CD8+ T-Cell depletion and rapamycin synergize with combined coreceptor/stimulation blockade to induce robust limb allograft tolerance in mice

A systematic review of immunomodulatory strategies used in skin-containing preclinical vascularized composite allotransplant models

BACKGROUND

Acute rejection remains a vexing problem in vascularized composite allotransplantation (VCA). Available immunosuppressive regimens are successful at minimizing alloimmune response and allowing VCA in humans. However, repeated rejection episodes are common, and systemic side effects of the current standard regimen (Tacrolimus, MMF, Prednisone) are dose limiting. Novel immunomodulatory approaches to improve allograft acceptance and minimize systemic toxicity are continuously explored in preclinical models. We aimed to systematically summarize past and current approaches to help guide future research in this complex field.

METHODS

We conducted a systematic review of manuscripts listed in the MEDLINE and PubMed databases. For inclusion, articles had to primarily investigate the effect of a therapeutic approach on prolonging the survival of a skin-containing preclinical VCA model. Non-VCA studies, human trials, anatomical and feasibility studies, and articles written in a language other than English were excluded. We followed the preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses (PRISMA) guidelines.

RESULTS

The search retrieved 980 articles of which 112 articles were ultimately included. The majority of investigations used a rat model. An orthotopic hind limb VCA model was used in 53% of the studies. Cell and drug-based approaches were investigated 58 and 52 times, respectively. We provide a comprehensive review of immunomodulatory strategies used in VCA preclinical research over a timeframe of 44 years.

CONCLUSION

We identify a transition from anatomically non-specific to anatomical models mimicking clinical needs. As limb transplants have been most frequently performed, preclinical research focused on using the hind limb model. We also identify a transition from drug-based suppression therapies to cell-based immunomodulation strategies.

Limited efficacy of rapamycin monotherapy in vascularized composite allotransplantation

BACKGROUND

Vascularized composite allotransplantation (VCA) is a novel and life-enhancing procedure to restore a patient's function and/or appearance. Current immunosuppression in VCA recipients is based on calcineurin inhibitor (CNI) therapy that can lead to severe complications, such that inducing immune tolerance is a major goal of VCA research. In contrast to CNI, rapamycin (RPM) is thought to be beneficial to the development of immune tolerance by suppressing T-effector cells (Teffs) and expanding T-regulatory (Treg) cells. However, we found high dose RPM monotherapy prolonged VCA survival by only a few days, leading us to explore the mechanisms responsible.

METHODS

A mouse orthotopic forelimb transplantation model (BALB/c- > C57BL/6) was established using WT mice, as well as C57BL/6 recipients with conditional deletion of T-bet within their Treg cells. Events in untreated VCA recipients or those receiving RPM or FK506 therapy were analyzed by flow-cytometry, histopathology and real-time qPCR.

RESULTS

Therapy with RPM (2 mg/kg/d, p < .005) or FK506 (2 mg/kg/d, p < .005) each prolonged VCA survival. In contrast to FK506, RPM increased the ratio of splenic Treg to Teff cells (p < .05) by suppressing Teff and expanding Treg cells. While the proportion of activated splenic CD4 + Foxp3- T cells expressing IFN-γ were similar in control and RPM-treated groups, RPM decreased the proportions ICOS+ and CD8+ IFN-γ + splenic T cells. However, RPM also downregulated CXCR3+ expression by Tregs, and forelimb allografts had reduced infiltration by CXCR3+ Treg cells. In addition, allograft recipients whose Tregs lacked T-bet underwent accelerated rejection compared to WT mice despite RPM therapy.

CONCLUSIONS

We demonstrate that while RPM increased the ratio of Treg to Teff cells and suppressed CD8+ T cell allo-activation, it failed to prevent CD4 Teff cell activation and impaired CXCR3-dependent Treg graft homing, thereby limiting the efficacy of RPM in VCA recipients.

