Microbiological and clinical effects of topical subgingival antimicrobial treatment on human periodontal disease

Concise evaluation and therapeutic guidelines for severe periodontitis: A public health perspective

The main goal of periodontology is to prevent and arrest gingivitis and periodontitis to avoid tooth loss and focal infection of periodontal origin. Periodontal scaling or flap surgery of moderate-to-severe periodontitis have shortcomings, most likely because removal of herpesviruses and bacterial pathogens in deep periodontal lesions and the adjacent inflamed gingiva requires systemic antimicrobial treatment (or gingivectomy). Valacyclovir (1000 mg twice daily on day 1, and 500 mg twice daily on day 2 and on day 3) is a potent anti-herpesvirus agent. Antibiotic combinations against bacterial pathogens include amoxicillin-metronidazole (250 mg of each, thrice daily for 4 days; for systemically healthy adults) and ciprofloxacin-metronidazole (500 mg of each, twice daily for 4 days; for immunosuppressed individuals and patients exposed to contaminated water and poor sanitation). Supportive antiseptic treatment may consist of 0.1%-0.2% sodium hypochlorite (regular household bleach) as cooling spray in ultrasonic scalers, flosser fluid in oral irrigators, and mouthrinse in patient self-care. The anti-infective treatment described here helps control cases of severe periodontitis and constitutes an exceedingly inexpensive alternative to conventional (mechanical) periodontal therapy.

Use of mouthwashes against COVID-19 in dentistry

The proximity to the patient during dental care, high generation of aerosols, and the identification of SARS-CoV-2 in saliva have suggested the oral cavity as a potential reservoir for COVID-19 transmission. Mouthwashes are widely-used solutions due to their ability to reduce the number of microorganisms in the oral cavity. Although there is still no clinical evidence that they can prevent the transmission of SARS-CoV-2, preoperative antimicrobial mouth rinses with chlorhexidine gluconate (CHX), cetylpyridinium chloride (CPC), povidone-iodine (PVP-I), and hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) have been recommended to reduce the number of microorganisms in aerosols and drops during oral procedures. This paper therefore aims to provide a comprehensive review of the current recommendations on the use of mouthwashes against the COVID-19 pandemic and to analyse the advantages and disadvantages of most conventional antiseptic mouthwashes used in dentistry.

Efficacy of Natural and Allopathic Antimicrobial Agents Incorporated onto Guided Tissue Regeneration Membrane Against Periodontal Pathogens: An in vitro Study

INTRODUCTION

Periodontal disease is one of the most prevalent afflictions worldwide. It is an infection of the periodontium as a result of subgingival colonization of the specific microbiota, leading to loss of attachment, which requires optimal care for regeneration to its pre-disease state. Guided Tissue Regeneration (GTR) is one of the successful treatment modalities in Periodontal Regenerative Therapy, but is vulnerable to bacterial colonization. The conflict between usage of classical antibiotics and plant origin antimicrobial agents has recently been in the limelight.

AIM

The aim of this study was to assess the in vitro antimicrobial activity of amoxicillin, metronidazole and green coffee extract loaded onto GTR membrane against periodonto-pathogens.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Pure form of amoxicillin, metronidazole and green coffee extract were obtained. One percent concentration of each antimicrobial agent was prepared by appropriate dilution with distilled water. GTR membrane was cut into a size of 1x0.5 cm under sterile conditions and was coated with the antimicrobial agents respectively and with distilled water as the negative control. Antimicrobial activity was checked against Aggregatibacter actinomycetemcomitans (A. actinomycetemcomitans) and Porphyromonas gingivalis (P. gingivalis) using agar disc diffusion method. The statistical analysis was done using Kruskal Wallis ANOVA and Mann-Whitney U test.

RESULTS

One percent amoxicillin showed level of significance (p>0.05) against both A. actinomycetemcomitans and P. gingivalis. Green coffee extract showed no zone of inhibition against both the bacterial species.

CONCLUSION

Loading of commercially available antimicrobial agents onto GTR membrane can prevent its bacterial colonization leading to better treatment outcomes for periodontal regeneration.

Management of Chronic Periodontitis Using Subgingival Irrigation of Ozonized Water: A Clinical and Microbiological Study

INTRODUCTION

Adjunctive use of professional subgingival irrigation with scaling and root planing (SRP) has been found to be beneficial in eradicating the residual microorganisms in the pocket.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the effect of ozonized water subgingival irrigation on microbiologic parameters and clinical parameters namely Gingival index, probing pocket depth, and clinical attachment level.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Thirty chronic periodontitis patients with probing pocket depth ≥6mm on at least one tooth on contra lateral sides of opposite arches were included in the study. The test sites were subjected to ozonized water subgingival irrigation with subgingival irrigation device fitted with a modified subgingival tip. Control sites were subjected to scaling and root planing only. The following clinical parameters were recorded initially and after 4 weeks at the test sites and control sites. Plaque Index, Gingival Index, probing pocket depth, clinical attachment level. Microbiologic sampling was done for the test at the baseline, after scaling, immediately after ozonized water subgingival irrigation and after 4 weeks. In control sites microbiologic sampling was done at the baseline, after scaling and after 4 weeks. The following observations were made after 4 weeks. The results were statistically analysed using independent t-test and paired t-test.

RESULT

Test sites showed a greater reduction in pocket depth and gain in clinical attachment compared to control sites. The total anaerobic counts were significantly reduced by ozonized water subgingival irrigation along with SRP compared to SRP alone.

CONCLUSION

Ozonized water subgingival irrigation can improve the clinical and microbiological parameters in patients with chronic periodontitis when used as an adjunct to scaling and root planing.

Intrabony defects and non-surgical treatment

Periodontitis can lead to vertical bone loss with the creation of 'intrabony defects', associated with higher risk of progression if left untreated. Intrabony defects are considered candidates for periodontal surgical procedures, in order to arrest disease progression and achieve bone regeneration. This paper brings forward anecdotal and scientific evidence from the literature to describe how even non-surgical periodontal treatment can result in clinical and radiographic resolution of periodontal intrabony defects.

