Gradual phosphorylation regulates PC4 coactivator function

Molecular Mechanisms of Functional Modulation of Transcriptional Coactivator PC4 via Phosphorylation on Its Intrinsically Disordered Region

To investigate the effects of phosphorylation on the function of the human positive cofactor 4 (PC4), an enhanced molecular dynamics (MD) simulation was performed. The simulation system consists of the N-terminal intrinsic disordered region (IDR) of PC4 and a complex that comprises the C-terminal acidic activation domain of a herpes simplex virion protein 16 (VP16ad) and a homodimer of the C-terminal structured core domain of PC4 (PC4ctd). An earlier report of an experimental study reported that the PC4-VP16ad interaction is modulated by incremental phosphorylation of the IDR. That report also proposed a dynamic model where phosphorylated serine residues of a segment (SEAC) in the IDR contact positively charged residues (lysin and arginine) of another segment (K-rich) in the IDR. This contact formation induced by the phosphorylation results in variation of PC4-VP16ad interaction. However, this contact formation has not yet been measured directly because it is transiently formed and because the SEAC and K-rich segments are unstructured with high flexibility. We performed two simulations to mimic the incremental phosphorylation: the IDR was not phosphorylated in one simulation and only partially phosphorylated in the other. Our simulation results indicate that the phosphorylation weakens the IDR-VP16ad contact considerably with the induction of a compact structure in the IDR. This structure was stabilized by electrostatic interactions between the phosphorylated serine residues of a segment and lysine or arginine residues of another segment in the IDR, but the conformational fluctuation of this compact structure was considerably large. Consequently, the present study supports the experimentally proposed dynamic model. Results of this study can be important for computational elucidation of the functional modulation of PC4.

The Role of S. cerevisiae Sub1/PC4 in Transcription Elongation Depends on the C-Terminal Region and Is Independent of the ssDNA Binding Domain

Saccharomyces cerevisiae Sub1 (ScSub1) has been defined as a transcriptional stimulatory protein due to its homology to the ssDNA binding domain (ssDBD) of human PC4 (hPC4). Recently, PC4/Sub1 orthologues have been elucidated in eukaryotes, prokaryotes, and bacteriophages with functions related to DNA metabolism. Additionally, ScSub1 contains a unique carboxyl–terminal region (CT) of unknown function up to date. Specifically, it has been shown that Sub1 is required for transcription activation, as well as other processes, throughout the transcription cycle. Despite the progress that has been made in understanding the mechanism underlying Sub1′s functions, some questions remain unanswered. As a case in point: whether Sub1’s roles in initiation and elongation are differentially predicated on distinct regions of the protein or how Sub1′s functions are regulated. Here, we uncover some residues that are key for DNA–ScSub1 interaction in vivo, localized in the ssDBD, and required for Sub1 recruitment to promoters. Furthermore, using an array of genetic and molecular techniques, we demonstrate that the CT region is required for transcription elongation by RNA polymerase II (RNAPII). Altogether, our data indicate that Sub1 plays a dual role during transcription—in initiation through the ssDBD and in elongation through the CT region.

The Catalytic Subunit of Schizosaccharomyces pombe CK2 (Cka1) Negatively Regulates RNA Polymerase II Transcription through Phosphorylation of Positive Cofactor 4 (PC4)

Positive cofactor 4 (PC4) is a transcriptional coactivator that plays important roles in transcription and DNA replication. In mammals, PC4 is phosphorylated by CK2, and this event downregulates its RNA polymerase II (RNAPII) coactivator function. This work describes the effect of fission yeast PC4 phosphorylation on RNAPII transcription in a cell extract, which closely resembles the cellular context. We found that fission yeast PC4 is strongly phosphorylated by the catalytic subunit of CK2 (Cka1), while the regulatory subunit (Ckb1) downregulates the PC4 phosphorylation. The addition of Cka1 to an in vitro transcription assay can diminish the basal transcription from the Ad-MLP promoter; however, the addition of recombinant fission yeast PC4 or Ckb1 can stimulate the basal transcription in a cell extract. Fission yeast PC4 is phosphorylated in a domain which has consensus phosphorylation sites for CK2, and two serine residues were identified as critical for CK2 phosphorylation. Mutation of one of the serine residues in PC4 does not completely abolish the phosphorylation; however, when the two serine residues are mutated, CK2 is no longer able to phosphorylate PC4. The mutant which is not phosphorylated is able to stimulate transcription even though it is previously phosphorylated by Cka1, while the wild type and the point mutant are inactivated by Cka1 phosphorylation, and they cannot stimulate transcription by RNAPII in cell extracts. Those results demonstrate that CK2 can regulate the coactivator function of fission yeast PC4 and suggests that this event could be important in vivo as well.

