Developmental validation of reduced-size STR Miniplex primer sets

Targeted sequencing of high-density SNPs provides an enhanced tool for forensic applications and genetic landscape exploration in Chinese Korean ethnic group

BACKGROUND

In this study, we present a NGS-based panel designed for sequencing 1993 SNP loci for forensic DNA investigation. This panel addresses unique challenges encountered in forensic practice and allows for a comprehensive population genetic study of the Chinese Korean ethnic group. To achieve this, we combine our results with datasets from the 1000 Genomes Project and the Human Genome Diversity Panel.

RESULTS

We demonstrate that this panel is a reliable tool for individual identification and parentage testing, even when dealing with degraded DNA samples featuring exceedingly low SNP detection rates. The performance of this panel for complex kinship determinations, such as half-sibling and grandparent-grandchild scenarios, is also validated by various kinship simulations. Population genetic studies indicate that this panel can uncover population substructures on both global and regional scales. Notably, the Han population can be distinguished from the ethnic minorities in the northern and southern regions of East Asia, suggesting its potential for regional ancestry inference. Furthermore, we highlight that the Chinese Korean ethnic group, along with various Han populations from different regional areas and certain northern ethnic minorities (Daur, Tujia, Japanese, Mongolian, Xibo), exhibit a higher degree of genetic affinities when examined from a genomic perspective.

CONCLUSION

This study provides convincing evidence that the NGS-based panel can serve as a reliable tool for various forensic applications. Moreover, it has helped to enhance our knowledge about the genetic landscape of the Chinese Korean ethnic group.

Cost-Effective Next Generation Sequencing-Based STR Typing with Improved Analysis of Minor, Degraded and Inhibitor-Containing DNA Samples

Forensic DNA profiles are established by multiplex PCR amplification of a set of highly variable short tandem repeat (STR) loci followed by capillary electrophoresis (CE) as a means to assign alleles to PCR products of differential length. Recently, CE analysis of STR amplicons has been supplemented by high-throughput next generation sequencing (NGS) techniques that are able to detect isoalleles bearing sequence polymorphisms and allow for an improved analysis of degraded DNA. Several such assays have been commercialised and validated for forensic applications. However, these systems are cost-effective only when applied to high numbers of samples. We report here an alternative, cost-efficient shallow-sequence output NGS assay called maSTR assay that, in conjunction with a dedicated bioinformatics pipeline called SNiPSTR, can be implemented with standard NGS instrumentation. In a back-to-back comparison with a CE-based, commercial forensic STR kit, we find that for samples with low DNA content, with mixed DNA from different individuals, or containing PCR inhibitors, the maSTR assay performs equally well, and with degraded DNA is superior to CE-based analysis. Thus, the maSTR assay is a simple, robust and cost-efficient NGS-based STR typing method applicable for human identification in forensic and biomedical contexts.

Resolution of mitochondrial DNA mixtures using a probe capture next generation sequencing system and phylogenetic-based software

Interpreting mixtures with nuclear genetic markers remains one of the persisting challenges in forensic DNA analysis, particularly when the DNA is degraded or present in trace amounts. In these scenarios, analyzing mitochondrial (mt) DNA can be useful due to the higher copy number per cell compared to nuclear DNA. However, until the emergence of Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) with its clonal sequencing capability, analysis of mtDNA mixtures was very challenging. A mitochondrial genome probe capture Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) system was used to sequence complex mtDNA mixtures and two different software programs to analyze the sequence data. Analysis of contrived mixtures of two contributors in 50:50 and 95:5 ratios as well as three-person mixtures ranging from near equal proportions (~33:33:33 ratio) to low amounts of the minor contributors (e.g., a 90:5:5 ratio) is reported. This system was also applied to the analysis of mtDNA mixtures from forensically relevant samples. For data analysis, both the variant frequency-based software program GeneMarker®HTS and the phylogenetic-based software program Mixemt was used to de-convolute the mixtures. Using the massively parallel, clonal features of NGS, one can bioinformatically separate and count the individual sequence reads to calculate the proportions of individual contributors using phylogenetically informative polymorphisms. GeneMarker®HTS allows us to detect all mutations, including "private" mutations (non-phylogenetically informative polymorphisms) and assign them to individual contributors based on the frequency of the sequence reads, provided that the proportions of the various contributors are sufficiently different. Using a probe capture NGS system and both GeneMarker®HTS and Mixemt software programs, the interpretation of complex mixtures of equal proportion contributors, trace amount contributors, and more than two contributors in contrived mixtures, as well as interpretation of challenging forensic specimens is demonstrated.