Surgical and nonsurgical periodontal therapy. Learned and unlearned concepts

This review aims to highlight concepts relating to nonsurgical and surgical periodontal therapy, which have been learned and unlearned over the past few decades. A number of treatment procedures, such as gingival curettage and aggressive removal of contaminated root cementum, have been unlearned. Advances in technology have resulted in the introduction of a range of new methods for use in nonsurgical periodontal therapy, including machine-driven instruments, lasers, antimicrobial photodynamic therapy and local antimicrobial-delivery devices. However, these methods have not been shown to offer significant benefits over and above nonsurgical debridement using hand instruments. The method of debridement is therefore largely dependent on the preferences of the operator and the patient. Recent evidence indicates that specific systemic antimicrobials may be indicated for use as adjuncts to nonsurgical debridement in patients with advanced disease. Full-mouth disinfection protocols have been proven to be a relevant treatment option. We have learned that while nonsurgical and surgical methods result in similar long-term treatment outcomes, surgical therapy results in greater probing-depth reduction and clinical attachment gain in initially deep pockets. The surgical technique chosen seems to have limited influence upon changes in clinical attachment gain. What has not changed is the importance of thorough mechanical debridement and optimal plaque control for successful nonsurgical and surgical periodontal therapy.

Low-cost periodontal therapy

Periodontitis is a complex infectious disease that affects low-income individuals disproportionately. Periodontitis is associated with specific bacterial species and herpesviruses, and successful prevention and treatment of the disease is contingent upon effective control of these pathogens. This article presents an efficacious, highly safe, minimally invasive, practical and low-cost periodontal therapy that involves professional and patient-administered mechanical therapy and antimicrobial agents. The major components are scaling for calculus removal, periodontal pocket irrigation with potent antiseptics, and treatment with systemic antibiotics for advanced disease. Povidone-iodine and sodium hypochlorite have all the characteristics for becoming the first-choice antiseptics in the management of periodontal diseases. Both agents show excellent antibacterial and antiviral properties, are readily available throughout the world, have been safely used in periodontal therapy for decades, offer significant benefits for individuals with very limited financial resources, and are well accepted by most dental professionals and patients. Four per cent chlorhexidine applied with a toothbrush to the most posterior part to the tongue dorsum can markedly reduce or eliminate halitosis in most individuals. Systemic antibiotics are used to treat periodontopathic bacteria that are not readily reached by topical therapy, such as pathogens within gingival tissue, within furcation defects, at the base of periodontal pockets, and on the tongue, tonsils and buccal mucosae. Valuable antibiotic therapies are amoxicillin-metronidazole (250 mg of amoxicillin and 250 mg of metronidazole, three times daily for 8 days) for young and middle-aged patients, and ciprofloxacin-metronidazole (500 mg of each, twice daily for 8 days) for elderly patients and for patients in developing countries who frequently harbor enteric rods subgingivally. Scaling to remove dental calculus and the prudent use of inexpensive antimicrobial agents can significantly retard or arrest progressive periodontitis in the great majority of patients.

Systematic review on the effect of rinsing with povidone-iodine during nonsurgical periodontal therapy

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

The existing literature is inconsistent regarding whether there is any additional effect of povidone-iodine (PVP-iodine) as an adjunctive to scaling and root planing, and, if there is an effect, what its size is. Therefore, the aim of this study was to assess the additional effect of PVP-iodine as an adjunct to scaling and root planing compared with water, saline or no rinse in the treatment of chronic periodontitis.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

An electronic literature search of the databases PubMed, EMBASE and the Cochrane Central Library, and a handsearch, were performed (up to November 2008). Two reviewers independently identified and selected screened abstracts for possible inclusion, and assessed randomized, controlled clinical trials comparing the additional benefit of PVP-iodine with water, saline rinsing or no rinsing in the nonsurgical periodontal therapy of patients with chronic periodontitis. A fixed-effects meta-analysis was conducted in the absence of statistically significant heterogeneity.

RESULTS

A small, but statistically significant additional beneficial effect of the adjunctive use of PVP-iodine with enhanced probing pocket depth reductions of 0.28 mm (95% confidence interval: 0.08 to 0.48, p = 0.007) was found. There was no significant heterogeneity between studies (I(2) = 0%). However, most of the studies included in the meta-analysis were of low quality, and the treatment modalities showed various differences such as the use of PVP-iodine at different concentrations and application modalities. Nevertheless, single-rooted teeth, in particular, showed an additional benefit after scaling and root planing with PVP-iodine, particularly when the treatment was repeated during the healing stage.

CONCLUSION

The adjunctive use of PVP-iodine during scaling and root planing may increase the clinical pocket depth reduction, although the clinical significance is small to moderate.

How to select the right mouthrinses in periodontal prevention and therapy. Part II. Clinical use and recommendations

Based on scientific proof, only few mouthrinse solutions can be recommended. However, it is impossible to construct an extended table that would provide precise recommendations or advices for mouthrinse utilisation related to any possible discomfort or diseases. Only reliable information on the drugs available against periodontal disease can be offered to the therapist. By evaluation of her or his individual experiences, she or he has to judge all the armamentarium she or he possesses to react in the best possible way in each specific situation.

Hydrogen peroxide tooth-whitening (bleaching) products: review of adverse effects and safety issues

Hydrogen peroxide in the form of carbamide peroxide is widely used for tooth whitening (bleaching), both in professionally- and in self-administered products. Adverse effects have become evident. Cervical root resorption is a possible consequence of internal bleaching and is more frequently observed in teeth treated with the thermo-catalytic procedure. Tooth sensitivity is experienced in 15-78% of patients undergoing external tooth bleaching. However, clinical studies addressing other adverse effects are lacking. Direct contact with hydrogen peroxide induces genotoxic effects in bacteria and cultured epithelial cells, but the effect is reduced or totally abolished in the presence of metabolising enzymes. Several carcinogenesis studies, including the hamster cheek pouch model, indicate that hydrogen peroxide (H(2)O(2)) might possibly act as a promoter. Until further clinical research is concluded to address the question of possible carcinogenicity, it is recommended that: tooth-bleaching products using concentrated H(2)O(2) should not be used without gingival protection; that H(2)O(2) containing products should be avoided in patients with damaged or diseased soft tissues. For nightguard vital bleaching, minimal amounts of low dose H(2)O(2) (including in the form of carbamide peroxide) are preferred, thereby avoiding prolonged and concentrated exposures.

