Bullous pemphigoid: serum antibody titre and antigen specificity

Nonbullous pemphigoid: Insights in clinical and diagnostic findings, treatment responses, and prognosis

BACKGROUND

Nonbullous pemphigoid is an under-recognized phenotype of the autoimmune bullous disease pemphigoid, characterized by the absence of blisters. Several disease aspects have not been studied previously.

OBJECTIVE

To describe the characteristics of nonbullous pemphigoid.

METHODS

A retrospective review study of medical records. The diagnosis of pemphigoid was based on meeting 2 of the following 3 criteria: (1) pruritus, (2) positive direct immunofluorescence microscopy, or (3) positive indirect immunofluorescence microscopy on salt-split skin.

RESULTS

The review included 69 patients. The mean delay in diagnosis was 29 months. Skin examination most often showed pruritic papules/nodules (37%) or pruritus without primary skin lesions (22%). Histopathologic findings were mainly nonspecific. Results of direct and indirect immunofluorescence microscopy were positive in 60% and 69%, respectively. During follow-up, blisters formed in 17%, which was associated with a positive indirect immunofluorescence microscopy (P = .014) and a positive BP180 immunoblot result (P = .032). The Kaplan-Meier estimates of mortality at 1, 2, and 3 years were 14%, 34%, and 46%, respectively, with an 8.6-fold increased all-cause mortality risk.

LIMITATIONS

The retrospective study design.

CONCLUSIONS

Nonbullous pemphigoid presented with heterogeneous pruritic skin lesions, resulting in delayed diagnosis. Direct and indirect immunofluorescence microscopy are essential to diagnose nonbullous pemphigoid, in contrast to histopathology, mainly showing nonspecific findings. An increased all-cause mortality risk was observed during follow-up.

Normal human skin is superior to monkey oesophagus substrate for detection of circulating BP180-NC16A-specific IgG antibodies in bullous pemphigoid

BACKGROUND

Bullous pemphigoid (BP) is the most common autoimmune subepidermal blistering skin disease. Two antigens have been identified as targets of circulating autoantibodies (autoAbs) - BP180 and BP230 - with BP180 being a critical transmembrane adhesion protein of basal keratinocytes of the epidermis. The noncollagenous domain 16A (NC16A) of BP180 is the immunodominant epitope in patients with BP, and anti-BP180-NC16A IgG antibodies (Abs) correlate to disease activity. Routine serological testing and follow-up of BP relies on indirect immunofluorescence (IIF) of serum Abs, commonly performed on monkey oesophagus (ME), and/or enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) testing on recombinantly produced fragments of BP180 and BP230 (BP180-NC16A, BP230-C/N).

OBJECTIVES

To determine if NC16A epitopes are well represented on ME substrate.

METHODS

Sera from different BP cohorts were tested by IIF on ME and normal human skin (NHS). To confirm findings, affinity-purified anti-BP180-NC16A/BP230 polyclonal Abs and recombinant anti-BP180-NC16A/BP230 monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) were used.

RESULTS

For sensitive detection of BP180-NC16A-specific IgG Abs, sections of NHS are superior to the widely used ME. Confirmation comes from polyclonal affinity-purified anti-BP180-NC16A/BP230 Abs, and by mAbs cloned from a patient with active BP.

CONCLUSIONS

Use of NHS is preferable over ME in routine IIF testing for BP. These results are of clinical relevance because anti-BP180-NC16A IgG titres are correlated to disease activity and detecting them reliably is important for screening, diagnosis and follow-up of patients with BP.

Mutation in exon 1a of PLEC, leading to disruption of plectin isoform 1a, causes autosomal-recessive skin-only epidermolysis bullosa simplex

PLEC, the gene encoding the cytolinker protein plectin, has eight tissue-specific isoforms in humans, arising by alternate splicing of the first exon. To date, all PLEC mutations that cause epidermolysis bullosa simplex (EBS) were found in exons common to all isoforms. Due to the ubiquitous presence of plectin in mammalian tissues, EBS from recessive plectin mutations is always associated with extracutaneous involvement including muscular dystrophy, pyloric atresia and cardiomyopathy. We studied a consanguineous family with sisters having isolated blistering suggesting EBS. Skin disease started with foot blisters at walking age and became generalized at puberty while sparing mucous membranes. DNA sequencing revealed a homozygous nonsense mutation (c.46C>T; p.Arg16X) in the first exon of the plectin variant encoding plectin isoform 1a (P1a). Immunofluorescence antigen mapping, transmission electron microscopy, western blot analysis and qRT-PCR were performed on patient skin and cultured keratinocytes, control myocardium and striated muscle samples. We found hypoplastic hemidesmosomes and intra-epidermal 'pseudo-junctional' cleavage fitting EBS. Screening for cardiomyopathy and muscle dystrophy showed no abnormalities. We report the first cases of autosomal-recessive EBS from P1a deficiency affecting skin, while mucous membranes, heart and muscle are spared. The dominant expression of the P1a isoform in epidermal basal cell layer and cultured keratinocytes suggests that mutations in the first exon of isoform 1a cause skin-only EBS without extracutaneous involvement. Our study characterizes yet another of the eight isoforms of plectin and adds a tissue-specific phenotype to the spectrum of 'plectinopathies' produced by mutations of unique first exons of this gene.

