Ciliate Research. From Myth to Trendsetting Science

This special issue of the Journal of Eukaryotic Microbiology (JEM) summarizes achievements obtained by generations of researchers with ciliates in widely different disciplines. In fact, ciliates range among the first cells seen under the microscope centuries ago. Their beauty made them an object of scientia amabilis and their manifold reactions made them attractive for college experiments and finally challenged causal analyses at the cellular level. Some of this work was honored by a Nobel Prize. Some observations yielded a baseline for additional novel discoveries, occasionally facilitated by specific properties of some ciliates. This also offers some advantage in the exploration of closely related parasites (malaria). Articles contributed here by colleagues from all over the world encompass a broad spectrum of ciliate life, from genetics to evolution, from molecular cell biology to ecology, from intercellular signaling to epigenetics etc. This introductory chapter, largely based on my personal perception, aims at integrating work presented in this special issue of JEM into a broader historical context up to current research.

Amitotic division of the macronucleus in Tetrahymena thermophila: DNA distribution by genomic unit

The macronucleus of the ciliate Tetrahymena cell contains euchromatin and numerous heterochromatins called chromatin bodies. During cell division, a chromatin aggregate larger than chromatin body appears in the macronucleus. We observed chromatin aggregates in the dividing macronucleus in a living T. thermophila cell, and found that these were globular in morphology and homogeneous in size. To observe globular chromatin clearly, optimal conditions for making it compact were studied. Addition of Mg ion, benomyl and oryzalin, microtubule inhibitors, to cell suspension was effective. Globular chromatin appeared when the micronuclear anaphase began at the cell cortex, and disappeared long after cell separation. Using living cells with a small macronucleus at early log phase, we counted the number of globular chromatin per nucleus and measured the DNA content of globular chromatin in the macronucleus which was stained with Hoechst 33342 by using ImageJ. The number of globular chromatin per nucleus was reduced by half after division, indicating the globular chromatin is a distribution unit of DNA. A globular chromatin contained similar DNA content as that of the macronuclear genome. We developed methods for inducing and isolating a cell with an extremely small macronucleus with a DNA amount of one globular chromatin. These cells grew, divided, and give clones, suggesting that the macronuclear genome is not dispersed within the macronucleus and the globular chromatin may be a macronuclear genome. We named this globular chromatin "macronuclear genome unit" (MGU).

The conjugation-specific Die5 protein is required for development of the somatic nucleus in both Paramecium and Tetrahymena

Development in ciliated protozoa involves extensive genome reorganization within differentiating macronuclei, which shapes the somatic genome of the next vegetative generation. Major events of macronuclear differentiation include excision of internal eliminated sequences (IESs), chromosome fragmentation, and genome amplification. Proteins required for these events include those with homology throughout eukaryotes as well as proteins apparently unique to ciliates. In this study, we identified the ciliate-specific Defective in IES Excision 5 (DIE5) genes of Paramecium tetraurelia (PtDIE5) and Tetrahymena thermophila (TtDIE5) as orthologs that encode nuclear proteins expressed exclusively during development. Abrogation of PtDie5 protein (PtDie5p) function by RNA interference (RNAi)-mediated silencing or TtDie5p by gene disruption resulted in the failure of developing macronuclei to differentiate into new somatic nuclei. Tetrahymena DeltaDIE5 cells arrested late in development and failed to complete genome amplification, whereas RNAi-treated Paramecium cells highly amplified new macronuclear DNA before the failure in differentiation, findings that highlight clear differences in the biology of these distantly related species. Nevertheless, IES excision and chromosome fragmentation failed to occur in either ciliate, which strongly supports that Die5p is a critical player in these processes. In Tetrahymena, loss of zygotic expression during development was sufficient to block nuclear differentiation. This observation, together with the finding that knockdown of Die5p in Paramecium still allows genome amplification, indicates that this protein acts late in macronuclear development. Even though DNA rearrangements in these two ciliates look to be quite distinct, analysis of DIE5 establishes the action of a conserved mechanism within the genome reorganization pathway.

Morphological apoptotic characteristics of the post-meiotic micronuclei in Paramecium caudatum

In a previous study, the apoptotic degeneration of meiotic products outside the paroral region of Paramecium caudatum was indirectly demonstrated by means of "apofluor" staining. In this experiment, conjugating pairs and exconjugants of P. caudatum were stained with either "apofluor" or carbol fuchsin or both to find some direct evidence to demonstrate the apoptotic characteristics of this process. As a result, asynchronous meiotic nuclear degeneration was observed. Furthermore, a number of additional meiotic nuclei were found. Disintegrating/dividing meiotic nuclei outside the paroral region were observed, which might be the origin of these additional meiotic nuclei. Condensed chromatin and disintegrated chromatin attached to the nuclear membrane were also observed in degenerating nuclei, which are the typical morphological characteristics of apoptosis. Comparison of the cells stained by the above two methods indicated that "apofluor"-stained meiotic nuclei could not be detected by carbol fuchsin in some cells, which suggests a time lag between meiotic nuclear DNA degradation and their eventual disappearance. In this study, some direct evidence was found to show that the meiotic nuclear degeneration in P. caudatum is of apoptotic nature, which further confirmed our previous study (Yang et al. 2007) and indicated that morphological apoptotic characteristics discovered in multicellular organisms do exist in unicellular eukaryotic ciliate protozoa.