Hydrogen peroxide tooth-whitening (bleaching): review of safety in relation to possible carcinogenesis

Hydrogen peroxide in the form of carbamide peroxide is widely used in professionally and self-administered products for tooth whitening. Hydrogen peroxide is a highly reactive substance that can damage oral soft and hard tissues when present in high concentrations and with exposures of prolonged duration. This review examines the issue of oral mucosal damage and possible carcinogenicity relating to the use of hydrogen peroxide in the mouth for tooth whitening, with an emphasis on safety with prolonged exposure to low concentrations of peroxide products.

How to select the right mouthrinses in periodontal prevention and therapy. Part I. Test systems and clinical investigations

The use of mouthrinses is increasing, especially as adjuncts to the daily mechanical oral hygiene. Different test systems may and can be used to test their antibacterial and clinical effects: bacteriology in vitro, substantivity in vivo, 4-day plaque re-growth, experimental gingivitis and long-term use. The plaque re-growth investigations of a few days are not only of limited use but may also be dangerous because often too extensive conclusions have been drawn from their design. The 'gold standard' test is the experimental gingivitis model to reveal the antiplaque as well as the antigingivitis effects of any mouthrinse preparation during 3 weeks. The last kind of investigations are of several months' duration, where the substances are used as supplements to mechanical oral hygiene measures.

Position Paper: The Role of Supra- and Subgingival Irrigation in the Treatment of Periodontal Diseases

This position paper addresses the role of supra- and subgingival irrigation in the treatment of periodontal diseases. It was prepared by the Committee on Research, Science and Therapy of the American Academy of Periodontology. The document is divided into two portions, consisting of supragingival irrigation and subgingival irrigation. In their respective segments, these treatment techniques are assessed as monotherapies and as adjuncts to conventional treatment. The conclusions drawn in this paper represent the position of the American Academy of Periodontology regarding irrigation therapy in the treatment of periodontal diseases.

Local Anti-Infective Therapy: Mechanical and Physical Approaches. A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Although mechanical non-surgical therapy (scaling and root planing) is the most common means of initial treatment of periodontal diseases, the relative clinical efficacy of various methods, including manual versus machine-driven, with or without adjunctive agents, has not been determined.

RATIONALE

This systematic review analyzes the literature in an effort to identify the most effective therapies, based on both clinical and patient-centered outcomes.

FOCUSED QUESTION

In patients with periodontitis, what is the effect of mechanically-driven instrumentation (e.g., power-driven) and/or subgingival irrigation with and without manual instrumentation compared to manual instrumentation alone?

SEARCH PROTOCOL

Two investigators examined MEDLINE and the Cochrane Oral Health Group specialized registry for clinical trials published in English. Hand searches were performed of the International Journal of Periodontics & Restorative Dentistry, Journal of Clinical Periodontology, Journal of Periodontology, and Journal of Periodontal Research. Searches were performed for articles published through April 2002. Editors of these journals were asked to provide information on articles currently under review. In addition, an electronic discussion group on periodontal diseases and treatment was contacted, as were manufacturers of manual and mechanical instruments and of adjunctive agents.

SELECTION CRITERIA

INCLUSION CRITERIA

Only randomized clinical trials, cohort studies, or case-control studies at least 3 months long were included. All studies had to compare manual instrumentation (MI; scaling and root planing [SRP]) alone with some other form of non-surgical therapy. These included MI versus mechanically-driven instruments (MDI) alone; MI versus MI plus MDI; MI versus MDI plus an agent (e.g., chlorhexidine); and MI versus subgingival irrigation (SGI) delivered in conjunction with MI or MDI.

EXCLUSION CRITERIA

Studies not meeting the inclusion criteria or those treating periodontal diseases as a manifestation or complication of some other disease or disorder were not included.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

Probing depth, clinical attachment level, bleeding on probing, and gingival recession were the primary outcomes. Because of the heterogeneity of the patient populations, treatments, and outcome measures, meta-analysis was not appropriate. Only in-study data were compared. Four of the studies required extrapolating data from figures and graphs, resulting in questionable accuracy.

MAIN RESULTS

1. Nine studies, representing a study population of 129, were included in the review. 2. Five studies compared MI with MDI alone. The other 4 compared MI alone to MI plus SGI or subgingival tissue treatment. 3. There was comparable efficacy between MI and MDI when treating single-rooted teeth. 4. The use of SGI or subgingival tissue treatment as an adjunct to MI provided no additional benefit compared to MI alone. 5. Findings reported in the review must be interpreted with considerable caution, as lack of study heterogeneity made meta-analysis unfeasible and the need to extrapolate outcomes values from graphs and figures may have resulted in some inaccuracy.

REVIEWERS' CONCLUSIONS

1. Manual and mechanically-driven instrumentation appears comparable in affecting improved clinical outcomes. 2. Instrumentation time for MI and MDI were similar, except for 1 study in which MDI was significantly shorter. 3. Adjunctive SGI plus MI and subgingival tissue treatment result in similar clinical outcomes when compared to MI alone. 4. If study data are to be effectively and analytically combined to facilitate meaningful comparisons of treatment outcomes, detailed and standardized study designs must be developed and used consistently in clinical trials.

Use of antimicrobial agents during supportive periodontal therapy

Individual susceptibility to periodontal breakdown involves an interplay of genes, periodontal pathogens and other modulating factors. Anti-infective treatment, which includes oral hygiene measures, mechanical debridement, pharmacologic intervention and surgery, has been shown to be effective in arresting the progression of periodontal disease. Nevertheless, due to the chronic nature of the disease, susceptible individuals who are not maintained in a supervised recall program subsequent to the active treatment phase, show signs of recurrent destruction. Supportive periodontal therapy (SPT) is an integral part of periodontal treatment for patients with history of periodontitis, and is needed to prevent recurrence of disease in susceptible individuals. To prevent re-infection with periodontal pathogens, SPT includes elimination of dental plaque and bacteria from the oral cavity, thereby preventing the recurrence of pathogens into the gingival area. For individuals at risk of developing periodontitis, SPT should combine self-performed and professional anti-infective therapy, using mechanical and pharmacological means. The existing evidence suggests that the adjunctive use of antimicrobial pharmacologic therapy during SPT may enhance the results of mechanical debridement. The use of antimicrobials varies between patients, and is dependent on risk assessment and longitudinal monitoring of the clinical status of the periodontium.

