Peritubular capillaritis in renal allografts: prevalence, scoring system, reproducibility and clinicopathological correlates

Pre-Transplant Cytokine Levels as Signatures of Microvascular Inflammation in Kidney Allograft Biopsies

BACKGROUND

 The presence of microvascular inflammation (MVI) characterized by leukocyte margination in the glomeruli (glomerulitis, Banff score 'g') and peritubular capillaries (peritubular capillaritis, Banff score 'ptc') is a hallmark histological feature of antibody-mediated rejection (AMR), even in the absence of circumferential C4d positivity. In this study, we assessed the efficacy of pre-transplant plasma cytokines as an ancillary screening tool to identify MVI in kidney allograft indication biopsies to facilitate better graft survival.

METHOD

 This single-center prospective analytical study comprises 38 kidney transplant recipients whose peripheral blood was collected before transplant and assessed for the plasma cytokine concentrations of FOXP3, IL-6, TGF beta, and IL-17 using enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA). Histopathological assessment was done in post-transplant indication biopsies, and Banff scores of 'g+ ptc' were calculated to categorize recipients into three MVI groups. The correlational, regression, and ROC curve analyses were used to assess the association and predictive ability of the cytokines with respect to MVI.

RESULTS

 In our study cohort, 27 recipients had MVI=0, five had MVI=1, and six had MVI≥2. A significant difference in plasma cytokines was observed between these groups, and we found a strong negative correlation of FOXP3 with MVI, whereas a strong positive correlation of IL-6, TGF beta, and IL-17 was recorded with MVI. We have also assessed the predictive ability of these cytokines, FOXP3, IL-6, TGF-beta, and IL-17, through the ROC curve, which showed an AUC of 0.70, 0.76, 0.84, and 0.72, respectively.

CONCLUSION

 Our findings suggest that the pre-transplant levels of cytokines FOXP3, IL-6, TGF-beta, and IL-17 could be measured to identify recipients at risk of post-transplant MVI, which could further serve as an additional tool for effective management of the kidney allograft.

WARS1, TYMP and GBP1 display a distinctive microcirculation pattern by immunohistochemistry during antibody-mediated rejection in kidney transplantation

Antibody-mediated rejection (ABMR) is the leading cause of allograft failure in kidney transplantation. Defined by the Banff classification, its gold standard diagnosis remains a challenge, with limited inter-observer reproducibility of the histological scores and efficient immunomarker availability. We performed an immunohistochemical analysis of 3 interferon-related proteins, WARS1, TYMP and GBP1 in a cohort of kidney allograft biopsies including 17 ABMR cases and 37 other common graft injuries. Slides were interpreted, for an ABMR diagnosis, by four blinded nephropathologists and by a deep learning framework using convolutional neural networks. Pathologists identified a distinctive microcirculation staining pattern in ABMR with all three antibodies, displaying promising diagnostic performances and a substantial reproducibility. The deep learning analysis supported the microcirculation staining pattern and achieved similar diagnostic performance from internal validation, with a mean area under the receiver operating characteristic curve of 0.89 (± 0.02) for WARS1, 0.80 (± 0.04) for TYMP and 0.89 (± 0.04) for GBP1. The glomerulitis and peritubular capillaritis scores, the hallmarks of histological ABMR, were the most highly correlated Banff scores with the deep learning output, whatever the C4d status. These novel immunomarkers combined with a CNN framework could help mitigate current challenges in ABMR diagnosis and should be assessed in larger cohorts.

Peritubular Capillaritis in Native Kidney Biopsies

OBJECTIVES

To determine the frequency and predictors of peritubular capillaritis (PTCitis) among native kidney biopsies.

METHODS

Consecutive native kidney biopsies of 169 patients were reexamined for capturing possible PTCitis according to the Banff Classification. The relation of PTCitis with demographic and clinicopathological findings was evaluated. Logistic regression analysis was performed to determine predictors of PTCitis.

RESULTS

Peritubular capillaritis was captured in 90 (53.3%) patients, with scores of 1, 2, and 3 in 57 (33.7%), 31 (18.3%), and 2 (1.2%) patients, respectively. The highest frequency of PTCitis was observed in pauci-immune glomerulonephritis. In univariate analysis, male sex, the presence of interstitial inflammation, pauci-immune glomerulonephritis, and a higher serum creatinine level were associated with a higher risk of PTCitis, while severe interstitial fibrosis/tubular atrophy was associated with a lower risk. The presence of interstitial inflammation (odds ratio [OR], 5.94 [95% confidence interval (CI), 1.41-25.03]; P = .015), pauci-immune glomerulonephritis (OR, 3.08 [95% CI, 1.01-9.36]; P = .048), and a higher serum creatinine level (per 1 mg/dL) (OR, 1.56 [95% CI, 1.14-2.11]; P = .005) were independent predictors of PTCitis development in a multivariate regression model.

CONCLUSIONS

Peritubular capillaritis is common in native biopsies and more likely to be observed in the presence of interstitial inflammation, pauci-immune glomerulonephritis, and a higher serum creatinine level.

Clinical Heterogeneity of the VEXAS Syndrome: A Case Series

The objective of this study is to describe the clinical features and outcomes of patients with the newly defined vacuoles, E1 enzyme, X-linked, autoinflammatory, somatic (VEXAS) syndrome. Nine men with somatic mutations in the UBA1 gene were identified; the most frequent variant was p.Met41Thr (7 of 9, 78%). The median age at VEXAS diagnosis was 74 (67, 76.5) years, and patients had a median duration of symptoms for 4 years before diagnosis. Refractory constitutional symptoms (88%), ear and nose chondritis (55%), and inflammatory arthritis (55%) were common clinical features. Vasculitis was noted in 44%. All patients had significantly elevated inflammatory markers and macrocytic anemia. Thrombocytopenia was present in 66% at diagnosis of VEXAS. Eight patients had bone marrow biopsies performed. All bone marrows were hypercellular, and there was vacuolization of the erythroid (100%) or myeloid precursors (75%). Glucocorticoids attenuated symptoms at prednisone doses ≥20 mg per day, but no other immunosuppressive agent showed consistent long-term control of disease. One patient with coexisting plasma-cell myeloma received plasma-cell-directed therapy with improvement of the inflammatory response, which is a novel finding. In conclusion, VEXAS syndrome is a clinically heterogeneous, treatment-refractory inflammatory condition caused by somatic mutation of the UBA1 gene. Patients often present with overlapping rheumatologic manifestations and persistent hematologic abnormalities. As such, internists and subspecialists, including pathologists, should be aware of this condition to avert diagnostic delay, now that the etiology of this syndrome is known.

Quantitative contrast-enhanced ultrasound for the differentiation of kidney allografts with significant histopathological injury

OBJECTIVE

To identify specific quantitative contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS) parameters that could distinguish kidney transplants with significant histopathological injury.

METHODS

Sixty-four patients were enrolled in this prospective observational study. Biopsies were performed following CEUS and blood examination.

RESULTS

28 biopsy specimens had minimal changes (MC group), while 36 had significant injury (SI group). Of these, 12 had rejection (RI group) and 24 non-rejection injury (NRI group). In RI and NRI groups, temporal difference in time to peak (TTP) between medulla and cortex (ΔTTPm-c) was significantly shorter compared to the MC group (5.77, 5.92, and 7.94 s, P = 0.048 and 0.026, respectively). Additionally, RI group had significantly shorter medullary TTP compared to the MC group (27.75 vs. 32.26 s; P = 0.03). In a subset of 41 patients with protocol biopsy at 1-year post-transplant, ΔTTPm-c was significantly shorter in the SI compared to the MC group (5.67 vs. 7.67 s; P = 0.024). Area under receiver operating characteristic curves (AUROCs) for ΔTTPm-c was 0.69 in all patients and 0.71 in patients with protocol biopsy.