The Tetrahymena thermophila phagosome proteome

In vertebrates, phagocytosis occurs mainly in specialized cells of the immune system and serves as a primary defense against invading pathogens, but it also plays a role in clearing apoptotic cells and in tissue remodeling during development. In contrast, unicellular eukaryotes, such as the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila, employ phagocytosis to ingest and degrade other microorganisms to meet their nutritional needs. To learn more about the protein components of the multistep process of phagocytosis, we carried out an analysis of the Tetrahymena phagosome proteome. Tetrahymena cells were fed polystyrene beads, which allowed for the efficient purification of phagosomes. The protein composition of purified phagosomes was then analyzed by multidimensional separation coupled with tandem mass spectrometry. A total of 453 peptides were identified that resulted in the identification of 73 putative phagosome proteins. Twenty-eight of the proteins have been implicated in phagocytosis in other organisms, indicating that key aspects of phagocytosis were conserved during evolution. Other identified proteins have not previously been associated with phagocytosis, including some of unknown function. Live-cell confocal fluorescence imaging of Tetrahymena strains expressing green fluorescent protein-tagged versions of four of the identified phagosome proteins provided evidence that at least three of the proteins (including two with unknown functions) are associated with phagosomes, indicating that the bulk of the proteins identified in the analyses are indeed phagosome associated.

The SUMO pathway is developmentally regulated and required for programmed DNA elimination in Paramecium tetraurelia

Extensive genome-wide remodeling occurs during the formation of the somatic macronuclei from the germ line micronuclei in ciliated protozoa. This process is limited to sexual reproduction and includes DNA amplification, chromosome fragmentation, and the elimination of internal segments of DNA. Our efforts to define the pathways regulating these events revealed a gene encoding a homologue of ubiquitin activating enzyme 2 (UBA2) that is upregulated at the onset of macronuclear development in Paramecium tetraurelia. Uba2 enzymes are known to activate the protein called small ubiquitin-related modifier (SUMO) that is covalently attached to target proteins. Consistent with this relationship, Northern analysis showed increased abundance of SUMO transcripts during sexual reproduction in Paramecium. RNA interference (RNAi) against UBA2 or SUMO during vegetative growth had little effect on cell survival or fission rates. In contrast, RNAi of mating cells resulted in failure to form a functional macronucleus. Despite normal amplification of the genome, excision of internal eliminated sequences was completely blocked. Additional experiments showed that the homologous UBA2 and SUMO genes in Tetrahymena thermophila are also upregulated during conjugation. These results provide evidence for the developmental regulation of the SUMO pathway in ciliates and suggest a key role for the pathway in controlling genome remodeling.

A Dictyostelium long chain fatty acyl coenzyme A-synthetase mediates fatty acid retrieval from endosomes

We have identified a subset of Dictyostelium endosomes that carry a long chain fatty acyl coenzyme A-synthetase (LC-FACS 1) on their cytosolic surface. Immunofluorescence studies and observations using GFP-fusion proteins collectively suggest that LC-FACS 1 associates with endosomes a few minutes after their formation, remains bound through the acidic phase of endocytic maturation and dissociates early in the phase where the endosomal content is neutralised prior to exocytosis. Mutants in the fcsA gene, encoding the LC-FACS 1 protein, were constructed by homologous recombination. These cells show a strong defect in the intracellular accumulation of fatty acids, either taken up together with the liquid medium or bound to the surface of particles. Because the mutant cells are otherwise fully competent for macropinocytosis and phagocytosis, we conclude that the LC-FACS 1 protein mediates the retrieval of fatty acids from the lumen of endosomes into the cytoplasm.

Molecular Aspects of Membrane Trafficking in Paramecium

Results achieved in the molecular biology of Paramecium have shed new light on its elaborate membrane trafficking system. Paramecium disposes not only of the standard routes (endoplasmic reticulum --> Golgi --> lysosomes or secretory vesicles; endo- and phagosomes --> lysosomes/digesting vacuoles), but also of some unique features, e.g. and elaborate phagocytic route with the cytoproct and membrane recycling to the cytopharynx, as well as the osmoregulatory system with multiple membrane fusion sites. Exocytosis sites for trichocysts (dense-core secretory vesicles), parasomal sacs (coated pits), and terminal cisternae (early endosomes) display additional regularly arranged predetermined fusion/fission sites, which now can be discussed on a molecular basis. Considering the regular, repetitive arrangements of membrane components, availability of mutants for complementation studies, sensitivity to gene silencing, and so on, Paramecium continues to be a valuable model system for analyzing membrane interactions. This review intends to set a new baseline for ongoing work along these lines.