Multicenter prospective study of the humoral autoimmune response in bullous pemphigoid

Bullous pemphigoid (BP) is an autoimmune bullous disease, associated with autoantibodies directed against the hemidesmosomal components BP180 and BP230. In this study for the first time different laboratories have analyzed the autoantibody profile in the same group of 49 prospectively recruited BP patients. The results show that: 1) disease severity and activity correlated with levels of IgG against the BP180-NC16A domain, but also against a COOH-terminal epitope of BP180, 2) distinct epitopes of the BP180 ectodomain other than BP180-NC16A were recognized by 96% of the BP sera; and 3) the combined use of BP180 and BP230 ELISA led to the detection of IgG autoantibodies in all the BP sera. These results demonstrate the usefulness of the combined ELISAs based on various BP180 and BP230 fragments in establishing the diagnosis of BP and support the concept that BP180 is the major autoantigen of BP.

Role of BP180NC16a-enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) in the diagnosis of bullous pemphigoid in China

BACKGROUND

Autoantibodies of bullous pemphigoid (BP) patients react with two components of the hemidesmosome of stratified epithelia: the BP antigen 230 (BP230) and the BP antigen 180 (BP180). Recently, strong evidence has been provided that autoantibodies to BP180 play a key role in subepidermal blister formation in BP patients, and NC16A contains an important antigen determinant of BP.

OBJECTIVE

To study the role of BP180NC16a enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (BP180NC16a-ELISA) in the diagnosis of BP in China.

METHODS

Sera from BP patients (n = 42) and control subjects (normal controls, n = 24; pemphigus patients, n = 18) were measured by BP180NC16a-ELISA. All BP sera were obtained at presentation from patients who had not received previous systemic treatment. The values of immunoglobulin G (IgG) antibody levels measured by ELISA were compared with those measured by indirect immunofluorescence (IIF) (gold standard for the diagnosis of BP) on salt-split skin.

RESULTS

Using BP180NC16a-ELISA, 41 of the 42 BP sera were positive, whereas only one of the serum samples from 24 normal controls was positive and all the pemphigus sera showed a negative result. Thus, the sensitivity and specificity of BP180NC16a-ELISA were both 97.62%. There was no correlation between the mean ELISA values and IIF titers. The ELISA and IIF results were further compared and analyzed using a 2 x 2 contingency table, which showed that they were not significantly different.

CONCLUSIONS

It is suggested that BP180NC16a-ELISA is a useful tool for the diagnosis of BP.

Subacute prurigo variant of bullous pemphigoid: autoantibodies show the same specificity compared with classic bullous pemphigoid

We describe a 76-year-old white woman with a 6-month history of intensive pruritus and excoriated papules resembling subacute prurigo. Histopathology showed signs of chronic dermatitis, whereas findings by direct and indirect immunofluorescence microscopy were compatible with bullous pemphigoid (BP). The patient's serum contained IgG autoantibodies that recognized epitopes on both BP180 and BP230 by Western blot analysis of epidermal extracts. In addition, we found strong reactivity with recombinant NC16A, an immunodominant region of BP180 targeted in the majority of BP sera, whereas no antibodies against the keratinocyte-derived soluble BP180 ectodomain (LAD-1) or the recombinant intracellular domain of BP180 were detected. The patient's disease responded well to oral methylprednisolone and mycophenolate mofetil. Disease activity correlated with enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay reactivity of antibodies to BP180 but not with titers of antibodies to the dermoepidermal junction as determined by indirect immunofluorescence on salt-split skin. Our findings suggest that the subacute prurigo form of BP is a true variant of BP.

