The effect of culture filtrates of oral strains of black-pigmented Bacteroides on the matrix production of chick embryo cartilage cells in vitro

Supernatant cytotoxicity and proteolytic activity of selected oral bacteria against human gingival fibroblasts in vitro

The purpose of this study was to determine if endodontic bacterial act in vitro on human gingival fibroblast functions via extracellular products. The bacteria used were Prevotella nigrescens, Capnocytophaga ochracea, Peptostreptoccocus micros and Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans. Supernatants were collected from bacterial cultures at the beginning of the stationary phase when their density was similar. Toxins that inhibited fibroblast proliferation were found in all culture supernatants of Gram-positive or Gram-negative bacterial strains, except for Prev. nigrescens. The cytotoxicity of A. actinomycetemcomitans supernatant was about 1000 fold higher than the others. This supernatant diluted to 1/1000 led to total fibroblast growth inhibition whereas only 25% growth inhibition was obtained with Capn. ochracea and Pept. micros diluted to 1/10. Bacterial supernatant proteolytic activity was investigated in confluent fibroblast cultures that were incubated for 48 hr with each of the supernatants diluted to 1/2 except for A. actinomycetemcomitans supernatant diluted to 1/20. Indirect immunofluorescence studies of extracellular-matrix molecules, followed by immunoelectrophoretic analysis of extracts of whole-cell layers, demonstrated that only conditioned medium of Prev. nigrescens had a proteolytic activity capable of degrading the greater part of type I collagen and fibronectin fibres in the extracellular matrix.

Evidence for genetic control of changes in f-actin polymerization caused by pathogenic microorganisms: in vitro assessment using gingival fibroblasts from human twins

Attachment to and migration upon a substratum, as well as other functions of connective tissue cells, are regulated mainly by cytoplasmic structural proteins, particularly filamentous actin (f-actin). Pathogenic microorganisms exert negative effects on cytoskeletal proteins. In the present study, normal gingival fibroblasts from 10 sets of human twins (6 fraternal, DZ; 4 identical, MZ) were exposed to soluble extracts from Porphyromonas gingivalis or Fusobacterium nucleatum, then f-actin was stained using FITC-labeled phalloidin. Cells were examined under fluorescence, and a computer-assisted image analyzer quantitated f-actin polymerization as fluorescence intensity on a per-cell basis. Intraclass correlation coefficients for f-actin in MZ/MZ vis-a-vis DZ/DZ paired cell cultures were determined to assess the possible heritability of responses to the microorganism preparations. F-actin labeling was significantly different between control cultures and those exposed to the extracts. Both F. nucleatum and P. gingivalis effected f-actin and fibroblast morphology. When the data were adjusted for gender and age effects, and for differences in control f-actin levels, fibroblasts from MZ twin pairs were moderately similar in both absolute and relative responses to bacterial challenges; cells from DZ twins showed little similarity when response was measured on the absolute scale, and moderate similarity using the relative scale.

Characterization of inhibitory effects of suspected periodontopathogens on osteogenesis in vitro

By using an in vitro bone-forming culture system, the chick periosteal osteogenesis (CPO) model, the direct effects on osteogenesis of sonicated extracts derived from oral bacteria were examined. Both extracts from bacterial species having strong associations with periodontal diseases (Porphyromonas gingivalis, Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans, and Prevotella intermedia, hereinafter referred to as suspected periodontopathogens) and extracts from species not correlated with periodontal disease (Streptococcus sanguis, Veillonella atypica, and Prevotella denticola, hereinafter referred to as nonpathogenic bacteria) were tested. All bacterial cultures were grown under standard anaerobic culture conditions. Sonicated bacterial extracts were prepared from the bacterial pellet. These were added in various proportions to the CPO cultures. Parameters of osteogenesis, including alkaline phosphatase activity, calcium and P(i) accumulation, and collagen synthesis, were measured in 6-day-old cultures. Compared with controls grown in the absence of bacterial products, osteogenesis was inhibited significantly in cultures treated with extracts derived from the suspected periodontopathogens. No osteogenic inhibition was observed in cultures treated with extracts from the nonpathogenic bacteria. These results suggest that the ability to inhibit osteogenesis in vitro may be a pathogenic property shared by a limited group of species. Further characterization of the P. gingivalis extracts revealed that both proteinaceous and nonproteinaceous products, including lipopolysaccharide, were able to inhibit osteogenesis. P. gingivalis extract-mediated inhibition of osteogenesis in CPO cultures was blocked by indomethacin, implicating prostaglandins in the regulation of the bacterial effects. The bacterial extracts had either reversible or irreversible inhibitory effects on osteogenesis when added after differentiation or before/during differentiation of bone cells, respectively.