CONCLUSIONS

RI and NRI groups had shorter ΔTTPm-c compared to the MC group. AUROCs for both patient groups were good, making ΔTTPm-c a promising CEUS parameter for distinguishing patients with significant histopathological injury.

A 2020 Banff Antibody-mediatedInjury Working Group examination of international practices for diagnosing antibody-mediated rejection in kidney transplantation - a cohort study

The Banff antibody-mediated rejection (ABMR) classification is vulnerable to misinterpretation, but the reasons are unclear. To better understand this vulnerability, we evaluated how ABMR is diagnosed in practice. To do this, the Banff Antibody-Mediated Injury Workgroup electronically surveyed an international cohort of nephrologists/surgeons (n = 133) and renal pathologists (n = 99). Most providers (97%) responded that they use the Banff ABMR classification at least sometimes, but DSA information is often not readily available. Only 41.1% (55/133) of nephrologists/surgeons and 19.2% (19/99) of pathologists reported that they always have DSA results when the biopsy is available. Additionally, only 19.6% (26/133) of nephrologists/surgeons responded that non-HLA antibody or molecular transcripts are obtained when ABMR histologic features are present but DSA is undetected. Several respondents agreed that histologic features concerning for ABMR in the absence of DSA and/or C4d are not well accounted for in the current classification [31.3% (31/99) pathologists and 37.6% (50/133) nephrologist/surgeons]. The Banff ABMR classification appears widely accepted, but efforts to improve the accessibility of DSA information for the multidisciplinary care team are needed. Further clarity is also needed in Banff ABMR nomenclature to account for the spectrum of ABMR and for histologic features suspicious for ABMR when DSA is absent.

Integrative Analyses of Circulating Small RNAs and Kidney Graft Transcriptome in Transplant Glomerulopathy

Transplant glomerulopathy develops through multiple mechanisms, including donor-specific antibodies, T cells and innate immunity. This study investigates circulating small RNA profiles in serum samples of kidney transplant recipients with biopsy-proven transplant glomerulopathy. Among total small RNA population, miRNAs were the most abundant species in the serum of kidney transplant patients. In addition, fragments arising from mature tRNA and rRNA were detected. Most of the tRNA fragments were generated from 5′ ends of mature tRNA and mainly from two parental tRNAs: tRNA-Gly and tRNA-Glu. Moreover, transplant patients with transplant glomerulopathy displayed a novel tRNA fragments signature. Gene expression analysis from allograft tissues demonstrated changes in canonical pathways related to immune activation such as iCos-iCosL signaling pathway in T helper cells, Th1 and Th2 activation pathway, and dendritic cell maturation. mRNA targets of down-regulated miRNAs such as miR-1224-5p, miR-4508, miR-320, miR-378a from serum were globally upregulated in tissue. Integration of serum miRNA profiles with tissue gene expression showed that changes in serum miRNAs support the role of T-cell mediated mechanisms in ongoing allograft injury.

The role of non-HLA antibodies in solid organ transplantation: a complex deliberation

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

There is tremendous interest in understanding when, if, and how non-HLA antibodies contribute to allograft injury. Numerous non-HLA target antigens have been identified and sensitization to these targets have been associated with delayed allograft function, rejection, and allograft failure. This review focuses on the clinical utility of HLA antibody testing, highlighting the strengths and limitations of current clinical studies, and the need for defining characteristics to inform non-HLA antibody pathogenicity.

RECENT FINDINGS

Clinical studies continue to show associations between non-HLA antibodies and rejection and reduced allograft survival across multiple transplanted organ types. The worst clinical outcomes continue to be observed among recipients testing positive for both non-HLA and donor-specific HLA antibodies. Mechanistic insights from both animal and clinical studies support a model in which tissue injury accompanied by an inflammatory environment influence non-HLA antibody formation and pathogenicity.

SUMMARY

Immune triggers that lead to non-HLA antibody formation and pathogenicity are complex and poorly understood. The ability of non-HLA antibodies to mediate allograft injury may depend upon their affinity and strength (titer), target specificity, density of the target antigen, and synergy with donor-specific HLA antibodies.

Rabbit antithymocyte globulin induces human lymphocyte activation, proliferation, and apoptosis in the absence of complement: an experimental study

Rabbit antithymocyte globulin (rATG) has become the first choice for induction therapy in HLA-presensitized patients undergoing organ transplantation. Meanwhile, complement inhibitors have been approved for preventing or treating antibody-mediated rejection in these patients. The biological effects of rATG on lymphocytes in cases of complement deficiency or significant inhibition are not yet clear. We measured lymphocyte activation, proliferation, and apoptosis in response to rATG treatment in the absence of complement. T-cell subsets were analyzed transcriptomically features to rATG stimulation. Activation-related phenotypes on T cells were determined in patients after rATG administration. We found that rATG treatment led to lymphocyte activation and proliferation in vitro without the addition of complement. A dose-dependent apoptosis in rATG-treated lymphocytes was detected, which was partially caspase-3-dependent but Fas/FasL-independent. T cells were more sensitive to rATG stimulation than were non-T cells. Both CD4⁺ T cells and CD8⁺ T cells upregulated a series of genes related to cell activation, cytokine production and apoptosis to rATG stimulation. CD69 and CD25 levels in surviving T cells were increased in patients after rATG administration. These findings indicate that rATG can stimulate lymphocyte activation, proliferation, and apoptosis in the absence of complement. Biologic effects of rATG other than complement-dependent cytotoxicity need to be concerned.

Pre-Transplant Angiotensin II Type 1 Receptor Antibodies and Anti-Endothelial Cell Antibodies Predict Graft Function and Allograft Rejection in a Low-Risk Kidney Transplantation Setting

Background

Non-HLA antibodies, anti-angiotensin II type 1 receptor antibodies (anti-AT1R) and anti-endothelial cell antibodies (AECA), are known to play a role in allograft rejection. We evaluated the role of both antibodies in predicting post-transplant outcomes in low-risk living donor kidney transplantation (LDKT) recipients.

Methods

In 94 consecutive LDKT recipients who were ABO compatible and negative for pre-transplant HLA donor-specific antibodies, we determined the levels of anti-AT1Rs using an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and the presence of AECAs using a flow cytometric endothelial cell crossmatch (ECXM) assay with pre-transplant sera. Hazard ratio (HR) was calculated to predict post-transplant outcomes.

Results

Pre-transplant anti-AT1Rs (≥11.5 U/mL) and AECAs were observed in 36 (38.3%) and 22 recipients (23.4%), respectively; 11 recipients had both. Pre-transplant anti-AT1Rs were a significant risk factor for the development of acute rejection (AR) (HR 2.09; P=0.018), while a positive AECA status was associated with AR or microvascular inflammation only (HR 2.47; P=0.004) throughout the follow-up period. In particular, AECA (+) recipients with ≥11.5 U/mL anti-AT1Rs exhibited a significant effect on creatinine and estimated glomerular filtration rate (P<0.001; P=0.028), although the risk of AR was not significant.

Conclusions

Pre-transplant anti-AT1Rs and AECAs have independent negative effects on post-transplant outcomes in low-risk LDKT recipients. Assessment of both antibodies would be helpful in stratifying the pre-transplant immunological risk, even in low-risk LDKT recipients.