Phosphorylation-dependent association of human chromatin protein PC4 to linker histone H1 regulates genome organization and transcription

Human Positive Coactivator 4 (PC4) is a multifaceted chromatin protein involved in diverse cellular processes including genome organization, transcription regulation, replication, DNA repair and autophagy. PC4 exists as a phospho-protein in cells which impinges on its acetylation by p300 and thereby affects its transcriptional co-activator functions via double-stranded DNA binding. Despite the inhibitory effects, the abundance of phosphorylated PC4 in cells intrigued us to investigate its role in chromatin functions in a basal state of the cell. We found that casein kinase-II (CKII)-mediated phosphorylation of PC4 is critical for its interaction with linker histone H1. By employing analytical ultracentrifugation and electron microscopy imaging of in vitro reconstituted nucleosomal array, we observed that phospho-mimic (PM) PC4 displays a superior chromatin condensation potential in conjunction with linker histone H1. ATAC-sequencing further unveiled the role of PC4 phosphorylation to be critical in inducing chromatin compaction of a wide array of coding and non-coding genes in vivo. Concordantly, phospho-PC4 mediated changes in chromatin accessibility led to gene repression and affected global histone modifications. We propose that the abundance of PC4 in its phosphorylated state contributes to genome compaction contrary to its co-activator function in driving several cellular processes like gene transcription and autophagy.

Identification, characterization and expression analyses of PC4 genes in Yesso scallop (Patinopecten yessoensis) reveal functional differentiations in response to ocean acidification

Transcriptional coactivator p15 (PC4), considered a multifunctional chromosome associated protein, is actively involved in transcription regulation, DNA replication, damage repair and chromosome formation. Although studies have reported significant effects of PC4 in most vertebrates and some invertebrates, the complete PC4 gene members are less systematically identified and characterized in scallops. In this study, seven PC4 genes (PyPC4s) were identified in the Yesso scallop Patinopecten yessoensis using whole-genome scanning via bioinformatic analyses. Phylogenetic and protein structural analyses were performed to determine the identities and evolutionary relationships of the seven genes. Expression profiles of PyPC4s were further investigated in embryos/larvae at all developmental stages, healthy adult tissues, and mantles that were exposed to low pH stress (pH 6.5 and 7.5) with different time durations (3, 6, 12 and 24 h). Spatiotemporal expression patterns indicated the functional roles of PyPC4s at all development stages and in healthy adult tissues, with PY-3235.33 demonstrating remarkably high constitutive expressions. Expression regulations (up- and down-regulation) of PyPC4s under low pH stress levels demonstrated a time-dependent pattern with functional complementation and/or enhancement, revealing that PyPC4s exhibited differentiated functions in response to ocean acidification (OA). Collectively, our data offer a novel perspective stating that low pH is a potential inducer leading to functional differentiation of PyPC4s in scallops. The results provide preliminary information on the versatile roles of PC4(s) in bivalves in response to OA.

The Transcription Factor SUB1 Is a Master Regulator of the Macrophage TLR Response in Atherosclerosis

Toll-like receptor 2 and 4 (TLR2, TLR4) signaling is implicated in atherosclerotic plaque formation. The two-stage master regulator Virtual Inference of Protein-activity by Enriched Regulon (VIPER) analysis of macrophage TLR2 and TLR4 signature genes integrated with coexpression network genes derived from 371 patient-derived carotid specimens identifies activated RNA polymerase II transcriptional coactivator p15 (SUB1/Sub1, PC4) as a master regulon in the atherogenic TLR response. It is found that TLR2 and TLR4 signaling is proinflammatory and proatherosclerotic in chow-fed apolipoprotein E-deficient (ApoE-/- ) mice. Through transgenic myeloid-specific Sub1 knockout in ApoE-/- mice, it is discovered that these proatherosclerotic effects of TLR2 and TLR4 signaling are mediated by Sub1. Sub1 knockout in macrophages enhances anti-inflammatory M2 macrophage polarization and cholesterol efflux. Irradiated low density lipoprotein receptor-deficient (Ldlr-/- ) mice transplanted with Sub1-/- murine bone marrow display reduced atherosclerosis. Promoter analysis reveals Sub1-dependent activation of interferon regulatory factor 1 (Irf1) transcription in a casein kinase 2 (Ck2)-dependent manner, and Sub1-knockout macrophages display decreased Irf1 expression. Artificial Irf1 overexpression in Sub1-knockout macrophages enhances proinflammatory M1 skewing and lowers cholesterol clearance. In conclusion, the TLR master regulon Sub1, and its downstream effect on the transcription factor Irf1, promotes a proinflammatory M1 macrophage phenotype and enhances atherosclerotic burden in vivo.

