Human prion protein: exploring the thermodynamic stability and structural dynamics of its pathogenic mutants

Human familial prion diseases are known to be associated with different single-point mutants of the gene coding for prion protein with a primary focus at several locations of the globular domain. We have identified 12 different single-point pathogenic mutants of human prion protein (HuPrP) with the help of extensive perturbations/mutation technique at multiple locations of HuPrP sequence related to potentiality towards conformational disorders. Among these, some of the mutants include pathogenic variants that corroborate well with the literature reported proteins while majority include some unique single-point mutants that are either not explicitly studied early or studied for variants with different residues at the specific position. Primarily, our study sheds light on the unfolding mechanism of the above mentioned mutants in depth. Besides, we could identify some mutants under investigation that demonstrates not only unfolding of the helical structures but also extension and generation of the β-sheet structures and or simultaneously have highly exposed hydrophobic surface which is assumed to be linked with the production of aggregate/fibril structures of the prion protein. Among the identified mutants, Q212E needs special attention due to its maximum exposure of hydrophobic core towards solvent and E200Q is found to be important due to its maximum extent of β-content. We are also able to identify different respective structural conformations of the proteins according to their degree of structural unfolding and those conformations can be extracted and further studied in detail. Communicated by Ramaswamy H. Sarma.

Identification of Two Early Folding Stage Prion Non-Local Contacts Suggested to Serve as Key Steps in Directing the Final Fold to Be Either Native or Pathogenic

The initial steps of the folding pathway of the C-terminal domain of the murine prion protein mPrP(90–231) are predicted based on the sequential collapse model (SCM). A non-local dominant contact is found to form between the connecting region between helix 1 and β-sheet 1 and the C-terminal region of helix 3. This non-local contact nucleates the most populated molten globule-like intermediate along the folding pathway. A less stable early non-local contact between segments 120–124 and 179–183, located in the middle of helix 2, promotes the formation of a less populated molten globule-like intermediate. The formation of the dominant non-local contact constitutes an example of the postulated Nature’s Shortcut to the prion protein collapse into the native structure. The possible role of the less populated molten globule-like intermediate is explored as the potential initiation point for the folding for three pathogenic mutants (T182A, I214V, and Q211P in mouse prion numbering) of the prion protein.

Correlating solvation with conformational pathways of proteins in alcohol-water mixtures: a THz spectroscopic insight

Water, being an active participant in most of the biophysical processes, is important to trace how protein solvation changes as its conformation evolves in the presence of solutes or co-solvents. In this study, we investigate how the secondary structures of two diverse proteins - lysozyme and β-lactoglobulin - change in the aqueous mixtures of two alcohols - ethanol and 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol (TFE) using circular dichroism measurements. We observe that these alcohols change the secondary structures of these proteins and the changes are protein-specific. Subsequently, we measure the collective solvation dynamics of these two proteins both in the absence and in the presence of alcohols by measuring the frequency-dependent absorption coefficient (α(ν)) in the THz (0.1-1.2 THz) frequency domain. The alcohol-water mixtures exhibit a non-ideal behaviour with the highest absorption difference (Δα) obtained at X_alcohol = 0.2. The protein solvation in the presence of the alcohols shows an oscillating behaviour in which Δα_protein changes with X_alcohol. Such an oscillatory behaviour of protein solvation results from a delicate interplay between the protein-water, protein-alcohol and water-alcohol associations. We attempt to correlate the various structural conformations of the proteins with the associated solvation.

Monitoring site-specific conformational changes in real-time reveals a misfolding mechanism of the prion protein

During pathological aggregation, proteins undergo remarkable conformational re-arrangements to anomalously assemble into a heterogeneous collection of misfolded multimers, ranging from soluble oligomers to insoluble amyloid fibrils. Inspired by fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) measurements of protein folding, an experimental strategy to study site-specific misfolding kinetics during aggregation, by effectively suppressing contributions from inter-molecular FRET, is described. Specifically, the kinetics of conformational changes across different secondary and tertiary structural segments of the mouse prion protein (moPrP) were monitored independently, after the monomeric units transformed into large oligomers O_L, which subsequently disaggregated reversibly into small oligomers O_S at pH 4. The sequence segments spanning helices α2 and α3 underwent a compaction during the formation of O_L and elongation into β-sheets during the formation of O_S. The β1-α1-β2 and α2-α3 subdomains were separated, and the helix α1 was unfolded to varying extents in both O_L and O_S.