Safety and efficacy of eculizumab in the prevention of antibody-mediated rejection in living-donor kidney transplant recipients requiring desensitization therapy: A randomized trial

We report results of a phase 2, randomized, multicenter, open-label, two-arm study evaluating the safety and efficacy of eculizumab in preventing acute antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) in sensitized recipients of living-donor kidney transplants requiring pretransplant desensitization (NCT01399593). In total, 102 patients underwent desensitization. Posttransplant, 51 patients received standard of care (SOC) and 51 received eculizumab. The primary end point was week 9 posttransplant treatment failure rate, a composite of: biopsy-proven acute AMR (Banff 2007 grade II or III; assessed by blinded central pathology); graft loss; death; or loss to follow-up. Eculizumab was well tolerated with no new safety concerns. No significant difference in treatment failure rate was observed between eculizumab (9.8%) and SOC (13.7%; P = .760). To determine whether data assessment assumptions affected study outcome, biopsies were reanalyzed by central pathologists using clinical information. The resulting treatment failure rates were 11.8% and 21.6% for the eculizumab and SOC groups, respectively (nominal P = .288). When reassessment included grade I AMR, the treatment failure rates were 11.8% (eculizumab) and 29.4% (SOC; nominal P = .048). This finding suggests a potential benefit for eculizumab compared with SOC in preventing acute AMR in recipients sensitized to their living-donor kidney transplants (EudraCT 2010-019630-28).

Tubular Ectasia in Renal Allograft Biopsy: Associations With Occult Obstructive Urological Complications

BACKGROUND

Urological obstructive complications (UOC) affect up to 15% of kidney transplants (KTX). Most cases are excluded by ultrasonography (US); however, accuracy may be limited in the early transplant phase. Features of acute tubular injury (ATI) in KTX biopsy may be informative but histological features indicating UOC are ill defined. Tubular ectasia (TE) was shown to be associated with UOC in experimental data. We evaluated the association of histomorphological features, particularly TE, with occult (=without relevant hydronephrosis in US) UOC and renal outcomes.

METHODS

We included all recipients with an early indication biopsy (976 of 1537 consecutive KTX). The biopsy finding of TE classified as "suspicious of UOC" was compared with the following endpoints: delayed graft function, estimated glomerular filtration rate, and occult UOC. Additionally, histopathological features of ATI were reevaluated by a single pathologist to increase diagnostic accuracy.

RESULTS

Fifty-eight (5.9%) patients presented with TE, which was not related to delayed graft function or estimated glomerular filtration rate. Forty percent of patients had a UOC (most frequently ureteral stenosis) close to biopsy. Comparing these biopsies to matched controls, TE was significantly associated with UOC (odds ratio 2.69; P = 0.018). After histopathological reevaluation of these biopsies including additional features of ATI, we developed a final multivariate model with a highly significant relationship to UOC (Receiver operating characteristic-area under the curve: 0.77; P = 0.001). The model provides a specificity of 78% and negative predictive value of 73%.

CONCLUSIONS

TE together with additional signs of ATI indicates occult UOC. This histological phenotype should trigger more detailed evaluation for UOC when there is no evidence of relevant hydronephrosis in the ultrasonography.

A Peripheral Blood Gene Expression Signature to Diagnose Subclinical Acute Rejection

BACKGROUND

In kidney transplant recipients, surveillance biopsies can reveal, despite stable graft function, histologic features of acute rejection and borderline changes that are associated with undesirable graft outcomes. Noninvasive biomarkers of subclinical acute rejection are needed to avoid the risks and costs associated with repeated biopsies.

METHODS

We examined subclinical histologic and functional changes in kidney transplant recipients from the prospective Genomics of Chronic Allograft Rejection (GoCAR) study who underwent surveillance biopsies over 2 years, identifying those with subclinical or borderline acute cellular rejection (ACR) at 3 months (ACR-3) post-transplant. We performed RNA sequencing on whole blood collected from 88 individuals at the time of 3-month surveillance biopsy to identify transcripts associated with ACR-3, developed a novel sequencing-based targeted expression assay, and validated this gene signature in an independent cohort.

RESULTS

Study participants with ACR-3 had significantly higher risk than those without ACR-3 of subsequent clinical acute rejection at 12 and 24 months, faster decline in graft function, and decreased graft survival in adjusted Cox analysis. We identified a 17-gene signature in peripheral blood that accurately diagnosed ACR-3, and validated it using microarray expression profiles of blood samples from 65 transplant recipients in the GoCAR cohort and three public microarray datasets. In an independent cohort of 110 transplant recipients, tests of the targeted expression assay on the basis of the 17-gene set showed that it identified individuals at higher risk of ongoing acute rejection and future graft loss.

CONCLUSIONS

Our targeted expression assay enabled noninvasive diagnosis of subclinical acute rejection and inflammation in the graft and may represent a useful tool to risk-stratify kidney transplant recipients.

A Fully Automated System Using A Convolutional Neural Network to Predict Renal Allograft Rejection: Extra-validation with Giga-pixel Immunostained Slides

Pathologic diagnoses mainly depend on visual scoring by pathologists, a process that can be time-consuming, laborious, and susceptible to inter- and/or intra-observer variations. This study proposes a novel method to enhance pathologic scoring of renal allograft rejection. A fully automated system using a convolutional neural network (CNN) was developed to identify regions of interest (ROIs) and to detect C4d positive and negative peritubular capillaries (PTCs) in giga-pixel immunostained slides. The performance of faster R-CNN was evaluated using optimal parameters of the novel method to enlarge the size of labeled masks. Fifty and forty pixels of the enlarged size images showed the best performance in detecting C4d positive and negative PTCs, respectively. Additionally, the feasibility of deep-learning-assisted labeling as independent dataset to enhance detection in this model was evaluated. Based on these two CNN methods, a fully automated system for renal allograft rejection was developed. This system was highly reliable, efficient, and effective, making it applicable to real clinical workflow.

Banff survey on antibody-mediated rejection clinical practices in kidney transplantation: Diagnostic misinterpretation has potential therapeutic implications

The aim of this study was to determine how the Banff antibody-mediated rejection (ABMR) classification for kidney transplantation is interpreted in practice and affects therapy. The Banff Antibody-Mediated Injury Workgroup electronically surveyed clinicians and pathologists worldwide regarding diagnosis and treatment for 6 case-based scenarios. The participants' (95 clinicians and 72 renal pathologists) assigned diagnoses were compared to the Banff intended diagnoses (reference standard). The assigned diagnoses and reference standard differed by 26.1% (SD 28.1%) for pathologists and 34.5% (SD 23.3%) for clinicians. The greatest discordance between the reference standard and clinicians' diagnosis was when histologic features of ABMR were present but donor-specific antibody was undetected (49.4% [43/87]). For pathologists, the greatest discordance was in the case of acute/active ABMR C4d staining negative in a positive crossmatch transplant recipient (33.8% [23/68]). Treatment approaches were heterogeneous but linked to the assigned diagnosis. When acute/active ABMR was diagnosed by the clinician, treatment was recommended 95.3% (SD 18.4%) of the time vs only 77.7% (SD 39.2%) of the time when chronic active ABMR was diagnosed (P < .0001). In conclusion, the Banff ABMR classification is vulnerable to misinterpretation, which potentially has patient management implications. Continued efforts are needed to improve the understanding and standardized application of ABMR classification in the transplant community.

