phase of light reflected from individual Ph is monitored as visible stimuli are delivered to them. The record of the light’s phase is decoded to reveal a reproducible pattern of deformation in the OS, while the amplitude reveals changes in scattering and structural rearrangements. The method has been demonstrated in a few labs and has been used to measure responses from both rods and cones. With the ability to detect responses to stimuli isomerizing less than 0.01% of photopigment, this technique may prove to be a quick, noninvasive, and objective way to measure subtle disease-related dysfunction at the cellular level, and thus to provide an entirely new and complementary biomarker for retinal disease and recovery.

Retinal ganglion cells dysfunctions in schizophrenia patients with or without visual hallucinations

The electroretinogram has revealed photoreceptor, bipolar cell, and, in one prior study, retinal ganglion cell (RGC) dysfunction in schizophrenia. The structural abnormalities of the RGC are well documented in schizophrenia and such abnormalities have been associated with visual hallucinations (VH) in neurological disorders. The goals of this study were: 1) to examine the functional responses of photoreceptors and RGC in schizophrenia patients in comparison with healthy controls; and 2) to compare the extent of retinal dysfunction in schizophrenia patients with or without VH. We recorded the flash electroretinogram in scotopic and photopic conditions, and the pattern electroretinogram, in schizophrenia patients (n = 29) and healthy controls (n = 29). Schizophrenia patients were divided in two groups: schizophrenia patients with VH (VH group, n = 12) and schizophrenia patients with auditory hallucinations or no hallucinations (AHNH group, n = 17). Our results replicate previous findings regarding photoreceptor dysfunction in schizophrenia. PERG results showed a significant increase of the P50 implicit time in schizophrenia patients compared with controls (t(55) = 2.1, p < .05, d = 0.55) and a significant increase of the N95 implicit time in schizophrenia patients compared with controls (t(55) = 4.2; p < .001, d = 0.66). We found an increased rod b-wave implicit time (dark-adapted 0.01 ERG) in the VH group compared to the AHNH group and to the control group, which was associated with lifetime VH score. Our results demonstrate a slowing of RGC signaling in schizophrenia patients, which could affect the quality of visual information reaching the visual cortex. The implications of the data for understanding VH in schizophrenia are discussed.

Looking into the brain through the retinal ganglion cells in psychiatric disorders: A review of evidences

Psychiatry and neuroscience research need novel approaches to indirectly investigate brain function. As the retina is an anatomical and developmental extension of the central nervous system (CNS), changes in retinal function may reflect neurological dysfunctions in psychiatric disorders. The last and most integrated retinal relay before visual information transfer to the brain is the ganglion cell layer. Here, based on collected arguments, we argue that these cells offer a crucial site for indirectly investigating brain function. We describe the anatomical and physiological properties of these cells together with measurements of their functional properties named pattern electroretinogram (PERG). Based on ganglion cell dysfunctions measured with PERG in neurological disorders, we argue for the relevance of studying ganglion cell function in psychiatric research. We review studies that have evaluated ganglion cell function in psychiatric and addictive disorders and discuss how changes in PERG measurements could be functional markers of pathophysiological mechanisms of psychiatric disorders.

Characterization of structure and function of the mouse retina using pattern electroretinography, pupil light reflex, and optical coherence tomography

OBJECTIVE

To perform in vivo analysis of retinal functional and structural parameters in healthy mouse eyes.

ANIMAL STUDIED

Adult C57BL/6 male mice (n = 37).

PROCEDURES

Retinal function was evaluated using pattern electroretinography (pERG) and the chromatic pupil light reflex (cPLR). Structural properties of the retina and nerve fiber layer (NFL) were evaluated using spectral-domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT).

RESULTS

The average pERG amplitudes were found to be 11.2 ± 0.7 μV (P50-N95, mean ± SEM), with an implicit time for P50-N95 interval of 90.4 ± 5.4 ms. Total retinal thickness was 229.5 ± 1.7 μm (mean ± SEM) in the area centralis region. The thickness of the retinal nerve fiber layer (mean ± SEM) using a circular peripapillary retinal scan centered on the optic nerve was 46.7 ± 0.9 μm (temporal), 46.1 ± 0.9 μm (superior), 45.8 ± 0.9 μm (nasal), and 48.4 ± 1 μm (inferior). The baseline pupil diameter was 2.1 ± 0.05 mm in darkness, and 1.1 ± 0.05 and 0.56 ± 0.03 mm after stimulation with red (630 nm, luminance 200 kcd/m(2)) or blue (480 nm, luminance 200 kcd/m(2)) light illumination, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Pattern electroretinography, cPLR and SD-OCT analysis are reproducible techniques, which can provide important information about retinal and optic nerve function and structure in mice.