Direct effects of metabolic products and sonicated extracts of Porphyromonas gingivalis 2561 on osteogenesis in vitro

It is well documented that oral microorganisms play a significant role in the initiation and progression of periodontal disease. By using various in vitro models, it has been shown that some bacteria considered periodontal pathogens or their products can stimulate bone resorption and some other parameters of osteoblast-like cell activity. However, the effects of these organisms and their products on osteogenesis itself are not known. This study was undertaken to determine the direct effects of metabolic products and sonicated extracts of Porphyromonas gingivalis on bone formation in the chick periosteal osteogenesis model. Cultures of P. gingivalis 2561 were grown under standard anaerobic culture conditions. The spent medium was collected, and following centrifugation, sonicated bacterial extracts were prepared from the bacterial pellet. These were added in various proportions to the chick periosteal osteogenesis cultures. Sonicated extracts were further fractionated into five molecular-size ranges and similarly tested. Parameters of osteogenesis, including alkaline phosphatase activity, calcium and Pi accumulation, and collagen synthesis, were measured on 6-day-old cultures. Compared with controls devoid of bacterial products, osteogenesis was inhibited significantly in cultures treated with either conditioned medium or extracts obtained from P. gingivalis. Various amounts of inhibitory activity were observed in the different ultrafiltration molecular-size fractions, with very profound inhibitory effects observed in the < 5-kDa range. Histological observations indicated the presence of cells, some bone, and/or new fibrous connective tissue at all concentrations, indicating that toxicity was not a factor. These results suggest that periodontal pathogens such as P. gingivalis might contribute to the bone loss in periodontal diseases not only by stimulating resorption but, possibly, by inhibiting bone formation directly.

Identification of components in Fusobacterium nucleatum chemostat-culture supernatants that are potent inhibitors of human gingival fibroblast proliferation

The present investigation concerned the effect of chemostat-culture cell-free supernatants of Fusobacterium nucleatum on the growth and synthetic activity of human gingival fibroblasts in vitro. Human gingival fibroblasts were cultured in fetal calf serum supplemented Dulbecco-Vogt medium containing various dilutions of conditioned or unconditioned bacterial culture medium. Cell proliferation was monitored by assessing cell growth over 5 days or incorporation of [3H]-thymidine into DNA. Protein and proteoglycan synthesis were monitored by the incorporation of [3H]-proline and [35S]-sulfate, respectively, into macromolecules. While the conditioned culture medium caused a complete inhibition of cell growth and incorporation of [3H]-thymidine DNA, there was no discernible effect on protein or proteoglycan synthesis. This indicated that the cells remained viable yet unable to divide. Such a view was supported by the observation that the inhibitory effect was reversible upon removal of the conditioned medium. This activity had a molecular size less than 30,000, was heat-stable and nonvolatile. Chemical analysis of the conditioned bacterial culture supernatants indicated that high proportions of butyrate, ammonium, and acetate were present. When these components were added to unconditioned medium and tested, most of the inhibitory activity could be attributed to ammonium and butyrate. Since many bacteria which constitute the subgingival microflora release ammonium and butyrate, a very high concentration of these metabolites may well accumulate. Clearly, the potential for inhibition of fibroblast proliferation has ramifications related to diminished tissue repair following bacterially-induced periodontal destruction.

Factors in virulence expression and their role in periodontal disease pathogenesis

The classic progression of the development of periodontitis with its associated formation of an inflammatory lesion is characterized by a highly reproducible microbiological progression of a Gram-positive microbiota to a highly pathogenic Gram-negative one. While this Gram-negative microbiota is estimated to consist of at least 300 different microbial species, it appears to consist of a very limited number of microbial species that are involved in the destruction of periodontal diseases. Among these "putative periodontopathic species" are members of the genera Porphyromonas, Bacteroides, Fusobacterium, Wolinella, Actinobacillus, Capnocytophaga, and Eikenella. While members of the genera Actinomyces and Streptococcus may not be directly involved in the microbial progression, these species do appear to be essential to the construction of the network of microbial species that comprise both the subgingival plaque matrix. The temporal fluctuation (emergence/disappearance) of members of this microbiota from the developing lesion appears to depend upon the physical interaction of the periodontal pocket inhabitants, as well as the utilization of the metabolic end-products of the respective species intimately involved in the disease progression. A concerted action of the end-products of prokaryotic metabolism and the destruction of host tissues through the action of a large number of excreted proteolytic enzymes from several of these periodontopathogens contribute directly to the periodontal disease process.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Cytotoxic and immunostimulatory effects of Bacteroides cell products