Microvascular inflammation in renal allograft biopsies assessed by endothelial and leukocyte co-immunostain: a retrospective study on reproducibility and clinical/prognostic correlates

The most prominent histologic lesion in antibody-mediated rejection is microvascular inflammation (MVI); however, its recognition and scoring can be challenging and poorly reproducible between pathologists. We developed a dual immunohistochemical (IHC)-stain (anti-CD34/anti-CD45 for endothelium/leukocytes) as ancillary tool to improve on the semi-quantitative Banff scores and allow quantification of MVI. We examined the relationship between CD34-CD45 IHC-based quantitative MVI score (the inflamed peritubular capillary ratio, iptcr) and renal-graft failure or donor-specific antibodies (DSA) strength at the time of biopsy. Quantitative iptcr score was significantly associated with renal graft failure (hazard ratio 1.81, per 1 SD-unit [0.13 points] of iptcr-increase; P = 0.026) and predicted the presence and strength of DSA (ordinal odds ratio: 2.42; P = 0.005; 75 biopsies/60 kidney transplant recipients; 30 HLA- and/or ABO-incompatible). Next, we assessed inter-pathologist agreement for ptc score and ptc extent (focal/diffuse) using CD34-CD45 IHC as compared to conventional stain. Compared to conventional stain, CD34-CD45 IHC significantly increased inter-pathologist agreement on ptc score severity and extent (κ-coefficient from 0.52-0.80 and 0.46-0.68, respectively, P < 0.001). Our findings show that CD34-CD45 IHC improves reproducibility of MVI scoring and facilitates MVI quantification and introduction of a dual anti-CD34/CD45 has the potential to improve recognition of MVI ahead of DSA results.

A method to reduce variability in scoring antibody-mediated rejection in renal allografts: implications for clinical trials - a retrospective study

Poor reproducibility in scoring antibody-mediated rejection (ABMR) using the Banff criteria might limit the use of histology in clinical trials. We evaluated the reproducibility of Banff scoring of 67 biopsies by six renal pathologists at three institutions. Agreement by any two pathologists was poor: 44.8-65.7% for glomerulitis, 44.8-67.2% for peritubular capillaritis, and 53.7-80.6% for chronic glomerulopathy (cg). All pathologists agreed on cg0 (n = 20) and cg3 (n = 9) cases, however, many disagreed on scores of cg1 or cg2. The range for the incidence of composite diagnoses by individual pathologists was: 16.4-22.4% for no ABMR; 17.9-47.8% for active ABMR; and 35.8-59.7% for chronic, active antibody-mediated rejection (cABMR). A "majority rules" approach was then tested in which the scores of three pathologists were used to reach an agreement. This increased consensus both for individual scores (ex. 67.2-77.6% for cg) and for composite diagnoses (ex. 74.6-86.6% cABMR). Modeling using these results showed that differences in individual scoring could affect the outcome assessment in a mock study of cABMR. We conclude that the Banff schema has high variability and a majority rules approach could be used to adjudicate differences between pathologists and reduce variability in scoring in clinical trials.

Evaluation of Microvascular Inflammation in ABO-Incompatible Kidney Transplantation

BACKGROUND

In ABO-incompatible kidney transplantation, the diagnostic criteria for antibody-mediated rejection remain controversial because C4d deposition is commonly observed. Thus, we investigated microvascular inflammation (MVI score ≥ 2) within 1 year as a predictor of graft outcome.

METHODS

A total of 148 recipients without preformed or de novo donor-specific anti-HLA antibody were stratified based on MVI score less than 2 (n = 117) and MVI score of 2 or greater (n = 31).

RESULTS

We found that 5-year graft survival was significantly lower (P = 0.0129) in patients with MVI (89.8%) than in patients without MVI (97.0%). Graft function, as characterized by serum estimated glomerular filtration rate, was also significantly worse for patients with MVI than it was for patients without MVI, between 3 months and 10 years after transplantation (P = 0.048). Multivariate analysis indicated that HLA class II mismatch (P = 0.0085) was an independent marker of MVI.

CONCLUSIONS

Microvascular inflammation score of 2 or greater is significantly associated with poor graft outcome after ABO-incompatible kidney transplantation. We suggest that MVI score of 2 or greater in ABOi transplantation be used as a basis to diagnose antibody-mediated rejection.

Diffuse Extent of Peritubular Capillaritis in Late Antibody-Mediated Rejection: Associations With Levels of Donor-Specific Antibodies and Chronic Allograft Injury

BACKGROUND

Recently, diffuse peritubular capillaritis (ptc) has been suggested to independently predict chronic transplant injury and loss, and although the ptc score is a diagnostic criterion for antibody-mediated rejection, the utility of diffuse ptc is under debate.

METHODS

We evaluated the diagnostic value of ptc characteristics in this cross-sectional study including 85 biopsies of patients with donor-specific antibodies (DSA). Biopsies were reevaluated for the extent (diffuse vs focal), score and leukocytic composition in relation to DSA binding strength (mean fluorescence intensity [MFI]_max). Chronic allograft injury (transplant chronic glomerulopathy [cg] or chronic lesion score CLS]) were associated with ptc features.

RESULTS

Peritubular capillaritis was detected in 50% (76% mononuclear ptc). Peritubular capillaritis scores 1, 2, and 3 were present in 36%, 55%, and 9%, and focal or diffuse ptc in 36% or 64%. Diffuse ptc was associated with DSA MFI_max (median: 4407 vs 2419 [focal ptc; P = 0.04] or 1946 [no ptc; P = 0.004]), cg (58% vs no ptc 24% [P = 0.02]), and higher CLS (mean: 6.81 vs 4.67 [focal ptc, P = 0.01] or 5.18 [no ptc, P = 0.001]), respectively. The association of ptc score of 2 or greater with cg was slightly better than with diffuse ptc. Diffuse ptc and ptc score of 2 or greater remained independently related to cg after adjusting for DSA_MFI_max, C4d, or previous rejection episodes, however lost their independent relation after adjusting for total microcirculation scores. Diffuse ptc was the only ptc characteristic independently related to CLS.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results emphasize the clinical relevance of reporting diffuse ptc, which may relate to DSA binding strength and potentially to chronic graft injury.

Rejection of the Renal Allograft in the Absence of Demonstrable Antibody and Complement

BACKGROUND

Recent literature has stressed the prominent role of antibodies in graft loss. This study was designed to assess a growing perception that T cell-mediated rejection (TCMR) is no longer clinically relevant.

METHODS

Five hundred forty-five renal allograft recipients over a 3-year period were screened for biopsies with: (a) TCMR including borderline change (BL), (b) negative complement protein C4 degradation fragment, and (c) absence of donor-specific antibody at time of transplant, within 30 days of the biopsy, and up to 4 measurements at later time points.

RESULTS

These stringent requirements identified 28 "pure" cases of late TCMR/BL. Low-grade glomerulitis, peritubular capillaritis, or chronic transplant glomerulopathy were found in 9/28 (32%) biopsies. Serum creatinine showed complete short-term remission in 7/10 (70%) BL and 9/18 (50%) TCMR patients 1 month postbiopsy. Yet, both treated and untreated patients demonstrated further decline in graft function as assessed by serum creatinine and estimated glomerular filtration rate.

CONCLUSIONS

Late TCMR seen in 7.9% of biopsies can contribute to significant deterioration of graft function in patients in whom the dominant contribution of antibody-mediated injury has been reasonably excluded. Our data also reinforce existing literature showing that microvascular lesions do not have absolute specificity for a diagnosis of antibody-mediated rejection.