Hematopoietic chimerism and donor-specific skin allograft tolerance after non-genotoxic CD117 antibody-drug-conjugate conditioning in MHC-mismatched allotransplantation

Hematopoietic chimerism after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation may establish a state of donor antigen-specific tolerance. However, current allotransplantation protocols involve genotoxic conditioning which has harmful side-effects and predisposes to infection and cancer. Here we describe a non-genotoxic conditioning protocol for fully MHC-mismatched bone marrow allotransplantation in mice involving transient immunosuppression and selective depletion of recipient hematopoietic stem cells with a CD117-antibody-drug-conjugate (ADC). This protocol resulted in multilineage, high level (up to 50%), durable, donor-derived hematopoietic chimerism after transplantation of 20 million total bone marrow cells, compared with ≤ 2.1% hematopoietic chimerism from 50 million total bone marrow cells without conditioning. Moreover, long-term survival of bone marrow donor-type but not third party skin allografts is achieved in CD117-ADC-conditioned chimeric mice without chronic immunosuppression. The only observed adverse event is transient elevation of liver enzymes in the first week after conditioning. These results provide proof-of-principle for CD117-ADC as a non-genotoxic, highly-targeted conditioning agent in allotransplantation and tolerance protocols.

Targeted Complement Inhibition Protects Vascularized Composite Allografts From Acute Graft Injury and Prolongs Graft Survival When Combined With Subtherapeutic Cyclosporine A Therapy

BACKGROUND

Recipients of vascularized composite allografts require aggressive and lifelong immunosuppression, and because the surgery is usually performed in nonlife-threatening situations, the development of strategies to minimize immunosuppression is especially pertinent for this procedure. We investigated how complement affects acute graft injury, alloimmunity, and immunosuppressive therapy.

METHODS

Vascularized composite allografts were transplanted from Balb/C to C57BL/6 mice that were complement deficient (C3 or double C3a Receptor (R)/C5aR), or treated with a targeted complement inhibitor (CR2-Crry). Allografts were analyzed for acute inflammation and injury, subacute T cell response, and survival in the absence and presence of cyclosporine A (CsA) therapy.

RESULTS

Allografts in C3-deficient or CR2-Crry-treated recipients were protected from skin and muscle ischemia-reperfusion injury (IRI). C3aR/C5aR-deficient recipients were more modestly protected. IgM and C3d colocalized within allografts from wild type and C3aR/C5aR-deficient recipients indicating IgM-mediated complement activation, and C3d deposition was almost absent in allografts from C3-deficient and CR2-Crry-treated recipients. Inflammatory cell infiltration and P-selectin expression was also significantly reduced in C3-deficient and CR2-Crry-treated recipients. Acute treatment with CR2-Crry or with 3 mg/kg per day CsA modestly, but significantly increased median allograft survival from 5.8 to 7.4 and 7.2 days, respectively. However, combined acute CR2-Crry treatment and CsA therapy increased mean graft survival to 17.2 days. Protection was associated with significantly reduced T cell infiltration of allografts and Tc1 cells in recipient spleens.

CONCLUSIONS

Complement-mediated IRI augments graft allogenicity, and appropriate complement inhibition ameliorates IRI, decreases alloimmune priming and allows more immune-sparing CsA dosing.

Regulatory T Cell-Dependent and -Independent Mechanisms of Immune Suppression by CD28/B7 and CD40/CD40L Costimulation Blockade

Blocking of costimulatory CD28/B7 and CD40/CD40L interactions is an experimental approach to immune suppression and tolerance induction. We previously reported that administration of a combination of CTLA-4Ig and MR1 (anti-CD40L mAb) for blockade of these interactions induces tolerance in a fully mismatched allogeneic splenocyte transfer model in mice. We now used this model to study whether regulatory T cells (Tregs) contribute to immune suppression and why both pathways have to be blocked simultaneously. Mice were injected with allogeneic splenocytes, CD4(+) T cells, or CD8(+) T cells and treated with MR1 mAb and different doses of CTLA-4Ig. The graft-versus-host reaction of CD4(+) T cells, but not of CD8(+) T cells, was inhibited by MR1. CTLA-4Ig was needed to cover CD8(+) T cells but had only a weak effect on CD4(+) T cells. Consequently, only the combination provided full protection when splenocytes were transferred. Importantly, MR1 and low-dose CTLA-4Ig treatment resulted in a relative increase in Tregs, and immune suppressive efficacy was abolished in the absence of Tregs. High-dose CTLA-4Ig treatment, in contrast, prevented Treg expansion and activity, and in combination with MR1 completely inhibited CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cell activation in a Treg-independent manner. In conclusion, MR1 and CTLA-4Ig act synergistically as they target different T cell populations. The contribution of Tregs to immune suppression by costimulation blockade depends on the concentration of CTLA-4Ig and thus on the degree of available CD28 costimulation.

