Vasovagal syncope: diagnostic role of head-up tilt test in patients with positive ocular compression test

Usefulness of ocular compression during electroencephalography in distinguishing breath-holding spells and syncope from epileptic seizures

Episodes of syncope or breath-holding spells are often misdiagnosed as epileptic events. The purpose of this study was to assess the usefulness of an electroencephalogram (EEG) with ocular compression to distinguish breath-holding spells and syncope from epileptic seizures. A retrospective analysis was performed on the EEG records of all children on whom ocular compression was performed from 2000 to 2003. Data from 116 patients with a clinical diagnosis consistent with either syncope or breath-holding spells were compared with a group of 46 patients with epilepsy. The RR interval during ocular compression was significantly higher in syncope patients compared with patients with epilepsy (P < .005). Using 2 seconds of asystole as the cutoff, the sensitivity of ocular compression was 26%, with 100% specificity. The change in RR interval from baseline to ocular compression also distinguished patients with breath-holding spells and syncope from patients with epilepsy. Even a small increase of 0.5 seconds in the RR interval demonstrated a sensitivity of 46%, with a specificity of 98%. Ocular compression performed during an EEG is useful in distinguishing patients with breath-holding spells and syncope from those with epileptic seizures. A requirement of a 2-second period of asystole with ocular compression excludes many patients. Our data indicate that an RR interval increase of 0.5 seconds over baseline identifies additional patients with increased vagal tone. Prompt and accurate diagnosis of the etiology of loss of consciousness might preclude the need for further extensive and expensive evaluation and reduce patient and parental distress.

Ocular Compression Maneuver Aborts Benign Cough‐Induced Headache

Benign cough-induced headache is a short-lasting cranial discomfort. The therapeutic role of lumbar puncture (LP) or indomethacin in benign patients with benign cough-induced headache patients is debatable. Transient ocular compression (OC) raises intraocular pressure (IOP) and can limit the impact of cough-induced choroidal venous congestion. A self-applied maneuver that instantaneously aborts cough-induced headache is described in two patients. The effect of this maneuver supports a recent hypothesis that cough-induced headache may be due to ocular choroidal venous congestion and mechanical antidromic trigeminal nerve activation. The OC maneuver has several potential complications and its self-application in benign cough-induced headache should be regarded as an experimental procedure until more data regarding its efficacy and safety become available.

Randomized double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of oral atenolol in patients with unexplained syncope and positive upright tilt table test results

The objective of this investigation was the assessment of the response rate of oral atenolol in patients with vasovagal syncope after 1 month of treatment. We randomized into two groups all patients referred to our unit who had had at least one episode of syncope or two episodes of presyncope 1 month before presentation and had a positive isuprel Tilt Table Test (TTT). Group 1 (Gr 1) received oral atenolol, and group 2 (Gr 2) received placebo medication. After a 1-month period patients were reassessed for degree of their symptoms and underwent repeated TTT. Forty-two patients were enrolled in the study. Gr 1 and Gr 2 were comparable in age (38 +/- 13 years vs 43 +/- 14 years, p = 0.216 and sex (male/female = 6:15 vs 10:11, p = 0.204). The severity of attack was similar in both groups. Eight patients in Gr 1 and six patients in Gr 2 had mitral valve prolapse (p = 0.5). No significant differences were seen in systolic blood pressure (122 +/- 17 vs 117 +/- 16 mmHg, p = 0.334), diastolic blood pressure (70 +/- 11 vs 72 +/- 11 mm Hg, p = 0.677), and heart rate (79 +/- 12 vs 79 +/- 13, p = 0.98) between the two groups. The response rates (negative TTT) after 1 month of treatment were 62% versus 5% (p = 0.0004) in the atenolol and control group, respectively. Moreover, patients who received atenolol reported feeling better compared with those who received placebo (71% vs 29%, p = 0.02). In conclusion, atenolol significantly improved symptoms of patients with vasovagal syncope.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Upright tilt testing in evaluating syncope: a comprehensive literature review

BACKGROUND

Upright tilt testing is widely utilized for the evaluation of syncope. Recently, there have been concerns about the specificity and the lack of standard methodology for this test. The purpose of this study was to summarize the methodologies of upright tilt testing in patients with syncope of unknown origin, the responses in control subjects, and the reproducibility and selection of therapy.

METHODS

We used MEDLINE to search English language articles from 1966 to June 30, 1992. Studies were included for content review if they met our inclusion criteria. Data were extracted from each article by two trained reviewers using a predesigned data collection instrument.

