Breaking the first circle

Immune Response Regulation by Antigen Receptors' Clone-Specific Nonself Parts

Antigen determinants (epitopes) are recognized by the combining sites (paratopes) of B and T cell antigen receptors (BCR/TCR), which again express clone-specific epitopes (idiotopes) that can be recognized by BCR/TCR not only of genetically different donors but also within the autologous immune system. While xenogeneic and allogeneic anti-idiotypic BCR/TCR are broadly cross-reactive, only autologous anti-idiotypes are truly specific and of functional regulatory relevance within a particular immune system. Autologous BCR/TCR idiotopes are (a) somatically created at the third complementarity-determining regions, (b) through mutations introduced into BCRs during adaptive immune responses, and (c) through the conformational impact of both. As these idiotypic characters have no genomic counterparts they have to be regarded as antigen receptor-intrinsic nonself-portions. Although foreign, however, they are per se non-immunogenic, but in conjunction with immunogenicity- and adjuvanticity-providing antigen-induced immune responses, they induce abating regulatory idiotypic chain reactions. The dualistic nature of antigen receptors of seeing antigens (self and nonself alike) and being nonself at the same time has far reaching consequences for an understanding of the regulation of adaptive immune responses.

Structural insights into the evolution of an antibody combining site

The crystal structures of a germline antibody Fab fragment and its complex with hapten have been solved at 2.1 A resolution. These structures are compared with the corresponding crystal structures of the affinity-matured antibody, 48G7, which has a 30,000 times higher affinity for hapten as a result of nine replacement somatic mutations. Significant changes in the configuration of the combining site occur upon binding of hapten to the germline antibody, whereas hapten binds to the mature antibody by a lock-and-key fit mechanism. The reorganization of the combining site that was nucleated by hapten binding is further optimized by somatic mutations that occur up to 15 from bound hapten. These results suggest that the binding potential of the primary antibody repertoire may be significantly expanded by the ability of germline antibodies to adopt more than one combining-site configuration, with both antigen binding and somatic mutation stabilizing the configuration with optimal hapten complementarity.

Assessment of a functional role of auto-anti-idiotypes in idiotype dominance

We have used a well-defined idiotypic system, the cross-reactive idiotype of A strain (CRIA) (Ab1) idiotype generated in A/J mice injected with arsonate coupled to keyhole limpet hemocyanin (ARS-KLH), to determine the frequency of precursors for auto-anti-idiotypic antibodies (auto-Ab2) in naive and immunized A/J mice by limiting dilution analysis after polyclonal activation by lipopolysaccharide. In naive animals, the precursor frequencies of auto-Ab2 B cells were below the limit of sensitivity of the technique in the majority of A/J mice, and could be detected in only 20% of the animals. Upon immunization with ARS-KLH, a large increase in auto-Ab2 precursor frequency was observed. This shift in frequency was not found when A/J mice were injected with KLH alone, or when BALB/c mice, which do not express the CRIA idiotype, were injected with ARS-KLH. To study the functional role of the auto-Ab2 B cells, we injected neonatal A/J mice with polyclonal rabbit Ab3 antibodies directed against a recurrent idiotype of auto-Ab2. Thereafter, these mice were injected with ARS-KLH. Although the anti-arsonate response level was normal, the CRIA Ab1 expression was reduced tenfold. Thus, the suppression of auto-Ab2 affects Ab1 dominance. We further show that the presence of maternal Ab1 can strongly modify the immune response of the offspring by inducing higher levels of the idiotype after immunization. Furthermore, IgM anti-arsonate antibodies were detected before immunization with antigen. From these data, we conclude that the affinity of antigen alone cannot explain the dominance of CRIA. Network selection is important in the shaping of the available repertoire.

Immunoglobulin VH and VK genes of the BALB/c anti-foot-and-mouth disease virus (O1) VP1 response: cloning, characterization and transgenic mice

Hybridomas producing monoclonal antibodies of different isotypes were isolated from BALB/c antibody responses to the capsid protein VP1 of the foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) strain O1. According to antigen binding measured by ELISA a weak-binding (81D10, IgM) and a strong-binding antibody (113C12, IgG2a) were selected. As RNA sequencing of productive immunoglobulin VH and VK genes turned out, both chains of the weak-binding antibody (81D10) are encoded by germline (i.e. not mutated) genes whereas the gene encoding the strong-binding antibody (113C12) k chain is mutated at several sites. Therefore, rearranged VH and VK genes of 81D10 were cloned, expressed in immunoglobulin non-producing plasmacytoma cells, and mice transgenic for the 81D10 k gene were produced. These mice provide a first step in the development of a transgenic mouse model for genetical investigations in the affinity maturation of anti-viral immunoglobulin variable genes.