Immunopathology of rejection: do the rules of solid organ apply to vascularized composite allotransplantation?

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

As both the number of vascularized composite allotransplants (VCAs) recipients and the duration of their follow-up are limited, immunopathology of VCA rejection remains incompletely understood. VCAs have several immunological peculiarities, which make inaccurate a direct extrapolation of all rules established for solid organs.

RECENT FINDINGS

Despite their bone marrow content, VCA do not induce chimerism in recipient and are therefore not spontaneously tolerated. Skin compartment of VCA contains a high density of antigen-presenting cells (APCs), some with self-renewal capacity. Donor APCs are responsible for continuous direct allosensitization of recipient's T cells that explains the high incidence of skin T-cell-mediated rejection and their occurrence beyond 1 year.Regenerative capability of the skin prevents the development of chronic rejection of this compartment as long as immunosuppression is maintained. In contrast, VCA can develop graft arteriosclerosis, which could be because of T cell and/or chronic antibody-mediated rejection (AMR). VCA recipients can indeed develop donor-specific antibodies (DSA). Whether DSA can also trigger acute AMR of VCA remains to be clarified.

SUMMARY

A better understanding of the specificities of the immunopathology of VCA rejection should pave the way for the rationalization of immunosuppressive strategies aiming at optimizing long-term outcome.

The Macrophage-depleting Agent Clodronate Promotes Durable Hematopoietic Chimerism and Donor-specific Skin Allograft Tolerance in Mice

Hematopoietic chimerism is known to promote donor-specific organ allograft tolerance; however, clinical translation has been impeded by the requirement for toxic immunosuppression and large doses of donor bone marrow (BM) cells. Here, we investigated in mice whether durable chimerism might be enhanced by pre-treatment of the recipient with liposomal clodronate, a macrophage depleting agent, with the goal of vacating BM niches for preferential reoccupation by donor hematopoietic stem cells (HSC). We found that liposomal clodronate pretreatment of C57BL/6 mice permitted establishment of durable hematopoietic chimerism when the mice were given a low dose of donor BM cells and transient immunosuppression. Moreover, clodronate pre-treatment increased durable donor-specific BALB/c skin allograft tolerance. These results provide proof-of-principle that clodronate is effective at sparing the number of donor BM cells required to achieve durable hematopoietic chimerism and donor-specific skin allograft tolerance and justify further development of a tolerance protocol based on this principle.

Pre-treatment of allogeneic bone marrow recipients with the CXCR4 antagonist AMD3100 transiently enhances hematopoietic chimerism without promoting donor-specific skin allograft tolerance

Hematopoietic chimerism established by allogeneic bone marrow transplantation is known to promote donor-specific organ allograft tolerance; however, clinical application is limited by the need for toxic host conditioning and "megadoses" of donor bone marrow cells. A potential solution to this problem has been suggested by the observation that recipient bone marrow mobilization by the CXCR4 antagonist AMD3100 promotes chimerism in congenic bone marrow transplantation experiments in mice. Here we report that a single subcutaneous dose of 10 mg/kg AMD3100 in recipient C57BL/6 mice was able to enhance hematopoietic chimerism when complete MHC-mismatched BALB/c donor bone marrow cells were transplanted 1h after drug dosing. However, levels of chimerism measured 30 days post-transplantation were not sustained when mice were reexamined on day 90 post-transplantation. Moreover, transient chimerism induced by this protocol did not support robust donor-specific skin allograft tolerance. Using the same transient immunosuppression protocol, we confirmed that "megadoses" of donor bone marrow cells could induce durable chimerism associated with donor-specific skin allograft tolerance without AMD3100 pre-treatment. We conclude that in this protocol AMD3100 pretreatment may empty bone marrow niches that become reoccupied by allogeneic donor hematopoietic progenitor cells but not by true long-lived donor hematopoietic stem cells, resulting in short-lived chimerism and failure to support durable donor-specific allograft tolerance.