The etiologic role of Bacteroides in both periodontal and periapical infections has been well documented, with current interest focusing on the specific pathogenic mechanisms involved. The effects of cell fractions derived from Bacteroides gingivalis (BG), Bacteroides intermedius (BI), and Bacteroides asaccharolyticus (BA) have been studied in vitro through: an assessment of the direct cytotoxic effects on human gingival fibroblasts using a tetrazolium dye reduction assay, an evaluation of murine lymphocyte stimulation and interleukin-1 release, and the induction of human lymphocyte-mediated cytotoxicity. Both BG and BI stimulated interleukin-1 release (P less than 0.001), while BA, a nonoral organism, was not significantly active in this respect. Only BG sonicates were able to induce lymphocyte-mediated cytotoxicity (P less than 0.005). All three Bacteroides species demonstrated direct cytotoxic effects on cultured gingival fibroblasts, and these effects were related to the relative protein content and endotoxin activity of the sonicate preparations for each organism. These data show that BG and BI possess factors which may enhance their virulence through activities not shared with BA.

Direct and immune-cell-mediated effects of Bacteroides gingivalis on bone metabolism in vitro

We investigated direct and immune-cell-mediated effects of Bacteroides gingivalis on bone metabolism in vitro. Fetal mouse long-bone rudiments were cultured under aerobic conditions in the presence of (a) intact bacteria, (b) low molecular weight (MW less than 1000) metabolic products of the bacteria, or (c) conditioned media of mouse spleen cells activated by whole bacteria. A suspension of intact bacteria, added directly to the bone culture, had no effect on bone resorption or bone formation. Low molecular weight (MW less than 1000) excretion products of the bacteria inhibited bone resorption and transiently reduced mineralization of the diaphysis, while the growth in length of the bones was not affected. However, conditioned media of bacteria-activated spleen cells strongly enhanced bone resorption and increased osteoclast numbers in the bone culture, while inhibiting mineral formation in the diaphysis. This led to a strongly negative mineral balance. These data do not support a direct effect of either bacteria or bacterial products on bone tissue as a likely explanation for bone loss in periodontal disease. Rather, they favour the concept that the loss of bone in this disease is an indirect effect of the host response, resulting from the contact of immune cells with the bacteria. This implies that bacterial invasion of the connective tissue of the gingiva may not be a prerequisite for alveolar bone loss.

Particles and molecules in endodontic leakage

It is assumed that above a critical level, microleakage causes periapical disease and jeopardizes periapical tissue repair. The purpose of this investigation was first to find out to what degree obturation prevents leakage of bacteria-sized particles or large protein molecules, and second if leakage of the commonly used dye methylene blue is comparable with that of a small bacterial metabolic product of similar molecular size. Sections, 9 mm long, obtained from 46 extracted human incisor roots had their root canals prepared in a standardized manner and obturated in four experimental ways using gutta-percha. The root sections were mounted in the middle of tubes that were closed at both ends with rubber membrane stoppers, which permitted sampling from the apical reservoir. The coronal reservoir was filled with a solution of 1 mg/ml latex beads, 4 micrograms/ml endotoxin, 0.5 per cent butyric acid, 0.1 per cent valeric acid and 0.1 per cent methylene blue water. After 1 and 2 weeks, samples were taken from the apical reservoir and tested for the presence of latex beads by phase-contrast microscopy, for endotoxin with a limulus lysate test, for butyric acid with gas-chromatography and for methylene blue with spectrophotometric analysis. Leakage of bacteria-sized particles and large-sized protein molecules could be prevented only when both sealer and pressure were used in obturating root canals with gutta-percha. Leakage of butyric acid proved to be comparable with leakage of methylene blue; microleakage of these small molecules could not be prevented in this study whatever method of filling was used.