Clinical response to experimental forces and non-surgical therapy of teeth with various alveolar bone loss

Firm lateral force is necessary for the thorough removal of calculus during scaling and root planning (SRP) with hand instruments. However, this firm lateral force should be applied to root surfaces without considering the tooth's loss of supporting tissues. The purpose of the present study was two-fold: firstly, to evaluate the initial pain response of periodontally diseased non-molar teeth with two different levels of alveolar bone loss (ABL) to experimental lateral and vertical pull forces; and secondly, to examine the clinical response of these teeth to non-surgical therapy. Twenty patients with chronic periodontitis were specifically selected in two groups according to the level of ABL at non-molar teeth. Group I consisted of 10 patients who have 141 non-molar teeth with a radiographic evidence of 40-65% ABL. Group II consisted of 10 patients who have 132 non-molar teeth with a radiographic evidence of > or =70% ABL. All patients were systemically healthy, free of pain, and reported no current medication usage. Starting from 0 and gradually increasing an experimental lateral force with digital force gauge, and also an experimental vertical pull force with mechanical force gauge were applied to each tooth and measured. As a result of a single experimental force applied to each non-molar tooth, the initial pain response emerged in the patients was determined by means of electronic bell system used by patients themselves. Each patient was treated with SRP using specific hand instruments under local anesthesia. Plaque index (PI), gingival index (GI), probing depth (PD), clinical attachment level (CAL) and periotest values (PV scores) were compared in both groups at initial and at month 3. A mean experimental lateral force of 24.6 N and a mean experimental vertical pull force of 48.3 N caused initial pain response in group I. Initial pain response occurred with a mean experimental lateral force of 5.3 N and a mean experimental vertical pull force of 19.4 N in group II. Only group I showed statistically significant decrease in PI, GI, PD and a significant attachment gain at month 3 (P < 0.05). There was a decrease of 6 PV in group I at month 3 (P < 0.05), whereas an increase of 4 PV was observed in group II (P > 0.05). This study showed that lateral and vertical forces required for effective SRP do not cause any problem in the group with 40-65% ABL. However, they may cause trauma in the group with approximately 70% ABL. Thus, the results suggest that the degree of healing would be different in the group with > or =70% ABL and in the group with 40-65% ABL.

Nonsurgical periodontal therapy

Regular home care by the patient in addition to professional removal of subgingival plaque is generally very effective in controlling most inflammatory periodontal diseases. When disease does recur, despite frequent recall, it can usually be attributed to lack of sufficient supragingival and subgingival plaque control or to other risk factors that influence host response, such as diabetes or smoking. Causative factors contributing to recurrent disease include deep inaccessible pockets, overhangs, poor crown margins and plaque-retentive calculus. In most cases, simply performing a thorough periodontal debridement under local anesthesia will stop disease progression and result in improvement in the clinical signs and symptoms of active disease. If however, clinical signs of disease activity persist following thorough mechanical therapy, such as increased pocket depths, loss of attachment and bleeding on probing, other pharmacotherapeutic therapies should be considered. Augmenting scaling and root planing or maintenance visits with adjunctive chemotherapeutic agents for controlling plaque and gingivitis could be as simple as placing the patient on an antimicrobial mouthrinse and/or toothpaste with agents such as fluorides, chlorhexidine or triclosan, to name a few. Since supragingival plaque reappears within hours or days after its removal, it is important that patients have access to effective alternative chemotherapeutic products that could help them achieve adequate supragingival plaque control. Recent studies, for example, have documented the positive effect of triclosan toothpaste on the long-term maintenance of both gingivitis and periodontitis patients. Daily irrigation with a powered irrigation device, with or without an antimicrobial agent, is also useful for decreasing the inflammation associated with gingivitis and periodontitis. Clinically significant changes in probing depths and attachment levels are not usually expected with irrigation alone. Recent reports, however, would indicate that, when daily irrigation with water was added to a regular oral hygiene home regimen, a significant reduction in probing depth, bleeding on probing and Gingival Index was observed. A significant reduction in cytokine levels (interleukin-1beta and prostaglandin E2, which are associated with destructive changes in inflamed tissues and bone resorption also occurs. If patient-applied antimicrobial therapy is insufficient in preventing, arresting, or reversing the disease progression, then professionally applied antimicrobial agents should be considered including sustained local drug delivery products. Other, more broadly based pharmacotherapeutic agents may be indicated for multiple failing sites. Such agents would include systemic antibiotics or host modulating drugs used in conjunction with periodontal debridement. More aggressive types of juvenile periodontitis or severe rapidly advancing adult periodontitis usually require a combination of surgical intervention in conjunction with systemic antibiotics and generally are not controlled with nonsurgical anti-infective therapy alone. It should be noted, however, that, to date, no home care products or devices currently available can completely control or eliminate the pathogenic plaques associated with periodontal diseases for extended periods of time. Daily home care and frequent recall are still paramount for long-term success. Nonsurgical therapy remains the cornerstone of periodontal treatment. Attention to detail, patient compliance and proper selection of adjunctive antimicrobial agents for sustained plaque control are important elements in achieving successful long-term results. Frequent re-evaluation and careful monitoring allows the practitioner the opportunity to intervene early in the disease state, to reverse or arrest the progression of periodontal disease with meticulous nonsurgical anti-infective therapy.