Acceleration of ageing via disturbing mTOR-regulated proteostasis by a new ageing-associated gene PC4

Research on ageing‐associated genes is important for investigating ageing and anti‐ageing strategies. Here, we firstly reported that the human positive cofactor 4 (PC4), a multifunctional and highly conserved nucleoprotein, is accumulated and activated during ageing and causes global accelerated ageing process by disrupting proteostasis. Mechanistically, PC4 interacts with Sin3‐HDAC complex and inhibits its deacetylated activity, leads to hyper‐acetylation of the histones at the promoters of mTOR‐related genes and causes mTOR signalling activation. Accordingly, mTOR activation causes excessive protein synthesis, resulting in impaired proteostasis and accelerated senescence. These results reveal a new biological function of PC4 in vivo, recognizes PC4 as a new ageing‐associated gene and provides a genetically engineered mouse model to simulate natural ageing. More importantly, our findings also indicate that PC4 is involved in histone acetylation and serves as a potential target to improve proteostasis and delay ageing.

Chromatin Protein PC4 Orchestrates B Cell Differentiation by Collaborating with IKAROS and IRF4

The chromatin protein positive coactivator 4 (PC4) has multiple functions, including chromatin compaction. However, its role in immune cells is largely unknown. We show that PC4 orchestrates chromatin structure and gene expression in mature B cells. B-cell-specific PC4-deficient mice show impaired production of antibody upon antigen stimulation. The PC4 complex purified from B cells contains the transcription factors (TFs) IKAROS and IRF4. IKAROS protein is reduced in PC4-deficient mature B cells, resulting in de-repression of their target genes in part by diminished interactions with gene-silencing components. Upon activation, the amount of IRF4 protein is not increased in PC4-deficient B cells, resulting in reduction of plasma cells. Importantly, IRF4 reciprocally induces PC4 expression via a super-enhancer. PC4 knockdown in human B cell lymphoma and myeloma cells reduces IKAROS protein as an anticancer drug, lenalidomide. Our findings establish PC4 as a chromatin regulator of B cells and a possible therapeutic target adjoining IKAROS in B cell malignancies.

Efficacy of a small molecule inhibitor of the transcriptional cofactor PC4 in prevention and treatment of non-small cell lung cancer

The human positive coactivator 4 (PC4) was originally identified as a multi-functional cofactor capable of mediating transcription activation by diverse gene- and tissue-specific activators. Recent studies suggest that PC4 might also function as a novel cancer biomarker and therapeutic target for different types of cancers. siRNA knockdown studies indicated that down-regulation of PC4 expression could inhibit tumorigeneicity of A549 non-small cell lung cancer tumor model in nude mice. Here we show that AG-1031, a small molecule identified by high throughput screening, can inhibit the double-stranded DNA binding activity of PC4, more effectively than its single-stranded DNA binding activity. AG-1031 also specifically inhibited PC4-dependent transcriptional activation in vitro using purified transcription factors. AG-1031 inhibited proliferation of several cultured cell lines derived from non-small cell lung cancers (NSCLC) and growth of tumors that formed from A549 cell xenografts in immuno-compromised mice. Moreover, pre-injection of AG-1031 in these mice not only reduced tumor size, but also prevented tumor formation in 20% of the animals. AG-1031 treated A549 cells and tumors from AG-1031 treated animals showed a significant decrease in the levels of both PC4 and VEGFC, a key mediator of angiogenesis in cancer. On the other hand, all tested mice remained constant weight during animal trials. These results demonstrated that AG-1031 could be a potential therapy for PC4-positive NSCLC.