Studies of human visual pathophysiology with visual evoked potentials

Visual evoked potentials (VEPs) offer reproducible and quantitative data on the function of the visual pathways and the visual cortex. Pattern reversal VEPs to full-field stimulation are best suited to evaluate anterior visual pathways while hemi-field stimulation is most effective in the assessment of post-chiasmal function. However, visual information is processed simultaneously via multiple parallel channels and each channel constitutes a set of sequential processes. We outline the major parallel pathways of the visual system from the retina to the primary visual cortex and higher visual areas via lateral geniculate nucleus that receive visual input. There is no best method of stimulus selection, rather visual stimuli and VEPs' recording should be tailored to answer specific clinical and/or research questions. Newly developed techniques that can assess the functions of extrastriate as well as striate cortices are discussed. Finally, an algorithm of sequential steps to evaluate the various levels of visual processing is proposed and its clinical use revisited.

Center-surround antagonism in spatial vision: Retinal or cortical locus?

Mach and Hering had early advanced a model of spatial visual processing featuring an antagonistic interaction between adjoining areas in the visual field. Spatial opponency was one of the first findings when single-unit studies of the retina were begun. Not long afterwards psychophysical experiments revealed a center-surround organization closely matching that found in the mammalian retina. It hinged on the demonstration of reduction of sensitivity in a small patch of the visual field when its surround was changed from dark to bright. Because such patterns inevitably produce borders, well-known phenomena of border interaction could be seen as providing alternative explanations, whose substrate would most likely be in the visual cortex. These competing viewpoints are discussed especially as they pertain to the recent demonstration of spatial differences in the center/surround organization between the normal and affected eyes of amblyopes. To the extent that most findings favor a retinal site for the psychophysically measured antagonism, and that evidence is accumulating for a direct effect on the mammalian retina of stimulus manipulation during visual development, the difference in spatial parameters of center/surround antagonism in amblyopia suggests that the dysfunction in amblyopia begins already in the retina.

The optic nerve head component of the human ERG

The local responses of the multifocal ERG reveal continuous changes in the second order waveforms from the nasal to the temporal retina. Scrutiny of these changes suggests the presence of an additive component whose latency increases with the distance of the stimulus from the optic nerve head. This observation led to the hypothesis of a contributing source in the vicinity of the optic nerve head whose signal is delayed in proportion to the fiber length from the stimulated retinal patch to the nerve head. The hypothesis was tested with two independent methods. In Method 1, a set of different local response waveforms was approximated by two fixed components whose relative latency was allowed to vary and the fit of this two component model was evaluated. In Method 2, two signals were derived simultaneously using different placements for the reference electrode. The placements were selected to produce a different ratio of the signal contributions from the retina and the nerve head in the two recording channels. The signals were then combined at a ratio that canceled the retinal component. Method 1 yielded an excellent fit of the two component model. Waveforms and latencies of the hypothetical optic nerve head component derived from the two methods agree well with each other. The local latencies also agree with the propagation delays measured in the nerve fiber layer of the monkey retina. In combination, these findings provide strong evidence for a signal source near the optic nerve head.

Comparisons of contact lens, foil, fiber and skin electrodes for patterns electroretinograms

Pattern electroretinograms are small physiologic signals that require good patient cooperation and long recording times, particularly when conditions are not optimal. Six electrodes were compared to evaluate their efficacy. Pattern electroretinograms were recorded in eight healthy volunteers to high-contrast, pattern-reversal checks (40' width) with Burian-Allen, DTL fiber, C-glide, gold foil, HK loop and skin electrodes. Raw data for 320 reversals were analyzed off-line to evaluate signal amplitude, quality, P50 and N95 peak times, artifact rate and electrical noise. Insertion time, impedance and subjective comfort were also assessed. The Burian-Allen contact lens electrode gave the largest signal and lowest impedance but was the least comfortable and had the highest artifact rate (p < 0.01). A skin electrode on the lower eyelid produced the smallest pattern electroretinogram with the poorest quality (p < 0.05). The four other electrodes were foil or fiber electrodes in contact with the tear film, conjunctiva and/or the inferior cornea. The signal from these showed only minor differences. When electrodes are compared for pattern electroretinograms recording, the foil and fiber electrodes do not differ substantially but contact lens and skin electrodes show substantial disadvantages.