Safety issues relating to the use of hydrogen peroxide in dentistry

Hydrogen peroxide is used widely in professionally and self-administered products. Hydrogen peroxide is a highly reactive substance which can damage oral soft tissues and hard tissues when present in high concentrations and with exposures of prolonged duration. This report provides an overview of health issues relating to the use of hydrogen peroxide, with an emphasis on safety with prolonged exposure to low concentrations of peroxide products. There is good evidence for the safety of hydrogen peroxide when used at low concentrations on a daily basis over extended periods of time, in self-administered oral health care products such as dentifrices and mouthrinses. These low concentrations neither damage oral hard or soft tissues, nor do they pose a significant risk of adverse long-term effects. Caution should be exercised with the increasingly higher concentration peroxide products used for 'walking' or 'power' bleaching due to the possibility of chemical irritation of oral soft tissues with injudicious use. The volumes of material and application times should be controlled carefully. Thorough education of patients is particularly important with self-applied gels because of the lack of professional supervision with such products. Such education is part of the duty of care of the dentist who supplies bleaching gels for at-home use.

Nonsurgical periodontal therapy in 2000: a literature review

BACKGROUND

This article addresses the advantages and limitations of nonsurgical periodontal therapies to treat patients with mild-to-moderate chronic periodontitis.

TYPES OF STUDIES REVIEWED

Controlled clinical trials were selected that assessed the efficacy of the following treatment methods: mechanical instrumentation, ultrasonic débridement, supragingival irrigation, subgingival irrigation, local drug delivery, administration of systemic antibiotics and host-response modulation. Evidently, data with regard to alterations of probing depth, clinical attachment levels and inflammatory status were evaluated.

RESULTS

Comparison of the data from test and control groups revealed the following results. Manual and ultrasonic débridement can be used to treat most patients with mild-to-moderate chronic periodontitis. Patients who do not practice optimal plaque control can enhance their personal hygiene procedures by using supragingival irrigation. Subgingival irrigation usually does not provide any benefit beyond that achieved with root planing. Systemic and locally delivered antimicrobial agents appear to be most beneficial among patients who do not respond to conventional treatment. Host modulation may enhance root planing modestly.

CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS

The data indicate that most patients with mild-to-moderate periodontitis can be treated with nonsurgical therapies. However, clinicians need to be aware of the limitations of each technique with regard to the magnitude of improvement that it can induce at specific sites.

Diagnostic utility of specific microbiological markers for periodontal diseases

Specific detection of marker organisms Porphyromonas gingivalis, Prevotella intermedia, and Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans with an immunoassay provided 2 types of useful information directly into private clinical practice: 1) persistence of P. gingivalis in patients undergoing regular treatment allowed rapid identification of pockets requiring further treatment without waiting for measurable progression of lesions and 2) presence of A. actinomycetemcomitans in adults at any stage of diagnosis or treatment identified patients who may prove to have difficult-to-manage periodontitis. We made these findings in 253 patients (234 in specialist periodontal practices [F-ME 55; MHM 179] and 19 in general dental practice [EWM]). The search for useful diagnostic markers overlaps only partly with the search for periodontal pathogens. The P. gingivalis marker and the A. actinomycetemcomitans marker identify 2 different patterns of infection that appear to reflect 2 different underlying problems. Demonstration of pocket-dependent infection with P. gingivalis in treated patients provides an outcome marker for sites not converting to marker-negative sites at detection levels of the immunoassay. This information facilitates selection of sites and patients requiring adjustment of treatment regimens. Detection of A. actinomycetemcomitans in adult patients is significantly associated with periodontitis characterized as refractory. Positive identification of A. actinomycetemcomitans with the immunoassay supports clinical decision-making by drawing attention to adult patients who require closer monitoring and intensive persistent treatment. Successful application of immunoassay detection of microbiological markers is based on continuous patient monitoring to support clinical decisions; it does not replace careful clinical judgment.

Computer-assisted densitometric image analysis of digital subtraction images: in vivo error of the method and effect of thresholding

The aim of the present study was to assess the in vivo error of the method as well as the effect of thresholding when obtaining and evaluating standardized periapical radiographs for computer-assisted densitometric image analysis (CADIA). Twenty healthy volunteers participated in an experimental gingivitis study in which neither mechanical nor chemical plaque control was performed for 21 days. Two pairs of standardized periapical radiographs were taken at days 0 (baseline) and 21 (follow-up), one from a maxillary area (15 volunteers) and one from a mandibular molar/premolar area (17 volunteers). Each baseline radiograph was digitized and its image displayed on a monitor. The follow-up radiograph was then superimposed and digitized as well. After gray level correction, subtraction radiographic images were produced. The difference in gray level between the baseline and the follow-up image was calculated within each region of interest (ROI) at each picture point (pixel). In bone ROI, changes in density reflected the amount of change due to methodological errors plus the basic bone remodeling over 3 weeks. For gingival ROI, changes in density reflected the methodological error plus a possible change in soft tissue density during the experimental gingivitis. Within all of the ROI, some pixels indicated a change in gray level. A change in gray level was then thresholded; i.e., only changes >5 and then >10 gray levels were registered and used for calculation of the CADIA values. With a threshold of 5, 44/45 maxillary bone ROI and 60/66 mandibular bone ROI showed a change in density, while 41/45 maxillary gingiva ROI and 26/66 mandibular gingiva ROI indicated a change in density. With a threshold of 10, 16/45 maxillary bone ROI and 12/66 mandibular bone ROI indicated a change in density, while 13/45 maxillary gingiva ROI and 1/66 mandibular gingiva ROI indicated a change. The amounts of changes in density calculated in the various ROI were low even when applying no threshold, ranging from -0.279 to 0.621. Applying a threshold of 5, the CADIA values ranged from -0.234 to 0.727. With a threshold of 10, the changes in density ranged from -0.318 to 0.133. In vivo, CADIA of standardized radiographs indicated change in density due to methodological errors. Application of thresholds may avoid false-positive diagnoses. When applying CADIA in clinical research, the range of change to be expected due to methodological limitations as well as the threshold for true change should be evaluated. These thresholds may differ in various areas of the mouth, i.e., bone or gingival, maxillary/mandibular, anterior/posterior ROI.

