Examiner agreement on caries detection and plaque accumulation during dental surveys of elders

Root caries: a periodontal perspective

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

A prevailing dental problem in the periodontal patient is root caries. Specifically, periodontal involvement often results in root surfaces becoming exposed and at risk for this condition. Periodontal therapy often leads to increased gingival recession as well, and the associated increased root caries risk may compromise the long-term success and survival of periodontally treated teeth.This narrative review will address the topic of root caries in the periodontal patient, focusing on unmet research needs.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The Medline database was searched to identify items dealing with root caries, in terms of clinical features, diagnosis, pathogenic mechanisms and histopathology, as well as epidemiology, focusing then on the relationship between root caries and periodontal disorders.

RESULTS

Although there is extensive literature on root caries, consensus is lacking regarding certain aspects, such as diagnostic criteria, prevalence within populations and indisputable risk factors. Advancing age could be an aggravating factor in susceptibility to root caries for the periodontal patient; however, definitive evidence in this regard is still missing. Similarly, full awareness of the increased risk of root caries in patients with periodontal disease or long-term periodontal treatment appears to be still lacking.

CONCLUSION

Research regarding root caries in age-specific (elderly) periodontal patients is needed. Improved oral hygiene practices, locally applied preventive measures, good dietary habits and regular dental check-ups are crucial approaches to prevent both periodontal disease progression and root caries. Periodontal patients with root exposure should follow a strict root caries prevention protocol, as an integral component of their periodontal maintenance therapy.

Examiner performance in calibration exercises compared with field conditions when scoring caries experience

The objective of this study was to verify how valid misclassification measurements obtained from a 'pre-survey' calibration exercise are by comparing them to validation scores obtained in 'field' conditions. Validation data were collected from the 'Smile for Life' project, an oral health intervention study in Flemish children. A calibration exercise was organized under 'pre-survey' conditions (32 age-matched children examined by eight examiners and the benchmark scorer). In addition, using a pre-determined sampling scheme blinded to the examiners, the benchmark scorer re-examined between six and 11 children screened by each of the dentists during the survey. Factors influencing sensitivity and specificity for scoring caries experience (CE) were investigated, including examiner, tooth type, surface type, tooth position (upper/lower jaw, right/left side) and validation setting (pre-survey versus field). In order to account for the clustering effect in the data, a generalized estimating equations approach was applied. Sensitivity scores were influenced not only by the calibration setting (lower sensitivity in field conditions, p < 0.01), but also by examiner, tooth type (lower sensitivity in molar teeth, p < 0.01) and tooth position (lower sensitivity in the lower jaw, p < 0.01). Factors influencing specificity were examiner, tooth type (lower specificity in molar teeth, p < 0.01) and surface type (the occlusal surface with a lower specificity than other surfaces) but not the validation setting. Misclassification measurements for scoring CE are influenced by several factors. In this study, the validation setting influenced sensitivity, with lower scores obtained when measuring data validity in 'field' conditions. Results obtained in a pre-survey calibration setting need to be interpreted with caution and do not (always) reflect the actual performance of examiners during the field work.

Inter-individual variation in the plaque formation rate of young individuals

OBJECTIVES

The aim of the present study was to describe the inter-individual variation in the plaque formation rate of 38 young adults.

METHODS

The plaque formation rate was estimated by employing a quantitative plaque percent index (P% index). A substantial inter-individual variation in the plaque formation rate was observed. The possible contributions of stimulated salivary flow rate, buffer capacity, diet and smoking to the variation in plaque formation were estimated by regression analysis.

RESULTS

The control variables explained only 2.5% of the variance in the plaque formation rate. Neither associations nor the total model were significant. The present method of measuring plaque presented as a simple and time-effective procedure.

CONCLUSIONS

It is suggested that the observed variation in the plague formation rate between the young individuals can be regarded as a biological function which is possibly an inherent individual characteristic. Studies with larger sample sizes are required to confirm the findings of the present study.

The use of fluorescein-enhanced quantitative light-induced fluorescence to monitor de- and re-mineralization of in vitro root caries

The use of fluorescein-enhanced quantitative light-induced fluorescence (QLF) in the detection of in vitro root caries demineralization and reminerlization was investigated. Fourteen previously extracted human premolar roots were selected and determined to be caries-free. Cementum was removed and nail varnish applied leaving an exposed window. Positive and negative controls were selected. During a demineralizing regimen, roots were removed at regular intervals (12, 48, 72 and 120 h) and immersed in sodium fluorescein (0.2 mg L(-1)). Following gentle rinsing, each root was examined using QLF before being returned to the demineralizing solution. Following 120 h, each tooth was sectioned through the lesion and one-half retained for transverse micro radiography (TMR) analysis. The remaining half were subjected to a remineralizing regimen undergoing the same fluorescein and QLF examinations at 7, 28 and 36 days. Results showed that QLF effectively monitored demineralization/remineralization of root dentine as represented by fluorescein penetration. TMR analysis showed good correlations with QLF (DeltaZ/DeltaQ) after demineralization (r = 0.89) and remineralization (r = 0.84). The technique could represent an in vivo method for root caries detection and classification.