Current pathological perspectives on chronic rejection in renal allografts

Chronic rejection in renal transplantation clinically manifests as slow deterioration in allograft function and is a major contributor of late renal graft loss. Most cases of chronic rejection involve chronic antibody-mediated rejection (ABMR) triggered by the interaction of donor-specific alloantibodies with endothelial cells of the microcirculation. The evolution of the Banff classification involved a major revision of the ABMR criteria during the 2000s and led to the inclusion of detailed pathological characteristics of chronic ABMR in the 2013 Banff scheme, including microcirculation damage observed as newly formed basement membranes and arterial fibrous intimal proliferation. Inflammation of microvasculature including glomeruli and/or peritubular capillaries is also seen in substantial cases of chronic ABMR, defined as chronic active ABMR. Chronic active T cell-mediated rejection (TCMR) results from chronic T cell-mediated injury involving renal arteries but is less characterized under the current Banff classification, mainly due to the expanding histological criteria of chronic active ABMR. Characteristics shared by these two chronic rejection types can potentially cause diagnostic confusion. Hence, the diagnostic criteria or categories of chronic renal rejection require amendment of the current Banff classification. Assessment of rejection cases with molecular phenotyping advanced the mechanistic understanding of various dysfunctions in renal allograft, including ABMR and TCMR. Identification of disease-specific changes in gene expression by immunohistological studies, especially in chronic ABMR, has already been validated by several studies, warranting potential application to the pathological diagnostic process. This review provides an overview of current pathological perspectives on chronic rejection of renal allografts and future directions.

Banff Borderline Changes Suspicious for Acute T Cell-Mediated Rejection: Where Do We Stand?

The definition of Banff Borderline became ambiguous when the Banff 2005 consensus modified the lower threshold from i1t1 (10-25% interstitial inflammation with mild tubulitis) to i0t1 (0-10% interstitial inflammation with mild tubulitis). We conducted a worldwide survey among members of the Renal Pathology Society about their approach to this diagnostic category. A web-based survey was sent out to all 503 current members (153 respondents). A database search yielded which threshold for Banff i was applied in the most influential manuscripts about Borderline. Among the 139 nephropathologists using the Borderline category, 67% use the Banff 1997 definition, requiring Banff i1. Thirty-seven percent admitted to sometimes exaggerating Banff i in the presence of tubulitis, to reach a diagnosis of Borderline. Forty-eight percent were dissatisfied with the definition of Borderline. The majority of the most influential manuscripts used the 1997 definition, contrary to the current one. There is considerable dissatisfaction with Borderline, and practice in Banff i thresholds is variable. Until additional studies inform a revision, we suggest leaving it to each pathologist's discretion whether to use i0 or i1 as the minimal threshold. In order to avoid future ambiguity, a web-based synopsis of all scattered current Banff definitions and rules should be created.

Protocol Biopsies: Utility and Limitations

As both T cell and antibody-mediated rejection can have a subclinical phase, protocol biopsies provide an early opportunity to intervene before the onset of clinical allograft dysfunction. Protocol biopsies are usually done after reperfusion to establish baseline, between 3 and 6 months to identify subclinical rejection, and at 6-12 months to assess chronicity and persistent inflammation that have prognostic implication. Treatment of both subclinical T cell and antibody-mediated rejection prevents progression of rejection and development of interstitial fibrosis/tubular atrophy or transplant glomerulopathy. Although subclinical rejection has become less frequent in low-risk patients on triple immunosuppression containing tacrolimus, protocol biopsies may still be useful in selected population. Protocol biopsies are more likely to benefit patients at higher risk for rejection, including those who are highly sensitized, transplanted across donor-specific antibody barriers, or on calcineurin inhibitor/corticosteroids sparing regimens. Interstitial fibrosis on protocol biopsies, especially in conjunction with persistent inflammation, predicts lower allograft survival.

Peritubular capillaritis in the renal allograft takes center stage

Capillaritis in the renal allograft is important for diagnosis and prognosis. Although glomerulitis has been well studied, peritubular capillaritis has been defined only relatively recently. The finding that peritubular capillaritis severity score and extent may correlate independently with graft outcome mandates further prospective studies to confirm this finding, and to enhance recognition and quantitation of this important lesion.

2013 Banff Criteria for Chronic Active Antibody-Mediated Rejection: Assessment in a Real-Life Setting

Significant changes in the criteria for chronic active antibody-mediated rejection (CAABMR) were made in the Banff 2013 classification. These modifications expanded the number of patients diagnosed with CAABMR, with undetermined clinical significance. We compared the 2007 and 2013 criteria for the composite end point of death-censored graft failure or doubling of serum creatinine in 123 patients meeting the criterion related to the morphologic evidence of chronic tissue injury. In all, 18% and 36% of the patients met the 2007 and 2013 criteria, respectively. For the criterion related to antibody interaction with endothelium, only 25% were positive based on the 2007 definition compared with 82% using the 2013 definition. Cox modeling revealed that a 2013 but not a 2007 diagnosis was associated with the composite end point (adjusted hazard ratio 2.5 [95% confidence interval (CI) 1.2-5.2] vs. 1.6 [95% CI 0.7-3.8], respectively). The 2013 criterion based on both the C4d score and the glomerulitis plus peritubular capillaritis score (g+ptc) was more strongly associated with the end point than the 2007 criterion based only on C4d; however, when dissected by component, only the C4d component was significant. The association with clinical outcomes improved with the 2013 criteria. This is related to the new C4d threshold but not to the g+ptc ≥2 component.

T-cell-mediated rejection of the kidney in the era of donor-specific antibodies: diagnostic challenges and clinical significance

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Burgeoning literature on antibody-mediated rejection (ABMR) has led to a perception that T-cell-mediated rejection (TCMR) is no longer a significant problem. This premise needs to be carefully appraised.

RECENT FINDINGS

A review of the literature indicates that TCMR remains an independent-risk factor for graft loss. Importantly, it can occur as a sensitizing event that triggers ABMR, and adversely affects its outcome. Moreover, T cells are regularly present in lesions used to diagnose ABMR, and these lesions can also develop in the absence of donor-specific antibodies (DSA). Conversely, patients with DSA are at risk for mixed ABMR-TCMR, which is quite common in many studies, and may require a combined anti-T-cell and anti-B-cell strategy for the best outcome.

SUMMARY

T-cell-based clinical monitoring and therapy is still relevant for prophylaxis of both cellular and humoral rejection, treatment of steroid refractory TCMR, which occurs in up to 20% of patients, and optimization of clinical outcome in mixed TCMR-ABMR, which is more frequently encountered than generally appreciated, and still associated with unacceptably high rates of graft loss.

New insights in antibody-mediated rejection

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

In the present review, we aim to describe the state of knowledge concerning antibody-mediated rejection (ABMR) spectrum and diagnosis criteria before analyzing the present and future promising leads regarding ABMR prognosis markers and treatment.

RECENT FINDINGS

Recent studies regarding complement-binding donor-specific antibodies and the molecular approach highlighted the unmet need for stratification tools for prognosis and treatment inside ABMR disease.

SUMMARY

ABMR is the leading cause of kidney allograft failure. The recent expansion of its spectrum is related to the paradigm of a continuous process, leading insidiously to a chronic form of ABMR and to the progressive acknowledgement of new entities (such as vascular ABMR, subclinical ABMR, C4d-negative ABMR). Considering the global picture of ABMR, the Banff classification gradually refined the diagnosis criteria so that it now describes a clinically relevant and coherent entity. Nevertheless, if the diagnosis mainly relies on conventional assessment, such as histological findings and circulating donor-specific antibodies, these criteria face serious limitations in terms of stratification of patients at risk of graft loss inside ABMR disease. Recently, new promising tools have emerged in order to identify long-term outcomes at the time of the diagnosis of rejection. In this regard, donor-specific antibodies' complement-fixing ability and the molecular approach contributed significantly. Currently, however, no clinically relevant surrogate marker of treatment efficiency is currently available.