RESULTS

Thirty-three articles were included for review. There was considerable variability in the methodologies of tilt testing. Overall positive responses were reported in 49% of patients in passive-only studies as compared with 66% of patients in studies using isoproterenol with tilt testing. The percentage of positive responses increased with increasing angle of testing for studies using isoproterenol. There was no relationship between the percentage of positive responses and the maximum dose of isoproterenol. When we compared the results of passive studies that tested patients for 60 minutes at 60 degrees with the results of isoproterenol studies that tested patients at 60 degrees, the positive rate for passive-only studies was 54% as compared with 52% for the isoproterenol studies. The percentage of positive response in control subjects with passive studies was 8.9% (range 0% to 100%), and with isoproterenol 27% (range 0% to 65%). Other groups of patients showed a wide range of positive responses (range 0% to 83%). Reproducibility ranged from 71% to 87%. Upon retesting while the patient was receiving therapy, 90% of 115 positive patients were negative. Eighty-nine percent of 105 positive patients who were receiving therapy and followed for a mean time of 12 months were free of syncope.

CONCLUSIONS

This review strongly suggests that isoproterenol may not have an effect on stimulating vasovagal syncope during upright tilt testing. We recommend protocols of passive tilt testing procedures at 60 degrees for 45 to 60 minutes since the overall specificity is higher with this method. The use of isoproterenol during tilt testing adds to the cost and complexity of the test, is associated with a higher rate of false-positive responses, leads to potential complications, and, thus, should be avoided.

The role of pacing for the management of neurally mediated syncope: carotid sinus syndrome and vasovagal syncope

The role of permanent cardiac pacing for the management of neurocardiogenic syncope is controversial; however, it does have a secondary role in appropriately selected individuals. Neurocardiogenic syncope includes vaso-vagal and enhanced antagonism of sympathetic-parasympathetic mechanisms. Differentiation of the so-called cardiac inhibitory, vasodepressor, and mixed forms of these disorders is frequently misleading when establishment of effective treatment strategies is attempted. Cardiac pacing can artificially restore near-normal heart rate and atrioventricular synchrony during a neurocardiogenic syncopal episode; however, cardiac pacing does not alter the peripheral vasodilatation, nor does it prevent the occurrence of the reflux response. Syncopal patients with carotid sinus hypersensitivity or vasovagal responses that include marked bradycardia and loss of atrioventricular synchrony can be supported by dual-chamber cardiac pacing in combination with other therapeutic interventions that diminish the severity of the reflex response. The conditions of patients with carotid sinus syndrome and carotid sinus hypersensitivity are frequently improved with cardiac pacing, and the conditions of elderly patients with vasovagal syncope are commonly improved with artificial pacing. The classic younger patient with malignant vasovagal syncope derives less benefit from artificial pacing; however, in carefully selected persons dual-chamber pacing combined with drug therapy and education decreases syncopal episodes and permits a return to normal activities.

Nitroglycerin infusion during upright tilt: a new test for the diagnosis of vasovagal syncope

The aim of our present study was to assess the value of nitroglycerin infusion during upright posture as a new provocative test for diagnosis of vasovagal syncope. To this purpose 40 patients with unexplained syncope (17 men and 23 women, mean age 47 years) and 25 asymptomatic control subjects with negative baseline head-up tilt underwent two other tilting tests, one during nitroglycerin infusion and one during isoproterenol infusion. The protocol of the nitroglycerin test consisted of a maximum of five successive stages of 5 minutes in the supine position plus 10 minutes 80-degree upright tilt at progressively increasing infusion rates (increments of 0.86 microgram/kg/hr every stage). During the nitroglycerin test a positive response (syncope in association with sudden hypotension and bradycardia) occurred in 21 (53%) patients with unexplained syncope, an exaggerated response (minor symptoms in association with slowly increasing hypotension alone) occurred in 10 (25%), a negative response in 9 (22%), and drug intolerance in 0. During the isoproterenol test these percentages were 25%, 25%, 32%, and 18%, respectively. Only 2 (8%) control subjects had a positive response to nitroglycerin test and 2 (8%) to isoproterenol test. Thus the nitroglycerin test seems to be a useful alternative tool for diagnosis of vasovagal syncope; it is equally specific but more sensitive and feasible than the isoproterenol test.

Head-upright tilt table testing for recurrent, unexplained syncope

Recurrent episodes of unexplained syncope are a common and often frustrating problem for the practicing physician. Although vasovagally mediated episodes of hypotension and bradycardia have been felt to be a common cause of these idiopathic events, traditionally this was a diagnosis of exclusion. Recently, head-upright tilt table testing has emerged as a method both for confirming the diagnosis of vasovagal syncope and for better understanding the mechanisms by which these events occur. This paper reviews current understanding of the pathophysiology of vasovagal syncope, the development and role of head-upright tilt table testing in its evaluation, and potential therapeutic modalities that can be helpful for the prevention of recurrent episodes.

Head-upright tilt table testing in evaluation of recurrent, unexplained syncope

Recurrent syncope is one of the most common problems referred to the pediatric neurologist for evaluation. Traditional evaluations are time consuming and expensive, and leave 40% of patients without a precise diagnosis. Vasovagal syncope has been believed to be a common cause of syncope; however, no reliable diagnostic modality has been available to confirm this theory. Head-upright tilt table testing has recently emerged as a useful tool in the evaluation and management of recurrent, unexplained syncope. In this review, we present the pathophysiologic mechanisms of vasovagal syncope and relate them to the reflexes triggered during head-upright tilt table testing. Additionally, we review the clinical data on the uses of this test in unexplained syncope, suggest a practical testing protocol, and elaborate potential therapeutic modalities that can be employed to prevent further episodes. Head-upright tilt table testing will likely become a standard test employed by both adult and child neurologists.