The development of miniSTRs as a method for high-speed direct PCR

There are situations in which it would be very valuable to have a DNA profile within a short time; for example, in mass disasters or airport security. In previous work, we have promoted reduced size STR amplicons for the analysis of degraded DNA. We also noticed that shorter amplicons are more robust during amplification, making them inhibition resistant, and potentially applicable to high-speed direct PCR. Here, we describe a set of miniSTRs capable of rapid direct PCR amplification. The selected markers are a subset of the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS) loci modified to permit high-speed amplification. Using the proposed protocol, the amplification of eight loci plus amelogenin directly from a saliva sample can be completed in 7 min and 38 s using a two-step PCR with 30 cycles of 98°C for 2 s and 62°C for 7 s on a Streck Philisa thermocycler. Selection of DNA polymerase, optimization of the two-step PCR cycling conditions, the primer concentrations, and the dilution of saliva is described. This method shows great potential as a quick screening method to obtain a presumptive DNA profile when time is limited, particularly when combined with high-speed separation and detection methods.

Efficacy of reduced-size short tandem repeat PCR analysis for degraded DNA samples

BACKGROUND

Short tandem repeats (STR) typing is an essential analysis method for human identification in forensic field. When DNAs obtained from the field as evidences are severely degraded or in too small amounts, STR analysis often shows allele drop-out.

OBJECTIVE

To improve STR analysis for degraded DNA or trace DNA, reduced-size STR (rSTR) polymerase chain reaction (PCR) system was devised by selecting relatively large-size STR loci.

METHODS

The rSTR PCR system consisted of 8 loci (amelogenin, SE33, CSF1PO, D7S820, D13S317, D2S1338, TPOX, and FGA). The size of PCR product was reduced by designing new primers in the flanking region. The efficiency of this system was verified against existing kits through concordance study, sensitivity study, efficiency study, and casework sample study.

RESULTS

The size of PCR product in the rSTR PCR system was reduced to be less than 322 bp. The amplicon of each locus was reduced by about 100 bp on average. Results of this rSTR PCR system were confirmed using 146 Korean samples and other commercial kits. The rSTR PCR system was capable of analyzing DNA samples with a minimum amount of DNA of 16 pg and a degradation index of 4.215.

CONCLUSION

The rSTR PCR system was more effective than other PCR kits for obtaining genetic profiles from a small amount of DNA or degraded DNA. The combination of this new system and other commercial kits is more effective than existing systems. This combination is expected to be helpful for the identification of unidentified bodies and skeletal samples.

Applications of Probe Capture Enrichment Next Generation Sequencing for Whole Mitochondrial Genome and 426 Nuclear SNPs for Forensically Challenging Samples

The application of next generation sequencing (NGS) for the analysis of mitochondrial (mt) DNA, short tandem repeats (STRs), and single nucleotide polymorphism (SNPs) has demonstrated great promise for challenging forensic specimens, such as degraded, limited, and mixed samples. Target enrichment using probe capture rather than PCR amplification offers advantages for analysis of degraded DNA since two intact PCR primer sites in the template DNA molecule are not required. Furthermore, NGS software programs can help remove PCR duplicates to determine initial template copy numbers of a shotgun library. Moreover, the same shotgun library prepared from a limited DNA source can be enriched for mtDNA as well as nuclear markers by hybrid capture with the relevant probe panels. Here, we demonstrate the use of this strategy in the analysis of limited and mock degraded samples using our custom probe capture panels for massively parallel sequencing of the whole mtgenome and 426 SNP markers. We also applied the mtgenome capture panel in a mixed sample and analyzed using both phylogenetic and variant frequency based bioinformatics tools to resolve the minor and major contributors. Finally, the results obtained on individual telogen hairs demonstrate the potential of probe capture NGS analysis for both mtDNA and nuclear SNPs for challenging forensic specimens.

Whole genome nucleosome sequencing identifies novel types of forensic markers in degraded DNA samples

In the case of mass disasters, missing persons and forensic caseworks, highly degraded biological samples are often encountered. It can be a challenge to analyze and interpret the DNA profiles from these samples. Here we provide a new strategy to solve the problem by taking advantage of the intrinsic structural properties of DNA. We have assessed the in vivo positions of more than 35 million putative nucleosome cores in human leukocytes using high-throughput whole genome sequencing, and identified 2,462 single nucleotide variations (SNVs), 128 insertion-deletion polymorphisms (indels). After comparing the sequence reads with 44 STR loci commonly used in forensics, five STRs (TH01, TPOX, D18S51, DYS391, and D10S1248)were matched. We compared these “nucleosome protected STRs” (NPSTRs) with five other non-NPSTRs using mini-STR primer design, real-time PCR, and capillary gel electrophoresis on artificially degraded DNA. Moreover, genotyping performance of the five NPSTRs and five non-NPSTRs was also tested with real casework samples. All results show that loci located in nucleosomes are more likely to be successfully genotyped in degraded samples. In conclusion, after further strict validation, these markers could be incorporated into future forensic and paleontology identification kits, resulting in higher discriminatory power for certain degraded sample types.