An index of clinical oral disorder in elders (CODE)

Attempts to construct an index of oral health or disorder suitable for older adults have been limited in clinical scope or based on the judgement of very few individuals. Consequently, we present here a multidimensional index of Clinical Oral Disorder in Elders (CODE) based on a breadth of clinical measures relevant to elders. The data for the index are derived from a clinical examination of jaw function, dentures, mucosa, teeth, and periodontium. Weighting or ranking for each disorder within the context of an elderly person was established as mild, moderate or severe by experienced dental clinicians and dental hygienists. Subsequently, the index was constructed by transforming the weights into a numerical value for each clinical measure. Individual scores can relate to the heaviest weight identified during the examination or to the sum of the weights assigned throughout the examination, and the average score during a series of examinations will reflect the clinical status of a particular population. Clinical applications in elderly residential-care populations indicate that the index can be constructed efficiently and with reasonable reliability. We suggest, therefore, that the CODE index is suitable for descriptive and comparative research by providing a clinical format for measuring oral disorder in disabled elders, and, when combined with a psychosocial index, it should be very comprehensive indicator of oral dysfunction in older adults.

Oral health and history of respiratory tract infection in frail institutionalised elders

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to look for a relationship between history of respiratory tract infection (RTI) and oral health in very old subjects.

SETTING AND SUBJECTS

302 frail elders (mean age: 85 years) living in a medical care facility were examined by one dentist.

OUTCOME MEASURES

The incidence of RTI over 1 year had been recorded along with markers of nutritional status and degree of dependency. The oral examination comprised an evaluation of hygiene, quality of prostheses and the prevalence of caries, periodontal disease and mucosal disorders.

RESULTS

One third (33%) of the subjects had experienced at least one episode of RTI, and a fifth (19%) had visited the dentist in emergency. The incidence of RTI had been greater among dentate subjects and those who came to the dentist in emergency. The dentate subjects with a history of RTI had higher plaque score (P = 0.02). Half (49%) of the subjects had oral disorders that could develop in a dental emergency and these subjects had had a higher risk of RTI (relative risk: 1.9, 95% confidence interval: 1.1-3.9). The presence of selected oral disorders associated with low serum albumin increased the relative risk of having had RTI to 3.2 (1.5-6.7). The association between presence of actual oral health problems and previous experience of RTI was more noticeable in those who had poor general health or were more debilitated.

CONCLUSIONS

The present study suggests that poor oral hygiene and the presence of potential emergency could be major risk factors for RTI among the frail elderly.

Caries prevalence and associated predisposing conditions in recently hospitalized elderly persons

The prevalence of caries and caries risk factors was studied among 120 consecutively hospitalized elderly persons. Coronal caries was recorded using the WHO criteria, and active and inactive root caries in accordance with Fejerskov et al. The CPITN was used to evaluate the periodontal state and plaque accumulation in accordance with Löe & Silness. Of the 1212 teeth examined 5% had active coronal caries (2% inactive), 14% active root caries (2% inactive), and 10% fillings with recurrent caries. No relationship was found between caries prevalence, degree of dependence, number of medicaments, age, and gender. Patients with psychiatric diseases had increased caries prevalence (P < 0.01), and lower caries prevalence was associated with frequent tooth brushing (P < 0.05). At the tooth level root caries was associated with high plaque scores (P < 0.001), degree of gingival recession (P < 0.001), presence of coronal caries (P < 0.001), and increased pocket depth (P < 0.01). The results strongly indicate that oral hygiene measures should be introduced immediately after hospitalization of these patients.

Examiner agreement on periodontal indices during dental surveys of elders

Indices used to evaluate periodontal health have been widely accepted in epidemiological studies, yet their reliability cannot be guaranteed. The aim of this study was to evaluate the reliability of periodontal indices applied on elders. 19 elderly subjects, 73-years-old on average, were examined at a 1st appointment by 2 independent examiners. They were re-examined 2 weeks later during a 2nd session. The examinations were performed in a dental chair with good illumination. Periodontal health was evaluated using the community periodontal index of treatment need, and tooth mobility was evaluated using 2 different indices. Inter and intra-examiner agreements were evaluated using kappa statistics. Taken as an overall measurement, the CPITN was a reliable assessment of periodontal treatment need in elders. Disagreement occurred mainly on the evaluation of bleeding and shallow pockets. The detection of fairly mobile teeth was reliable; however, the performance of the more sensitive scale was deceptive. it seems that, in the case of tooth mobility, a choice has to be made between sensitivity or reproducibility. It can be concluded that examiners should be trained carefully since the reliability of the CPITN and tooth mobility evaluation were good but close to a critical level for which an agreement is classified as poor.