Effects of topical metronidazole and tetracycline in treatment of adult periodontitis

The present study was performed to assess and compare the clinical healing and the microbiological findings following local application of metronidazole or tetracycline to augment subgingival scaling in previously untreated adult periodontitis sites. Eighteen patients with moderate to severe adult periodontitis at single-rooted teeth were selected. In each patient, 3 interproximal sites having comparable root anatomy, probing depth > or =5 mm and bleeding on probing were randomly assigned to 1 of 3 treatment groups: 1) two sessions of subgingival scaling and root planing; 2) similar to 1, with each treatment supplemented with a 25% metronidazole sustained release gel; 3) similar to 1 with each treatment supplemented with a 3% tetracycline ointment. The treatments were performed by 1 operator and the clinical variables probing depth, attachment level, and bleeding on probing were evaluated at baseline, 3 months and 6 months by a second blinded examiner. The microbiological findings were evaluated using a commercial test kit. The average probing depth reduction for the 3 groups at 6 months was 1.5 mm and the average gain of clinical attachment was 0.8 mm. There were no significant differences between the effects following topical application of the metronidazole gel or the tetracycline ointment. Scaling and root planing alone appeared as effective as the drug augmented regimens, although there was a weak but non-significant tendency for better results in sites treated with the antibiotic drugs. Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans was generally not detected; Prevotella intermedia was not significantly reduced, while Porphyromonas gingivalis was significantly reduced in all treatment groups. It was concluded that the augmentative effect of the metronidazole gel and the tetracycline ointment was comparable but small compared to scaling and root planing alone. The clinical importance of such small augmentation effects should be further evaluated.

Identification of bacterial markers by culture technique in evaluation of periodontal therapy

The aim of the present study was to evaluate whether the presence of A. actinomycetemcomitans, P. gingivalis and P. intermedia, as revealed by culture technique, could discriminate between three distinct adult patient groups, those: with recurrent periodontal disease, with cured periodontal disease or who were periodontally healthy. Forty one patients previously treated for advanced periodontitis were divided into recurrent or cured groups, with a third periodontally healthy reference group. All subjects were sampled for the three bacterial strains under scrutiny. Although all three micro-organisms were found significantly more often in diseased sites, it was concluded that a sample positive for all three may indicate a false record of disease activity. However, a sample negative for the three bacteria strongly indicates an absence of disease activity.

Localized juvenile periodontitis and Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans in a Brazilian population

Localized juvenile periodontitis (LJP) has been used as a model for studying periodontal disease, and its prevalence is considered to be higher in third-world countries (0.3-8%) than in industrialized countries (0.1%). Mostly, the disease has been associated with Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans (A.a.) but lack of association has also been reported. The aim of this study was to identify LJP patients in geographically different Brazilian populations and assess the presence of A.a. in their periodontal lesions. 7843 children, 12-19-years of age, from the cities of Rio de Janeiro, Votorantim and Belo Horizonte were screened, and LJP patients were identified by strict clinical and radiographical criteria. A final LJP prevalence of 0.3%, with a 99% confidence interval between 0.16% to 0.47%, was found. The prevalence in the subpopulations varied between 0.1-1.1% in the different areas. Subgingival bacterial samples were obtained from the oral cavity of 25 patients and their family members. 80% of these patients, 39.5% of their family members, 35.3% of their parents, and 43.9% of all siblings were culture positive for A.a. All but one of the families had at least one member in addition to the patient who was culture positive for A.a. In 3 families, > 1 member showed radiographic and clinical signs of LJP. 30% of non-LJP subjects coming from one of the areas with higher LJP prevalence harbored A.a. We conclude that LJP is highly associated with A.a. in this Brazilian population.

Microbiological response to mechanical treatment in combination with adjunctive therapy. A review of the literature

The recognition of the microbial origin and the specificity of periodontal infections has resulted in the development of several adjunctive therapies (antibiotics and/or antiseptics) to scaling and root planing in the treatment of chronic adult periodontitis. This article aims to review the "additional" effect of a subgingival irrigation with chlorhexidine, or a local or systemic application of tetracycline or metronidazole, performed in combination with a single course of scaling and root planing in patients with chronic adult periodontitis. All treatment modalities are compared with scaling and root planing, based on their impact on: the probing depth (PD); total number of colony forming units per ml (CFU/ml); the proportions and/or the detection-frequency of Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans, Porphyromonas gingivalis, and Prevotella intermedia; and/or on the percentages of cocci, spirochetes, motile, and other micro-organisms on dark field microscopy examination. All treatment modalities, including scaling and root planing without additional chemical therapy, resulted in significant reductions in the probing depth and the proportions of periodontopathogens, at least during the first 8 weeks post-therapy. However in comparison to a single course of scaling and root planing, the supplementary effect of adjunctive therapies seems to be limited. In general, only the irrigation with chlorhexidine 2%, the local application of minocycline, and the systemic use of metronidazole (in case of large proportions of spirochetes) or doxycycline (in case of large proportions of A. actinomycetemcomitans) seem to result in a prolonged supplementary effect when compared to scaling and root planing. Therefore, the use of antibiotics on a routine basis, especially in a systemic way, in the treatment of chronic adult periodontitis, can no longer be advocated, considering the increasing danger for the development of microbial resistance.

A comparative study of a surgical method and scaling and root planing using the Odontoson

This investigation compared a traditional periodontal surgical method with a non-surgical treatment of scaling and root planing by an ultrasonic device (Odontoson M) using irrigation with an iodised solution. 8 adult patients with periodontal disease were each treated at 2 randomly chosen quadrants by a Widman flap type surgical technique, and the remaining non-surgically. The patients then attended bi-monthly oral hygiene sessions over a period of 1 year. At that stage, clinical evaluation revealed that the Odontoson M plus an ionized irrigant solution achieved a statistically comparable outcome to that of surgical treatment, even in the pockets initially up to 7 mm in depth.