Phenotype switching in polymorphic Tetrahymena: a single-cell Jekyll and Hyde

For nearly half a century, phenotype switching in the group of polymorphic species of the ciliate genus Tetrahymena has been the subject of investigations of the underlying mechanisms, the accompanying biochemical and structural changes, and the evolution of polymorphic survival strategy. Beginning with the pioneering systematic studies by Furgason in 1940 of hymenostome ciliates, the experimental approach rapidly expanded to include investigations of growth, nutrition, physiology, morphology, and morphogenesis in the polymorphic species. Recently, with progress in elucidation of the novel signaling ligand and identification of elements of the subsequent signal transduction cascade, in addition to the growing catalog of intracellular events associated with differentiation in these unicellular eukaryotes, we have begun to address the mechanistic basis of polymorphism. This review summarizes and integrates the history and recent discoveries concerning Tetrahymena polymorphic cells. We are now poised to answer fundamental questions about this interesting pathway of cell differentiation.

Biochemical analysis of membrane proteins from an early maturation stage of phagosomes

We used an improved technique for pulse-chase labeling of phagosomes using custom-made magnetic microparticles. With the help of a permanent magnet we purified both newly formed, nascent and early matured (i.e., 5-min-old) condensed phagosomes in high amounts. The protein patterns of membrane proteins of newly formed phagosomes and 5-min-old condensed ones were compared by two-dimensional (2-D) electrophoresis. The protein patterns allowed the detection of protein spots that changed in abundance between these two stages. Three protein spots abundant in condensed phagosomes only and one spot well-stained in both stages were collected from ten preparative Coomassie brilliant blue-stained 2-D gels. Following microdigestion, selected purified oligopeptides were sequenced by Edman degradation. While the oligopeptide sequences of proteins from two spots showed high homology to an already sequenced 25 kDa calcium binding protein, the other two showed no significant homology to protein sequences available in sequence databases. Presently polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and cloning experiments are set up to reveal the cDNAs of these proteins in order to study their function by knock-out and gene replacement experiments.

Disturbance of the determination of germinal and somatic nuclei by heat shock in Paramecium caudatum

During conjugation of Paramecium caudatum, nuclear determination occurs soon after the third postzygotic division: one of the four anterior nuclei becomes the micronucleus and the remaining three degenerate, while four posterior nuclei differentiate into macronuclear anlagen. Macronuclear differentiation is supposed to be dependent on a cytoplasmic differentiation factor. In this study, postzygotic cells were subjected to heat shock for 30 min and nuclear changes were observed by staining with carbol fuchsin solution. When heat shock was initiated during the period from metaphase to telophase of the third postzygotic division, cells showed an excess of macronuclear anlagen and were typically amicronucleate. Abnormal nuclear localization around the end of the third (last) postzygotic division may explain the origin of these kinds of cells. A similar phenomenon appeared after treatment with actinomycin D or emetine. Since heat shock did not inhibit macronuclear differentiation but destroyed the formation of micronuclei, some factor(s) probably plays an essential role in nuclear determination, especially in the protection of the micronuclei.

Maturation of phagosomes is accompanied by specific patterns of small GTPases

In this study we purified phagosomes of the ciliated protozoan Tetrahymena thermophila to analyze aspects of the maturation pathway of phagocytotic vesicles. Phagosomes were labeled with magnetic microparticles and then purified in high amounts with the help of a permanent magnet. By combining a pulse-chase labeling protocol with the magnetic separation procedure we were able to isolate phagosomes of defined ages, which represent distinct stages of their maturation pathway. GTP-overlay assays showed that a set of small GTPases of the ras superfamily is associated with these phagosomes. Phagosomes isolated at different stages of maturation revealed a change in the pattern of the small GTPases. Some small GTPases identified by the GTPase overlay assays could be aligned to India ink stained protein spots in two-dimensional gels of isolated phagosomes. The results presented here are a first step to identify the members of small GTPases associated with phagosomes during their maturation pathway. Microsequencing of pooled polypeptides by mass-spectrometric techniques will identify the primary structure of these small GTPases.

Coronin involved in phagocytosis: dynamics of particle-induced relocalization visualized by a green fluorescent protein Tag

Coronin is a protein involved in cell locomotion and cytokinesis of Dictyostelium discoideum. Here we show that coronin is strongly enriched in phagocytic cups formed in response to particle attachment. A fusion of coronin with green fluorescent protein (GFP) accumulates in the cups within less than 1 min upon attachment of a particle and is gradually released from the phagosome within 1 min after engulfment is completed. Phagocytic cup formation competes with leading edge formation and can be interrupted at any stage. When the cup regresses, coronin dissociates from the site of accumulation. TRITC-labeled yeast cells have been used to assay phagocytosis quantitatively in wild-type and coronin-null cells. In the mutant, the rate of uptake is reduced to about one third, which shows that coronin contributes to the efficiency of phagocytosis to about the same extent as it improves the speed of cell locomotion.