Structural mechanisms of oligomer and amyloid fibril formation by the prion protein

Misfolding and aggregation of the prion protein is responsible for multiple neurodegenerative diseases. Works from several laboratories on folding of both the WT and multiple pathogenic mutant variants of the prion protein have identified several structurally dissimilar intermediates, which might be potential precursors to misfolding and aggregation. The misfolded aggregates themselves are morphologically distinct, critically dependent on the solution conditions under which they are prepared, but always β-sheet rich. Despite the lack of an atomic resolution structure of the infectious pathogenic agent in prion diseases, several low resolution models have identified the β-sheet rich core of the aggregates formed in vitro, to lie in the α2-α3 subdomain of the prion protein, albeit with local stabilities that vary with the type of aggregate. This feature article describes recent advances in the investigation of in vitro prion protein aggregation using multiple spectroscopic probes, with particular focus on (1) identifying aggregation-prone conformations of the monomeric protein, (2) conditions which trigger misfolding and oligomerization, (3) the mechanism of misfolding and aggregation, and (4) the structure of the misfolded intermediates and final aggregates.

Comparing the energy landscapes for native folding and aggregation of PrP

Protein sequences are evolved to encode generally one folded structure, out of a nearly infinite array of possible folds. Underlying this code is a funneled free energy landscape that guides folding to the native conformation. Protein misfolding and aggregation are also a manifestation of free-energy landscapes. The detailed mechanisms of these processes are poorly understood, but often involve rare, transient species and a variety of different pathways. The inherent complexity of misfolding has hampered efforts to measure aggregation pathways and the underlying energy landscape, especially using traditional methods where ensemble averaging obscures important rare and transient events. We recently studied the misfolding and aggregation of prion protein by examining 2 monomers tethered in close proximity as a dimer, showing how the steps leading to the formation of a stable aggregated state can be resolved in the single-molecule limit and the underlying energy landscape thereby reconstructed. This approach allows a more quantitative comparison of native folding versus misfolding, including fundamental differences in the dynamics for misfolding. By identifying key steps and interactions leading to misfolding, it should help to identify potential drug targets. Here we describe the importance of characterizing free-energy landscapes for aggregation and the challenges involved in doing so, and we discuss how single-molecule studies can help test proposed structural models for PrP aggregates.

New insights into xanthine oxidase behavior upon heating using spectroscopy and in silico approach

Thermal dependent conformational changes of xanthine oxidase (XOD) were studied using sensitive and non-destructive methods like fluorescence spectroscopy and molecular modeling in the temperature range of 25-85°C. Intrinsic fluorescence studies showed that the microenvironment of tryptophan and tyrosine residues becomes more exposed to solvent as the temperature increased up to 85°C, whereas in case of flavin cofactor is rather conserved. At higher temperatures, the flavin adenine dinucleotide is displaced from the core of the protein, but is not fully released as shown by the Stern Volmer quenching constant and accessible fraction of the cofactor. Anyway, no significant changes in the structure of XOD monomer were identified after running molecular dynamics simulations at temperatures 25°C, 65°C and 85°C. Therefore, we can conclude that the most important changes in the protein structure at thermal treatment mainly consist on molecular aggregation and dissociation events.

Single-molecule approaches to prion protein misfolding

The structural conversion of the prion protein PrP into a transmissible, misfolded form is the central element of prion disease, yet there is little consensus as to how it occurs. Key aspects of conversion into the diseased state remain unsettled, from details about the earliest stages of misfolding such as the involvement of partially- or fully-unfolded intermediates to the structure of the infectious state. Part of the difficulty in understanding the structural conversion arises from the complexity of the underlying energy landscapes. Single molecule methods provide a powerful tool for probing complex folding pathways as in prion misfolding, because they allow rare and transient events to be observed directly. We discuss recent work applying single-molecule probes to study misfolding in prion proteins, and what it has revealed about the folding dynamics of PrP that may underlie its unique behavior. We also discuss single-molecule studies probing the interactions that stabilize non-native structures within aggregates, pointing the way to future work that may help identify the microscopic events triggering pathogenic conversion. Although single-molecule approaches to misfolding are relatively young, they have a promising future in prion science.