Optimization of STR locus enrichment for STR profiling of fragmented DNA

DNA degradation is a major obstacle in gaining an accurate profile with standard DNA typing technology. Although alternative genotyping strategies such as mini-STRs and SNPs have proven to be more successful in profiling degraded DNA, these approaches also have limitations. Here, we show that locus enrichment by hybridization of degraded genomic DNA with an STR locus-specific biotinylated oligonucleotide is a powerful approach to overcome problems in STR typing of highly degraded DNA. An experimental investigation of factors affecting the efficiency of this method indicates that the choice of primer and molar ratio of primers to genomic DNA are critical factors in improving enrichment of the STR locus before genotyping with multiplex kits. In addition, we find that indirect capture rather than direct capture with magnetic beads yields better enrichment efficiency for STR locus enrichments. Using these strategies, we demonstrate an improvement in STR typing of DNA from cultured cells damaged by exposure to sunlight or UV. We suggest that this approach could be applied to highly degraded forensic samples alone or in combination with mini-STRs.

Use of short tandem repeat fingerprinting to validate sample origins in hepatitis C virus molecular epidemiology studies

Sequence analysis is used to define the molecular epidemiology and evolution of the hepatitis C virus. Whilst most studies have shown that individual patients harbour viruses that are derived from a limited number of highly related strains, some recent reports have shown that some patients can be co-infected with very distinct variants whose frequency can fluctuate greatly. Whilst co-infection with highly divergent strains is possible, an alternative explanation is that such data represent contamination or sample mix-up. In this study, we have shown that DNA fingerprinting techniques can accurately assess sample provenance and differentiate between samples that are truly exhibiting mixed infection from those that harbour distinct virus populations due to sample mix-up. We have argued that this approach should be adopted routinely in virus sequence analyses to validate sample provenance.

A new multiplex assay of 17 autosomal STRs and Amelogenin for forensic application

This paper describes a newly devised autosomal short tandem repeat (STR) multiplex polymerase chain reaction (PCR) systems for 17 autosomal loci (D1S1656, D2S441, D3S1358, D3S3045, D6S477, D7S3048, D8S1132, D10S1435, D10S1248, D11S2368, D13S325, D14S608, D15S659, D17S1290, D18S535, D19S253 and D22-GATA198B05) and Amelogenin. Primers for the loci were designed and optimized so that all of the amplicons were distributed from 50 base pairs (bp) to less than 500 bp within a five-dye chemistry design with the fifth dye reserved for the sizing standard. Strategies were developed to overcome challenges that encountered in creating the final assay. The limits of the multiplex were tested, resulting in the successful amplification of genomic DNA range from 0.25-4 ng with 30 PCR cycles. A total of 681 individuals from the Chinese Han population were studied and forensic genetic data were present. No significant deviations from Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium were observed. A total of 180 alleles were detected for the 17 autosomal STRs. The cumulative mean exclusion chance in duos (CMECD) was 0.999967, and cumulative mean exclusion chance in trios (CMECT) was 0.99999995. We conclude that the present 17plex autosomal STRs assay provides an additional powerful tool for forensic applications.

Occult androgenetic-biparental mosaicism and sporadic hepatic mesenchymal hamartoma

The incidence of hepatic mesenchymal hamartoma (HMH) is increased in patients with placental mesenchymal dysplasia (PMD), which appears to be caused by androgenetic-biparental mosaicism (ABM). We hypothesized that occult ABM might underlie cases of HMH with no known history of PMD. Formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded HMH specimens from 10 such patients and liver specimens from 6 non-HMH controls were identified retrospectively from the surgical pathology records of a pediatric hospital. The relative abundance of maternal and paternal alleles was assessed by quantitative polymerase chain reaction amplification of polymorphic short tandem repeats and single nucleotide polymorphisms located on 15 different chromosomes. Androgenetic-biparental mosaicism was diagnosed in one patient based on global allelic imbalances at all informative loci. In that patient, the greatest imbalances were observed in stroma-rich portions of the hamartoma, with no significant imbalance in histologically normal liver or epithelium-rich portions of the hamartoma. A retrospective, unbiased review of the histology and clinical records from all 10 patients revealed no morphologic or clinical correlates to distinguish the affected patient, except that she had multiple cutaneous hemangiomas, which like HMH, appear to be more common in patients with PMD. Our findings suggest that other patients with apparently sporadic HMH, hemangioma, or other lesions seen more frequently with PMD may harbor occult ABM. Recognition of ABM may be important because its long-term consequences are unknown but may be significant.