The neck as a preferred recipient site for vascularized composite allotransplantation in the mouse

BACKGROUND

The mouse is still considered the premier model in basic immunologic and transplant-related research. However, because of its much smaller size, the mouse has proven to be a technically difficult and physiologically fragile model from a surgical standpoint. That is why only a few studies currently use mouse models in vascularized composite allotransplantation. The purpose of this study therefore was to develop a reproducible and reliable surgical technique in the mouse for future vascularized composite allotransplantation studies.

METHODS

Forty DBA/2 (H2-D) hindlimb osteomyocutanous flaps were transplanted into the right cervical region of C57BL/6 (H2-D) mice using a nonsuture cuff technique. The donor iliac artery and femoral vein were mounted with polyimide cuffs (inner diameter, 0.404 mm; wall thickness, 0.025 mm) and subsequently anastomosed to the recipient common carotid artery and external jugular vein. Immunosuppressant drugs were used postoperatively.

RESULTS

The overall success rate was 85.0 percent (34 of 40). The mortality rate was 12.5 percent (five of 40); all deaths resulted from perioperative bleeding. Only one arterial insufficiency was encountered after transplantation. The operative time was approximately 2 hours. Indefinite allograft survival (>120 days) could be achieved using a specific immunosuppressant regimen.

CONCLUSIONS

This novel mouse model allows performing vascularized composite allotransplantation with very high success and survival rates. The advantages over conventional models are multifold. A high-flow common carotid artery keeps the anastomosis patent, and diastolic suction of the heart reduces the risk of venous stasis and thrombus formation. Less destruction because of the heterotopic positioning of the hindlimb graft further reduces the associated mortality and morbidity in this fragile model.

Improving the safety of tolerance induction: chimerism and cellular co-treatment strategies applied to vascularized composite allografts

Although vascularized composite allografts (VCAs) have been performed clinically for a variety of indications, potential complications from long-term immunosuppression and graft-versus-host disease remain important barriers to widespread applications. Recently it has been demonstrated that VCAs incorporating a vascularized long bone in a rat model provide concurrent vascularized bone marrow transplantation that, itself, functions to establish hematopoietic chimerism and donor-specific tolerance following non-myeloablative conditioning of recipients. Advances such as this, which aim to improve the safety profile of tolerance induction, will help usher in an era of wider clinical VCA application for nonlife-saving reconstructions.

Translating tolerogenic therapies to the clinic - where do we stand?

Manipulation of the immune system to prevent the development of a specific immune response is an ideal strategy to improve outcomes after transplantation. A number of experimental techniques exploiting central and peripheral tolerance mechanisms have demonstrated success, leading to the first early phase clinical trials for tolerance induction. The first major strategy centers on the facilitation of donor-cell mixed chimerism in the transplant recipient with the use of bone marrow or hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. The second strategy, utilizing peripheral regulatory mechanisms, focuses on cellular therapy with regulatory T cells. This review examines the key studies and novel research directions in the field of immunological tolerance.

Rapamycin as immunosuppressant in murine transplantation model

The potent immunosuppressive action of rapamycin has been described in many different mouse models of transplantation. In these models, rapamycin prevent or delay allograft rejection. In several models, rapamycin allowed mixed donor-recipient hematopoietic chimerism to develop facilitating tolerance induction. In our own experience, we observed that rapamycin synergized with CD8(+) T cell depletion and coreceptor/costimulation blockade to induce long-term survival of Balb/C to C57Bl/6 heterotopic limb allograft. Herein, we describe immunosuppression cocktails containing rapamycin and methods to evaluate several read outs associated with tolerance induction such as mixed donor-recipient hematopoietic chimerism and in vitro or in vivo recipient alloreactivity.

Dendritic cells transfected with PD-L1 recombinant adenovirus induces T cell suppression and long-term acceptance of allograft transplantation

The purpose of this study is to assess the potential of dendritic cells transfected with PD-L1 recombinant adenovirus induces CD8+ T cell suppression and kidney allograft tolerance. To prove it, DCs transfected with PD-L1 recombinant adenovirus (DC/Ad-PD-L1) were transferred into the MHC-mismatched rat kidney transplants. After kidney transplantation, the mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) assay and kidney function were analyzed. The results demonstrated that after administration of DC/Ad-PD-L1, the proliferation, cytokines secretion and activation marker expression of CD8+ T cells were suppressed. In addition, DC/Ad-PD-L1 could improve kidney function and survival of transplants. The findings suggested that DC/Ad-PD-L1 could induce CD8+ T cell tolerance and lead to kidney allograft tolerance, which provided a promising finding for clinical application.