Methods of analysis for peritubular capillaritis and glomerulitis in acute renal rejection: capillaritis in management of routine diagnosis

Glomerulitis and peritubular capillaritis have been recognized as important lesions in acute renal rejection (AR). We studied glomerulitis and peritubular capillaritis in AR by 2 methods and investigated associations with C4d, type/grade of AR, and allograft survival time. Glomerulitis was measured according to Banff scores (glomerulitis by Banff Method [gBM]) and by counting the number of intraglomerular inflammatory cells (glomerulitis by Quantitative Method [gQM]). Capillaritis was classified by the Banff scoring system (peritubular capillaritis by Banff Method [ptcBM]) and by counting the number of cells in peritubular capillaries in 10 high-power fields (hpf; peritubular capillaritis by Quantitative Method [ptcQM]). These quantitative analyses were performed in an attempt to improve our understanding of the role played by glomerulitis and capillaritis in AR. The g0 + g1 group (gBM) associated with negative C4d (P = .02). In peritubular capillaritis, a larger number of cells per 10 hpf in peritubular capillaries (ptcQM) were observed in positive C4d cases (P = .03). The group g2 + g3 (gBM) correlated with graft loss (P = .01). Peritubular capillaritis was not significantly related to graft survival time. Our study showed that the Banff scoring system is the best method to study glomerulitis and observed that the evaluation of capillaritis in routine biopsies is difficult and additional studies are required for a better understanding of its meaning in AR biopsy specimens of renal allografts.

The significance of histological diagnosis in renal allograft biopsies in 2014

In 2014, the renal allograft biopsy still represents the best available diagnostic 'gold' standard to assess reasons for allograft dysfunction. However, it is well recognized that histological lesion observed in the biopsy is of limited diagnostic specificity and that the Banff classification as the international diagnostic standard represents mere expert consensus. Here, we review the role of the renal allograft biopsy in different clinical and diagnostic settings. To increase diagnostic accuracy and to compensate for lack of specificity, the interpretation of biopsy pathology needs to be within the clinical context, primarily defined by time post-transplantation and patient-specific risk profile. With this in mind, similar histopathological patterns will lead to different conclusions with regard to diagnosis, disease grading and staging and thus to patient-specific clinical decision-making. Consensus generation for such integrated diagnostic approach, preferably including new molecular tools, represents the next challenge to the transplant community on its way to precision medicine in transplantation.

The Basics of Renal Allograft Pathology

Renal allograft biopsy provides critical information in the management of renal transplant patients, and must be analyzed in close collaboration with the clinical team. The histologic correlates of acute T-cell mediated rejection are interstitial inflammation, tubulitis, and endothelialitis; polyomavirus nephropathy is a potential mimic. Evidence of antibody-mediated rejection includes C4d deposition; morphologic acute tissue injury; and donor specific antibodies. Acute tubular injury/necrosis is a reversible cause of impaired graft function, especially in the immediate post-transplant period. Drug toxicity, recurrent disease, chronic injury, and other entities affecting both native and transplant kidneys must also be evaluated.

Glomerular inflammation correlates with endothelial injury and with IL-6 and IL-1β secretion in the peripheral blood

BACKGROUND

Transplant glomerulitis is an active form of glomerular injury associated with suboptimal graft outcome, inadequate histologic reproducibility, and poorly understood pathogenesis. Using a modified pathologic schema where glomerular inflammation is defined by the presence of five or more leukocytes per glomerulus, we sought to assess the reproducibility of transplant glomerulitis and to prospectively investigate the pathogenesis of glomerular inflammation.

METHODS

Our cohort includes 59 kidney transplant recipients who underwent 60 "for cause" allograft biopsies. In addition to light microscopy, the majority of the biopsies were assessed using immunohistochemistry, immunofluorescence, and electron microscopy studies. Biopsies were classified as noninflamed (n=21), inflamed (borderline changes or above) without glomerulitis (n=21), and transplant glomerulitis (n=18). Peripheral blood was collected on the day of biopsy and cytokines secreted by peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) were measured ex vivo.

RESULTS

Our modified schema had higher inter-observer agreement for detecting glomerulitis than that of the current Banff schema. Biopsies with glomerulitis showed ultrastructural signs of glomerular capillary wall remodeling. In contrast to other anatomic compartments, intraglomerular leukocytes in glomerulitis group consisted largely of monocytes. Patients with glomerulitis had high levels of IL-6 and IL-1β secreted by PBMCs. Furthermore, the percentage of inflamed glomeruli and the number of intraglomerular monocytes showed independent association with IL-6 and IL-1β levels, which tended to correlate with subsequent estimated glomerular filtration rate decline.

CONCLUSIONS

Inter-observer reproducibility of transplant glomerulitis can be improved by using more stringent histologic criteria. Glomerular inflammation correlates with endothelial injury, monocyte influx, and IL-6 and IL-β secretion by circulating immune cells.

A systematic review of the role of C4d in the diagnosis of acute antibody-mediated rejection

In this study, we conducted a systematic review of the literature to re-evaluate the role of C4d in the diagnosis of acute antibody-mediated rejection of kidney allografts. Electronic databases were searched until September 2013. Eligible studies allowed derivation of diagnostic tables for the performance of C4d by immunofluorescence or immunohistochemistry with comparison to histopathological features of acute antibody-mediated rejection and/or donor-specific antibody (DSA) assays. Of 3492 unique abstracts, 29 studies encompassing 3485 indication and 868 surveillance biopsies were identified. Assessment of C4d by immunofluorescence and immunohistochemistry exhibited slight to moderate agreement with glomerulitis, peritubular capillaritis, solid-phase DSA assays, DSA with glomerulitis, and DSA with peritubular capillaritis. The sensitivity and specificity of C4d varied as a function of C4d and comparator test thresholds. Prognostically, the presence of C4d was associated with inferior allograft survival compared with DSA or histopathology alone. Thus, our findings support the presence of complement-dependent and -independent phenotypes of acute antibody-mediated rejection. Whether the presence of C4d in combination with histopathology or DSA should be considered for the diagnosis of acute antibody-mediated rejection warrants further study.

Preconditioning renoprotective effect of isoflurane in a rat model of virtual renal transplant

BACKGROUND

The development of warm-cold ischemia-reperfusion (IR) injury of the kidney grafts is inevitable during renal transplantation. However, there is currently no definite renoprotective strategy available in the protection of the graft tissue. In the present study, we compared the renal protection of preconditioning isoflurane with N-acetylcysteine (NAC) in a novel rat model of warm-cold renal IR injury.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Adult Sprague-Dawley rats were randomly assigned to receive inhaled isoflurane (1.5% for 2 h), NAC (1 g/kg, intra-arterial injection) or placebo before the induction of brief warm ischemia (10 min) followed by cold ischemia (45 min) periods. Plasma levels of creatinine and tissue inflammatory reaction in the kidney were analyzed 72 h after reperfusion.

RESULTS

Elevated plasma level of creatinine and urea indicated the development of acute renal injury secondary to IR injury. The creatinine levels were reduced in animals pretreated with inhaled isoflurane and NAC, and the level was more significantly decreased in the isoflurane-treated group. Preconditioning with volatile isoflurane also significantly suppressed the tissue myeloperoxidase activity and expression of the inducible nitric oxide synthase. Immunostaining confirmed that myeloperoxidase expression was most significantly attenuated in the glomerulus and peritubular capillaries of rats pre-exposed to isoflurane.

CONCLUSIONS

We present the first study demonstrating that the administration of volatile isoflurane before induction of experimental warm-cold renal IR injury provides preconditioning renoprotective effect, which is superior to the treatment with NAC. The beneficial renoprotective effect of isoflurane is most likely mediated by attenuation of proinflammatory reaction in the injured kidney.