Effect of polyethylene glycols on the alkaline-induced molten globule intermediate of bovine serum albumin

In the present study, the formation of one molten globule-like unfolding intermediate of bovine serum albumin (BSA) at pH 11.2 has been established with the help of circular dichroism (CD) spectra, fluorescence spectroscopy and 'phase diagram' approach. Additionally, we have shown the conformational changes occurring in the pH 11.2 intermediate of BSA when it was exposed to different molecular weight polyethylene glycols (PEGs) at varying concentrations. When the pH 11.2 intermediate of BSA was treated by PEG 400 there was induction of secondary and non-native tertiary contacts. In case of PEG 8000 and PEG 20,000, the loss in secondary as well as tertiary structure was observed. PEG 8000 and 20,000 altered the conformation of the pH 11.2 intermediate and resulted in its transition to another intermediate state in which the hydrophobic patches were inaccessible.

Direct observation of multiple misfolding pathways in a single prion protein molecule

Protein misfolding is a ubiquitous phenomenon associated with a wide range of diseases. Single-molecule approaches offer a powerful tool for deciphering the mechanisms of misfolding by measuring the conformational fluctuations of a protein with high sensitivity. We applied single-molecule force spectroscopy to observe directly the misfolding of the prion protein PrP, a protein notable for having an infectious misfolded state that is able to propagate by recruiting natively folded PrP. By measuring folding trajectories of single PrP molecules held under tension in a high-resolution optical trap, we found that the native folding pathway involves only two states, without evidence for partially folded intermediates that have been proposed to mediate misfolding. Instead, frequent but fleeting transitions were observed into off-pathway intermediates. Three different misfolding pathways were detected, all starting from the unfolded state. Remarkably, the misfolding rate was even higher than the rate for native folding. A mutant PrP with higher aggregation propensity showed increased occupancy of some of the misfolded states, suggesting these states may act as intermediates during aggregation. These measurements of individual misfolding trajectories demonstrate the power of single-molecule approaches for characterizing misfolding directly by mapping out nonnative folding pathways.

Prion protein and its conformational conversion: a structural perspective

The key molecular event in the pathogenesis of prion diseases is the conformational conversion of a cellular prion protein, PrP(C), into a misfolded form, PrP(Sc). In contrast to PrP(C) that is monomeric and α-helical, PrP(Sc) is oligomeric in nature and rich in β-sheet structure. According to the "protein-only" model, PrP(Sc) itself represents the infectious prion agent responsible for transmissibility of prion disorders. While this model is supported by rapidly growing experimental data, detailed mechanistic and structural aspects of prion protein conversion remain enigmatic. In this chapter we describe recent advances in understanding biophysical and biochemical aspects of prion diseases, with a special focus on structural underpinnings of prion protein conversion, the structural basis of prion strains, and generation of prion infectivity in vitro from bacterially-expressed recombinant PrP.

Sequence-dependent prion protein misfolding and neurotoxicity

Prion diseases are neurodegenerative disorders caused by misfolding of the normal prion protein (PrP) into a pathogenic "scrapie" conformation. To better understand the cellular and molecular mechanisms that govern the conformational changes (conversion) of PrP, we compared the dynamics of PrP from mammals susceptible (hamster and mouse) and resistant (rabbit) to prion diseases in transgenic flies. We recently showed that hamster PrP induces spongiform degeneration and accumulates into highly aggregated, scrapie-like conformers in transgenic flies. We show now that rabbit PrP does not induce spongiform degeneration and does not convert into scrapie-like conformers. Surprisingly, mouse PrP induces weak neurodegeneration and accumulates small amounts of scrapie-like conformers. Thus, the expression of three highly conserved mammalian prion proteins in transgenic flies uncovered prominent differences in their conformational dynamics. How these properties are encoded in the amino acid sequence remains to be elucidated.

Structural and functional alterations of two multidomain oxidoreductases induced by guanidine hydrochloride

The unfolding and refolding of two multidomain oxidoreductases, bovine liver catalase and flavoprotein bovine milk xanthine oxidase (XO), have been analyzed by fluorescence spectroscopy, circular dichroism, and activity measurements. Two intermediates, a partially folded active dimer disassembled from the native tetramer and a partially folded inactivated monomer, are found to exist in the conformational changes of catalase induced by guanidine hydrochloride (GdnHCl). Similarly, two intermediates, an active, compacted intermediate bound by flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) partially and an inactive flexible intermediate with FAD completely dissociated, exist in the conformational changes of XO induced by GdnHCl. The activity regains completely and an enhancement in activity compared with the native catalase or native XO is observed by dilution of catalase or XO incubated with GdnHCl at concentrations not >0.5 or 1.8 M into the refolding buffer, but the yield of reactivation for catalase or XO is zero when the concentration of GdnHCl is >1.5 or 3.0 M. The addition of FAD provides a remarkable protection against the inactivation of XO by GdnHCl under mild denaturing conditions, and the conformational change of XO is irreversible after FAD has been removed in the presence of a strong denaturing agent. These findings provide impetus for exploring the influences of cofactors such as FAD on the structure-function relationship of xanthine oxidoreductases.