Recurrent unexplained syncope in the elderly: the use of head-upright tilt table testing in evaluation and management

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the usefulness of head-upright tilt table testing for vasovagal episodes in the evaluation and management of elderly patients with recurrent idiopathic syncope.

DESIGN

Prospective survey.

SETTING

Electrophysiology laboratory of a university hospital.

PATIENTS

Twenty-five patients (11 male, 14 female; mean age 73 +/- 6 years) with recurrent unexplained syncope and seven control subjects with other causes of syncope (4 male, 3 female; mean age 70 +/- 4 years).

METHODS

Each patient underwent head-upright tilt table testing for 30 minutes with or without an infusion of isoproterenol (1-3 micrograms/min given intravenously) in an attempt to provoke bradycardia, hypotension, or both.

MAIN RESULTS

Syncope occurred in nine patients (36%) during the baseline tilt and in seven patients (28%) during isoproterenol infusion (total positives 64%). None of the controls had syncope during the test. All of the patients who had positive test results eventually became tilt table negative with therapy, and over a mean follow-up period of 24 months, no further syncopal episodes have occurred.

CONCLUSIONS

Head-upright tilt table testing combined with isoproterenol infusion may be a useful tool in the diagnosis of vasovagal syncope in the elderly and in the evaluation of preventive therapy.

Time-frequency dynamics in neurally mediated syncope

In this study, the responses during syncope were determined by noninvasive beat-to-beat analysis during passive orthostasis. Twenty patients with recurrent unexplained syncope (13 men and seven women) and ten healthy aged-matched control subjects were studied during 80 degrees head-up tilt for 25 min. Time-frequency mapping of R-R intervals, systolic and diastolic pressures and respiration was used to determine the responses to tilt. The spectral estimation was based on a modified Wigner distribution and the frequency content was evaluated on a beat-to-beat basis. Ten patients developed syncope (tilt-positive group) during tilt, while the remaining ten were asymptomatic (tilt-negative group). Control subjects reacted to tilt by the immediate shortening of R-R intervals to a plateau with an accompanying moderate increase in diastolic pressure. In the tilt-negative group the responses to tilt were similar, but of greater amplitude. In contrast, in the tilt-positive group, R-R intervals gradually and continuously decreased with tilt while systolic and diastolic pressures increased until shortly before syncope, when an abrupt fall in blood pressure followed by R-R intervals lengthening occurred. Furthermore, the R-R intervals fluctuations at both respiratory and nonrespiratory frequencies were the highest at rest as well as during tilt in the tilt-positive group. Nonrespiratory fluctuations in blood pressure increased more during tilt in both tilt-positive and negative groups compared to the control group. The nonrespiratory fluctuations in R-R intervals and blood pressure reached a maximum at syncope, simultaneously with hypotension and bradycardia. Time-frequency mapping has demonstrated that an elevated parasympathetic tone at rest which persists during orthostasis identifies patients prone to vasodepressor syncope. The counteracting sympathetic activation is not sustained and results in hypotension followed by cardioinhibition and loss of consciousness.

Carotid sinus massage, eyeball compression, and head-up tilt test in patients with syncope of uncertain origin and in healthy control subjects

To verify the role of abnormal neural mechanisms in unexplained syncopes, we evaluated the results of carotid sinus massage (CSM), eyeball compression (EBC), and head-up tilt test (HUT) in the basal state (B) and during isoproterenol infusion (ISO) in: (1) 100 consecutive patients affected by syncope which, despite careful cardiovascular and neurologic examination, was of uncertain origin (age 60 +/- 18 years; 54 men) and (2) 25 healthy subjects matched 4:1 with the patients of the previous group. All the patients underwent CSM and EBC in the supine and standing position for 10 seconds and HUT at 60 degrees for 60 minutes; if HUT-B was negative (68 cases), it was repeated during ISO (1 to 5 micrograms/min) infusion. In the patients with uncertain syncope, spontaneous symptoms were fully reproduced in 49%, 16%, 32%, and 16% of cases respectively by means of CSM, EBC, HUT, and HUT-ISO; overall positivity for at least one test was observed in 79% of cases. The results of CSM, EBC, or HUT-ISO were linked to age, sex, and underlying heart disease. In the healthy subjects, syncope was induced by CSM, EBC, HUT, and HUT-ISO in one case each; overall positivity was 16%. In conclusion, neural reflex induction tests reproduced spontaneous symptoms in most patients affected by uncertain syncope, while they evoked normal responses in most healthy subjects. Therefore on the basis of results of induction tests, the diagnosis of neurally mediated syncope can be ascribed to most patients affected by syncope of uncertain origin.