The effect of phosphate ion on the ssDNA binding mode of MoSub1, a Sub1/PC4 homolog from rice blast fungus

MoSub1 is an ortholog of yeast single stranded DNA binding protein Sub1 or human PC4 from rice blast fungus. All of them share a similar DNA binding region and may have similar biological roles. The well-studied Sub1/PC4 has been reported to play multiple roles in DNA metabolic processes, such as transcription and DNA repair and their DNA binding capacity is significantly affected by phosphorylation. Here, we determined the crystal structure of MoSub1 complexed with ssDNA in a phosphate solution. The crystal structure of the MoSub1-ssDNA complex was solved to a resolution of 2.04 Å. A phosphate ion at the interface of the protein-DNA interaction of the complex bridged the lys84 of the protein and two nucleotides. The DNA was bound in novel mode (L mode) in the MoSub1 complex in the presence of phosphate ions, while DNA bound in the straight mode in the absence of the phosphate ion and in U mode in the same binding motif of the PC4-ssDNA complex. The crystal structure of the complex and a small-angle X-ray scattering analysis revealed that the phosphate ion at the protein-DNA interface affected the DNA binding mode of MoSub1 to oligo-DNA and provided a new structural clue for studying its functions.

Sub1 and RNAPII, until termination does them part

Sub1 was initially identified as a coactivator factor with a role during transcription initiation. However, over the last years, many evidences showed that it influences processes downstream during mRNA biogenesis, such as elongation, termination, and RNAPII phosphorylation. The recent discover that Sub1 directly interacts with the RNAPII stalk adds new insights into how it achieves all these tasks.

Mechanistic roles of protein disorder within transcription

Understanding the interactions of proteins involved in transcriptional regulation is critical to describing biological systems because they control the expression profile of the cell. Yet sadly they belong to a less well biophysically characterized subset of proteins; they frequently contain long disordered regions that are highly dynamic. A key question therefore is, why? What functional roles does protein disorder play in transcriptional regulation? Experimental data exemplifying these roles are starting to emerge, with common themes being enabling complexity within networks and quick responses. Most recently a role for disorder in mediating phase transitions of membrane-less organelles has been proposed.

Transcription cofactor PC4 plays essential roles in collaboration with the small subunit of general transcription factor TFIIE

In eukaryotes, positive cofactor 4 (PC4) stimulates activator-dependent transcription by facilitating transcription initiation and the transition from initiation to elongation. It also forms homodimers and binds to single-stranded DNA and various transcriptional activators, including the general transcription factor TFIIH. In this study, we further investigated PC4 from Homo sapiens and the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans (hPC4 and cePC4, respectively). hPC4 strongly stimulated transcription on a linearized template, whereas it alleviated transcription on a supercoiled template. Transcriptional stimulation by PC4 was also alleviated by increasing the amount of TFIID. GST pull-down studies with general transcription factors indicated that both hPC4 and cePC4 bind strongly to TFIIB, TFIIEβ, TFIIFα, TFIIFβ and TFIIH XPB subunits and weakly to TBP and TFIIH p62. However, only hPC4 bound to CDK7. The effect of each PC4 on transcription was studied in combination with TFIIEβ. hPC4 stimulated both basal and activated transcription, whereas cePC4 primarily stimulated activated transcription, especially in the presence of TFIIEβ from C. elegans. Finally, hPC4 bound to the C-terminal region of hTFIIEβ adjacent to the basic region. These results indicate that PC4 plays essential roles in the transition step from transcription initiation to elongation by binding to melted DNA in collaboration with TFIIEβ.

Sub1 associates with Spt5 and influences RNA polymerase II transcription elongation rate

The transcriptional coactivator Sub1 has been implicated in several steps of mRNA metabolism in yeast, such as the activation of transcription, termination, and 3'-end formation. In addition, Sub1 globally regulates RNA polymerase II phosphorylation, and most recently it has been shown that it is a functional component of the preinitiation complex. Here we present evidence that Sub1 plays a significant role in transcription elongation by RNA polymerase II (RNAPII). We show that SUB1 genetically interacts with the gene encoding the elongation factor Spt5, that Sub1 influences Spt5 phosphorylation of the carboxy-terminal domain of RNAPII largest subunit by the kinase Bur1, and that both Sub1 and Spt5 copurify in the same complex, likely during early transcription elongation. Indeed, our data indicate that Sub1 influences Spt5-Rpb1 interaction. In addition, biochemical and molecular data show that Sub1 influences transcription elongation of constitutive and inducible genes and associates with coding regions in a transcription-dependent manner. Taken together, our results indicate that Sub1 associates with Spt5 and influences Spt5-Rpb1 complex levels and consequently transcription elongation rate.