Microchip electrophoresis of Alu elements for gender determination and inference of human ethnic origin

We performed a series of multi-locus PCRs followed by the rapid and efficient microchip electrophoretic sorting of Alu products with LIF detection. Five polymorphic human-specific Alu insertions (RC5, A1, PV92, TPA and ACE) were used for inference of human ethnicity and two monomorphic Alu insertions for sex typing, one fixed on the X chromosome (AluSTXa) and the other on the Y chromosome (AluSTYa). These markers were used to generate unique DNA profiles for five different DNA samples. The PCR-based assays used primers that flank the insertion point to determine genotypes based on the presence or absence of the Alu element. A1, RC5, PV92, TPA and ACE were used for ethnicity determinations and have two alleles, each indicating the presence (+) or absence (-) of the Alu element on the paired chromosomes, which results in three genotypes (+/+, +/- or -/-). RC5 and A1 did not show ethnic heterogeneity resulting in a homozygous (-/-) genotype, which correctly inferred that DNA samples originating from a Caucasian male and an Asian male were not of African ancestry. The results from the five Alu markers indicated that these Alu loci could assist in identifying the individual's ethnicity using microchip electrophoresis in under 15 min of separation time. Using microchip electrophoresis and mixed genotype ratios, male DNA-to-female DNA of 1:9, corresponding to a ratio of Y-to-X chromosomes of 1:19, was also detected for both AluSTXa and AluSTYa to provide gender identification without requiring separation of female from male cells prior to the assay.

A study of PCR inhibition mechanisms using real time PCR

In this project, real time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was utilized to study the mechanism of PCR inhibition through examination of the effect of amplicon length, melting temperature, and sequence. Specifically designed primers with three different amplicon lengths and three different melting temperatures were used to target a single homozygous allele in the HUMTH01 locus. The effect on amplification efficiency for each primer pair was determined by adding different concentrations of various PCR inhibitors to the reaction mixture. The results show that a variety of inhibition mechanisms can occur during the PCR process depending on the type of co-extracted inhibitor. These include Taq inhibition, DNA template binding, and effects on reaction efficiency. In addition, some inhibitors appear to affect the reaction in more than one manner. Overall we find that amplicon size and melting temperature are important in some inhibition mechanisms and not in others and the key issue in understanding PCR inhibition is determining the identity of the interfering substance.

Identification of forensically relevant body fluids using a panel of differentially expressed microRNAs

The serology-based methods routinely used in forensic casework for the identification of biological fluids are costly in terms of time and sample and have varying degrees of sensitivity and specificity. Recently, the use of a molecular genetics-based approach using messenger RNA (mRNA) profiling has been proposed to supplant conventional methods for body fluid identification. However, the size of the amplification products used in these mRNA assays (approximately 200-300 nt) might not be ideal for use with degraded or compromised samples frequently encountered in forensic casework. Recently, there has been an explosion of interest in a novel class of small noncoding RNAs, microRNAs (miRNAs, approximately 20-25 bases in length), with numerous published studies reporting that some miRNAs are expressed in a tissue-specific manner. In this article, we provide the first comprehensive evaluation of miRNA expression in dried, forensically relevant biological fluids--blood, semen, saliva, vaginal secretions, and menstrual blood--in an attempt to identify putative body fluid-specific miRNAs. Most of the 452 human miRNAs tested (approximately 67% of the known miRNAome) were either expressed in multiple body fluids or not expressed at all. Nevertheless, we have identified a panel of nine miRNAs--miR451, miR16, miR135b, miR10b, miR658, miR205, miR124a, miR372, and miR412--that are differentially expressed to such a degree as to permit the identification of the body fluid origin of forensic biological stains using as little as 50 pg of total RNA. The miRNA-based body fluid identification assays were highly specific because the miRNA expression profile for each body fluid was different from that obtained from 21 human tissues. The results of this study provide an initial indication that miRNA profiling may provide a promising alternative approach to body fluid identification for forensic casework.