Rationale of mechanical plaque control

Patients who have received extensive periodontal treatment also demonstrate a high susceptibility to periodontal disease. Maintenance of periodontal health following therapy includes a lifelong supportive care consisting of daily removal of the microbial plaque by the patient, supplemented by professional care in an individually designed programme. Mechanical supragingival plaque control by self care is of utmost importance. The goal is to create a positive attitude by information and motivation to give the patient knowledge and confidence. The patient should be advised to use appropriate aids and technique. A soft brush, an interspace brush, interdental tooth brushes or tooth picks are recommended in periodontal patients. Professional tooth cleaning involves removal of supragingival plaque from all tooth surfaces using mechanically driven instruments and fluoride prophy paste and, when indicated, removal of calculus and subgingival plaque. Disclosing solution is used to visualize the plaque to the patient and to the clinician in order to reinforce instruction in oral hygiene. Oral hygiene measures alone seem to have limited effect on subgingival microflora in cases of severe disease. In shallow and moderately deep pockets a good plaque control can change the subgingival flora towards a more "healthy" composition. Subgingival plaque removal is performed with hand- and/or ultrasonic instruments. Cracks within the cementum, grooves, fissures, resorption lacunae, furcations may create difficulties in cleaning the root surface. Ultrasonic instrumentation has a beneficial effect in creating a smooth surface without extensive removal of cementum. Besides, the cavitational activity contributes to plaque removal which makes the instrument further suitable during maintenance therapy. The result of the debridement is assessed on the healing response in the tissues. The frequency of maintenance visits must be given on an individual basis according to the needs of every special patient. The visit includes plaque evaluation (disclosion), oral hygiene instruction, probing depth measurements, registration of bleeding on probing, scaling (plaque removal) if indicated, tooth polishing, fluoride application and radiographs if indicated. The goal is to identify and treat signs of recurrence of periodontal disease in order to prevent further loss of attachment.

Hydrogen peroxide: a review of its use in dentistry

Several dentifrices that contain hydrogen peroxide are currently being marketed. The increased use of bleaching agents containing (or generating) H2O2 prompted this review of the safety of H2O2 when used in oral hygiene. Daily exposure to the low levels of H2O2 present in dentifrices is much lower than that of bleaching agents that contain or produce high levels of H2O2 for an extended period of time. Hydrogen peroxide has been used in dentistry alone or in combination with salts for over 70 years. Studies in which 3% H2O2 or less were used daily for up to 6 years showed occasional transitory irritant effects only in a small number of subjects with preexisting ulceration, or when high levels of salt solutions were concurrently administered. In contrast, bleaching agents that employ or generate high levels of H2O2 or organic peroxides can produce localized oral toxicity following sustained exposure if mishandled. Potential health concerns related to prolonged hydrogen peroxide use have been raised, based on animal studies. From a single study using the hamster cheek pouch model, 30% H2O2 was referred to as a cocarcinogen in the oral mucosa. This (and later) studies have shown that at 3% or less, no cocarcinogenic activity or adverse effects were observed in the hamster cheek pouch following lengthy exposure to H2O2. In patients, prolonged use of hydrogen peroxide decreased plaque and gingivitis indices. However, therapeutic delivery of H2O2 to prevent periodontal disease required mechanical access to subgingival pockets. Furthermore, wound healing following gingival surgery was enhanced due to the antimicrobial effects of topically administered hydrogen peroxide. For most subjects, beneficial effects were seen with H2O2 levels above 1%.

The effects on chronic periodontitis of a subgingivally-placed redox agent in a slow release device

Adjunctive chemical agents can reduce the need for meticulous plaque control. The aim of this investigation was to evaluate the periodontal treatment potential of subgingival application of the redox agent methylene blue in a slow-release device. This randomized, single-blind, split-mouth study included 18 patients aged 35-57 years, with chronic adult periodontitis, pocketing of at least 5 mm and radiographic evidence of regular bone loss. All experimental sites received subgingival debridement at day 0. Test sites received 32% w/w methylene blue in the slow release device at days 0 and 28. Clinical examination and microbiological sampling were performed at days 0, 7, 28, 56 and 84. Clinical improvements were seen in both groups, but test sites showed consistently greater improvements, some of which were statistically significant (as determined by between-group comparisons utilising SNDs). Significant between-group differences in relation to baseline levels were seen in bleeding index at days 7 and 56, in probeable pocket depth at day 56 and for the Perioscan BANA test at day 7. This pilot study thus showed that adjunctive methylene blue in a slow-release device can produce greater clinical and microbiological improvements than subgingival debridement alone.

DNA probe detection of periodontopathogens in advanced periodontitis

Species-specific DNA probes were used to determine the presence of Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans (A.a.), Porphyromonas (Bacteroides) gingivalis, Prevotella intermedia, Treponema denticola, Eikenella corrodens, Fusobacterium nucleatum, and Wolinella recta in subgingival plaque from deep pockets/sites of patients with advanced periodontitis. The subjects were 20 patients with severe adult periodontitis, 13 men and 7 women (mean age 45.6 +/- 6.7 yr). For each subject, 9-10 subgingival sites with the deepest probing depths from each quadrant were sampled by the paper point method, a total of 198 sites, with mean probing depth 7.2 +/- 1.6 mm and clinical attachment level 9.5 +/- 2.7 mm. A.a. was present in at least one site in 75% of the subjects; P. gingivalis was found in 95%; P. intermedia and W. recta were found in 90%, respectively; and T. denticola, E. corrodens, and F. nucleatum were found in all subjects. In the 198 samples, A.a. was detected in 25.8%, P. gingivalis in 51.5%, P. intermedia in 64.1%, T. denticola in 60.6%, E. corrodens in 72.9%, F. nucleatum in 74.7%, and W. recta in 65.7%. The predominant combination was the simultaneous presence of P. intermedia, T. denticola, E. corrodens, F. nucleatum, and W. recta in 89.5% of the subjects and 46.8% of the sites. Of these sites, 51.1% showed the combined presence of P. gingivalis and 28.4% that of both A.a. and P. gingivalis. None of the seven bacteria could be detected in 14.4% of the total sites sampled. The present study indicates that severe destructive adult periodontitis is a multibacterial infection and that certain combinations of periodontopathogens seem to be important in the pathogenesis of the disease.

Oral imaging as a diagnostic tool for assessing osseous changes

Practical use of images for diagnosis of osseous abnormalities presumes cost-effective technology that targets known physiologic processes. The most obvious modalities for such applications are radiographic, and the newest are characterized by quantitative methods expressed both tomographically and by means of digital subtraction registered in two and three dimensions. Quantitative nuclear medicine and possibly electron spin resonance spectroscopy also appear promising. New analytic techniques for interpreting osseous images include characterization of trabecular patterns by fractal descriptors and micromorphometry.