Signaling from the secretory granule to the nucleus

Neurons and endocrine cells use a complex array of signaling molecules to communicate with each other and with various targets. The majority of these signaling molecules are stored in specialized organelles awaiting release on demand: 40-60 nm vesicles carry conventional or small molecule neurotransmitters, and 200-400 nm granules contain bioactive peptides. The supply of small molecule neurotransmitters is tightly regulated by local feedback of synthetic rates and transport processes at sites of release. The larger granules that contain bioactive peptides present the secretory cell with special challenges, as the peptide precursors are inserted into the lumen of the secretory pathway in the cell soma and undergo biosynthetic processing while being transported to distant sites for eventual secretion. One solution to this dilemma in information handling has been to employ proteolytic cleavage of secretory granule membrane proteins to produce cytosolic fragments that can signal to the nucleus, affecting gene expression. The use of regulated intramembrane proteolysis to signal from secretory granules to the nucleus is compared to its much better understood role in relaying information from the endoplasmic reticulum by SREBP and ATF6 and from the plasma membrane by cadherins, Notch and ErbB4.

Sub1 and RPA associate with RNA polymerase II at different stages of transcription

Single-stranded DNA-binding proteins play many roles in nucleic acid metabolism, but their importance during transcription remains unclear. Quantitative proteomic analysis of RNA polymerase II (RNApII) preinitiation complexes (PICs) identified Sub1 and the replication protein A complex (RPA), both of which bind single-stranded DNA (ssDNA). Sub1, homolog of mammalian coactivator PC4, exhibits strong genetic interactions with factors necessary for promoter melting. Sub1 localizes near the transcription bubble in vitro and binds to promoters in vivo dependent upon PIC assembly. In contrast, RPA localizes to transcribed regions of active genes, strongly correlated with transcribing RNApII but independently of replication. RFA1 interacts genetically with transcription elongation factor genes. Interestingly, RPA levels increase at active promoters in cells carrying a Sub1 deletion or ssDNA-binding mutant, suggesting competition for a common binding site. We propose that Sub1 and RPA interact with the nontemplate strand of RNApII complexes during initiation and elongation, respectively.

Dynamic protein-DNA recognition: beyond what can be seen

Traditionally, specific DNA recognition is thought to rely on static contacts with the bases or phosphates. Recent results, however, indicate that residues far outside the binding context can crucially influence selectivity or binding affinity via transient, dynamic interactions with the DNA binding interface. These regions usually do not adopt a well-defined structure, even when bound to DNA, and thus form a fuzzy complex. Here, we propose the existence of a dynamic DNA readout mechanism, wherein distant segments modulate conformational preferences, flexibility or spacing of the DNA binding motifs or serve as competitive partners. Despite their low sequence similarity, these intrinsically disordered regions are often conserved at the structural level, and exploited for regulation of the transcription machinery via protein-protein interactions, post-translational modifications or alternative splicing.

Peptide-protein interactions suggest that acetylation of lysines 381 and 382 of p53 is important for positive coactivator 4-p53 interaction

The human transcriptional positive coactivator 4 (PC4) activates several p53-dependent genes. It has been demonstrated that this is a consequence of direct interaction with p53. Previously, we have concluded that PC4 interacts mainly with the C-terminal negative regulatory domain of p53 through its DNA binding C-terminal half. NMR chemical shift perturbation studies with peptide fragments indicated that amino acids 380-386 of p53 are crucial for interaction with PC4. This was verified by fluorescence anisotropy and sedimentation velocity studies. A peptide consisting of p53-(380-386) sequence, when attached to a cell penetration tag and nuclear localization signal, localizes to the nucleus and inhibits luciferase gene expression from a transfected plasmid carrying a Luc gene under a p53-dependent promoter. Acetylation of lysine 382/381 enhanced the binding of this peptide to PC4 by about an order of magnitude. NMR and mutagenesis studies indicated that serine 73 of PC4 is an important residue for recognition of p53. Intermolecular nuclear Overhauser effect placed aspartate 76 in the vicinity of lysine 381, indicating that the region around residues 73-76 of PC4 is important for p53 recognition. We conclude that the 380-386 region of p53 interacts with the region around residues 73-76 of PC4, and acetylation of lysine 382/381 of p53 may play an important role in modulating p53-PC4 interaction and as a consequence PC4 mediated activation of p53 target genes.