Capillary dilation and rarefaction are correlated with intracapillary inflammation in antibody-mediated rejection

Antibody-mediated rejection (ABMR) remains one of the major causes of graft loss after renal transplantation. It is dominated by endothelial damage in microcirculation. Clarifying the mechanism of microcirculating damage is obviously a key step to understand the pathogenesis of ABMR. Here we characterized capillary variation in ABMR and its possible mechanisms. Compared with T cell-mediated rejection and stable grafts, there was a significant dilation and rarefaction in peritubular capillaries (PTCs) of the ABMR group; Image-Pro Plus revealed a significantly larger intra-PTC area. Interestingly, the dilation of PTCs was strongly correlated with the intra-PTC cell counting. Moreover, peritubular capillary inflammation is correlated with in situ T-bet expression, and there was a good correlation between the intra-PTC expression of T-bet and the PTC diameter. HIF-1α up-regulation could be observed in ABMR but it was not necessary for capillary dilation. In general, ABMR is characterized with early capillary dilation and rarefaction; our data confirmed that the dilation is strongly correlated with intracapillary inflammation, which in turn is correlated with in situ T-bet expression. T-bet plays an important role in the development of microcirculating injury, and thus it is a potential target for the treatment of ABMR.

Biomarkers for kidney transplant rejection

The immune management of organ transplant recipients is imperfect. Beyond general dosing guidelines for immunosuppressive agents and clinical diagnostic tests for rejection or infection, there are few objective tools to determine the aggregate status of a patient's alloimmune response or protective immune capacity. The lack of prognostic precision significantly contributes to patient morbidity and reduces long-term allograft survival after kidney transplantation. Noninvasive biomarkers that could serve as predictive tools or surrogate end points for rejection might help clinicians individualize immunosuppression and allow for early intervention, ideally prior to clinically evident organ dysfunction. Although the growing understanding of organ rejection has provided numerous candidate biomarkers, none has been confirmed in robust validation studies as sufficiently useful to guide clinical practice independent of traditional clinical methods. In this Review, the general characteristics of biomarkers and surrogate end points; current biomarkers under active clinical investigation; and the prominent barriers to the translation of biomarkers into clinical practice are discussed.

The specificity of acute and chronic microvascular alterations in renal allografts

The diagnosis of an antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) is made when there is evident histologic injury in the presence of detectable donor-specific alloantibodies (DSA) and diffuse peritubular capillary C4d staining (C4d-pos). In the presence of only detectable DSA or C4d-pos, the tissue injury is currently considered "presumptive" for antibody causation. In acute antibody-mediated rejection (AAMR), diagnostic morphologic features include microvascular inflammation (MVI), specifically glomerulitis and peritubular capillaritis. In the case of chronic active AMR (CAAMR), these inflammatory lesions have progressed to chronic microvascular injury, transplant glomerulopathy (TG) and peritubular capillary basement membrane multilayering (PTCBMML). Either TG or PTCBMML is sufficient morphological evidence for a diagnosis of CAAMR. Unfortunately, these lesions are not specific. MVI, TG, and PTCBMML are found in the setting of cell-mediated immunity, as well as in association with non-alloimmune mechanisms. The available treatments for AMR and CMR are different, and it is important to ascertain the dominant mechanism when approaching an individual patient. At present, no gold standard exists to establish the specific pathogenesis in the more ambiguous cases. We detail here the differential diagnosis of MVI, TG, and PTCBMML.

Posttransplant monitoring of de novo human leukocyte antigen donor-specific antibodies in kidney transplantation

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

To summarize the evidence supporting the negative impact of de novo donor-specific antibodies (dnDSA) in renal transplantation and to describe the natural history associated with the development of dnDSA.

RECENT FINDINGS

Recent studies have increased our appreciation of the risk factors that predispose to dnDSA while illuminating how these risk factors may relate to the pathophysiology underlying its development. In addition, details regarding the natural history of dnDSA are now available in the context of the different clinical pathologic phenotypes that occur in the patients in whom it develops. Common pitfalls in defining and monitoring dnDSA, when understood, may provide some explanation for the heterogeneity in published studies.

SUMMARY

Recognizing that dnDSA is a major cause of late graft loss, and, more importantly, is detectable in many cases long before dysfunction or graft loss occurs, identifies an opportunity to intervene and change the outcome for the patient.

The clinical and genomic significance of donor-specific antibody-positive/C4d-negative and donor-specific antibody-negative/C4d-negative transplant glomerulopathy

BACKGROUND

This study investigated the mechanisms involved in development of donor-specific antibody (DSA) and/or C4d-negative transplant glomerulopathy (TGP) by allograft gene expression profiles using microarrays.

DESIGN, SETTING, PARTICIPANTS, & MEASUREMENTS

This cohort study was conducted in kidney transplant recipients. Patients were eligible for inclusion if they required a clinically indicated biopsy at any time point after their transplant. They were then classified according to their histopathology findings and DSA and C4d results. Eighteen chronic antibody-mediated rejection (CAMR), 14 DSA+/C4d- TGP, 25 DSA-/C4d- TGP, and 47 nonspecific interstitial fibrosis/tubular atrophy (IFTA) biopsy specimens were identified. In a subset of patients from the study population, biopsy specimens in each group and normal transplant kidney specimens were analyzed with Affymetrix Human Gene 1.0 ST Arrays.

RESULTS

The mean sum score of glomerulitis and peritubular capillaritis increased from 0.28±0.78 in IFTA specimens to 0.75±0.85 in DSA-/C4d- TGP specimens, 1.71±1.49 in DSA+/C4d-/TGP specimens, and 2.11±1.74 in CAMR specimens (P<0.001). During a median follow-up time of 2 (interquartile range, 1.4-2.8) years after biopsy, graft loss was highest in CAMR specimens (27.8%) compared to IFTA specimens (8.5%), DSA+/C4d- TGP specimens (14.3%), and DSA-/C4d- TGP specimens (16%) (P=0.01). With use of microarrays, comparison of the gene expression profiles of DSA-/C4d- TGP specimens with glomerulitis + peritubular capillaritis scores > 0 to normal and IFTA biopsy specimens revealed higher expression of quantitative cytotoxic T cell-associated transcripts (QCAT). However, both CAMR and DSA+/C4d- TGP specimens had higher expression of not only QCAT but also IFN-γ and rejection-induced, constitutive macrophage-associated, natural killer cell-associated, and DSA-selective transcripts. Endothelial cell-associated transcript expression was upregulated only in CAMR biopsy specimens.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggested that DSA+/C4d- TGP biopsy specimens may be classified as CAMR. In contrast, DSA-/C4d- TGP specimens showed increased cytotoxic T cell-associated transcripts, suggesting T cell activation as a mechanism of injury.

Endothelial injury in renal antibody-mediated allograft rejection: a schematic view based on pathogenesis

Circulating donor-specific antibodies (DSA) cause profound changes in endothelial cells (EC) of the allograft microvasculature. EC injury ranges from rapid cellular necrosis to adaptive changes allowing for EC survival, but with modifications of morphology and function resulting in obliteration of the microvasculature.Lytic EC injury: Lethal exposure to DSA/complement predominates in early-acute antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) and presents with EC swelling, cell necrosis, denudation of the underlying matrix and platelet aggregation, thrombotic microangiopathy, and neutrophilic infiltration.Sublytic EC injury: Sublethal exposure to DSA with EC activation predominates in late-chronic AMR. Sublytic injury presents with (a) EC shape and proliferative-reparative alterations: ongoing cycles of cellular injury and repair manifested with EC swelling/loss of fenestrations and expression of growth and mitogenic factors, leading to proliferative changes and matrix remodeling (transplant glomerulopathy and capillaropathy); (b) EC procoagulant changes: EC activation and disruption of the endothelium integrity is associated with production of procoagulant factors, platelet aggregation, and facilitation of thrombotic events manifested with acute and chronic thrombotic microangiopathy; and (c) EC proinflammatory changes: increased EC expression of adhesion molecules including monocyte chemotactic protein-1 and complement and platelet-derived mediators attract inflammatory cells, predominantly macrophages manifested as glomerulitis and capillaritis.Throughout the course of AMR, lytic and sublytic EC injury coexist, providing the basis for the overwhelming morphologic and clinical heterogeneity of AMR. This can be satisfactorily explained by correlating the ultrastructural EC changes and pathophysiology.The vast array of EC responses provides great opportunities for intervention but also represents a colossal challenge for the development of universally successful therapies.