Partial revertant mosaicism of keratin 14 in a patient with recessive epidermolysis bullosa simplex

A patient with recessive epidermolysis bullosa simplex due to a previously described homozygous KRT14 1842-2A-->C splice-site mutation was re-examined, because we unexpectedly found signs of revertant mosaicism. The germline mutation resulted in different aberrant transcripts containing premature termination codons, all leading to truncated keratin 14 proteins. Basal keratinocytes in skin and in culture completely lacked keratin 14 and intermediate filaments. From this keratin 14-/- patient we started cultures from a new skin biopsy and here, we serendipitously found keratinocytes that spontaneously expressed keratin 14. This biopsy had been taken from an area of skin that was clinically affected, because blisters could simply be evoked by gentle rubbing. Immunofluorescence and electron microscopy of additional biopsies from this skin area revealed a mosaic expression of keratin 14 and reappearance of intermediate filaments in basal keratinocytes. Immunoblotting showed a revertant keratin 14 polypeptide with seemingly normal molecular weight. DNA analysis of exon 2 and its flanking intron borders showed no additional mutations in the genomic KRT14 sequence. Analysis of mRNA isolated from mosaic skin keratinocytes revealed an additional in-frame transcript (1844T-->G, 1845Delta6) that codes for an abnormal keratin 14 polypeptide with a two residue deletion and one amino acid change. The re-expression of a revertant, albeit abnormal, keratin 14 polypeptide, so-called partial revertant mosaicism, accounts for the antibody staining pattern and for the reappearance of intermediate filaments, which however, are semifunctional and not able to revert the clinical phenotype. The combination of a keratin 14-positive and a keratin 14-negative cell population in epidermis as well as in cultured keratinocytes suggests that the cellular reversion might be caused by an endogenous factor. We hypothesize that a second somatic modulating factor in the genome that affects the processing of the mutant KRT14 pre-mRNA may underlie this phenomenon.

False-negative results in immunoblot assay of serum IgA antibodies reactive with the 180-kDa bullous pemphigoid antigen: the importance of primary incubation temperature

BACKGROUND

Different subepidermal autoimmune blistering skin disorders are characterized by linear deposition of IgA, sometimes accompanied by linear IgG, along the epidermal basement membrane zone. Identification of the targeted autoantigen is usually attempted by immunoblotting. Although immunoblotting works well for human IgG, the method is less successful for IgA and often no or only faint signals are obtained.

OBJECTIVES

To improve the method of immunoblotting for diagnosis of IgA-mediated bullous dermatoses.

METHODS

Eleven sera, selected from patients with linear deposition of IgA along the epidermal basement membrane zone in vivo, were tested by immunoblotting for antigen specificity using different primary incubation temperatures.

RESULTS

No reliable information regarding IgA antigen specificity was obtained when the primary incubation was undertaken at room temperature. In 10 of 11 sera, IgA bound to the 180-kDa bullous pemphigoid antigen (BP180) when the primary incubation temperature was increased to 37 degrees C.

CONCLUSIONS

Primary incubation at room temperature may result in false-negative results in the IgA-BP180 immunoblot assay.

Type XVII collagen (BP180) and LAD-1 are present as separate trimeric complexes

This study characterized the high molecular mass BP180 complex that is observed when unheated sodium dodecyl sulfate extracts of human skin or keratinocytes are subjected to sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and immunoblotting. In heated extracts BP180 is present as a monomer with a molecular weight of 180 kDa, in unheated extracts BP180 runs at a molecular weight position over 500 kDa. By preincubating the unheated extracts at temperatures between 31 degrees C and 40 degrees C, the high molecular weight complex could be "melted" down to monomeric BP180. Under the conditions employed the T1/2 of the dissociation process was between 35 degrees C and 36 degrees C. The temperature resistance of the high molecular weight complex was used to analyze its molecular composition by performing two-dimensional electrophoresis with a "low-temperature" first dimension step and a "high-temperature" second dimension step. Silver staining and immunoblotting of the two-dimensional gels revealed the high molecular weight complex to be composed of solely BP180, indicating that the complex is the nondissociated homotrimeric form of BP180. The 120 kDa linear IgA dermatosis antigen (LAD-1) is an collagenous anchoring filament protein with homology to the extracellular collagenous part of BP180. Two-dimensional immunoblotting showed that LAD-1, as BP180, is also present as a high molecular mass complex and does not form mixed complexes with BP180.

Paraneoplastic pemphigus as the presenting symptom of a lymphoma of the tongue

A patient is described who initially presented with an acrovesicular eczema which subsequently developed into erythema multiforme with histopathological features of bullous pemphigoid. Although the various laboratory studies pointed to the diagnosis of paraneoplastic pemphigus (PNP), the underlying neoplasm was not detected until 6 months later, when the biopsies of an oral lesion showed the presence of an underlying non-Hodgkin lymphoma.