The role of black-pigmented Bacteroides in human oral infections

Today, 10 black-pigmented Bacteroides (BPB) species are recognized. The majority of these species can be isolated from the oral cavity. BPB species are involved in anaerobic infections of oral and non-oral sites. In the oral cavity, BPB species are associated with gingivitis, periodontitis, endodontal infections and odontogenic abscesses. Cultural studies suggest a specific role of the various BPB species in the different types of infection. Bacteroides gingivalis is closely correlated with destructive periodontitis in adults as well as in juveniles. Bacteroides intermedius seems to be less specific since it is found in gingivitis, periodontitis, endodontal infections and odontogenic abscesses. The recently described Bacteroides endodontalis is closely associated with endodontal infections and odontogenic abscesses of endodontal origin. There are indications that these periodontopathic BPB species are only present in the oral cavity of subjects suffering from periodontal breakdown, being absent on the mucosal surfaces of subjects without periodontal breakdown. BPB species associated with healthy oral conditions are Bacteroides melaninogenicus, Bacteroides denticola and Bacteroides loescheii. There are indications that these BPB species are part of the normal indigenous oral microflora. Many studies in the past have documented the pathogenic potential and virulence of BPB species. This virulence can be explained by the large numbers of virulence factors demonstrated in this group of micro-organisms. Among others, the proteolytic activity seems to be one of the most important features. Several artificial substrates as well as numerous biological proteins are degraded. These include anti-inflammatory proteins such as alpha-2-macroglobulin, alpha-1-antitrypsin, C3 and C5 complement factors and immunoglobulins. B. gingivalis is by far the most proteolytic species, followed by B. endodontalis. Like other bacteria, the lipopolysaccharide of B. gingivalis has shown to be active in bone resorption in vitro and is capable in stimulating interleukin-1 production in human peripheral monocytes. Based on the well documented association with periodontal disease and the possession of relevant virulence factors, BPB species must be considered as important micro-organisms in the etiology of oral infections. B. gingivalis seems to be the most pathogenic and virulent species.

Biology of asaccharolytic black-pigmented Bacteroides species

Images

The effect of the outer membrane fraction of Bacteroides gingivalis W50 on glycosaminoglycan metabolism by human gingival fibroblasts in culture

The synthesis of extracellular [35S]-SO4- and [3H]-glucosamine-labelled glycosaminoglycan (GAG) was studied in confluent human gingival fibroblast cultures in vitro. The differential synthesis of the total chondroitin sulphate/dermatan sulphate (CS/DS) and heparan-sulphate (HS) fraction was measured following chondroitinase-ABC digestion, nitrous-acid treatment and column chromatography on Sephadex G50. Control cultures synthesized a CS/DS fraction that represented 78 per cent of the total [35S]-SO4-GAG; the residual 22 per cent was heparan sulphate. Similar cultures were labelled with [3H]-glucosamine and the proportions of a high molecular-weight hyaluronic acid (HA) and proteoglycan fractions measured by gel-filtration HPLC after papain and hyaluronidase digestions. The HA fraction represented 66 per cent of the total isotope incorporated in control cultures. GAG chains released on treatment with papain (24 per cent of the total label incorporated) were of apparent molecular weight 17-20 kDa. All cultures exposed to Bacteroides gingivalis W50 outer membrane at concentrations between 2 and 50 micrograms ml-1 displayed a decrease in the CS/DS fraction and a reciprocal increase in the HS. However, the proportion of HA synthesized was slightly enhanced with a reciprocal decrease in the proteoglycan (papain-digestible) fraction. There was no alteration in the molecular weight of the papain-digestion products or the size distribution of the hyaluronic-acid fraction.

Effects of ammonia and volatile fatty acids produced by oral bacteria on tissue culture cells

Culture filtrates of several bacterial species isolated from the oral cavity were tested for their effects on two types of tissue culture cells: Vero cells, the continuous cell line of African green monkey kidney cells; and chondrocytes, isolated from 15-day-old chick embryo tibiae. Only a limited number of bacterial species--i.e., the asaccharolytic black-pigmented Bacteroides species and Fusobacterium species--affected the two cell types. The effect on Vero cells, detected by the rounding of the cells, correlated with the butyric acid concentration in the bacterial supernatant, which confirms previous findings. A small enhancement of this effect was found with propionic acid and ammonium ions. The same strains which affected Vero cells also affected chondrocytes, detected by a vacuolization of the cells. However, volatile fatty acids on their own had no visible effect on these cells. Instead, ammonium ion in the culture filtrate, when present in concentrations of 20 to 60 mmol/L, proved to be responsible for vacuolization of the chondrocytes. The volatile fatty acids (butyric and propionic) had a limited additive effect. No effects were visible with cell extracts of the bacteria.

