The differential diagnosis of tardive dyskinesia

A combined analysis of double-blind studies with risperidone vs. placebo and other antipsychotic agents: factors associated with extrapyramidal symptoms

Combined data from double-blind risperidone studies were used to analyse the severity of extrapyramidal symptoms (EPS) associated with treatment in patients with chronic schizophrenia. Factors associated with maximum EPS severity were increasing risperidone dose (< or = 8 mg/day was similar to placebo), lower baseline EPS scores, and longer duration of psychotic symptoms, particularly in older patients. EPS severity was significantly greater in patients receiving haloperidol or other antipsychotics than in those receiving risperidone (4 to 8 mg/day) or placebo. Antiparkinsonian medications were required by significantly fewer patients treated with risperidone (4 to 8 mg/day) than by patients treated with haloperidol or other antipsychotics. Combined efficacy data showed that 4 to 8 mg/day was also the most efficacious dose range; there was no increase in efficacy with doses over 4 mg/day. Based on these data and post-marketing experience, 4 mg/day is an appropriate initial target dose for most patients with schizophrenia. Higher doses may be appropriate for patients with chronic illness, and lower doses may be appropriate for patients with a first psychotic episode or for elderly patients.

New strategies for old problems: tardive dyskinesia (TD). Review and report on severe TD cases treated with clozapine, with 12, 8 and 5 years of video follow-up

Tardive dyskinesia (TD) is the most feared and troublesome extrapyramidal side-effect of prolonged neuroleptic (NL) treatment. We present a review of TD. Its pathophysiology remains elusive, although extrapyramidal symptoms (EPS) increase the liability for TD. Nowadays, therefore, avoidance of all EPS remains the best preventive strategy, as it is not possible to predict which liable patients will develop TD, or of what type or severity. TD frequently includes dystonic features, and is more disabling when these dystonias are present. Clozapine (CLZ) has been reported to be effective in suppressing nearly 60% of TD syndromes, specially those with dystonic features. Based on the few reports in the literature on CLZ and TD by the early 1980s, we started to videotape the first severe TD patient treated with CLZ in 1984. We present the first three case reports of severe TD, with prominent disabling dystonic features, treated with CLZ and videotaped since pretreatment and then periodically for 12, 8 and 5 years of follow-up, respectively. The patients' current diagnosis, gender and age are: Case 1, DSM-IV Schizophrenia Residual Type, male, 39 years; Case 2, DSM-IV Polysubstance Related Disorder, Borderline Personality Disorder, female, 28 years; Case 3, DSM-IV Schizoaffective Disorder, male, 40 years. Two of them presented with a recurrence of TD because of CLZ interruption within the first 2 months of treatment, with no further breakthrough to date. The first two cases have complete remission of TD; the third case is still improving after 5 years of CLZ treatment, with only minor dystonic features persisting that constitute no impairment for work or daily routines at present. All patients, independent of their psychiatric primary diagnosis, have shown significant and progressive improvement in both motor and psychosocial aspects. None of them has been rehospitalized. Long-term treatment and follow-up is required to avoid TD recurrence and to assure full assessment of treatment effectiveness. Ideally, periodic video recording with standardized examination is advisable for long-term follow-up and outcome assessment. At present, CLZ could be regarded as the drug of choice for patients with TD, specially for those with disabling and or dystonic features and who require ongoing NL therapy. The use of novel antipsychotic agents for TD treatment and prevention, with their low EPS liability, is promising, but has yet to be tested.

Motor and mental aspects of acute extrapyramidal syndromes

Acute extrapyramidal syndromes (EPS) are one of the major limitations to effective neuroleptic treatment. These disorders have both motor (objective) and mental (subjective) aspects, which must be considered in any evaluation and differential diagnosis of treatment-related side effects. The disorders of akathisia, acute dystonia and parkinsonism have unique features that are best understood in the context of a careful assessment of patient characteristics, drug factors and temporal aspects. Though acute EPS are commonly explained on the basis of dopamine D2 receptor antagonism, data from several lines of study raise important questions about this hypothesis. The roles of receptor subtype specificity, brain region selectivity and ratios of different receptor subtype antagonism are discussed. New and novel antipsychotic drugs with low rates of EPS are important clinical advancements that will increase patients' ability to participate in therapy and rehabilitation and thus improve their quality of life.

Neuroleptic drug-induced extrapyramidal syndromes and tardive dyskinesia

Neuroleptic (antipsychotic) drug-induced acute extrapyramidal syndromes (EPS) and the late onset tardive dyskinesia (TD) are the major side effects that limit the use of these highly efficacious agents. The appropriate strategy for controlling these side effects is based on the clinical presentations, pathophysiological mechanisms, and contributions of patient and treatment-related risk factors. New information about the mechanisms of action of neuroleptics and the long-term outcome of acute EPS and TD provide valuable insights into these syndromes. The most effective method for maximizing the benefits and minimizing the risks of neuroleptics is to use the lowest effective dose of both neuroleptic and antiEPS drugs in patients who benefit from them. The next major advancement will be to develop new compounds which effectively control psychotic symptoms and are free of the undesirable acute and tardive motor syndromes.

Tardive dyskinesia in psychiatric patients with substance use disorders

The authors report on the incidence of tardive dyskinesia (TD) in a sample of 284 psychiatric patients who chronically abused street drugs; 82.4% had received neuroleptic treatment for the length of their illness (10.5 +/- 5.8 years). The incidence of TD was 15.9%. The incidence of TD was significantly higher in groups of patients in which alcohol alone (25.4%) or in combination with cannabis (26.7%) was the drug of abuse than in those groups in which alcohol was either absent or used in combination with sedatives, opioids, or stimulants. Tardive dyskinesia was absent in patients not treated with neuroleptics and in a control group of drug abusers free of mental disorders. The anatomical distribution was similar to that reported in other psychiatric samples. Mean severity was mild and incapacitation and distress were minimal. Polydrug abuse was dominant in both patients and controls, and alcohol abuse was more frequent among TD patients. It is concluded that chronic use of alcohol by mental patients undergoing pharmacotherapy with neuroleptics enhances the vulnerability of these patients to TD.

Neuroleptic side effects: acute extrapyramidal syndromes and tardive dyskinesia

The neuroleptic-induced motor system side effects of acute extrapyramidal syndromes (EPS) and tardive dyskinesia (TD) are the major limitations of these drugs. Effective strategies for managing these problems are based on the clinical presentations, pathophysiological processes, and a complex interaction of patient and treatment variables. New concepts about the causes and long-term outcome of acute EPS and TD are emerging to challenge some of the commonly held views about these syndromes. The primary method of preventing undue side effects is to use the lowest effective dose of both neuroleptic and anti-EPS drugs. The pressing need is for novel compounds which treat schizophrenia and are free of the undesirable motor system effects (a nonneuroleptic neuroleptic).

Clinical features of movement disorders

The descriptive aspects of all types of movement disorders and their related syndromes and terminologies used in the literature are reviewed and described. This comprises the features of (a) movement disorders secondary to neurological diseases affecting the extrapyramidal motor system, such as: athetosis, chorea, dystonia, hemiballismus, myoclonus, tremor, tics and spasm, (b) drug induced movement disorders, such as: akathisia, akinesia, hyperkinesia, dyskinesias, extrapyramidal syndrome, and tardive dyskinesia, and (c) abnormal movements in psychiatric disorders, such as: mannerism, stereotyped behaviour and psychomotor retardation. It is intended to bring about a more comprehensive overview of these movement disorders from a phenomenological perspective, so that clinicians can familiarize with these features for diagnosis. Some general statements are made in regard to some of the characteristics of movement disorders.