Sequential analysis of donor-specific antibodies and pathological findings in acute antibody-mediated rejection in a rat renal transplantation model

Alloantibodies contribute significantly to renal transplant rejection by activation of complement and various cytokines with a variety of effector cells, and are a major cause of allograft loss. Although there is clinical evidence of antibody- and complement-mediated injury in renal transplantation, the mechanism of antibody-mediated rejection remains largely unknown. In order to understand the sequential production of antibodies and complement components, we presensitized recipient rats by skin transplantation. Anti-donor-specific IgG levels reached a maximum 2 weeks following presensitization after which the rats underwent renal transplantation from the same donor strain. We then evaluated sequential pathological findings based on the Banff classification and several factors related to graft rejection. In this presensitized model, peritubular capillaries were already dilated and stained for C4d. Neutrophil and mononuclear cell infiltration in these capillaries was detected beginning 2 h after transplantation. Donor-specific antibody IgG levels decreased rapidly and anti-IgG antibody stained glomerular and peritubular capillaries in the grafts beginning 2 h after transplantation. Additionally, several cytokines and complement components showed marked changes in the presensitized group. Thus, in the donor-specific presensitized recipient, alloantibodies and complement were activated immediately after transplant. C4d deposition in peritubular capillaries appears to be a key factor for the diagnosis of antibody-associated rejection.

Molecular diagnosis of antibody-mediated rejection in human kidney transplants

Antibody-mediated rejection is the major cause of kidney transplant failure, but the histology-based diagnostic system misses most cases due to its requirement for C4d positivity. We hypothesized that gene expression data could be used to test biopsies for the presence of antibody-mediated rejection. To develop a molecular test, we prospectively assigned diagnoses, including C4d-negative antibody-mediated rejection, to 403 indication biopsies from 315 patients, based on histology (microcirculation lesions) and donor-specific HLA antibody. We then used microarray data to develop classifiers that assigned antibody-mediated rejection scores to each biopsy. The transcripts distinguishing antibody-mediated rejection from other conditions were mostly expressed in endothelial cells or NK cells, or were IFNG-inducible. The scores correlated with the presence of microcirculation lesions and donor-specific antibody. Of 45 biopsies with scores>0.5, 39 had been diagnosed as antibody-mediated rejection on the basis of histology and donor-specific antibody. High scores were also associated with unanimity among pathologists that antibody-mediated rejection was present. The molecular score also strongly predicted future graft loss in Cox regression analysis. We conclude that microarray assessment of gene expression can assign a probability of ABMR to transplant biopsies without knowledge of HLA antibody status, histology, or C4d staining, and predicts future failure.

The impact of C4d and microvascular inflammation before we knew them

It is important to identify prognostically important morphologic criteria in post-transplant management to tailor therapy and improve outcomes. Therefore, using biopsies carried out for cause <1-yr post-transplant, from an era when C4d staining and microvascular inflammation (MVI) were not clinically utilized, we studied the importance of C4d and MVI on graft survival. Snap-frozen first renal allograft biopsy specimens (done for cause) in the first post-transplant year from 1996 to 2001 were stained/examined for C4d, and pathology re-examined by a separate blinded pathologist. Graft outcomes in patients with and without MVI and/or C4d were compared. Of 128 patients, 39 (30.5%) biopsies were C4d+ and 89 (69.5%) were C4d-; 67 (52.3%) had no MVI (MVI-) while 61 (47.7%) had glomerulitis, peritubular capillaritis, or both (MVI+). There were no significant demographic differences between MVI+ and MVI- patients. A greater proportion of C4d+ biopsies was MVI+ (67%) than MVI- (33%; p = 0.004). C4d positivity had no impact on death-censored graft survival (DCGS). In contrast DCGS was worse in MVI+ than MVI- regardless of presence/absence of C4d (p = 0.005). In biopsies for cause carried out <1-yr post-transplant, MVI is associated with decreased DCGS, independent of the presence of C4d.

Peritubular capillaritis in early renal allograft dysfunction is an indicator of acute rejection

BACKGROUND

Kidneys showing acute rejection (AR) processes often are accompanied by various levels of peritubular capillaritis (Ptc), especially cases of acute humoral rejection (AHR). However, it is not known whether the presence of Ptc alone is sufficient evidence of allograft rejection. This study was performed to determine the diagnostic value of Ptc as a marker for AR among cases of early renal allograft dysfunction.

METHODS

Fifty-three AR showed C4d deposition in the peritubular capillaries (PTCs; C4d+AR group), 50 AR were without C4d deposition (C4d-AR group), 30 had Ptc alone (Ptc group), 28 had acute tubular necrosis (ATN group), and 78 were surveillance biopsies (control group).

RESULTS

Analyzing the immunophenotype of infiltrating T lymphocytes and serum antibodies, discovered that 85.9% of control biopsies presented with a regulatory phenotype. Among the Ptc cohort, 93.3% of biopsies showed the cytotoxic phenotype with no significant different between C4d+AR and C4d-AR (96.2% vs 92.0%). We also observed the prevalence of panel-reactive antibody (PRA) and major-histocompatibility-complex class I chain-related gene A (MICA) antibodies to be increased among Ptc (30.0% and 43.3%, respectively), albeit not significantly different from C4d+AR (49.1% and 39.6%, respectively). The prevalences were low in other groups.

CONCLUSIONS

These results implied that Ptc in biopsy specimens from patients with early renal allograft dysfunction was an indicator of AR, especially AHR.

Pathological diagnosis of antibody-mediated rejection in renal allograft without c4d staining, how much reliable?

Background:

C4d as a part of complement activation process is a marker for detecting antibody-mediated rejection (ABMR) and its positivity accompanied by positive donor specific antibody (DSA), and morphologic view of humoral rejection has been suggested to detect ABMR since 2003.

Materials and Methods:

41 specimens of transplanted kidney biopsies gathered from 2006 to 2008 were evaluated for morphological changes on light microscopy, and nephro-pathologist made distinct diagnosis for all of specimens then c4d staining was done for all of them. The association between primary diagnosis without c4d staining and c4d scoring on peritubular capillaries and glomerular capillaries were evaluated to determine whether morphological changes were enough for distinct diagnosis or not.

Results:

Acute tubular necrosis (ATN) 27%, interstitial fibrosis and tubular atrophy (IF&TA) 17%, and T cell mediated rejection (TCMR) 22% were the commonest diagnosis on light microscopy, and 17% of all biopsies had diffuse positive c4d staining. There was not any report of ABMR in morphological evaluation while c4d positive staining was seen in some specimens (17%). It may result from masking of ABMR by other morphological changes such as TCMR and no specific histologic changes for ABMR on light microscopy.

Conclusion:

We would like to emphasize that c4d staining should be done for all of renal allograft biopsies, and pathologists all over the world should consider the probability of ABMR masked by other morphological changes on light microscopic evaluation.