Secretory granule to the nucleus: role of a multiply phosphorylated intrinsically unstructured domain

Intrinsically unstructured domains occur in one-third of all proteins and are characterized by conformational flexibility, protease sensitivity, and the occurrence of multiple phosphorylation. They provide large interfaces for diverse protein-protein interactions. Peptidylglycine alpha-amidating monooxygenase (PAM), an enzyme essential for neuropeptide biosynthesis, is a secretory granule membrane protein. As one of the few proteins spanning the granule membrane, PAM is a candidate to relay information about the status of the granule pool and conditions in the granule lumen. Here, we show that the PAM cytosolic domain is unstructured. Mass spectroscopy and two-dimensional gel electrophoresis demonstrated phosphorylation at 10-12 sites in the cytosolic domain. Stimulation of exocytosis resulted in coupled phosphorylation and dephosphorylation of specific sites and in the endoproteolytic release of a soluble, proteasome-sensitive cytosolic domain fragment. Analysis of granule-rich tissues, such as pituitary and heart, showed that a similar fragment was generated endogenously and translocated to the nucleus. This multiply phosphorylated unstructured domain may act as a signaling molecule that relays information from secretory granules to both cytosol and nucleus.

Multisite protein phosphorylation--from molecular mechanisms to kinetic models

Multisite phosphorylation is an important mechanism for fine-tuned regulation of protein function. Mathematical models developed over recent years have contributed to elucidation of the functional consequences of a variety of molecular mechanisms involved in processing of the phosphorylation sites. Here we review the results of such models, together with salient experimental findings on multisite protein phosphorylation. We discuss how molecular mechanisms that can be distinguished with respect to the order and processivity of phosphorylation, as well as other factors, regulate changes in the sensitivity and kinetics of the response, the synchronization of molecular events, signalling specificity, and other functional implications.

Activation of p53 function by human transcriptional coactivator PC4: role of protein-protein interaction, DNA bending, and posttranslational modifications

Tumor suppressor p53 controls cell cycle checkpoints and apoptosis via the transactivation of several genes that are involved in these processes. The functions of p53 are regulated by a wide variety of proteins, which interact with it either directly or indirectly. The multifunctional human transcriptional coactivator PC4 interacts with p53 in vivo and in vitro and regulates its function. Here we report the molecular mechanisms of the PC4-mediated activation of p53 function. PC4 interacts with the DNA binding and C-terminal domains of p53 through its DNA binding domain, which is essential for the stimulation of p53 DNA binding. Remarkably, ligation-mediated circularization assays reveal that PC4 induces significant bending in the DNA double helix. Deletion mutants defective in DNA bending are found to be impaired in activating p53-mediated DNA binding and apoptosis. Furthermore, acetylation of PC4 enhances, while phosphorylation abolishes, its ability to bend DNA, activate p53 DNA binding, and, thereby, regulate p53 functions. In conclusion, PC4 activates p53 recruitment to p53-responsive promoters (Bax and p21) in vivo through its interaction with p53 and by providing bent substrate for p53 recruitment. These results elucidate the general molecular mechanisms of activation of p53 function, mediated by its coactivators.

Versatile regulation of multisite protein phosphorylation by the order of phosphate processing and protein-protein interactions

Multisite protein phosphorylation is a common regulatory mechanism in cell signaling, and dramatically increases the possibilities for protein-protein interactions, conformational regulation, and phosphorylation pathways. However, there is at present no comprehensive picture of how these factors shape the response of a protein's phosphorylation state to changes in kinase and phosphatase activities. Here we provide a mathematical theory for the regulation of multisite protein phosphorylation based on the mechanistic description of elementary binding and catalytic steps. Explicit solutions for the steady-state response curves and characteristic (de)phosphorylation times have been obtained in special cases. The order of phosphate processing and the characteristics of protein-protein interactions turn out to be of overriding importance for both sensitivity and speed of response. Random phosphate processing gives rise to shallow response curves, favoring intermediate phosphorylation states of the target, and rapid kinetics. Sequential processing is characterized by steeper response curves and slower kinetics. We show systematically how qualitative differences in target phosphorylation--including graded, switch-like and bistable responses--are determined by the relative concentrations of enzyme and target as well as the enzyme-target affinities. In addition to collective effects of several phosphorylation sites, our analysis predicts that distinct phosphorylation patterns can be finely tuned by a single kinase. Taken together, this study suggests a versatile regulation of protein activation by the combined effect of structural, kinetic and thermodynamic aspects of multisite phosphorylation.