Electrical responses from diabetic retina

Diabetic retinopathy has long been considered to be a retinal manifestation of systemic diabetic angiopathy. Indeed, it is therapeutically true. However, the prolongation of OP peak latency in diabetic eyes without any angiographic evidence of angiopathy leads us to presume that certain neuronal disorders occur early in diabetic eyes. Even though we cannot neglect the possibility that the prolongation of the OP peak latency may derive from undetectable retinal hypoperfusion, it is still far from conventional diabetic angiopathy. Rather, the status should be properly termed "intraretinal diabetic neuropathy" in that the neurones are the disturbed cells to cause visual dysfunction. Thereafter, the OP amplitude diminishes as retinopathy advances, probably depending on the degree of retinal circulatory disturbance. Marked diminution of the OP amplitude predicts rapid progression and poor prognosis of retinopathy. Diabetic retinal pigment epitheliopathy as manifested by one of our non-photic EOG responses is another kind of early ocular involvement of diabetes. Because its mechanisms are not yet known, so far we have not succeeded in correlating it to any kind of subjective visual index. Routine fundus inspection or fluorescent fundus angiography is incapable of detecting the compromised neural retina and/or retinal pigment epithelial integrity and thus the electrophysiology of vision has the edge in ophthalmology.

Prognostic value of pattern reversal visual-evoked potentials in idiopathic epiretinal membrane

BACKGROUND

Prognostically favorable factors for epiretinal membrane removal have been described in the literature by several authors. Little information, however, is available about the objective assessment of the preoperative macular function. This study reports the results of idiopathic epiretinal membrane removal and the prognostic value of preoperative, pattern reversal visual-evoked potentials (PRVEPS) in recovery of visual acuity (VA).

METHODS

In 60 patients (60 eyes) with idiopathic epiretinal membrane we performed PRVEP examination preoperatively. All eyes were operated on by standard three-port vitrectomy with membrane removal. Two eyes were excluded because of postoperative complications. Follow-up VA was compared with preoperative VA for the 58 study eyes and correlated with preoperative PRVEP parameters.

RESULTS

The mean preoperative VA was 0.2, the mean postoperative VA, 0.4. The PRVEP was recordable in 74%, 67% and 36% of cases for check sizes of 17, 10 and 7 arcmin respectively. Twenty patients (50%) had an increase in VA of two lines or more, in 25 patients (43%) VA remained within one line of the preoperative value, and in 4 patients (7%) VA decreased by two lines or more. The mean preoperative VA was not significantly different between the group with an improved VA and the group that did not benefit from membrane removal. Of the PRVEP parameters, only the N80 latency for the 17' check size was significantly associated with postoperative visual outcome.

CONCLUSION

The PRVEP is applicable as a predictor for visual outcome in cases of epiretinal membrane removal. For the 17' pattern size we found a significant association of the combination of recordability and delayed N80 latency with visual outcome.

Pattern reversal visual evoked potentials in eyes with macular holes and their fellow eyes

PURPOSE

To investigate whether the pattern reversal visual evoked potential can be useful in the diagnosis and management of macular hole patients.

METHODS

The pattern reversal visual evoked potential was measured in 66 patients with a macular hole and in 43 healthy control subjects. Check sizes of 34', 17' and 10' were applied.

RESULTS

Results showed that, for the check sizes of 34', 17' and 10', eyes with a macular hole had significantly prolonged N80 and P100 latencies and a significantly reduced P100 amplitude as compared to their fellow eyes. Furthermore, for the 10' check size, the fellow eyes appeared to have a significantly reduced P100 amplitude in comparison with the control eyes, whereas N80 and P100 latencies of the fellow eyes of the macular hole patients were not prolonged.

CONCLUSION

Significant pattern reversal visual evoked potential alterations were shown in eyes with macular holes and fellow eyes for small check sizes.