Altered expression of epithelial cell surface glycoconjugates and intermediate filaments at the margins of mucosal wounds

Alterations in cell to cell adhesion are necessary to enable the type of cell movements that are associated with epithelial wound healing and malignant invasion. Several studies of transformed cells have related epithelial cell movement to changes in the cell surface expression of the carbohydrate structures represented by the ABO blood group antigens and, in particular, by Lewis antigens and their biosynthetic precursors. To study further the relationship between cell surface carbohydrates and keratinocyte cell movement, experimental wounds were created in human oral mucosa and examined by immunohistochemical methods for their expression of selected cytokeratins (K5, K16, K19), basement membrane components (laminin alpha5 and gamma2-chains, BP180, collagen IV and collagen VII), and blood group antigen precursor structures Le(x), sialosyl-Le(x), Le(y), H antigen, N-acetyllactosamine, and sialosyl-T antigen. The changes induced by wounding in the expression of collagen IV, laminin gamma2-chain (laminin-5), and laminin alpha5-chain were similar to those found in skin wounds and served to define the region of epithelial movement. This region was found to show a marked increase in staining for both Lewis antigen Y (Le(y)) and H blood group antigen, and decreased staining of Le(x), thus indicating an upregulation in wounded epithelium of the fucosyltransferases responsible for the synthesis of the H antigen. The changes in carbohydrate expression extended beyond the wound margin into the nonwounded epithelium, a pattern of expression similar to K16, which was also strongly upregulated in both the outgrowth and the adjacent nonwounded epithelium. These findings provide further support for an influence of such carbohydrate structures on the migratory behavior of epithelial cells.

Molecular biological aspects of acquired bullous diseases

Bullous diseases of the oral mucosa and skin were originally classified on the basis of clinical and histological criteria. The discovery of autoantibodies in some of these patients and the introduction of molecular biology have resulted in a new understanding of the pathological mechanisms of many of the bullous lesions. In this article, updated topics of the immune-mediated bullous lesions which involve oral mucosa and skin are reviewed. Pemphigus antigens, which are desmosomal-associated proteins and belong to the cadherin superfamily of cell adhesion proteins, have been isolated, and their genes have been cloned. The antigens which react with autoantibodies from patients with bullous pemphigoid, cicatricial pemphigoid, acquired epidermolysis bullosa, and linear IgA disease are all proteins of the hemidesmosome basement membrane complex. Interestingly, most of the antigens also appear to be the target for mutations seen in patients with the inherited type of epidermolysis bullosa in which bullous lesions are a prominent clinical feature.

Revertant mosaicism in epidermolysis bullosa caused by mitotic gene conversion

Mitotic gene conversion acting as reverse mutation has not been previously demonstrated in human. We report here that the revertant mosaicism of a compound heterozygous proband with an autosomal recessive genodermatosis, generalized atrophic benign epidermolysis bullosa, is caused by mitotic gene conversion of one of the two mutated COL17A1 alleles. Specifically, the maternal allele surrounding the mutation site on COL17A1 (1706delA) showed reversion of the mutation and loss of heterozygosity along a tract of at least 381 bp in revertant keratinocytes derived from clinically unaffected skin patches; the paternal mutation (R1226X) remained present in all cell samples. Revertant mosaicism represents a way of natural gene therapy.

Effects of keratin 14 ablation on the clinical and cellular phenotype in a kindred with recessive epidermolysis bullosa simplex

We studied a kindred with recessive epidermolysis bullosa simplex in which the affected members lacked expression of the basal cell keratin 14. The patients had severe generalized skin blistering that improved slightly with age. The basal cells of the patients did not express keratin 14 and contained no keratin intermediate filaments. The expression of keratin 5, the obligate copolymer of keratin 14, was slightly reduced. The expression of keratin 15, the alternative basal cell keratin, was increased, suggesting upregulation or stabilization to compensate for the lack of keratin 14. The expression of keratin 16, keratin 17, and keratin 19 in the patient's skin was not different from controls. Immunoelectron microscopy showed a loose network of keratin 5/keratin 15 protofilaments in the basal cells. Keratin 15 filaments did not aggregate into higher order bundles. Sequence analysis of genomic DNA revealed a homozygous mutation in the 3'-acceptor splice site of intron 1 (1840 A-->C) in the affected individuals. This mutation led to the skipping of exon 2 in 24% of the KRT14 transcripts and to the use of a cryptic splice site in 76% of the transcripts. Premature termination codons were generated in all transcripts (codons 175+1 or 175+29), leading to a truncated keratin 14 protein within the helical 1B rod domain. The disorder was associated with circumscribed hyperkeratotic lesions with the histology of epidermolytic hyperkeratosis. The prognosis of keratin 14 ablation is much better in the human than in the mouse.