Prion protein self-peptides modulate prion interactions and conversion

Background

Molecular mechanisms underlying prion agent replication, converting host-encoded cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into the scrapie associated isoform (PrP^Sc), are poorly understood. Selective self-interaction between PrP molecules forms a basis underlying the observed differences of the PrP^C into PrP^Sc conversion process (agent replication). The importance of previously peptide-scanning mapped ovine PrP self-interaction domains on this conversion was investigated by studying the ability of six of these ovine PrP based peptides to modulate two processes; PrP self-interaction and conversion.

Results

Three peptides (octarepeat, binding domain 2 -and C-terminal) were capable of inhibiting self-interaction of PrP in a solid-phase PrP peptide array. Three peptides (N-terminal, binding domain 2, and amyloidogenic motif) modulated prion conversion when added before or after initiation of the prion protein misfolding cyclic amplification (PMCA) reaction using brain homogenates. The C-terminal peptides (core region and C-terminal) only affected conversion (increased PrP^res formation) when added before mixing PrP^C and PrP^Sc, whereas the octarepeat peptide only affected conversion when added after this mixing.

Conclusion

This study identified the putative PrP core binding domain that facilitates the PrP^C-PrP^Sc interaction (not conversion), corroborating evidence that the region of PrP containing this domain is important in the species-barrier and/or scrapie susceptibility. The octarepeats can be involved in PrP^C-PrP^Sc stabilization, whereas the N-terminal glycosaminoglycan binding motif and the amyloidogenic motif indirectly affected conversion. Binding domain 2 and the C-terminal domain are directly implicated in PrP^C self-interaction during the conversion process and may prove to be prime targets in new therapeutic strategy development, potentially retaining PrP^C function. These results emphasize the importance of probable PrP^C-PrP^C and required PrP^C-PrP^Sc interactions during PrP conversion. All interactions are probably part of the complex process in which polymorphisms and species barriers affect TSE transmission and susceptibility.

The unfolding of the prion protein sheds light on the mechanisms of prion susceptibility and species barrier

Prion diseases are a group of fatal neurodegenerative disorders that manifest as infectious, sporadic, or familial and are all associated with the misfolding of the prion protein (PrP). Disease-modulating polymorphisms in the PrP amino acid sequence can make an individual more or less susceptible to infection. One example is the presence of arginine in place of glutamine at position 171 in sheep, which confers resistance to scrapie. To investigate whether the physical folding properties of PrP are influenced by the presence of arginine at codon 171, we have introduced the mutation at the equivalent position (codon 167) in recombinant mouse PrP. We have then compared the unfolding properties of wild-type PrP and the Q167R mutant by monitoring the fluorescence and circular dichroism of folding-sensitive tryptophan mutants. For both wild-type PrP and the Q167R mutant the formation of secondary structure and tertiary structure is concurrent, which indicates that unfolding proceeds without the accumulation of an equilibrium intermediate. The major effect of the mutation is the destabilization of the protein as shown by the shift of the unfolding transition, which can be rationalized from high-resolution structures of PrP. Comparison of the unfolding pathways of mouse and hamster PrP highlights dramatic differences in the mechanisms of folding, which may contribute to the species barrier effect that is observed in the transmission of prion disease.

Rapid folding of the prion protein captured by pressure-jump

The conversion of the cellular form of the prion protein (PrP(C)) to an altered disease state, generally denoted as scrapie isoform (PrP(Sc)), appears to be a crucial molecular event in prion diseases. The details of this conformational transition are not fully understood, but it is perceived that they are associated with misfolding of PrP or its incapacity to maintain the native fold during its cell cycle. Here we present a tryptophan mutant of PrP (F198W), which has enhanced fluorescence sensitivity to unfolding/refolding transitions. Equilibrium folding was studied by circular dichroism and fluorescence. Pressure-jump experiments were successfully applied to reveal rapid submillisecond folding events of PrP at temperatures not accessed before.