Mouse hind limb transplantation: a new composite tissue allotransplantation model using nonsuture supermicrosurgery

BACKGROUND

The development of microsurgical techniques has facilitated the establishment of vascularized composite tissue transplant models in small mammals. Because the mouse would be the ideal model to study various composite tissue allotransplantation (CTA)-related problems, we designed two new surgical techniques for orthotopic (ORT) and heterotopic (HET) hind limb transplantation.

METHODS

BALB/c hind limbs were transplanted to BALB/c or C57BL6 recipients using a nonsuture cuff technique. ORT: donor femoral vessels were anastomosed to recipient femoral vessels, the sciatic nerve approximated end-to-end and osteosynthesis was performed using an intramedullary rod. HET/cervical: Donor femoral vessels of a reduced size osteomyocutaneous hind limb CTA were anastomosed to recipient common carotid artery and external jugular vein without nerve approximation.

RESULTS

Both procedures could be performed with a high success rate (ORT: 62%; HET: 90%). Donor operation lasted for 100±12 min and recipient operation 114±27 min (ORT) and 54±16 min (HET). Complication rates in terms of bleeding, and thrombosis at the cuff side was slightly higher in the ORT group. All syngeneic grafts survived long term (>100 days). FK506 (2 mg/kg) significantly prolonged graft survival (87±22 days) when compared with untreated controls (6±1 day). Functional evaluation of ORT grafts by means of video gait kinematics and CatWalk analysis revealed specific differences of gait parameters when compared with nontransplanted controls (P<0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The ORT hind limb transplant model seems to be best suited to study functional outcome and nerve regeneration in CTA. The technically less demanding HET/cervical model may be used to investigate basic immunology and clinically relevant questions related to acute and chronic rejection, and ischemia reperfusion injury in reconstructive transplantation.

Interferon gamma licensing of human dendritic cells in T-helper-independent CD8+ alloimmunity

The high frequency of allogeneic reactive CD8(+) T cells in human and their resistance to immunosuppression might be one of the reasons why successful tolerance-inducing strategies in rodents have failed in primates. Studies on the requirement for T-helper cells in priming CD8(+) T-cell responses have led to disparate findings. Recent studies have reported CD8(+)-mediated allograft rejection independently of T-helper cells; however, the mechanisms that govern the activation of these T cells are far from being elucidated. In this study, we demonstrated that lipopolysaccharide-treated dendritic cells (DCs) were able to induce proliferation and cytotoxic activity of allogeneic CD8(+) T cells independently of CD4(+) T cells, while adding mycophenolic acid (MPA) to LPS abolished this capacity and resulted in anergic CD8(+) T cells that secreted high levels of interleukin-4 (IL-4), IL-5, IL-10, and transforming growth factor-β. Interestingly, we demonstrated that MPA inhibited the LPS-induced synthesis of tumor necrosis factor-α, IL-12, and interferon-γ (IFN-γ) in DCs. Importantly, we found that adding exogenous IFN-γ to MPA restored both the synthesis of cytokines and the ability to activate CD8(+) T cells. However, adding IL-12 or tumor necrosis factor-α had no effect. These results suggest that IFN-γ has an important role in licensing DCs to prime CD4-independent CD8 allogeneic T cells via an autocrine loop.

Hand transplantation and vascularized composite tissue allografts in orthopaedics and traumatology

Composite tissue allograft (CTA) is defined as heterologous transplantation of a complex comprising skin and subcutaneous, neurovascular and mesenchymal tissue. Such techniques allow complex reconstruction using matched tissue, without donor site morbidity. The potential indications in orthopaedics-traumatology could in the future be more frequent than the present indications of heart, lung, liver, kidney and pancreas transplantation. International clinical experience clearly demonstrates the feasibility of CTA, both surgically and immunologically. However, immunosuppression remains indispensable, exposing the patient to risks that are not acceptable for purely functional surgery, except in very particular indications. The main hope for the future lies in induction of graft-specific tolerance.