Poly(Glu60Ala30Tyr10) (GAT)-induced IgG monoclonal antibodies cross-react with various self and non-self antigens through the complementarity determining regions. Comparison with IgM monoclonal polyreactive natural antibodies

Previous studies have shown that the antibodies of the preimmune repertoire are able to bind to various auto- and xenoantigens including chemical haptens. Sequence analysis of two such murine monoclonal IgM natural autoantibodies showed that they are encoded by unmutated germ-line variable regions of the light and heavy chain (V alpha and VH) genes which were also found in various murine immune responses, like phenyl-oxazolone, dinitrophenyl, arsonate, phosphorylcholine and influenza virus hemagglutinin. These data raised the question as to whether induced antibodies possessing germ-line sequence are also able to react with autoantigens. To study this problem, anti-poly(Glu60Ala30Tyr10) (GAT) and anti-alprenolol (Alp) monoclonal antibodies, carrying similar VH and V alpha genes and the same IgG1 isotype, were examined for their capacity to react with several self and non-self antigens. The results showed that: (a) the anti-GAT antibodies tested reacted with different autoantigens, such as murine tubulin, actin and myosin as well as trinitrophenyl (TNP) and bovine serum albumin. Similarly, one of the anti-Alp showed weak reactivities for myosin, DNA, actin and TNP; (b) in contrast two other anti-Alp antibodies did not react with any of the tested antigens. Since the major differences between the oligoreactive anti-GAT and the monoreactive anti-Alp antibodies are in the complementarity determining regions (CDR) our results suggest that the observed cross-reactions are mediated by hypervariable loops. Sequence comparison of these antibodies indicate a possible correlation between cross-reactivity and the presence of aromatic and charged amino acids in the CDR.

Poor repertoire selection in symmetric idiotypic network models

The selection of B and T cell repertoires is known to be influence by idiotypic interactions during early ontogeny. Early B cell clones are multi-specific, have numerous idiotypic interactions, produce IgM antibodies, and may constitute a separate cell lineage (characterised by the Ly1 or CD5 marker). Furthermore, because early B cells are self-reactive, self antigens should play a crucial role in the repertoire selection. Previously we developed a theoretical model of idiotypic B cell interactions. The model is based on a (symmetric) bell-shaped interaction function. The symmetry and the shape are a consequence of the process of receptor crosslinking. Assuming that early (i.e. IgM) B cell interactions are independent of helper T cell activation, we now apply this model to the problem of idiotypic repertoire selection. In the model the molecular structures of B cell receptors (i.e. of the idiotypes) and of self antigens are represented by random (bit)patterns. Interactions are based on complementary matches between these patterns. Therefore, the repertoire selection is brought about by stimulatory networks based upon complementary matches. These results show that the presence of a self antigen specifically shapes the B cell repertoire. The selection depends on the nature of the antigenic signal; we incorporate either stimulatory or inhibitory (i.e. tolerizing) self antigens. Clones stimulated by the self antigen tend to become aggressive in the network; tolerized self-reactive clones tend to become suppressed. Thus, idiotypic interactions play a facilitating role in self/non-self discrimination. However, since the idiotypic selection is only a tendency, the immune system should not rely on it. We next incorporate two classes of B cells. We call them the early, or "IgM", and the late, or "IgG", B cells (IgG B cells appear after the development of the IgM repertoire). IgG B cells may have only a few idiotypic interactions. We investigate whether the early IgM repertoire, which is (partly) selected by self antigen, influences the selection of the late IgG repertoire. It turns out that this influence can only be non-specific. Either we find a similar tendency in the IgG repertoire, or we find that the IgG repertoire influences the IgM repertoire non-specifically. Thus, despite the fact that this theoretical work readily confirms empirical results showing that the manipulation of early idiotypic interactions can have specific and long-lasting effects, the presupposed physiological role of these interactions, in terms of self-reactivity or repertoire selection, fails to develop in our models.

Idiotypic networks incorporating T-B cell co-operation. The conditions for percolation

Previous work was concerned with symmetric immune networks of idiotypic interactions amongst B cell clones. The behaviour of these networks was contrary to expectations. This was caused by an extensive percolation of idiotypic signals. Idiotypic activation was thus expected to affect almost all (greater than 10(7] B cell clones. We here analyse whether the incorporation of helper T cells (Th) into these B cell models could cause a reduction in the percolation. Empirical work on idiotypic interactions between Th and B cells however, would suggest that two different idiotypic Th models should be developed: (1) a Th which recognises native B cell idiotypes, i.e. a non-MHC-restricted "ThId" model, and (2) a "classical" MHC-restricted helper T cell model. In the ThId model, the Th-B cell interaction is symmetric. A 2-D model of a Th and a B cell clone that interact idiotypically with each other accounts for various equilibria (i.e. one virgin and two immune states). Introduction of antigen does indeed lead to a state switch from the virgin to the immune state; such a system is thus able to "remember" its exposure to antigen. Idiotypic signals do however, percolate in ThId models via these "B-Th-B-Th" pathways: proliferating Th and B cell clones that interact idiotypically, will always activate each other reciprocally. In the MHC-restricted Th model, Th-B interactions are asymmetric. Because the B cell idiotypes are processed and subsequently presented by MHC molecules, the Th receptor and the native B cell receptor are not expected to be complementary. Thus the Th and the B cells are unable to activate each other reciprocally, and a 2-D Th-B cell model cannot account for idiotypic memory. In contrast to the ThId model, idiotypic activation cannot percolate via "B-Th-B-Th" interactions. Due to the assymmetry idiotypic activation stops at the first Th level. A Th clone cannot activate a subsequent B cell clone: if the B cells recognise the Th cells, they see idiotype but get no help; if the Th cells see the B cells, the B cells are helped but see no idiotype. The percolation along "B-B-B" pathways in these two models is next analysed. Two B cells clones, each helped by one Th clone, are connected by a symmetric idiotypic interaction. It turns out that in both models the second (i.e. anti-idiotypic) B cells (B2) never proliferate.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)