Subgingival minocycline hydrochloride ointment in moderate to severe chronic adult periodontitis: a randomized, double-blind, vehicle-controlled, multicenter study

The safety and efficacy of subgingivally-applied 2% minocycline ointment was evaluated in a randomized, double-blind study of 103 adults with moderate to severe periodontitis. Two groups were compared; one received the test minocycline ointment and the other a vehicle control. Both groups had scaling and root planing at baseline, after which the test or control ointments were applied with an applicator into the periodontal pockets at baseline, and at 2, 4, and 6 weeks. Assessment of clinical response was made by measuring probing depth and probing attachment level and gingival bleeding. These measurements were made at baseline prior to scaling and root planing, and at weeks 4 and 12. Microbiological assessment of the subgingival flora was carried out with DNA probes at baseline, and at weeks 2, 4, 6, and 12 to identify and quantify Porphyromonas gingivalis, Prevotella intermedia, and Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans. Subgingival minocycline ointment resulted in statistically significantly greater reduction of P. gingivalis at weeks 2, 4, 6, and 12; P. intermedia at weeks 2, 4, 6, and 12; and A. actinomycetemcomitans at weeks 6 and 12. Probing depth reductions were seen for both groups at weeks 4 and 12; however, this reduction was statistically significantly greater in subjects treated with minocycline ointment. Reduction in gingival index and probing attachment gain were seen in both groups, however, the differences between the groups were not statistically significant.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Suppression of subgingival Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans in localized juvenile periodontitis by systemic tetracycline

The current study assessed the clinical and microbiological effects of systemic antimicrobial therapy alone in Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans-infected adolescents with periodontal disease. The study involved 6 localized juvenile periodontitis patients 13-18 years of age, who harbored high numbers of A. actinomycetemcomitans in subgingival plaque samples. The periodontal lesions were microbiologically monitored by selective culture, and clinically assessed for probing pocket depth and periodontal attachment level 3 months prior to baseline, and at 3, 6, 12, and 24 months posttreatment. Tetracycline-HCl (250 mg/QID) was prescribed until 1 week after subgingival A. actinomycetemcomitans was no longer detectable or for a maximum of 8 weeks. During 3 months prior to treatment, pocket depth was unchanged, and was then significantly reduced from an average of 7.1 mm to 5.1 mm 12 months after treatment (p = 0.02). The mean change in clinical attachment level was a gain of 1.4 mm between baseline and 12 months (p = 0.02). 3 of the 6 patients were still infected with A. actinomycetemcomitans after 8 weeks of antibiotic therapy and 4 subjects were infected at 12 months. Numbers of A. actinomycetemcomitans were still suppressed in most lesions. There was a strong association between mean numbers of A. actinomycetemcomitans in periodontal pockets and mean change in probing attachment level at any given time point. For 22 available comparisons, derived from all time points, there was a strong association (r = 0.68) between subgingival A. actinomycetemcomitans and change in probing attachment level.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Topical application of tetracycline-HCl in human periodontitis

Previous in vitro studies have suggested that tetracycline-HCl (TTC-HCl) is adsorbed and actively released from root dentin. The aim of the current study was to evaluate the binding to and release of TTC-HCl from human root dentin surfaces in vivo, and to evaluate the clinical utility of TTC-HCl irrigation as an adjunct to scaling and root planing. Experiment I utilized two contralateral mandibular single-rooted teeth which were examined in four adults with severe generalized periodontitis. One tooth in each patient was carefully scaled and root planed, under local anesthesia, and the other used as an unscaled control. Each subgingival root surface was irrigated for 5 min with an aqueous TTC-HCl solution at a concentration of 100 mg/ml. Gingival crevicular fluid samples were collected on paper strips for the next three weeks. The TTC-HCl concentrations in each sample were determined by the inhibition zone of B. cereus cultured on agar plates. The TTC-HCl concentrations in gingival crevicular fluid collected 15 min after irrigation were 3100 +/- 670 micrograms/ml from the scaled lesions and 4700 +/- 1300 micrograms/ml from the unscaled root surfaces. The antibiotic concentrations decreased logarithmically over the next 7 days; 1500 +/- 270 micrograms/ml and 1100 +/- 330 micrograms/ml at 2 h, 880 +/- 350 micrograms/ml and 1300 +/- 360 micrograms/ml at 6 h and 19 +/- 5 micrograms/ml and 31 +/- 26 micrograms/ml at 1 week for scaled and unscaled root surfaces, respectively. Results for week two and three indicated an average of over 8 micrograms/ml.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

In vitro susceptibilities of Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans to a number of antimicrobial combinations

The in vitro susceptibilities of Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans to 14 antimicrobial combinations were studied by using the checkerboard titration technique. The results, expressed as the range of the fractional inhibitory concentration indices, were as follows: for metronidazole or its hydroxymetabolite combined with cefixime, 0.2 to 0.6; for moxalactam, 0.2 to 0.6; for penicillin G, 0.3 to 0.6; for tobramycin, 0.8 to 2.0; for erythromycin, 0.8 to 1.7; for ciprofloxacin, 0.2 to 0.6; for tetracycline, 0.8 to 1.2. Our observations indicated that the beta-lactam antibiotics as well as ciprofloxacin act synergistically with both metronidazole and its hydroxymetabolite against A. actinomycetemcomitans. Synergistic interactions were independent of the individual MICs of the antibiotics tested. Erythromycin, tobramycin, and tetracycline combined with either metronidazole or its hydroxymetabolite showed additive to indifferent effects against the five strains of A. actinomycetemcomitans, with the fractional inhibitory concentration indices ranging from 0.8 to 2.0. A. actinomycetemcomitans was found to be highly susceptible to ciprofloxacin (MIC of ciprofloxacin for 90% of strains tested, 0.010 micrograms/ml) and cefixime (MIC of cefixime for 90% of strains tested, 0.8 micrograms/ml). The results indicate that in patients who are allergic to penicillin, cefixime and ciprofloxacin may be useful alternative antibiotics in combination with metronidazole for the treatment of A. actinomycetemcomitans-associated periodontitis.