Degradation of bovine articular cartilage proteoglycans in vitro. The effect of Bacteroides gingivalis

The black-pigmented Bacteroides gingivalis has previously been isolated from periodontal pockets and been shown capable of inflicting advanced tissue damage. Its effect on the degradation of articular cartilage proteoglycans has not previously been known. In these experiments it was demonstrated that under aerobic conditions the anaerobic microbe B. gingivalis is very potent in degrading the proteoglycans of fresh articular cartilage. It is even more potent in the presence of fetal calf serum (FCS) than in its absence. When the cartilage has been frozen/thawed there is still a slight enhancement of the degradation by B. gingivalis, but when the cartilage has been devitalized and de-enzymed by heat, the cartilage-degrading capacity of B. gingivalis is totally abolished. However, addition to the cartilage cultures of filtered conditioned medium from B. gingivalis inhibits in some degree the degradation of articular cartilage proteoglycans. It is therefore suggested that the great cartilage-degrading ability of Bacteroides gingivalis shown in this culture system could be due to its ability to degrade proteinase inhibitors.

Pathogenic synergy: mixed intra-abdominal infections

In this article we review our researches into the pathogenesis of mixed infections. These may conveniently be divided into in vitro and in vivo studies. In vitro we confirmed that interference with the killing of aerobes by polymorphonuclear leucocytes (PMN's) is a property of the Bacteroides strains tested and appears to depend on competition for opsonins i.e. complement factors. Further studies are in progress to define which complement factors and which bacterial structures are involved. The influence of B. fragilis on chemotaxis has also been studied. Our preliminary data suggest that B. fragilis is itself poorly chemotactic and reduces the chemoattractivity of Proteus mirabilis. This observation is surprising when we consider that abscess formation is the hall-mark of B. fragilis infections and needs clarification. In vivo we have developed a skin infection model in mice which is economical and gives reproducible and quantitative results. In this model we have demonstrated pathogenic synergy between Escherichia coli and B. fragilis. Further studies are planned to assess the role of complement and bacterial factors in this in vivo synergy.

Pathogenic synergy: mixed infections in the oral cavity

In almost all infections in the oral cavity, mixed populations of bacteria are present. However, recent evidence points to a certain specificity in these infections: Streptococcus mutans is related to caries and black-pigmented Bacteroides species are suspected pathogens in periodontal disease. Periodontal diseases, endodontic infections and submucous abscesses in the oral cavity are probably mixed infections in which anaerobic bacteria together with facultatives or other anaerobes are present. In experimental mixed anaerobic infections black-pigmented Bacteroides strains have been shown to play a key role. Little is known about the pathogenic synergy between the bacteria involved in mixed infections. Important mechanisms could be nutritional interrelationships and interactions with the host defense. Within the group of black-pigmented Bacteroides B. gingivalis seems to be the most virulent species. These bacteria possess a great number of virulence factors, which might be important in the pathogenesis of oral infections.

Effect of anaerobic bacteria on killing of Proteus mirabilis by human polymorphonuclear leukocytes

Killing of Proteus mirabilis by human polymorphonuclear leukocytes was tested in the presence of different Bacteroides species. In vitro experiments showed that anaerobic bacteria interfered with the killing of aerobic bacteria. However, this inhibitory effect was not a property of all Bacteroides species. Bacteroides gingivalis W83 showed the greatest inhibitory effect of the five Bacteroides strains tested. Killing of P. mirabilis was inhibited by the culture supernatant of B. gingivalis but not by washed cells. Two factors were found in the supernatant of B. gingivalis to account for the inhibitory effect. One was heat stable with a molecular weight of less than 3,500 and inhibited the killing activity of leukocytes, and the other was heat labile and partly inactivated the complement system. The killing experiments paralleled chemiluminescence measurements.

Butyrate: a cytotoxin for Vero cells produced by Bacteroides gingivalis and Bacteroides asaccharolyticus

Culture filtrates of B. gingivalis and B. asaccharolyticus are cytotoxic for Vero cells. It is shown that the cytotoxic effect is due to the butyrate concentrations present in the culture filtrates of these strains. This cytotoxic effect proved to be reversible. Strains of the B. melaninogenicus subspecies intermedius and melaninogenicus did not produce butyrate and did not show cytotoxic activity towards Vero Cells. The significance of the production of toxic concentrations of butyrate for the etiology of especially periodontal diseases is discussed.